I find it very interesting to see how the different shows put the teams in different perspective. If this were Med, you would automatically be on Dr. Charles' side. She is his patient, the police are interfering in his treatment of her. But because this is P.D. - you're actively following the investigation. You want it to be resolved and don't immediately think about treatment. Thus his interference puts him in a bad light. The framing of the different viewpoints is done brilliantly - even though neither party is in the wrong here.
Yeah I mean like the only thing I would or could do if that happens was crying crying until I don’t have tears left and then continue crying and then there would be a random lady ask me questions which answers I don’t have that’s abojt the last thing I would want
Most of these child actors are put through Monarch Mind Control from around three years old. Most are sexually abused by the studios. That is trauma she can draw from.
@@h.z.takavdinov2167 I’m completely chilled. I think it’s you that sounds angry. What’s up? You don’t like truth? Does it make you rethink your idols in media? You angry at me instead of these so-called stars? 😂
@@Irunwithscissors63 im not angry, im simply baffled. I was in your place when i was around 14 years of age, all invested in these conspiracy theories and whatnot, but you'll grow up and realize you sound like a lunatic (no offense). I'm a screenwriter and have been in the film industry for quite some time now, and what you're saying made my crew have a good laugh too. Anyway, cheers 🥂
as the oldest of my siblings & weak to any protective older sisters in media, the "crawled out from under her older sister" really got me; to protect a sibling like that...i'd do the same thing and it scares me
I’m the youngest in my family, and I know for a fact that my older siblings would do whatever it took to take care of me. I can only imagine how terrifying it must’ve been for the little girl, huddled under her sister. I’d hold on to my brothers and sister so tight, I’d probably end up hurting them. Sibling bonds are incredible.
I'm the oldest of three siblings. I'm not even in a dangerous country but I'm scared if something happens because my little bros are twins and I'm only one person. I would do anything to protect them, but I know in a situation like this I would not be able to protect both of them by myself.
As the oldest with distant Asian parents, I have nightmares about these situations. And the thing I'm most worried about is that my body isn't thick enough to block the bullets.
To be fair, not only was Dr Charles completely in the right, not only avoiding any lawsuits by going through the proper procedure, but he's also the psychiatrist meaning he has a better understanding of when she is ready to talk than any cop could have. She was close to unresponsive and then went crazy and attacked a staff member once already, how do you know she isn't going to snap again and snatch the gun from the holster instead of a knife? Sure, the staff were a little aggressive in rushing her, but he does not deserve any hate for following procedure and doing what keeps the most people safe at the given time.
That's exactly what I came down here to say, she absolutely was not ready to talk and honestly he did everything exactly right, the only thing that med did 'wrong' if you can even call it that was that they might've spooked her again by running in like that, and there's no guarantee that going slow would've helped either given that she was still within reach of a weapon and still visibly not okay!
As a med professional- Dr Charles is 100% in the right. Such patients well being is doctors first priority - everything else doesn’t matter. Even if the roles were reversed, say PD wanted to talk to a suspect in such state, the doctors and nurses would still never allow it.
Ya honestly this is why I think all cop duos should be accompanied by a healthcare/psych professional. To help de-escalate, especially on wellness checks
The problem is she was coherent she wasn't crazy any other time I would be all right with Dr Charles treatment but this time he was in the wrong she knew she was at the hospital but she didn't know why the police officer got her to put down the weapon and was able to talk to her yeah she was talking about her family like she wanted to help them and of course people would think that she's insane because she should know that they're dead but the problem is her brain doesn't remember that her brain is all scrambled don't understand what is going on that's what she needed and also she could still help her family by telling the police officers what she remembers but putting her out and rushing her like that she's never going to trust anyone again in sedating a patient I don't know what the exact effects of that does to your memory but I will say that she was scared she didn't know why she was there maybe her brain was also making her think that she was still at her home and was going to be attacked who knows what that nurse even said or did to her to make her react like that
@@gamingprism7554 which is why I never said he said it but instead it’s what he meant. Lindsey tried to strong arm him into doing what she said because she’s the police & his line about cops thinking their cops everywhere was meant as a - I’m the head of psychiatry so in this setting I’m in charge. I will determine when she is ready to speak, not you!
