It does not surprise me. 25 years ago I sat listening to a Sami man who cried because his children were bullied by Norwegian kids. Norway has a dark history of cultural assimilation which in short means that the indigenous peoples should adapt and become Norwegians. They stole Sami children and forced them to forget their language and culture.
Its scary, imagine being and living there in such suffocating environment where everyday you fear of losing your identity, your culture and your family..
Bokkisam, is that an Indian name @@KiranKumarBokkesam ? For your information, what *@Fan Bhagat Singh da* says is happening at this moment in 6 European countries. And that is just one of the torture parents and kids are going through besides being broke ... do u know how many parents and kids have committed suicide? Go read or watch real life stories. Most of them are being erased by child services and corrupt politicians. Many foreign kids are stolen to convert them.
Just watched the movie and in complete shock. Cannot put in words what the mother must have gone through. She indeed is a strong women who fought against all odds. Thank God she was reunited with her kids. I wish no parent ever have to face such a situation
next time a norwegian couple feeds their kids with spoon and fork in India, Indian authority will take custody of their kids saying its endangerment of children with metal object.. and make the couple's lives miserable.
@@wasimgill4101 oh..wow! i didnt know that, in that case the authorities should have provided child custody and protection to wife, imagine what the wife went thru...lossing kids and facing domestic violence from husband
I was 17 only I didn't hear about it much but when I got to know from my mother I literally cried out..and after watching the trailer I just got goosebumps..Western countries will perish one day..Mark my words..
Bruh you don't know the whole story. When you are in there nation you have to follow there rules and the solution was she moved back to India and she did by the end.
Indianexpress quote «Chatterjee vs Norway»: «There was no allegation of violence or incest. All the complaints were about the parents’ “care ability”. This did not appear to justify placing the children in permanent foster care, without allowing the parents to even visit them.»
Understanding the Indian culture and upbringing of our country, now what steps are the governments of these foreign countries taking to return our kids?
It's not about culture. As the trailer showed they make money by putting kids in foster care and they make up bogus reasons to take them away from parents. I learned about this about a year ago when stories were coming out about them taking away kids of refugees since the country of origin can't intervene.
Stop going to their counyryband proving our real begging bowl situation . Let them also realise that cheap labour is needed in running their factories then they will call us on our terms. NOT all Countries are Bankrupt Like USA and UK .
Norway country , Germany etc stealing kids- what kind of countries are they. They shamelessly doing it in name of fake democracy. Reason - parents feeding child with hand etc
I'm watching the movie now and, it's heartbreaking to watch ...what a cold society, horrible what this lady had to go through....not a country I'd want to visit, poor lady! A parent's worst nightmare
Whatever their intentions were they had no right to take away the children from an attentive mother. Prior to this movie I was not even aware of this, now I keep seeing this is an actual cruel occurrence in Norway where they take away children from their parents. It’s absolutely sickening to see some people have no empathy and humanity in them
@@yellow8879 this is not a documentary, and it is a fictional and commercial movie. it has some truth but not the entire truth. child cases are extremely complex, and it is not how it seems
@@KiranKumarBokkesam Maybe you should read my initial comment instead of jumping into conclusions. I wasn’t talking the depiction of the movie I was talking about the actual experience of whom this movie based on. I’m aware this is a movie and dramatization is something that’s inevitable. Those other cases I mentioned about they are not my words nor my experiences rather experiences of others. You seem to have bias, since you keep defending Norway and tbh I don’t care about that. All I know is I’d still have the same response if this was any other country. I don’t agree nor support children being taken away from their attentive and loving parents
@@yellow8879 why would anyone take away children from attentive and loving parents?? That is the plot of the movie RRR. there is a RUclipsr called 'Namaste from Norway' who made a video on this with a woman who used to work in the child welfare system of Norway. It did make some past mistakes and has learned from them. It's not like that anymore. I don't know how you are forming your opinions. this movie has only consulted the mother and not the father. and it has neither access to the actual case because it is confidential. I am not jumping to any conclusions. I am ready to talk about it. You may always email me. I live in Denmark which is a neighboring country to Norway and is considered inferior to Norway. I have nothing to gain from defending Norway. It's currently the world's best country overall in many social indicators. It is a huge shame and a waste of resources for someone to make a movie like this to make money by appealing to people's sentiments and emotions rather than being honest and educating about this country's systems. Indian people and culture in general are well respected in the entire world including Norway. It would only be fair for us to do the same towards others. making such movies and misleading people helps nobody.
its difficult to understand force feeding as an Indian to me as I am the child who literally a lot of beating from my mom for not eating my food and supplements.I still got shouted on this but I did not found it wrong nor I do now , for me when I talk about it looks funny . and this is really common in family as we kids do not take proper food .
@@ggwhhbb1822 thr is a difference between overfeeding and proper feeding.. parents knows that green veggies grains and fruits are good for children.. but children loves to ears chocolates ice cream and other junk food like n oodles samosa chaumin and soo on
@Heera Subedi I never spoke about domestic violence it is about feeding with hands which is not forced feeding in certain cultures and you study the cultural diversity of Asia before barking here.Something for your brains The Nordic countries are considered to be the most gender equal in Europe, with Sweden, Finland and Denmark consistently ranking among the top 5 on the European Gender Equality Index. Yet, 32 percent of Danish women, 30 percent of Finish women and 28 percent of Swedish women aged 15 or older have experienced physical or sexual intimate partner violence (IPV)-a stark contrast to an EU-average of 22 percent. Similarly, the occurrence of psychological partner violence as well as violence by non-partners against women in these countries is higher than elsewhere in the EU
Terrible reporting. No mention of the fact that she was in abusive relationship with her husband, no mention of the fact that her children had autism, no mention of the fact that she would beat her children. While I understand that she's a mother, it's more important that children have a good childhood and their needs met by someone who is capable of dealing with the challenges of a difficult child. Would you want a differently abled kid to sleep in the same room as an abusive father? This movie creates a narrative that is dramatic but ultimately untrue and biased.
