Palestine Divided | Al Jazeera World
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 27 сен 2024
- In 1947 when the UN General Assembly voted for the partition of the region between Jews and Palestinian Arabs the land was divided on a relatively equal measure.
But after the 1948 Arab-Israeli War only 22 percent of Palestinian land remained. When Israel was founded in 1948 it divided Palestinians between the Gaza Strip and the West Bank, creating separate territories with very little freedom of movement between the two.
In the Six-Day War of 1967, Israel occupied both territories, began building settlements and appeared to implement separate policies on each.
"The aim has always been to create different atmospheres and cultures; here and there," says Dr. Nashat al-Aqtash, a political analyst and academic.
The decades of separation have distanced the Palestinian communities living in the two territories who have developed distinct social and cultural identities.
None of the conflicts or peace talks over the decades, including the Oslo Accords of 1993, has succeeded in changing the map or this divide.
Filmmaker Asraf Mashhrawi examines the political, social and economic history of the split, analysing major events such as the Oslo Accords, the Fatah-Hamas conflict, the Israeli blockade of Gaza and the attacks of recent years - with interviews from Israeli experts like Haaretz journalist Amira Hass and lawyer Sari Bashi.
More from Al Jazeera World on:
RUclips - aje.io/aljazeer...
Facebook - / aljazeeraworld
Twitter - / aljazeera_world
Visit our website - www.aljazeera.c...
Subscribe to AJE on RUclips - aje.io/YTsubscribe
EVERYDAY LIFE FOR PALESTINIANS
What palestinians? I only know falafelstinians
Why do they destroy olive trees,fig trees,flags,cemeteries, homes,and children?
It is a symbel of aottoman colonialism
Wars have consequences for the defeated.
Especially for the side that started the war.
Freedom now to the Palestinian people Gaza Strip war peace ✊🏾👊🏾✌🏾
This is truly saddening. There are no winners here. Only lost lives, and broken souls (on both sides). No doubt there another side to this tragic story that is to be said from the perspective of the State of Israel. Having said this, given the horror of holocaust, one would think people of the State of Israel would be the first to empathize with, and reduce human suffering. I guess two forces drive human behavior. Fear and Empathy. Fear drives need for control and aggression. Empathy is the ability to see oneness even in difference, and leads to caring and love. I can only pray to God Almighty that there will be a day when the Israeli and Palestinian siblings are able to leave behind their fears and embrace their higher, more powerful, emotions of empathy, love, and caring.
I actually see Israel as a winner because if they are not stopped now the Palestinians will be expelled to the Sinai - after 70 years of inhumane living conditions - and the world will not even blink BECAUSE THAT WOULD BE ANTI-SEMITIC! - SO WHAT?!?!?!?!
@@TheKitbonn If you Zionists could expel all the Palestinians you would have done so, long ago. It was not possible, and now you have been reduced to living in an apartheid.
The refugee families will return, and reclaim all the land that was stolen from them.
@@ChristineQ-wr6iv If they could? Can you explain to me what stops them?
@@jakubklis6797 Disgrace, and possible expulsion from the international community, is all that prevents Israeli Jews from ethnically cleansing all of the Occupied Territories and Gaza. They would also take a huge hunk of Syria, Lebanon, Egypt and Jordan, if it were possible to do so.
@@ChristineQ-wr6iv It sure is apartheid. Year 2020.
And the Palestinians were left with 22% of the original UN-proposed territories. And even this only in theory, because one third of the West Bank is full of Jewish settlements...
There would be no such discussion with the Israelis if they lost the 6 day war.
Coulda, woulda, shoulda
@@fresatx what do u prefer
@haneen hammad then y did they started the war
@haneen hammad No, it was Jews from those countries not the official governments
who started the war? it was the arabs with their anti-semitism
And I love how they say Israel locked the Arabs behind a fence just to be mean -- without mentioning that the fence saved countless lives (both Jewish and Arab) from being blown up on buses and cafes.
nice lies
Let's be real, Israel has NEVER wanted a Palestinian State to exist, and without the people, the state can't exist. What you're seeing is colonialism, oppression and suppression of a specific people, an ethnic cleansing, a genocide, Illegal occupation. Must be a struggle for you to not be able to open you're eyes and see it. Two wrongs don't make it right, the Israelis don't have a right to become perpetrators of crimes against humanity! (I say Israelis because it's not just the Israeli gvt but it's also "settlers" doing it).
