Over my many years of living in America as a POC this exchange has rattled me to the core. My eyes have finally been open to what America truly is and I have finally been awoken to what true evil is!
More because Sanders loves to grandstand than to understand economics. Unfortunately, he never learned when he got his B.A. in Poli-Sci and isn't interested in understanding now, which is precisely why he babbles off numbers that he (as he admits at the end of the video) cannot even be remotely certain of its accuracy. Legislation driven by envy and your proximity to the compulsive collection of tax revenue is by far the least effective and gives rise to the ugliest and most desperate rhetoric from him, Pelosi, Maxine Waters, Schumer, and the rest of the knuckle-dragging carnival barkers. Socialism sucks.
Let’s get one thing straight. No one... I mean no one, can argue with the fact that America is crumbling. Why do you think it is? We are DIVIDED. As a nation we need to HELP each OTHER... that’s the only way. If we keep spending money on the wrong things (ie. military spending) then we will pay for it in the long run. Just watch.
I love Sanders, but I don't so much like the way he handled this. His points were valid, but still, he could have let Mulvaney speak. And Mulvaney's point about "We didn't factor in the fact that wealthy families would get a tax break" is potentially defensible. But all Sanders had to say was "Okay, well, NOW you know. What are you going to do about it?"
And people think angry old man Sanders should be president. Before you grill people over stats, get them right first. Most of these politicians vote for things they don't read or understand and then go off when they don't like something.
"Hi, I'm Rich, and I'm so stupid that I love it when assholes like Trump and Mulvaney steal from me because one day a billionaire might pat me on the head."
He is correct, though. If the Waltons donated their entire estate to charities, then the net tax could very well be 0 anyway. Sanders is operating on the assumption they are dying while they are having the discussion. You cant do that in regards to estate taxes.
The Walton's (in Arkansas) are paying 0.17% MORE in Federal Taxes Arkansas has a 7% top rate, under the old 39.6% Federal Rate in 2017 they would have been able to write off all of that 7% so $10 of income would be net $5.617 or $10.00 - $0.70 (state) - $3.683 (federal). Federal being 39.6% of $9.30 (or $10.00-$0.70) In 2018 they pay the 7% tax to Arkansas on $10 and then pay 37% on $10 again which brings the net down to $5.60 - government makes $0.017 per $10 on high earners in Arkansas.
52 billion is a bunch. granted, but how is it percentage wise based on income? if, the tax breaks are legal, wouldn't anyone take advantage of them? rich, or poor.
Mulvaney appeared to be the ill informed one. His smirk, deflection, and condescending tone in response to Sander's direct question spoke volumes. I've always been troubled by the hubris of hypocrites.
Bernie feels "it's a little bit unfair" Want a cookie, Bernie? Would it help? Try hard to imagine how unfair it is to pay almost $7 bucks per gallon driving 120 miles to and from work 5 days a week. Spare us your sniveling. You're a grown up now.