Are you saying the children were abused? The eldest was 1.4 years old and the youngest was 3 months old when they were initially taken away. Why shouldnt a 1.4 yr old sleep with his parents? My friends Malaysian of Chinese descent have 2 girls 4 years apart. They co-slept with the elder girl until the second child was born. Then the second girl co slept with the parents until she was 4 or 5. The mother is asia-pac manager of a leading pharmaceutical company and father is a doctor like myself. So what is wrong with co-sleeping? My friend is a strict mother and values discipline. Like any Asian parent. How is this considered as abusive?
I don't know about this case of what's truth and what's not. But Growing up with an abusive environment as of myself, is not good for a child... Say it abuse towards the child or abuse towards the mother or other family member. It scars you for life...
@@KiranKumarBokkesam thankful that we can feel what the love of family means, thankful for that when our mother feed us by all her love so that we will be more attached toh her ,thankful for the bond we can have because when she feeds you by giving up all other works you get to know how precious you are to her, thankful for we are democratic and don't have this much loop holes in our laws like Norwegian, thankful for atleast can raise our voices for when something bad happen .., good and bad happens in every country but because a mother feeding their baby is a crime than its nonsense a small baby newborn can't eat a mother have to feed their milk toh that new born why don't they also call it force feeding as a new born should drink milk by their own ...
@@KomalKumari-vm8vw, you seem very naive and ignorant and are wrong and need to read more and travel more. All those nice things happen in Norway too and you are wrong about being able to raise your voice in India and about the loopholes in Indian and Norwegian law.
Case in point families should do more due diligence and research before immigrating to foreign lands. and dont go to countries that seem to offer the most but often do not
Indianexpress quote «Chatterjee vs Norway»: «There was no allegation of violence or incest. All the complaints were about the parents’ “care ability”. This did not appear to justify placing the children in permanent foster care, without allowing the parents to even visit them.»
Germany case s utter nonsense. Germans were right. As a Dr. My question hw does vaginal tear occur n baby nd y the Indian government supports family t get bc k t mess thy created for baby. Thy shud ne er get the child. A vaginal tear s serious crime.
ya Norway has bunch of chads and Karens who judge hand feeding and disciplining. This is part of being a desi parent and I agree that people should abide by a countries rules but the point of this is also to shed light on shitty policies and greed in country that otherwise appears modern and inclusive
Shame on Norway and its racist behavior . And more shame as they think its propaganda . They should be apologise and bow to modiji. Bengali is official Indian language .
How ignorant are these European countries even in the era of social media. I wouldn’t step a foot in these countries as an Indian let alone live there. Shame on these governments for breaking families.
@@KiranKumarBokkesam u r materialistic person... For mother... They would die for their child.... His husband was abusive towards her... But not with children... N this doesn't imply to run away with kids second better done was parents divorce... Did u read human psychology biological mother milk does amazing thing.... They preventing the kids from there.... Wen it's abt child she left the crores n countries facilities with no one second.... Live with ur 🤑 money.....
Sorry but s3xual assault is a big accusation, there is no 'cultural differences' there; better safe than sorry so hopefully it was properly investigated.
Hopefully but a lot of the time the authorities themselves place these kids in the hands of p3do’s. especially in dirty western europe, these people travel to asia and SEA just to defile children.
As far as i know, Ariha's medical examination found that she had injury in her private parts. Therefore they suspected SA. I am wondering how does a child gets injury as such. Am i understanding something wrong here?
To be honest we only get to listen only one side of story. Other side which is Norway child services we never hear anything from them. Father asked divorce saying mother used to hit him as well. In most of these cases generally neighbours inform police if they hear hitting, crying babies etc. Only after that this child care people start keeping eye. They can not be there all the time and no one will do the hitting part when they are there. They somewhere mentioned that kids even used to get scared to go to mother. I understand all our parents love us including my parents but even my mother has sometimes hit me to the extent which could be illegal if I was in Norway.
First: This mother did not hit her children, they took her children from her because she was feeding them with her own hands. They kidnap children for stupid reasons. Second: Even if parents beat their children, this is not a sufficient excuse for kidnapping children from their parents and destroying the family. We mostly beaten by our mothers, and when we remember this we find it funny. But when you remember that you were kidnapped from your parents, you suffer all your life when you remember that you lived far from your mother, and you feel that your childhood and your identity were stolen from you.
@@salimd7842 who told you that child was taken due to force feeding? This was mentioned by parents and they succeeded in giving us wrong information. We never heard side from Norway authorities. Recently one officer in Norway said that he can not disclose the reasons but it was not related to co-sleeping or force feeding. Jab to me choti thi tab maine in parents ko news me Dekha tha. Tab Norway ki govt pe itna gussa aya tha. Par ab jab Germany Ka case Dekha to samajh aa raha he ki kabi bhi sirf ek side sunke nirnay nahi Lena chahiye.
@@salimd7842 - The Second point you made is exactly why kids need to be taken away from physically abusive parents in other countries. Forget India...parents and people will never change over there.
@@alwaysSifyable How do you that this false? You accuse the parents but not the norwegian government for their pathetic laws. If the didnt want her kids, why would she fight the government tooth and nail to get them back. I implore you to use your brain to think not your rear end please.
Omg this scared the hell out of me…i feed my 2 years old boy with hand..i live in us california and aw he is having iron deficiency doctor routed me to health care team and they asked me if he self feed or not ….😮 im gonna lie now.
it would help if you didn't lie about anything. instead, it would help if you cooperated with them. they are there for a reason. it is this kind of behaviour from foreign cultures that makes them more suspicious and also causes trouble to other foreign parents who are honest.
@@KiranKumarBokkesam lol im being honest till now dnt worry about it But this is fact that We co sleep with out children,we feed them by our hands,we apply tika on teir forehead and its just norm to us n not to some countries But luckily California sooo open minded and inclusive 💜
@@renuhazari544 you can do all those things and more in norway too ... also I know about California because my cousins live there. it is a lovely place for some things but still can't beat norway
The world should know that never mess with a country like India. Indians will set the new global rule under which everybody (including repeat : everybody) will flourish properly.
