"Watch collecting is a journey of upward mobility and it doesn't need to be" - well said that man. "I experimented with spending twelve grand on a watch and it did nothing for me". This is amazing. Insightful. Well said. Watch collecting is about finding a piece that makes you correspond to it emotionally and not financially. This was worth the admission alone. Thanks guys.
Andrew won this! A bit of everything, a perfect balance between friendship, between sentiment, heritage and controversy! Makes his collection feel so unpredictable and fun! 👏👏
@@shanghaiffggagreed, he’s a watch designer and he gets to design what he wants. I don’t think that’s arrogant, that’s just him liking what he likes, and that’s the point of a personal collection.
When George talks about his watches, it sounds like an Academy Awards acceptance speech. When Adrian talks about his watches, it sounds like a therapy session.
a Rolex cuck therapy session lol , Love Adrian and his photography but holy crap his Bias is horrible . His Watch Snobbery just screams " i have low Testosterone and my wife cheats on me with my friends "
Andrew wins this for me - just a proper collectors mindset I feel. Adrian's is sensible to a fault - there's not so much as a yellow G Shock just to even demonstrate a sliver of some nonconformity. George's collection is just George, and I think that's what's disappointed me most about it. I was expecting to see some crazy solid gold Tag Autavia or something like a marine chronometer that had been passed down through the family.
It would have been very nice to see George's Navitimer. I think that was his first watch? And he also tore it apart soon after receiving it to understand how it worked. I think it says so much about him and foreshadowed what his relationship with watches would be like. That watch is probably the most interesting watch in all three of the guy's collections in terms of the story it tells.
i love that you basically called Adrian a sheep of a watch consumer 😂 i like him but youre not wrong he just likes rolex and thats boring just like the majority of general public
Hahahaha of course with all those limited 25 limited pieces designed by Mr Bamford ! Now I know why one of the most beautiful, historic watch’s near to the Daytona is ugly! mr Banford destroyed the design of such an icon like the Heur Monaco into a TV 📺 Apple huge screen on wrist! Only show off love Adrian’s collection and the Longines Big eye rest of all watch’s rubbish specially that White GP and the Hublot 🤢
My vote is for Andrew. His collection was the most diverse. George’s collection is just way too personalized with collaborations and honestly hard for me to resonate with. Adrian is the obviously a tool watch guy, as am I, but it is too centered on Rolex.
OMG! Thanks for the shout and im over the moon that you guys actually made this into an episode! Thank you 🙏🙏🙏 love the ep and that 15 watch on the table is an amazing collection to be honest! From Geoge i love the GP most(keeps begging him to make more of it 😂) , Andrew that hublot wins it for me simple as that, Adrian i love the Kermit and i think its correct you wear it more as it looks amazing on you man! Once again thank you guys 🙌🙌🙌
The eccentric watch designer = 8/10 The sarcastic watch reporter = 7/10 ( I cannot get on board with the Hublot ) The Rolex employee = 4/10 ( 10/10 for predictability )
I agree with Adrian. I like to wear watches for myself, if a person notices it, it can become inconvenient, due to price and social settings. Definitely love to disappear when it comes to watches
Hands down Adrian's collection just for the insane diversity not just of watch specs but of the timing of release, the colors, the wearablity everything!
Adrian won, as his collection seems the most thoughtful in what he likes and he really had to stretch to create that collection so they had to be meaningful. Andrew’s was the most eclectic, and interesting for other people to view. George’s was the biggest window into his personality since they were all products of his own imagination. But in the end, everyone’s collection is the best, because they are reflections of different likes, personalities, and willingness to stretch to achieve. So I think all three win because they all really seem to enjoy what they brought, and more importantly they wear/wore them (Adrian, get good insurance and wear the Sub again-it’s only a thing in the end). If you aren’t wearing a watch, you haven’t collected it, you’ve invested in it.
Collection review: In short, Andrew nailed it with his quite imaginative style (8.7/10)! George has a killer touch to his watches aka Branford personalisation which would be the dream of every collector. Great watches, great brands(9.2)! Τhis is another level and it’s unbeatable! Finally Adrian seems a Rolex Ad trying to be objective(6.2/10)! Sorry Adrian you are too boring but I love your videos and straps😂 P.S. You guys it’s incredible you didn’t present a single Omega or a Zenith😢
@@BarkandJack Adrian, you appreciate the timeless elegance of classic tool watches! ✨️ At the same time your work is quite inspiring! keep it up! This is another way to say boring in your case 😀 Cheers from Genève 🇨🇭
I’m with Adrian on this one. My watches are for me. I don’t care what other people think, and I prefer not to attrach to much attention. The Explorer is a beautiful watch yet very simple. I love it
George Collection is 4 out of 10. We were expecting more personal watches without the commercial interest. Something where there is not financial involvement, I don't see Collabs as part of a personal collection, the passion is undeniable but I would be more interested in non Bamford collabs. Adrian 5 out of 10, it's basically the same watch but at least he knows what he likes, it's consistant but lacks originality. Andrew is 7 out 10 for the diversity and for sharing watches that are more accessible to the rest of us, a lot more relatable. I won't mentioned the Hublot :). I was surprised that Andrew didn't share other watches from his collection such as the Bronze Tudor or that incredible Norquain. Overall it was very interesting to watch where I feel that for some, we actually know more about their personality vs others still trying to protect a certain privacy. Thanks for as great episode.
Almost exactly the kind of collections I expected to see. George with his amazing limited editions comprising a few of his fantastic Bamford’s, but not bringing out his real big boys(which I really admire about him). Adrian with his safe collection as he is Mr safe, but an amazing set of safe watches, this would appeal to safe watch collectors. Then Andrew with his semi flamboyant collection showing his varied and often flamboyant taste. I think your collections are direct reflections of your personalities. I think as time goes by collectors watches tend to reflect their personalities. 10 out of 10 for all three collections. I would gladly sport with pride and add to my collection any of the watches shown. Thanks again for a great show!!!!🎉
Adrian wins for me. Explorer II Polar is the best of the bunch. George’s GP is cool. Andrew’s white ceramic is fun. I tried it skeptically and was surprised how fun it is. Adrian, wear your Rootbeer more and don’t worry what people think. George, love your Silverstein B&R. Well done guys. 😊❤
Great show. If I were to pick a collection to pick up of the table and keep, it would be Adrian’s. But it could easily be anyone’s collection. Andrew’s collection looks and feels most authentic to me as a reflection of an individual’s journey. Each piece is quirky and interesting and at first glance you know there is a story there. George’s collection is predictable based on his business. Would’ve been interested to see one or two pieces without a BWD connection.