How does anyone watch Bernie Sanders fight against greed and think he would be bad for this country...... it's so sad in a time when we Need somone with these exact ideas to be running this country HE IS RIGHT THERE, but ironically we have the worst person you can even think of in office
The topic I want to discuss here is why every true progressive mind should support President Trump and has no reason not to do so. (1) The definition of a “true progressive mind”: who sees the injustice in the disparity of income, namely 1% vs 99%. (2) Two solutions to this issue: (a) the overall political and economic situation of USA improves dramatically resulting in a decent level of earning for low-end of the social ladder, (b) otherwise the only alternative is the redistribution of wealth by means of taxing the rich (e.g. 50% on the 2nd million of income and 90% on the 3rd million, etc.) and by the justification of unfairness in the initial distribution of the wealth (i.e. income) (3) The key is the consensus of the population for solution (b) to happen when solution (a) does not exist. (4) The major obstacles to reach that consensus are the following big problems that have persisted for so long if not forever, and have CLOUDED THE ISSUE OF 1% VS 99%: (a) Global terrorism; (b) The federal deficit; (c) Illegal immigration and open southern boarder; (d) Drug epidemic. Any of these CLOUDING ISSUES can be used against the urgency and consideration of 1% vs 99%. How can 1% vs 99% be important when the life of an average citizen is not secured ? How can you justify more money for helping the poor when the government is facing bankruptcy ? How can you justify more money for helping the poor when the number of the poor may be increasing infinitely by illegal immigrants ? How can you justify more money for helping the poor when the drug epidemic adds tremendous burden on the welfare system ? On the other hand, after these problems are either completely solved or dramatically reduced, the 1% vs 99% issue will STAND OUT, and the portion of the population who want to see the current situation of 1% vs 99% persist forever will have few excuse for their argument ! If you do not believe that Trump has the true intention to solve these problems despite his display of true willingness to do so, GIVE HIM A FAIR CHANCE ! The Obama administration showed no intention to solve these problems and have greatly exacerbated these problems instead. If you can tolerate Obama administration’s policies toward these problem, WHAT RIGHT DO YOU HAVE TO TRY TO DESTROY TRUMP ADMINISTRATION AND TO IMPEDE ITS EFFORTS IN SOLVING THESE PROBLEMS ? (5) Paris Treaty for climate change: Paris Treaty is extremely important for the health of the Earth. However, because I believe that the future of this country depends on the success of Trump administration (as far as solving the above problems goes), if its success depends on the required economic growth and the economic growth depends on the TEMPORARY WITHDRAW from the Paris treaty, I support it ! (6) Tulsi Gabbard for President 2024 !
Ugh Bernie sanders views are so detrimental to this country. How disparaging is it to say that American families require government help just to subsist. Our whole view of government is so skewed. It is to ensure life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. Government should not be responsible for peoples meals, healthcare, or housing. Get government out of the way and let the market regulate itself!
truzar100 ....who starts more businesses or expands existing establishments? The top tear....fools will wait for the sun to shine as other increase their opportunities.
@@5150pop what a load of rubbish. small businesses start more businesses but they struggle because people just don't make enough money to buy stuff and pay mortgages. medical bill utility bill ect ect. big business has never been so flush with cash as they are today. and where do they hide that cash? in tax havens. it does not trickle down that's why the rich are getting richer and the poor are staying poor
I bet he has a bumper sticker that says "1/10 of a percent". This guy is like I better talk fast if I'm going to answer any questions before he interrupts me again...
Tough argument to keep up with but both had a point until halfway through when Mulvaney admitted federal cuts to pre-existing social plan funding in favor of high income tax cuts...
bernie has become a multimillionaire . bernie why dont you explain to the american people why you collect a pay check for renaming 2 post offices in your home state and have only introduced one other bill that was signed into law. you have passed those three bills in the 28 yrs he has been an elected to congress or the senate . just what do you do ?
Hey sanders lower our debt that you created , that will make the dollars I have worth more,. Where’s your plan for that? No it’s to him all money is Washington’s.
I don't go either way when it comes to Bernie Sanders, I dont know enough about him to really judge his political views. But he sure seems a bit.... incoherent almost. Like he knows what he wants to say but can't quite stay on topic. In no way do I hate him, and I'm not slandering his character at all. He just seems to struggle with some things. The other guy, Mulvaney, seemed to legitimately try to answer the questions but kept getting cut off because Sanders couldn't follow...
sanders could follow and does know what he is talking about because he knows the language of deception. you see these top percent feeders hide what they are trying to do in language that is designed to fool the layman.
Bernie wasn't about to let Mick answer the question in anyway that did not prove his point. How many times did he interrupt? Bernie can peddle class envy with the best of them. May we all experience the bliss of socialism that has made Venezuela the marvel that it is today.
Venezuela's problems stem mostly from US sanctions not socialism. if you want to prove its socialism lift all sanctions and resume full trade cooperation.
Powerful Bernie Sanders. We really missed a chance in 2016. We would be having a great change in our country but in a way that would benefit all. Bernie has already changed our country for the better. Look at the diversity of people at his rallies. That type of diversity is the America I want to live in.
