Free to my RUclips family: Get my "Cycle Indicator" tutorial at go.topdogtrading.com/freetrainingclass BE CAREFUL OF COMMENTS BELOW! Scammers are getting much worse!! They are using my name and logo in comments to trick you. DO NOT EVER send money to someone from the comments, DMs, discord, telegram, or WhatApp. Long comment threads of "people" (bots) giving names of people making them lots of money are FAKE! 😡
Amazing and so helpful. I got to learn about your channel while researching about VWAP with Standard Deviations and ever since I become hooked to every video I see on your channel. You are a life saver. God Bless you! Much love from Kenya 🇰🇪
I must admit, I hadnt understood it at all till I saw your video. And you are 100% right when you said the crossover notion is all over the internet. Ty!
after my little trading experience, what i realised is that its not "more" about finding a trend or entering timely, but to know when to exit (either in loss or profit). green becomes red in a blink of an eye and/or red becomes deep red before you even know it. thats where people loose in leveraged trading products.
My observation is--When swing trading forex with entry on 15 minute chart,momentum has to be in the same direction on both 1H & 4H charts as well--otherwise trader is doomed from the start.Reason being that trend on lower time frames can flip on A dime & there has to be some higher time frame juice for trader to make some dough.We seek your wisdom & thank you.
Hey topdog, which broker should I choose for daytrading? Have identified a few like coinexx, cryptorocket and justforex, but would like an expert opinion before finalizing.
I enjoy a fairly high success rate using the Macd in conjunction with acc/dist and a stoch. puts are easier to catch and it this market puts are plentiful and profitable.
Without a trend , trading is gambling. And most of the time there is no trend. Even when there is it’s hard to spot or predict when it will end. Usually ends just as you get into what you thought was a trend
@@lukeArmstrong524 That’s why you always use risk management.Cut your losses and let your winners run.That’s how you survive in the world of trading,otherwise you blow your account like 90% of all traders in the world.
Not true,I don’t understand how this guy said true and this is his channel,I just subbed too.Also depending what you’re trading but the stock market and crypto have been in a down trend forever now,also you can trade the range,also you can trade the trend on different time frame’s,I don’t get this comment,although new trader’s should follow the trend and you can make it with that and risk management,trends are everywhere and it’s in a trend more then not.
@@TraderRY you must be very wealthy then following all the great trends lol. But yes the markets are falling. Usually they advise against shorting but buying right now seems to always reverse very fast and be a loser on the daily chart at least. I stay away from lower timeframes
Good question. There's a bit more to it than just that. Check out one of my older RUclips videos on how to choose a good time interval for your charts: ruclips.net/video/tWbFj76NFiM/видео.html
Despite the dip in crypto, I still thank you for the level-headed financial advice. I started forex and crypto investment with $4,345 and since following you for few weeks now, I’ve gotten $18,539 in my portfolio. Thanks so much Mrs. Marie Georgiana
I invest with Mrs. Marie too, she charges a 20% commission on profit made after every trading session which is fair compared to the effort she put in to make huge profits
As a first time investor I started trading with her with just a thousand bucks. my portfolio is worth much more than that now within just weeks of trading with her.
Most if not all indicators only tell you what has happened in the past. History. The closest thing for me to time now is what's happening now and this is called price action. Trends can help. Support and resistance. Break outs. Order book. What's happening now is key. Indicators can only act as a guide but should never be used solely as entries.
The most accurate indicator to estimate new trends is the WaveTrend on Tradingview after I highly modified it. MACD, RSI etc alone does not do the trick. WaveTrend is based on the MACD with the possibility to include different levels, which, when accurate set, are extremely accurate. The levels are replacing the signal line which is extremely unreliable to estimate trends.
Barry, that is one EXCELLENT video!! Man I only wished I saw this before I started trading today, what a game changer on the MACD!! Bless you for sharing! I can only imagine the gems that must be in your "Keys To The Castle" offer. Just amazing content!