My thoughts, one collection is from someone that likes to create, another collection is from someone that is attracted to the moment and the final collection is from someone that ties his likes to his budget. These three collections kind of sum up the various collectors and watch enthusiasts out there. I think all the collections are fine because they suit a need and fulfill a void for the collector in particular.
It’s interesting to learn how other collectors approach the hobby. What surprised me the most was that the oldest watches were the Explorers. I expected to see a couple of vintage watches and not just modern reissues. To me, those old watches that I’ve acquired are more important than most of my modern ones because I feel like I’m a curator of history which makes choosing my next purchase a struggle between practicality and sentiment.
Guys, that was a good episode! But what was interesting for me to learn is that I no longer base my collection on the influencers of the time, but have developed my own established taste. It was expensive, but now I can endure the annual collection reviews without buying impulses. For me, Andrew has won (7 points) ! I love you guys.
Andrew's collection is my favorite of the three, but it's a bit chronograph heavy. That said, the Longines is absolutely superb. That and a Casio for the beach is all you'd ever really need.
George’s collection is a good representation of brands with his personal customization. 9 out of 10. Adrian gets a 2 for being Rolex centric. Andrew gets a 10 for individual choices.
That was a good way to kill an hour on this cold Sunday afternoon. It’s shame that George couldn’t generally see past his own commercial interests as he has an excellent grasp of the wider market but failed to expand. I would say that Andrew won by the width of one of Bark & Jack’s NATOs, with Adrian a close second.
I totally take on board your thoughts that George was only exhibiting his own work, but actually that's an incredible luxury to have. To take a model that you love and really personalise it to one's own tastes must be fabulous. I've had a play with the configurator on his website and getting something out that actually works is really hard, so full credit to him for being extremely good at what he does.
Loved this thanks! As a fledgling collector looking in on those who've been at it for years its great to see it all comes down to a reflection of personality and individuality. Standouts for me were the IWC ( maybe camera angle and lighting) and the Hublot
I put on a watch that makes me smile, be it build quality or looks, but never to impress. Adrian’s comment about loving a watch because he can disappear is epic and spot on, it’s a relationship with the owner and wearer only that matters.
This was great guys! Really loved each of them, and appreciated seeing each of your personalities come through in the collections! Would be honored to one day see one of our watches make it in there and hope you guys are doing great and have a wonderful holidays! All the best, Ben
Andrew. His words are from a point of wonder still-and connection to sentiment. Awash in watches these three have access where pedestrians like me can only piggy back on and love to be along. I’m a forever fan of Adrian and I mirror his collection ethos (only an Explorer and Sub) but didn’t know I needed other lanes to peer into via the other two. George shows me where the farther reaches are on the horizon from where I stand (again, closer to Adrian) and I so appreciate how he sees watches and what he wants to show up for him. Appreciate you guys. A point to upvote: that moment in the end when Adrian is on the spot about selling Bark & Jack-it got so raw and very real. Love it. More of that kind of exchange and getting each other into an off balance spot. So real. Human and fun. It becomes less a presentation. Or a show. Bravo all around.
Each one is a 10/10. It's not a out brand diversity, nor about checking different boxes. You guys buy/create what you like and stand by it. That's all that matters for me to make a collection personal.... and perfect for you.
Adrian for me, hands down. I actually own the 16570 Polar which was his first big boy watch and I love it, and I sold my Sub 16610 to get it, absolutely no regrets. I think you should get rid of the Kermit and the Rootbeer Adrian and trade the 42mm Explorer II for another 16570 Polar, that one with the Explorer and the IWC would make a simple yet killer 3 watch collection. Well, maybe add a speedy in the future 😂
If I had to make a 5 watch collection of everything shown... 1. Chopard x Bamford Desert Racer 2. Hublot Unico 3. Heuer Monaco x Bamford 4. Studio Underd0g 5. Rolex Kermit. Basically a perfect 5-watch collection IMO... with room for a Speedy to round out 6. Awesome collections Guys!
0: Shit watch, 1: Not for me, 2: Take my money, rating in the order as displayed: George: 1+1+2+2+1 = 7 Adrian: 1+2+2+2+1 = 8 Andrew: 2+1+2+1+1 = 7 Big fan of you guys, appreciate you sharing your love of watches. Love from Istanbul. ❤️
Andrew takes the win for me here, solid and diverse collection 9/10. Next George has a very cool and different set, but I think he should do it again with no collabs aloud. I’m sure he’s some super cool pieces tucked away that are maybe private to him and that he maybe doesn’t want to share and that’s totally, but I’m sure I’m not the only one that would love to see more of what he’s got! 8/10 for him. And finally Adrian, again solid “Rolex” collection which we all knew was coming, but man I wish he’d venture out more, 6/10. Awesome ep guys!
In my book Andrew gets the W for this episode. Just in diversity alone he wins by miles. George always bringing interesting stuff to the forefront and I reckon Adrian doesn't need to sell bark and jack just yet as he seems to already be on a very sweet sponsorship deal with Rolex. Would've found it interesting to have the price tag of each collection to see what the value proposition is. I appreciate that you can admire a watch as an object in itself but it is interesting to have the price as it do find it informs my judgement as well. I just got my first watch (other that a Casio f-91w) which is a Serica California that I absolutely adore but I simply can't imagine spending over £2k on a watch in the next two years. I find it hard on personal level to be able to justify the spend but I think I may have caught the bug which I fear is going to be harsh on my future bank statements. Andrew, I really appreciate you backing Hublot, I also feel they get underserved hate. One of the coolest watches that I'd love to own one day is the Hodinkee limited edition Classic Fusion in titanium which is just
Who wins? The viewers! That was a really cool episode. George: 9.4/10 Adrian: 9.6/10 and Andrew 9.4/10. Back in May of 2018, I had a brief conversation with Adrian on IG about requesting either a Tudor GMT or Rolex Pepsi. I was grateful to have gotten the call for both watches soon after. There I was with TWO amazing watches. But one was out of place.... it was the Rolex. To this day, I still daily the Tudor GMT (I did upgrade the bracelet to the Tudor 5-link) and added other watches to the collection. But I keep going back to the tried and true (Tudor). I share this, not to gloat about getting an AD call, but to communicate that podcasts, reviews and engagements like this are great tools to help viewers understand the "why" behind collecting. Happy Holidays, Gents! PS: Adrian recommended I get the Tudor, he was right all along.