And she will never be ready but I'm pretty sure in this show she does become ready and they do hopefully catch the guy but in real life they would never trust that person again and what she needed was the truth and to be told what was going on you don't know if maybe that nurse that got stabbed did something that brought her back to that situation at her house or said something that brought on that situation at the house you don't know nothing when you have PTSD you don't need to be sedated you need to be told what is going on and what time it is and where you are and what's going on which she was able to tell them where she was and instead of giving her any answers to see how she responds they just stabbed her with a needle and sedate her and say she's psychologically not prepared he was treating her like she was crazy and she's not crazy literally what she was going through was PTSD and I should know because I have PTSD I know what it's like to hear somebody say certain words to smell something that brings me back sometimes a certain touch will mess with my mind yeah I may not do what she did but that does it mean that everybody's PTSD is the same
This actually happened. Cassidy Stay was the only one to survive in her family by playing dead when her uncle opened fire to her family. RIP her family. :( and her uncle pleaded not guilty like wtf
Apparently a lot of the cases in Chicago Med and PD are based on real life cases so there’s a chance that this could’ve been based off of Cassidy’s story
And Ronald Lee Haskell was ultimately found guilty on all 6 counts of Capital murder (one for each of the lives he took, Cassidy’s 4 siblings plus her parents) and sentenced to death. And rightfully so! He’s currently on death row at Allan B. Polunsky Unit in Texas awaiting his deserved demise!
I see a lot of comments bashing Dr Charles here. And while I agree that the two nurses definitely went in way too hot to sedate the girl, I think Dr. Charles was right in that it wasn't the right time to interview her yet. Eye witness accounts are notoriously unreliable, and then you add in the fact that she's a young girl who has just been through such a dramatic event... there is a big risk that her testimony could point the cops in the complete wrong direction.
@@jameliakingstom1190 he was right in it being to soon to talk to her, for al the rest, he was wrong and the police lady handled it better. This poor girl will never trust that staff again. Speeking from experience.
@@SL-gz3dy she won't trust them but she might trust him/ Doctors tend not to get involved with the restraint side of thing so that they're a friendly face to talk to.
Dr Charles was right, the girl was not in a right state of mind, she was suffering from recent trauma and a danger to those around her as well. Questioning her right away would not lead to anything. The police would have to wait until the medical staff took care of her and she has regained some sort of consciousness about what she experienced.
Charles was right but the nurses where in the wrong, the girl was just getting talked down and then they run in just like that instead of trying to approach her
Sorry Erin, I'm with Dr. Charles. Trying to question her like this probably would've triggered something and Erin would've been the first line to face the girl's next rampage. And it could've been worse than the previous attack. The girl needs time to breathe and realize the danger is over.
@@sebby324 Can bet theres hundreds if not thousands of cases that happened exactly like that though that are real-most storylines in shows like this are
@@zoeknap9777 maybe but that doesn't change the fact that it's a fictional drama series. What law enforcement television series isn't inspired by certain real life events?
After seeing how caring Erin is with Polly as well as caring and great with all kids through cases I'm quite sorry we never got a chance to perhaps see Linstead become serious couple with a kid maybe. I feel sorry for the poor girl for losing her family and moving to completely new, unknown city
it was a rough way to sedate her. could've handled in a calm way if possible. Dr. Charles' intention was right. the police might also not be able to gather information from the kid bcs she's still too traumatized from what happened so it's really better to just let her rest.
The little girl just stabbed a nurse, they have to act fast because there is a chance she could do it again. She may be just a kid but she is clearly a threat to the safety of the staff so they have to treat her as one. Medical staff have a right to safety too.
welcome to the psych ward. at one of my stays, something happened where one patient was hauled off, sedated and restrained. a day later said patent was much calmer and was more open to conversation, and even apologized for their actions. its hard to understand but when you are hospitalized, your safetly is the staff's number one concern. by restraining her, they can focus on the work they need to do so that she can be in the best mental state she can be in to help the police. a dissociated, traumatized girl would more likely to give unclear answers and trigger another mental break in which she could harm herself or others.
