I decided to travel the Post-Soviet space, and to talk to locals about their life in the Soviet Union and after its collapse. Let's explore Georgia with me :) 📍 Thank you for watching and here are more videos of mine on this topic: ruclips.net/video/uakT5YGN2KQ/видео.html - Georgia before and after collapse of the Soviet Union (Big trip through the country) ruclips.net/user/liveOGLegTp-eBQ - Russia of the Soviet Union vs now | What has changed since the USSR?
Thank you Eli. I well remember listening to Radio Moscow here in Scotland at night broadcasting the exercise programs. It was fascinating to hear your interviews with local people concerning if they preferred the USSR to to Russia today.
19:49 Oh I jumped out of happiness seeing Liya 😀 The wonderful lady hosted me while I was in Gori.Liya melted my heart with the warm Georgian hospitality and took care of me.One of the best homes I have stayed so far anywer in the world🥰
Now that Bald and Bankrupt is not doing too many videos in post-Soviet countries anymore, we are now lucky to have a native Russian do such videos! Thank you
There’s a stark difference between the two, tbh I never liked Bald and the way he was presenting the places he visited although I watched some of his videos. Eli’s content is much, much better, no matter the country she visits.
@@minime7375 They're just different. Bald's is from the perspective of N outsider, and a blend of history, humour and wide eyed wonder and discovery. Eli's is more polished but presented with loving care and a more Russian perspective. To each their own opinion, but I like them both in their own way
@Eric-ii9ce 1. This isn’t a “propaganda video” so your comment is just petty 2. Plenty of journalists, including Western ones from left-leaning media freelanced or are freelancing for RT, the fact that youtube (and other non-free speech platforms) deemed it “Russian propaganda” doesn’t mean we’re all brainwashed. RT is available on Rumble and a lot of it has nothing to do with politics. 3. I don’t see why anyone feels the need to be nasty, if you believe her videos to be “Russian propaganda” scroll ahead nd don’t watch them, you wouldn’t want to be brainwashed into believing Russians are regular people and Russia is home to rich cultures. Leaving aside the fact that this video is from Georgia…
I'm a proud American, but I when I watch your videos in a weird way I feel like I'm in the room with you visiting your family or the people you visit. So I want to be respectful to the people even when I'm watching it on my phone. So I hang my ego up like a hat at the door and just listen. Always enjoy listening to other people's side of history. I think you do a beautiful job telling the stories of a place and people
Eli greetings from Albania. This is my first time commenting on your channel. I remember the days when our country and USSR were close allies. Now like many post socialist states we are sucked by Anti Russian mad propaganda and demonization of our socialist past and glorification of the West. This is not good. This is no less of a propaganda than Communist ones, not to say more. In your channel, you show us the real Russia, the real people, the real past and present experience based on ground reality. You are an ambassador of Russia and much of the places you visit than most people in power in Russia are today. Whether we like our communist past or not, admitting all its faults and crimes, compared to today, no, I would say today's situation is far worse than those times. Some might disagree. Everyone is entitled to their opinion. Despite all, I will not hide my sentiments, and say Glory to the Red Army, Glory to the USSR, to the russian and soviet martyrs, and glory to Stalin for whatever good he did without forgetting his bad and for freeing Europe from nazi bestialities. But certainly Nikita Krushchev who was passionate about de-stalinization was not that kind of a good guy either. But better than Gorbachev. Gorbachev sold out USSR, Russia and this entire conflict Ukraine vs Russia, Armenia vs Azerbaijan originate from Krushchev's times and became full blown during Gorbachev's rule. My point is, while we must not forget much evil that socialism might have had, its good surpassed its evil, in my opinion. We must not fall into idiotic historical revisionism and demonize all our past, a tragic reality many countries of the former Eastern bloc suffer, and some are pathologically obsessed with especially if they join NATO or the EU. Let's focus on the present and future, learning from the past from its mistakes and from its achievements unless we do not want to make the world a worse place than what already is. Wish you all best for your time and efforts you put to produce these priceless videos and documentaries.
"obsessed with especially if they join NATO" - and for good reason, otherwise you could by invaded by Russia like Ukraine. Just watch russian TV to see what they are able to discuss, very westernfobic and aggresive talks.
That tune wakes up my husband to go to work 😅. He's in his forties and misses USSR a lot. I remember this tune on my granny's radio when I was visiting her (I was growing up in Greece).
My favorite composer is Sergei Prokofiev who died on the same day Stalin did. Apparently there weren’t any flowers available because they were all used for Stalins funeral so they ended up using flowers made of paper for Prokofiev.
I'm so into everything about Russia and Soviet Union that I even started to learn Russian. U have a great channel. Greetings from ex Yugoslavia. Cрасибо
England had sanatoriums back in the old days. When Agatha Christie went missing for 11 days in 1926, she was found inside a sanatorium under a different name, having lost her memory of what happened.
My ex-husband's private super expensive school in England had a sanatorium. Re. Agatha Christie, I always wondered if she was doing some undercover research for a story.
Eli, I'm a senior American man, and have learned more from your tours and discussions about Russia and the Caucuses with local people than ever before. So nice to learn how they live and what they believe. I'd love to learn more about the people's Christian beliefs. Thanks so much
Tnis was a very interesting video! One can see how beautiful and grand that sanitorium was at one time. It's a shame it has fallen into disrepair, as well as some of those other structures. If a certain person in charge had focused on restoring and maintaining the land and structures he has instead of lusting for more land and structures, it would be a different world. As that old woman said, we all need to be friends. There's no need to be enemies, because our stay on this planet is very short. Anyway, I just love your sense of humor and your sense of adventure, Eli, as well as the fact that you seem to get along with everybody. You set a good example for all humanity.
America has been the aggressor since the Cold War, not Russia nice try at sneaking in some western propaganda, though ! America sponsored bloody coup 8 years of killing civilians in Donbas ? Western cancel culture is hilarious ! American, forever wars is what shapes the warmongering on earth these past 75 years. Get your head out of the sand ! Putin is breaking American hegemony, and we will have a more just world after. How are the sanctions going ? Russia has recorded profits less than 3% unemployment ! ❤❤❤❤❤
Another great video, Eli. I enjoy hearing the comparisons from people you interview, as to what was best USSR times, or Russian Federation, modern times. Lovely Destinations, interesting peoples. Thanks for posting, as some of us will never be able to get there, to have a look for ourselves.
Here in poland we have quite a few abandoned sanatoriums with 'healing waters', those rotten-egg-smelling ones, full of minerals. It`s unfortunate that people stopped coming there, now it`s super dangerous because most of the wells are in the basement and without proper filtration the whole underground level is full of co2, you will just collapse on the stairs down and never come up...
