The Chinese have fought each other and foreign invaders for thousands of years, to unite the whole of China. Today China is stronger than ever, and its people can enjoy peace and prosperity more than ever in history. Those that want to divide China's territories up will not succeed. No matter how many countering China organizations are formed (QUAD, NATO..), the Chinese are ready and waiting to defend their land and its large population, just like their ancestors have done for thousands of years. It would be best if India and China have friendly relation. Pravin Sawhney speaks to facts.
@@mg.f.9023 china settled all the land borders with neighbors except india and butan who also controled by india, with the way of mutual respect. Mao once said to his generals, he thought really really hard for a week and could not figure out why india wanted to have a war with china in 1962. I guess india thought it is just BECAUSE I CAN with the support of both superpowers in the world USA and soviet union. and chinese dared not to fight back?
@@liveinsea1you are missing the point. India is not China. India is an artificial country created by the British. It has too many internal divisions and conflicts. Having an external enemy units the country. That is why it hasn't resolved border disputes with most neighbors.
@@mg.f.9023reality prove you wrong. There were dispute between china and it's neighbor like family feud throughout history, but their border with China never change for thousands of years. Vietnam today is still the same Vietnam, Korea don't loss an inch throughout thousands of years, their culture language religion are intact thought history. You are using the mind of aggressive westerners to judge a country of civilization. Yes, if china behave like the European, all its neighbors will loss the land and culture, language and religion. Examples abound in America, Australia and many Africa and Asia nations who were once colonized that have loss their identity totally.
The reason why India has internal problems and issues with its neighbors like Pakistan or Bangladesh or China etc all stems from the backdrop of British colonialism of which India to a certain accent tolerated for a long long time.
If people like Pravin were in power, he'd have broken up India into several countries. He's the perfect puppet leader...just like the all Pakistani PMs.
When the EAM calls it "the India-China border", fully knowing that there is no such "border", it shows why things are going wrong. It called the "Line of Actual Control (LAC)". When he calls the LAC as the "border", it ignores the history and circumstances why it's not a border. With such an understanding, whether by design or ignorance (which is unlikely), things can never be objectively addressed. Moreover, when the EAM makes such false statements, the other side is surely watching and saying, "how can we deal with such liars"?
What is a border? A border is a real or artificial line that separates geographic areas. Borders are political boundaries. They separate countries, states, provinces, counties, cities, and towns. A border outlines the area that a particular governing body controls
Xi always suggest Nepal to make Good relation with India but Modi says something opposite That is the reason why people of Nepal do not like Indian leader and burecrate
when Nepal experience earthquake, India purposefully close the road alternative to Nepal, making Nepali trapped. this is the moment Nepal become furious
@@edhiepitz Due to the indian blockade, China had to airlift aid relief to Nepal disaster struck victims. ln the near future, roads and rails from China will serve Nepal with access for transportation without going through india.
He is a man that even his enemy can deal with because he his words will stay and he will mean and say what he mean to say. Unlike Modi and Jaishankar, they are duplicitous in their words and deeds, resulting in not meaning what they say, and saying what they mean. If I were the Chinese, then it is best to be wary of such persons as Modi or Jaishankar, because they can convenient backtrack on their agreement, and in effect any deals made with them is really not to be relied upon. Walk away from India is the better action to take. Let the world knows that China has no faith that Modi is a person that China can do deals with. ps. The West is already aware of the nature of India's Modi govt. becasue I watch an Israeli ex-Ambassador saying that China is aggressive but their words can be trusted once they agree on a deal made, whereas with India, it is much harder to make a deal because she can backtrack on deals, or make retrospective demands after a deal was already agreed upon.
@@HTeo-og1lg China is assertive not aggressive. It knows modi india cant be trusted from experience dealing with them but no need to walk away from them , just be patient n keep the status quo will do. Walking away only benefit the uS
Unless India realises n takes or initiates Positive Approach, there is No Way " Both These Countries would ever Enjoy Good Neighborly Relations" , Which remains a Big Sore Point for Both Sides
First he caught my eyes as one of the brightest minister India ever produced but rapidly he lost my respect because he became like the rest, no substance except talk and joke. Being a minister is not a talk show comedian as he thought so.
most chinese leaders refuse to talk to the media, one is because they dont have good skills in arguring, the other is winning the arguement wont help to better the country. its a waste of time. the media will not change their mind to make you looking good even if you won the argurement.
@@nirmalbhel3231 it's a combination of jealousy plus anger plus fear. The same feeling of seeing your date being touchy and flirtatious and slutty with your competitor in love. America is all that because they know they are longer the top kahuna and do not command that respect and fear anymore. So with the loss of self esteem and sense of power the have reduced themselves to this state. Angry ? Only part of it.
@@freddymercury2259 not the america today. They have lost all of that and more in the last 70 years or so. All they know is how to create wars and how to run away when it gets too hot .
India will never be a superpower as it is still bowing to its Master in the White House and it still believes that it can get benefit from siding with both the East & West at the same time 🤣🤣🤣
@@rajnair1357 ,, It is never to be good . To get a good future , The work need to be done is a given, That included Sacrifices & pain , truthfully painful .
Indian leaders must set examples in truthfulness and strive for principles of social equality and clean living. These are the obstacle for uniting a billion people in a diverse culture and language nation. The upright character is the only common language for India.
US has built China and is looking fwd build itself. India's master is itself, will buy oil from RUSSIA despite of criticism. India will fight against China if China attacks, not on anyone's advice
Finally, some of the truth is coming out. There are many more aspects and actions, all pointing to the failures of the Indian govt and agencies. This is my understanding why the Indian EAM has been evading a clear answer for over three years. The fear of jeopardising relations with the US, already damaged through the Modi govts poor democracy standards is now being salvaged by supporting the Quad and siding with the US in SCS. And thus preventing peace and prosperity in the China-Pak-India region.
India and China must unite and cooperate for peace and benefit of both people. Do not allow foreign powers to divide you and rule over you. With goodwill the border issues can be resolved very quickly. Otherwise let it be in the backburner. Not long ago both nations were victims of the west. Focus on what's important for the people. Peace 🙏 ✌
Jaishankar will modified his both his stance and statement based on his boss Modi mood. Don't take him seriously. Remember India was a 56 Kingdom subcontinent rules by 32 Emperors and Kings, etc divided over 570 districts. It is like saying Tamil Nadu owns South Tibet. Not logical by history.
I really can't understand the Indian foreign policy to China as a Chinese. It is so aggressive and unfriendly to China by working with US to against Chinese. It is not smart dealing with the Number 1 manufacturing country and 1.4 billion people like that while India is also seeking to develop themself N improve the living standard of their 1.4 billion people at the same time. Do you Indian need a peaceful and stable outside environment to grow and attract the investment? I sometime really happy to see the unfriendly actions from India to against the Chinese including the Chinese investments. These actions have awakened the Chinese stop investing to India or withdraw from India! The Chinese are out of trouble by not investing in India directly.
We INDIANS have right to know and keep up to date ourselfs about the affairs of our Nation. Those who hide the facts are not doing good to the people of India and of course to India too.
Pravin knows Foreign policy more than any one in the world and best defense expert (spent some years in the defence you know..). Also an expert in economics and 10 other areas (you will see in coming months). Anyone who can beat this?😂 I think everyone following this channel will definitely agree. BTW he is his sponsors favourite 😍
Indian democracy? Locking up the oppositions to win by default? . It was a shocker! Despite illegal electoral bond cheating and getting people to donate to avoid extortion charges etc, , locking up dissidents and chief ministers, freezing finances of opposition at election, and BJP partisan controlled of Police, judicial, and electoral commission, and food subsidies to 800,000,000 by direct payment, the oppositions did Incredibly well! Voters didn't buy the BS completely because of worsening economy.