How can he say this owning three houses surely socialism is about all being equal he is in the top one percent himself he is purely emotionally driven remember Bernie facts don't care about your feelings.!
This is why Andrew Yang needs to be president.people in office don't respect Bernie enough.i think Bernie is just going through the motions and just arguing just to argue.yang demands respect and speaks in a way where he gets through to people
Sanders quit against evil hillary and hillary was unelectable due to being mired in scandals thus bringing trump to office the real criminal is the DNC
He is only one man if we voted for more with more like him, then maybe we could really get something done. Our legislation is full of corrupt thieves that suck the cocks of corporate America.
I would bet you 1000$ that I'm more intelligent than you by any objective measurement AND more "educated" (I assume you mean universities since they're such a guarantee of practical-minded individuals \kappa)
God Bless Bernie, please God take special care of him.
Bernie continues to get fucked over by the establishment, as usual. your imaginary god hasnt helped in any way whatsoever....
May the force be with you Bernie!!!! ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Feel the Bern, the millennial messiah. God help this country.
When you steal $20 out of your mom's purse and dad finds out.
😂😂😂😂
the guy is skillfully avoiding the answer of the wealthiest family tax cut.
The Washington Post was instrumental in dismissing Sanders during the Democratic primaries. Just sayin.'
Over my many years of living in America as a POC this exchange has rattled me to the core. My eyes have finally been open to what America truly is and I have finally been awoken to what true evil is!
Sanders isn't even trying to listen. Whenever Mulvaney answers his question Sanders just babbles and says it's not true and pivots.
Teh EasygoingPants because anybody with half a brain knows that Mulvaney is full of shit.
More because Sanders loves to grandstand than to understand economics. Unfortunately, he never learned when he got his B.A. in Poli-Sci and isn't interested in understanding now, which is precisely why he babbles off numbers that he (as he admits at the end of the video) cannot even be remotely certain of its accuracy. Legislation driven by envy and your proximity to the compulsive collection of tax revenue is by far the least effective and gives rise to the ugliest and most desperate rhetoric from him, Pelosi, Maxine Waters, Schumer, and the rest of the knuckle-dragging carnival barkers. Socialism sucks.
Sankento you are completely wrong.
Washington is Berning Hot!
Get em Bernie!!
Hold his squirmy feet to the FIRE. GO BERNIE!
Let’s get one thing straight. No one... I mean no one, can argue with the fact that America is crumbling. Why do you think it is? We are DIVIDED. As a nation we need to HELP each OTHER... that’s the only way. If we keep spending money on the wrong things (ie. military spending) then we will pay for it in the long run. Just watch.
Julia Chernov real talk
Mick was shook
thank you very much Senator.
Bernie talks like he doesn't own three houses or is part of the top 1%.
I tell you why his wife was blame for funds missing from the university she was running.
He's probably in the top 10%, definitely not the top 1%
I love Sanders, but I don't so much like the way he handled this. His points were valid, but still, he could have let Mulvaney speak. And Mulvaney's point about "We didn't factor in the fact that wealthy families would get a tax break" is potentially defensible. But all Sanders had to say was "Okay, well, NOW you know. What are you going to do about it?"
But there's no one to carry on the fight.
This man is now the chair of budget committee
And people think angry old man Sanders should be president. Before you grill people over stats, get them right first. Most of these politicians vote for things they don't read or understand and then go off when they don't like something.
"Hi, I'm Rich, and I'm so stupid that I love it when assholes like Trump and Mulvaney steal from me because one day a billionaire might pat me on the head."
Mick Mulvaney looked visibly shaken getting Berned!!
Yeah Bernie, stick it to him! 💪🏼
My mans in the back working the camera is a whole mood.
Mulvaney is so screwed.
TRUTH TO POWER - BERNIE TALKS TRUTH TO GREEDY LYING REPUBLICANS !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
All Bernie can do is play that one string guitar. He won't even let Mulvaney answer the question.