Gamarjoba Eli! Such a fascinating video of “Stalin’s Georgia!” Thank you so much for sharing your travel experience with us. I kept looking at a Georgia map to try track where you went to and try and picture myself there too. It makes it more real to me other than faceless names and lines on the map. The people you meet there seem so friendly and welcoming. Stalin’s history is so interesting. He is such a big figure in history yet he had humble beginnings. Whether good or bad we all share common human experiences. If only we can all be friends the world would be a much better place. Looking forward to the next Georgia adventure! Warm greetings from California! 🤩🤩🤩✌🏻🫶
Always look forward to your uploads. Interesting perspectives of the people living there. In US, we also had sanitariums back in the day but was mostly used for Tuberculosis patients - maybe other diseases too, but TB was the most.
these were more like spas (you can visit similar places in Budapest) with natural water springs (Different ones recommended for different maladies) and you would also have massages etc.... vs like a quarantine type one like for TB. lots of amazing natural healing waters throughout Europe (and I'm sure elsewhere but I don't know about it to say so :) )
I like your videos, showing different places in Russia and the former USSR. I am interested in soviet era history. I've never been to Georgia, but I hope one day to visit it. You just got a new subscriber :) Greetings from Bulgaria. Привет от България.
it's exremely interesting hearing people who preferred the USSR. We grew up thinking everyone hated living under the Soviets and everyone was thrilled when it ended. But how that guy spoke reminds me of hearing americans talk about how the 50s were better and today everything is crazy prices and generally sucks now. Global prosperity to depression is relatable in every country
American's romantisize the 50s-60s but people weren't exactly treated well, civil rights and vietnam, even italians were still treated like shit in america. but it still had a charm to it, things seemed like they could only get better where today it feels like it can only get worse.
12:22 OMJ(o my jesina), I'm so glad my Uncle Vanya (Ivan the Righteous) doesn't know your channel and probably wouldn't like it either. He would freak out if he had to watch this scene. That was his "deserved" favorite sanatorium back in the Soviet days!!! 😥🚩🕵🛂🛡🗡🛃👮🚩😪
Thank you Eli for this interesting and historical video about the Soviet times in Georgia. Merry Christmas and Happy New Year, full of joy and happiness❤⭐️🌲⭐️🌲
Thank you Eli. As always, your tours are so very interesting and informative, giving American people a much better understanding of Russian life and history. I greatly appreciate you dear one.
Thank you Eli for this lovely video i have visited Georgia before but didn't know about this place ..interesting town and love your videos as they are informative and fun at the same time .. love from Oman
I'm delighted you are doing this series on former USSR feelings, people and places. The story will be lost soon as those who remember die away. Young people will forge their own way of economics and politics, yet hopefully some will carry the ideals of USSR with them. Of course, the ideals were not met exactly since people everywhere, especially leaders, fall prey to elitism and hubris. Thanks for just showing us what you see. Sanatoriums were popular for many decades until the idea of corporatizing "healthcare" came along with specialists and hospitals. Profit, not health.
In the USSR, my father worked as a carpenter at a small enterprise. He had two vacations in similar sanatoriums. And both times at the expense of the company, with a very small surcharge. We probably judge the USSR by the stereotypes created for us by Hollywood.
7 месяцев назад+3
That is success :D, two vacations in whole misarable life spent in cue for the meat and banana. :D I have two vacations a year and I don't need and state support because I earn enough money to pay for that like most of us. Not like your father's misarable salary in some kind of "kolchoz".
You have no idea fool, back in the 1960’s it wasn’t bad, these old folks know what they’re talking about. But the world moves on, I moved to USA in 1972 , I am a Disabled Veteran of US Army and retired now. I can tell you, I worked my ass off here, paid taxes, paid off mortgage etc, I like USA, I went to Latvia in 2023 on vacation, it was a miserable place with hateful people, they looked scared, I split from there to Italy, now that is extraordinaire Rome Pompeii, Coliseum. Latvia is just bunch of slaves to a few rich, making miserable pittance and shitty healthcare
I’m from Quebec and i’ve been watching your videos a lot, i did not know much about Russia before! It’s so crazy to see this crossover episode i would have never thought Quebec and Russia would merge haha!
Thankyou for showing us a bit of Russian history that would have otherwise been keep a bit too quite, it was good to see some nice Georgian folks and see the amazing Sanatorium.
The conversation at 16:20 got pretty intense. You politely and bravely stood your ground presenting facts in a non-overbearing way. Accolades for your delivery, your smile and what you stand for. Much love from Canada.
Russia has made progress. In the old days such comments would have meant instant arrest and likely a prompt encounter with a firing squad. Except for the example of Paul Robeson, who could pull off a public challenge confronting Stalin because he was a famous foreigner.
That's not idle comments. That's everyday life and death the way it used to be. If you are that unfamiliar with history, you could start by reading up on Genrikh Yagoda or :Nikolai Yezhov or Lavrentiy Beria, paying attention to how they died. Try reading "Stalin: the Court of the Red Tsar" by Simon Sebag Montefiore. Or the numerous works of Solzhenitsyn. If you don't already know the answer to your own quandary, you obviously haven't familiarized yourself with much history as of the present time.@@carlosgaspar8447
An interesting fact is that the USA today imprisons more people than the USSR ever did, and the only people who went to the gulag were Nazis 😉. Stalin’s only mistake was that he didn’t imprison more of those people. If he had, the USSR might still be with us today.
WOW! This is really interesting Eli! Awesome video! And with a fellow Canadian). It gave me chills when you were walking down the stairs of Stalin's dacha because I just pictured him also walking down those stairs. Very interesting. I look forward to seeing more of your Soviet adventures) On an unrelated note, I am a cartographer and for a fun project I decided to recreate an old red army map from the Great Patriotic War. It's a map showing the red army attack on Königsberg (now Kaliningrad). When I watched your video about the fort there, I didn't realize how many forts are around the city! It's incredible!
This was very interesting and there was so much I never saw. It´s a shame to let the sanatorium or the datcha from Stalin rot to the grounds. Especially the sanatorium is still some kind of beautiful, but if it´s restorated it would be precious. I was very curiuos regarding the Stalin museum, the old style bath house and the train waggon. There is a lot of history left. It is definitive worth a visit.
Thank you for your videos, showing me parts of the world I will certainly never visit... and I love that you give expression to both sides, always. That's so, so important! It shows how complex history is.
Thank you, Eli, for this honest view of your Russia. I had planned a trip to Kaliningrad, but the war with Ukraine and the American Russophobia stopped it. Stalin was loved for stopping the Nazis, but hated for some brutality in gulags and with political enemies. My parents fought in WWII, and always had respect for Russians. They both met Nikita Kruschev - he loved the American farm tractors! That sanatorium is beautiful, and the tuberculosis sanatoriums here in the States were also often in the country -- but never so elegant. Virtual travel to Russia is all I can get now, so please keep exploring!
Eli, you know you give us a realist view without any propaganda of how things are in Russia and other places today and really broaden our appreciation of how things were and indeed are. We have learned so very much.
Interestingly, the music in the first 10 seconds of this video was used on the old Radio Moscow international shortwave broadcasts in the 60's and 70's. I believe the song was named "Moscow Nights". All the best, Will.
Beautiful story - time machine. Very similar, to ex Yugoslavia and their nations living together, with a difference of being able to travel abroad. Thank you very much, and keep up great travel adventures Eli...
But it is usually rewritten and "corrected" by power elites and conflict winners...unfortunately. The "art of sparing information out" is an important tool for that unfortunately widely spread way of of producing news, history books etc.😮 everywhere!!
Love your channel and your very informative videos. I hope they restore these incredibly historic places. Right now is ghostly. You can only imagine all the people who once walked those floors.
