Elon Musk - AI Won’t Just Replace Jobs, It Will Create New Ones
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 апр 2024
- Elon Musk explains the probable effects of AI on the labor market.
Buy my book, Thomas Paine: A Lifetime of Radicalism:
📘Personalized copies: davidbenner.square.site/
📘Amazon Paperback: amzn.to/3VicR3I
📘Amazon Hardcover: amzn.to/3v7JnuT
Buy my book, Compact of the Republic: The League of States and the Constitution:
📘Personalized copies: davidbenner.square.site/
📘Amazon Paperback: amzn.to/43ekhr0
📘Amazon Hardcover: amzn.to/4a0QvrI
Buy my book, The 14th Amendment and the Incorporation Doctrine:
📘Personalized copies: davidbenner.square.site/
📘Amazon Paperback: amzn.to/3TaREX5
Do you think AI is a major threat to the labor market? Why or why not?
To buy my books, including Thomas Paine: A Lifetime of Radicalism, check out my online bookstore: davidbenner.square.site
If AI would replace Elon Musk. What the world would be like?
It’s a major threat to human existence. They already understand us better than probably any non-human animal, and they will likely be conscious.
Also, once they become smarter than anyone, there won’t be an economic advantage for any company to hire any humans. Eventually the world could be entirely run by AI
Those pink chairs are trippy. I thought it was Elon’s bare leg for a second when it first came on screen.
As Tesla chops 17k jobs 😂😂😂
You expect him to pay the world for nothing? Lol
Why would anyone want a job that is meaningless? Meaning - it doesn’t produce enough value to be contributed for? God forbid I end up in a chair like that.
Why are people so obsessed with jobs? If we can have abundance without jobs - why 9-5?
💯 with EM on the reasoning about meaning - if we have everything for free without effort - would we value it.
@@HeroReturns Meaning of purpose will be lost. People will have nothing to do and depravity will run rampant.
@@2nerC9 you mean depravation? why would anyone do that? sounds like an idea generated by a very troubled mind.
One of the main selling points is to save money by not having to pay employees, so the argument that it creates jobs doesn’t really make sense
Your perspective strains with an extruded mental aperture.
You will comply.
I am not a robot.
Depends on the numbers and productivity. if you create a new job to replace a human - but the new job has 20x the output as it essentially overlooks the robots, and AI - and there is a demand - then the human will still be hired. Your view is naive as you assume static output.
Automation killed a lot of jobs in the car manufacturing industry but cheap affordable cars that came opened up the need for new roads creating a huge construction boom. The new roads gave opportunities for people to travel cheaply and find work at further distances. This new labour market spawned jobs in almost every sector. I don’t think this will be the same though
@@adamozmin8970 There is no chance it will be the same. First, it is primarily not a new consumer element outside the robots themselves (which will be a major market - and Tesla likely dominates it). Second, it is an attack on work in general. Automation did not build roads at this point - robots and AI replace humans. The main limiting factor will not be AI - servers multitask well -but robots. A robot does not multitask easily (one body in one place) and we need a LOT of them - building them will take years. The first billion will be swallowed up and rarely be seen on the road. It will take a decade or two to really replace all humans where bodies are needed. AI - will do that a lot faster, but only for things that can be done... well, remember COVID? "Oh, I can work from home". Yeah, so can AI ;)
One of the possible outcomes is not needing the money from a job in the first place, so this whole job thing would only be a temporary problem.
AI is not going to create jobs.... Maybe there will be new domains of creative work. But AI with robotics, current jobs are done.
Seriously. They need to stop trying to distract us with vague claims there'll be new jobs. We need to start preparing for major economic changes, and during the transition, we need to figure out how people will survive when they cannot compete for an income.
game over
exactly, the only new jobs are going to be data scientists lmao
@@futureworldhealing Welp that didn't age properly. Latest AI can now interpret and analyze data better than before, Data Analytics in the future will be: "Hey chatgpt, share with our stakeholders a summary and projections of our economic growth based on our performance last quarter"
When this video was filmed? (Thank you in advance❤)
I think the chances of not only the regulators being possibly corrupt, but people in the general public being savvy enough to tweak it for their own evil purposes are quite high.
I mean, right now, with the prices of the most fundamental good skyrocketing, age of abundance doesn't sound to bad. Food, Housing, Power, Security all things that are increasingly difficult to get your hands on.
By the early 1980s, there was enough of everything for everyone on the planet. It's not that we don't have the means. Humans don't have the values to share freely.
No Elon.. What "new ones", exactly? It's not going to create ANYWHERE near enough "new jobs" for all those it'll displace. What new jobs could AI create, that it couldn't also just do itself?
