China foreign policy become fantastic 🤘 day by day truly they will rule the world n its happening, US era is over but hard to say that India become pawns in international geopolitics n it's fact.
SG you got to have your graphics team highlight the points on the map with a flash or arrow when you mention the place, one is lost looking for the points on the map while trying to stay focused to what you conveying to us
Hath hila hila ke matter solve nahi hote. 1.corona kal main hamla ker China ne socha Bharat response nahi dega,per dia. 2.chinies thinking ki long negotiation table per India tthak jayega. 3.Yeh ki shayad govt.India ki change ho jaye . Bharat ab China ko ba khubi read ker Sakta hai. (Bharat ab China Expert ban gaya hai)
@@IndianArma I think my view is quite objective. By losing patrolling rights, both sides have lost as well as gained territory. And by restoration of patrolling rights, both sides have gone back to status quo.
@@IndianArma, u believe me, These bot bhakts have lost their minds long ago, take their 100₹, give them 50₹ back, They will celebrate that they recieved 50 back... Bhakts are such optimistic, that their objective is to credit their lord, Even if he farts ...
@@fabulousindian6582OK we are bhakts... At least we are no boot lickinkg slaves/inbreds like you, who wear the farts of your Italian madam... Asshole😂😂
One thing which caught my attention was the mention that Indian infrastructure in that area has increased dramatically. But for Modi, it would have remained desolate and easy picking for the Chinese. Hope the Congress remembers this whenever they try to needle the Govt. about "huge losses" in those areas to Chinese forces.
OFCOURSE we Indians have LOST territory under Modi to Chinese despite his tall claims of 56 inch chest and "ghar mein ghuske marenge". There is no denying that India lost territory to China under coward Modi - Nehru 2.0.
Thanks Modi, Thanks Jayshankar Ji, Big Thanks to the Beloved Indian Army.. Thanks to IAF for supply and patrol missions and everything. Thanks to Navy for providing P8i's for reconnaissance and surveillance and Mig 29K's for patrolling mission.. All elements came together and performed.. Bharat Mata ki jay.. Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj ki jay
Hold on to your horses - this announcement is from India's side only (according to Brahma Chellaney), not from the Chinese side. There is no reason to celebrate - at least not yet!
@@abba747 congress wastest idiotic party made mistakes by not developing infrastructure in parliament saying we are ostrich we don't need infrastructure in border but bjp is slow should immediately develop infrastructure or leave pmo bjp waste party then
China wants entire arunchal pradesh just becuase you hate anglos will you give away arunachal? Plz dont support china if you are patriotic china is as much enemy as us
Really love The Print for such detailed analysis. Both Shekhar Gupta and Snehesh Alex Phillips are doing a great service to India by not siding with any political narrative. Thankyou Team 'The Print'.
Shekhar ji, This is a welcome sign. But we need to see that it is not in sync with the China policy of Gain 2 inch and then concede 1 inch as compromise gaining 1 inch in the process. We must not concede the legitimate, legal and strategic position.
@stevesteve4700 the level of wisdom and the intricate strategy hidden in that comment was eye opening. Our armed forces better be paying heed to this middle class indian sun tzu and chanakya put together and drawing inspiration from his experience of trawling through reams and reams of whatsapp forwards
Excellent analysis Shekhar. I do have a question: why do we persist on using feet instead of meters? We have stopped using miles, so why use feet? Thanks.
Your content exchange and style, also knowledge is phenomenal. Take a bow, Shekhar Gupta. Stay like this and keep enriching the audience. Huge respect sir.
I have been travelling to these areas of east Laddakh. Infrastructure development is awesome. Roads, airports, health services are of international standards. Army and air force deployment is massive. Many new roads are being built to improve connectivity. One su h is between Demchok to Manali which will pass through record altitude of over 18000ft.
I watched this video 3 times, and I'm still scratching my head on what exactly has happened. There're so many points of disengagement, its hard to keep track what was discussed when. As much informative the digressions are, can that be skipped for such long-winded discussions?
Amazing thought presentation with statistics with imagination. The thing which lack is, shekar sir's thought presentation as projection directly connected to his brain....... ❤❤❤
Shekhar - You need to cover where this is coming for, the real reason for PRC pulling back, the larger geopolitical context to all this! And what will be next.
what about the real reason why India is making up with China? (Bangladesh color revolution against pro-india government by US, mass investment pull out and stock sells from Western nations, increasing scrutiny on India black ops in western nations, more western reports on India's domestic human rights violations as well as India's stance in Ukraine war) India is now on western s*** list just like China is, except India is far rom ready to be independent from western nations, unlike China.
Hold on to your horses - this announcement is from India's side only (according to Brahma Chellaney), not from the Chinese side. There is no reason to celebrate - at least not yet!