In the video, we can see how splendid the KGB sanatorium was. It's a shame to see it in this condition. It would be interesting if the place could be restored, even for the sake of preserving historical heritage. Thanks for the video, Eli.
It made me think of Versailles. Obviously it was once a beautiful facility and should be restored as such. Once it decays to ruin, the people will regret losing it.
@@user-dh6bj2me5p Georgia is not terribly rich country and there are many more practical concerns which need addressing. Hopefully as Georgia becomes more prosperous and more and more people discover what an excellent tourist destination it truly is, money will be spent to restore these buildings to their glory.
Or totally forget. I met a girl from Versailles and I said, "Oh, you're from the home of the Treaty of Versailles!" She said, "What?" because she never had heard of the Treaty of Versailles even though she had lived there for 25 years.@@user-dh6bj2me5p
Wow. So so interesting. As always, Eli. Well done. I didn't expect Georgian peoples reaction to stalins ancestry. If in fact he was of Georgian ancestry. Thank you so much for this great video!🔥
Veliky Stalin - Hero of the Soviet Union and Saviour of the world Stalin should not to be loved or reviled He must be acknowledged for his singular contribution to history, and therefore, he should be revered It is very disheartening to see modern Georgia - where Stalin should be a towering figure - engage in historical amnesia and revisionism
Interesting video series from Georgia. It surprises me... in 2016 I spent one year in Georgia and got in touch with many locals born after 1990... they have a totally different opinion on Stalin and USSR with respect to the elder people interviewed by Eli. Unlike their parents, they're used to the idea that everyone have to look for his own job and home, rather than waiting for the state to give them both.
Crazy to let a place like this fall into disrepair. It's gorgeous! I saw abandoned sanatoriums in Latvia, Estonia and Belarus. Not quite as grand as this though - 20th century design. It is very sad.
They did not just let it fall in dispair. Driving a wedge into the Russian-Georgia relationship caused the Russians not to go there anymore. Hence the collapse
У Грузии нет денег на реставрацию этого всего и нет желания, т.к. отношения с Россией испорчены и как правило в таких ситуациях пытаются зачеркнуть и забыть общую историю и все, что связано, а не восстанавливать.
Thank you for this History Lesson I learned about The USSR when i went to Grade School . Back in The early Years . 1960 "S . We had To Learn What The Words Meant . (USSR) How the people lived and there work also . We read this in hard covered books . There were no computers like they have now a days . And at the End of each school Quater we took written tests on what we learned . As well as of end School year exams on what they taught us during that year to pass and move on to the next grade or class . So much to remember back then . I look forward to watching more of your travels .
I remember when you first started doing this and I will say the same thing again your documentaries are some of the most interesting out there I am glad for your secess Miss Eli❤
Everywhere you go is an interesting visit Eli. I am from Quebec, Canada like Dominic, so I asked myself: what is this fellow doing in Georgia? You both seemed to be having fun.
Hi Eli! It is a disgrace that such a structure and service remains abandoned. It is certainly useful for those people who do not have a roof to stay under. It seems that after the fall of the USSR everything, besides the communist ideal, was deliberately left to its abandonment and degradation. This is a mistake that everyone makes when they leave a situation that had lasted too long and had become oppressive. I agree with the fact that at that time we wanted to free ourselves from an oppressive situation, for those who considered it as such, however, functional objects and structures can continue to be used because in the end they are only objects that have a valid utility like that healthcare facility. Another reason for not abandoning these functional structures is that at that time we have services to use and we don't know if after a regime the government that succeeds it can give to the people at least as much as the regime gave. In any case, Stalin had good taste in the architecture to be created because it is evident from the columns, from the large halls of the rooms, from the floors representing mosaics that Stalin wanted to recreate the beauty of classicism. It is interesting to hear the opinions of people who lived in the USSR period and see the differences between that time and now. Basically, every regime has given its people good things and bad things, then, there are points of view as to whether something appears better or worse. When I went to school, they always told us that Russian communism was something bad and despicable, but, I always wondered if it was like they said or was it just to make us believe that Russia is a place not to practice as much as the Russian people, therefore, we had to be indifferent towards them. Then I happened to meet people from Eastern Europe who lived under the communist regime and they all told me that in that period no one died of hunger because everyone worked and could bring bread home. After the fall of the regime, the first thing that disappeared was his work and consequently everything else. However, seeing videos of many Russian RUclipsrs, I noticed that Russia is a very strong country economically and I don't think I see people dying of hunger. This means that however the end of one era and the beginning of another brought good or bad consequences, there was simply an adaptation. In any case, Russia remains a great country that should not be underestimated and admired. Thank you for the content of this video, I greet you and hug you. 😊
Under communism Russia was basically a caste system of Soviet bosses and cringing flunkies. Russia never had more than about 7% of the population in the Communist Party, and those who knew it best regarded fellow communists as legions of ass-kissing whores and murderers. Principled citizens begged family members to not prostitute themselves into joining. There were always a few who drank the Kool-Aid and actually believed the highly structured lies, but as time went by fewer and fewer people were fooled until it all fell apart in 1991. The legend of "enough food" and "enough employment" was often achieved simply by killing off the surplus population until there was food enough to go around and jobs enough to go around. That took no brains or talent, just killing the innocent until those left standing were smart enough and scared enough to not complain.
7 месяцев назад
I lived behind iron curtain. Funny to see, how many people who did not experinced "soviet paradise of workers and farmers" suffered from its idealization. Men, were literally forced lived beding fence, who wanted to escape by crossing border was shot or jailed and persecuted. Get it?
Hello Eli I'm from Greece and I watch your videos. I'm big fan of Stalin and USSR and your videos proof that people in USSR have better times then than today..
Living in the west (Greece), I always considered the collapse of the USSR to be a good thing. Well we have thousands of Georgian ladies here, looking after our old people, our aging mothers and fathers, aunts and uncles. I was shocked to find out how NOSTALGIC they are about the Soviet times! And then I realized the difference in the perspective : we, westerners, approach the matter theoretically. For them it was the collapse of their world. From respectable home-owners they had to become immigrants, move to a land the language of which they didn't speak and stay confined in a flat changing the... bedsheets (to put it politely) of an aging, ailing, often senile person.
The communists always had full employment by having 2 or 3 or 4 people do the work of one person, and splitting up the paycheck accordingly. Or, Stalin would take the number of unemployed and have that many random people randomly killed. Nobody around to be unemployed meant no unemployment problem. In the 1930's, Stalin's quota to Khrushchev was to eliminate 40,000 random people in the Moscow area. Fewer Russians to complain about unemployment or not enough food. Khrushchev knew Stalin from the inside out, which is why he denounced him in 1956.
@@jackieowещё одна анти советская пропаганда. Такого не было и нет. Мои бабушка и дедушка очень хорошо относились к Сталину ! В стране был порядок и справедливость ! Не довольны Сталином только воры , бандиты , либералы, предатели .
By not being there, you must be wiser than Khrushchev who was there. You must be smarter than all the Soviet veterans Simon Sebag Montefiore interviewed for "Stalin: the Court of the Red Tsar." You must be more experienced and knowledgeable than Alexander Solzhenitsyn.@@ItsTristan1st
I was so sad to see the abandoned sanatorium's condition. Its natural surroundings, the beauty of the building, and the noble idea that built in the first place, all now lie in ruins. I hope this building is renovated. Thank you for showing me the hidden aspects of the Soviet Union and the Georgia of today.. By the way, there are many admirers of Stalin in India and a prominent politician is named after STalin.