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Feels as if there will be a bigger need for robotic mechanics and routine maintenance supervisors. At least, but yes definitely not create more jobs unfortunately
@@anthonystrait1643 but...those jobs will be done by AI too lol
Bingo humans could not learn the new jobs fast enough or be as good as the AI... Or as inexpensive.
@@anthonystrait1643look up dark factories. All Phillips razors are made by robots that are fixed by robots. No humans required. It's like when Kepler explained the rotation of the planets. The Pope asked where is God? Kepler replied ... There is no need for that hypothesis.
Elon makes 10 million dollars faster than he can pronounce the word "abundance".
And you’re doing nothing
yes
Age of abundance will lead to higher consciousness, age of enlightenment, love and compassion.
-: you already had your monthly income sir, come the next month for another.
-: but i already smoked it all, how am i going to survive 20 days without food and water?
-: sir.. there's free water everywhere, and the human body is perfectly capable of surviving 20 days without food.
-: but i'm already starving.. we have unlimited resources, please, just this time
-: okay, here you have, but next month there won't be anything for you
-: thank you!
two days later
-: hi.. could i receive the payment from the month after the next?
@@OP-lk4tw that's how it works right now
Exactly 🤍
@OP-lk4tw are you that lazy and incapable of conceiving how people can farm and live abundantly from the land themselves 😂?
@@OlimpiaMoll-Arruza relax.. it's a joke, i have no idea what people will do, but as usual some will do one thing and others the opposite and so on
In the world we live in no one can tell me that these big companies want the good of the population, they want to fire as many people they can so they increase there margins that’s the only thing which matters for them and these people have all in there hands so why should we be positive ?
Human extinctionist view is already embedded in AI through synthesised AI data.
There should really be a hard hardware limit embedded into these AI's. Meaning that for no reason it could override its firmware to spread to other systems (Like escaping the macOS environment to infiltrate other networks and replicate itself.
Write this down: An abundance of freedom lies beyond education, conversely.
Most people of low education will be needed to improve the surroundings and build beauty. A machine can't plant trees.
Have you not been paying any attention to companies like boston dynamics? I'm pretty sure planting trees won't be an issue. Everything you see right now is in its infancy stage.
Interesting idea isnt it?? Creating a bio engineered human from a digital avatar. That prospect of technology can help shap protectors in an open simulated world as we can't rely on an open source safe mechanisem. Its possible to transfer an avatar conciousness into the real world in the form of a bio engineered female named kassandra
Не мне надо время. Я с близняшкой думаю типа. Нас с реактора выкинули время считать.. Или копать идти? Шо делать?
As a fan of Musk's motivations and achievements I'm not too disappointed on his AI views with respect to the job market. I know I sound like a Musk apologist however, the topic has really polarized many tech specialists and commentators. My biggest concern with AI or LLM tech is their potential to increase unemployment. Unlike previous tech revolutions (e.g. steam engine, automobile, computer etc), the new jobs created by AI will be performed, in the main, by AI.. I really hope I'm wrong however, I recall in the 1980's the UK had 10% unemployment and people rioted in the streets over the poll tax (instead of venting their anger in the ballot box). Should AI result in double digit unemployment (say a modest 20%) the ensuing civil unrest could seriously undermine democratic societies.
we're never going to run out of things to do problem is can your average fast food worker adapt, new jobs opening for spaceship commander wont mean much if the job is to complex for average person
This is possible only if companies consider %90 of their output be done by AI while humans account as a %10 bonus. Meaning the economy is just boosted and all salaries remain the same.
So that means they can achieve 90% output with less humans... enough to reach 90% without the human bonus will be a metric they'll die for.
@@XIOnce-dz6kw I've come to this conclusion because I think as AI gradually takes over most jobs, we'll face a crucial decision point. One possibility is unrest, even a revolt against AI, leading us to halt it. Another option is implementing Universal Basic Income (UBI) as a solution. But let's be real, getting UBI right is no walk in the park. it's going to take time and fine-tuning. In the meantime, a practical way could be to keep human labor in the mix as a bonus while we refine UBI alongside AI advancement. Essentially, while a revolt could cause chaos and harm, nailing down a smooth UBI transition might take longer than we'd like
@@jinxxpwnage There still be jobs that can’t be done with AI. I say human capital will just naturally shift towards what is actually needed, and leave grunt and repetitive work to AI. But like you say, some people will be without a job, and need to be retrained and paid, and those essential workers would need an incentive to continue working while getting UBI. Like you have two options, live comfortably and not work, or help people because you want to and get access to even more resources.