Dear SG, One thing which can be corrected, Karakoram pass is very far away from Gilgit Xinjiang highway. There is no threat to that highway from the Indian side from Karakoram pass.
There was only one question on my mind when I started watching this episode ' have we returned to status quo ante 2019 ? ' ....that was answered at the end....thank you print team 👍
I regularly hear these episodes on podcasts. Enjoyed the unedited 39-minute-long episode. I request to share some unedited versions to let people know the efforts involved in correcting the facts and the human side of Shekhar Gupta Ji
Yes, the timing is important. Also the Chinese have made no firm commitments. No reason to celebrate yet, as long as "ground realities" of Depsang and Demchok do not change!
India continues to make his army and economy stronger and stronger with make in India and also keep dialogue and diplomacy keep going with china.This is only way of peace in both LoC and LaC.
India can try to keep up but avoid draining resources that like lead up to collapse of the soviet.. This also a risk to china, but much more riskier to a poorer nation. In fact , for years, china kept its arm spending low not only because it is is a waste of money, but to keep a low profile to avoid the attention of USA.. Maybe , it is karma that india got to spend big on military
@@mg.f.9023 Military spending will increase with economic growth and India economy is growing and India also working on creating defence ecosystems within india. USA military bases all over the world and this need huge military spending to maintain this military bases also USA economy is 25 trillion dollar and same with china.
@@biggpicture2930 only want to say that peace come with cost of strong military and economy. India don’t want to involve in any war for next 30-40 year and focus on economic growth. USA and China not involve in any war and not fight any war within inside their country and also use other countries ground to challenge each other.
27:55 Two corrections:- 1) Demchok is not where COK is at its narrowest 2) Aksai Chin is a Chinese name. Kindly refer to it as Chinese Occupied Kashmir
..........Why Nehru expanded Northern Borders with China during 1947-1962??? These are main reasons... 1) Britain left India hurriedly so Nehru annexed/ merged Hyderabad, Manipur and Kashmir etc small nations or Princely States in 1948.. 2) Nehru invaded Goa twice and merged with India in 1961... 3) After annexation of Goa in 1961, Nehru and Indian Army morale increased strongly so Nehru tried to merge " Aksai Chin" from 1950 to 1962 so India- China War happened ( Aksai Chin was a vast barren lands so British- India government never showed it in any Indian maps). Aksai Chin was always under Tibetans control and Aksai Chin belongs to Tibet forever.... 4) Indira Gandhi annexed Sikkim in 1975 by using Indian Military forces. India tried to annex Nepal and Bhutan failed because America, UN and China protected Nepal and Bhutan from Indian expansionism during 1950-1975...........
SG, you missed 3 imp reasons: A. Massive infra, tech & equip upgrade by india in last 5yrs. B.Moving tanks 'first' on tops overlooking the chinese side. C.Modi elected as Pm 3rd term so no chance to deal with congress or weak opposition.
What impact is this going to have on west which was using Khalistanis on their soil to poke India relentlessly? Is this one of those movements where India is stating into the eyes of west while looking towards east?
Nice episode. Even though disputed, the fact that India & China haven't exchanged LAC maps unlike LoC (with Pakistan), patrolling becomes much more important than permanent deployment on LAC vice versa in case of LoC
Dear SG Times have changed. A monologue that's hastily prepared isn't cutting it anymore. Good graphics and crisp voice over would be best but anything closer to good graphics is basic.
In a major breakthrough related to the four-and-a-half-years of military standoff along the LAC, after the Chinese incursions in eastern Ladakh, India and China have agreed to restore patrolling rights in the Depsang Plains in the north and Demchok in the south of Ladakh. This agreement comes after several meetings (31 so far) were held by the WMCC (Working Mechanism for Consultation and Coordination on India-China Border Affairs), 21 rounds of India-China Corps Commander Level Meetings, as well as multiple meetings between the two Foreign Ministers in order to ease tensions, narrow down the differences and find early resolution of the outstanding issues. It is noteworthy, since May 2020, Indian and Chinese troops have had multiple confrontations in the seven friction points in the eastern Ladakh - Galwan Valley (PP 14), Hot Springs (PP 15), Gogra (PP 17A), North and South banks of Pangong Tso, Depsang Plains and Charding Nullah in Demchok region. According to both EAM and Foreign Secretary, disengagement has happened at all the friction points, leading to pre-2020 status quo in the region. As per reports, overall deployment of troops along the LAC will be ‘thinned down’ in due course. The arrangement assumes greater significance since it comes just ahead of the 16th BRICS Summit, scheduled to be held in Kazan, Russia, on October 22-23, where Indian PM Narendra Modi and Chinese President Xi Jinping are expected to hold bilateral talks on the sidelines of the two-day summit. Calling the development a ‘positive and good’ one, EAM S. Jaishankar emphasized the outcome as a product of “very patient and persevering diplomacy”. After all, only peace and stability along the border will lead to growth and prosperity in the two countries.