Gulags were regular prisons with maximum sentences of 10 years (in "free" America there are a higher percentage of Americans in the prison system now than were ever in gulags), and deportations saved millions from Nazi savagery. The anti-communist propaganda got you, Eli.
Eli, Hello. I worked for Dr. Aarmand Hammer who went to college with Stalin. They were great friends. Stalin brought Hammer with him when he came home during our Thanksgiving break from school. Hammer later formed Occidental Petroleum and also got into the fertilizer industry and he was the one who had the trade agreement with Russia for 100,000,000 tons of fertilizer over a 20 year period. PLease read the Biography of Aarmand Hammer if you would like to get a different perspective of trade between the US and Russia.
.. wish i could be there in person .. 😊 🍀 i like history .. thank you for sharing this experience through your captivating video footage .. .. and greetings from 🇮🇩 Indonesia .. 22:28
Again, a very good video. In one way, its sad to see how this once beautiful buildings now disintegrate. The must have been very impressive when they were just finished and the first guest went there. Some spots you visited I knew already from videos from Bald & Bankrupt (Benjamin Rich). I can understand the old people that they miss the Soviet Union. Everything has bad and good sides, the free healthcare, schools, that everyone has a roof over his head and a job and all the different nationality lived in Peace inside the Soviet Union is something who might a big contrast to today's capitalistic jungle and all this nationalist and religious conflicts in the world.
My childhood and youth were spent in the USSR in the late 60s and early 80s. Those were wonderful years, it was a different civilization and different people
In the Soviet Union, Georgia was in a privileged position, it received from the general budget from 3 to 5 times more subsidies than it contributed to this budget, that is, in fact, it lived at the expense of the Russian regions, which at that time remained semi-impoverished, although they gave the main budget to industrial production.As the USSR collapsed, all these republics fell into poverty because they could not support themselves, they have no mineral resources, no industrial base, no large scientific and technological centers, they have a different mentality, more like Arabic, where merchants are more respected than people of intellectual labor
This was fascinating. Keep it up, Eli. 🏞 The video discusses the history of a small town in West Georgia and its transformation after the dissolution of the Soviet Union. 00:38 Stalin's visit to the town for medical treatment and the construction of a resort The town faced abandonment and theft after the dissolution of the Soviet Union Discussion about expectations of a post-Soviet country 🏞 The video explores the history and current state of sanatoriums in a former industrial town. 07:37 The sanatoriums and bath houses were popular during the Soviet times, attracting elites for treatments and vacation. The narrator meets a compatriot from Moscow who is volunteering in the area. The sanatoriums were originally for workers of the Metallurgy Factory and medical institutions, but now the area is abandoned and inhabited by stray dogs. 🏛 The video explores a visit to Stalin's hometown in Georgia and the impact of the Soviet era on the local culture. 14:08 The Soviet experience in a sanatorium is described as strict and regimented. Locals in the city of Gori, Georgia have a strong admiration for Stalin, evident in the naming of streets and avenues. The debunk of Stalin's cult of personality led to the removal of all names associated with Stalin in Russia.
Sanatoria here, were usually associated with mental health issues, or incurable contagious diseases like tuberculosis. With new vaccines and new methods they lost their purposes. Some continental places keep certain aspects of sanatoria with hot and cold baths, taking waters, keep fit classes and a healthy diet. I used to use the old Soviet system at school when I was late after going home for lunch - I would pretend to give my name to the school prefect (Vladimir Ilyich Ulyanov)......and he would pretend to write it down.😊
![Kodak Black - Sharp Vibes [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/oEV0OoLJeIs/mqdefault.jpg)
I decided to travel the Post-Soviet space, and to talk to locals about their life in the Soviet Union and after its collapse. Let's explore Georgia with me :)
📍 Thank you for watching and here are more videos of mine on this topic:
ruclips.net/video/uakT5YGN2KQ/видео.html - Georgia before and after collapse of the Soviet Union (Big trip through the country)
ruclips.net/user/liveOGLegTp-eBQ - Russia of the Soviet Union vs now | What has changed since the USSR?
Thank you , Eli .
Thank you Eli. I well remember listening to Radio Moscow here in Scotland at night broadcasting the exercise programs. It was fascinating to hear your interviews with local people concerning if they preferred the USSR to to Russia today.
He is a creep. She gets prettier alll the time. Interesting video.
@@syork4126I don't think so, he is a nice guy and he he seem to know the Eastern Bloc rather unusual for westerners.
Same place
19:49 Oh I jumped out of happiness seeing Liya 😀 The wonderful lady hosted me while I was in Gori.Liya melted my heart with the warm Georgian hospitality and took care of me.One of the best homes I have stayed so far anywer in the world🥰
g(e)orgeous, non bourgeois Caucasus
Do you have a link, please? I intend to visit, and might like to stay with her.
Now that Bald and Bankrupt is not doing too many videos in post-Soviet countries anymore, we are now lucky to have a native Russian do such videos! Thank you
There’s a stark difference between the two, tbh I never liked Bald and the way he was presenting the places he visited although I watched some of his videos. Eli’s content is much, much better, no matter the country she visits.
@@minime7375 They're just different. Bald's is from the perspective of N outsider, and a blend of history, humour and wide eyed wonder and discovery. Eli's is more polished but presented with loving care and a more Russian perspective. To each their own opinion, but I like them both in their own way
@Eric-ii9ce You see the name of the channel and comment w/o watching, right?
@Eric-ii9ce
1. This isn’t a “propaganda video” so your comment is just petty
2. Plenty of journalists, including Western ones from left-leaning media freelanced or are freelancing for RT, the fact that youtube (and other non-free speech platforms) deemed it “Russian propaganda” doesn’t mean we’re all brainwashed. RT is available on Rumble and a lot of it has nothing to do with politics.
3. I don’t see why anyone feels the need to be nasty, if you believe her videos to be “Russian propaganda” scroll ahead nd don’t watch them, you wouldn’t want to be brainwashed into believing Russians are regular people and Russia is home to rich cultures. Leaving aside the fact that this video is from Georgia…
Every single video she posts is propaganda. You’re blind if you can’t see it.
I'm a proud American, but I when I watch your videos in a weird way I feel like I'm in the room with you visiting your family or the people you visit. So I want to be respectful to the people even when I'm watching it on my phone. So I hang my ego up like a hat at the door and just listen. Always enjoy listening to other people's side of history. I think you do a beautiful job telling the stories of a place and people
When you comment it helps her logarithms. Interactive is interesting as others can communicate easily.
You are proud on what. For invading and destroying the Middle East by USA and NATO. Free Palestine.
Eli greetings from Albania. This is my first time commenting on your channel.
I remember the days when our country and USSR were close allies.
Now like many post socialist states we are sucked by Anti Russian mad propaganda and demonization of our socialist past and glorification of the West. This is not good. This is no less of a propaganda than Communist ones, not to say more.
In your channel, you show us the real Russia, the real people, the real past and present experience based on ground reality.