I love all the collections for what they mean to each of you. I learned to appreciate a couple of things I did not in the past and it made be reflect on my collection.
I'm running so late with AET. Brilliant episode again. All collections are amazing and I salute to the achievements on the table! 🙌 George proves again he is a genius and a rock star, Andrew is sophisticated in versatility and Adrian creates honest and independent content while wearing what he loves. But you guys just put a bug in my ear and I'd love to see a Bamford X Bark & Jack special edition! 😍😄
Adrain was a big influence for me getting my Explorer 124270. I absolutely love that watch. All of its beauty is in its simplicity. I’ve owned other Rolexes and none made me happy every time I looked at it. I got mine brand new this past June. And I’ve worn it every day since. This is my first Oyster bracelet and first EZ Link. And maybe the taper helps, but it’s the most comfortable bracelet to date. I recently tried on a Vacheron overseas. Very cool bracelet. Not as comfortable. I still might get it (it’s a touch big for my 6.5” wrist). Either way, great convo and really enjoyed this one.
George 6/10 it’s very personal, a bit goofy but some cool pieces and stories. Adrain 7/10 clean, simple style, you can’t go wrong with Rolex, but you need to mix it up. Not one single Chronograph? Andrew 8/10 different styles, colors, brands and not just high dollar stuff. In my opinion it’s the most diverse and unique collection so it takes my vote for the “best”
It was such a cool episode. I think Andrew did the best job at showing a collection with some progression and connections. The Hublot was a bit of a misstep IMHO ; a tad vulgar😂. George had more of a showcase of cools projects; very cool indeed. Adrian’s collection demonstrates someone who would rather go for class and safe investment, than displaying adventure and self confidence (in the sense of a Rolex protecting you from being judged). I respect that.
George what's the movement in that bell and Ross Alain Silberstein watch? I have a similar collab watch from Louis Erard based on Selitta elabore and not really happy with the accuracy. Was wondering if yours is more accurate. Thnx.
I almost got excited thinking we would actually see George's collection. I mean come on! We all know it's 50+ watches so just show us already. His "5 watches" collection felt more like a marketing promo for Bamford. I get that he loves his own creations, but please show us ALL your other watches too. Andrew gets the 10/10 Adrian 9.5/10 Good stuff guys!
Thanks guys. Great entertainment as usual! Nów the ratings: Andrew 7/10. Just to many chrono’s for a 5 watch collection. All are pieces I wouldn’t say no to! Adrian 8/10. Very much a tool watch collection but just too many Rolex’s. George 9/10. Well balanced super funky collection. 1 chrono, 1 diver, 1 funky dress watch, 1 summer watch and the hard core tool watch. All 3 collections are awesome and suit each one of you. Thanks for sharing. ❤
The explorer 36 with the 20mm lug width is pure class. The Kermit should be worn selectively. He has the best explorer 2. The root beer sorta doesn’t fit but I wouldn’t sell it.
I’m a Rolex fan so I am all about Adrian’s collection. I want to have a big Rolex collection to pass to my kid and enjoy my whole life. I have 6 already and 7th coming this week. I love them and there is no explanation. The good news is historically always they have retained or increased in value so it’s safe money to park. So while flashy, hype, common, boring, or whatever ppl think about Rolex the truth is they are perfect watches, timeless, robust and classy at the same time and they will always be desired. I like them all. Bamfords brilliance to be able to work with brands and to have a story about every co creation is insane and something most of us will never be able to do, Andrews collection is great but as well but for me it’s Adrian’s :) GREAT video guys! Love watching your stuff. Makes me feel great to be a part of the watch collecting community
Andrew's collection is by far the most balanced and wearable everyday. Bamford's is a bit out there and the best watch geek's collection, but not everyday wearable. Adrian's is a very 'nice' collection, and not surprising he went with 4 Rolex! Overall I vote for Andrew's as it's the most balanced for everyday wear.
Always good to watch About Effing Time. However, I got the sense that it was only Adrian who was honest and showed his real watch collection. The others, who own Patek and AP, were hiding their real collections and used this episode as a bit of a marketing opportunity. Now that AET has ended I will continue to follow Adrian, but not the others.
Andrew wins this by a mile for me. Was expecting more from George tbh. Adrians is just boring, obv good but boring. Great for going for a hike and shooting B-rolls I guess.
I have been subscribed to you guys since the beginning of your channel and first of all, chapeau for you all having the stones to put it all out there. Watches are so personal, so to me there is no “winner”in this. I think the winner is good taste, which you all seem to have and is very rare in this space. I actually liked every watch you guys pulled out and your stories behind your purchases. I own a few that you have displayed myself. Great show. Cheers ✨
The highlight of this video for me was having my OCD triggered at 18:42 when the watches were being put on the table in what appeared to be a random manner - to watching it all come together at 43:15 and my mind calming down 😀 THANK YOU - otherwise I wouldn’t have been able to look past it and rate Andrew’s collection as the best 😜🤘🏼- mainly because it was diverse and was still “him”. It’s also pretty cool to see your choices and then go “ah that makes sense” because of how the three of you bring your whole self forward in these videos and the podcast! It’s so easy for your watches to make sense because of who YOU are 😊
Ah rating: Andrew - 8/10 - purely because you could use a nice vintage dress as part of that collection as opposed to 4 chronographs 😊 Adrian - 6 George - 4 (Sorry GB.. the watches didn’t make me smile)
Love how Adrian stayed true to himself and did not "flashify" his curation, most would try to shake off a "Captain boring" tag, he just owns it:D screams strong character, and the other 2 of course as well, George being Bamford first and Andrew looking to do well and deliver on the expectation
George: 2/10 Andrew: 5/10 Adrian: 9/10 George's collection felt like a self-centered Bamford promotion with pretentious collab name dropping. Where are the vintage watches if you love them so much? This just felt awkward and embarrassing. Andrew's collection has something to please everybody. A little bit of fun, a little bit of class and a little bit of controversy. With having a little bit of everything I find the collection lacking personality and courage. What are you really into? Adrian's collection is an honest personal collection. I don't like Rolex. However, I can appreciate a collection that has the most honest connection with the collector. I love how everything isn't perfect with this collection! It's got a movement that runs backwards, a watch that you don't dare to wear and a watch you're trying to replace. This is everybody's watch collection! A beautiful personal collection, bravo. Ps. Thanks for the videos!
