It's so unfair that team fearless got their vocals pre recorder while anti fragile did a one take audio live. And some voices in antifragile got their voices edited but left the others untouched, like Lara and Sophia they could've edited it a little bit like Yoonchae's highnote but they left them so raw. They all still did great tho the fact that they just practiced for days, and sang live wihtout backing tracks and sang all of their lines.
@@4pfcarti792 your point would make sense if one of the fearless and one of anti-fragile teams receive immunity but It doesn't work like that, only one team out all 4 will get it
all I’m gonna say is I don’t think it’s fair to say that team a for anti fragile had “stability” issues when both fearless teams were obviously not live or were very smoothed over. Emily actually did great for someone who probably auditioned for a dance role and is now singing live while dancing, I personally love the way she delivered her lines.
Antifragile was 100% more difficult to sing and dance. I’m glad you were able to see that. I’m not sure how many members will make the final group, but I personally think HYBE should build around: Nayoung Sophia Lara and Samara. And the remaining spots should go to a combination of Yoonchae, Marquise, UA, Megan, Daniella, Mei, Emily.
53:51 They are training for about 1 year now. So I think She was considering her performances in their monthly evaluations. You cannot determine their capabilities with just 2 performances/mission.
Karle is talented but with this particular mission she did bad, she almost passed out singing because of laryngitis. With Team B Samara carried her team but with team A they have chemistry as group.
I love how you also considered the difficulty of the girls' parts when making comments about them cause haters are always attacking them without keeping in mind these factors.
The fact that majority of them gor their voices edited and put auto tuned in is crazy, the only girls that doesn't have their voices edited are sophia and karlee
Its only mission 2 performances but they do had more performances while training bcs most of them are trained for a year at least except samara. So they do have evalutions tracks on every trainees and how they growth within the time they trained.
Yeah I feel like the commentary of the usual jurs was based in their whole journey in the project, way beyond of what we get to see, while the invited guests are more close to our perspective except that they have a more technical view
My mandatory votes have been manon and samara, lara and sophia are close after. Daniela and karlee really impressed me this mission shooting them up my personal ranks haha. I personally think what that lady said about people voting on nationality is so funny because first of all every promotional video they had of dream acadamy was like a united nations meeting. Then these are all the top 20 from 1000+ girls who auditioned, I'm pretty sure they all have a certain skill set that they approved of before putting them on this program. Also she needs to remember that they have girls with pre existing fanbases plus their nationalities are known for pushing their people (like samara not only was in the now united bootcamp but shes also brazilian. Brazil and phillipines are basically cousins when it comes to pushing their people through these shows. Theyre also the most loyal when it comes to fanbases.) They also don't really give anyone much since we don't know any of the girls personality that well with these stingy clips. I'm not particularly voting for any nationality anyways since I'm American but my main 2 girls are swiss/African and Brazil.
The ones that I feel like should debit are: Samara, Nayoung, Sophia, Daniela, Mei, Marquise, Yoonchae, Lara. Honourable mentions: Karlee, Meghan, Lexie, Manon
Obviously they're emphasizing more on group chemistry. Which means a team of lesser skilled dancers and vocalists that have great chemistry will shine more on stage than a team of better dancers and vocalists that have no chemistry. It's been proven in survival shows before so I won't be surprised if people's favorites don't make it despite their excellent skills.
I liked this format, everything in one go. One idea is you could just wait for everything of a mission to come out and react to all of it at once too, that way you could include the eliminations.
I managed to notice that the ones that stand out and are better they don't comment on. Now the ones that did well (but weren't the best) they quickly mention and they focus more on talking about those who didn’t do well on the mission 🤔 So i think they didn't talk much about Samara - for example - in the first mission and in this one it's a good sign
No worries AL, I feel you. I think we need longer unedited cuts of the commentary videos. And don't feel bad for disagreeing with the professionals. We value your opinion. 💖
Wait I might be wrong, but why do I feel the audio of songs the antifragile teams performed infront of leserrafim members listen similar to the mission performance audios...arent they live performances especially Emily????????
Celeste is always the one who gets the least amount to sing in the group she's in, she got like 2 seconds in this one idk if is on purpose but man im so sad
@@adriano.bradford2125 It's literally a competition where you have to judge the people out of their performance. I have nothing against her personally. I'm just saying she was bad, pitchy and out of breath in the performance. Anne said she was the strongest so I was confused with her judgment hence this comment.