You are an ambassador of Russia and much of the places you visit than most people in power in Russia are today.
Whether we like our communist past or not, admitting all its faults and crimes, compared to today, no, I would say today's situation is far worse than those times. Some might disagree. Everyone is entitled to their opinion.
Despite all, I will not hide my sentiments, and say Glory to the Red Army, Glory to the USSR, to the russian and soviet martyrs, and glory to Stalin for whatever good he did without forgetting his bad and for freeing Europe from nazi bestialities.
But certainly Nikita Krushchev who was passionate about de-stalinization was not that kind of a good guy either. But better than Gorbachev. Gorbachev sold out USSR, Russia and this entire conflict Ukraine vs Russia, Armenia vs Azerbaijan originate from Krushchev's times and became full blown during Gorbachev's rule.
My point is, while we must not forget much evil that socialism might have had, its good surpassed its evil, in my opinion.
We must not fall into idiotic historical revisionism and demonize all our past, a tragic reality many countries of the former Eastern bloc suffer, and some are pathologically obsessed with especially if they join NATO or the EU.
Let's focus on the present and future, learning from the past from its mistakes and from its achievements unless we do not want to make the world a worse place than what already is.
Wish you all best for your time and efforts you put to produce these priceless videos and documentaries.
ruclips.net/video/lPMlmkOXfzg/видео.htmlsi=TdIfTg14QuBX6wWn
"obsessed with especially if they join NATO" - and for good reason, otherwise you could by invaded by Russia like Ukraine. Just watch russian TV to see what they are able to discuss, very westernfobic and aggresive talks.
This is one of my all time favourite channels, love from Iraq ❤
I’ll be visiting Iraq soon! Looks like a wonderful country!
That tune wakes up my husband to go to work 😅. He's in his forties and misses USSR a lot.
I remember this tune on my granny's radio when I was visiting her (I was growing up in Greece).
My favorite composer is Sergei Prokofiev who died on the same day Stalin did. Apparently there weren’t any flowers available because they were all used for Stalins funeral so they ended up using flowers made of paper for Prokofiev.
I'm so into everything about Russia and Soviet Union that I even started to learn Russian. U have a great channel. Greetings from ex Yugoslavia. Cрасибо
England had sanatoriums back in the old days. When Agatha Christie went missing for 11 days in 1926, she was found inside a sanatorium under a different name, having lost her memory of what happened.
My ex-husband's private super expensive school in England had a sanatorium.
Re. Agatha Christie, I always wondered if she was doing some undercover research for a story.
Eli, I'm a senior American man, and have learned more from your tours and discussions about Russia and the Caucuses with local people than ever before. So nice to learn how they live and what they believe. I'd love to learn more about the people's Christian beliefs. Thanks so much
Russians don't know much about the Caucasus. So, Eli can't help you much.
Tnis was a very interesting video! One can see how beautiful and grand that sanitorium was at one time. It's a shame it has fallen into disrepair, as well as some of those other structures. If a certain person in charge had focused on restoring and maintaining the land and structures he has instead of lusting for more land and structures, it would be a different world. As that old woman said, we all need to be friends. There's no need to be enemies, because our stay on this planet is very short. Anyway, I just love your sense of humor and your sense of adventure, Eli, as well as the fact that you seem to get along with everybody. You set a good example for all humanity.
I'm sure that there are many reasons to be enemies with many individuals of questionable intentions.
@@vitordelimaOn both sides.
The people should be friends and stand against their respective governments
America has been the aggressor since the Cold War, not Russia nice try at sneaking in some western propaganda, though ! America sponsored bloody coup 8 years of killing civilians in Donbas ? Western cancel culture is hilarious ! American, forever wars is what shapes the warmongering on earth these past 75 years. Get your head out of the sand ! Putin is breaking American hegemony, and we will have a more just world after. How are the sanctions going ? Russia has recorded profits less than 3% unemployment ! ❤❤❤❤❤
@@mfreund15448And corporations, hospitals, universities, banks...
Eli you also look so happy and have an appearance of almost love about you!
Another great video, Eli. I enjoy hearing the comparisons from people you interview, as to what was best USSR times, or Russian Federation, modern times. Lovely Destinations, interesting peoples. Thanks for posting, as some of us will never be able to get there, to have a look for ourselves.
Love my regular dose of adventure, inspiration and optimism , thanks Eli!
Here in poland we have quite a few abandoned sanatoriums with 'healing waters', those rotten-egg-smelling ones, full of minerals. It`s unfortunate that people stopped coming there, now it`s super dangerous because most of the wells are in the basement and without proper filtration the whole underground level is full of co2, you will just collapse on the stairs down and never come up...
Racism is high in Polska 😒
Gamarjoba Eli! Such a fascinating video of “Stalin’s Georgia!” Thank you so much for sharing your travel experience with us. I kept looking at a Georgia map to try track where you went to and try and picture myself there too. It makes it more real to me other than faceless names and lines on the map. The people you meet there seem so friendly and welcoming. Stalin’s history is so interesting. He is such a big figure in history yet he had humble beginnings. Whether good or bad we all share common human experiences. If only we can all be friends the world would be a much better place. Looking forward to the next Georgia adventure! Warm greetings from California! 🤩🤩🤩✌🏻🫶
A Russian friend also made a video in this area, Gorgeous Joseph's Georgia, but maybe it is rather tendentious. He was a Sibirian KGBrian once!😮😎😁
😂😱😉😉😉
Thanks 👍🏻 Eli. Frequently watching your informative, interesting videos.... Best wishes from Sri Lanka 💐💐🇱🇰🇱🇰
Always look forward to your uploads. Interesting perspectives of the people living there. In US, we also had sanitariums back in the day but was mostly used for Tuberculosis patients - maybe other diseases too, but TB was the most.
these were more like spas (you can visit similar places in Budapest) with natural water springs (Different ones recommended for different maladies) and you would also have massages etc.... vs like a quarantine type one like for TB. lots of amazing natural healing waters throughout Europe (and I'm sure elsewhere but I don't know about it to say so :) )
Thanks, Eli, for this amazing bit of history!❤
Your are such a great people-story-teller, Eli. A rare pearl on RUclips. 1 million subscribers in 2024. Wish you all the best.
This is a proof of your improved modern journalism. Keep up with your nice work. Peace.
Eli, this was a terrific video and history of the sanitoriums! Thank you 😊
I like your videos, showing different places in Russia and the former USSR. I am interested in soviet era history. I've never been to Georgia, but I hope one day to visit it. You just got a new subscriber :) Greetings from Bulgaria. Привет от България.
You could just take a ferry trip across the Black Sea.
Me too comrade
It bothers me that people can let such a beautiful building turn into a ruin.
Its legacy is being the home of Soviet Hitler lmao let it be a ruin
Война.Грузии с Абхазией 1992-1994г.Грузии с Южной Осетией 1992-1993г.и 2008г.
Gawd so uninformed
it's exremely interesting hearing people who preferred the USSR. We grew up thinking everyone hated living under the Soviets and everyone was thrilled when it ended. But how that guy spoke reminds me of hearing americans talk about how the 50s were better and today everything is crazy prices and generally sucks now. Global prosperity to depression is relatable in every country
American's romantisize the 50s-60s but people weren't exactly treated well, civil rights and vietnam, even italians were still treated like shit in america. but it still had a charm to it, things seemed like they could only get better where today it feels like it can only get worse.