exactly! she was cooperating already the least they could have done was be gentle not attack her like that, i hope the girl got a physical i wouldnt be surprised if she got bruised from their grip, im surprised we didnt hear a crack from the way they pushed her arms aroudn liek that
@@targaryenbatman5728 if she made a statement or eye witness or confessed to anything it wouldn't be usable because the state she's in. He did right by shutting her up Infront of a police officer/detective
@@AlwaysGoLeft yeah sure, i wasn’t advocating for the investigation just that the kid is never going to trust the people who are supposed to help her, erin took her time no rush building trust instead of destroying it
It was probably more of a subconscious reflex action than an actual planed strategy. When attacked people do one of two things - Flight or Fright. They run like Hell to get away from the danger. Or freeze up & play dead to make the person/thing threatening them think they're no longer alive. Her brain decided on Fright - aka playing dead in order to survive. She more than likely would have fainted. & her sister would have fallen on her as she was shot further protecting her. Young children (& animals) will often opt for the Fright/Freeze option when confronted with danger. Because they are aware they cannot out run an attack. & for those who like to rip apart & bash discussions like this. Saying "Oh but it's just a TV show. You *KNOW* it's all fake." The story on the show may be fictional. *BUT* it's was written using multiple real world examples of similar situation. & psychological accounts of what people actually will do when faced with situations like this.
*Sees a kid climb out from under a pile of bodies from a shooting, who looks no older than maybe 7* ''I kNoW wHaT tO dO lEt'S aSk A mIlLiOn QuEsTiOnS!''
@@Sarawarawara- Now I read your comment, that makes more sense. If you’re reading this and took offence to my previous comment Leah, or anyone else for that matter, I owe you an apology for jumping to conclusions.
Dr. Charles was totally right. The authority of a medical specialist should supersede any sort of authority the police think they have. I mean, the kid’s recovering from the most traumatic experience she’ll ever go through. Even if she could interview her, how could she be certain anything she says would be admissible as evidence in her current state? Right now, she’s a danger to herself and everyone around her, which makes more of a liability than anything else. All that should matter is her own mental well-being so that she’s actually in a state where she would be of any use to the police The reason I know this is because in Transformers Prime, Optimus once personally stated that Ratchet’s expertise as the team’s medic supersedes his own authority as the team leader. After all, if you don’t take care of yourself, you can’t take care of anyone else
during the inspection did anyone else notice the supposedly dead girl in the blue shirt breath? it was at 1:50 watch a bit before and watch carefully, like i know its all acting and stuff but the breath was so obvious
Dr charles was so right tho. the girl was obviously traumatized and in shock, she lost her whole family right in front of her, and shes slightly injured, she was obviously not in the right state of mind to talk about the incident and who killed her family.
🇿🇦🇿🇦 this my favorite drama all the time I watched full episodes the whole day keep on doinge this guys you make my day feel easier 💐🙏🙏🤩💗👍👍💯💯💯🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦 qhubekani ukusijabulisa ngiyabonga niyangiqhaza kakhehle nginithanda nonke ama actors ngisho no procedures thank you 💕 umuhle umsebenzi wenu 💖💝🌼💖 🇿🇦🇿🇦💯💯💯 ngiyabonga iNkosi I've nani ngegama le Nkosi u Jesu Christu 🙏🥳 the 🙏🙏🙏👍👍👍👍✨💐
Hey that's the little girl from Miracles from Heaven!! Also, the poor girl (polly) must've been terrified... hearing all the shots, her big sister dead in top of her, thinking she was finally safe when she was talking to Erin and the the nurses scaring her like that...
Idk what how or out of what perpective.. but im sure that the child was okay when she laid the knife down so i think de charles was the one wrong.. of course she is in a bad state but she did put the knife down
I'm with Erin on this one, I understand where Dr. Charles is coming from, but Erin was able to get through to Polly when she was in an agitated and unstable state. I think they should have given her some time to help Polly calm down and talk about what happened.
Though Erin's actions comes from a good place Dr. Charles is right, he's the right person to determine when the poor child is ready to talk to the police. Forcing her to do so before she's ready could potentially do far more harm then good.
Ok ok ok but where did she even get the scalpel? I work with teens where there's concern with suicidal ideation and self harm, all sharp things are locked up. Of course nothing is fool proof but how did she just go from catatonic to finding a scalpel???????
The girl just lost her entire family. She is in a psyche ward. She attacked the medical staff there. Tell me, is there any indication that she is capable of helping Erin out, even if she said she wanted to? The problem with the girl now is, not only is she traumatized, she is not rational. She is a danger to herself even. Really, Erin... what were you thinking? You think that interviewing her can solve your case any faster, when she can't even think straight?? She is in the psyche ward for a reason!