Thank you for clarifying the events since 2016. PM Modi is a consummate perception manager. He certainly uses a big part of his day doing that. I hope he would allocate more of his time at doing stuffs that would actually help Indians.
India GDP per capita is only $2731 (estimate in 2024), and Thailand is $6909(2023) , Vietnam is $4163 and Philippine is $3498. India doesn't look like a superpower.
Modi Amit Shah have boosted the issue of Sikh by killing so many Sikh inside and outside the country. By removing the articles they have also repelled those Kashmiries who were with them. They have accelerated unrest in Manipur. Pakistan was also annoyed by abrogation of 370. In short, Modi and Amit Shah have made a mess for India.
Balochistan & KPK must be freed from hands of pakistan, In long run it will be beneficial not only for pak & india but it will beneficial for the whole world @@IronMan-nu3rb
This exposes India's policy of spreading lies for both domestic and international consumption purposes. The credibility of what present Indian government says on different platforms about their achievements or about strength of their friendship with friendly countries or strength of Indian defence against enemy countries seems to be very low now.
Summing it up its the colonial government Britain that had planted the bad seeds before leaving that has now grown into fruition of bad fruits. India since independence has not have any leadership who's able to cut the umbalical cord nor undo the spell the british had put on them. If they have any self worth and independence demand the return of their priced diamond. That stone will continually remind the indians of their impotence .
What a great video, clear and concise! I am Indian, and a keen supporter of the BJP. From what I heard in this video, both China and India are to blame. First, why did China want to build a road for its army in territory that wasn't Chinese? Now to India. India has built a trend of untrustworthiness in its dealings, whether in trade or diplomatic field. Then there is the US digging at India to oppose the Chinese. Then there is Dr Jaishankar. He has direct personal interests that clash with his position. His son lives in the US. He is married to a Japanese wife. Japan is a vassal of the US. Therefore, there will always be tension with so many factors at play. For India to succeed, it has to become CREDIBLE. It must display professionalism. Mean what you say and say what you mean. It must stop following in behind the US. Finally, PM Modi must replace his foreign minister. Be friend with all, but not subservient. Have a position on the world stage instead of being all things to all men. Work with China in a close and friendly manner. Above all, remember that the US is a fast fading power. Don't back a losing horse!
That was not even a surgical strike. It was a minor cross-LoC raid conducted by Indian Army Special Forces a few kilometers inside Pakistani-occupied territory.
When Modi stepped off the plane in Moscow & hugged Putin Washington went ballistic. Hence India live in fear of being friendly with China lest it enrage Washington. There is no permission for peace.
After listening to Parvin Sawhney, I started to have a better understanding of the tensions between India and China. In politics, many political leaders are led astray by money and power temptations. I hope the current Indian government looked after the interests of the common people by focusing on infrastructure development, education, and trade.
Until you drew a boundary unilaterally where no boundary ever exited- that is what abrogation of article 370 led to.... China doesn't like their tibetans got shortchanged by India.
@@biggpicture2930 If Ladakh had no boundary to the Tibetan side previously, then the situation is same as it was before the abrogation. China has sabotaged the status quo, as it seems to me, only to keep India busy on the eastern side so that their investment on the western side on CPEC run smoothly through POK. Chinese logic reminds me that of the wolf of my childhood fable who wanted to devour the lamb.
@@biggpicture2930 Wasn't there a boundary line between J&K and China occupied Tibet previous to the abrogation? So how the abrogation of 370 could anyway mean to draw the border unilaterally? China's logic is that of the wolf of our childhood fable , who needed an alibi to eat the lamb. Here China's intention is to keep India busy on the eastern side so that her huge investment in CPEC running through Pakistan occupied Kashmir remains safe. China wants India to remain terrorstruck and unguarded.
Fact based and realistic analysis…..hope your efforts provoke the thought process of those who deny ground realities and living in a state of denial,which is dangerous to us all.Nothing will go off USA or Europe.South Asian region and its people,who haven’t been fortunate enough to have a sincere and prudent leadership,will bear the brunt of leadership’s failure to bring peace in the region.
This was a very good and accurate summary of recent historical events. You are a great strategic analyst and about one of the few voices in India I trust and will listen to.
IN THIS INSTANCE.....the saying......'If you see an Indian and a snake......hit the Indian.....not the snake'.....very apt😂. Please don't misunderstand.....I'm not being racist or putting down the Indians.....I'm merely stating.....IN THIS INSTANCE only.
Astonished to see such an analysis with a facts, cool heads, and most importantly sincerity for the real good of India as well as lasting peace and prosperity in this particular region. Salute !
PATRIOTS, LOYYAL OF HIS COUNTRY, GAVE ADVICES FROM THE CORE OF HIS HEART. ALWAYS HE SPOKE ON MERIT, THATS WHY PEOPLE OF PAKISTAN LIKE MR, PARVEEN SAWANY❤❤❤
China reacted to the boundary newly drawn by india because of the abrogation of 370... India then told china it is only a line on the map and nothing to do with reality.. China didn't buy that... Failure to convince china is the real issue.. Maybe the line should not have been drawn .. then no issue... Maybe no abrogation of 370 then no issue... @biggpicture2930 or maybe we would gift even ladakh like earlier and no issue? @abhinashkumar3161 Tibetans would be pleased. @biggpicture2930 Kashmir is turning into a very hot issue for India, just like Afghanistan had been for soviet....... Breaking up India ?....... Shouldn't have erased Article 370 but hindu nationalist has an empire to build... @biggpicture2930 Even the Americans are not pleased, because india is creating more trouble for itself, when they want India to devote entirely as 'ukraine' for china....
Chinese sources often present a different perspective on the issues between China and India, especially regarding border tensions and diplomatic relations. Here's a summary of the key points often highlighted by Chinese sources to counter the Indian narrative: Key Points from Chinese Sources: Historical Border Agreements: Chinese sources frequently refer to historical border agreements and claim that their actions are in response to violations or changes in the status quo by India. China asserts that it has always respected historical treaties and that its troop movements are defensive and within its territory. Doklam and Border Disputes: Regarding the Doklam standoff, China maintains that it was constructing a road within its territory and that India unilaterally crossed into disputed territory claimed by Bhutan and China. China accuses India of provoking the Doklam crisis and insists that its subsequent military buildup was a necessary response to Indian aggression. Galwan Valley Incident: In the Galwan Valley clashes, Chinese sources claim that Indian troops crossed into Chinese territory and initiated the confrontation. China emphasizes that its forces acted in self-defense and that the casualties were a result of Indian provocation. 2020 Troop Movements: Chinese narratives often argue that the PLA's troop movements in 2020 were a reaction to Indian infrastructure development and increased military presence near the LAC. They assert that India’s actions were unilateral changes to the status quo, prompting China to reinforce its positions. Wuhan and Chennai Summits: Chinese sources highlight the positive outcomes of the Wuhan and Chennai informal summits, emphasizing the agreements on cooperation and the importance of maintaining peace and stability. They suggest that India's actions, such as the revocation of Article 370, contradicted the spirit of these summits and exacerbated tensions. India's Strategic Alignment with the U.S.: China views India's growing strategic alignment with the U.S., especially through the Quad (Quadrilateral Security Dialogue), as a threat to regional stability and as an effort to contain China. Chinese sources argue that India's participation in U.S.-led initiatives undermines efforts to build trust and resolve bilateral issues through dialogue. Economic and Trade Relations: Despite political and military tensions, China points to the robust trade relationship between the two countries as evidence of the potential for cooperation. Chinese sources often call for separating economic relations from political disputes to ensure mutual prosperity. Conclusion: Chinese sources present a narrative that portrays China as a defender of historical agreements and regional stability, while accusing India of unilateral provocations and strategic alignments that threaten peace. This perspective emphasizes China's defensive actions in response to perceived Indian aggression and infrastructure developments near disputed borders. They advocate for continued dialogue and economic cooperation while expressing concern over India's growing ties with the U.S. and its allies.