Maybe another more promising option would have been to end the illegal occupation and the take back the illegal settlements.
But it just happened that they preferred to build a wall around their illegal settlements and cut off another big part of Palestinian territory.
So, you’re right, they’re not locking the Palestinians behind fences and walls just to be mean.
They have perfectly rational reasons to do so: They want to keep Palestinian soil and they want to take more of while being safe of resistance.
Free Palestine, from Poland 🇵🇱
you mean free terrorism
Your country was once divided between Russia,Austria and Prussia in the 19th century.God Bless Poland!
Heh heh heh ! Chee you good at History. One learns new things everyday.
@@nathancoleman7235
@@nathancoleman7235Very good.
Love and prayers 🙏 from Pakistan
08:07
"In 1967, Israel attacked Egypt"
Wasn't the state of Israel threatened to be wiped off the map by Nasser? Israeli ships blocked in the straits of Tiran? and Syria digs to divert the streams that fed the sea of Galilee?
What would any country do in such a situation?
Get the whole story AJ
"None, with the possible exception of the 1948 War of Independence, were what Israelis call "wars of necessity." They were all wars of choice-or, worse, folly." - Zeev Maoz, IDF Chief for 3 of these wars.
You can't expect facts from a Qatari propoganda. They only tell the arab narrative
Let's be real, Israel has NEVER wanted a Palestinian State to exist, and without the people, the state can't exist but... I love how Israel forgets to mention Abdel Nasser closing the Straits of Tiran was because of Israeli aggression against Palestinians. I love how Israel forgets to mention Hamas is a creation of theirs to destroy any Palestinian liberation, to fight against Yasser Arafat and the PLO. The list could go on.
There is plenty enough land in this world for everybody to have a land, people are just too greedy to figure out a way to do it, human beings do not want peace, thats a fact, if they wanted peace there is ways to have it, going to war over peace just blows my mind.
What about the right to self defense? In case someone wants to take your land for example.
I think, most people want to live in peace. But most people want justice, too.
Jika masih ada petinggi petinggi palestina gila jabatan, harta , dan tahta maka tidak akan ada persatuan sejati diantara kekuatan kekuatan palestina. Jika diantara kalian masih dibutakan oleh dunia dan menjadi lupa bahwa di sisi Allah Lah tempat terbaik kembali. Maka jangan berharap palestina menjadi negara kuat apalagi berdaulat. Kalian menjadi lemah dan dijajah israel. Kembalilah jadi jati diri kalian dan bersatulah saudaraku. Tolong menolonglah dalam kebaikan, jangan saling menolong dalam kejahatan dan permusuhan.
Free palestine
You lack the truth. In 1947 there was no sovereign country called Palestine.
You are ignorant. Please keep quite if you do not know about the situation
Free to Palestine!!! Hellas 🇬🇷
respect from qayat
qatar
no
One sided documentary.
free free Palestine 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸
Abed Abed Free Kurdistan from arab colonists! Free Amazigh!! Free Coptes! Free Yezidi!! Free Israel, Judea and Samaria!! Arab colonists go back to Saudi Arabia!!!
Ponmyre
Free Palestine? I'll take two!
@@FirstnameLastname-pt5ss -free israel from arab hate
Free Palestine 🇵🇸 from the River to the Sea!
Free palestina
Free Kurdistan from arab colonists! Free Amazigh!! Free Coptes! Free Yezidi!! Free Israel, Judea and Samaria!! Arab colonists go back to Saudi Arabia!!!
palestine it's nothing
@@yanivsh4306
Israël = 💩 🤢🤢🤢🤢
No one in the world want you
@@mohaobba6695 stay mad ..i don't care about u
@@yanivsh4306
Israel it's nothing 😉
Watching now end of 2024 and life has only been worse and more difficult to the Palestinians 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
All Palestinian refugee families will return, and reclaim their land.
There will be One State, a country that includes Gaza, the West Bank and all of Israel.
Palestine Today keep dreaming. The Islamic Caliphate will fail once again.
Palestine Today God forbid
Palestine Today here come isis to kill hamas and fatah - what a shame. there wont be no gaza anymore.
mauritius69
IT IS ISRAEL THAT KILLS INNOCENT PEOPLE:
In the summer of 2014 Israel murdered over two thousand Palestinians in cold blood and so in reality Israel is the problem and not Iran, isis Hamas or Hezbolllah.