From an "inside" viewpoint of dissociative episodes; the young girl most likely doesn't remember anything as soon as the dissociation set in. Have personally "woke up" in an emergency room before after a dissociative episode and do not remember anything between the triggered event and the world becoming solid and real again. Ambulance ride, assessments, blood work..... none of that is remembered. (Diagnosed with a dissociative condition August 2022) The sedation part seems a little unreal from experiences in behavioral hospitals, but it is just a show. She was most likely in some sort of PTSD like flashback and scared and freaked out. A quiet room with minimal sensory input could have helped without being sedated. At least from personal experience of being in dissociative episodes.
she’s traumatised that’s why she’s not speaking when the police arrived i mean i wouldn’t blame her i would be traumatised too and i wouldn’t talk after that would happen
I find it very interesting to see how the different shows put the teams in different perspective. If this were Med, you would automatically be on Dr. Charles' side. She is his patient, the police are interfering in his treatment of her. But because this is P.D. - you're actively following the investigation. You want it to be resolved and don't immediately think about treatment. Thus his interference puts him in a bad light. The framing of the different viewpoints is done brilliantly - even though neither party is in the wrong here.
And if you were in fire you’d be like wtf am I doing here 😂
Very well put! And so true, love Med and PD. Still holding out on Fire for some reason
@@trevorc7621 I was like that too at first, but once you get into it, it’s actually so good!
Whoa hold it. There is obvoiusly only one peron right here, and that is not the police.
Like whether you’re cheering for the lion or the gazelle
Man, imagine being the only one to survive something like that. You’d feel so alone, lost, and helpless.
this actually happened, you can search it in youtube! I felt so bad for her
@@harvirg883 jepp ineed! Hope she is doing okey now
Everyone is helpless in situations like this poor girl:(
It actually happened to me I survived an active shooter and everyone in the house with me didn't make it
Yeah I mean like the only thing I would or could do if that happens was crying crying until I don’t have tears left and then continue crying and then there would be a random lady ask me questions which answers I don’t have that’s abojt the last thing I would want
The child actress was amazing. Must be so hard to act something like that. I wonder how hard it was for the actress to get into that mindset to act.
She was the main character in miracles from heaven, she’s amazing
Most of these child actors are put through Monarch Mind Control from around three years old. Most are sexually abused by the studios.
That is trauma she can draw from.
@@Irunwithscissors63 chill the hell out
@@h.z.takavdinov2167 I’m completely chilled. I think it’s you that sounds angry. What’s up? You don’t like truth? Does it make you rethink your idols in media? You angry at me instead of these so-called stars? 😂
@@Irunwithscissors63 im not angry, im simply baffled. I was in your place when i was around 14 years of age, all invested in these conspiracy theories and whatnot, but you'll grow up and realize you sound like a lunatic (no offense). I'm a screenwriter and have been in the film industry for quite some time now, and what you're saying made my crew have a good laugh too. Anyway, cheers 🥂
2:40
My god. He went through and beat leukemia, only to be shot down with his family at the age of 10.
Seriously tragic...
Life's not fair and death does not wait for you to be ready nor is it considerate.
I nkow but at the end It's Chicago pd it's what it do
@@bursegsardaukar more like other humans idk what wrong with people
as the oldest of my siblings & weak to any protective older sisters in media, the "crawled out from under her older sister" really got me; to protect a sibling like that...i'd do the same thing and it scares me
Yeah, being the older sibling I'd definitely do whatever it takes to protect my younger sister, so I sure hope nothing ever happens.
Me too and technically speaking, I'm not even the oldest.
I’m the youngest in my family, and I know for a fact that my older siblings would do whatever it took to take care of me. I can only imagine how terrifying it must’ve been for the little girl, huddled under her sister. I’d hold on to my brothers and sister so tight, I’d probably end up hurting them. Sibling bonds are incredible.
I'm the oldest of three siblings. I'm not even in a dangerous country but I'm scared if something happens because my little bros are twins and I'm only one person. I would do anything to protect them, but I know in a situation like this I would not be able to protect both of them by myself.
As the oldest with distant Asian parents, I have nightmares about these situations. And the thing I'm most worried about is that my body isn't thick enough to block the bullets.
To be fair, not only was Dr Charles completely in the right, not only avoiding any lawsuits by going through the proper procedure, but he's also the psychiatrist meaning he has a better understanding of when she is ready to talk than any cop could have. She was close to unresponsive and then went crazy and attacked a staff member once already, how do you know she isn't going to snap again and snatch the gun from the holster instead of a knife? Sure, the staff were a little aggressive in rushing her, but he does not deserve any hate for following procedure and doing what keeps the most people safe at the given time.
to be fair it's just a TV show
Uh no I’ve ce but you do kno that she Saul she wanted to talk right!?