Except it was reported : "USCIRF exposes Modi's government and its real agenda behind the annexation of the state of Jammu and Kashmir (J&K) in 2019-revocation of Article 370.., criminal negligence and ignorance towards the genocide in Manipur and the most recent incident of killing of Hardeep Singh Nijjar in Canada..."
Washington Post The New Alliance Between India and Israel”, published in February 2023 wrote on October 11, this year in an article: “Over the past decade, India and Israel have grown increasingly closer as partners and allies…Ties have blossomed under [Indian] Prime Minister’s Narendra Modi and [Israeli Prime Minister] Benjamin Netanyahu, with India and Israel using similar tactics in the occupied territories of Kashmir and the Palestinian territories…seizing lands, displacing people, criminalising dissent, muzzling journalists, and controlling people’s movements…Zionism and Hindutva [Hindu Nationalism] in controlling Palestine and Kashmir…whereas Israel wants to erase Palestinians, India has for decades, used assimilation as a tactic to control Kashmir. Now it is a lot more open to erasing Kashmiris”.
He tells the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth. That id10t external foreign affairs minister lied thru his teeth. No one will take him seriously. From : Singapore 🇸🇬
Well said…..this region of South East, specifically India and Pakistan lacks sincere and prudent leadership…….they(the leadership) assume that other side are stupid as much as their own populace.That is the tragedy and you have rightly identified it in your comment on Mr Swahny’s very intelligent,realistic and fact based analytical Vlog.
Washington Post The New Alliance Between India and Israel”, published in February 2023 wrote on October 11, this year in an article: “Over the past decade, India and Israel have grown increasingly closer as partners and allies…Ties have blossomed under [Indian] Prime Minister’s Narendra Modi and [Israeli Prime Minister] Benjamin Netanyahu, with India and Israel using similar tactics in the occupied territories of Kashmir and the Palestinian territories…seizing lands, displacing people, criminalising dissent, muzzling journalists, and controlling people’s movements…Zionism and Hindutva [Hindu Nationalism] in controlling Palestine and Kashmir…whereas Israel wants to erase Palestinians, India has for decades, used assimilation as a tactic to control Kashmir. Now it is a lot more open to erasing Kashmiris”.
1. After Chinese modernisation, they wanted their troops in Border, but treaty dont allow that, that why they use disputed Doklam as a tool. The management of this is India's blunder "" but it says clearly about the Chinese bad intention, why they bring troops"". 2. To further prevent their incursions and claims, India needs to develop the border infrastructure till Indian claims, so that we can create edge like Doklam. 3. Not Normalising relations with China, is good for India because to grow and create India's own stature in this century, we need West.
Excellent snapshot on India-China relations and future challenges for Mr. Modi and his incompetent EAM, Mr. Jaishankar. Both of these will be history but the people of India will have to pay for their flawed foreign policy concerning India's neighbours, including China.
Since India is not agreeing to normalise until status quo ante is restored by China. Such Lackeys of China like Swamy are thrown out on social to compensate. Frequency of videos has increased indicating frustration of Chinese and their agents
@@mohican6158 time was with soviets till they made a bad move in Afghanistan. One bad aggressive move and you do not know where things will end. While China is no Soviet and India is no Afghanistan, China has a lot to lose. PS- Geopolitics Class is over kid for today, you can go and play now.
@@Wishfulthinker9383 yep and thats why china isn't making any bad rash moves in any of the situation be it taiwan, SCS or LAC but the thing is will india face the same fate as Venezuela's coup attempt or Bangladesh's regime change which is happening right now by the dark hands of the ones sitting in the west , now thats the real question isn't it ?
@@mohican6158 when recession hit which it will soon, China will be impacted the most. People in China do not question dictatorship of Xi because of economic prosperity. Any disruption to that will lead to a Bangladesh like situation in China. The rule there is by force not by people’s mandate. China will meet Soviets’ fate sooner or later due to its arrogance. Xi erred in showing off. Hide strength and buy time was a right strategy, Xi committed blunder by premature ejaculation. Push back against China is serious and widespread.
China as an independent country was unified in 221 BC, that is 2245 years ago. India as an independent country exists since 1947, after the WW2. Between 1857 and 1947 it was the British Raj more 641 ancient reigns, eventually protectorates under the british colonizer, excluding Arunachal Pradesh that belonged to Tibet... Under the british ruler, Raj of Britain included what is now Pakistan, Bangladesh... Tricky history, indeed.
India Is on the Brink Aug. 9, 2023 NRW YORK TIME ince Mr. Modi took office in 2014, his ruling party has torn those asunder with dangerous exclusionary politics intended to charge up the party’s base and advance its goal of remaking India’s secular republic into a majoritarian Hindu state. The repugnant nature of this brand of politics has been clear for some time, but the situation in Manipur shows what’s ahead for India: The world’s most populous country is slowly degenerating into a conflict zone of sectarian violence. This development is rooted in a skewed idea of Hindu supremacy. Historically, Hindu nationalists have idolized Adolf Hitler, dating back to the period before independence, when the leading ideologue of the movement, M.S. Golwalkar, praised the Nazi’s “final solution” to the Jewish problem and held it up as a “a good lesson for us in Hindustan to learn and profit by.” “Mein Kampf,” with its focus on racial superiority, has consistently remained a bestseller in India. Yet, today, many Hindu nationalists are also ardent supporters of Israel and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, whom Modi considers one of his close friends and allies. Far-right Hindu nationalists even rallied outside the Israeli Embassy in New Delhi asking to enroll in the Israel Defense Forces to combat the common enemy of both Israel and India. “The same radical jihadist Islamist terrorist thinking that Israel is a victim of, we are a victim of as well,” one anchor said on television. “Israel is fighting this war on behalf of all of us.” Another leader of Modi’s BJP said on social media: “We may face the situation that Israel is confronting today if we don’t stand up against Politically motivated Radicalism.”
A nation cannot be a super power when it's still bowing down to its master. If India can move completely away from its master. Then clean up corruption then it can become a very modern and powerful nation indeed.
A very brave and clear narrative it is - albeit in retrospect.I'm not sure whether it is consistent with his elaborate opinions on RUclips earlier.That said the the opposition is essentially caught in the Modi's perception trap.They have mostly agreed by default that China is the enemy and refuse to see that honesty and clearsightedness essential to diplomacy and the future of India's long term interests.Modi scores internally there. Modi's problem is to navigate out of this to still play brinkmanship and have active commercial collaboration with China while keeping the US on the right side.This kind of opportunism has limitations.And it is this that he is struggling with.Jaishanker is only trying to articulate to a global audience what the amateur businessman called Modi is trying to sell.While this is indicative of his total disregard for standard and best practices as also of norms of global behaviour this is also another example of his political naivete of national power and its application. Strategic autonomy and non-alignment may be synonyms in his dictionary but then it used to be based on principles tested on an an international platform.The sovereignty of decision-making or its lack of is evident in trying to listen to his industrial masters and flexing his biceps to the domestic audience and finding a convincing mean through his muzzled institutions.China would surely be taking advantage of this foolhardy effort. Even if Modi bumbles to support China or remain grudgingly submissive would be finally in the nation's interest. My bet however will be that Modi and his henchmen would think to steer India through disasters or such like situations to survive because they believe India to be stupid.
It's like Commentry post cricket match connecting some dots and making comments how this players shouldn't played this shot or this player played like this . Very reductonist analysis.