Neither Iran, Hezbollah, ISIS or Hamas pose a threat to Israel, they pose a threat to the Israeli occupation and oppression of Palestinians.
Read the palestine papers.
Abbas only wants half a million of these 3rd generation "refugees".
Gaza will go back to Egypt and Israel will be a Jewish country with freedom for all of her inhabitants❤😇
☮️❤️JUST WALL OFF JERUSELEM TO EVERYBODY AND TURN IT INTO A MUSEUM CITY, PUT KORAN,BIBLE AND TORAH ON STANDS INSIDE TELLING THREE DIFFERENT STORIES TO TOURISTS☮️❤️
I love how they leave out the fact that the Arab leaders refused the land for the 'palestinian' arabs and 5 Arab armies attacked israel. Arabs lost, jews won, but Arabs expect to have this land anyway. BTW Jordan was also part of "the brittish mandate of palestine" and is 70% of the land mass, mostly 'palestinian' arabs live there, jews were ethnically cleaned.
Some 80% of the territory of Palestine is currently occupied by Jordan. Jordan IS Palestine! Always was, too.
And I love how they say Israel locked the Arabs behind a fence just to be mean -- without mentioning that the fence saved countless lives (both Jewish and Arab) from being blown up on buses and cafes.
How old are you. You know nothing about Palestine. Israel started the war with their Arab neighbors. Don't speak unless you can add to the conversation. No one has time for "well I heard". Read a book! Research!
Would you be ok with a group of people coming into your home and saying this is their home and to get out unless you want them to end you and your entire bloodline? Then finding you after the fact and offering to give you back part of your home while living in your home with you.
Partial offering seldom prevails..
General assembly number 181 was clearly rejected by the Arabs. The 1947 petition plan was accepted by the Jews and rejected by the Arabs. After the 1947 petition plan was accepted by the Jews. The Arabs immediately went to war. In 1948 the Arabs joined with their 1:49 from five Arab countries, and attacked Israel, the Arabs were defeated they lost the war. The Arabs after the Oslo accords continually rejected peace offers in 2000, 2001 the Clinton parameters as well as in 2008. The Arabs should know you reap what you sow.
mistakes can be made by some and not all is to be perfect or agreed by all. some leaders are imposed
God bless you for saying the truth
Y'all always say "well the Arabs shouldn't have rejected the 1947 plan" blah, blah, blah. Do you know anything about those plans? Would you want to give up over half of your house so a family of 3 can take over while you and your family of 5 live in the smaller section?
😂😂 well that’s not wat natanyahu said the man never had any intentions for a Palestinian state he said it in his own words 10 days ago my friend
A documentary made Al jazeera would require you to be awaken and on alert to not be deceived.
Bias information, one sided against Israel. That is the land of Judea since king David and Salomons time. There is no " country or state of Palestine".
Thet video is not true the most of the things in there are lies
Said right bro 👌
Zionists always deny the truth, lidor_a_gever
And, you know it.
@@lavnyasharma7871 *Here are some facts relating to the Arab ownership of Palestinian land* from ‘The Birth of Israel’ by Simha Flapan, who from 1954 to 1981 was National Secretary of Israel’s MAPAM party.
The Israel Absentees’ Property Law of 1950 stated that any Arabs who left their place of residence between Nov ‘47 and Sept ’48, [this does not mean they actually crossed any borders], were declared absentees and their property subject to *appropriation* by the [Israeli] Custodian of Absentees Property.