Latest update- read a newspaper article this evening. The Indian couple were NOT charged according to the fact that they were sleeping together with kids, or feeding by hand, according to local police officer in Stavanger, Norway, they were charged on other reasons. Supposedly, the local police were called to their house on MULTIPLE occasions, due to domestic trouble, shouting etc. Also, the father says in this article that the film portrays him wrongly, and that he never beat her. He is afraid to return to India, as he most likely will have to go through a long prosess in court.
Well the film came out more than 10 years later after this incident.. within this whole time the father never once came to see his own children.. when things got hard he went to Norwegian media and claim his wife was immature and mentally disabled and got separated from his wife.. to me that looks like for him his Norwegian job and citizenship was more important than his children.. and because of his and this government claims this women had to regularly go through psych evaluation back in India just to prove that she wasn't mentally disabled..
@@us-276 According to this article (postet yesterday), father said that he had suffered depression for 5 yrs. As I said, he is afraid to return to India in fear of repercussions. But; if he knows that he is innocent (is he?); why would he then fear returning to India? doesn`t make sense.
Indianexpress quote «Chatterjee vs Norway»: «There was no allegation of violence or incest. All the complaints were about the parents’ “care ability”. This did not appear to justify placing the children in permanent foster care, without allowing the parents to even visit them.»
@@us-276 I agree with you. Watch when the "Lousy Husband" gets OLD. He will pay any amount of money to come back to India for his RESPECT & DIGNITY. In the West at his OLD age he will be booked into a Nursing Care Home and will lose All his Respect & Dignity.
It hurts how you narrated it. Knowing father of child was such a bad person you addressed them as Mr Bhattacharya and his wife? Everything is wrong with this statement guys !
Those 2 years must have felt like 2000 years for her Norway and other Scandinavian countries should do ateast SOMETHING about their easily exploitable child protection services, which dont protect children but endager them.
The sad thing is that because of this movie, everyone believes it's purely due to cultural differences, the Norwegian government wants money and to just steal the kids away. No, the children would not have been taken away for eating with their hands, they would not have been taken away for anything that would not be considered abusive, neglectful or harmful. This movie not only fails to acknowledge the other side of the story, where many Indians and others live happily in Norway with their children, who eat with their hands and speak their mother tongue at home, without being torn away from their family. It fails to tell the true story, they never reached out to barnevernet to get the story. It's so loosely based on the reality that was, and focuses on trying so very, very hard on the sympathy to be for only the mother. It's a shame because what the real story could be - and this had potential to truly show the reality of the whole situation they were in would have been a real criticism on the Norwegian welfare system, truly a look into the psychological side of what happened and show the culture differences, be a started to create discussion and improvement. The barnevern could and still can't say much about the case; but there was concerns of domestic abuse, there was police reports from several disturbances, and concern for welfare checks. Also the children was not instantly taken away. Foster homes are only allocated after several warnings, and the local municipality keeps a watchful eye to ensure that the children are satisfied and well cared for. One of the main reasons children are taken away from their families, especially in the more public cases has been from what I've read - parental abuse. Hitting your, or others children is considered Abuse and assault, and is 100% illegal in Norway. You may say "it's what we do, we discipline our children, i worked out well" But this is one "cultural" thing that will never be budged on, as it causes trauma and physical health is at risk.
I believe kids should not be hit either, but taking them away from their parents for a reason they didn't have solid evidence to support? How's that justifiable? And I agree, this movie could have done a lot better had they at least tried to portray the other side neutrally. But I'm sorry, this is one case where I'm definitely with the mother. Nobody has the right to takeaway someone's children based on their own judgements without solid proof of wrongdoing. As far as physical abuse goes, I am honestly not sure if a slap counts as abuse. That's one thing all kids have experienced here in India at least once, when they're being extremely unruly. I am definitely not in favour of that happening, but to take kids away from their family isn't the solution. Maybe councilling is.
There are tens of thousands of children who disappeared in Europe... What happened to this mother is not an isolated case... Sweden is proud of having kidnapped 28,000 children from their parents in one year. You can imagine how many children have been kidnapped in Europe in the past few years.. Do not forget the mass graves of children in Canada, the Europeans in Canada kidnapped indigenous children from their parents... These children were tortured, raped and killed inside the church. Europe has a long history of child abduction and rape.
Just simply admit that Norway have a barbaric society as per their DNA like Vikings... Bloody cultureless and insensitive society which cannot understand a simple thing that how much important to have child to be their own mother.... it's a very simple and basic thing in any civilized society but obviously it will not find any place in Vikings barbaric society...
@@mihirojha4475 how will you collect solid proof if your parents hit you inside your house? assume that you are the chief of the child protection department.
@@KiranKumarBokkesam Denmark me baith baith Kar hame pls gyan mat dijiye ki ham kya kare. India itna aapko kharap lagta hai to yahan aakar Human Rights Movement kijiye
The movie is about basically a bunch of Karen’s belonging to a misspelt Welfare department abducting a Bengali woman’s kids bcos she was being a desi mom 😂🤷🏻♀️
Germany girl baby case, baby had injury and had to stitch private part, how the hell baby would get hurt.. cant support just because someone just because indian they should be human first
Bahut shauk hota hai Indians ka bahar ja kar dusri country ki citizenship lene ka... but according to me... aap bahr jao studies kar lo paisa kama lo sab kar lo but laut kar India hi aao or yahi ke citizen raho.. thats the safest.
@@KiranKumarBokkesam I would any day prefer to live in lndia than some tyrannical controlled society like the European countries. By the way l have done my Masters from Hannover , Germany and have lived in both Canada as well as the US for over 15 years before returning to lndia and starting my own business. So l have experience of living in both Europe as well as America . The worst and most racist place l have lived is in Europe. I understand your predicament of having to live in a rotten and decaying place like Denmark and its frustration. Have you read Hamlet by Shakespere where he says and l quote " There is something rotten in the state of Denmark". That is what you are Rotten lnside.
Tit for Tat .... 2-3 German / Norwegian tourist k baccho ko pakad lo .... Saab gore line par aa jayenge ... Just bolo parents were abusing by piercing kids mouth with fork...bus itna hi
European countries can do hundreds of good deeds, but when you take away children from their parents on trumped up charges simply because as a country you are ignorant, then there is nothing good or decent about said countries.