@@matthewforsyth284 Did you just have a stroke?
That's exactly what I came down here to say, she absolutely was not ready to talk and honestly he did everything exactly right, the only thing that med did 'wrong' if you can even call it that was that they might've spooked her again by running in like that, and there's no guarantee that going slow would've helped either given that she was still within reach of a weapon and still visibly not okay!
@@climatixseuche only difference would have been security rushing in instead of nurses and immediately restraining her in hard restraints
As a med professional- Dr Charles is 100% in the right. Such patients well being is doctors first priority - everything else doesn’t matter. Even if the roles were reversed, say PD wanted to talk to a suspect in such state, the doctors and nurses would still never allow it.
Ya honestly this is why I think all cop duos should be accompanied by a healthcare/psych professional. To help de-escalate, especially on wellness checks
The problem is she was coherent she wasn't crazy any other time I would be all right with Dr Charles treatment but this time he was in the wrong she knew she was at the hospital but she didn't know why the police officer got her to put down the weapon and was able to talk to her yeah she was talking about her family like she wanted to help them and of course people would think that she's insane because she should know that they're dead but the problem is her brain doesn't remember that her brain is all scrambled don't understand what is going on that's what she needed and also she could still help her family by telling the police officers what she remembers but putting her out and rushing her like that she's never going to trust anyone again in sedating a patient I don't know what the exact effects of that does to your memory but I will say that she was scared she didn't know why she was there maybe her brain was also making her think that she was still at her home and was going to be attacked who knows what that nurse even said or did to her to make her react like that
Man I love Dr Charles & his line at 6:46 is brilliant. Basically saying I don’t care if you are a cop, in this setting I am in charge so back down!
That’s not what he said
@@gamingprism7554 they are saying this is what he was meaning, they never said he said that.
@@gamingprism7554 which is why I never said he said it but instead it’s what he meant. Lindsey tried to strong arm him into doing what she said because she’s the police & his line about cops thinking their cops everywhere was meant as a - I’m the head of psychiatry so in this setting I’m in charge. I will determine when she is ready to speak, not you!
When I saw that injured nurse and blood on the wall, I thought it was the killer going after the kid to finish the job.
And she will never be ready but I'm pretty sure in this show she does become ready and they do hopefully catch the guy but in real life they would never trust that person again and what she needed was the truth and to be told what was going on you don't know if maybe that nurse that got stabbed did something that brought her back to that situation at her house or said something that brought on that situation at the house you don't know nothing when you have PTSD you don't need to be sedated you need to be told what is going on and what time it is and where you are and what's going on which she was able to tell them where she was and instead of giving her any answers to see how she responds they just stabbed her with a needle and sedate her and say she's psychologically not prepared he was treating her like she was crazy and she's not crazy literally what she was going through was PTSD and I should know because I have PTSD I know what it's like to hear somebody say certain words to smell something that brings me back sometimes a certain touch will mess with my mind yeah I may not do what she did but that does it mean that everybody's PTSD is the same
This actually happened. Cassidy Stay was the only one to survive in her family by playing dead when her uncle opened fire to her family. RIP her family. :( and her uncle pleaded not guilty like wtf
Apparently a lot of the cases in Chicago Med and PD are based on real life cases so there’s a chance that this could’ve been based off of Cassidy’s story
Justice systems are always f*cked up
And Ronald Lee Haskell was ultimately found guilty on all 6 counts of Capital murder (one for each of the lives he took, Cassidy’s 4 siblings plus her parents) and sentenced to death. And rightfully so!
He’s currently on death row at Allan B. Polunsky Unit in Texas awaiting his deserved demise!
I see a lot of comments bashing Dr Charles here. And while I agree that the two nurses definitely went in way too hot to sedate the girl, I think Dr. Charles was right in that it wasn't the right time to interview her yet. Eye witness accounts are notoriously unreliable, and then you add in the fact that she's a young girl who has just been through such a dramatic event... there is a big risk that her testimony could point the cops in the complete wrong direction.
i love dr charles
He was wrong
@@jameliakingstom1190 Why do you think that? I'm interested to hear the reasons.
@@jameliakingstom1190 he was right in it being to soon to talk to her, for al the rest, he was wrong and the police lady handled it better. This poor girl will never trust that staff again. Speeking from experience.
