Ash Sarkar Calls Emily Thornberry Out On Palestine
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 22 авг 2024
- Novara Live broadcasts every weekday from 6PM on RUclips and Twitch.
Episodes of Downstream are released Sundays at 3PM on RUclips.
__________________________
Support our journalism by buying Novara Media merch:
shop.novaramed...
Donate one hour’s wage per month, or whatever you can afford:
novara.media/su...
More centrist politicians are going to come out and say they didn't know Israel would go this far. Don't let them. Everyone knew.
They were warned!
@@henrypierce8900 fr the last 25 years no less
Hamas shiuld have thought of that before poking the bear
When genuinely innocent Germans professed their ignorance of the holler cause, no one believed them; why should we believe these politicians for whom lying is in their nature?
@@henrypierce8900 By Israel itself, no less!
Thank you for exposing her outrageous hypocrisy
thornberry is as sincere as a bucket of sick!!! however, a bucket of sick may contend this!!!
@@normankennith7919huh my food poisoning actually came in handy 😂 i asked my bucket of sick it said its offended 😂
@@zachszone2072 i'm glad you brought it up! but she was chundering on a bit!
thornberry needs to stop telling porkies, although it does look like she has eaten some of them!!! unless she is a jewess of course!!!
@@zachszone2072apologies to your bucket of sick on my, as well as many others behalf.
watching news the otherday , Israel keeps brining on Spokesperson for the government with British accent
Ash Sarkar.
Always outnumbered.
Never outgunned..
Timesplitters reference?
And always wrong .
I'm gonna steal this and make a poster
Ask her how she claims to be a “libertarian communist “ in 2024 😂
Spot on
When grandchildren ask her what she did during the genocide, she can assure them that she supported the slaughter of 10's of thousands.
Once you've proven you're inhumane you can't prove you're human again
Yeah the Palestinians are awful aren’t they.
@@MrFoggy13 Pathetic
@@MrFoggy13Brain fogged up? Dementia?
@@adriftinaboat3452 don’t give them excuses they’re just bad people.
@@MrFoggy13 if all Palestinans could be judged by yhe actions of hamas then all brits and Americans should be held accountable for their actions against native Americans Indians and the Chinese
This was brilliant. Well done Ash for calling her out.
👏🏾👏🏾👍🏾
.. and so fluently articulate with apt selection of collective punchline words/ phrases.
This woman showed great courage! She was the only " honest" person in that program!
😂🤣😂🤣😂 there nothing funnier than seeing someone displaying willful ignorance and thinking others don't see through it. 😂🤣😂🤣😂
She has no argument! as long as Hamas is holding hostages Palestinians can't cry for Israel's reaction. Release the hostages and then complain about Israel's attack. This channel is full of BS. Instead of blaming Hamas and calling for release of hostages and a free democratic elections (not that Palestinians know what democracy is), they keep blaming Israel for doing the same thing every country in the world would do. Israel's priority is to protect Israeli civilians not Palestinian civilians. That responsibility is on Hamas and everyone is ignoring it.
Cutting the power, water and food is collective punishment period.
These politicians are shameful
Ash 🙌 Novara Media 🙌 for not letting Thornberry, Labour, or any of the rest of them rewrite history.
She is rewriting history. Hamas started this war, they could finish it. That they choose to hide behind their mother’s skirts shows how disgusting they are.
So the war started on October 7th 2023 and not 70 years before? OK!
@@graemebarriball303 This war started long ago. As the Israeli Palestinian war, since 1948.
@@huwwiliams8426it was started when the Arabs conquered that land a 1000 years plus before that
@@graemebarriball303 Uh, Hamas have agreed to the ceasefire deal, and yet Israel have to "check" what Hamas have agreed to, despite them proposing everything. We are waiting on Israel, NOT Hamas.
Gaslighting at its most insidious!
But that’s Novara media’s remit.