A detailed account was prepared by Joseph Schechtman... _“The amount of this property,”_ he wrote in 1952, is _“very considerable”: 2,990,000 dunams (739,750 acres) of formerly Arab owned land, including olive and orange groves, vineyards, citrus orchards, and assorted tree gardens, became totally _*_deserted?_* (Note: deserted only because those who attempted to return to their land and homes were killed) _... 2,070,270 dunams were of good quality, 136,530 of medium quality and 751,730 dunams were of poor soil. In addition, 73,000 dwelling rooms in _*_abandoned?_*_ Arab houses and 7,800 shops, workshops and storerooms became ownerless in towns and villages._
*Bank accounts estimated to total up to 5 million Palestinian pounds and left in Arab and non-Arab banks were frozen by the Israel government. All of this Arab absentee property, movable and immovable, was entrusted to an official “custodian".*
Schechtman went on to detail how the property was utilized:
_It is difficult to overestimate the tremendous role this abandoned Arab property has played in the settlement of 100’s of 1000’s of Jewish immigrants who have reached Israel since the proclamation of the state in May 1948. 47 new rural settlements established on the sites of abandoned Arab villages absorbed 25,255 new immigrants...over 1 million dunams leased by the custodian of Jewish settlements and individual farmers for the raising of grain crops._
Large tracts of land belonging to Arab absentees have also been leased to Jewish settlers, old and new, for the raising of vegetables. In the south alone, 15,000 dunams of vineyards and fruit trees have been leased to co-operative settlements; a similar area has been rented...This has saved the Jewish Agency and the government millions of dollars.
Abandoned Arab dwellings in towns have also not remained empty. By the end of July 1948, 170,000 people, notably new immigrants and ex-soldiers, in addition to about 40,000 former tenants...have been housed in premises under the custodian’s control; and 7,000 shops, workshops, and stores were sublet to new arrivals. The existence of these Arab houses - vacant and ready for occupation - has to a large extent, solved the greatest immediate problem which faced the Israeli authorities in the absorption of immigrants.
[details come from Joseph Schechtman’s book, The Arab Refugee Problem (New York, 1952) pp.95-96, 100-101, reprinted in Flapan’s book pp107-8.]
@@ChristineQ-wr6iv no they dont and i knew they dont you dont need to lie and at list check if what you saying is true before you make yourself look damb
@@ChristineQ-wr6iv do you evan know what a zionist is?
no body can take away Palestine from Israel
with love from India
like some one took your mother and you don't want her back? lol
Land always known as Palestine : what a comedy
Historically land is known as israel, Judea, kingdom of Judah, kingdom of Israel. Never was the kingdom of Palestine
zionist tyrants have been cursed by Almighty Allah (swt)
these cursed doomed people are not allowed on those
land's they have always been hypocrites who broke every
covenant they made with Almighty Allah (swt)......................
@@peacemaker2988 i dont think. you should bet money on that habibi... palestine is taken over
@@peacemaker2988 you don't live up to your name do you, "peace maker" ?
Palestine was, is and will be forever.. Long live Palestine..
Who were the news asking their God about,....
When they tell us in the bible, .....
Were giants that they had to defeat in order to access their land, during their exodus !!!
Were there not palestinians in what they clearly called palestine themselves !!!!!??????
This land not occupy Israel but nato and America, if nato did not support israel then Palestine
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
Well you started a war that you couldn't win. That's too bad.
M Czenk
Palestine will be Free from the river to the sea 🇵🇸
...and not to forget the internal divide of the war of 2007 and their victims.
Thanks a lot, British Government and Balfour Declaration!
Britain should be ashamed of that declaration
Right, British or Jewish really same.
They really kept apostasy to God,
and shed innocent blood with history.
You lost 3 wars!
Not true.
The land wasn’t always known as Palestine.
The Romans named the land Palestine in 135AD.
The land consists of both Palestinian Jews and Palestinian Arabs.
I'd rather live under Israeli control than under Syrian, Egyptian, Lebanese, Iraqi, Iranian or Jordanian rule any day.
phtellq8
Palestine will be Free from the river to the sea 🇵🇸
‘Palestine had always been one terrorist’…. That is incorrect. The history of that land has changed hands multiple times.
“O ye that judge with fairness! If this Cause is to be denied then what other cause in this world can be vindicated or deemed worthy of acceptance?”
[Baha'u'llah (The promised one of all ages), Tablets of Baha'u'llah, p. 130]
Anyone know who the Palestinians were before British got involved? Were they part of the Ottoman Empire that sided with Hitler?
I would point out that when the individual was talking about the map at the time of the partition....the second that the partition went into effect, Israel was attacked on all sides by a combined Arab Army to include the Palestinians. Israel, with little outside assistance won that war and changed the map to what it is today.
Tell them,my brother. They think people are fools. They like to always play the victim.
Any country would not accept immigrants taking over slice of their land
Any nation with extremist Islam as its growing religion cannot live in peace. Demand of separate nation is common once they grow in numbers. Such incidents will be common in Europe and many other western countries where radical Islam is growing at amazing rate due to high birth rate.