12:22 OMJ(o my jesina), I'm so glad my Uncle Vanya (Ivan the Righteous) doesn't know your channel and probably wouldn't like it either. He would freak out if he had to watch this scene. That was his "deserved" favorite sanatorium back in the Soviet days!!! 😥🚩🕵🛂🛡🗡🛃👮🚩😪
Another great production! Thanks, Eli. ❤
Thank you Eli for this interesting and historical video about the Soviet times in Georgia. Merry Christmas and Happy New Year, full of joy and happiness❤⭐️🌲⭐️🌲
I must admit,this video was very interesting and informative,as usual.Keep up the good work!Thank you.USA subscriber
Thank you Eli. As always, your tours are so very interesting and informative, giving American people a much better understanding of Russian life and history. I greatly appreciate you dear one.
Thank you Eli for this lovely video i have visited Georgia before but didn't know about this place ..interesting town and love your videos as they are informative and fun at the same time .. love from Oman
I enjoyed this video, Eli. Thanks
I'm delighted you are doing this series on former USSR feelings, people and places. The story will be lost soon as those who remember die away. Young people will forge their own way of economics and politics, yet hopefully some will carry the ideals of USSR with them. Of course, the ideals were not met exactly since people everywhere, especially leaders, fall prey to elitism and hubris. Thanks for just showing us what you see. Sanatoriums were popular for many decades until the idea of corporatizing "healthcare" came along with specialists and hospitals. Profit, not health.
In the USSR, my father worked as a carpenter at a small enterprise. He had two vacations in similar sanatoriums. And both times at the expense of the company, with a very small surcharge. We probably judge the USSR by the stereotypes created for us by Hollywood.
That is success :D, two vacations in whole misarable life spent in cue for the meat and banana. :D I have two vacations a year and I don't need and state support because I earn enough money to pay for that like most of us. Not like your father's misarable salary in some kind of "kolchoz".
@go read the declassified CIA document on soviet food consumption. Stop posting bs and do some reading
I think you're right. At least for my generation, in the 1950s and 1960s. But thank you for sharing. So much to learn.
You have no idea fool, back in the 1960’s it wasn’t bad, these old folks know what they’re talking about. But the world moves on, I moved to USA in 1972 , I am a Disabled Veteran of US Army and retired now. I can tell you, I worked my ass off here, paid taxes, paid off mortgage etc, I like USA, I went to Latvia in 2023 on vacation, it was a miserable place with hateful people, they looked scared, I split from there to Italy, now that is extraordinaire Rome Pompeii, Coliseum. Latvia is just bunch of slaves to a few rich, making miserable pittance and shitty healthcare
..your smile Eli..Will disolve any Coldwar between us
Thanks again for sharing
Happy holidays from Canada Eli, and wishing you and your family a happy, healthy and prosperous New Year from Canada!!
🎄☮️🇨🇦❤️🇷🇺🙏
I’m from Quebec and i’ve been watching your videos a lot, i did not know much about Russia before! It’s so crazy to see this crossover episode i would have never thought Quebec and Russia would merge haha!
Thankyou for showing us a bit of Russian history that would have otherwise been keep a bit too quite, it was good to see some nice Georgian folks and see the amazing Sanatorium.
The conversation at 16:20 got pretty intense. You politely and bravely stood your ground presenting facts in a non-overbearing way. Accolades for your delivery, your smile and what you stand for.
Much love from Canada.
Eli travels everywhere and knows how to converse with all kinds of people.
She's no dummy.
Russia has made progress. In the old days such comments would have meant instant arrest and likely a prompt encounter with a firing squad. Except for the example of Paul Robeson, who could pull off a public challenge confronting Stalin because he was a famous foreigner.
@@jackieow can you cite the source of your firing squad for making idle comments.
That's not idle comments. That's everyday life and death the way it used to be. If you are that unfamiliar with history, you could start by reading up on Genrikh Yagoda or :Nikolai Yezhov or Lavrentiy Beria, paying attention to how they died. Try reading "Stalin: the Court of the Red Tsar" by Simon Sebag Montefiore. Or the numerous works of Solzhenitsyn. If you don't already know the answer to your own quandary, you obviously haven't familiarized yourself with much history as of the present time.@@carlosgaspar8447
An interesting fact is that the USA today imprisons more people than the USSR ever did, and the only people who went to the gulag were Nazis 😉. Stalin’s only mistake was that he didn’t imprison more of those people. If he had, the USSR might still be with us today.
Eli's good manners and friendliness are adorable
WOW! This is really interesting Eli! Awesome video! And with a fellow Canadian). It gave me chills when you were walking down the stairs of Stalin's dacha because I just pictured him also walking down those stairs. Very interesting. I look forward to seeing more of your Soviet adventures)
On an unrelated note, I am a cartographer and for a fun project I decided to recreate an old red army map from the Great Patriotic War. It's a map showing the red army attack on Königsberg (now Kaliningrad). When I watched your video about the fort there, I didn't realize how many forts are around the city! It's incredible!
Eli had a big strong smile around him. And her smile always makes me smile.
This was very interesting and there was so much I never saw. It´s a shame to let the sanatorium or the datcha from Stalin rot to the grounds. Especially the sanatorium is still some kind of beautiful, but if it´s restorated it would be precious. I was very curiuos regarding the Stalin museum, the old style bath house and the train waggon. There is a lot of history left. It is definitive worth a visit.
As usual, a good look at ordinary people and not politics. Thank you Eli.
lol what? are you blind and deaf or what ?
Thank you for your videos, showing me parts of the world I will certainly never visit... and I love that you give expression to both sides, always. That's so, so important! It shows how complex history is.
I hope all of these beautiful places can be resurrected to their former glory!
Thank you, Eli, for this honest view of your Russia. I had planned a trip to Kaliningrad, but the war with Ukraine and the American Russophobia stopped it. Stalin was loved for stopping the Nazis, but hated for some brutality in gulags and with political enemies. My parents fought in WWII, and always had respect for Russians. They both met Nikita Kruschev - he loved the American farm tractors! That sanatorium is beautiful, and the tuberculosis sanatoriums here in the States were also often in the country -- but never so elegant. Virtual travel to Russia is all I can get now, so please keep exploring!
Thank you Eli for a very interesting and informative video. (one of your best) !
Thank you EliI , I really enjoy your travels. I really liked the nice lady at the end who played the piano. She seemed very nice, just like you 🙂
Eli, you know you give us a realist view without any propaganda of how things are in Russia and other places today and really broaden our appreciation of how things were and indeed are. We have learned so very much.
Thank you for a very interesting episode. I really enjoy the history and education that you provide. I am looking forward to more videos.
Ви також можете дослідити цю історію з книжок, щоб вам не потрібно було стежити за пропагандистським каналом.
Excellent video Eli - thank you for a great education!
Interestingly, the music in the first 10 seconds of this video was used on the old Radio Moscow international shortwave broadcasts in the 60's and 70's. I believe the song was named "Moscow Nights". All the best, Will.
Glad you had subtitles, lol! Happy Holidays and thank you for the videos!