@@MrFoggy13 You obviously enjoy being gaslight🤣
@@MrFoggy13 mug
I'm slowly but surely beginning to accept the fact that labour in power will be just as bad as the Tories .
Worse
Awful realisation isn’t it?
Red and blue Tories.
Really? By every metric Labour outperforms Tories in government. Do you really think Netenyatu cares what we think ? What do Labour have in opposition apart from words ? Have you forgotten that they need to be careful to get in power first before they can do anything?
Worse than Tories. Forgotten that Starmer worked for free to get people off the death penalty.
There is absolutely no choice anymore. We need someone like Netanyahu to sort out our mess 😢
Defending war criminals since 1948
Indeed. The only loyalty they know.
pompous woman..this woman was a human rights lawyer????
Just like Starmer. What an utter disgrace they both are. And all in the name of the "Labour Party". I mean really! They certainly won't be getting my vote whilst they're fronting the Party.
Just like Kid Starver. Says a lot!
Sir Kid Starver @@sufmeister786
Scary
Exactly, its honestly unbelievable and shocking.
Thornberry was straight-up gaslighting
Is that the modern term for lying?
@@yabiggalla100% I don’t know why people insist on using tumblr lingo and just call it what it actually is
@@HahaDamn
Tumblr lingo?
The term gaslighting is used by psychotherapists and counsellors when dealing with NPD patients and specially their abused victims.
The term features legitimately in the medical DSM5 manual on mental disorders and has been in use long before Tumblr or even the internet existed.
The phrase was coined from the famous 1944 Ingrid Bergman movie in which a Narcissistic husband continuously erodes his wife's confidence through constantly manipulating the environment to support his lies.
In the movie the protagonist try's to convince his victim she is going blind by gradually dimming the gaslights in her home over a long period of time. He sends her insane.
Such as when Thornberry said, there had been selective journalism going on relating to that piece.
To cover her lies she manipulates the environment for the viewer instead of admitting she was wrong.
Its a form of narcissistic manipulation they use when caught out.
Gaslight is also a very good movie similar to Alfred Hitchcocks masterpieces.
@@yabiggalla
The term Gaslighting has been around for decades and is a legitimate term used in psychotherapy relating to Narcissistic personality disorder. NPD.
Its in the medical DSM5 manual.
Its a form of manipulation and more than just lies.
The term comes from the 1944 Ingrid Bergman movie (Gaslight) in which she plays an abused wife whose husband sends her slowly insane by lowering the gaslighting in her home over time using it to convince her she is going blind.
Its more than just lies.
Similar to the boiling frog theory.
Its insidious manipulation carried out over time to alter the victims perception of the environment in a relationship or trust partnership.
The majority of our liberal politicians use it these days because liberalism relies on convincing the voter into backing something they wouldn't ordinarily agree to and often against their will.
Like a genocide.
Politicians these days manipulate the viewer/voter after the event by changing the environment surrounding their lie to distract from the lie itself.
Thornberry did it twice in this interview.
Such as when she blames 'selective journalism'
to distract from what every viewer definitely remembers her saying on the original interview with Victoria Derbyshire.
Then she tries again by bringing George Galloway into the environment out of nowhere.
The purpose is to get you doubting yourself on what you thought she meant and not doubting her.
Gaslight is a classic movie.
Another good Psychotherapy term is flying monkeys which relates to the Alpha Sociopath or NPD using loyal minions to do the lies for them or attack the victim as a group.
Such as when many tory cabinet ministers did interviews trying to manipulate something heinous Boris said, or Sunak, Truss etc.
The term was coined from the Flying monkeys from the Wizard of OZ movie.
They are sent out as a group to mess with Dorothy's head..
The term is also in the DSM5 manual.
Thornberry is one also doing the work of lying for the Israel lobby.
@@yabiggalla No, it's the term for what it is.
If anyone says they didn’t know what the outcome would be they are either lying or they are totally ignorant. At no point in the 9 months has the retaliation been proportionate.