It's a problem in Europe I live in the UK a lot will not integrate.
Iran should give them a land to create their own state. And definitely not call it Palestine because theses Arabs have nothing to do with the Palestinians e little Christian town. Even the name palestni is not an Arabic name which says it all.
@hasinajassat9600 It's correct .
And now its 2021
The land NOT always known as 'palestine.'
palestine was a word the Romans used to insult Israel some 2,000 years ago.
Today, the same and is known as it has ALWAYS been known as Israel.
Joel 3:4 "Yea, and what have ye to do with me, O Tyre, and Zidon, and all the coasts of Palestine? will ye render me a recompence? " (Long before the Romans).
Lies
1mommas
Palestine will be Free from the river to the sea 🇵🇸
"always known" since 1948 🤣what a shmekele
I guess all the mess is based on the failed separation plan in 1948.
Maybe the British shouldn't leave so quickly. They and the UN had to fulfill this plan. Some had to move, but their would have been a Palestine State since than.
The plan tryed to follow the settlements of jews and Palestinians at that time.
Now there is occupation and lost of land every day.
To anyone who thinks this is ok I hope your family goes through the same situation. Israel needs to be democratic for all
Evan Salmon Which is why there are numerous muslim arabs sitting in the Knesset.
noone is free in this World until Palestine not freeeee!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
like anyone cares about them...lol
In the name of god
Palestine will win whatever this consequence amin
22:54.... "They want to see the other part of Palestine." Ha ha ha !
Where is Judea ?? Jews want to see that .
In one way or another we all know Israel is going to end it's fact Jews know it.
And Palestaians will take it back from river to the sea
Lol keep dreaming. Hail Israel 🇮🇱
I hope so 😍😍
tom johnson,israel is gods prophecy from the sea to euphrat river,u are false deceiver
@@makedonistoi God prophecy??
Since when we committing with God willing or instructions ??
Weather it's God's willing or not! I think God telling us not to kick them out or shooting people or raped women or put children in jail or demolishing houses ...
@@haneenkhaleel7954 -that is because arab islam took the holy land,ya that right,if they stayed in arabia,these thing dont happen now,u are living on jewish lands,in torah,in bible,in quran say jewish land.i dont understand why u fail to see the light of truth
Al Jazeera newspaper makes good toilet paper.
fucpalsitine I prefer using the paper from the fantasy book written by a pedophile named Muhammed.
fucpalsitine
Palestine will be Free from the river to the sea 🇵🇸
KILLER SLAYER 😂 Palestine was never free (romans, ottomans, british, etc.) Let's keep this tradition 🇮🇱
CaVau
Hhhhh nice joke 👍🏻
KILLER SLAYER It's funny because it's true.
All they need is 6 days 😂😂
Yeah, when the enemy is unprepared - dishonest as always
@@TheKitbonn Arabs nations attacked first , Israel only defended themselves, of course there lying now , crying babies.
@@roldandelcid6186 actually, Egypt lost because cowardly Israel blew up they equipment before they got to use it.
@@sufimasfi aaaaaah okayyyyyy
@@sufimasfi hahaha that's called preventing. Not coward. Middle East is true coward. Attacking a small country like Israel. God bless Israel was never defeated
👍😭🌿🌿☘🍀
Cut it in half with free movement and enterprise
Palestin divided into Gaza and West bank they are living separate into two parts but Palestin Arab still living in Israel state they are citizenship of Israel country there's no Palestinian state because they don't want to independent in 1948 in two states Arab and Jews but to condemned Jews and taking war against Israel
These documentaries never state that the 1948 'arab Israeli war' was started by arabs. From the beginning, they would not accept a Jewish state, tried by violence to eradicate the Jews and lost. They lost that and the six day war; that's why they are in the position they are in. No one came in and simply displaced them, they lost wars...it's happened countless times to countless people in the history of the world. I will never understand why this situation is considered any different.
Did you hear about the Palestinian entrepreneurs when the Palestinian youth went to throw stones they learned and started startups? me neither
But now it is forbidden for Israel to kill children, enter Muslim women, and steal computers from young men
Was that supposed to be funny?
correction about the claim that there was always a Palestine, there is no recollection in history of a Palestinian state/people/nation, there are recollections of the place and its inhabitants being called Palestinian since the roman days, before the British the region was under ottoman rule with the Israel/Palestine or whatever you wish to call it being a sort of international zone between the Arab nations at the time.