Chinese came to help Pakistan. India was keeping LOC hot. Chinese at LAC,India was forced to make LOC silent. They have achieved their goal. If India again pursue LOC, then Chinese are sitting up North. Two front war.
महाराष्ट्र के चुनाव ( नोव्हेंबर २०२४ ) के पेहेले चीन ने अपनी सेना वापस बुलायी और यह एक भारत कि बहुत बडी जीत है ऐसा चीन पेहेले कभी नही करता था उलटा चुनाव को प्रभावित करणे के लिये बहुत हि घतीया चाले चलता था और आगर उसकी हार होनी है तो चुनाव के बाद हि ऐसे स्टेप लेता था
The problem here is that India is the ones to announce it and China didn’t say anything about it. That shows who is more desperate, and this is a big revelation and a wrong posture. Media should refrain from this “feel good” announcement, which adds to the impression that India is more desperate.
Why would China say, anything, about it? As if it is a big thing in China like it is in India. Being such a sophisticated country, China has a lot of matter to attend. India stop harassing Chinese companies would be more significant to address than a pesky neighbor stop making problems. Resolving the border problems or not doesn't do anything much. It's in the mountain, not in their doorstep!
China top leadership has democratic pressures to make such announcements? So why are you even expecting such behavior from China? Our rules don't apply to China's political leadership. Unless you have a high opinion about the "virtues of Chinese dictatorship".
It is in our intrest to keep China Stretched as well... Indians are already feeling the heat of inflation due to two global wars... Another war by China on Taiwanin will have huge socio- economic impications in the region... Let the descalation be delayed till the other two wars settle
But india is bursting with unemployment issues, regional tensions that could tear india apart very soon, amidst the fallout with USA and canada over panun and nijar
In fact, I see it the other way around, India is kept stretched . Resources are diverted away to military from growing its economy and improving brain .
@@biggpicture2930 you did not need to get personal here... Please enlighten us what is Toxic food and all..??? Frustrated hai kya..?? teen teen comments... India has been always streched so I don't think it should be a new thing... The economic growth every country is registering now is due to the base effect... I am sure about which you know nothing... And I am sure you want another war... Mr self Proclaimed intellect who thinks it is his birth right to demene other people you are the toxic Indian that people should stay away from
@@biggpicture2930 you did not need to get personal here... Please enlighten us what is Toxic food and all..??? Frustrated hai kya..?? teen teen comments... India has been always streched so I don't think it should be a new thing... The economic growth every country is registering now is due to the base effect... I am sure about which you know nothing... And I am sure you want another war... MrSelfProclaimed Intellect who thinks it is his birth right to demene other people... You are the prime example of toxicity...
Just a a suggestion please consider summarizing your points more concisely to make the video length shorter and use more images and videos to keep the audience engaged. You are loosing the interest & attention of the viewers with such long videos wherein while you discuss the issue in detail its getting way too stretched.
To ensure that India obtains an undisturbed environment along our northern border to continue with our nation's strategic objective of unhindered economic development, India must learn how to wait for a more opportune moment to resolve any issue of her interest. Indian govt has done an excellent job of meeting this objective vis-a-vis the Chinese without compromising on the nation's honour and interests. All the clever talk by the commentariat is just that; empty talk and lot of politics. Indian establishment has outflanked and outsmarted both, the Chinese by playing the QUAD/US card and the intellectual mercenaries ubiquitous in our media by ignoring the clamor sustained by them since Galwan.
Shekhar ji and Sneheesh ji: can drones be used to effectively neutralize Chinese tank deployment advantage in Depsang plains? Or does high altitude poses some challenges?
Dumb Question: Before 1962, was the entire Aksai Chin mainland was an integral part of India? Did our loss in the war lead to permanently losing that piece on the East?
Short answer :yes Long answer: Entire ladakh claimed today by India was part of the territory historically inherited from british india. But since communist revolution and chinese capture of tibet china is trying to expand west to control rhe dominating heights by a technique called salami slicing Eg:If they want a point 5km inside,they will invade 10km inside and then after drama retreat to their originall desired 5km point and maintaining buffer in remaining 5km in name of disputed territory
SG not sure you read this right. Himalayan heights are not very conducive for Chinese soldiers. So having secured Bangla for radiating heat outwards and Pakistan already on board there is no need to keep sitting at the great heights.