@@ranjininaidu2103 exactly.. there is nothing more important than a child to his/her mother and vice versa .. these western countries with step mother/father/sister and what not will never understand the importance of relations
@@ranjininaidu2103 they don't take away children for silly reasons. I live here in Denmark. I have friends in Norway. this movie is exaggerated. And even if they do take away the child, the child is taken way better care of than an abusive parent. It is not like you can't get your child back. At least children here have way more rights and social security and wealth from the moment they are born, unlike in many other countries.
Such a shameful act done by Norwegian Govt. Separating children from their mother is not only jst wrong its a sin as well as crime. One of my dream was to go Norway and settle there bt after this I started hating them their country , culture and their system.
@@TheDjevelIn4llofus-mj6wz don't grandparents and aunts or uncles or other relatives raise some children in India? your kids won't get taken from you in Norway if you don't get convicted of abusing them.
This was not the struggle of an Indian couple, but it was the struggle of an Indian mother.
It does not surprise me. 25 years ago I sat listening to a Sami man who cried because his children were bullied by Norwegian kids. Norway has a dark history of cultural assimilation which in short means that the indigenous peoples should adapt and become Norwegians. They stole Sami children and forced them to forget their language and culture.
Its scary, imagine being and living there in such suffocating environment where everyday you fear of losing your identity, your culture and your family..
@@fanbhagatsinghda6200 it doesn't happen anymore. It was long back.
@@KiranKumarBokkesamHey bro why u so sound like “Norway ka Dalal”?
@@whoaskedxdegfx I think he's the dalal of Norway
Bokkisam, is that an Indian name @@KiranKumarBokkesam ?
For your information, what *@Fan Bhagat Singh da* says is happening at this moment in 6 European countries. And that is just one of the torture parents and kids are going through besides being broke ... do u know how many parents and kids have committed suicide? Go read or watch real life stories. Most of them are being erased by child services and corrupt politicians. Many foreign kids are stolen to convert them.
Just watched the movie and in complete shock. Cannot put in words what the mother must have gone through. She indeed is a strong women who fought against all odds. Thank God she was reunited with her kids. I wish no parent ever have to face such a situation
next time a norwegian couple feeds their kids with spoon and fork in India, Indian authority will take custody of their kids saying its endangerment of children with metal object.. and make the couple's lives miserable.
Its jz not fork or sleeping with kids. Father used to hit mother n children.
@@wasimgill4101 oh..wow! i didnt know that, in that case the authorities should have provided child custody and protection to wife, imagine what the wife went thru...lossing kids and facing domestic violence from husband
@@wasimgill4101 lol so why wasn't wasn't case filed on him
@@deepg2477 That chiId was sexually assaulted by her Parents
It's normal in Indian culture but in Germany It's a crime and justified for child safety
not our way bro. we actually respect others.
I was 17 only I didn't hear about it much but when I got to know from my mother I literally cried out..and after watching the trailer I just got goosebumps..Western countries will perish one day..Mark my words..
Bruh you don't know the whole story. When you are in there nation you have to follow there rules and the solution was she moved back to India and she did by the end.
So we should impose our policies on them too dare the child sleep alone
huh?
@@saichaitanya2329 you dont know anything, its a system child kidnapping and not just rules duhhh
EXACTLY THEY NEED TO GET PERISHED
One of the most beautiful movie..which melts our heart...mother is always be a mother nothing is more powerful than the word "MOTHER"..
Indianexpress quote
«Chatterjee vs Norway»:
«There was no allegation of violence or incest. All the complaints were about the parents’ “care ability”. This did not appear to justify placing the children in permanent foster care, without allowing the parents to even visit them.»
Understanding the Indian culture and upbringing of our country, now what steps are the governments of these foreign countries taking to return our kids?
That chiId was sexually assaulted by her Parents
It's normal in Indian culture but in Germany It's a crime and justified for child safety
It's not about culture.
As the trailer showed they make money by putting kids in foster care and they make up bogus reasons to take them away from parents.
I learned about this about a year ago when stories were coming out about them taking away kids of refugees since the country of origin can't intervene.
culture? looks like old fashioned racism
Stop going to their counyryband proving our real begging bowl situation . Let them also realise that cheap labour is needed in running their factories then they will call us on our terms. NOT all Countries are Bankrupt Like USA and UK .
Norway country , Germany etc stealing kids- what kind of countries are they.
They shamelessly doing it in name of fake democracy.
Reason - parents feeding child with hand etc
I'm watching the movie now and, it's heartbreaking to watch ...what a cold society, horrible what this lady had to go through....not a country I'd want to visit, poor lady! A parent's worst nightmare
Whatever their intentions were they had no right to take away the children from an attentive mother. Prior to this movie I was not even aware of this, now I keep seeing this is an actual cruel occurrence in Norway where they take away children from their parents. It’s absolutely sickening to see some people have no empathy and humanity in them
you are very wrong
@@KiranKumarBokkesam Wrong about what exactly?
@@yellow8879 this is not a documentary, and it is a fictional and commercial movie. it has some truth but not the entire truth. child cases are extremely complex, and it is not how it seems
@@KiranKumarBokkesam Maybe you should read my initial comment instead of jumping into conclusions. I wasn’t talking the depiction of the movie I was talking about the actual experience of whom this movie based on. I’m aware this is a movie and dramatization is something that’s inevitable. Those other cases I mentioned about they are not my words nor my experiences rather experiences of others. You seem to have bias, since you keep defending Norway and tbh I don’t care about that. All I know is I’d still have the same response if this was any other country. I don’t agree nor support children being taken away from their attentive and loving parents
@@yellow8879 why would anyone take away children from attentive and loving parents?? That is the plot of the movie RRR. there is a RUclipsr called 'Namaste from Norway' who made a video on this with a woman who used to work in the child welfare system of Norway. It did make some past mistakes and has learned from them. It's not like that anymore. I don't know how you are forming your opinions. this movie has only consulted the mother and not the father. and it has neither access to the actual case because it is confidential. I am not jumping to any conclusions. I am ready to talk about it. You may always email me. I live in Denmark which is a neighboring country to Norway and is considered inferior to Norway. I have nothing to gain from defending Norway. It's currently the world's best country overall in many social indicators. It is a huge shame and a waste of resources for someone to make a movie like this to make money by appealing to people's sentiments and emotions rather than being honest and educating about this country's systems. Indian people and culture in general are well respected in the entire world including Norway. It would only be fair for us to do the same towards others. making such movies and misleading people helps nobody.