Once - not too long ago - I wrote "Ash Sarkar...you are a star!" Well, in this interview you certainly were STELLAR! Thank you to the Novara Team for articulatng, presenting and informing us in a manner all too often lacking in the mainstream media! KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK!
A LUTA CONTINUA!
Good for you, Ash, for speaking up against Labour hypocrisy.
Ash you were amazing ....you were also outnumbered but not outclassed ...respect to you
Yes.....she out classed then
Absolutely, well done.
Amazing indeed, but for Ash, just another brilliant day.
She’s just a gem, fearlessly and fiercely compassionate and incisive. ❤
How can these people sit there and just talk double standards. If Russia was doing this they would be condemning putin
When will the Palestinians have the right to defend themselves?
Palestine have thier state,under Palestine president,they have a good policeforce,they should have a legal army
And how could they do that when everything they ever had is utterly destroyed. I've never seen one single Palestinian holding a weapon, ever. No gun, no knife, no rocket, nothing. And when they wave a white flag or hold up their hands they are shot. Israel will live with their shame forever.
They do...they just started a fight they cannot win....so are now pretending to be the victim. They should have told Iran to 'foxtrot oscar' when they were told to provoke Israel
@@LeahJosefinaGonzalez I don't think you quite understand... Palestinians have armed IDF Israeli soldiers in their 'state' & they certainly didn't invite them there (look up 'Occupation'). Their homes & businesses are burned down & 'Israeli settlers' throw them off their land & take it to build homes for themselves.
All Palestinian movements are monitored by the Israeli state & they need a 'pass' to go from one area to another.
In the next life apparently
Emily has nowhere to hide. Ash offers her the alternative of either you were too stupid to see what the rest of us could all see or you didn't care, and Emily makes a pathetic attempt to try and wriggle out of this.
Set her up like a barrister would. Also, Ash opening remark - i am sitting opposite two very intelligent people, sweet talk first.
that should be the title of the video.
Ash clouted her to political toddler level!!!
She is outright contradicting herself !!
" They are right to cut off water electric and food but it has to be under international law". ???
How is this individual anywhere near pokitics in the UK of Israel. !!
Same with sir stalin, and he's a human rights lawyer!
Attorney general , doesn't even know the law
@@henrypierce8900 Allegedly .
@@henrypierce8900 Thornberry was as well. Sure that's what was said in interview.
A liar, becomes a thug and could become a murderer and or a rapist. Been proven time after time.
How is it that Israel has the power to cut off water, electricity, food, etc., to Palestinians and folk are just accepting of this appalling power imbalance?
How on Earth would cutting food and water for a "short" period help them get the hostages back?
Far too many innocent people are being killed.
What's stopping Hamas from surrendering? You are more bothered about the loss of life than they are.
They started it off by killing innocent people
So you think that you should surrender to a force that has been slaughtering civilians and children for over 6 months??
@@wadtony123talking to you.
Britain killed more in Dresden Olin one day and America killed 100,000 in one day in Hiroshima. Sorry but what war are you talking about that tons of civilians aren’t killed????
Well done Ash 👏🏼👏🏼
What about the Palestinian hostages in Israel???
Sorry Thornbury, we don't believe you.
Thornbury is disingenuous
Too kind.
Politicians are disingenuous
@@PortilloMoment She's not kind. She's ruthlessly ambitious the same as her master.
@@nigelhaywood9753 I think it’s quite obvious the commenter meant calling her ‘disingenuous’ is too kind. She’s quite obviously a deceitful demon.
Still hot though
4 pro Israel versus Ash Sarkar is probably a 50-50 duel.
🤣🤣🤣
It’s not against Israel to draw attention to war crimes. Labour cannot gaslight this. They refused to be impartial and it’s not pro Hamas to call that out.
No, more like 20-80.
Usual BBC "un" bias.