Officially there was never a Palestinian state or a group of people named thusly since the Romans named the inhabitants of the area as such with no distinction between Jews, Macaroons Iranians Egyptians and whatever, this is a sly tactic trying to say that the Palestinian people are a distinct group here when in fact you talk about ambitious Arab groups from the likes of Iran and Jordan mostly with the mission to subjugate the land under Qatars holy doctrine per their religion.
and before you take me out of context after reading this im not saying that the people who call them selves palatinates should be kicked out or have no rights to the land, what I am saying however is that instead of misleading us who we should talk to we should address the problem from it source(which mostly happened because of the British and USSR)
Achtung woof wrong
its about HATE. Arabs all over palestine and the world harbour a deep hatred for Jews. this is because they see them as less humans. it has been so since prophet mohammed labeled them so. infidels, kafir because they do not ascribe to muslim faith. thats where it all started and being that they are cousins the devide has been from long. Read history. its not a political war, its a religious war, a spiritual war. sibling rivalry.
The Arabs - descendants of Ishmael have been at war with Jews descendants of Isaac who are both sons of Abraham/Ibrahim. one being the child of promise (Isaac) and the other a child (Ishmael) born of a maidservant of Abraham.
These two have been at war, Ishmael aggresively and angrily trying to wipe off Isaac's generation from the face of the earth because he was not happy his father did not bless Him or accord him the first born's blessings instead they were given to Isaac.
so many t&c to move in their own land....what nonsense is this😡😠i really dont like how that israeli politician said about hammer on the head, so rude after took palestinian land still can said it. that amira also....😵 feel like to slap her😡😠Ya Allah please give this Palestine land to whom its belong. so painful & break my heart to see this aamiin aamiin aamiin ya mujib🇲🇾❤🇵🇸
Hamas wants special attention,the barbaric behavour makes this impossible.I lived and worked in a country where our death with have been celebrated.I know this type of war,i set the bar very high.I look at your channel and i have no emotion to share.
Why did so much go wrong when Israel withdrew in 2005? Wasn’t that the beginning of something good?
This documentary is really full of lies.
I feel sad for this Dad about his documents. So much restrictions by the Israeli authorities resulting in separating families. Gaza and West Bank are in one territory...but why strict imposition of separate permits.?
Where's Palestine? Who are they? A bunch of radical stateless masses? If they're unwanted by their Arab brethrens, we can offer them a State for their own.. They can come inhabit the Indian Island of North Sentinel Island, in the Bay of Bengal. Its free of cost... Come migrate..
Go read an anbias facts not a composition of opinion. There's a lot of information missing. Its very comfortable to start on one point in time and not to mention what happened before. Although what was said is true and sad but there's more to this never ending stoy.
long live lsreal we love you and pray for you. May God bless lsreal forever...you got our support in Africa.
lies from the start to the finish - the land was not allways called palestine - in fact palestine as a territorial district was a british / leage of nations creation , prior to WW1 it was devided between different Turkish regions . The arab state in Palestine according to the UN 1947 plan was not impossible all it needed was arab approval and today there would be an arab palestine state in 45 % of the land - the arabs thought they could get it all though war and they lost .
When compromises and peace are rejected by the Palestinian leaders, there won't be peace or compromises. Then you get walls and things like that.
If this make you feel good , why not , do y see the old Roman map, it’s clearly saying Palestine ( and this more then 2000 years ago)
I see you even disagree with the Roman
@@اميرابداح-خ3ه It was called Palestine by the Romans as a punishment after the Jews of Judea (mind that name!) and Galilea stood up against the Jews. An expert like you should know that.
Bert NL yah ok ,
@@اميرابداح-خ3ه its not about feelings and I only said that the name was not used all the time not that it was never used at all .
What astounds me is where is all the Arab oil rich countries accountability in all of this, the least they can do is assimilate their peoples. Israel absorbed its people fleeing persecution and certain death from Muslim Arab countries leaving their property, buisness of communities 1000,s of years old. Please practice Muslim charity and look after your own people.why doesn't Lebanon , Syria , Jordan , Egypt , Saudi Arabia, etc take in the Palestinian refugee and make them citizens.