When Henry kissinger made secret trip to China in 1971 to make groundwork for nixon-mao encounter, he found several slogans against amerika on road & also board in his room written in English " world should unite 2 throw American imperialism & their running dogs ". When it was reported to Mao, he dismissed them as empty words. Same way In 1954, Nehru was given huge applause to his hindi speech . All while PLA constructing roads into Indian territory. It took 8years for nehru 2 realise that Chinese grand welcome doesn't always mean friendship.Chinese say one thing, mean one thing & do all together another. Deception is natural 2 them
In wikimedia commons map of indo china border in 1963 post the sino pak border treaty, we can see that india claims the borders set by the same treaty except sakshgam valley unlike the west. Why so?
When China was developing infrastructure in their side for the last 6 decades India under the inefficient leadership did not develop border infrastructure. However, I see some people eager to blame the current government for the situation.
Exclusive content, privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
This is in response to US interference in Bangladesh. Seems Joe Biden has no clue what he is doing.
China foreign policy become fantastic 🤘 day by day truly they will rule the world n its happening, US era is over but hard to say that India become pawns in international geopolitics n it's fact.
@surendrabarsode8959 Modi only do scripted conversation. He has no ability to talk unscripted.
SG you got to have your graphics team highlight the points on the map with a flash or arrow when you mention the place, one is lost looking for the points on the map while trying to stay focused to what you conveying to us
Its not even that hard
Too bad maps. They need to political rather than geographic
@@Here4Now how tf will you explain terrain with a political map smooth brain
Hath hila hila ke matter solve nahi hote.
1.corona kal main hamla ker China ne socha Bharat response nahi dega,per dia.
2.chinies thinking ki long negotiation table per India tthak jayega.
3.Yeh ki shayad govt.India ki change ho jaye .
Bharat ab China ko ba khubi read ker Sakta hai.
(Bharat ab China Expert ban gaya hai)
Even ameture youtubers have better animated maps while explaining.
If losing access to some patrolling points by India is “something”, then China losing access to some patrolling points is ALSO something.
Please take an objective view. Please.
@@IndianArma I think my view is quite objective. By losing patrolling rights, both sides have lost as well as gained territory. And by restoration of patrolling rights, both sides have gone back to status quo.
@@IndianArma, u believe me, These bot bhakts have lost their minds long ago, take their 100₹, give them 50₹ back, They will celebrate that they recieved 50 back...
Bhakts are such optimistic, that their objective is to credit their lord, Even if he farts ...
@@fabulousindian6582OK we are bhakts... At least we are no boot lickinkg slaves/inbreds like you, who wear the farts of your Italian madam... Asshole😂😂
@@fabulousindian6582 lol , one which gifted 40,000 sq km aksai chin area to china in 1962 .
should not call other one bhakt 🤡🤡😂
My father was posted at Leh during the clashes, always good to hear news like this.
Liar please secure your IP address 😂
One thing which caught my attention was the mention that Indian infrastructure in that area has increased dramatically. But for Modi, it would have remained desolate and easy picking for the Chinese. Hope the Congress remembers this whenever they try to needle the Govt. about "huge losses" in those areas to Chinese forces.
OFCOURSE we Indians have LOST territory under Modi to Chinese despite his tall claims of 56 inch chest and "ghar mein ghuske marenge". There is no denying that India lost territory to China under coward Modi - Nehru 2.0.
Zorawar singh is the culrit. HE should have built roads
@@abba747 elaborate ..dont spit and run like prophet Muhammad
Any neutral source ? @@abba747
Thanks Modi, Thanks Jayshankar Ji, Big Thanks to the Beloved Indian Army.. Thanks to IAF for supply and patrol missions and everything. Thanks to Navy for providing P8i's for reconnaissance and surveillance and Mig 29K's for patrolling mission.. All elements came together and performed.. Bharat Mata ki jay.. Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj ki jay
Hold on to your horses - this announcement is from India's side only (according to Brahma Chellaney), not from the Chinese side. There is no reason to celebrate - at least not yet!
Do not ever believe China same Nehru believed them.
Do not be fooled by them.
@@abba747 Unlike India, china does not need to announce anything to its public as it is not democracy.
@@abba747 congress wastest idiotic party made mistakes by not developing infrastructure in parliament saying we are ostrich we don't need infrastructure in border but bjp is slow should immediately develop infrastructure or leave pmo bjp waste party then
It's a message to USA that disputes can be resolved if USA n Canada keeps pushing the wrong way.
S , may be. Ltets see, what will happen with fighter jet engine deal.