Regarding Amit Shah and Jaishankar statement that soon India will seize Pakistan Occupied Kashmir. "In all history there is no war which was not hatched by the governments, the governments alone, independent of the interests of the people, to whom war is always pernicious even when successful." - Leo Tolstoy Already Kashmir is bribed for decades . It has the highest meat consumption in WORLD whereas rest of India has one of lowest percapita meat consumption. Also percapita GDP of India is lower than 22 nations of Subsaharan Africa. Money is snatched from poor to create highest percapita car ownership in India in Kashmir Rasputin "Let papa (Nicholas II) not plan war. It will be the end of Russia and all of us. We shall be destroyed to the last man". Two main rootless national parties have been on the forefront to implement cash transfers. In Orissa BJP has announced Rs.50000 to each woman. Amit Shah and Jaishankar announced that that would grab Pakistan Occupied Kashmir (POK). If India conquers in its magnificent obsession of Akand Bharat, POK will have to bribed. The cost of war and money spent on winning hearts will have to paid by South Indians. Farmers though rich will not pay a paisa either as income tax or for military adventures. How much delusional it is . After 1947 due to socialist and equilatarian policies talent has fled to every remote corner of the globe. The consequence is that India cannot have a foreign policy. Lots of Indians will be really hurt in one or other part of the world by any foreign policy/war. Therefore , likeSwitzerland, put it into the constitution that 1)India has no foreign policy 2)India will not send it's troops beyond its borders even for United Nations peace keeping missions. Just suspicion of hostile foreign policy can spark a war. None of great powers of Europe and Turkey wanted to start a world war. Just like Jaishankar they wanted to snatch some territory. Result ? Kaiser lost his empire and Czar of biggest and oldest empire lost his head and could not save his family. Max Plank who discovered Quantum mechanics was found begging for food. India stay home stay safe. ===================== “War has all the characteristics of socialism most conservatives hate: Centralized power, state planning, false rationalism, restricted liberties, foolish optimism about intended results, and blindness to unintended secondary results." - Joseph Sobran "A state of war only serves as an excuse for domestic tyranny." - Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn ===================== All mania can be traced to internationalism. USA it's flying saucers, they believe in inter galactic ideologies. Akanda Bharat is COMMUNIST INTERNATIONALIST Ideology. This will be proved in end.. All stem from AVOIDANCE to answer the question "will socialism work in one street? ". Saying yes will invite peals of laughter. So the question is kicked upwards to national and international levels. As General Secretary of the Jan Sangh, Deendayal Upadhyaya made his first public statement on the party’s economic policy on July 25, 1953: “Our economic programme is absolutely socialistic. We are committed to the present economic set up and to the reduction of inequalities in income and expenditure. We wish to establish a 1:20 proportion between the lowest and the highest income. Search for : The eccentric economic ideology of RSS and BJP -Sanjeev Sabhlok. Indiatimes website ≠====================== Nirmala Sitaraman is taxing and buying gold! Why? Before first world war German government cornered , seized all the gold it could lay it's hands on. Gold prices shoots up in war. German government, TAX EATERS, made huge profit even when Germany lost the war. Millions were sacrificed to tax eaters. Governments should not hold gold.
The Chinese have fought each other and foreign invaders for thousands of years, to unite the whole of China. Today China is stronger than ever, and its people can enjoy peace and prosperity more than ever in history. Those that want to divide China's territories up will not succeed. No matter how many countering China organizations are formed (QUAD, NATO..), the Chinese are ready and waiting to defend their land and its large population, just like their ancestors have done for thousands of years. It would be best if India and China have friendly relation. Pravin Sawhney speaks to facts.
Friendly relation with China means, be a good friend and give China whatever land or sea they want.😅
@@mg.f.9023 china settled all the land borders with neighbors except india and butan who also controled by india, with the way of mutual respect.
Mao once said to his generals, he thought really really hard for a week and could not figure out why india wanted to have a war with china in 1962. I guess india thought it is just BECAUSE I CAN with the support of both superpowers in the world USA and soviet union. and chinese dared not to fight back?
@@liveinsea1you are missing the point. India is not China. India is an artificial country created by the British. It has too many internal divisions and conflicts. Having an external enemy units the country. That is why it hasn't resolved border disputes with most neighbors.
@@mg.f.9023reality prove you wrong. There were dispute between china and it's neighbor like family feud throughout history, but their border with China never change for thousands of years. Vietnam today is still the same Vietnam, Korea don't loss an inch throughout thousands of years, their culture language religion are intact thought history. You are using the mind of aggressive westerners to judge a country of civilization. Yes, if china behave like the European, all its neighbors will loss the land and culture, language and religion. Examples abound in America, Australia and many Africa and Asia nations who were once colonized that have loss their identity totally.
People in Xinxiang and Tibet are suffering... Not to mention Hong Kong
Unfortunately, countries like India and Pakistan are still picking their way through the backdraft of British colonialism
Britain planned it this way.
@@fahmad7194 only weak people make a lot of excuse.
@@edhiepitz and what do the strong people do?
@@fahmad7194 they do like what Russia and China are doing.
@@edhiepitzwhen the truth doesn't fit your made up mind everything would be either wrong or the other a brainwashed monkey.
The reason why India has internal problems and issues with its neighbors like Pakistan or Bangladesh or China etc all stems from the backdrop of British colonialism of which India to a certain accent tolerated for a long long time.
Yes blame it on the british... but you re a fool.
Simply, the religious oriented ideology is the very reason for the Partition of United India, Pre 1947.
Did India have a good relationship neighbors, name it one
Name one country apart from North Korea Chinese had good relationship 😢
@@santhugowda7179 hmm, Russia, Laos, Myanmar, Thailand, Kazakhstan, Tajikistan, Pakistan, nepal, Bhutan
ஃ Show one country which doesn't have neighbour problem.
@masterwong
India has problems with all its neighbors.
From : France 🇫🇷
Pravin Sawhney IS the speaker of the truth in India. The Indian government would be better served if it had more people like him in there.
@@Dos895 he would be fired day 1
If people like Pravin were in power, he'd have broken up India into several countries. He's the perfect puppet leader...just like the all Pakistani PMs.
Modi said no Chinese Cross over the border... Why did Jayashanker said otherwise.
Because his wife is Japanese 😂😂😢
@@alyasagan3620 because jay shangkar once said that India lost in 1962 and make indian angry. This statement is his redemption that he's loyal to BJP
It was modis Jumla, he has made so many Jumlas before that, ha added another one.
Jayashanker mistook the tibetans for chinese
What do u mean Modi said no Chinese cross over the border?? Which timeframe was he talking about??
When the EAM calls it "the India-China border", fully knowing that there is no such "border", it shows why things are going wrong. It called the "Line of Actual Control (LAC)". When he calls the LAC as the "border", it ignores the history and circumstances why it's not a border. With such an understanding, whether by design or ignorance (which is unlikely), things can never be objectively addressed.
Moreover, when the EAM makes such false statements, the other side is surely watching and saying, "how can we deal with such liars"?
For China there is no border, the whole world and the space above belongs to them as per their history books 😂
What is a border?
A border is a real or artificial line that separates geographic areas. Borders are political boundaries. They separate countries, states, provinces, counties, cities, and towns. A border outlines the area that a particular governing body controls
Whats EAM?
it is a kind of border
@@sobant4795Minister of Foreign Affairs.
Xi always suggest Nepal to make Good relation with India but Modi says something opposite
That is the reason why people of Nepal do not like Indian leader and burecrate
when Nepal experience earthquake, India purposefully close the road alternative to Nepal, making Nepali trapped. this is the moment Nepal become furious
@@edhiepitz
Due to the indian blockade, China had to airlift aid relief to Nepal disaster struck victims. ln the near future, roads and rails from China will serve Nepal with access for transportation without going through india.
India on the path of British ,to make neighbouring countries it's slave
@@stevencher9968 It's a good thing.
Nepal should fence Indian border and deport as much Indian possible working in Nepal
@@stevencher9968 Yeah it was a disaster and wake up call for Neighbouring country of India.