Why don't the Palestinians accept that they have lost the war to Israel? At least, they should admit that wars have consequences
U a fool
Hamas took Palestine 70 years back .What good will come out in the next 70 years ? Netanyahu and now Bennet says there will never be a two state solution .What do the Palestinians want ? One state peace and harmony or two state conflict .Let the people decide
Hamas took Gaza(not all Palestine) in 2006,not 70 years ago
Gaza has a border with Egypt..why cant they open with gazans atleast ...we blame Israel but Egypt can open border with Gaza...
Japheth barasa Egypt has widened its security trench to 1km because the terrorists of Hamas were smuggling weapons through Egypt and destabilising the region. Israel closed its boarder with Gaza for the same reasons as the Egyptian.
@@DavidHaTzadik they cant blame anyone for the blockade..if both egypt and Israel impose it to keep terror out..until they change the tactics the blockade will continue I think
Japheth barasa Exactly. They need to get rid of Hamas and start normalizing their relationship to Israel.
Is Israel is form from refugee?
It mean you occupied the Palestinian land 😄😄😄
According to your own characters you Palestine divides yourself
Palestine will be Free from the river to the sea 🇵🇸
gods wish for israel is from the sea to euphrat river,why lie u deceiver,like ur prophet
makedonistoi
Your god is a real e-state agent, my god is the creator of this universe
@@asymptotesconverge3426 -u however are a hater of the only jewish natioin on world,congrats
@@asymptotesconverge3426 -are u fascist,christianfascist or islamofascist,curious to know who i dealing with
makedonistoi
Free Palestinian
I was struggling before the 8 minute mark, but when the English guy said in 1967 that Israel attacked Syria, Egypt and Jordan I had to stop watching this trash.
Crime and sadness. Bad karma.
WHAT...does sides mean ..? ..ask yourself. ...who made this so....not...you.? ?
You went to war 3 times. You lost!
Israel attacked?
Why don't all of the Palestian Arabs move to the West Bank, and Isreal gets Gaza, and the Isrealis pull out of the West Bank?
No this won't be done because of Jordan river in West bank.where 45%of water for israel.
I don't know why that guy is bent on yahoo, he should get gmail it works better
35:25 - "In August 2005, Israel withdrew unilaterally from the Gaza Strip, this signified an abandonment of both the peace process and any notion of a future Palestinian state." Say what??! I guess Al Jazeera English isn't that different from Al Jazeera Arabic after all...
you are a moron, because the sentence continues like this "in the eyes of the Palestinian people who saw this as a foundation shakeup", finish it stop being a crafty you know what you are.
And you are a troll.
That Alex Kal is both a troll and a homophobe.
The State of Israel celebrated this year its' 73rd birthday.
The kingdom of Israel lasted 328 years (1050 - 722 BCE).
The Kingdom of Judah lasted another 136 years after the Kingdom of Israel,
which was then followed by the self-governed Yehud Medinata (539-332 BCE),
Hasmonean Kingdom (140-37 BCE) and Herodian Kingdom (37 BCE - 70 CE).
overall the region has been under Jewish rule for more than 800 years (900 if you count in modern day Israel).
the Arabs controlled the region between 636-1099 CE, a total of 463 years.
This Land is first and foremost Jewish.
There are 50 Muslim states and 21 Arab states but only one Jewish state.
Others are welcome to stay as long as they respect that.
A land cannot be religious, a race or a ethno-religious thing.
The conflict is about international law, and not superstitions.
Aren't the Palestinians actually crossing into a different country when they enter Israel? If there are two states then there are borders. Did no one on the Palestinian side think of this during negotiations?
The arabs lays as they have made their bed, and they are not very good at making their bed!
Why are the Palestinian not migrating to Syria and Jordan ?
JC C Because they are palestinans.Neither syrians nor jordanians.Just like asking french people;why don't you guys go to germany or italy.Think for yourself.
Ashique Basheer
No, many of the Palestinians aren’t from Palestine. Many migrated from Syria,Ottoman Iraq, Balkans....how do I prove it?? Many “Palestinians” still have Syrian, Egyptian surnames!
all these Arab states won't accept that Israel exist, therefore - if they will let Palestinians in - it will count as if they are accepting Israel as a country. If that makes sense
Because they prefer the israeli living conditions instead of the islamist ridden countries.