Middle finger to Anglosphere
They sold weapons so not our enemies as some think. We should never forget that our enemy is China
China wants entire arunchal pradesh just becuase you hate anglos will you give away arunachal? Plz dont support china if you are patriotic china is as much enemy as us
They are not the enemy
@@varoonnone7159 they are
@@oldngolddays6177
That's pure paranoia
You live in the 1850s, the West has moved on
Really love The Print for such detailed analysis. Both Shekhar Gupta and Snehesh Alex Phillips are doing a great service to India by not siding with any political narrative. Thankyou Team 'The Print'.
Never forget what Shekhar Gupta did with TSD and col hunny bakshi. (Research about it)
We need a lot of these kind of vids to unmalign his image .
Shekhar ji, This is a welcome sign. But we need to see that it is not in sync with the China policy of Gain 2 inch and then concede 1 inch as compromise gaining 1 inch in the process.
We must not concede the legitimate, legal and strategic position.
INDIA SHOULD NEVER LOWER ITS GUARD AS FOR NATIONAL SECURITY AND DEFENCE
Why not?
Wonderful declaration and what an instruction to the armed forces! Way to go. Keep it up.
@stevesteve4700 the level of wisdom and the intricate strategy hidden in that comment was eye opening. Our armed forces better be paying heed to this middle class indian sun tzu and chanakya put together and drawing inspiration from his experience of trawling through reams and reams of whatsapp forwards
I agree 100%! Keep your national security and defence tightly and stay away!
Do not bother us! Well, just bother Canada.
@@doncorleone3901You do not have Sun Tzu equivalent in India?
Excellent analysis Shekhar. I do have a question: why do we persist on using feet instead of meters? We have stopped using miles, so why use feet? Thanks.
From the episode I could understand the intelligence of Rahul and Congress leaders on their claim of land lost to China 😅😅
Waiting for this video.thanks having today's CTC on this topic
धन्यवाद शिखरजी for this level of detail!
Congress must be very unhappy with this development.
After long time something good from Mr Shekhar Gupta 😊
Thank you for another clear analysis and explanation.
Your content exchange and style, also knowledge is phenomenal. Take a bow, Shekhar Gupta. Stay like this and keep enriching the audience. Huge respect sir.
Great analysis
Excellent analysis and Snehesh’s expert comments
Thank you for watching and writing in, my friend. I'm glad you found the episode insightful...best wishes, Shekhar
@@ThePrintIndia
You're a gem for journalism
Incredible hand motions, head shaking is beautiful
Great reporting good work shekarji & Philip ji
Jai jawan
Bharat mata ki jai
I have been travelling to these areas of east Laddakh. Infrastructure development is awesome. Roads, airports, health services are of international standards. Army and air force deployment is massive. Many new roads are being built to improve connectivity. One su h is between Demchok to Manali which will pass through record altitude of over 18000ft.
Very nice presentation, thanks.
I watched this video 3 times, and I'm still scratching my head on what exactly has happened. There're so many points of disengagement, its hard to keep track what was discussed when. As much informative the digressions are, can that be skipped for such long-winded discussions?
Shekhar looking handsome, only Indian capable of speaking for a half hour and convey as little as possible
Do you get paid for uncalled meanness ?
@@varoonnone7159 Most of us do it for free. But if one's getting paid, I'd like to sign up.
Well said ... Singh ji
Indeed responsible journalism from Lahore Pakistan
Amazing thought presentation with statistics with imagination. The thing which lack is, shekar sir's thought presentation as projection directly connected to his brain....... ❤❤❤
Very interesting and informative.. JAI HO..
Sir.... ur views are valuable.. but pl make them brief...
Thanks!
Dear Arko, thank you for supporting our journalism.
Shekhar - You need to cover where this is coming for, the real reason for PRC pulling back, the larger geopolitical context to all this! And what will be next.
what about the real reason why India is making up with China? (Bangladesh color revolution against pro-india government by US, mass investment pull out and stock sells from Western nations, increasing scrutiny on India black ops in western nations, more western reports on India's domestic human rights violations as well as India's stance in Ukraine war)
India is now on western s*** list just like China is, except India is far rom ready to be independent from western nations, unlike China.
Hold on to your horses - this announcement is from India's side only (according to Brahma Chellaney), not from the Chinese side. There is no reason to celebrate - at least not yet!
@@abba747wow you are commenting the same comment on every comment.
Because he is a Chinese mole 😂@@jimmyrockford7814
@@abba747ahh, Chinese slave
Dear SG, One thing which can be corrected, Karakoram pass is very far away from Gilgit Xinjiang highway. There is no threat to that highway from the Indian side from Karakoram pass.