I'm new to this but these indicators, to me, seem to reflect WHAT happened. They don't seem predicative when 2/10 year treasuries and the DXY are all over the place.
Thank you for sharing that. What specifically do you mean when you refer to "supply and demand zones?" I've seen traders identify them in different ways.
indicators dont predict anything either... they tell you where you are relative to what has already happened. this is like driving your car down an un known freeway by only looking at the rearview mirrors.
I’ve learned that, yes, all these indicators can be helpful but, for the most part, they are a distraction. The candles (if you use candlestick charts) tell you everything you need to know in real time, volume, momentum, trend, trend reversals, it’s all in there. There is no indicator that is going to tell you what’s “going” to happen. Nobody knows what the next candle’s going to do. Make your analysis and go with the highest probable outcome. I’ve cleaned my charts down to nothing but ma’s, and you know what? I’m less confused, more decisive, less stressed and I’m getting better entries and exits, because I’M NOT BEING DISTRACTED!!!! We humans love to over complicate everything.
@@TopDogTrading I’m not anti indicator, I’m just trying to keep things as simple as possible, that’s just me. There’s enough micro and macro insanity, not only every day but every hour, that can and will blow up your technical analysis, at least in this current environment. Look how paralyzed the market is just over this debt ceiling crap. Every time someone from the government opens their mouth the market swings. I long for simpler days when markets moved because a business created something.
It’s a new week and we’ve been facing a downward market ever since the dump in digital assets this year but on the bright side I have a well trained professional trader who helps me go home with a very satisfying amount in profits, I’m so grateful to him.
I don't even know the equation nor the usage of the three indicators I use to profit from the market. All I know is the way I use it is making my account double every month and it's 100% no loss.
so much of confidence after 3 months of trading. clear ideas on when to hop out of the trade. manage the risk, secure the profit and letting the trade run... that's what Mr. LUCAS NOSAA mean to me. He's very reliable and efficient💯
The MACD line DOES show you how far apart the 12 and the 26 EMAs are. that's where the actual value of the MACD line comes from. The MACD is a momentum indicator, it was never meant for signals, but so many traders they to get signals from it. It shows you the trend direction based on the 12 and 26 EMAs, and then it shows you the momentum of that trend. At the end of the day, you are 100% right, indicators are never wrong. They tell you the result of the formula they are programmed to calculate. It's up to the trader to interpret that information. If a trade cannot property interpret the information, that's on the trader, not the indicator. And yes, indicators lag, but they lag because they are supposed to. If you want something that doesn't lag, look to price action, not an indicator.
Thanks for the free indicator, but I have an insulting question to ask. From what you say, you make money trading. Then why bother with the youtube channel?
@@TopDogTrading Because one would want to know how your trading profits compare with your youtube income. If someone is a successful trader, there would be no reason to waste time making youtube videos, unless the youtube videos and other trading education products pay better than the actual trading. It's a completely logical thought.
@@bluenetmarketing You can make money from both, what's the problem? I know TopDog from years, he maxed his channel benefit & so many others did. And BTW, when one rich they invest & let professionals drive not trade!
@@reporter5534 He gives good information, but does it add up that someone who makes a ton of money trading would do youtube videos? I've always wondered about it with all the trader channels. Haven't you. It's a natural curiosity. I KNOW John Carter makes money trading because he posts his statement and I've watched him make hundreds of thousands of dollars day trading, first hand. It's just a curiosity, that's all.
Free to my RUclips family: Get my "Cycle Indicator" tutorial at go.topdogtrading.com/freetrainingclass
BE CAREFUL OF COMMENTS BELOW! Scammers are getting much worse!! They are using my name and logo in comments to trick you. DO NOT EVER send money to someone from the comments, DMs, discord, telegram, or WhatApp. Long comment threads of "people" (bots) giving names of people making them lots of money are FAKE! 😡
one of the best trading videos i ever saw. my biggest confusion with indicators was cleared.