Adrian's collection is "safe" but if I could own one of three collections it would be he his. I'd rather enjoy wearing my watches than trying to appease to other watch enthusiasts by having interesting obscure pieces.
This shows how personal and subjective watch collecting is. All collections are 10/10 for the owner. As objective collections on their own I prefer Andrews based on my personal taste, would pick Adrian's based on value, and would love to have my own customized versions of George's. P.S. George, if you can get Calvin and Hobbes on a dial that would be truly impressive.
I don’t think every watch is one thing or the other. They are not absolute as a collection but absolute individually depending on occasion. A watch can help you stand out or be understated depending on place, function and purpose. Of course this is why collections grow over time with you as you experience various stages of life. For me, my collection tells my story over time. From college to being in the military as a single man to 30 years later as a husband, father and professional. Every watch is different just like the occasion and the individual that wears them. I really enjoyed this video. The selections shown were fantastic. It’s all about the stories they tell and the conversations they foster. Thank you.
I respect George, and I think his collection is super awesome. However, why doesn’t he ever showcase his other big pieces? I know he has a deep connection with the ones he designed and collaborated with, but he’s constantly nagging on hype pieces/brands and I’m pretty sure he has a fair share of time pieces from said brands. Is he ashamed of owning pieces from AP, Patek, Rolex etc? I also understand if he doesn’t want to show it off for security reasons, but it just doesn’t make sense to me when he calls Rolex and other big brands boring if he owns them too. Perhaps they don’t represent him? If that’s the case, why not sell them?
My favourites from all this in order. 1. George's Chopard Mille Miglia 2. George's Girard Peregaux Laureatto 3. Andrew's Hublot Big Bang 4. George's Franck Muller Jumping Hour 5. Adrian's Rolex Explorer 2
Adrian you didn't wanna wear a 10K watch but have an explorer 2 (about 10K USD and trades for higher) and a rootbeer which sells for well over 10k RRP? Time to wear the Kermit as part of the daily rotation again!
@@BarkandJack love that it's back on the wrist! I definitely understand the hesitancy when this price craziness plus crime in London was on the rise. But I'm stoked you're getting solid wrist time in with it!
Andrew has the most versatility, even with that Hublot. Adrian resonates with one brand mostly, which isn't a bad thing (that explorer is my favourite out of all of the watches shown). George is definitely a taste tinkerer, whatever the platform he'll subdue it to his preference. Awesome show!
"Watch collecting is a journey of upward mobility and it doesn't need to be" - well said that man. "I experimented with spending twelve grand on a watch and it did nothing for me". This is amazing. Insightful. Well said. Watch collecting is about finding a piece that makes you correspond to it emotionally and not financially. This was worth the admission alone. Thanks guys.
Andrew won this! A bit of everything, a perfect balance between friendship, between sentiment, heritage and controversy! Makes his collection feel so unpredictable and fun! 👏👏
At the surface level - Andrew values sub-dialed strap monsters, Adrian values conventional simplicity, and George values himself
So true!! 😂😂
a little unkind, George values shifting the market towards his design style
@@shanghaiffggagreed, he’s a watch designer and he gets to design what he wants. I don’t think that’s arrogant, that’s just him liking what he likes, and that’s the point of a personal collection.
Easy win for Amdrew. Absolutely no surprise or intrigue in George and Adrian's collections.
When George talks about his watches, it sounds like an Academy Awards acceptance speech.
When Adrian talks about his watches, it sounds like a therapy session.
a Rolex cuck therapy session lol , Love Adrian and his photography but holy crap his Bias is horrible . His Watch Snobbery just screams " i have low Testosterone and my wife cheats on me with my friends "
lol and when Andrew speak about his watches it sounds like he is speaking about abusive relationships
Andrew wins this for me - just a proper collectors mindset I feel. Adrian's is sensible to a fault - there's not so much as a yellow G Shock just to even demonstrate a sliver of some nonconformity. George's collection is just George, and I think that's what's disappointed me most about it. I was expecting to see some crazy solid gold Tag Autavia or something like a marine chronometer that had been passed down through the family.
tbh very boring compared to george's collection.
It would have been very nice to see George's Navitimer. I think that was his first watch? And he also tore it apart soon after receiving it to understand how it worked. I think it says so much about him and foreshadowed what his relationship with watches would be like. That watch is probably the most interesting watch in all three of the guy's collections in terms of the story it tells.
i love that you basically called Adrian a sheep of a watch consumer 😂 i like him but youre not wrong he just likes rolex and thats boring just like the majority of general public
Andrew is thoughtful, Adrian is honest, George is a billionaire
hahaha agreed... GB's collection is epic. To make your own collection is totally Baller!
Nah! George's dad is the billionaire, George is one of four future Aires to the dynasty.
Haha, nailed it! 😂👍 Although I love the 3 combined - such great energy and connection!
Hahahaha of course with all those limited 25 limited pieces designed by Mr Bamford ! Now I know why one of the most beautiful, historic watch’s near to the Daytona is ugly! mr Banford destroyed the design of such an icon like the Heur Monaco into a TV 📺 Apple huge screen on wrist! Only show off love Adrian’s collection and the Longines Big eye rest of all watch’s rubbish specially that White GP and the Hublot 🤢
Adrian's collection is boring. Rolex, rolex and rolex. Dude needs to expand his horizons
My vote is for Andrew. His collection was the most diverse. George’s collection is just way too personalized with collaborations and honestly hard for me to resonate with. Adrian is the obviously a tool watch guy, as am I, but it is too centered on Rolex.