There was only one question on my mind when I started watching this episode ' have we returned to status quo ante 2019 ? ' ....that was answered at the end....thank you print team 👍
I regularly hear these episodes on podcasts. Enjoyed the unedited 39-minute-long episode. I request to share some unedited versions to let people know the efforts involved in correcting the facts and the human side of Shekhar Gupta Ji
Really does he have a human side 😂 I thought he was an animal thank you very much for this important information
They could replace the laptop with a banner now.
I have been to these areas around pangong tso in peak winters... Lake is frozen and winds are so strong you can't stay out in open...
Very well explained. Glad to see we had enough clout to hold our own.
Is timing is perfect for Taiwan adventure?
Yes, the timing is important. Also the Chinese have made no firm commitments. No reason to celebrate yet, as long as "ground realities" of Depsang and Demchok do not change!
Yes timing is good.
Due to negligence of the previous govts. The Chinese built up their advantage along the LAC.
Thank you 🙏🇨🇳🇨🇳
If it is not pre 2013 situation than Depsang & Demchok are still issue. so called "legacy issues" are not resolved.
Thank you for the information. Good this occurred.
Good stuff Thanks
Dear Prithwis,
Thank you for watching and writing in.
Very difficult to understand without good maps and graphics
Sir someone has uploaded un-edited version on Spotify.
It was an error and has been fixed and re-uploaded. Thank you for pointing this out, Chetan...Shekhar
India continues to make his army and economy stronger and stronger with make in India and also keep dialogue and diplomacy keep going with china.This is only way of peace in both LoC and LaC.
China’s spending is equivalent to $711 billion, nearly approaching the US levels of military expenditure at $875 billion this year.
India can try to keep up but avoid draining resources that like lead up to collapse of the soviet.. This also a risk to china, but much more riskier to a poorer nation. In fact , for years, china kept its arm spending low not only because it is is a waste of money, but to keep a low profile to avoid the attention of USA.. Maybe , it is karma that india got to spend big on military
@@mg.f.9023 Military spending will increase with economic growth and India economy is growing and India also working on creating defence ecosystems within india.
USA military bases all over the world and this need huge military spending to maintain this military bases also USA economy is 25 trillion dollar and same with china.
@@biggpicture2930 only want to say that peace come with cost of strong military and economy. India don’t want to involve in any war for next 30-40 year and focus on economic growth.
USA and China not involve in any war and not fight any war within inside their country and also use other countries ground to challenge each other.
@@mg.f.9023 so what?
27:55 Two corrections:-
1) Demchok is not where COK is at its narrowest
2) Aksai Chin is a Chinese name. Kindly refer to it as Chinese Occupied Kashmir
Before the Tsunami unleashes ,it appears rescinding retreating.
Loved the explanation, but needed to improve on the animation for better understanding.
SG Sir . Would be good have CTC about latest constitutional changes in Pakistan
why are explanations being given after resolution?
Chinese Agent explaining Indian position.
U mean american puppet
@ARX689 Yeah, I mean American puppet ..😆
It needs to be verified in the field Mr. Gupta.
..........Why Nehru expanded Northern Borders with China during 1947-1962???
These are main reasons...
1) Britain left India hurriedly so Nehru annexed/ merged Hyderabad, Manipur and Kashmir etc small nations or Princely States in 1948..
2) Nehru invaded Goa twice and merged with India in 1961...
3) After annexation of Goa in 1961, Nehru and Indian Army morale increased strongly so Nehru tried to merge " Aksai Chin" from 1950 to 1962 so India- China War happened ( Aksai Chin was a vast barren lands so British- India government never showed it in any Indian maps). Aksai Chin was always under Tibetans control and Aksai Chin belongs to Tibet forever....
4) Indira Gandhi annexed Sikkim in 1975 by using Indian Military forces. India tried to annex Nepal and Bhutan failed because America, UN and China protected Nepal and Bhutan from Indian expansionism during 1950-1975...........
So, there is no permanent solution.keep going in circles.
SG, you missed 3 imp reasons: A. Massive infra, tech & equip upgrade by india in last 5yrs. B.Moving tanks 'first' on tops overlooking the chinese side. C.Modi elected as Pm 3rd term so no chance to deal with congress or weak opposition.
What impact is this going to have on west which was using Khalistanis on their soil to poke India relentlessly?
Is this one of those movements where India is stating into the eyes of west while looking towards east?
Not the West, just Canada
Khalistan gonna f uck ur Bharat mata 🇵🇰🇵🇰🤣🤣🤣🤣
Nice episode. Even though disputed, the fact that India & China haven't exchanged LAC maps unlike LoC (with Pakistan), patrolling becomes much more important than permanent deployment on LAC vice versa in case of LoC
Dear SG
Times have changed. A monologue that's hastily prepared isn't cutting it anymore. Good graphics and crisp voice over would be best but anything closer to good graphics is basic.