Glad to hear the video was so helpful fo ryou Debadatta.
Amazing and so helpful. I got to learn about your channel while researching about VWAP with Standard Deviations and ever since I become hooked to every video I see on your channel. You are a life saver. God Bless you! Much love from Kenya 🇰🇪
And YES!!! I was using The MACD all wrong!!! OH MY!!!!!.... Thank youuuuuuuuuuu
Glad I could be so helpful for you.
You're more than welcome!
Your custom MacD settings and its use as a leading indicator pure genius Doc B 💪 Keep up the good work! Traders need it !!
Thanks Tsanko, will do!
Hi tsanko can you please say the config of macd. Thank you in advance. 🙏
@@dhavalvanjara572 yes plz. i am very interested
Love this video. You're a wonderful teacher!
Thank you so much!
Excellent explanation. Thanks
Glad it was helpful!
Brilliant sir, thanks a ton. I use macd with slightly different setting and it is a brilliant indicator.
Excellent, thanks for contributing that.
I must admit, I hadnt understood it at all till I saw your video. And you are 100% right when you said the crossover notion is all over the internet. Ty!
You're very welcome Prasenjit!
after my little trading experience, what i realised is that its not "more" about finding a trend or entering timely, but to know when to exit (either in loss or profit). green becomes red in a blink of an eye and/or red becomes deep red before you even know it. thats where people loose in leveraged trading products.
The markets can indeed change very quickly!
Loved the video and the free class on your website. That indicator def helped + the explanation 🎉
Glad it was helpful!
thanks for in depth explanation in detail . we like it because indicator never wrong. thanks barry sir.
My pleasure
This was very useful. Completely different way of looking & analysing macd
Glad it was helpful Krishna!
Thank you, Doctor Burns
You're very welcome Warren.
My observation is--When swing trading forex with entry on 15 minute chart,momentum has to be in the same direction on both 1H & 4H charts as well--otherwise trader is doomed from the start.Reason being that trend on lower time frames can flip on A dime & there has to be some higher time frame juice for trader to make some dough.We seek your wisdom & thank you.
Hey topdog, which broker should I choose for daytrading? Have identified a few like coinexx, cryptorocket and justforex, but would like an expert opinion before finalizing.
Real interesting. Curious how to configure the bottom converg/diverg in ninja?? Thanks for the vid
This content is gold, sir. Thank you!
Glad you're getting so much value from it Phil
Thanks for such a meaningful teaching
Glad it was helpful Bairagi!
This definitely helps with understanding thanks.
You're very welcome!
Thanks for the great explaination mate 👌
Happy to help
what is the time frame you used? thanks
I don't recall, but it's not relevant to the point of this tutorial.
I use a combination of 9 12 26 EMAs on a 3minute time frame for intraday along with macd. Tremendous results on heikin ashi charts.
Wonderful, keep up the good work Ganesh.
Could you tell me little bit more about your strategy if you don’t mind of course I would be extremely grateful👍
Try for MACD 8,21,5 it’s a bit quicker and helps on all time frames
This is dope. Finally understood something I hadn't grasped. Thanks a Milly 👌👍💯
Happy to help Julia!
I never knew this. Amazing.
Glad the video was so helpful John.
Thank you can you show us how you use stochastic indicator as a timing tool for pullbacks
I have a recording on that at go.topdogtrading.com/freetrainingclass
Thank you so much! I'm starting to learn how to trade and there's a bunch of videos that don't explain the basics.
You're very welcome Miche.
wow! cool info on the macd. always wondered what it stood for! Thanks !
Glad it was helpful!
Is it Apply on Indian market
Thanks Dr Barry, appreciate the insight and experience
My pleasure Dan!
I enjoy a fairly high success rate using the Macd in conjunction with acc/dist and a stoch. puts are easier to catch and it this market puts are plentiful and profitable.
Thanks for sharing, and keep up the good work.