Feeding from hand is sign of love and care omg they are crazy
sick western culture
What a hypocrite Germany’s foster care system is seriously really bad bad bad
So sorry for , this happens in Norway every day all year Thanks for the movie Mrs chatterjee
its difficult to understand force feeding as an Indian to me as I am the child who literally a lot of beating from my mom for not eating my food and supplements.I still got shouted on this but I did not found it wrong nor I do now , for me when I talk about it looks funny . and this is really common in family as we kids do not take proper food .
i was pushed so much about eating as a kid that i hate it as an adult. one of my cousin's used to be force fed and she is very obese now.
@@ggwhhbb1822 thr is a difference between overfeeding and proper feeding.. parents knows that green veggies grains and fruits are good for children.. but children loves to ears chocolates ice cream and other junk food like n oodles samosa chaumin and soo on
They won’t understand people who take appointments to meet their family won’t understand
@Heera Subedi I never spoke about domestic violence it is about feeding with hands which is not forced feeding in certain cultures and you study the cultural diversity of Asia before barking here.Something for your brains The Nordic countries are considered to be the most gender equal in Europe, with Sweden, Finland and Denmark consistently ranking among the top 5 on the European Gender Equality Index. Yet, 32 percent of Danish women, 30 percent of Finish women and 28 percent of Swedish women aged 15 or older have experienced physical or sexual intimate partner violence (IPV)-a stark contrast to an EU-average of 22 percent. Similarly, the occurrence of psychological partner violence as well as violence by non-partners against women in these countries is higher than elsewhere in the EU
What I am now in life is all because of beating from parents when I was kid
Outstanding 👍🏻 Rani 😢 v pain full story 😢
Rani is awesome 👌
Rani is the best …..Only mother can feel the pain of separating from her children uffff what a pain god bless you mother 👏👏👏👏
my mother separated my brother from me. now talk.
@@KiranKumarBokkesam go talk to your mum then. Not to a random stranger on the internet.
Norwegian welfare authorities need to be very careful. This is such a torture for the family and children n extended family.
Terrible reporting. No mention of the fact that she was in abusive relationship with her husband, no mention of the fact that her children had autism, no mention of the fact that she would beat her children. While I understand that she's a mother, it's more important that children have a good childhood and their needs met by someone who is capable of dealing with the challenges of a difficult child. Would you want a differently abled kid to sleep in the same room as an abusive father? This movie creates a narrative that is dramatic but ultimately untrue and biased.
Are you saying the children were abused? The eldest was 1.4 years old and the youngest was 3 months old when they were initially taken away. Why shouldnt a 1.4 yr old sleep with his parents? My friends Malaysian of Chinese descent have 2 girls 4 years apart. They co-slept with the elder girl until the second child was born. Then the second girl co slept with the parents until she was 4 or 5. The mother is asia-pac manager of a leading pharmaceutical company and father is a doctor like myself. So what is wrong with co-sleeping? My friend is a strict mother and values discipline. Like any Asian parent. How is this considered as abusive?
I don't know about this case of what's truth and what's not. But Growing up with an abusive environment as of myself, is not good for a child... Say it abuse towards the child or abuse towards the mother or other family member. It scars you for life...
East and West... always India is the best💪🇮🇳 no other countries are beat India... Proud to be an Indian 🇮🇳💪🙏
Norway ranks world number one and India ranks world number 101
Fix your rape problem and overpopulation and disparity and lack of humanity and racism first.
@@KiranKumarBokkesam Nikal laude pehli fursat mein nikal
@@KiranKumarBokkesam so what ? Go and live in Norway. Leave ASAP
@@troi818 EXACTLY¡ well said bro. Such chucks should leave india ASAP
I am thanking God for having born and brought up in Bharath. We do not have such a stringent law enforcement wrt child right protection
I'm ashamed to be part of india,Maharashtrah.😶
Failure country Bro.😂
lol 😂 😂 so then why are you thankful?
@@KiranKumarBokkesam thankful that we can feel what the love of family means, thankful for that when our mother feed us by all her love so that we will be more attached toh her ,thankful for the bond we can have because when she feeds you by giving up all other works you get to know how precious you are to her, thankful for we are democratic and don't have this much loop holes in our laws like Norwegian, thankful for atleast can raise our voices for when something bad happen .., good and bad happens in every country but because a mother feeding their baby is a crime than its nonsense a small baby newborn can't eat a mother have to feed their milk toh that new born why don't they also call it force feeding as a new born should drink milk by their own ...
@@KomalKumari-vm8vw, you seem very naive and ignorant and are wrong and need to read more and travel more. All those nice things happen in Norway too and you are wrong about being able to raise your voice in India and about the loopholes in Indian and Norwegian law.
The other side of the coin is that child abuse is woefully under reported.
Case in point families should do more due diligence and research before immigrating to foreign lands. and dont go to countries that seem to offer the most but often do not
We are very proud of India people for making this movie
why? the movie is made by a private company with allegiance to the ruling party and is made for profit
@@KiranKumarBokkesammajority of India chose the party. maybe you should leave to pakistan if you cannot respect democracy
الدول الغربية دائماً تريد أن نصغي لثقافتها الساذجة المنحرفة العرب والهند ثقافتنا متشابه نحب صغارنا وعوائلنا
HOW DARE THEY!!! THIS IS THE MOST RACIST THING EVER. NORWAY SHOULD LEARN AND RESPECT OTHER CULTURES.