Parween swamy is not a toady but an honest man with Straightforward views
He is a man that even his enemy can deal with because he his words will stay and he will mean and say what he mean to say. Unlike Modi and Jaishankar, they are duplicitous in their words and deeds, resulting in not meaning what they say, and saying what they mean. If I were the Chinese, then it is best to be wary of such persons as Modi or Jaishankar, because they can convenient backtrack on their agreement, and in effect any deals made with them is really not to be relied upon. Walk away from India is the better action to take. Let the world knows that China has no faith that Modi is a person that China can do deals with.
ps. The West is already aware of the nature of India's Modi govt. becasue I watch an Israeli ex-Ambassador saying that China is aggressive but their words can be trusted once they agree on a deal made, whereas with India, it is much harder to make a deal because she can backtrack on deals, or make retrospective demands after a deal was already agreed upon.
do a search how he and Gazla takes side on China and Pak...
@@HTeo-og1lg which deal by india was back tracked between india and china
Show this man's honest certificate..
@@HTeo-og1lg China is assertive not aggressive. It knows modi india cant be trusted from experience dealing with them but no need to walk away from them , just be patient n keep the status quo will do. Walking away only benefit the uS
*To be blunt, Jaishankar is a liar, plain and simple!*
He dies what he us made or toldto do
@sc-to4uf
Agree absolutely
That id10t is a big liar
Jaishankar is just saying what he is paid to say.
😂
Very realistic analysis. I am from Pakistan and do not dislike Indians who realise and promote facts.
Ha! Ha! Ha! maybe "extended" facts!
Unless India realises n takes or initiates Positive Approach, there is No Way " Both These Countries would ever Enjoy Good Neighborly Relations" , Which remains a Big Sore Point for Both Sides
Excellent analysis in such a simple way. Sawhni Sahib you made it so easy to understand.
First he caught my eyes as one of the brightest minister India ever produced but rapidly he lost my respect because he became like the rest, no substance except talk and joke.
Being a minister is not a talk show comedian as he thought so.
I hope no zelensky in Indian podium 😊
most chinese leaders refuse to talk to the media, one is because they dont have good skills in arguring, the other is winning the arguement wont help to better the country. its a waste of time. the media will not change their mind to make you looking good even if you won the argurement.
Whole world respects Jai Shankar if few countries hates him them it is ok
@@nirmalbhel3231 because they see that India will be a good proxy
@@nirmalbhel3231 He is good as an entertainer in talkshow, not so as a politician.
India has become like their master USA a big liar. Mr. jaishankar was very conservative on facts in his accusation.
At least USA has the Brain and Muscle to defend their territory and interest
why US is angry on India then...
@@nirmalbhel3231 it's a combination of jealousy plus anger plus fear. The same feeling of seeing your date being touchy and flirtatious and slutty with your competitor in love. America is all that because they know they are longer the top kahuna and do not command that respect and fear anymore. So with the loss of self esteem and sense of power the have reduced themselves to this state. Angry ? Only part of it.
@@freddymercury2259 not the america today. They have lost all of that and more in the last 70 years or so. All they know is how to create wars and how to run away when it gets too hot .
Thanks for your cool head to bring peace to this region..
India will never be a superpower as it is still bowing to its Master in the White House and it still believes that it can get benefit from siding with both the East & West at the same time 🤣🤣🤣
and believe in "Democracy and Freedom"
Don't know what can happen in future
@@rajnair1357 ,,
It is never to be good .
To get a good future ,
The work need to be done is a given,
That included Sacrifices & pain , truthfully painful .
Indian leaders must set examples in truthfulness and strive for principles of social equality and clean living. These are the obstacle for uniting a billion people in a diverse culture and language nation. The upright character is the only common language for India.
US has built China and is looking fwd build itself. India's master is itself, will buy oil from RUSSIA despite of criticism. India will fight against China if China attacks, not on anyone's advice
This smacks of TRUTHFULNESS, IMPARTIALITY, AND SCIENCE. IT'S AN ACADEMICBSTUDY of HISTORICAL dimensions.
Thank you so much.❤
Finally, some of the truth is coming out. There are many more aspects and actions, all pointing to the failures of the Indian govt and agencies. This is my understanding why the Indian EAM has been evading a clear answer for over three years. The fear of jeopardising relations with the US, already damaged through the Modi govts poor democracy standards is now being salvaged by supporting the Quad and siding with the US in SCS. And thus preventing peace and prosperity in the China-Pak-India region.
Jaishanker is such a liar.
Why not jayshanker talk about abrogation of 370 declared Ladakh, Jumo & Kashmir uonion territory
India and China must unite and cooperate for peace and benefit of both people. Do not allow foreign powers to divide you and rule over you. With goodwill the border issues can be resolved very quickly. Otherwise let it be in the backburner. Not long ago both nations were victims of the west.
Focus on what's important for the people. Peace 🙏 ✌
learn about india and you won't write silly stufff anymore
Our problem is own theatre commands!!! Nobody knows what our capabilities are senior most planners and advisers included!!!!
Jaishankar will modified his both his stance and statement based on his boss Modi mood.
Don't take him seriously.
Remember India was a 56 Kingdom subcontinent rules by 32 Emperors and Kings, etc divided over 570 districts.
It is like saying Tamil Nadu owns South Tibet. Not logical by history.
Brilliant insight as always Sir ❤
I really can't understand the Indian foreign policy to China as a Chinese. It is so aggressive and unfriendly to China by working with US to against Chinese. It is not smart dealing with the Number 1 manufacturing country and 1.4 billion people like that while India is also seeking to develop themself N improve the living standard of their 1.4 billion people at the same time. Do you Indian need a peaceful and stable outside environment to grow and attract the investment? I sometime really happy to see the unfriendly actions from India to against the Chinese including the Chinese investments. These actions have awakened the Chinese stop investing to India or withdraw from India! The Chinese are out of trouble by not investing in India directly.
U r right thank u for being truthful
We INDIANS have right to know and keep up to date ourselfs about the affairs of our Nation. Those who hide the facts are not doing good to the people of India and of course to India too.
I wonder why has this channel which is so informative, so less viewers and subscribers.
This channel proves Indian mindset. They don't wanna accept Truth and Facts that go against their wishes.
Because the truth hurts 😜
Because common Indians love to watch quacks like parashant dhawan and garauve arya and shifuji and elvish etc etc they love to day dream
@@AliYashkun还有wion 和 palki！🤣
@@Cannoli_JJ wion and palki are being projected as international media but everyone outside india know it's just another zee news crap😅
Jaishankar statement is more political than reality. He has to be good in the eyes of Modi.
What a wonderful, peaceful human being Xi is...always doing his best to keep the aggressive Indians in good humour!!
😂
Aggressive ? You noticed.
Have they been like this?
great Chinese perspective as always.
Do you have your's?
Pravin knows Foreign policy more than any one in the world and best defense expert (spent some years in the defence you know..). Also an expert in economics and 10 other areas (you will see in coming months). Anyone who can beat this?😂 I think everyone following this channel will definitely agree. BTW he is his sponsors favourite 😍
Sir this program is very informative but video need part 1 and 2 ❤
What a brilliant analysis comes from you. Very interesting.
No doubt you are most knowledgeable, honest, fair commentator
He is purportedly better than Jaishanker, Modi and the rest. Who needs enemies when you have people like him populating India?
Indian democracy? Locking up the oppositions to win by default? . It was a shocker! Despite illegal electoral bond cheating and getting people to donate to avoid extortion charges etc, , locking up dissidents and chief ministers, freezing finances of opposition at election, and BJP partisan controlled of Police, judicial, and electoral commission, and food subsidies to 800,000,000 by direct payment, the oppositions did Incredibly well! Voters didn't buy the BS completely because of worsening economy.
Thank you for clarifying the events since 2016.
PM Modi is a consummate perception manager.
