What If The Entire Jedi Council Discover Sidious And Plagueis In The Phantom Menace, Remember Members Of The Council During Episode I Are Adí Gallia, Eeth Koth, Even Piell, Oppo Rancisis, Saesee Tiin, Kí Adí Mundi, Plo-Koon, Yaddle, Yarael Poof, Yoda, Mace Windu And Depa Billaba, The Place Is The Apartment Of The Palpatine Seen In The Phantom Menace Itself, The Story Is After Qui Gon Travell To NABOO Before The Duel Of The Fates
If you ask me, this is what I think it would happen: One, Plagueis as Drunk as he is, much more possible would be the manipulated Rich grampa, Two Sidious would be trying to kill the poor old man Plagueis, quite possible leading the Jedi to suspect that Plague is a benevolent Old muum discovered him and try to withdraw whatever partnership they had. Leading to a confrontation a possible recovery of Plagueis in the Jedi Temple
This is great. It sounds a whole lot better than the way Luke was portrayed in The Last Jedi. I'm curious, how would you have wrote Bens fall to the dark side?
Love these what if videos! To me this is kinda like a what if Obi Wan Saved Anakin before he burned Type what if because I believe the reason Luke Didn’t redeem Ben is because Much like Obi Wan and Anakin Luke knew Ben would never Let Luke Redeem him much like Anakin wouldn’t let Obi Wan redeem him because Obi Wan took his legs. Luke from Ben’s perspective Was trying to end him and he felt betrayed by his Own family and uncle who he looked up to. But I do definitely think Ben should’ve turned Good in the last Jedi or Rey should’ve joined Ben in the last Jedi to Give it a dark mirror of Vader asking Luke to join him.
Lol to me, he still was! When Luke saved everyone on Crait, that was him realizing he was wrong and going back to his true self. A legendary Jedi Master that uses the Force for knowledge and defense, just like Yoda taught him. I also love Luke's scene in Episode 9
Odd Head Canon but I believe When Luke saw What Ben could have become I believe he saw something much worse then Anything Kylo Ren actually did. I believe Luke saw a possible future where Ben Became just as evil if not more evil then caedus maybe Ben was unknowingly from Luke possessed by The Emperor because I believe At first Palpatine was wanting to take Ben as a host if he proved to be more powerful then Rey. That’s why I believe Luke lost control because He saw a future that was far worse then the one that really Happened. Also I wonder what Palpatine’s original Plan was before Ben betrayed Luke. Was he planning to just Outlive Luke? Or try to use Snoke or Rey if he found her to Kill Luke
Solid video on your fanfics as always. I actually have a question, did Luke ever learn the reason as to why Anakin turned to the darkside? Did he know it was over his mother and visions of her death or was that still an unknown to him?
In Legends, yes! Luke watched recordings of Anakin and Padme from the events of Episode 3. ruclips.net/video/tF9qGd6oC-8/видео.htmlsi=VgJfosIAaqVlqs_E In canon, I'm not sure.
This is where the sequel trilogy team failed. They failed to see that Luke would do just this, which is talk to Ben. He would never fail Ben, or the New Jedi Order, or let the Empire return. I remember when they were developing those movies they were adamant in saying "we want to do something new and not adapt the EU books" before they rebooted canon, but what they gave us was basically a remake of a New Hope and a somehow shittier version of the Dark Empire comic series with hijacked elements of the Legacy of the Force book series. I could go on and on and elaborate if you like, lol. Keep up the good work though, love the channel.
This is much better, well done. Where can I find more information about the timeline and relationship between Ben and Snoke. Also was Snoke a failed clone of Palatine which he (Palp)mind controlled?
I'd recommend checking out the book "Skywalker: A Family At War." Its a biography of the entire family and fills in a ton of important details about Ben before TFA. Snoke was a strandcast, meaning he was a being genetically made from Palpatine's DNA, but not a direct clone. He was basically a proxy to run the First Order since Palps couldn't leave Exegol. He was likely unaware of his true nature, but he wasn't mind controlled
My expectation is Disney is going to put a hiatus on Star Wars to try and save the MCU, and if they haven't sold Lucasfilm they'll reboot the franchise and write this out of canon. Somehow the sequels disappeared
I loved the voice acting you did. The writing is right on imo. Great job
Another awesome video 🤘
this is my absolute favorite time to have a fan fiction, LFG
Because they are all better than disney! 😂
What If The Entire Jedi Council Discover Sidious And Plagueis In The Phantom Menace, Remember Members Of The Council During Episode I Are Adí Gallia, Eeth Koth, Even Piell, Oppo Rancisis, Saesee Tiin, Kí Adí Mundi, Plo-Koon, Yaddle, Yarael Poof, Yoda, Mace Windu And Depa Billaba, The Place Is The Apartment Of The Palpatine Seen In The Phantom Menace Itself, The Story Is After Qui Gon Travell To NABOO Before The Duel Of The Fates
If you ask me, this is what I think it would happen:
One, Plagueis as Drunk as he is, much more possible would be the manipulated Rich grampa,
Two Sidious would be trying to kill the poor old man Plagueis, quite possible leading the Jedi to suspect that Plague is a benevolent Old muum discovered him and try to withdraw whatever partnership they had. Leading to a confrontation a possible recovery of Plagueis in the Jedi Temple
Better yet, what if you fixed the entire sequel trilogy.