Beautiful story - time machine. Very similar, to ex Yugoslavia and their nations living together, with a difference of being able to travel abroad. Thank you very much, and keep up great travel adventures Eli...
Thank you for another adventure! History must never be destroyed.
But it is usually rewritten and "corrected" by power elites and conflict winners...unfortunately. The "art of sparing information out" is an important tool for that unfortunately widely spread way of of producing news, history books etc.😮 everywhere!!
გმადლობთ საქართველოს ჩვენებისთვის, ელინა! \\Спасибо, что показали Грузию, Элина!
არაფერია ქართული, გარდა საბჭოთა წარსულისა
@@napoleonbonaparte4396egec saqartvelos nawili gaxda ginda tu ara
anti-qartvelia.
I love your videos so much, I appreciate you sharing your journey with all of us
Love your channel and your very informative videos. I hope they restore these incredibly historic places. Right now is ghostly. You can only imagine all the people who once walked those floors.
Georgia 🇬🇪 is a Independent Country.
Love Georgia 🇬🇪
❤ 🇬🇪
Nobody ever said Goergia wasn't an independent country. What are you getting on about ?
Others may have mentioned it but I have never heard a Canadian accent sound so Mexican as I did with your friend.
I visited Sanatorium Metalurgi in September and I talked to both of those residents. So cool to see them again here. Thanks for sharing
In the video, we can see how splendid the KGB sanatorium was. It's a shame to see it in this condition. It would be interesting if the place could be restored, even for the sake of preserving historical heritage. Thanks for the video, Eli.
It made me think of Versailles. Obviously it was once a beautiful facility and should be restored as such.
Once it decays to ruin, the people will regret losing it.
@@user-dh6bj2me5p Georgia is not terribly rich country and there are many more practical concerns which need addressing. Hopefully as Georgia becomes more prosperous and more and more people discover what an excellent tourist destination it truly is, money will be spent to restore these buildings to their glory.
Or totally forget. I met a girl from Versailles and I said, "Oh, you're from the home of the Treaty of Versailles!" She said, "What?" because she never had heard of the Treaty of Versailles even though she had lived there for 25 years.@@user-dh6bj2me5p
maybe bcwehad 5 war with russia in last century?
давно мечтаю попасть! место безумно атмосферное😊
Fascinating, thank you. And I'm very impressed with how polite and kind you are facing western ignorance and sense of superiority!
Thank you for providing some history and including the voices of the residents.
Wow. So so interesting. As always, Eli. Well done. I didn't expect Georgian peoples reaction to stalins ancestry. If in fact he was of Georgian ancestry. Thank you so much for this great video!🔥
Veliky Stalin - Hero of the Soviet Union and Saviour of the world
Stalin should not to be loved or reviled
He must be acknowledged for his singular contribution to history, and therefore, he should be revered
It is very disheartening to see modern Georgia - where Stalin should be a towering figure - engage in historical amnesia and revisionism
Lenin wanted Stalin demoted.
Another exciting and educational day for me, thanks Eli you're the best teacher online😍🤩😘
That was really interesting and well presented. Thankyou. The countryside looked beautiful.
Interesting video series from Georgia. It surprises me... in 2016 I spent one year in Georgia and got in touch with many locals born after 1990... they have a totally different opinion on Stalin and USSR with respect to the elder people interviewed by Eli. Unlike their parents, they're used to the idea that everyone have to look for his own job and home, rather than waiting for the state to give them both.
Crazy to let a place like this fall into disrepair. It's gorgeous! I saw abandoned sanatoriums in Latvia, Estonia and Belarus. Not quite as grand as this though - 20th century design. It is very sad.
They did not just let it fall in dispair. Driving a wedge into the Russian-Georgia relationship caused the Russians not to go there anymore.
Hence the collapse
У Грузии нет денег на реставрацию этого всего и нет желания, т.к. отношения с Россией испорчены и как правило в таких ситуациях пытаются зачеркнуть и забыть общую историю и все, что связано, а не восстанавливать.
So many fabulous buildings. Hope they will be renovated one day. Very interesting, thank you.
Thank you for this History Lesson I learned about The USSR when i went to Grade School . Back in The early Years . 1960 "S . We had To Learn What The Words Meant . (USSR) How the people lived and there work also . We read this in hard covered books . There were no computers like they have now a days . And at the End of each school Quater we took written tests on what we learned . As well as of end School year exams on what they taught us during that year to pass and move on to the next grade or class . So much to remember back then . I look forward to watching more of your travels .
Once beautiful~ It would be nice to see images/photos of this place when it was young and well taken care of.
Sad that a beautiful building has fallen into such disrepair. Interesting video.
Back in the USSR. Song by Beatles 1968. I love your channel.
I remember when you first started doing this and I will say the same thing again your documentaries are some of the most interesting out there I am glad for your secess Miss Eli❤
Natural inborn talent makes the difference. She makes it look easy to do the productions.
ELI - Please keep traveling through UK. show me the world - like Bald and Bankrupt.
Not like "Bald and Bankrupt". He is a pig
Everywhere you go is an interesting visit Eli. I am from Quebec, Canada like Dominic, so I asked myself: what is this fellow doing in Georgia? You both seemed to be having fun.
Thank you Eli, another great travel exploring awesome video 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼😌😌🥰🙏🤲🏼🕊️🎄⛄💐👍
You make even abandoned places seem interesting!. Thanks.
Hi Eli!
It is a disgrace that such a structure and service remains abandoned. It is certainly useful for those people who do not have a roof to stay under.
It seems that after the fall of the USSR everything, besides the communist ideal, was deliberately left to its abandonment and degradation. This is a mistake that everyone makes when they leave a situation that had lasted too long and had become oppressive.
I agree with the fact that at that time we wanted to free ourselves from an oppressive situation, for those who considered it as such, however, functional objects and structures can continue to be used because in the end they are only objects that have a valid utility like that healthcare facility. Another reason for not abandoning these functional structures is that at that time we have services to use and we don't know if after a regime the government that succeeds it can give to the people at least as much as the regime gave.
In any case, Stalin had good taste in the architecture to be created because it is evident from the columns, from the large halls of the rooms, from the floors representing mosaics that Stalin wanted to recreate the beauty of classicism.
It is interesting to hear the opinions of people who lived in the USSR period and see the differences between that time and now.
Basically, every regime has given its people good things and bad things, then, there are points of view as to whether something appears better or worse.
When I went to school, they always told us that Russian communism was something bad and despicable, but, I always wondered if it was like they said or was it just to make us believe that Russia is a place not to practice as much as the Russian people, therefore, we had to be indifferent towards them.
Then I happened to meet people from Eastern Europe who lived under the communist regime and they all told me that in that period no one died of hunger because everyone worked and could bring bread home. After the fall of the regime, the first thing that disappeared was his work and consequently everything else.
However, seeing videos of many Russian RUclipsrs, I noticed that Russia is a very strong country economically and I don't think I see people dying of hunger. This means that however the end of one era and the beginning of another brought good or bad consequences, there was simply an adaptation.
In any case, Russia remains a great country that should not be underestimated and admired.