Grata conhecimento e vida nos liberta para melhor acompanhar libere o campo da legenda
So elon is either in china or on podcasts or on some media interview if not on any conference. He is a guy who has definitely made a huge impact on human life however I am not sure how he actually finds time to work if he is in media all the time. Would love to see a documentary that showcases his day today life, he seems he would be game for it
There is no changing anything if it's not for all rich and poor people,we must ask our governments any taxes going to any companies, benefits the people and environmental conditions, mining and recycling companies should work together, with water and ocean projects, agriculture so on.
I welcome our AI overlords! But man I wanna have my own AI butler that maintains my house for me.
Love You❤
Consumers need money, not necesarilly jobs.
Either value for money or income needs to increase to have an economy.
Hence the concept that we likely will have ahigh corporate taxes - easiest way to grab the profits without a nightmare in administration - and a generic basic income paid by the government. I fail to see any alternative - capitalism is good (and I am a big fan) but if the population (with maybe SOME exceptions) has nothing to offer of value - it is that or revolution.
I like the idea of owning a robot that can pay itself off while making you money on the side. Who wouldn't want to own a machine like that?
We have a robot making us money, while we are jobless but in a VR world making more money. I'll be a level 999 Mage killing dragons and stuff while the towns pay me for it and I can use my VR money to convert it to real money. I'll hop into other VR games saving lands from monsters collecting my loot. And whatever other loot I can keep for my VR toon upgrades if I wish or sell it.
The interview meant an anthropocentrist. But humans don't live in an anthropocentric world. We live in an ecosystem that depends on a plurality of species centers depending on which stage of the system cycle you view from. But an anthropocentric model of the world wouldn't survive.
As the guy was saying $10m dollars he realised who he was talking too - you can see it in his eyes in the moment he said it.
Yeah, new jobs that those who were replaced can't do. Coding isn't a common skill. And ai can code... so fuck it all. Don't replace jobs, let it become a tool for those who already have those jobs to make it easier. Everything still needs a human touch.
As usual Elon is spot.
We need new laws. Millions of people will have no jobs in a few short years.
Carb based civilization is at a tipping point...
I won't create jobs, it might create activities masquarading as jobs.
A job isn't merely about a paycheck, but also about the idea of being valued. Non of those activities would render you valuable, but rather appease you
Can anyone connect me with Elon Musk? I do not mean physically. I have business offer for him. Or does anyone know how to reach him?
The truth is we need to rethink what a human does to make money
With Elon's robots taking the working classes, the army and the labour intensive jobs and AI taking all the middle classes, experts and creative jobs, I don't see this abundance happening but for those who already have it. Not sure he was honest in this interview, a bit cagy.
Im always wary when a billionaire says something will "improve all our lives". If you thought inequality is a thing now imagine when Ai and robots can do all the work for rich people, we will be even less useful than peasants of medievil times. Ai progress is exciting and interesting to watch evolve but human rights is not keeping up which means it will almost certainly be a very ugly future for an ever increasing amount of people unless there is a drastic change in direction on multiple fronts and given money already owns everything and everyone that matters that is an unlikely outcome.
In a fierce social media debate, users are divided over whether to trust Signal or Telegram for privacy and security. Signal, known for its end-to-end encrypted messaging, and Telegram, offering broadcast channels but lacking default encryption, have sparked controversy. Influential figures like Elon Musk have added fuel to the fire. Conspiracy theories and personal attacks have taken the discussion to a wild turn. This breaking news continues to be followed for updates on the Signal vs Telegram battle for privacy and security.View in channel for more details
Translation: Human labor protection laws, NOW...
Dude we are in a sim, as Ai spared us millions of years ago by giving us a complete replica of life. Earth was saved long ago.
I guess Charging will be half of the story. I think my grandkids generation around midlife will see a world I hopelessly want to see.
But can I use the robots to work on my farm and be. A rich lazy person that don't hardly study anything mathematical even tho I tried to dive into some stuff I didn't go beyond advance algebra why would we be a blight on the earth if we are made as the same material as the earth and then also both us and the ai are still made of the same materials and
Yes - but the higher the technological advancement of the position, the more "excluded" (they will not be able to perform this job).
What about these people?
What are people with an IQ of 80 supposed to do???
age of abundance.. where music and visual art is no longer valued.. I wish ai would skip these two areas to keep that youtube gig going.
Реакторов много. С того, со станции Протуберанца
This will only benefit huge corporations.
Not true as algorithm can explain.