That ratio is the best you can hope for on the BBC, oftentimes it’s an all pro Israel panel!
There is something deeply vile about a well-fed woman talking about cutting off food and water to children
Spot on
Ditto Nick Ferrari.
Emily “Labour Friend of Israel” Thornberry.
We're painfully aware that you've been doing this for a long time Emily Thornberry
And this woman is a lawyer!!! Hypocrisy all the way.
Just like Starmer.
Surely you're not expecting lawyers to be fair, or honest?
Well, she is led by Keir Starmer
Keir Starmer is also a human rights lawyer.
It's a lawyers job to pick apart the law and find loopholes for their clients. These people have no morals.
So according to the MP you can cut off the power from hospitals and incubators for Palestinians !!!!
Sick of their lies..gaslighting disgusting people. Well done Ash for holding them to account
Screw you Emily.....I watched you justify Israels actions. Labour are dead to me
With you 100% on that.
I will never forget when she was told "that's not the question I've asked", and her reply was "...it is *an* answer to the question, and I think an appropriate one at this time."
Any respect I had for her died in that moment.
she should go and find uncle nigel
Well! the 'COBYNATORS' can finally have it to themselves...
@@paulsworld7614ditto
" we have made it absolutely clear ". ???
Yes you've made it crystal clear Israel has the right to do whatever it wants !!
I love the expression on Ash's face. She's really no ones idiot
Thornberry backtracked with her genosplaining so much there I thought her head was gonna hit that bridge behind her!...She has the morals and ethics of the IDF!
Thornbury voted against a ceasefire measure in Parliament on November 16th 2023 ... She needs to define what "short term" means ...
77 years and still counting is a short term in her opinion 😂
perhaps, they've lack of insight, into the sheer gravity of the 'beyond the pale' violence, carried out by israel, thus 'dumb it dwn'..
There may well be breaches of law...
She knows there are breaches.
What a miserable liar.
Thank you Ash for shining the light on the BS 👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿
Well done, Ash. I could feel your controlled rage...I wouldve just lost it!
Well done Ash 🏴🇵🇸
Do you support gay people and women's rights?
@@ryansweeney1661no
@@user-dc9yv4rf1f why not? Are you not normal?
@@gavincampbell7690 What is normal?
Free palestine from islam
Ash is an absolute queen. I’m very grateful for your honesty and your integrity. ❤
Ash is a brilliant journalist AND a decent human beings..two qualities absolutely absent in the MSM in all of the western media.
Ashes to ashes, dust to dust! 🔥
Ash, your brevity in speaking truth to power is awe-inspiring!
So, Israel is saying that it has got the right to defend itself against the people whose land it is illegaly occupying? That doesn't make sense.
💯
Attacking is not defending.
It’s a level of hypocrisy and dishonesty that only a madman or soulless machine could claim.
@@extinction_event_5217That depends on your viewpoint, if your enemy is threatening there is a opportunity to strike first but in this case Hamas struck first everything else is spite and an attempt at the greater Israel project.
It's absolutely BONKERS! I KNOW!
Any food, water, electricity being cut off was going to effect children and civilians, we will never forget you pushed for this Keir, Emily and Lammy.
Absolutely right, well said.
Spot on!! They’re taking us for fools.
Collective punishment ok because … the IDF were ‘doing it anyway’ and it was chronologically close to Oct 7th. Lol, she’s a shit lawyer and completely underestimating the public.
They were not trying to get the hostages back Emily! They never were.
We say, "History will judge you" and Emily is experiencing that already her double standard.
Back peddling hard. We’re going to see a lot of this now and the mainstream media will let them
You can hear the emotion in Ash's voice. Bravo being able to stay as eloquent as usual.
Thank you Ash for speaking for the majority of the country. A big win for independent journalism. Im hungry, can we get sime more please 😋
I know Owen Jones is far too subtle to do the 'I told you so' dance at the Labour Party, but Owen Jones should totally do the 'I told you so' dance at the Labour Party. Ash Sarkar is brilliantly on point as always.