Modi hai tho mumkin hai ....
Its an open question whether India has established the double détente with both America and China.
You should never end this conflict.
Says not face to face then goes on to say literally face to face 😂😅
Thanks Shekar Ji. Does this disengagement pave way for Chaina to reaume issuance of VISA for Kailash Maansarovar parikrama yatra.
Too much fluff, can you come to the point faster!
In a major breakthrough related to the four-and-a-half-years of military standoff along the LAC, after the Chinese incursions in eastern Ladakh, India and China have agreed to restore patrolling rights in the Depsang Plains in the north and Demchok in the south of Ladakh. This agreement comes after several meetings (31 so far) were held by the WMCC (Working Mechanism for Consultation and Coordination on India-China Border Affairs), 21 rounds of India-China Corps Commander Level Meetings, as well as multiple meetings between the two Foreign Ministers in order to ease tensions, narrow down the differences and find early resolution of the outstanding issues.
It is noteworthy, since May 2020, Indian and Chinese troops have had multiple confrontations in the seven friction points in the eastern Ladakh - Galwan Valley (PP 14), Hot Springs (PP 15), Gogra (PP 17A), North and South banks of Pangong Tso, Depsang Plains and Charding Nullah in Demchok region. According to both EAM and Foreign Secretary, disengagement has happened at all the friction points, leading to pre-2020 status quo in the region. As per reports, overall deployment of troops along the LAC will be ‘thinned down’ in due course.
The arrangement assumes greater significance since it comes just ahead of the 16th BRICS Summit, scheduled to be held in Kazan, Russia, on October 22-23, where Indian PM Narendra Modi and Chinese President Xi Jinping are expected to hold bilateral talks on the sidelines of the two-day summit.
Calling the development a ‘positive and good’ one, EAM S. Jaishankar emphasized the outcome as a product of “very patient and persevering diplomacy”. After all, only peace and stability along the border will lead to growth and prosperity in the two countries.
Chinese came to help Pakistan. India was keeping LOC hot. Chinese at LAC,India was forced to make LOC silent. They have achieved their goal. If India again pursue LOC, then Chinese are sitting up North. Two front war.
Some one remembers
LoC was already silent after 2019 August...so yeah, whatever
India opening up to Taiwan ?
What about Finger areas?
“Know thy self, know thy enemy. A thousand battles, a thousand victories.”
- Sun Tzu
महाराष्ट्र के चुनाव ( नोव्हेंबर २०२४ ) के पेहेले चीन ने अपनी सेना वापस बुलायी और यह एक भारत कि बहुत बडी जीत है ऐसा चीन पेहेले कभी नही करता था उलटा चुनाव को प्रभावित करणे के लिये बहुत हि घतीया चाले चलता था और आगर उसकी हार होनी है तो चुनाव के बाद हि ऐसे स्टेप लेता था
Today shekar Gupta is very sad he will fast for health
This episode really cuts-the-clutter of this major issue.
Guptaji, it's 'Patrol' , not "Petrol" (which is put in cars😅)
SG is the first Geopolitical expert in India 🇮🇳
Yes, Age wise he probably is...
The problem here is that India is the ones to announce it and China didn’t say anything about it. That shows who is more desperate, and this is a big revelation and a wrong posture. Media should refrain from this “feel good” announcement, which adds to the impression that India is more desperate.
I am waiting for a day where India remains silent and the other side announces a truce.
Why would China say, anything, about it? As if it is a big thing in China like it is in India. Being such a sophisticated country, China has a lot of matter to attend. India stop harassing Chinese companies would be more significant to address than a pesky neighbor stop making problems. Resolving the border problems or not doesn't do anything much. It's in the mountain, not in their doorstep!
@@bibekjmWho is the one in need here?
In the past such developments surfaced either in south china morning post or global times. In this, it is brought up by India's media.
China top leadership has democratic pressures to make such announcements? So why are you even expecting such behavior from China? Our rules don't apply to China's political leadership. Unless you have a high opinion about the "virtues of Chinese dictatorship".
Shekhar should take a class of Mr Rahul Gandhi to make him understand little bit of indo china border issue
It is in our intrest to keep China Stretched as well... Indians are already feeling the heat of inflation due to two global wars... Another war by China on Taiwanin will have huge socio- economic impications in the region... Let the descalation be delayed till the other two wars settle
But india is bursting with unemployment issues, regional tensions that could tear india apart very soon, amidst the fallout with USA and canada over panun and nijar
In fact, I see it the other way around, India is kept stretched . Resources are diverted away to military from growing its economy and improving brain .
you need better school.. maybe cleaner water and non toxic food that makes indians more rational.