Thank you for the content of this video, I greet you and hug you. 😊
Under communism Russia was basically a caste system of Soviet bosses and cringing flunkies. Russia never had more than about 7% of the population in the Communist Party, and those who knew it best regarded fellow communists as legions of ass-kissing whores and murderers. Principled citizens begged family members to not prostitute themselves into joining. There were always a few who drank the Kool-Aid and actually believed the highly structured lies, but as time went by fewer and fewer people were fooled until it all fell apart in 1991. The legend of "enough food" and "enough employment" was often achieved simply by killing off the surplus population until there was food enough to go around and jobs enough to go around. That took no brains or talent, just killing the innocent until those left standing were smart enough and scared enough to not complain.
I lived behind iron curtain. Funny to see, how many people who did not experinced "soviet paradise of workers and farmers" suffered from its idealization. Men, were literally forced lived beding fence, who wanted to escape by crossing border was shot or jailed and persecuted. Get it?
Hello Eli I'm from Greece and I watch your videos. I'm big fan of Stalin and USSR and your videos proof that people in USSR have better times then than today..
The millions who died in gulags and starved in Ukraine did not have better times, but their memory was suppressed in Russia
oh ok thanks for your historical big knowledge and information i will take it under consideration@@champagne.future5248
Eli, I admire you with every new video more and more. Ti takaya molodec!
Wow crazy 😂😂😂thanks for sharing Eli.
Living in the west (Greece), I always considered the collapse of the USSR to be a good thing. Well we have thousands of Georgian ladies here, looking after our old people, our aging mothers and fathers, aunts and uncles. I was shocked to find out how NOSTALGIC they are about the Soviet times!
And then I realized the difference in the perspective : we, westerners, approach the matter theoretically. For them it was the collapse of their world. From respectable home-owners they had to become immigrants, move to a land the language of which they didn't speak and stay confined in a flat changing the... bedsheets (to put it politely) of an aging, ailing, often senile person.
The communists always had full employment by having 2 or 3 or 4 people do the work of one person, and splitting up the paycheck accordingly. Or, Stalin would take the number of unemployed and have that many random people randomly killed. Nobody around to be unemployed meant no unemployment problem. In the 1930's, Stalin's quota to Khrushchev was to eliminate 40,000 random people in the Moscow area. Fewer Russians to complain about unemployment or not enough food. Khrushchev knew Stalin from the inside out, which is why he denounced him in 1956.
🤮@@jackieow
@@jackieow absolute nonsense
@@jackieowещё одна анти советская пропаганда. Такого не было и нет. Мои бабушка и дедушка очень хорошо относились к Сталину ! В стране был порядок и справедливость ! Не довольны Сталином только воры , бандиты , либералы, предатели .
By not being there, you must be wiser than Khrushchev who was there. You must be smarter than all the Soviet veterans Simon Sebag Montefiore interviewed for "Stalin: the Court of the Red Tsar." You must be more experienced and knowledgeable than Alexander Solzhenitsyn.@@ItsTristan1st
Санаторий Медеа очень красивый похоже был...жаль что все пришло в такое уныние 😢😢
I was so sad to see the abandoned sanatorium's condition. Its natural surroundings, the beauty of the building, and the noble idea that built in the first place, all now lie in ruins. I hope this building is renovated. Thank you for showing me the hidden aspects of the Soviet Union and the Georgia of today.. By the way, there are many admirers of Stalin in India and a prominent politician is named after STalin.
Gulags were regular prisons with maximum sentences of 10 years (in "free" America there are a higher percentage of Americans in the prison system now than were ever in gulags), and deportations saved millions from Nazi savagery. The anti-communist propaganda got you, Eli.
Great as usual Eli, however I'd question Dominic's Canadian origins.
Eli, Hello. I worked for Dr. Aarmand Hammer who went to college with Stalin. They were great friends. Stalin brought Hammer with him when he came home during our Thanksgiving break from school. Hammer later formed Occidental Petroleum and also got into the fertilizer industry and he was the one who had the trade agreement with Russia for 100,000,000 tons of fertilizer over a 20 year period. PLease read the Biography of Aarmand Hammer if you would like to get a different perspective of trade between the US and Russia.
It is very pretty! Thanks for the video!
.. wish i could be there in person .. 😊
🍀 i like history ..
thank you for sharing this experience through your captivating video footage .. .. and greetings from 🇮🇩 Indonesia ..
22:28
Again, a very good video. In one way, its sad to see how this once beautiful buildings now disintegrate. The must have been very impressive when they were just finished and the first guest went there. Some spots you visited I knew already from videos from Bald & Bankrupt (Benjamin Rich). I can understand the old people that they miss the Soviet Union. Everything has bad and good sides, the free healthcare, schools, that everyone has a roof over his head and a job and all the different nationality lived in Peace inside the Soviet Union is something who might a big contrast to today's capitalistic jungle and all this nationalist and religious conflicts in the world.
My childhood and youth were spent in the USSR in the late 60s and early 80s. Those were wonderful years, it was a different civilization and different people
In the Soviet Union, Georgia was in a privileged position, it received from the general budget from 3 to 5 times more subsidies than it contributed to this budget, that is, in fact, it lived at the expense of the Russian regions, which at that time remained semi-impoverished, although they gave the main budget to industrial production.As the USSR collapsed, all these republics fell into poverty because they could not support themselves, they have no mineral resources, no industrial base, no large scientific and technological centers, they have a different mentality, more like Arabic, where merchants are more respected than people of intellectual labor
This was fascinating. Keep it up, Eli.
🏞 The video discusses the history of a small town in West Georgia and its transformation after the dissolution of the Soviet Union.
00:38
Stalin's visit to the town for medical treatment and the construction of a resort
The town faced abandonment and theft after the dissolution of the Soviet Union
Discussion about expectations of a post-Soviet country
🏞 The video explores the history and current state of sanatoriums in a former industrial town.
07:37
The sanatoriums and bath houses were popular during the Soviet times, attracting elites for treatments and vacation.
The narrator meets a compatriot from Moscow who is volunteering in the area.
The sanatoriums were originally for workers of the Metallurgy Factory and medical institutions, but now the area is abandoned and inhabited by stray dogs.
🏛 The video explores a visit to Stalin's hometown in Georgia and the impact of the Soviet era on the local culture.
14:08
The Soviet experience in a sanatorium is described as strict and regimented.
Locals in the city of Gori, Georgia have a strong admiration for Stalin, evident in the naming of streets and avenues.
The debunk of Stalin's cult of personality led to the removal of all names associated with Stalin in Russia.
9:08 This is how immigrants are supposed to behave.
Almost one year ago, I visited Georgia and came to Tskaltubo. It was such an interesting place.
Thank you, Eli, for bringing us with you! ✊🏽💝🌎👍🏽🌹🙏🏽
Sanatoria here, were usually associated with mental health issues, or incurable contagious diseases like tuberculosis. With new vaccines and new methods they lost their purposes. Some continental places keep certain aspects of sanatoria with hot and cold baths, taking waters, keep fit classes and a healthy diet.
I used to use the old Soviet system at school when I was late after going home for lunch - I would pretend to give my name to the school prefect (Vladimir Ilyich Ulyanov)......and he would pretend to write it down.😊
В России очень много таких санаториев с советских времен в отличной форме и они очень пользуются спросом.
I think in the west, sanatorium would be called a resort!! Those are incredible!!