Right on...a evil evil nation. I wish people would not go to those evil racist nations💯
Yes
no one should force feed kids , no physical violence to kids
Indianexpress quote
«Chatterjee vs Norway»:
«There was no allegation of violence or incest. All the complaints were about the parents’ “care ability”. This did not appear to justify placing the children in permanent foster care, without allowing the parents to even visit them.»
Right but good to have church burnings and become arsonists….😂
Germany case s utter nonsense. Germans were right. As a Dr. My question hw does vaginal tear occur n baby nd y the Indian government supports family t get bc k t mess thy created for baby. Thy shud ne er get the child.
A vaginal tear s serious crime.
This is not the German case though. It's Norwegian. And I'm afraid here in the mother is right.
@@mihirojha4475she is referring to the German case of Ariha Shah. Not the Norwegian one of Mrs. Chatterjee
Awesome 👌 👏
Norway is a sad sad country
Have you compared the social indicators of Germany, Norway and India? I'm sure there's more to the case than what you are showing
Angrej ka 14 😂😅
ya Norway has bunch of chads and Karens who judge hand feeding and disciplining. This is part of being a desi parent and I agree that people should abide by a countries rules but the point of this is also to shed light on shitty policies and greed in country that otherwise appears modern and inclusive
@kiran why are you spreading hatred everywhere in every comment. You should mind you own business. No one cares if you are in Norway or not.
@@deesa701 😂😂😂😂
Lol another male Karen spotted here😂
Shame on Norway and its racist behavior . And more shame as they think its propaganda . They should be apologise and bow to modiji. Bengali is official Indian language .
How ignorant are these European countries even in the era of social media. I wouldn’t step a foot in these countries as an Indian let alone live there. Shame on these governments for breaking families.
who wants abusive families to be together?
@@KiranKumarBokkesam who needs opinions from a man who thinks out of his rear end.
@@KiranKumarBokkesam u r materialistic person... For mother... They would die for their child.... His husband was abusive towards her... But not with children... N this doesn't imply to run away with kids second better done was parents divorce... Did u read human psychology biological mother milk does amazing thing.... They preventing the kids from there.... Wen it's abt child she left the crores n countries facilities with no one second.... Live with ur 🤑 money.....
@@TheDjevelIn4llofus-mj6wz😂
@@KiranKumarBokkesamIndiaphobe spotted.
Norway 🇳🇴 is shame for humanity
Sorry but s3xual assault is a big accusation, there is no 'cultural differences' there; better safe than sorry so hopefully it was properly investigated.
Hopefully but a lot of the time the authorities themselves place these kids in the hands of p3do’s. especially in dirty western europe, these people travel to asia and SEA just to defile children.
As far as i know, Ariha's medical examination found that she had injury in her private parts. Therefore they suspected SA.
I am wondering how does a child gets injury as such. Am i understanding something wrong here?
To be honest we only get to listen only one side of story. Other side which is Norway child services we never hear anything from them. Father asked divorce saying mother used to hit him as well.
In most of these cases generally neighbours inform police if they hear hitting, crying babies etc. Only after that this child care people start keeping eye.
They can not be there all the time and no one will do the hitting part when they are there.
They somewhere mentioned that kids even used to get scared to go to mother. I understand all our parents love us including my parents but even my mother has sometimes hit me to the extent which could be illegal if I was in Norway.
First: This mother did not hit her children, they took her children from her because she was feeding them with her own hands. They kidnap children for stupid reasons.
Second: Even if parents beat their children, this is not a sufficient excuse for kidnapping children from their parents and destroying the family.
We mostly beaten by our mothers, and when we remember this we find it funny. But when you remember that you were kidnapped from your parents, you suffer all your life when you remember that you lived far from your mother, and you feel that your childhood and your identity were stolen from you.
@@salimd7842 who told you that child was taken due to force feeding? This was mentioned by parents and they succeeded in giving us wrong information. We never heard side from Norway authorities. Recently one officer in Norway said that he can not disclose the reasons but it was not related to co-sleeping or force feeding. Jab to me choti thi tab maine in parents ko news me Dekha tha. Tab Norway ki govt pe itna gussa aya tha. Par ab jab Germany Ka case Dekha to samajh aa raha he ki kabi bhi sirf ek side sunke nirnay nahi Lena chahiye.
@@salimd7842 no. you have got it wrong.
@@salimd7842 - The Second point you made is exactly why kids need to be taken away from physically abusive parents in other countries. Forget India...parents and people will never change over there.
@@alwaysSifyable How do you that this false? You accuse the parents but not the norwegian government for their pathetic laws. If the didnt want her kids, why would she fight the government tooth and nail to get them back. I implore you to use your brain to think not your rear end please.
Omg this scared the hell out of me…i feed my 2 years old boy with hand..i live in us california and aw he is having iron deficiency doctor routed me to health care team and they asked me if he self feed or not ….😮 im gonna lie now.
it would help if you didn't lie about anything. instead, it would help if you cooperated with them. they are there for a reason. it is this kind of behaviour from foreign cultures that makes them more suspicious and also causes trouble to other foreign parents who are honest.
@@KiranKumarBokkesam lol im being honest till now dnt worry about it
But this is fact that
We co sleep with out children,we feed them by our hands,we apply tika on teir forehead and its just norm to us n not to some countries
But luckily California sooo open minded and inclusive 💜
@@KiranKumarBokkesam Force feeding kids and have your own kid share the same bed make them into monsters and arsonists?
@@TheDjevelIn4llofus-mj6wz this movie is fictitious and not based on facts. you can do them in norway without any problem
@@renuhazari544 you can do all those things and more in norway too ... also I know about California because my cousins live there. it is a lovely place for some things but still can't beat norway
Struggle of an Indian COUPLE??? What couple? Who couple?
The father needs to be jailed as well.
If it happened to a American couple, Norway would have licked the floor.
She is a great mother who fought the arctic scoundrels!
say what?
@@KiranKumarBokkesamnorwgain oil parasites
@@KiranKumarBokkesam Male Karen - Kiran.
@@TheDjevelIn4llofus-mj6wz bahut america ka tv dekhte ho lagta hai
@@KiranKumarBokkesam kepala otak ko la.