OMG! Thanks for the shout and im over the moon that you guys actually made this into an episode! Thank you 🙏🙏🙏 love the ep and that 15 watch on the table is an amazing collection to be honest! From Geoge i love the GP most(keeps begging him to make more of it 😂) , Andrew that hublot wins it for me simple as that, Adrian i love the Kermit and i think its correct you wear it more as it looks amazing on you man! Once again thank you guys 🙌🙌🙌
We may joke and call Adrians "captain boring" but his story about why he likes his explorer over his sub makes him truly captain class
Thanks Christopher 🙌🏻
@@BarkandJackUnderstatement is indeed underappreciated
Can't deny that Adrian has most exciting and diverse collection.
Is this taking the piss 🧐
4 Rolexes is not diverse ..
haha
Absolutely nailed it. A breathtaking collection
I’m 10 seconds in. George wins. 😂
Bell and Ross are very unique niche watches. You dont see them very often but when you do, its instantly recognizable.
The eccentric watch designer = 8/10
The sarcastic watch reporter = 7/10 ( I cannot get on board with the Hublot )
The Rolex employee = 4/10 ( 10/10 for predictability )
“Rolex Employee” 🤣
@@BarkandJackget me a better spot on that waitlist mate 😂
Hahaha nice! He really is such a rolie fanboy 🤣
I agree with Adrian. I like to wear watches for myself, if a person notices it, it can become inconvenient, due to price and social settings. Definitely love to disappear when it comes to watches
Andrew’s collection is the clear winner to me. So unique and different. That Hublot came out of nowhere and I respect that.
HANDS DOWN…. George has the best collection - unique & special. Adrian is a bit too Rolex. Andrew is not my cup of tea.
Hands down Adrian's collection just for the insane diversity not just of watch specs but of the timing of release, the colors, the wearablity everything!
Hahahahaha
Love this! Such diverse collecting parameters. Really something for everyone. Thanks for doing this!
Adrian won, as his collection seems the most thoughtful in what he likes and he really had to stretch to create that collection so they had to be meaningful. Andrew’s was the most eclectic, and interesting for other people to view. George’s was the biggest window into his personality since they were all products of his own imagination. But in the end, everyone’s collection is the best, because they are reflections of different likes, personalities, and willingness to stretch to achieve. So I think all three win because they all really seem to enjoy what they brought, and more importantly they wear/wore them (Adrian, get good insurance and wear the Sub again-it’s only a thing in the end). If you aren’t wearing a watch, you haven’t collected it, you’ve invested in it.
Adrian ...shows a non eclectic collection...stuck into a one trick pony mindset.
Collection review: In short, Andrew nailed it with his quite imaginative style (8.7/10)! George has a killer touch to his watches aka Branford personalisation which would be the dream of every collector. Great watches, great brands(9.2)! Τhis is another level and it’s unbeatable! Finally Adrian seems a Rolex Ad trying to be objective(6.2/10)! Sorry Adrian you are too boring but I love your videos and straps😂 P.S. You guys it’s incredible you didn’t present a single Omega or a Zenith😢
I know. Andrew’s talking about Rolex being essential to any good collection. Well, Omega and Zenith are more essential than Rolex imo.
Boring by name, boring by nature.
Know thyself ✅
@@BarkandJack Adrian, you appreciate the timeless elegance of classic tool watches! ✨️ At the same time your work is quite inspiring! keep it up! This is another way to say boring in your case 😀 Cheers from Genève 🇨🇭
@@AboutEffingTime Socrates, my favorite compatriot! 😁
I’m with Adrian on this one. My watches are for me. I don’t care what other people think, and I prefer not to attrach to much attention. The Explorer is a beautiful watch yet very simple. I love it
I stand by George´s one all the way, such creativity and story behind each piece.
George Collection is 4 out of 10. We were expecting more personal watches without the commercial interest. Something where there is not financial involvement, I don't see Collabs as part of a personal collection, the passion is undeniable but I would be more interested in non Bamford collabs. Adrian 5 out of 10, it's basically the same watch but at least he knows what he likes, it's consistant but lacks originality. Andrew is 7 out 10 for the diversity and for sharing watches that are more accessible to the rest of us, a lot more relatable. I won't mentioned the Hublot :). I was surprised that Andrew didn't share other watches from his collection such as the Bronze Tudor or that incredible Norquain. Overall it was very interesting to watch where I feel that for some, we actually know more about their personality vs others still trying to protect a certain privacy. Thanks for as great episode.
Some great thoughts and assessments. Nice work
For authenticity- I give them all an A. They seem very genuine to each person.
My favorite collection is Andrew’s.
Loved this one!!!
Almost exactly the kind of collections I expected to see. George with his amazing limited editions comprising a few of his fantastic Bamford’s, but not bringing out his real big boys(which I really admire about him). Adrian with his safe collection as he is Mr safe, but an amazing set of safe watches, this would appeal to safe watch collectors. Then Andrew with his semi flamboyant collection showing his varied and often flamboyant taste. I think your collections are direct reflections of your personalities. I think as time goes by collectors watches tend to reflect their personalities. 10 out of 10 for all three collections. I would gladly sport with pride and add to my collection any of the watches shown. Thanks again for a great show!!!!🎉
Adrian wins for me.
Explorer II Polar is the best of the bunch.
George’s GP is cool.
Andrew’s white ceramic is fun. I tried it skeptically and was surprised how fun it is.
Adrian, wear your Rootbeer more and don’t worry what people think.
George, love your Silverstein B&R.
Well done guys. 😊❤
🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻
The IWC on that strap looks the best
I put a watch on because I like to look at it. Not to appear or disappear or worry about others.
Well played
Great show. If I were to pick a collection to pick up of the table and keep, it would be Adrian’s. But it could easily be anyone’s collection. Andrew’s collection looks and feels most authentic to me as a reflection of an individual’s journey. Each piece is quirky and interesting and at first glance you know there is a story there. George’s collection is predictable based on his business. Would’ve been interested to see one or two pieces without a BWD connection.
yeh it gets old sometimes... Billionaires son incessantly peddling his own company and design genius. Just how fragile is that ego.
My thoughts, one collection is from someone that likes to create, another collection is from someone that is attracted to the moment and the final collection is from someone that ties his likes to his budget. These three collections kind of sum up the various collectors and watch enthusiasts out there. I think all the collections are fine because they suit a need and fulfill a void for the collector in particular.