Well done Ash for exposing these war criminals and Genocide supporters
Ash has exposed Hamas? Good job.
@@MrsZambezi 'I'm not stupid, ur stupid' is a really weak response in any context. In the context of defending the killing of over thirty thousand people, it's an admission that you can't defend it.
@@MrsZambezi Nah she has esposed the army with western backing has killed over 35k people. but good try
Ash has so proudly announced "" I am literally a Communist " nuffsaid !
@@bluepeter1519 Why 'nuffsaid'? What do you mean? What has being a Communist got to with it?
yes, Ash, thank you for being a constant voice of reason. and challenge. Boy do we need your voice right now.
I thought Hamas was in tunnels. But now they are in Rafah? What happened to the tunnels?
Ash Sarkar is absolutely fearless❤️🇵🇸❤️🇵🇸❤️
Ash on top form as always and always uses her air time to make powerful and complex points so eloquently. And the look on everyone else’s faces. I think she beautifully shamed them!
Plus she has grace She didn’t interrupt them even when they were lying and talking nonsense. But they tried to overtalk her. Well done Ash.
I m sick of people having amnesia when it comes to 7th Oct and taking the moral high ground and if I want to listen to Hamas sympathizers then I will move to the Middle East , oh wait they all live in the UK !
Looolllll 😂😂😂@@Netflix999
Massive massive respect Ash
Brilliant analysis! This woman, Emily sounded deceptively sincere initially till they delved a tad deeper. Thanks for churning the rot to the surface. Well done Ash and the rest of the panel at Novara Media.
On what planet does democracy equal apartheid and genocide
maximum respect and gratitude for your words ...Ash thank you from the bottom of my heart! surely the British public deserve better politicians...Thornberry is such a spineless gaslighting wimp!
Ash.. A Big Thank You.
It's voices like yours that make huge differences by standing up to these people.
You're a credit to NM.
"Unless they're really careful"??? Are you kidding me??! Like, they've been so careful up to now, right? Thornbury is a frickin joke. Labour are finished.
Too much tolerance for Israel's evils. Just too much. It's sick.
Good for you Ash.
Thornbury is one of many reasons I'm not voting Labour again.
Me ever
She also hates England
@@benfisher1376Does she? How do you arrive at this?
@nicholasgerrish6022 She doesn't like the English flag etc.
Same as can't stand the pigwoman
Thanks Moyà, Mike and of course Ash ❤
Fantastic! Ash was so good! Would love to see her hold the Tories to account too.
"Absolute right to defend itself". The clue is in the word 'absolute' and the politicians have stood and watched.
Right. Insane language to use in such an emotionally volatile situation.
isn't it, their 'own' media, which have set up palestinians in a relatively limited way, if not 'negatively', so that now, many since past, have more limited references of them, just as israel prefers it, and, ime, would've any other population, if situated there..
The Israelis have rejected a ceasefire after Hamas agreed to one. Netanyahu never cared for the hostages or wanted a ceasefire.
That ceasefire never involved returning hostages
@@kevinwilliams1421no you're wrong. NetanYAHOO didn't agree with PERMANENT CEASEFIRE...EVEN WITH HAMAS SAYING THEYBWOUKD.
NETANYAHOO is on record to saying Palistinians in Gaza and West Bank should go to Arab countries. Or did he mean just for holidays. Sympathy for the devil is a song NOT AN INSTRUCTION.
"OOOOO OOOO oooo oooo"
@@deputyvanhalen6386Correct. The deal included returning of hostages and the only reason it didn’t go through was Israel turning it down, period.
Ash you are brilliant, please stand as an MP against her! ❤
Thornberry: "we have been completely clear on what we expect... an immediate ceasefire".
When did Labour use one of their opposition days to motion an immediate ceasefire demand?