Rani u r superb.. 😘😘😘😘😘
The world should know that never mess with a country like India. Indians will set the new global rule under which everybody (including repeat : everybody) will flourish properly.
Too much developed countries!
That chiId was sexually assaulted by her Parents
It's normal in Indian culture but in Germany It's a crime and justified for child safety.
@@medanchess7892 do you think I'm a fool to believe this nonsense!🙄🙄
Not called developed country, it's foolish country, boycott country..
@@absolutetruth7232 what did he say anyways.
I support russia for invade the europe
Latest update- read a newspaper article this evening. The Indian couple were NOT charged according to the fact that they were sleeping together with kids, or feeding by hand, according to local police officer in Stavanger, Norway, they were charged on other reasons. Supposedly, the local police were called to their house on MULTIPLE occasions, due to domestic trouble, shouting etc. Also, the father says in this article that the film portrays him wrongly, and that he never beat her. He is afraid to return to India, as he most likely will have to go through a long prosess in court.
Well the film came out more than 10 years later after this incident.. within this whole time the father never once came to see his own children.. when things got hard he went to Norwegian media and claim his wife was immature and mentally disabled and got separated from his wife.. to me that looks like for him his Norwegian job and citizenship was more important than his children.. and because of his and this government claims this women had to regularly go through psych evaluation back in India just to prove that she wasn't mentally disabled..
@@us-276 According to this article (postet yesterday), father said that he had suffered depression for 5 yrs. As I said, he is afraid to return to India in fear of repercussions. But; if he knows that he is innocent (is he?); why would he then fear returning to India? doesn`t make sense.
Indianexpress quote
«Chatterjee vs Norway»:
«There was no allegation of violence or incest. All the complaints were about the parents’ “care ability”. This did not appear to justify placing the children in permanent foster care, without allowing the parents to even visit them.»
@@us-276 I agree with you. Watch when the "Lousy Husband" gets OLD. He will pay any amount of money to come back to India for his RESPECT & DIGNITY. In the West at his OLD age he will be booked into a Nursing Care Home and will lose All his Respect & Dignity.
This is probably to address a larger problem of how children are taken away and how the Govt earns money out of it
It hurts how you narrated it. Knowing father of child was such a bad person you addressed them as Mr Bhattacharya and his wife? Everything is wrong with this statement guys !
Woah I knew this woman. We had a mutual teacher. She told us about this way before.
Those 2 years must have felt like 2000 years for her
Norway and other Scandinavian countries should do ateast SOMETHING about their easily exploitable child protection services, which dont protect children but endager them.
Don't go norway 😭 if u have children. 👍🏻
go Norway! best country. I live in Denmark. and yet Norway is considered better.
@@KiranKumarBokkesam Not when their take away kids.
@@TheDjevelIn4llofus-mj6wz they don't. many indian parents live there
@@KiranKumarBokkesam There also many immigrant parents who been victimised. Do you work for the barnevernet?
If I was taken from my parents like that I will be very happy
How can you say like that?
@@dipanjannath3710 have some issues 😣
Bagwan kare aisa hi ho tumhare shaat, aapke maa baap ko ek nalayak aulaad se chutkara milega
@@ayushi4719 yes they will also happy... I am their unwanted child and there are so many other problems they have with me.
@@surovitabassum5487 Sad life..😞
Earlier media used to highlight people issues properly, now it is only behind hindu muslim so noone showing ariha news properly
this was not such a big issue in the first place
oh my god .......how stupid is this system???
it is not stupid
@@KiranKumarBokkesam based on the film, can u share us what is not right?
@@KiranKumarBokkesam Its not stupid for those who think out of their rear end.
Did they ever hear about familyplanning?
Yeah, it's a never ending problem around the globe. At least West Europe trying to enforce it on some.
How true is the movie...
It's only focused on the mothers telling of what happened, no real acknowledgement to what and how things really happened.
@@BlameItOnTheADD so what do u think the true story is? Are norwegian accept other culture in norway?
@@aryaoktaviantara8789 of course they do. otherwise why would so many foreigners live there happily?
The sad thing is that because of this movie, everyone believes it's purely due to cultural differences, the Norwegian government wants money and to just steal the kids away.
No, the children would not have been taken away for eating with their hands, they would not have been taken away for anything that would not be considered abusive, neglectful or harmful.
This movie not only fails to acknowledge the other side of the story, where many Indians and others live happily in Norway with their children, who eat with their hands and speak their mother tongue at home, without being torn away from their family. It fails to tell the true story, they never reached out to barnevernet to get the story.
It's so loosely based on the reality that was, and focuses on trying so very, very hard on the sympathy to be for only the mother.
It's a shame because what the real story could be - and this had potential to truly show the reality of the whole situation they were in would have been a real criticism on the Norwegian welfare system, truly a look into the psychological side of what happened and show the culture differences, be a started to create discussion and improvement.
The barnevern could and still can't say much about the case; but there was concerns of domestic abuse, there was police reports from several disturbances, and concern for welfare checks.
Also the children was not instantly taken away.
Foster homes are only allocated after several warnings, and the local municipality keeps a watchful eye to ensure that the children are satisfied and well cared for.
One of the main reasons children are taken away from their families, especially in the more public cases has been from what I've read - parental abuse. Hitting your, or others children is considered Abuse and assault, and is 100% illegal in Norway.
You may say "it's what we do, we discipline our children, i worked out well" But this is one "cultural" thing that will never be budged on, as it causes trauma and physical health is at risk.
I believe kids should not be hit either, but taking them away from their parents for a reason they didn't have solid evidence to support? How's that justifiable? And I agree, this movie could have done a lot better had they at least tried to portray the other side neutrally. But I'm sorry, this is one case where I'm definitely with the mother. Nobody has the right to takeaway someone's children based on their own judgements without solid proof of wrongdoing. As far as physical abuse goes, I am honestly not sure if a slap counts as abuse. That's one thing all kids have experienced here in India at least once, when they're being extremely unruly. I am definitely not in favour of that happening, but to take kids away from their family isn't the solution. Maybe councilling is.