I like this analysis. You sir, are a philosopher!
A brilliant mind at work here 🧠
Brilliant
totally agree. each collection has its relevance to the collector. this episode was full of personality!
Brilliant, very insightful analysis. Great episode, my (joint) favourite so far with the Marcus episode.
It’s interesting to learn how other collectors approach the hobby. What surprised me the most was that the oldest watches were the Explorers. I expected to see a couple of vintage watches and not just modern reissues. To me, those old watches that I’ve acquired are more important than most of my modern ones because I feel like I’m a curator of history which makes choosing my next purchase a struggle between practicality and sentiment.
Guys, that was a good episode! But what was interesting for me to learn is that I no longer base my collection on the influencers of the time, but have developed my own established taste. It was expensive, but now I can endure the annual collection reviews without buying impulses.
For me, Andrew has won (7 points) !
I love you guys.
I´m precisely at the same point in my journey.
All 3 are very good - the special memories attached to each is the real gold. Cheers
Andrew's collection is my favorite of the three, but it's a bit chronograph heavy. That said, the Longines is absolutely superb. That and a Casio for the beach is all you'd ever really need.
All three collections are great, because there are great people behind!
Shucks 💋
Thank you sir. 🙌🏻
George’s collection is a good representation of brands with his personal customization. 9 out of 10. Adrian gets a 2 for being Rolex centric. Andrew gets a 10 for individual choices.
That was a good way to kill an hour on this cold Sunday afternoon. It’s shame that George couldn’t generally see past his own commercial interests as he has an excellent grasp of the wider market but failed to expand. I would say that Andrew won by the width of one of Bark & Jack’s NATOs, with Adrian a close second.
I totally take on board your thoughts that George was only exhibiting his own work, but actually that's an incredible luxury to have. To take a model that you love and really personalise it to one's own tastes must be fabulous. I've had a play with the configurator on his website and getting something out that actually works is really hard, so full credit to him for being extremely good at what he does.
Loved this thanks! As a fledgling collector looking in on those who've been at it for years its great to see it all comes down to a reflection of personality and individuality.
Standouts for me were the IWC ( maybe camera angle and lighting) and the Hublot
Andrew won hands down, most diverse collection
I put on a watch that makes me smile, be it build quality or looks, but never to impress. Adrian’s comment about loving a watch because he can disappear is epic and spot on, it’s a relationship with the owner and wearer only that matters.
Overall, I would rate Andrew’s collection the most appealing but George’s Tag Heuer and GP are absolutely crazy !!!
This was great guys! Really loved each of them, and appreciated seeing each of your personalities come through in the collections! Would be honored to one day see one of our watches make it in there and hope you guys are doing great and have a wonderful holidays!
All the best,
Ben
Andrews’s for me. Can’t believe I didn’t see a single omega today!
Andrew. His words are from a point of wonder still-and connection to sentiment. Awash in watches these three have access where pedestrians like me can only piggy back on and love to be along. I’m a forever fan of Adrian and I mirror his collection ethos (only an Explorer and Sub) but didn’t know I needed other lanes to peer into via the other two. George shows me where the farther reaches are on the horizon from where I stand (again, closer to Adrian) and I so appreciate how he sees watches and what he wants to show up for him. Appreciate you guys.
A point to upvote: that moment in the end when Adrian is on the spot about selling Bark & Jack-it got so raw and very real. Love it. More of that kind of exchange and getting each other into an off balance spot. So real. Human and fun. It becomes less a presentation. Or a show. Bravo all around.
Adrian #1 - I too have a similar collection - a Hulk, a blue/black GMT, a green IWC XX and I do wish I could get my hands on a polar explorer
Each one is a 10/10. It's not a out brand diversity, nor about checking different boxes. You guys buy/create what you like and stand by it. That's all that matters for me to make a collection personal.... and perfect for you.
🙌
Adrian for me, hands down. I actually own the 16570 Polar which was his first big boy watch and I love it, and I sold my Sub 16610 to get it, absolutely no regrets. I think you should get rid of the Kermit and the Rootbeer Adrian and trade the 42mm Explorer II for another 16570 Polar, that one with the Explorer and the IWC would make a simple yet killer 3 watch collection. Well, maybe add a speedy in the future 😂
If I had to make a 5 watch collection of everything shown...
1. Chopard x Bamford Desert Racer
2. Hublot Unico
3. Heuer Monaco x Bamford
4. Studio Underd0g
5. Rolex Kermit.
Basically a perfect 5-watch collection IMO... with room for a Speedy to round out 6. Awesome collections Guys!
George's collection - Original
Adrian's collection - Classic
Andrew's collection - Contemporary
Well done Gents. Cheers from Montana. 👍⌚🥃
Everyone’s a winner 🏅
0: Shit watch, 1: Not for me, 2: Take my money, rating in the order as displayed:
George: 1+1+2+2+1 = 7
Adrian: 1+2+2+2+1 = 8
Andrew: 2+1+2+1+1 = 7
Big fan of you guys, appreciate you sharing your love of watches. Love from Istanbul. ❤️
I fell into the “upward mobility“ trap. I didn’t know what my ceiling was in a single watch until I shot through it… I’ve since learned.
Great video guys keep up the awesome work. Cheers!!
Andrew takes the win for me here, solid and diverse collection 9/10. Next George has a very cool and different set, but I think he should do it again with no collabs aloud. I’m sure he’s some super cool pieces tucked away that are maybe private to him and that he maybe doesn’t want to share and that’s totally, but I’m sure I’m not the only one that would love to see more of what he’s got! 8/10 for him. And finally Adrian, again solid “Rolex” collection which we all knew was coming, but man I wish he’d venture out more, 6/10. Awesome ep guys!
50 minutes of my Sunday time well spent, thanks. That GP is effing amazing.
Thanks for joining us mate.