And when did the Labour leader show his unqualified support for the zee on ist cause by perverting British parliamentary democracy?
Two conservatives sat next to each other and both lying as much as each other.
Red and blue Tories, like Galloway said two cheeks of the same arse.
" The quality of politicians " one of many superb lines Ash !!
On this topic, I find myself agreeing with these Communists. There is no way that I'm voting for the Labour Party. Not a chance!
Not gonna let you back peddle Thornberry or your boss. Your endorsement of collective punishment is on the record for all time
" I want to burgle this house, but in a lawful way" Brilliant . Ash Sarkar on point once again. ❤
Emily Thornberry has said in the past that Israel has a right to defend itself and did not condem cutting off food etc. Talking won't get anywhere we need to stop sending weapons. Another human rights lawyer enough said
It was at this point many of her constituents started asking her questions … she’s been awfully quiet of late .. hoping to avoid being called out. Well done Ash.
And folks that is exactly how you end someone’s political career. Nothing but FACTS! My goodness what a flawless victory for Ash Sarkar.
Ash should have pulled Emily up for the fact that Labour didn’t support a ceasefire as she claimed, they only supported a humanitarian pause to get hostages out and aid in!
Ash Sarkar is amazing. As bad as British Mainstream Media is, someone like Ash Sarkar would never be allowed on air in America.
You had Mehdi Hussain and he was popular on his show.There is always room for change.
@@lamueldagon7618 Mehdi Hasan is NO Ash Sarkar. Not even close.
@@spamfilter32 Well they are both culturally of a Muslim background and both British, both highly intelligent with different perspectives that challenge the status quo. I still don't see your point as change happens all the time even in America.
@@lamueldagon7618 Mehdi's show was cancelled, and Mehdi isn't even as left wing as Ash Sarkar.
@@lamueldagon7618 Ash Sarkar is a Communist. Mehdi Hasan is not.
Thank you Ash! Well done! 👏
Never voting Labour or Conservative again
Pathetic politicians...you carry on talking to the Isralies as they are obviously listening to you...not! A total disgracefulndisplay of complicity...shame on you. Well done Ash...brilliant, measured and intelligent.
Thornberry probably puked a little in her mouth when she realized that she had to debate Ash
A few pork pies probably came up
@beefybeef1326 now, now
Don't make me laugh at such stuff
The UK and especially the US answer to ISRAEL let me make that perfectly clear !!
By continuing to give Israel the green light throughout this Genocide they are FULLY complicit in what is happening. !!
Oh Mohammed, you have no idea what Genocide is.
@@paulphillips4267 And you do right because people like you are experts !!.
Why don't you tell the rest of us what Genocide is.....
Vile...Emily Thornbury gives off Umbridge vibes. Well done Ash! 👏
So glad Internet exists and we can all see her hypocrisy.
Thank you NM and thank you Ash.
I love strong intelligent women like Ash Sarkar.
Well done Ash Sarker for pulling up Thornberry’s disgraceful disingenuous faux condemnation.
Thank you to real journalists that ask the tough questions
Didn't she say......
" Israel has the right to defend itself ". !!!
This is when the Genocide and ethnic cleansing started so im very surprised she didn't say it again. !!
One of the dumbest things to say.
@@charisma-hornum-fries She is outright contradicting herself !!
She said Israel had the right to defend itself when when they stopped the water food and medicine !!!
Why is she denying this now does she think we are stupid or something !!
Not just that they have the right to defend themselves. They have the "absolute right".
@@FahadAyaz The ONLY ' illegal ' nation in the world that has the ' absolute ' right to defend itself. !!
apparently Iran isn't allowed to defend itself
Thorneberry .......... did anyone rate her? not me. Ditto Starmer.
Did you vote Brown or Corbyn?
Well done to Sarker for standing up to these Liars
We gotta protest more. The perpetrators are still on TV gaslighting