In this video u are using word acceletion wrto macd line.. so ifs not momentum? Or can it be percieved as momentum also.. though it misses mass in it
Correct, it's technically acceleration because there is no mass involved in the equation.
Congrats!!100K Subscribers
You noticed!!! Thank you so much 😀
wow , thanks for your video......also im glad to see your a ninja trader as well
You're very welcome James, and yes, I love NinjaTrader
Thank You !👍
You are welcome Maciek.
I would use hekin ashi candles. Makes a world of difference.
There is so much misunderstanding of the MACD out there - thanks for the clarification.
You're very welcome Zachary.
Yes all indicators will be never wrong because they're formed after price action has already played out.
Without a trend , trading is gambling. And most of the time there is no trend. Even when there is it’s hard to spot or predict when it will end. Usually ends just as you get into what you thought was a trend
100% true David. That's exactly why it's important to measure more than just the trend when looking to take a trade.
@@TopDogTrading volume is key....
@@lukeArmstrong524 That’s why you always use risk management.Cut your losses and let your winners run.That’s how you survive in the world of trading,otherwise you blow your account like 90% of all traders in the world.
Not true,I don’t understand how this guy said true and this is his channel,I just subbed too.Also depending what you’re trading but the stock market and crypto have been in a down trend forever now,also you can trade the range,also you can trade the trend on different time frame’s,I don’t get this comment,although new trader’s should follow the trend and you can make it with that and risk management,trends are everywhere and it’s in a trend more then not.
@@TraderRY you must be very wealthy then following all the great trends lol.
But yes the markets are falling. Usually they advise against shorting but buying right now seems to always reverse very fast and be a loser on the daily chart at least. I stay away from lower timeframes
This 15 min video is one of your best if not the best , just my opinion though , I found it extremely powerful
Wonderful, glad you found it so helpful Elwood.
Long time not to see you dr.Barry. using 400 tick only work on volatile stock right ?
Good question. There's a bit more to it than just that. Check out one of my older RUclips videos on how to choose a good time interval for your charts: ruclips.net/video/tWbFj76NFiM/видео.html
Thanks for explaining, as a new trader I understand now.
Glad it was helpful!
Can you develop an automated fibonacci expansion indicator?
Yes, we already have one.
@@TopDogTrading why not show it live on chart ? Rather than edited videos?
@@TopDogTrading where is it?
Thanks for the reinforcement Barry - always a good review here for your students
Always happy to help GS
Despite the dip in crypto, I still thank you for the level-headed financial advice. I started forex and crypto investment with $4,345 and since following you for few weeks now, I’ve gotten $18,539 in my portfolio.
Thanks so much Mrs. Marie Georgiana
Wow, amazing to see others who trade with Mrs Marie Georgiana, I'm currently on my 5th trade with her and my portfolio has grown tremendously.
I invest with Mrs. Marie too, she charges a 20% commission on profit made after every trading session which is fair compared to the effort she put in to make huge profits
This is not the first time I am hearing of Mrs Marie Georgiana and her exploits in the trading world but I have no idea how to reach her.
As a first time investor I started trading with her with just a thousand bucks. my portfolio is worth much more than that now within just weeks of trading with her.
With the consistent weekly profits I'm getting investing with her, there's no doubt she is the most reliable in the market. such a genius
where do you get your charts from ?? i like how easy they are
I used NinjaTrader in that video.
The 0line of the macd is the king of all indicators if you know how to trade it
Thank you for sharing that, much appreciated.
which one is good for trading, pitch forks theory or indicator theory, sir
They both have their place Mangi, they're completely different things.
Logical as always.. thanks and regards. Waiting for whole coverage on macd
Thank you Pitamber.
Most if not all indicators only tell you what has happened in the past. History. The closest thing for me to time now is what's happening now and this is called price action. Trends can help. Support and resistance. Break outs. Order book. What's happening now is key. Indicators can only act as a guide but should never be used solely as entries.