In my book Andrew gets the W for this episode. Just in diversity alone he wins by miles. George always bringing interesting stuff to the forefront and I reckon Adrian doesn't need to sell bark and jack just yet as he seems to already be on a very sweet sponsorship deal with Rolex. Would've found it interesting to have the price tag of each collection to see what the value proposition is. I appreciate that you can admire a watch as an object in itself but it is interesting to have the price as it do find it informs my judgement as well. I just got my first watch (other that a Casio f-91w) which is a Serica California that I absolutely adore but I simply can't imagine spending over £2k on a watch in the next two years. I find it hard on personal level to be able to justify the spend but I think I may have caught the bug which I fear is going to be harsh on my future bank statements. Andrew, I really appreciate you backing Hublot, I also feel they get underserved hate. One of the coolest watches that I'd love to own one day is the Hodinkee limited edition Classic Fusion in titanium which is just
Pretty impressive watches but kinda wanna cry cause I did not see any Tudor on this table. It’s such a care free daily brand.
Who wins? The viewers! That was a really cool episode. George: 9.4/10 Adrian: 9.6/10 and Andrew 9.4/10. Back in May of 2018, I had a brief conversation with Adrian on IG about requesting either a Tudor GMT or Rolex Pepsi. I was grateful to have gotten the call for both watches soon after. There I was with TWO amazing watches. But one was out of place.... it was the Rolex. To this day, I still daily the Tudor GMT (I did upgrade the bracelet to the Tudor 5-link) and added other watches to the collection. But I keep going back to the tried and true (Tudor). I share this, not to gloat about getting an AD call, but to communicate that podcasts, reviews and engagements like this are great tools to help viewers understand the "why" behind collecting. Happy Holidays, Gents! PS: Adrian recommended I get the Tudor, he was right all along.
I love all the collections for what they mean to each of you. I learned to appreciate a couple of things I did not in the past and it made be reflect on my collection.
I'm running so late with AET. Brilliant episode again. All collections are amazing and I salute to the achievements on the table! 🙌 George proves again he is a genius and a rock star, Andrew is sophisticated in versatility and Adrian creates honest and independent content while wearing what he loves. But you guys just put a bug in my ear and I'd love to see a Bamford X Bark & Jack special edition! 😍😄
Rolex Yawnsplorer ll (26:46) has me dying😂😂😂
Adrain was a big influence for me getting my Explorer 124270. I absolutely love that watch. All of its beauty is in its simplicity. I’ve owned other Rolexes and none made me happy every time I looked at it. I got mine brand new this past June. And I’ve worn it every day since. This is my first Oyster bracelet and first EZ Link. And maybe the taper helps, but it’s the most comfortable bracelet to date. I recently tried on a Vacheron overseas. Very cool bracelet. Not as comfortable. I still might get it (it’s a touch big for my 6.5” wrist). Either way, great convo and really enjoyed this one.
George 10. Andrew 8.9 Captain boring 7.7. But love all 3 of you!
George 6/10 it’s very personal, a bit goofy but some cool pieces and stories.
Adrain 7/10 clean, simple style, you can’t go wrong with Rolex, but you need to mix it up. Not one single Chronograph?
Andrew 8/10 different styles, colors, brands and not just high dollar stuff. In my opinion it’s the most diverse and unique collection so it takes my vote for the “best”
Andrew’s collection is real. That’s a down to earth but still incredible and well-rounded.
It was such a cool episode. I think Andrew did the best job at showing a collection with some progression and connections. The Hublot was a bit of a misstep IMHO ; a tad vulgar😂. George had more of a showcase of cools projects; very cool indeed. Adrian’s collection demonstrates someone who would rather go for class and safe investment, than displaying adventure and self confidence (in the sense of a Rolex protecting you from being judged). I respect that.
George what's the movement in that bell and Ross Alain Silberstein watch? I have a similar collab watch from Louis Erard based on Selitta elabore and not really happy with the accuracy. Was wondering if yours is more accurate. Thnx.
I almost got excited thinking we would actually see George's collection. I mean come on! We all know it's 50+ watches so just show us already. His "5 watches" collection felt more like a marketing promo for Bamford. I get that he loves his own creations, but please show us ALL your other watches too.
Andrew gets the 10/10
Adrian 9.5/10
Good stuff guys!
Avigation big eye by Longines is my favorite from this whole episode. Looking into one now. Great collections from all of you.
Adrian wins. But I’m bias because I’m an Adrian fan and I’m here on this channel because of him… 😂
Haha. Thanks mate 🙌🏻
Thanks guys. Great entertainment as usual! Nów the ratings: Andrew 7/10. Just to many chrono’s for a 5 watch collection. All are pieces I wouldn’t say no to! Adrian 8/10. Very much a tool watch collection but just too many Rolex’s. George 9/10. Well balanced super funky collection. 1 chrono, 1 diver, 1 funky dress watch, 1 summer watch and the hard core tool watch. All 3 collections are awesome and suit each one of you. Thanks for sharing. ❤
Andrew for me definitely. Love his collection.
Adrian might be “boring”, but you can argue is a great “collection” also!!! ❤
The explorer 36 with the 20mm lug width is pure class. The Kermit should be worn selectively. He has the best explorer 2. The root beer sorta doesn’t fit but I wouldn’t sell it.
I’m a Rolex fan so I am all about Adrian’s collection. I want to have a big Rolex collection to pass to my kid and enjoy my whole life. I have 6 already and 7th coming this week. I love them and there is no explanation. The good news is historically always they have retained or increased in value so it’s safe money to park. So while flashy, hype, common, boring, or whatever ppl think about Rolex the truth is they are perfect watches, timeless, robust and classy at the same time and they will always be desired. I like them all. Bamfords brilliance to be able to work with brands and to have a story about every co creation is insane and something most of us will never be able to do, Andrews collection is great but as well but for me it’s Adrian’s :) GREAT video guys! Love watching your stuff. Makes me feel great to be a part of the watch collecting community
Andrew's collection is by far the most balanced and wearable everyday. Bamford's is a bit out there and the best watch geek's collection, but not everyday wearable. Adrian's is a very 'nice' collection, and not surprising he went with 4 Rolex! Overall I vote for Andrew's as it's the most balanced for everyday wear.
I was going to add my own comment then I read this and realised i've got nothing 'new' to add as I completely agree with you on all points!
Always good to watch About Effing Time. However, I got the sense that it was only Adrian who was honest and showed his real watch collection. The others, who own Patek and AP, were hiding their real collections and used this episode as a bit of a marketing opportunity.
Now that AET has ended I will continue to follow Adrian, but not the others.
Andrew wins this by a mile for me. Was expecting more from George tbh. Adrians is just boring, obv good but boring. Great for going for a hike and shooting B-rolls I guess.