Ladies in Green did great! My personal ranking: Antifragile Team A (safe) Fearless Team B (safe) Honorable mention: Samara Megan Nayoung Lexie Brooklyn Eliminated: Marquise Iliya Mei Karlee
Não deixe isso te afetar sami pois você é talentosa e você merece debutar para ter uma vida financeira melhor e com o meu apoio junto as outras pessoas verdadeiras que estão do seu lado ❤
It is interesting that you have opposite opinions to the industry experts. You found it interesting and funny, a good attitude. I often disagreed with you and that’s okay that we don’t see the same things when we watch the same performance. We all have our own biases. I support and pull for certain people from Hawaii, I also think they deserve my support, it’s not mutually exclusive. I also liked Lexie and Sophia who are not from Hawaii.
![[HYBE x Geffen] Dream Academy - Mission 3 - Reaction - This is tough!](/img/1.gif)
It's so unfair that team fearless got their vocals pre recorder while anti fragile did a one take audio live. And some voices in antifragile got their voices edited but left the others untouched, like Lara and Sophia they could've edited it a little bit like Yoonchae's highnote but they left them so raw. They all still did great tho the fact that they just practiced for days, and sang live wihtout backing tracks and sang all of their lines.
well it’s fearless vs fearless tho
@@4pfcarti792 your point would make sense if one of the fearless and one of anti-fragile teams receive immunity but It doesn't work like that, only one team out all 4 will get it
@@lozner3763 it’s literally one anti fragile team wins immunity and one fearless team…
@@4pfcarti792 “whichever team receives more votes on average will receive immunity from elimination” keyword being team not teams.
@@lozner3763 The woman on the panel said 2 teams battle head to head and the winner of those team battles gets immunity. It's one of each.
all I’m gonna say is I don’t think it’s fair to say that team a for anti fragile had “stability” issues when both fearless teams were obviously not live or were very smoothed over. Emily actually did great for someone who probably auditioned for a dance role and is now singing live while dancing, I personally love the way she delivered her lines.
I’m a bit late but you do realize that both fearless teams were performing on a helipad right? That’s why they sang over it.
Either way it’s not fearless vs antifragile so it doesn’t matter lol.
I also think only some of it is prerecorded too btw lol
Antifragile was 100% more difficult to sing and dance. I’m glad you were able to see that.
I’m not sure how many members will make the final group, but I personally think HYBE should build around:
Nayoung Sophia Lara and Samara.
And the remaining spots should go to a combination of
Yoonchae, Marquise, UA, Megan, Daniella, Mei, Emily.
Lara’s vocal in the practice tho, dang 😅 fearless groups wouldn’t stand against antifragile groups if it was also pre recorded for them. 9:20
It’s really not tho but we’ll see with the netflix docu I guess
53:51 They are training for about 1 year now. So I think She was considering her performances in their monthly evaluations. You cannot determine their capabilities with just 2 performances/mission.
Karle is talented but with this particular mission she did bad, she almost passed out singing because of laryngitis. With Team B Samara carried her team but with team A they have chemistry as group.
I agree with them, similar to her first performance, Brooklyn’s voice sounds off almost like she’s hollering the words
Firt one from brazil ! GO Samara
I love how you also considered the difficulty of the girls' parts when making comments about them cause haters are always attacking them without keeping in mind these factors.
The fact that majority of them gor their voices edited and put auto tuned in is crazy, the only girls that doesn't have their voices edited are sophia and karlee
Yes, baby tell the true! Team Antifragile was so good Samara
Wow! , I like how Yunjin knew all of their names that's amazing .
Its only mission 2 performances but they do had more performances while training bcs most of them are trained for a year at least except samara. So they do have evalutions tracks on every trainees and how they growth within the time they trained.