@@SL-gz3dy she won't trust them but she might trust him/ Doctors tend not to get involved with the restraint side of thing so that they're a friendly face to talk to.
Their Faces when she got up was so amazing and pure, I wish these guys were actual cops
I feel really bad for the little girl 😥
She stabbed a nurse.
@@lukes7479 ella no quería hacerlo
@@joaquinchoque2254 No hablo espanol sorry.
@@lukes7479 no me disculpa yo también
@@lukes7479 her family was murdered
Olinsky: _"Polly! Twelve years old's got nobody in this city."_
Hank: _"She's got us!"_
Powerful mate 👍
She’s traumatized. That doctor is so in the right. Quit questioning the expert ffs.
Dr Charles was right, the girl was not in a right state of mind, she was suffering from recent trauma and a danger to those around her as well. Questioning her right away would not lead to anything. The police would have to wait until the medical staff took care of her and she has regained some sort of consciousness about what she experienced.
Charles was right but the nurses where in the wrong, the girl was just getting talked down and then they run in just like that instead of trying to approach her
Watching Chicago med teaches me one thing, do not argue with Dr.Charles. You'll never win.
The fact this was based on something that actually happened is just…
The entire chicago series is 10/10 🤌
Sorry Erin, I'm with Dr. Charles. Trying to question her like this probably would've triggered something and Erin would've been the first line to face the girl's next rampage. And it could've been worse than the previous attack. The girl needs time to breathe and realize the danger is over.
Three children died in that house... She watched her baby brother die after beating cancer...god
It’s not real lol
@@sebby324 Can bet theres hundreds if not thousands of cases that happened exactly like that though that are real-most storylines in shows like this are
@@zoeknap9777 maybe but that doesn't change the fact that it's a fictional drama series.
What law enforcement television series isn't inspired by certain real life events?
@@sebby324 its based on the cassidy stay, there are many cases like this.
The last Dr. Charles line is so true and powerful
The actor who play the Young girl also plays a character called Annabelle in Miracles from heaven. She is a very good actor.
actress, no?
I remember that movie 😂
"The problem with police is that wherever they go, they think they're police" -- Dr Charles' Sage Word of the Day
After seeing how caring Erin is with Polly as well as caring and great with all kids through cases I'm quite sorry we never got a chance to perhaps see Linstead become serious couple with a kid maybe. I feel sorry for the poor girl for losing her family and moving to completely new, unknown city
Polly Is such a good kid actress 🥰 She also acted Miracles from Heaven
it was a rough way to sedate her. could've handled in a calm way if possible. Dr. Charles' intention was right. the police might also not be able to gather information from the kid bcs she's still too traumatized from what happened so it's really better to just let her rest.
The little girl just stabbed a nurse, they have to act fast because there is a chance she could do it again. She may be just a kid but she is clearly a threat to the safety of the staff so they have to treat her as one. Medical staff have a right to safety too.
welcome to the psych ward. at one of my stays, something happened where one patient was hauled off, sedated and restrained. a day later said patent was much calmer and was more open to conversation, and even apologized for their actions. its hard to understand but when you are hospitalized, your safetly is the staff's number one concern. by restraining her, they can focus on the work they need to do so that she can be in the best mental state she can be in to help the police. a dissociated, traumatized girl would more likely to give unclear answers and trigger another mental break in which she could harm herself or others.
exactly! she was cooperating already the least they could have done was be gentle not attack her like that, i hope the girl got a physical i wouldnt be surprised if she got bruised from their grip, im surprised we didnt hear a crack from the way they pushed her arms aroudn liek that
As always, Dr Charles is right
No
Nah def not here, she was opening up, rushing her and sedating her doesn’t seem right
@@targaryenbatman5728 if she made a statement or eye witness or confessed to anything it wouldn't be usable because the state she's in. He did right by shutting her up Infront of a police officer/detective
Nope they grabbed her and man handled her after she watched her whole famiky die not the best approach
@@AlwaysGoLeft yeah sure, i wasn’t advocating for the investigation just that the kid is never going to trust the people who are supposed to help her, erin took her time no rush building trust instead of destroying it
She was hella smart to play dead ...very smart
It was probably more of a subconscious reflex action than an actual planed strategy. When attacked people do one of two things - Flight or Fright.
They run like Hell to get away from the danger. Or freeze up & play dead to make the person/thing threatening them think they're no longer alive.