Even our Lord can't do that
Someone already did. It's called the "Expanded Universe"
@@michaelfreitag7657 BAM!
Come on, Ben, you know you're too handsome for masks.
Yes this is how Luke should’ve reacted in the Last Jedi!👍🏻👏🏻
This is great. It sounds a whole lot better than the way Luke was portrayed in The Last Jedi. I'm curious, how would you have wrote Bens fall to the dark side?
Love these what if videos! To me this is kinda like a what if Obi Wan Saved Anakin before he burned Type what if because I believe the reason Luke Didn’t redeem Ben is because Much like Obi Wan and Anakin Luke knew Ben would never Let Luke Redeem him much like Anakin wouldn’t let Obi Wan redeem him because Obi Wan took his legs. Luke from Ben’s perspective Was trying to end him and he felt betrayed by his Own family and uncle who he looked up to. But I do definitely think Ben should’ve turned Good in the last Jedi or Rey should’ve joined Ben in the last Jedi to Give it a dark mirror of Vader asking Luke to join him.
Better title: What If the real Luke Skywalker was in the Sequel Trilogy.
Lol to me, he still was! When Luke saved everyone on Crait, that was him realizing he was wrong and going back to his true self. A legendary Jedi Master that uses the Force for knowledge and defense, just like Yoda taught him. I also love Luke's scene in Episode 9
😂. In my cannon he is just like EU luke!
Great job. Props on the hard choice for a subject. You should continue on this path sir. I listen to allot of what if’s and this was solid. 👍👍
Odd Head Canon but I believe When Luke saw What Ben could have become I believe he saw something much worse then Anything Kylo Ren actually did.
I believe Luke saw a possible future where Ben Became just as evil if not more evil then caedus maybe Ben was unknowingly from Luke possessed by The Emperor because I believe At first Palpatine was wanting to take Ben as a host if he proved to be more powerful then Rey.
That’s why I believe Luke lost control because He saw a future that was far worse then the one that really Happened.
Also I wonder what Palpatine’s original Plan was before Ben betrayed Luke. Was he planning to just Outlive Luke? Or try to use Snoke or Rey if he found her to Kill Luke
Solid video on your fanfics as always. I actually have a question, did Luke ever learn the reason as to why Anakin turned to the darkside? Did he know it was over his mother and visions of her death or was that still an unknown to him?
In Legends, yes! Luke watched recordings of Anakin and Padme from the events of Episode 3. ruclips.net/video/tF9qGd6oC-8/видео.htmlsi=VgJfosIAaqVlqs_E
In canon, I'm not sure.
Then we’d have a better sequel trilogy. Probably. Maybe.
I have so much focus on legends material I often forget Disney is “canon”
This is where the sequel trilogy team failed. They failed to see that Luke would do just this, which is talk to Ben. He would never fail Ben, or the New Jedi Order, or let the Empire return. I remember when they were developing those movies they were adamant in saying "we want to do something new and not adapt the EU books" before they rebooted canon, but what they gave us was basically a remake of a New Hope and a somehow shittier version of the Dark Empire comic series with hijacked elements of the Legacy of the Force book series. I could go on and on and elaborate if you like, lol. Keep up the good work though, love the channel.
This is much better, well done. Where can I find more information about the timeline and relationship between Ben and Snoke. Also was Snoke a failed clone of Palatine which he (Palp)mind controlled?
I'd recommend checking out the book "Skywalker: A Family At War." Its a biography of the entire family and fills in a ton of important details about Ben before TFA.
Snoke was a strandcast, meaning he was a being genetically made from Palpatine's DNA, but not a direct clone. He was basically a proxy to run the First Order since Palps couldn't leave Exegol. He was likely unaware of his true nature, but he wasn't mind controlled
My expectation is Disney is going to put a hiatus on Star Wars to try and save the MCU, and if they haven't sold Lucasfilm they'll reboot the franchise and write this out of canon. Somehow the sequels disappeared
What if Disney never destroyed Star Wars.
Luckily we don't have to wonder, because they didn't!