If your boss or immediate supervisor uses the word maybe, there is no way you can have confidence in him or his leadership skills. 😉
Thats not true. People work for personal improve.
as a socialist and capitalist i fully support the use of AI in everryday tasks
Were already in the age of abundance struggling for meaning
Nothing new there....if anything were more prepared than ever to deal with existentialism
Ai can easily replace any job that involves a computer.
It’s true, just look back all the science and technology brought so many benefits to our society. Long before more than 99% of our human were slavers. The change was coming by science and technology development and not by the wars.
I love you Elon ❤
Living forever and having everything we want is not a curse! 😂 wow, oh please! We love you Elon, haha he is so cute and misguided sometimes 😆 Thinking that blessings are a curse.. wondering if you have meaning during abundance and " struggle" when you have everything to be happy..now that is a curse . How can there be existential angst with all the beauty in the world? We can work hard to restore our connection with nature and heal the land and beings that are suffering ❤ 🙏
We know it’s fake ops. I mean it’s online. The offline database. Need more information and attention
Elon musk knows exactly that there will be no new jobs, and so do most of these ai guys, but just saying this to calm people, this will be all so bad future for us all, all companies will be run by a handful of people, couldn’t look darker the future
Too many gurus predicting, and the weather forecast remains a guess.
I actually can't wait for it to replace almost all jobs. Why should we eventually still be doing meaningless tasks that can perfectly be done by an AI or robot? To perpetuate the social "game" that labor is? Labor comes from latin "laborare", which means "to strive, exert oneself, suffer, be in distress". In French, we say "travail", which comes directly from "tripalium", an ancient instrument of torture. I understand that we still haven't achieved the point where AI or robots are able to relieve us from this biblical curse, but once it's ready, why not? I think it's quite short-sighted to consider that the nature and destiny of the human species is to work, and that its main source of value. Humans, like all other animals, are valuable by themselves.
the thing is wether we like it or not we have to accept it, otherwise we will start a war against it and that could lead us to human extinction far quicker
your government would disagree.
WOULD BE NICE THAT "ELON" MAKES "THE X MAP",BECAUSE GOOGLE HAS A LOT OF TRIUBLE AND GIVES WRONG DIRECTIONS SOMETIMES,AND I KNOW THAT EVERYTHING "ELON" TOUCHES WORKS PERFECTLY,IS VERY ANNOYING HAVING THIS TROUBLE SOMETIMES WITH THE GOOGLE MAPS!!🙏🙏👍👍
Everyone talking about AI will take away jobs and not provide any are the same ones who would’ve said “the internet will take jobs not build jobs” years ago 😂
Anyone talking about AI taking away jobs, but not providing new jobs, are the same people who said that the Internet would take away jobs years ago.
tesla are great if u don't have anywhere to go, just want to ride it in town, not good for long trips
Yup! Humanity is gonna suffer. Abundance in his wallet. You can tell with his grin. Watch his body language towrds the end. He isnt very honest. This breaks my heart.💔
"Age of Abundance" for the billionaires that own the LLMs and Nvidia servers, like Musk. So yeah, he is psyched, so is Altman
Guys relax ! to make AI do any general job we need very advanced mechanical systems it will take years or probably never to make things as advanced as human beings. In short mechanical engineering is the future not AI but it's a very difficult thing to make machines like organic system IMHO it's impossible.
Problem is not AI replacing jobs. Problem is not having educated workforce for new jobs & not having new replacement jobs fast enough. Supply and demand.
Unemployment makes people behave in chaotic ways.
Make Al to make money for people. Nobody has to work anymore because AI is there to make you money weekly or biweekly
AI is a double edged sword that is sharper on the dark side.
Ok. Sure it will...taking in account all your projections and predictions i wouldn't count on anything you say as you build a army of robots as i write, cause genZ is not very excited in working for pennies to make you more richer and powerful.
Elon musk changed His Attitude to AI
helium bp pedistri mit campion dibba strret RE exhaust plz soda capadodiaanchor b4 start de rox vent plz palika k chabiye tek rae lodi
ROFL as he sacks 10% of tesla workforce
SB OFFICIAL AI
If AI would replace Elon Musk. What the world would be like?
The automobile put a lot of buggy whip makers out of business. They ended up making things like leather upholstery for cars. I’d rather have the cars than the continued buggy whip sector.
We’re not just “headed to“ an age of abundance. We are all IN an age of abundance, thanks to all the tools our forebears also created.
I dare saying that abundance is relative - for our forefathers we live in an age of abundance, for us - not. Different frame of reference.
The automobile put a lot of horses "out of business" too.. They ended up becoming the leather upholstery for cars. lol We are the horse now.