Her brain decided on Fright - aka playing dead in order to survive. She more than likely would have fainted. & her sister would have fallen on her as she was shot further protecting her.
Young children (& animals) will often opt for the Fright/Freeze option when confronted with danger. Because they are aware they cannot out run an attack.
& for those who like to rip apart & bash discussions like this. Saying "Oh but it's just a TV show. You *KNOW* it's all fake." The story on the show may be fictional.
*BUT* it's was written using multiple real world examples of similar situation. & psychological accounts of what people actually will do when faced with situations like this.
*Sees a kid climb out from under a pile of bodies from a shooting, who looks no older than maybe 7*
''I kNoW wHaT tO dO lEt'S aSk A mIlLiOn QuEsTiOnS!''
the fact that this has happened IRL is so sad
Bless her , she is traumatized 💗
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Stop romanticizing trauma. there's nothing fun or romantic about PTSD/CPTSD/DID/OSDD
@@Ben_442 It was a “poor baby…” kinda thing
@@Sarawarawara- Now I read your comment, that makes more sense. If you’re reading this and took offence to my previous comment Leah, or anyone else for that matter, I owe you an apology for jumping to conclusions.
I watched Chicago med before I watched any of the others, when Dr. Charles showed up and took charge I was like “thank you daddy” I have issues lmao
Dr. Charles was totally right. The authority of a medical specialist should supersede any sort of authority the police think they have. I mean, the kid’s recovering from the most traumatic experience she’ll ever go through. Even if she could interview her, how could she be certain anything she says would be admissible as evidence in her current state? Right now, she’s a danger to herself and everyone around her, which makes more of a liability than anything else. All that should matter is her own mental well-being so that she’s actually in a state where she would be of any use to the police
The reason I know this is because in Transformers Prime, Optimus once personally stated that Ratchet’s expertise as the team’s medic supersedes his own authority as the team leader. After all, if you don’t take care of yourself, you can’t take care of anyone else
I love the Chicago Cinematic Universe
This gave me chills
Poor girl thank God she survived
I love antonio and erin big bro and little sis relationship
I wish there was a whole series
It is you can watch it on sky catch up
bro this needs to be on netflix
Indeed. Why are Fire and MD on netfmix but not PD??
@@moonluna464 med and fire are on netflix? which region?
@@marsham9302 all of them I think
All of them are on Viaplay. All the Chicago series
PD IS ON PRIME
Ich verstehe zwar kein englisch aber irgendwie feiere ich das trotzdem 😅
What episode was the same?
during the inspection did anyone else notice the supposedly dead girl in the blue shirt breath? it was at 1:50 watch a bit before and watch carefully, like i know its all acting and stuff but the breath was so obvious
At 1:50 look at the lady on the grounds belly she is to be playing dead and she is moving I guessed the editor missed that 🤣🤣
1:11 wait can someone please tell me who is the actor for the policewoman?? i recognise that voice
Brooke from One tree Hill
sophia bush
@@bathedintulipetals thank you!
the son at 1:57 was also an intern in grey's anatomy i think
Yess, Ross i think. Then he disappear
I thought he looked familiar
Also, he was on Suits
What episode and season is this ?
Which is the best season of chicago pd to watch? I don't want to start from season one.
Love the episodes so much please respond
hi guys I am a big fan of you guys. I love your videos
I was thinking maybe she did it 😂😂😂😂
OMG, i love Kylie
Lool. The blonde teen is from Maze Runner😅😅😅
Love this show
Same
@@airisalisha1309 it’s so good
Dr charles was so right tho. the girl was obviously traumatized and in shock, she lost her whole family right in front of her, and shes slightly injured, she was obviously not in the right state of mind to talk about the incident and who killed her family.
This is too real, officers ask questions to speed up their investigation instead of taking care of her health first. Horror movies
What happened? Did they catch whoever did it?
🇿🇦🇿🇦 this my favorite drama all the time I watched full episodes the whole day keep on doinge this guys you make my day feel easier 💐🙏🙏🤩💗👍👍💯💯💯🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦 qhubekani ukusijabulisa ngiyabonga niyangiqhaza kakhehle nginithanda nonke ama actors ngisho no procedures thank you 💕 umuhle umsebenzi wenu 💖💝🌼💖 🇿🇦🇿🇦💯💯💯 ngiyabonga iNkosi I've nani ngegama le Nkosi u Jesu Christu 🙏🥳 the 🙏🙏🙏👍👍👍👍✨💐
Omg how did you watch it la in South Africa?