Ron Rook cause mulvaney is lying.
He is correct, though. If the Waltons donated their entire estate to charities, then the net tax could very well be 0 anyway. Sanders is operating on the assumption they are dying while they are having the discussion. You cant do that in regards to estate taxes.
The Walton's (in Arkansas) are paying 0.17% MORE in Federal Taxes
Arkansas has a 7% top rate, under the old 39.6% Federal Rate in 2017 they would have been able to write off all of that 7% so $10 of income would be net $5.617 or $10.00 - $0.70 (state) - $3.683 (federal). Federal being 39.6% of $9.30 (or $10.00-$0.70)
In 2018 they pay the 7% tax to Arkansas on $10 and then pay 37% on $10 again which brings the net down to $5.60 - government makes $0.017 per $10 on high earners in Arkansas.
52 billion is a bunch. granted, but how is it percentage wise based on income? if, the tax breaks are legal, wouldn't anyone take advantage of them? rich, or poor.
Mulvaney appeared to be the ill informed one. His smirk, deflection, and condescending tone in response to Sander's direct question spoke volumes. I've always been troubled by the hubris of hypocrites.
Bernie feels "it's a little bit unfair" Want a cookie, Bernie? Would it help? Try hard to imagine how unfair it is to pay almost $7 bucks per gallon driving 120 miles to and from work 5 days a week. Spare us your sniveling. You're a grown up now.
How does anyone watch Bernie Sanders fight against greed and think he would be bad for this country...... it's so sad in a time when we Need somone with these exact ideas to be running this country HE IS RIGHT THERE, but ironically we have the worst person you can even think of in office
Mick Mulvaney was educated (and I use the term loosely) at Cosa Nostra College, followed by Trump University.
Don't go too far down. Just a bunch of poor people defending billionaires.
FFS Sanders shut your mouth and let the guy answer!!
God, an insane amount of deflection.
The aides are shaking their heads like "WTF is this guy?"
The topic I want to discuss here is why every true progressive mind should support President Trump and has no reason not to do so.
(1) The definition of a “true progressive mind”: who sees the injustice in the disparity of income, namely 1% vs 99%.
(2) Two solutions to this issue: (a) the overall political and economic situation of USA improves dramatically resulting in a decent level of earning for low-end of the social ladder, (b) otherwise the only alternative is the redistribution of wealth by means of taxing the rich (e.g. 50% on the 2nd million of income and 90% on the 3rd million, etc.) and by the justification of unfairness in the initial distribution of the wealth (i.e. income)
(3) The key is the consensus of the population for solution (b) to happen when solution (a) does not exist.
(4) The major obstacles to reach that consensus are the following big problems that have persisted for so long if not forever, and have CLOUDED THE ISSUE OF 1% VS 99%:
(a) Global terrorism;
(b) The federal deficit;
(c) Illegal immigration and open southern boarder;
(d) Drug epidemic.
Any of these CLOUDING ISSUES can be used against the urgency and consideration of 1% vs 99%.
How can 1% vs 99% be important when the life of an average citizen is not secured ?
How can you justify more money for helping the poor when the government is facing bankruptcy ?
How can you justify more money for helping the poor when the number of the poor may be increasing infinitely by illegal immigrants ?
How can you justify more money for helping the poor when the drug epidemic adds tremendous burden on the welfare system ?
On the other hand, after these problems are either completely solved or dramatically reduced, the 1% vs 99% issue will STAND OUT, and the portion of the population who want to see the current situation of 1% vs 99% persist forever will have few excuse for their argument !
If you do not believe that Trump has the true intention to solve these problems despite his display of true willingness to do so, GIVE HIM A FAIR CHANCE !
The Obama administration showed no intention to solve these problems and have greatly exacerbated these problems instead.
If you can tolerate Obama administration’s policies toward these problem, WHAT RIGHT DO YOU HAVE TO TRY TO DESTROY TRUMP ADMINISTRATION AND TO IMPEDE ITS EFFORTS IN SOLVING THESE PROBLEMS ?