In my taste, Andrew always wins. Though, he braver and leans forward more than I would.
I have been subscribed to you guys since the beginning of your channel and first of all, chapeau for you all having the stones to put it all out there. Watches are so personal, so to me there is no “winner”in this. I think the winner is good taste, which you all seem to have and is very rare in this space. I actually liked every watch you guys pulled out and your stories behind your purchases. I own a few that you have displayed myself. Great show. Cheers ✨
George has the most fun collection, Adrian has the most Rolex collection and Andrew has the most collection collection.
Love a good collection collection
1. Andrew
2. Adrian
3. George
Make no mistakes, they are all fantastic watches.
Like the production with four cameras btw…
I do my best. Actually there are 5
Each one of you have a great collection. I can see the passion you have for your collection. Hard to say who has the best.
Love your content, gents!
The highlight of this video for me was having my OCD triggered at 18:42 when the watches were being put on the table in what appeared to be a random manner - to watching it all come together at 43:15 and my mind calming down 😀 THANK YOU - otherwise I wouldn’t have been able to look past it and rate Andrew’s collection as the best 😜🤘🏼- mainly because it was diverse and was still “him”.
It’s also pretty cool to see your choices and then go “ah that makes sense” because of how the three of you bring your whole self forward in these videos and the podcast! It’s so easy for your watches to make sense because of who YOU are 😊
Appreciate you
Ah rating:
Andrew - 8/10 - purely because you could use a nice vintage dress as part of that collection as opposed to 4 chronographs 😊
Adrian - 6
George - 4 (Sorry GB.. the watches didn’t make me smile)
I put a watch on cause I love it. I don't care if anyone else does..
Go you 👌🏻
George - Self absorbed
Adrian - Fanboy
Andrew - Reasonable human being
I really enjoyed this video. Thank you 🙏
Love how Adrian stayed true to himself and did not "flashify" his curation, most would try to shake off a "Captain boring" tag, he just owns it:D screams strong character, and the other 2 of course as well, George being Bamford first and Andrew looking to do well and deliver on the expectation
Andrew's presentation did it for me. The diversity of the collection just feels right. Spot on.
1. Adrian
2. Andrew
3. George. George just sounds like a commercial for his own watches.
Thank you guys!! My Choice - Monaco, Explorer I, Longines BE, Roorbeer, Chopard ...Great conversation starter!
George: 2/10
Andrew: 5/10
Adrian: 9/10
George's collection felt like a self-centered Bamford promotion with pretentious collab name dropping. Where are the vintage watches if you love them so much? This just felt awkward and embarrassing.
Andrew's collection has something to please everybody. A little bit of fun, a little bit of class and a little bit of controversy. With having a little bit of everything I find the collection lacking personality and courage. What are you really into?
Adrian's collection is an honest personal collection. I don't like Rolex. However, I can appreciate a collection that has the most honest connection with the collector. I love how everything isn't perfect with this collection! It's got a movement that runs backwards, a watch that you don't dare to wear and a watch you're trying to replace. This is everybody's watch collection! A beautiful personal collection, bravo.
Ps. Thanks for the videos!
Thye're all great!
For me Andrew's collection takes the edge. Andy classy, and George is Art👏
Adrian's collection is "safe" but if I could own one of three collections it would be he his. I'd rather enjoy wearing my watches than trying to appease to other watch enthusiasts by having interesting obscure pieces.
hmmmmm safe is def the right word here. Just not safe on the streets
Only owning hype Rolex watches is arguably only trying to appeal to the hype. Certainly doesn’t scream ‘watch enthusiast’.
Andrew has the most unique and varied collection…. Two thumbs up. The other collections truly fit the owners, but his speaks to me.
This shows how personal and subjective watch collecting is. All collections are 10/10 for the owner. As objective collections on their own I prefer Andrews based on my personal taste, would pick Adrian's based on value, and would love to have my own customized versions of George's.
P.S. George, if you can get Calvin and Hobbes on a dial that would be truly impressive.
I don’t think every watch is one thing or the other. They are not absolute as a collection but absolute individually depending on occasion. A watch can help you stand out or be understated depending on place, function and purpose. Of course this is why collections grow over time with you as you experience various stages of life. For me, my collection tells my story over time. From college to being in the military as a single man to 30 years later as a husband, father and professional. Every watch is different just like the occasion and the individual that wears them. I really enjoyed this video. The selections shown were fantastic. It’s all about the stories they tell and the conversations they foster. Thank you.
I respect George, and I think his collection is super awesome. However, why doesn’t he ever showcase his other big pieces? I know he has a deep connection with the ones he designed and collaborated with, but he’s constantly nagging on hype pieces/brands and I’m pretty sure he has a fair share of time pieces from said brands. Is he ashamed of owning pieces from AP, Patek, Rolex etc? I also understand if he doesn’t want to show it off for security reasons, but it just doesn’t make sense to me when he calls Rolex and other big brands boring if he owns them too. Perhaps they don’t represent him? If that’s the case, why not sell them?
a fair observation. Hmmm Im sure he has his reasons.
It’s like choosing which one of my children I love the most. You all have great pieces. Thanks for sharing, great show as always.
My collection is closest to Adrian’s! Heck
🙌🏻
My favourites from all this in order.
1. George's Chopard Mille Miglia
2. George's Girard Peregaux Laureatto
3. Andrew's Hublot Big Bang
4. George's Franck Muller Jumping Hour
5. Adrian's Rolex Explorer 2
Adrian you didn't wanna wear a 10K watch but have an explorer 2 (about 10K USD and trades for higher) and a rootbeer which sells for well over 10k RRP? Time to wear the Kermit as part of the daily rotation again!
That story was from 2014-2015. I bought the Kermit for £5k, and it quickly grew in value.
And I do wear the Kermit a lot now. Still really enjoy this era of sub design.
@@BarkandJack love that it's back on the wrist! I definitely understand the hesitancy when this price craziness plus crime in London was on the rise. But I'm stoked you're getting solid wrist time in with it!
Andrew has the most versatility, even with that Hublot. Adrian resonates with one brand mostly, which isn't a bad thing (that explorer is my favourite out of all of the watches shown). George is definitely a taste tinkerer, whatever the platform he'll subdue it to his preference. Awesome show!