He certainly uses a big part of his day doing that.
I hope he would allocate more of his time at doing stuffs that would actually help Indians.
Dear PS. I really appreciate your analysis of the testy relations between these 2 gigantic countries
With that mindset, I can’t see the border situation and One to one relationship improving any time soon
you make friend with cereal killers?
India GDP per capita is only $2731 (estimate in 2024), and Thailand is $6909(2023) , Vietnam is $4163 and Philippine is $3498. India doesn't look like a superpower.
China's GDP per capita is above Malaysia today or 4x of India. India is still dilusional.
Modi Amit Shah have boosted the issue of Sikh by killing so many Sikh inside and outside the country. By removing the articles they have also repelled those Kashmiries who were with them. They have accelerated unrest in Manipur. Pakistan was also annoyed by abrogation of 370. In short, Modi and Amit Shah have made a mess for India.
370 is useless things
Kashmir MUST be freed from hands of India.
In long run it will be beneficial for both Pak n India.
@@IronMan-nu3rb it's a integral part of India and already free Pakistan should stop their propegenda and focus on their country
China be like
Balochistan & KPK must be freed from hands of pakistan,
In long run it will be beneficial not only for pak & india but it will beneficial for the whole world @@IronMan-nu3rb
he has always been fair and square based on facts. Thankyou
Thanks for such enlightening decoding of events, sir..... stay healthy and stay blessed
This exposes India's policy of spreading lies for both domestic and international consumption purposes. The credibility of what present Indian government says on different platforms about their achievements or about strength of their friendship with friendly countries or strength of Indian defence against enemy countries seems to be very low now.
Well said. Factual Analysis.
Amazing hidden truth revealed. Thank you, sir.👍
He us very clear and honest fair person
A very honest to goodness analyzis
A canny and cunning Jai-Shankar needs to pay heed to Bapu Nehru, first.
Summing it up its the colonial government Britain that had planted the bad seeds before leaving that has now grown into fruition of bad fruits. India since independence has not have any leadership who's able to cut the umbalical cord nor undo the spell the british had put on them. If they have any self worth and independence demand the return of their priced diamond. That stone will continually remind the indians of their impotence .
What a great video, clear and concise! I am Indian, and a keen supporter of the BJP. From what I heard in this video, both China and India are to blame. First, why did China want to build a road for its army in territory that wasn't Chinese? Now to India. India has built a trend of untrustworthiness in its dealings, whether in trade or diplomatic field. Then there is the US digging at India to oppose the Chinese. Then there is Dr Jaishankar. He has direct personal interests that clash with his position. His son lives in the US. He is married to a Japanese wife. Japan is a vassal of the US. Therefore, there will always be tension with so many factors at play. For India to succeed, it has to become CREDIBLE. It must display professionalism. Mean what you say and say what you mean. It must stop following in behind the US. Finally, PM Modi must replace his foreign minister. Be friend with all, but not subservient. Have a position on the world stage instead of being all things to all men. Work with China in a close and friendly manner. Above all, remember that the US is a fast fading power. Don't back a losing horse!
How come India DID NOT know the construction of the highway by China if indeed it was built on land owned by India?
Farcical Surgical Strike= Farzical Strike, in the words of Mr. Arun Shourie.
Awesome vlog Sir, as usual.
Joke 😂😂😂
That was not even a surgical strike. It was a minor cross-LoC raid conducted by Indian Army Special Forces a few kilometers inside Pakistani-occupied territory.
Thank you for your honest unbiased explanation. It appears peace between India and China will depend on a third party.
When Modi stepped off the plane in Moscow & hugged Putin Washington went ballistic. Hence India live in fear of being friendly with China lest it enrage Washington. There is no permission for peace.
After listening to Parvin Sawhney, I started to have a better understanding of the tensions between India and China. In politics, many political leaders are led astray by money and power temptations. I hope the current Indian government looked after the interests of the common people by focusing on infrastructure development, education, and trade.
Once again very smart analysis 🎉
But whatever the logic is, abrogation of article 370 is wholly India's internal issue and China has nothing to do with it.
Until you drew a boundary unilaterally where no boundary ever exited- that is what abrogation of article 370 led to.... China doesn't like their tibetans got shortchanged by India.
@@biggpicture2930
If Ladakh had no boundary to the Tibetan side previously, then the situation is same as it was before the abrogation.
China has sabotaged the status quo, as it seems to me, only to keep India busy on the eastern side so that their investment on the western side on CPEC run smoothly through POK.
Chinese logic reminds me that of the wolf of my childhood fable who wanted to devour the lamb.
@@biggpicture2930
Wasn't there a boundary line between J&K and China occupied Tibet previous to the abrogation?
So how the abrogation of 370 could anyway mean to draw the border unilaterally?
China's logic is that of the wolf of our childhood fable , who needed an alibi to eat the lamb. Here China's intention is to keep India busy on the eastern side so that her huge investment in CPEC running through Pakistan occupied Kashmir remains safe.
China wants India to remain terrorstruck and unguarded.
Fact based and realistic analysis…..hope your efforts provoke the thought process of those who deny ground realities and living in a state of denial,which is dangerous to us all.Nothing will go off USA or Europe.South Asian region and its people,who haven’t been fortunate enough to have a sincere and prudent leadership,will bear the brunt of leadership’s failure to bring peace in the region.
This was a very good and accurate summary of recent historical events. You are a great strategic analyst and about one of the few voices in India I trust and will listen to.
IN THIS INSTANCE.....the saying......'If you see an Indian and a snake......hit the Indian.....not the snake'.....very apt😂. Please don't misunderstand.....I'm not being racist or putting down the Indians.....I'm merely stating.....IN THIS INSTANCE only.
Excellent coverage of China India relations and events leading to present impasse
Either Jaishankar accepts this version or challenges him
Astonished to see such an analysis with a facts, cool heads, and most importantly sincerity for the real good of India as well as lasting peace and prosperity in this particular region. Salute !
india's fate has already been sealed in 1947 under the white man's proud Banner - ' DEMOCRACY '
if you know the democracy india is practicing, it is fake.... even though democracy is also practice in some form in china.
Right 👍 ON 👍😮
This man has large number of Chinese and pakistani audience.. 😂😂
Unfortunately. many still like BS! The current status or even the performance in the Olympic are the best testament.
PATRIOTS, LOYYAL OF HIS COUNTRY, GAVE ADVICES FROM THE CORE OF HIS HEART. ALWAYS HE SPOKE ON MERIT, THATS WHY PEOPLE OF PAKISTAN LIKE MR, PARVEEN SAWANY❤❤❤
We very well that
wonderful analysis
Very well explained....
L’amerique va essayer de diviser pour allumer le feu 🔥 entre les deux 😮😮
Vive l’Inde 🇮🇳 ❤ vive la Chine 🇨🇳 ❤ et vive les BRICS 💪💪
China reacted to the boundary newly drawn by india because of the abrogation of 370... India then told china it is only a line on the map and nothing to do with reality.. China didn't buy that... Failure to convince china is the real issue.. Maybe the line should not have been drawn .. then no issue... Maybe no abrogation of 370 then no issue...
@biggpicture2930 or maybe we would gift even ladakh like earlier and no issue?
@abhinashkumar3161 Tibetans would be pleased.
@biggpicture2930 Kashmir is turning into a very hot issue for India, just like Afghanistan had been for soviet....... Breaking up India ?....... Shouldn't have erased Article 370 but hindu nationalist has an empire to build...
@biggpicture2930 Even the Americans are not pleased, because india is creating more trouble for itself, when they want India to devote entirely as 'ukraine' for china....
Chinese sources often present a different perspective on the issues between China and India, especially regarding border tensions and diplomatic relations. Here's a summary of the key points often highlighted by Chinese sources to counter the Indian narrative:
Key Points from Chinese Sources:
Historical Border Agreements:
Chinese sources frequently refer to historical border agreements and claim that their actions are in response to violations or changes in the status quo by India.