@@biggpicture2930 you did not need to get personal here... Please enlighten us what is Toxic food and all..??? Frustrated hai kya..?? teen teen comments... India has been always streched so I don't think it should be a new thing... The economic growth every country is registering now is due to the base effect... I am sure about which you know nothing... And I am sure you want another war... Mr self Proclaimed intellect who thinks it is his birth right to demene other people you are the toxic Indian that people should stay away from
@@biggpicture2930 you did not need to get personal here... Please enlighten us what is Toxic food and all..??? Frustrated hai kya..?? teen teen comments... India has been always streched so I don't think it should be a new thing... The economic growth every country is registering now is due to the base effect... I am sure about which you know nothing... And I am sure you want another war... MrSelfProclaimed Intellect who thinks it is his birth right to demene other people... You are the prime example of toxicity...
Sab Changa si....
Just a a suggestion please consider summarizing your points more concisely to make the video length shorter and use more images and videos to keep the audience engaged. You are loosing the interest & attention of the viewers with such long videos wherein while you discuss the issue in detail its getting way too stretched.
Bharat future is economically Militirally strong and all will fallin line. For that most important thing इस for people like U to LUV BHARAT
But why their is no news about this development in Chinese media
因为共产党控制中国的一切媒体，它们控制人民的思想，它们送国土给你们印度，它们不会让人民知道的，所以中国媒体上不会详细报道和你们达成协议的内容！1962年，中国大胜印度，却把拿回的土地送给了你们，中国军人白白牺牲了，这就是中共的奇葩和不可思议的地方
Good news, but in this 4 years what we learn is china dictates whether LAC would be peaceful or not.
Please explain why native Leh tour guides cried to me they lost their homes with Galwan standoff? Are they chinese agents?
Ya but they still haven't returned the 4000 sq km they grabbed in laddakh, not to mention the 50 000 sq km in arunanchal. .
Use a better mic. Its very hard to hear complete sentence if there’s any disturbance
To ensure that India obtains an undisturbed environment along our northern border to continue with our nation's strategic objective of unhindered economic development, India must learn how to wait for a more opportune moment to resolve any issue of her interest. Indian govt has done an excellent job of meeting this objective vis-a-vis the Chinese without compromising on the nation's honour and interests. All the clever talk by the commentariat is just that; empty talk and lot of politics. Indian establishment has outflanked and outsmarted both, the Chinese by playing the QUAD/US card and the intellectual mercenaries ubiquitous in our media by ignoring the clamor sustained by them since Galwan.
Shekhar ji and Sneheesh ji: can drones be used to effectively neutralize Chinese tank deployment advantage in Depsang plains? Or does high altitude poses some challenges?
Dumb Question: Before 1962, was the entire Aksai Chin mainland was an integral part of India? Did our loss in the war lead to permanently losing that piece on the East?
Short answer is yes. We lost Aksi Chin, and Pakistan ceded a lot of land to the Chinks
Short answer :yes
Long answer: Entire ladakh claimed today by India was part of the territory historically inherited from british india.
But since communist revolution and chinese capture of tibet china is trying to expand west to control rhe dominating heights by a technique called salami slicing
Eg:If they want a point 5km inside,they will invade 10km inside and then after drama retreat to their originall desired 5km point and maintaining buffer in remaining 5km in name of disputed territory
SG not sure you read this right. Himalayan heights are not very conducive for Chinese soldiers. So having secured Bangla for radiating heat outwards and Pakistan already on board there is no need to keep sitting at the great heights.
When Henry kissinger made secret trip to China in 1971 to make groundwork for nixon-mao encounter, he found several slogans against amerika on road & also board in his room written in English " world should unite 2 throw American imperialism & their running dogs ". When it was reported to Mao, he dismissed them as empty words. Same way In 1954, Nehru was given huge applause to his hindi speech . All while PLA constructing roads into Indian territory. It took 8years for nehru 2 realise that Chinese grand welcome doesn't always mean friendship.Chinese say one thing, mean one thing & do all together another. Deception is natural 2 them
In wikimedia commons map of indo china border in 1963 post the sino pak border treaty, we can see that india claims the borders set by the same treaty except sakshgam valley unlike the west. Why so?
Can now indian army able to patrol galwan valley???? If not what is the changes??????? 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
India and China are competing powers so some distrust will always but if we can keep the border quiet it will be a step forward
Half information is always harmful 😂 uncle please review the new news headlines
If this is a success only for india, why isn't the govt doing the usual chest thumping
Because in geopolitics sometimes you should not do that. This government knows that well
Atleast Nehru lost land after fighting in war…
When China was developing infrastructure in their side for the last 6 decades India under the inefficient leadership did not develop border infrastructure.
However, I see some people eager to blame the current government for the situation.