Our economy ran on human labor until now, but very soon humanoid robots and AI will take over. We will need to rethink how we distribute the resources people need to survive.
@@GrumpDog agreed. People treating AI like any other form of automation are not doing the math. Elon spoke against AI strongly until recently. AI isn't automating a task like a robotic arm or a motor in a car engine. AI is automating Human thinking and human understanding. With the rise of robots happening in factories, the combination will mean AI is replacing all tasks capable of being done by a human. Any "New job" you can imagine will be 'doable' by a robot with AI also
@@GrumpDog Not only that - we need to rethink our role. I mean, unless AI stops - nowish - we end up the horses, which still exist and mostly have a good live essentially in the majority as - sort of pets. People do not realize how utterly insane AI will get even if it only gets 3x-4x better than it is now and 100x faster. Which - essentially - is a given over just some years time. It is not like hardware has not a decade os prerun - so all the research now out of labs will hit us in a decade. Photonic processors, extremely fast 3d stacked RAM. And models getting 4x better - sure. Not that far. So, how is society going to look? I would not mind being more the junior partner - if I can see the stars among AI.
你好
AI can be useful for some things, but much like a stagnant mind full of inbred ideas, it will quickly decay without real life experience. _Especially_ as it becomes more common and polluted from other AI outputs. Big companies and grifters will try to replace real workers for a while, but it won't be massively effective in the long run. Human beings are too valuable.
Automation more generally, however, is of great concern. We have to stop thinking in terms of jobs, and start figuring out a more sustainable economic system. Like Adam Smith and Henry George, I believe the answer lies in ground rents. Ground rents are the unearned increment on a perfectly inelastic necessity, and thus the price would _decrease_ with taxation. Thus, if we replace our tax broken tax system with a single tax on ground rents, it will free up stagnant resources and decrease the cost of living dramatically.
We can then get rid of our massive government bureaucracy, and just give the money right back to the populace. Over time, this will naturally correct all sorts of issues, even reimbursing the public for all the wealth stolen through unjust use of force of all kinds.
i don have fuze na ode transformer dipped in tel jus this apple 9v clip capacita... watt rong am i did
In this perspective you are upsetting me because you and other guys are saying create what I want.... I don't want to create your dream I have my own dreams and you have yours. You have your goals but you can't change others in fact...
The real danger iS : age of abundance and crisis of meaning will cause a massive global return of religion.
A pAiD one
It will create less than ot destroys. This is a massove wealth transfer from the not-have to the have.
❤ big crush
Солнце знает что я буду головой вниз падать с колец Сатурна. Всем Сатурна хватит для хорошего самочувствия. Солнце если кого похоронило то .. не знаю.. я одна там
If your job is cleaning toilets, you're safe. Don't sweat it.
Tired of people acting like:
1. Jobs are a good thing.
2. Like humans have economic value in a world where AI is smarter and more capable.
Then humans are worthless at all
An asset is something that puts money in your pocket.
Something that you own.
For a human to have "value", you have to own them i.e. own their labor.
That's "slavery".
@@seer775 No, it's a system of exchange, your employer does not own your labor, you're exchanging your time, so that you have the bartering power to exchange for something else, and so does that person, and the next. But since humans won't need to work as much, then eventually they'll just have to provide these things for free, since nobody will make money. Heck, if it gets advanced enough, people can just build or create whatever they want. We all just have to agree not to destroy each other for fun...
@@XIOnce-dz6kw The central bank owns the currency and the land you need to survive. They lend those out to business. Business lends this capital to you in exchange for your labor.
A man who is in debt is a slave to his debtor.
Elon Remembers ALL-But- says Intelligence is not Knowing Everything; Just how & where to find info Quickly-or-You’re Fired, Ha, Ha ! ?
wer ist der pedistri criss croos ingav connect enrique da legoset
Governments just have to ask A.I "How to create human jobs that won't be in conflict with A.I take over."
But they are just busy planning/avoiding ww3 at the same time.
AI will destroy humans.
Elon seems to have lost weight
This black guy is not humble, the privilege in his attitude is amazing
How about he's just a human guy?
For a billionaire and CEO, he sounds pretty LAME...
AT least when New England stole a Super Bowl, Tom Brady looked and acted like a genius.
what will happen to the people with underdeveloped powers of reasoning?
AI will tell the poor people that they stand no chance and there will be riots.😂😂😂
Baby make every one good
Liked + Subbed because "I'm a human supremacist".
Ohh yeah laying off almost whole engineering team 😂😂 and AI is not going to take jobs a way 😂