Is there a part 2 for this video?
Erin Character I Love And I Like Her. Her Voice Like My Sister When Talk To Me
2:02 hey, that's agent Whylie from the mentalist :)
Yay, Dr. Charles!
What season is this? What episode?
Season 3, Episode 22 “She’s Got Us” I did some Googling so I could watch it all on Peacock.
I wouldn’t be able to live with myself if that happened to my family I would feel alone lost empty bewildered and isolated
Where can I binge this?
I need to know what happens after this, who's the culprit? do they catch them?
Hey that's the little girl from Miracles from Heaven!!
Also, the poor girl (polly) must've been terrified... hearing all the shots, her big sister dead in top of her, thinking she was finally safe when she was talking to Erin and the the nurses scaring her like that...
Isnt the girl in this, the same who played anna in miracles from heaven? That was my fave film
Yeah, I thought I recognised her.
Idk what how or out of what perpective.. but im sure that the child was okay when she laid the knife down so i think de charles was the one wrong.. of course she is in a bad state but she did put the knife down
I miss Erin 😔
Good show
Too early to get a summary of what happened in this episode.
Where can I watch the whole episode..
Perfect episode ❤️❤️
I know Chicago med is which is based in that hospital and then I don't know about Chicago med or Chicago fire but they are all connect series :)
@@tanishatippin for me Chicago pd is very better series but Chicago med and Chicago fire is good
The girl gave me Michael Myers vibes when I saw her with the knife
6:46-6:51 I think a lot of people would agree with that
Doctor Charle's lines though LOL
I'm with Erin on this one, I understand where Dr. Charles is coming from, but Erin was able to get through to Polly when she was in an agitated and unstable state. I think they should have given her some time to help Polly calm down and talk about what happened.
That's a really crappy psych ward if the kid was able to get a hold of a knife
Though Erin's actions comes from a good place Dr. Charles is right, he's the right person to determine when the poor child is ready to talk to the police. Forcing her to do so before she's ready could potentially do far more harm then good.
Ok ok ok but where did she even get the scalpel? I work with teens where there's concern with suicidal ideation and self harm, all sharp things are locked up. Of course nothing is fool proof but how did she just go from catatonic to finding a scalpel???????
I need a pt2
It always reminded me of a real life edvens about a family who was killed of cold blood
They breathing ❤
What epesode is this??
The girl just lost her entire family. She is in a psyche ward. She attacked the medical staff there. Tell me, is there any indication that she is capable of helping Erin out, even if she said she wanted to? The problem with the girl now is, not only is she traumatized, she is not rational. She is a danger to herself even. Really, Erin... what were you thinking? You think that interviewing her can solve your case any faster, when she can't even think straight?? She is in the psyche ward for a reason!
From an "inside" viewpoint of dissociative episodes; the young girl most likely doesn't remember anything as soon as the dissociation set in. Have personally "woke up" in an emergency room before after a dissociative episode and do not remember anything between the triggered event and the world becoming solid and real again. Ambulance ride, assessments, blood work..... none of that is remembered. (Diagnosed with a dissociative condition August 2022) The sedation part seems a little unreal from experiences in behavioral hospitals, but it is just a show. She was most likely in some sort of PTSD like flashback and scared and freaked out. A quiet room with minimal sensory input could have helped without being sedated. At least from personal experience of being in dissociative episodes.
GOOD TV SERIES
she’s traumatised that’s why she’s not speaking when the police arrived i mean i wouldn’t blame her i would be traumatised too and i wouldn’t talk after that would happen
What episode or season is this off chicago pd
I believe not everyone needs to be sedated if she dropped the weapon and calmed down there should be a different procedure for that.
Episode?
1:51 she isn't dead on the left, you can see her breathe out
really??? they didn’t use real dead people???
She is, it's just the actor
Kind of unrealistic to expect an actor to stop breathing for however long it takes to get a take lmao.
U rlly expect the actor to actually get shot
Is there gonna be a part 2
Which episode is this
Does anyone know witch season and episode is this?
I’m shaking right now
Season 3 episode 22 if anyone is interested.
thank you :)
James
Thx ❤
Hi. I love your videos I want to see more from this how you catch the people that killed this family
Uhh u know this is fake right?
😂
1:52 why is she breathing if she's dead
because the actor is alive and can't hold their breath for the full take?
Yep this bad