China asserts that it has always respected historical treaties and that its troop movements are defensive and within its territory.
Doklam and Border Disputes:
Regarding the Doklam standoff, China maintains that it was constructing a road within its territory and that India unilaterally crossed into disputed territory claimed by Bhutan and China.
China accuses India of provoking the Doklam crisis and insists that its subsequent military buildup was a necessary response to Indian aggression.
Galwan Valley Incident:
In the Galwan Valley clashes, Chinese sources claim that Indian troops crossed into Chinese territory and initiated the confrontation.
China emphasizes that its forces acted in self-defense and that the casualties were a result of Indian provocation.
2020 Troop Movements:
Chinese narratives often argue that the PLA's troop movements in 2020 were a reaction to Indian infrastructure development and increased military presence near the LAC.
They assert that India’s actions were unilateral changes to the status quo, prompting China to reinforce its positions.
Wuhan and Chennai Summits:
Chinese sources highlight the positive outcomes of the Wuhan and Chennai informal summits, emphasizing the agreements on cooperation and the importance of maintaining peace and stability.
They suggest that India's actions, such as the revocation of Article 370, contradicted the spirit of these summits and exacerbated tensions.
India's Strategic Alignment with the U.S.:
China views India's growing strategic alignment with the U.S., especially through the Quad (Quadrilateral Security Dialogue), as a threat to regional stability and as an effort to contain China.
Chinese sources argue that India's participation in U.S.-led initiatives undermines efforts to build trust and resolve bilateral issues through dialogue.
Economic and Trade Relations:
Despite political and military tensions, China points to the robust trade relationship between the two countries as evidence of the potential for cooperation.
Chinese sources often call for separating economic relations from political disputes to ensure mutual prosperity.
Conclusion:
Chinese sources present a narrative that portrays China as a defender of historical agreements and regional stability, while accusing India of unilateral provocations and strategic alignments that threaten peace. This perspective emphasizes China's defensive actions in response to perceived Indian aggression and infrastructure developments near disputed borders. They advocate for continued dialogue and economic cooperation while expressing concern over India's growing ties with the U.S. and its allies.
Except it was reported : "USCIRF exposes Modi's government and its real agenda behind the annexation of the state of Jammu and Kashmir (J&K) in 2019-revocation of Article 370.., criminal negligence and ignorance towards the genocide in Manipur and the most recent incident of killing of Hardeep Singh Nijjar in Canada..."
Washington Post The New Alliance Between India and Israel”, published in February 2023 wrote on October 11, this year in an article: “Over the past decade, India and Israel have grown increasingly closer as partners and allies…Ties have blossomed under [Indian] Prime Minister’s Narendra Modi and [Israeli Prime Minister] Benjamin Netanyahu, with India and Israel using similar tactics in the occupied territories of Kashmir and the Palestinian territories…seizing lands, displacing people, criminalising dissent, muzzling journalists, and controlling people’s movements…Zionism and Hindutva [Hindu Nationalism] in controlling Palestine and Kashmir…whereas Israel wants to erase Palestinians, India has for decades, used assimilation as a tactic to control Kashmir. Now it is a lot more open to erasing Kashmiris”.
Yes Indians the instigators
Good megaphone for China..
Not really... The minister of Finance, India has also pivoted to attract china investments.
India should stay in Russia china block. Banya mentality chhod na padega.
Parveen you are telling half truth.
He tells the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth.
That id10t external foreign affairs minister lied thru his teeth. No one will take him seriously.
From : Singapore 🇸🇬
Well said…..this region of South East, specifically India and Pakistan lacks sincere and prudent leadership…….they(the leadership) assume that other side are stupid as much as their own populace.That is the tragedy and you have rightly identified it in your comment on Mr Swahny’s very intelligent,realistic and fact based analytical Vlog.
It will be boring if there is no fight.
Very informative!
Good program, the speaker is a balanced in the head analyst with good insight into the geo-military politics
I wish I could give a referral letter to the Chinese so they could increase your .50 cent.
50 cents , not .50cents go back to school , a proper one .5cents means half of a cent.......
@@biggpicture2930 Thank you, Sir, Thank you.🤣
War with pKistan has become a possibilty feel people in kashmir
😊😊😊
Pak will never allow Kashmir in peace, attacked and killed, reaped in 47. India is helping Kashmiris
Washington Post The New Alliance Between India and Israel”, published in February 2023 wrote on October 11, this year in an article: “Over the past decade, India and Israel have grown increasingly closer as partners and allies…Ties have blossomed under [Indian] Prime Minister’s Narendra Modi and [Israeli Prime Minister] Benjamin Netanyahu, with India and Israel using similar tactics in the occupied territories of Kashmir and the Palestinian territories…seizing lands, displacing people, criminalising dissent, muzzling journalists, and controlling people’s movements…Zionism and Hindutva [Hindu Nationalism] in controlling Palestine and Kashmir…whereas Israel wants to erase Palestinians, India has for decades, used assimilation as a tactic to control Kashmir. Now it is a lot more open to erasing Kashmiris”.
kashmaris, khalistani. manipul, nagaland,......... ... all trouble spots...... USA's warning to citizens... "don't go"....
Kashmir will become very hot... This could be the catalyst for India's breakup...
1. After Chinese modernisation, they wanted their troops in Border, but treaty dont allow that, that why they use disputed Doklam as a tool. The management of this is India's blunder "" but it says clearly about the Chinese bad intention, why they bring troops"".
2. To further prevent their incursions and claims, India needs to develop the border infrastructure till Indian claims, so that we can create edge like Doklam.
3. Not Normalising relations with China, is good for India because to grow and create India's own stature in this century, we need West.
Thank you, Sir.
👍
Gourav Arya is saying that china is now surrounded by 24 nations bcoz of our Minister Jaishankar.....
He is a langur wearing clothes and who can speak.
He is nuts
@@postman11aataa mila bhai ?
India just sont get it - British Raj was not an organically evolving Asian nation, and so its "borders" shall never be honored.
Excellent snapshot on India-China relations and future challenges for Mr. Modi and his incompetent EAM, Mr. Jaishankar. Both of these will be history but the people of India will have to pay for their flawed foreign policy concerning India's neighbours, including China.
If Chinese transfer 1.5 trillion dollar to India. 😊
@@santhugowda7179 hahahahaha, I wish they did!
He seems to be in the payroll of the Chinese
Ask him - how's that tea seller is doing??
You mean: "WHAT that tea seller is doing?"
he is enjoying PM post. That's the beauty of democracy, China can never taste it. People will be living under pressure
@@nirmalbhel3231 the elections were rigged. Freedom of press and speech was taken away. This is not democracy! Which planet u living on?
@@nirmalbhel3231
indian tea boy: Tea Sarr??
Putin: Ahh,Yes! CHINESE TEA!!!
@@nirmalbhel3231 There is no democracy nor equality in a caste system society.
Very well presented and do appreciate his unbiased approach.
Since India is not agreeing to normalise until status quo ante is restored by China. Such Lackeys of China like Swamy are thrown out on social to compensate. Frequency of videos has increased indicating frustration of Chinese and their agents
😂 calm down buddy, time is with china
why so desperate to normalize with a cereal killer? Can you stop it from eating anymore cereal?
@@mohican6158 time was with soviets till they made a bad move in Afghanistan. One bad aggressive move and you do not know where things will end. While China is no Soviet and India is no Afghanistan, China has a lot to lose.
PS- Geopolitics Class is over kid for today, you can go and play now.
@@Wishfulthinker9383 yep and thats why china isn't making any bad rash moves in any of the situation be it taiwan, SCS or LAC but the thing is will india face the same fate as Venezuela's coup attempt or Bangladesh's regime change which is happening right now by the dark hands of the ones sitting in the west , now thats the real question isn't it ?