Agreed. I never use an indicator as my sole reason for taking a trade.
Moon movement LMFAO!!! I remember there's an advertisement on YT about the "Time Trader" guy
السلام عليكم أحييك و اشكرك على هدا الدرس شكرا مرتا اخرى
The most accurate indicator to estimate new trends is the WaveTrend on Tradingview after I highly modified it.
MACD, RSI etc alone does not do the trick.
WaveTrend is based on the MACD with the possibility to include different levels, which, when accurate set, are extremely accurate.
The levels are replacing the signal line which is extremely unreliable to estimate trends.
Barry, that is one EXCELLENT video!! Man I only wished I saw this before I started trading today, what a game changer on the MACD!! Bless you for sharing! I can only imagine the gems that must be in your "Keys To The Castle" offer. Just amazing content!
Glad it was helpful so helpful for your Dave!
Never been a fan of the MACD.... RSI set with 40 - 60 breakouts with a moving average gives more than enough info to go with price action
Thank you for sharing that Greenman.
Nice hair cut
Thank you 😊
Hi Barry.. i kniw its being greedy.. But hope u shall onsider.. a series on macd.. in your style and interpretation.. thanks
Thanks for asking, but that's reserved for my course Pitamber.
I'm new to this but these indicators, to me, seem to reflect WHAT happened. They don't seem predicative when 2/10 year treasuries and the DXY are all over the place.
Les indicateurs ne peuvent pas se tromper ! Ils nous racontent le passé !😉
It's a bearish divergence price action formation.
I just reached enlightenment
LOL! Congratulations 7even!
BROBRO BROOO dude.. this is what i needed. thanks. its both btw.
Glad to help DJ!
In today's market none of those indicators will work. We are in a very corrupt market.
Need to filter relative volume
Follow liquidity
100%
It’s still a lagger the only true leading indicator is supply and demand zones and I would love to debate this any time
Thank you for sharing that. What specifically do you mean when you refer to "supply and demand zones?" I've seen traders identify them in different ways.
When you know what you are doing most indicators work as well as money management strategies......but who does? considering 95% of traders fail?
I agree 100%, money management is WAY more important than any indicator!
No touch till Friday let dust settle.
Thank you for the contribution to the discussion Jeff.
Math is never wrong.... right! 1 + 1 + 1 = 3... right answer and NOT 1.
indicators dont predict anything either... they tell you where you are relative to what has already happened. this is like driving your car down an un known freeway by only looking at the rearview mirrors.
Somewhat true, but actually nothing in trading is about predicting where the market is going in the future.
Please suggest me what to use qhen we take trade in intraday in india
@@TopDogTrading Trading is EVERYTHING about determining the odds that what you bought you can sell at a profit in the future.... aka predicting...
You really didn't explain what the RED SIGNAL LINE is.
Not even watching this. ALL indicators are 100% correct. All indicators are NEVER wrong. Indicators tell you what HAS happened. Not what WILL happen.
I’ve learned that, yes, all these indicators can be helpful but, for the most part, they are a distraction.
The candles (if you use candlestick charts) tell you everything you need to know in real time, volume, momentum, trend, trend reversals, it’s all in there. There is no indicator that is going to tell you what’s “going” to happen. Nobody knows what the next candle’s going to do. Make your analysis and go with the highest probable outcome.
I’ve cleaned my charts down to nothing but ma’s, and you know what? I’m less confused, more decisive, less stressed and I’m getting better entries and exits, because
I’M NOT BEING DISTRACTED!!!!
We humans love to over complicate everything.
Good point Floyd, thank you for sharing that. It's easy to get information overload which can lead to mental overwhelm.
@@TopDogTrading I’m not anti indicator, I’m just trying to keep things as simple as possible, that’s just me. There’s enough micro and macro insanity, not only every day but every hour, that can and will blow up your technical analysis, at least in this current environment. Look how paralyzed the market is just over this debt ceiling crap. Every time someone from the government opens their mouth the market swings. I long for simpler days when markets moved because a business created something.
historic charts are also almost never wrong
They are never wrong because they are always lagging!