Excuse me for being ignorant on this subject. So I may ask stupid questions. So as I see it, Gaza being part of Egypt, and the West Bank being part of Jordan, Israel refuses to link both Gaza and the West Bank because of govt. differences between Egypt/Israel and Jordan/Israel?
If Israel wanted to link Gaza and the West Bank via a tunnel or an airport, does Israel fear of their country being split into two different states, such as Gaza and the West Bank are now?
I thought this video helped share some understanding of the situation there. But then I read many of the comments, and it only made me more confused.
Again excuse me for my ignorance on this topic, but will read any replies from both sides without judgement. Thank you.
Al jazeera is Qatari propaganda and therefore there audiences is bias. Me and you are here to see an alternative perspective
There is NO palestine
1mommas there is no israel 😂😂
There is NOOO israel. Israhell
Pissrael
There’s 2.
My grandpa is old than israel lol
Israël = 🤢💩
I had similary isolation even worst. Mine Sefardic Mother barriers me contact with mine Father more than four years. Because as she said she musts helps to minę sefardic stepbrother obtained hole properties of mine father.Such sneaky sefardic defrauds are common even against Aschenazic Jews. So mine father is sneaky cheated supported to him biological not own sefardic son by organisating defrauds of money officially institutions. And I am isolated and kicked out even from mine home country.
God Bless Israel. Don't let your enemy destroy you.
Let them destroy themselves.
Love, from the Philippines.
F**k you zionist
There is a lot more conversation going on then what is put into English. Makes you wonder what they are hiding
They should just split Israel the southern region goes to Palestine while the north goes to Israel and all this bullshit will stop
jake mapping Why don't we split usa instead? please, stop it...
Squib thats why
squib? i'm not american, i don't know slangs..
ok
so...squib?
"Always known as Palestine?" Really? It was named Palestine by the Romans. It was first called JUDEA - the land of the JEWS. If you are going to call Judea "Palestine" now, you should also call Jerusalem "Aelia Capitolina" which was the name given to Jerusalem when the name "Palestine" was given to Judea.
The bottom line is that Jews and Arabs are really brothers. The fact that European powers and Islam made up an issue to divide and control them, and that gullible Arabs and Jews believe them is just PATHETIC !!!
There should be one State. It should have equal identity for Arabs and Jews. It will be that way or there will continue to be war. Let the Israelis and Palestinians choose for themselves whether they want to live in peace and prosperity under a common flag or perish as sadly misguided enemies.
Bryan Shane that will never happen cuz zionists r racist cunts...
***** IDF is nothing if not for the american weapons and technology, that with time they learned to manage and replicate.
wownouser no country can share with Islam. Islam and western style democracy cannot co-exist
Bryan Shane nice try but the truth is Islam cannot co-exist with others. They will take over just as they have done. 56 countries is enough for them.
wownouser it is obvious to some of us that Pals are only interested in victory just as their prophet commanded. Too bad the media is too politically correct to see the obvious. (except fox news)
Go too Jordan
jordan doesnt want them, egypt also. israel wanted to give gaza to egypt after the war in 1967, they said no thx. these are the palestinians "brothers"
The number of lies and deceit in this video is mind blowing! Palestine included Jordan and the majority of the Arabs (Palestinian) lived in Jordan.
the palestinians have rejected several partitions that had given them huge swaths of land. Israel had accepted instead Arab world sought to fight israel off. they lost and Israel took over the entire land. thats how the lands we have today were acquired. through conquest. so dont be cry babies
🇮🇱🇮🇳... always with Israel..
how I wish I could debate with Amira Hass on Palestinian issue . . . there's nothing/nobody to be blame of the fate of the Palestinian people but their own politics/narratives . . . they have never learn . . . and will NEVER learn . . .
A land always calle palestine??? Are you sure?
Yes. Only hasbarah can make you believe otherwise.
It's very odd that Al Jazeera omitted the attacks on Israeli buses and shops that killed many innocent people. Islam has tried numerous times to end Israel to no avail but keep hoping for a different result. I just don't get it, build up your areas and stop waging war, get an economy and a national currency.
"None, with the possible exception of the 1948 War of Independence, were what Israelis call "wars of necessity." They were all wars of choice-or, worse, folly." - Zeev Maoz
@@mortef yom kipur war also was not started by israel so check your resources