There are tens of thousands of children who disappeared in Europe... What happened to this mother is not an isolated case... Sweden is proud of having kidnapped 28,000 children from their parents in one year. You can imagine how many children have been kidnapped in Europe in the past few years.. Do not forget the mass graves of children in Canada, the Europeans in Canada kidnapped indigenous children from their parents... These children were tortured, raped and killed inside the church. Europe has a long history of child abduction and rape.
Just simply admit that Norway have a barbaric society as per their DNA like Vikings... Bloody cultureless and insensitive society which cannot understand a simple thing that how much important to have child to be their own mother.... it's a very simple and basic thing in any civilized society but obviously it will not find any place in Vikings barbaric society...
@@mihirojha4475 did you even read what she said?
@@mihirojha4475 how will you collect solid proof if your parents hit you inside your house? assume that you are the chief of the child protection department.
Rani Mukherjee, The Bollywood queen 👸 ♥️
I don't like her.
@@KiranKumarBokkesam Denmark me baith baith Kar hame pls gyan mat dijiye ki ham kya kare.
India itna aapko kharap lagta hai to yahan aakar Human Rights Movement kijiye
@@f.w.s.b6631 nahi. apke paas to bahut gyan hai.
@@KiranKumarBokkesam stop crying.
The movie is about basically a bunch of Karen’s belonging to a misspelt Welfare department abducting a Bengali woman’s kids bcos she was being a desi mom 😂🤷🏻♀️
Bunch of 😈😈😈😈 I just watched it and you are so 💯😂
Germany girl baby case, baby had injury and had to stitch private part, how the hell baby would get hurt.. cant support just because someone just because indian they should be human first
Boycott 🇩🇪
This Father Is Selfish
😢im.watching it rt now..horror story..Norway kidnaps 😢😮
Pati hamri tha 🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬
Bahut shauk hota hai Indians ka bahar ja kar dusri country ki citizenship lene ka... but according to me... aap bahr jao studies kar lo paisa kama lo sab kar lo but laut kar India hi aao or yahi ke citizen raho.. thats the safest.
really? A country that has such poor human rights protection and a poor rule of law?
@@KiranKumarBokkesam there is a book called Indian Constitution........
What on the earth is rule of law 😅 Angrej ka 14
@@KiranKumarBokkesam Not sure if India has poor human rights protection but they dont take away kids and have them become Breiviks and arsonist.😂
@@KiranKumarBokkesam I would any day prefer to live in lndia than some tyrannical controlled society like the European countries. By the way l have done my Masters from Hannover , Germany and have lived in both Canada as well as the US for over 15 years before returning to lndia and starting my own business. So l have experience of living in both Europe as well as America . The worst and most racist place l have lived is in Europe. I understand your predicament of having to live in a rotten and decaying place like Denmark and its frustration. Have you read Hamlet by Shakespere where he says and l quote " There is something rotten in the state of Denmark". That is what you are Rotten lnside.
Tit for Tat .... 2-3 German / Norwegian tourist k baccho ko pakad lo .... Saab gore line par aa jayenge ...
Just bolo parents were abusing by piercing kids mouth with fork...bus itna hi
try and see what happens
@@KiranKumarBokkesam try and see what?
What a stupid rule
I bet the father was actually abusive. He is the one to blame for all of this.
still not an excuse to kidnap your child. there are relatives. this child services cult should be shut down
Jo bhi Ho Hamara country is Best hai 😢
jo bhi ho? matlab kuch bhi?
Germany tu toh gyo
That chiId was sexually assaulted by her Parents
It's normal in Indian culture but in Germany It's a crime and justified for child safety
@@medanchess7892 that's normal in some culture? how old are you?
@@KiranKumarBokkesam age doesn't matter
@@KiranKumarBokkesam how old are actually?
jo bhi ho chaterjee ek no maal hai
Bhai desh mein raho apna. Edhar bhi job milta hain 🙄
Usake husband ko citizenship chahiye thi , usase Court me galat statement bhi Diya tha wife ko mentally unstable bol ke
She probably was a bad mom👎
The father is a horrible person.
Norway government is culturally very very backward…..sad
Wth 👁️👄👁️ is this
Vaha ke law ke hisab se ab usko dusri family ko 16 years tak de Diya jayega. Jaha vo Cristian school me Cristian culture sikhegi.
They are majority atheist countries
toh kya india me christian school nahi hai kya? aur india ke un christian schoolo mein "christian culture" nahi sikhaya ja raha hai kya?
You guys never show any of the good things these countries do. Or stress on those good things like you do with cases like this.
European countries can do hundreds of good deeds, but when you take away children from their parents on trumped up charges simply because as a country you are ignorant, then there is nothing good or decent about said countries.
@@ranjininaidu2103 exactly.. there is nothing more important than a child to his/her mother and vice versa .. these western countries with step mother/father/sister and what not will never understand the importance of relations
Slavery and looking down upon us is what they do the best
what good deed?
@@ranjininaidu2103 they don't take away children for silly reasons. I live here in Denmark. I have friends in Norway. this movie is exaggerated. And even if they do take away the child, the child is taken way better care of than an abusive parent. It is not like you can't get your child back. At least children here have way more rights and social security and wealth from the moment they are born, unlike in many other countries.
Such a shameful act done by Norwegian Govt. Separating children from their mother is not only jst wrong its a sin as well as crime. One of my dream was to go Norway and settle there bt after this I started hating them their country , culture and their system.
😂 😂 you are so naive. Norway is amazing
@@KiranKumarBokkesamOhh nice to u Norwegian bt the movie is also based on true event so not so nice for me fact is fact that’s it. 🤝
@@KiranKumarBokkesam youre mentally unstable.
@@whoaskedxdegfx the movie is not a documentary. it is a fictional commercial movie
Better stay in India
better stay in Norway. check the 'best countries to live' rankings
@@KiranKumarBokkesam go to norway if you want your kids taken and let others parent your kids….what a civiled world we live in 😂😂😂😂
@@TheDjevelIn4llofus-mj6wz don't grandparents and aunts or uncles or other relatives raise some children in India? your kids won't get taken from you in Norway if you don't get convicted of abusing them.