@@mohican6158 when recession hit which it will soon, China will be impacted the most. People in China do not question dictatorship of Xi because of economic prosperity. Any disruption to that will lead to a Bangladesh like situation in China. The rule there is by force not by people’s mandate.
China will meet Soviets’ fate sooner or later due to its arrogance. Xi erred in showing off. Hide strength and buy time was a right strategy, Xi committed blunder by premature ejaculation.
Push back against China is serious and widespread.
You sound more like a Chinese spokesperson than an Indian "journalist". 😀
China as an independent country was unified in 221 BC, that is 2245 years ago.
India as an independent country exists since 1947, after the WW2. Between 1857 and 1947 it was the British Raj more 641 ancient reigns, eventually protectorates under the british colonizer, excluding Arunachal Pradesh that belonged to Tibet...
Under the british ruler, Raj of Britain included what is now Pakistan, Bangladesh...
Tricky history, indeed.
India was just a region and not a country before the British arrived. Also the entire north east region was never a part of india.
India Is on the Brink
Aug. 9, 2023 NRW YORK TIME
ince Mr. Modi took office in 2014, his ruling party has torn those asunder with dangerous exclusionary politics intended to charge up the party’s base and advance its goal of remaking India’s secular republic into a majoritarian Hindu state. The repugnant nature of this brand of politics has been clear for some time, but the situation in Manipur shows what’s ahead for India: The world’s most populous country is slowly degenerating into a conflict zone of sectarian violence.
This development is rooted in a skewed idea of Hindu supremacy. Historically, Hindu nationalists have idolized Adolf Hitler, dating back to the period before independence, when the leading ideologue of the movement, M.S. Golwalkar, praised the Nazi’s “final solution” to the Jewish problem and held it up as a “a good lesson for us in Hindustan to learn and profit by.” “Mein Kampf,” with its focus on racial superiority, has consistently remained a bestseller in India.
Yet, today, many Hindu nationalists are also ardent supporters of Israel and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, whom Modi considers one of his close friends and allies.
Far-right Hindu nationalists even rallied outside the Israeli Embassy in New Delhi asking to enroll in the Israel Defense Forces to combat the common enemy of both Israel and India. “The same radical jihadist Islamist terrorist thinking that Israel is a victim of, we are a victim of as well,” one anchor said on television. “Israel is fighting this war on behalf of all of us.” Another leader of Modi’s BJP said on social media: “We may face the situation that Israel is confronting today if we don’t stand up against Politically motivated Radicalism.”
INDIA is a troubled divided nation
Thank you very much for your Analysis 👍
A nation cannot be a super power when it's still bowing down to its master. If India can move completely away from its master. Then clean up corruption then it can become a very modern and powerful nation indeed.
You still got the powerful rich controlling the government... You stll got the nationalists wanting more land...... China will give?
now is bowing to china now. India will let china help in investment and technology now.. Still obeying a master.. Idiott so also no superpower!
A very brave and clear narrative it is - albeit in retrospect.I'm not sure whether it is consistent with his elaborate opinions on RUclips earlier.That said the the opposition is essentially caught in the Modi's perception trap.They have mostly agreed by default that China is the enemy and refuse to see that honesty and clearsightedness essential to diplomacy and the future of India's long term interests.Modi scores internally there. Modi's problem is to navigate out of this to still play brinkmanship and have active commercial collaboration with China while keeping the US on the right side.This kind of opportunism has limitations.And it is this that he is struggling with.Jaishanker is only trying to articulate to a global audience what the amateur businessman called Modi is trying to sell.While this is indicative of his total disregard for standard and best practices as also of norms of global behaviour this is also another example of his political naivete of national power and its application.
Strategic autonomy and non-alignment may be synonyms in his dictionary but then it used to be based on principles tested on an an international platform.The sovereignty of decision-making or its lack of is evident in trying to listen to his industrial masters and flexing his biceps to the domestic audience and finding a convincing mean through his muzzled institutions.China would surely be taking advantage of this foolhardy effort.
Even if Modi bumbles to support China or remain grudgingly submissive would be finally in the nation's interest.
My bet however will be that Modi and his henchmen would think to steer India through disasters or such like situations to survive because they believe India to be stupid.
Ccp mouth peice😮
China's occupation of Tibet is questionable . China invaded Tibet
Gayshankar I mean I mean I mean I mean😂😂😂😂
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
It's like Commentry post cricket match connecting some dots and making comments how this players shouldn't played this shot or this player played like this .
Very reductonist analysis.
Regarding Amit Shah and Jaishankar statement that soon India will seize Pakistan Occupied Kashmir.
"In all history there is no war which was not hatched by the governments, the governments alone, independent of the interests of the people, to whom war is always pernicious even when successful." - Leo Tolstoy
Already Kashmir is bribed for decades . It has the highest meat consumption in WORLD whereas rest of India has one of lowest percapita meat consumption.
Also percapita GDP of India is lower than 22 nations of Subsaharan Africa. Money is snatched from poor to create highest percapita car ownership in India in Kashmir
Rasputin "Let papa (Nicholas II) not plan war. It will be the end of Russia and all of us. We shall be destroyed to the last man".
Two main rootless national parties have been on the forefront to implement cash transfers. In Orissa BJP has announced Rs.50000 to each woman. Amit Shah and Jaishankar announced that that would grab Pakistan Occupied Kashmir (POK). If India conquers in its magnificent obsession of Akand Bharat, POK will have to bribed.
The cost of war and money spent on winning hearts will have to paid by South Indians. Farmers though rich will not pay a paisa either as income tax or for military adventures.
How much delusional it is .
After 1947 due to socialist and equilatarian policies talent has fled to every remote corner of the globe. The consequence is that India cannot have a foreign policy. Lots of Indians will be really hurt in one or other part of the world by any foreign policy/war.
Therefore , likeSwitzerland, put it into the constitution that
1)India has no foreign policy
2)India will not send it's troops beyond its borders even for United Nations peace keeping missions.
Just suspicion of hostile foreign policy can spark a war. None of great powers of Europe and Turkey wanted to start a world war. Just like Jaishankar they wanted to snatch some territory. Result ? Kaiser lost his empire and Czar of biggest and oldest empire lost his head and could not save his family. Max Plank who discovered Quantum mechanics was found begging for food.
India stay home stay safe.
=====================
“War has all the characteristics of socialism most conservatives hate: Centralized power, state planning, false rationalism, restricted liberties, foolish optimism about intended results, and blindness to unintended secondary results." - Joseph Sobran
"A state of war only serves as an excuse for domestic tyranny." - Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn
=====================
All mania can be traced to internationalism. USA it's flying saucers, they believe in inter galactic ideologies.
Akanda Bharat is COMMUNIST INTERNATIONALIST Ideology. This will be proved in end..
All stem from AVOIDANCE to answer the question "will socialism work in one street? ". Saying yes will invite peals of laughter. So the question is kicked upwards to national and international levels.
As General Secretary of the Jan Sangh, Deendayal Upadhyaya made his first public statement on the party’s economic policy on July 25, 1953: “Our economic programme is absolutely socialistic. We are committed to the present economic set up and to the reduction of inequalities in income and expenditure. We wish to establish a 1:20 proportion between the lowest and the highest income.
Search for : The eccentric economic ideology of RSS and BJP -Sanjeev Sabhlok. Indiatimes website
≠======================
Nirmala Sitaraman is taxing and buying gold! Why?
Before first world war German government cornered , seized all the gold it could lay it's hands on.
Gold prices shoots up in war. German government, TAX EATERS, made huge profit even when Germany lost the war. Millions were sacrificed to tax eaters.
Governments should not hold gold.
India is very good of lying or telling a story.
PARAJIT-SHANKAR-EITHER..😮😮😮