It has nothing to do with math, you might as well just call them hindsight indicators.
It’s a new week and we’ve been facing a downward market ever since the dump in digital assets this year but on the bright side I have a well trained professional trader who helps me go home with a very satisfying amount in profits, I’m so grateful to him.
On telegram
Penlarry
👌🏽👌🏽👌🏽👌🏽👌🏽👌🏽👌🏽
I don't even know the equation nor the usage of the three indicators I use to profit from the market. All I know is the way I use it is making my account double every month and it's 100% no loss.
This "free" Trade Entry Timing video so far is 20 minutes of a sale pitch. Needs a scroll bar to ff through all of that.
We all now know what KiTT was doing in his free time when Michael wasn't in the car with him
so much of confidence after 3 months of trading. clear ideas on when to hop out of the trade. manage the risk, secure the profit and letting the trade run... that's what Mr. LUCAS NOSAA mean to me. He's very reliable and efficient💯
Follow him on telegram
@. Lucasnosaa
Walkers Samantha < SCAMMER!
A math function can predict what’s going to happen in the next 30 minutes?
Great question. Trading itself is not about predicting the future of the market.
People who teach trading, can’t trade. Trust me, there is no major indicator .
Never wrong, just late to the party
Just invent an indicator that tells you when big institutions are buying,,prob all u need
You may want to ask your charting platform is they offer a "block trades" indicator.
?????
The MACD line DOES show you how far apart the 12 and the 26 EMAs are. that's where the actual value of the MACD line comes from. The MACD is a momentum indicator, it was never meant for signals, but so many traders they to get signals from it.
It shows you the trend direction based on the 12 and 26 EMAs, and then it shows you the momentum of that trend.
At the end of the day, you are 100% right, indicators are never wrong. They tell you the result of the formula they are programmed to calculate. It's up to the trader to interpret that information. If a trade cannot property interpret the information, that's on the trader, not the indicator.
And yes, indicators lag, but they lag because they are supposed to. If you want something that doesn't lag, look to price action, not an indicator.
Thank you for the thoughtful contribution to the topic Russ.
These are retailers indicators. You cannot trust it blindly.
Definitely agree Sarah.
Stay away of any indicators. Use just liquidity zones
Thanks Captain Obvious!
Show me your trading statements.
Results speak, bs walks.
Thanks for the free indicator, but I have an insulting question to ask. From what you say, you make money trading. Then why bother with the youtube channel?
No problem, that's not an insulting question. The real insight will come when you successfully answer the question: "Why would you ask that?" 🤔
@@TopDogTrading Because one would want to know how your trading profits compare with your youtube income. If someone is a successful trader, there would be no reason to waste time making youtube videos, unless the youtube videos and other trading education products pay better than the actual trading. It's a completely logical thought.
@@bluenetmarketing You can make money from both, what's the problem? I know TopDog from years, he maxed his channel benefit & so many others did. And BTW, when one rich they invest & let professionals drive not trade!
@@reporter5534 He gives good information, but does it add up that someone who makes a ton of money trading would do youtube videos? I've always wondered about it with all the trader channels. Haven't you. It's a natural curiosity. I KNOW John Carter makes money trading because he posts his statement and I've watched him make hundreds of thousands of dollars day trading, first hand. It's just a curiosity, that's all.
Newbies trade with indicators.. and thats why they have bad results.
Never wrong, lmao, run away fast
Sorry. I cannot listen to someone who has adopted the latest fad of using "so" in every sentence uttered.
are u serious
all indicators lag lmao
All indicators are lagging therefore useless
They are most of the time wrong
So innother these indicators are useless..
He may be good but his accent is grating….like chalk on a black board
After all these, finally he loses!
This is a horror story.