Yeah I feel like the commentary of the usual jurs was based in their whole journey in the project, way beyond of what we get to see, while the invited guests are more close to our perspective except that they have a more technical view
My mandatory votes have been manon and samara, lara and sophia are close after. Daniela and karlee really impressed me this mission shooting them up my personal ranks haha. I personally think what that lady said about people voting on nationality is so funny because first of all every promotional video they had of dream acadamy was like a united nations meeting. Then these are all the top 20 from 1000+ girls who auditioned, I'm pretty sure they all have a certain skill set that they approved of before putting them on this program. Also she needs to remember that they have girls with pre existing fanbases plus their nationalities are known for pushing their people (like samara not only was in the now united bootcamp but shes also brazilian. Brazil and phillipines are basically cousins when it comes to pushing their people through these shows. Theyre also the most loyal when it comes to fanbases.) They also don't really give anyone much since we don't know any of the girls personality that well with these stingy clips. I'm not particularly voting for any nationality anyways since I'm American but my main 2 girls are swiss/African and Brazil.
you delivered with this comment, girl 👏
Sophia as leader vibe ❤
Celeste only had one line to sing. It's unfair to say that she didn't shine when she only appears on camera for 2 seconds.
literal, alta pajaa los de hybe
The ones that I feel like should debit are: Samara, Nayoung, Sophia, Daniela, Mei, Marquise, Yoonchae, Lara.
Honourable mentions: Karlee, Meghan, Lexie, Manon
Obviously they're emphasizing more on group chemistry. Which means a team of lesser skilled dancers and vocalists that have great chemistry will shine more on stage than a team of better dancers and vocalists that have no chemistry. It's been proven in survival shows before so I won't be surprised if people's favorites don't make it despite their excellent skills.
I liked this format, everything in one go. One idea is you could just wait for everything of a mission to come out and react to all of it at once too, that way you could include the eliminations.
I'm curious because they don't talk about Marquise, Manon, Daniela, Sophia and Samara. I don't if it's a good thing or not.
I managed to notice that the ones that stand out and are better they don't comment on. Now the ones that did well (but weren't the best) they quickly mention and they focus more on talking about those who didn’t do well on the mission 🤔 So i think they didn't talk much about Samara - for example - in the first mission and in this one it's a good sign
No worries AL, I feel you. I think we need longer unedited cuts of the commentary videos. And don't feel bad for disagreeing with the professionals. We value your opinion. 💖
i agree with you, i hope they give celeste more lines
Wait I might be wrong, but why do I feel the audio of songs the antifragile teams performed infront of leserrafim members listen similar to the mission performance audios...arent they live performances especially Emily????????
I thinks it's different. Look at Lara's voice in the "I go to ride 'til I die, die" part. It's much better than their performance video.
@@Vee-ju6nx haaaa, you are right I felt the same when I heard Lara's....but when I heard Emily's I was confused 😅😅
Thanks for the clarification...😊
my top6: SAMARA, LARA, NAYOUNG, MEGAN, LEXIE, DANIELA
Celeste is always the one who gets the least amount to sing in the group she's in, she got like 2 seconds in this one idk if is on purpose but man im so sad
Huh? Karlee was so bad... so out of breath and pitchy...
She had laryngitis give her a break
Hahahahaha same reaction but yeah she's sick in that performance so we should consider that but praising her so much for her vocals in this perf is 🤡
@@adriano.bradford2125 It's literally a competition where you have to judge the people out of their performance. I have nothing against her personally. I'm just saying she was bad, pitchy and out of breath in the performance. Anne said she was the strongest so I was confused with her judgment hence this comment.
SAMARAAAA!!🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🥰🥰🥰👑👑👈🏻👈🏻
Ladies in Green did great!
My personal ranking:
Antifragile Team A (safe)
Fearless Team B (safe)
Honorable mention:
Samara
Megan
Nayoung
Lexie
Brooklyn
Eliminated:
Marquise
Iliya
Mei
Karlee
On board with this 100%
Karlee was out of breath 😢i think there is high chance she gets eliminated
Não deixe isso te afetar sami pois você é talentosa e você merece debutar para ter uma vida financeira melhor e com o meu apoio junto as outras pessoas verdadeiras que estão do seu lado ❤
21:12 whattt!!!!!
Daniela❤❤❤❤
It is interesting that you have opposite opinions to the industry experts. You found it interesting and funny, a good attitude. I often disagreed with you and that’s okay that we don’t see the same things when we watch the same performance. We all have our own biases. I support and pull for certain people from Hawaii, I also think they deserve my support, it’s not mutually exclusive. I also liked Lexie and Sophia who are not from Hawaii.
I'm really late but wow all the comments are so biased ☠️
Try dance while singing lol