(5) Paris Treaty for climate change: Paris Treaty is extremely important for the health of the Earth. However, because I believe that the future of this country depends on the success of Trump administration (as far as solving the above problems goes), if its success depends on the required economic growth and the economic growth depends on the TEMPORARY WITHDRAW from the Paris treaty, I support it !
(6) Tulsi Gabbard for President 2024 !
This Beenie wants to be president.
Lamar Cantrell you should vote for Bernie.
The answer to sanders question about why that family is getting a tax "break" as he puts it is because they pay a huge amount in tax
Ugh Bernie sanders views are so detrimental to this country. How disparaging is it to say that American families require government help just to subsist. Our whole view of government is so skewed. It is to ensure life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. Government should not be responsible for peoples meals, healthcare, or housing. Get government out of the way and let the market regulate itself!
Sanders the scummer is high on my "CWII bucket list"!!!!!!!
Sanders must be running for President in 2020. Sure hope he does and loses.
Trump should change the nickname crazy Bernie to pathetic Bernie
The seltzer man BUM
I'm not rich enough to vote for Republicans.
Not yet, but someday soon.
Basic economics....trickle down affect, the 1% will expand and create massive wealth, it NEVER serves the bottom to eliminate them
trickle down effect is a lie told to the fools at the bottom so they accept the greed at the top,
truzar100 ....who starts more businesses or expands existing establishments? The top tear....fools will wait for the sun to shine as other increase their opportunities.
@@5150pop what a load of rubbish. small businesses start more businesses but they struggle because people just don't make enough money to buy stuff and pay mortgages. medical bill utility bill ect ect. big business has never been so flush with cash as they are today. and where do they hide that cash? in tax havens. it does not trickle down that's why the rich are getting richer and the poor are staying poor
Bernie Fucking Sanders folks
I bet he has a bumper sticker that says "1/10 of a percent". This guy is like I better talk fast if I'm going to answer any questions before he interrupts me again...
Tough argument to keep up with but both had a point until halfway through when Mulvaney admitted federal cuts to pre-existing social plan funding in favor of high income tax cuts...
Barney the Purple Dinosaur.
bernie has become a multimillionaire . bernie why dont you explain to the american people why you collect a pay check for renaming 2 post offices in your home state and have only introduced one other bill that was signed into law. you have passed those three bills in the 28 yrs he has been an elected to congress or the senate . just what do you do ?
His net worth is 2 million. Which is basically nothing and he has 3 best selling books.
mulvaney will burn in hell.
Hey sanders lower our debt that you created , that will make the dollars I have worth more,. Where’s your plan for that? No it’s to him all money is Washington’s.
Roger Joyce the republicans are in charge Maybe you should take the effort to learn about your government before spewing your bull
I don't go either way when it comes to Bernie Sanders, I dont know enough about him to really judge his political views. But he sure seems a bit.... incoherent almost. Like he knows what he wants to say but can't quite stay on topic. In no way do I hate him, and I'm not slandering his character at all. He just seems to struggle with some things.
The other guy, Mulvaney, seemed to legitimately try to answer the questions but kept getting cut off because Sanders couldn't follow...
sanders could follow and does know what he is talking about because he knows the language of deception. you see these top percent feeders hide what they are trying to do in language that is designed to fool the layman.
Bernie wasn't about to let Mick answer the question in anyway that did not prove his point. How many times did he interrupt?
Bernie can peddle class envy with the best of them. May we all experience the bliss of socialism that has made Venezuela the marvel that it is today.
Venezuela's problems stem mostly from US sanctions not socialism. if you want to prove its socialism lift all sanctions and resume full trade cooperation.
Powerful Bernie Sanders.
We really missed a chance in 2016. We would be having a great change in our country but in a way that would benefit all. Bernie has already changed our country for the better. Look at the diversity of people at his rallies. That type of diversity is the America I want to live in.
Bernie is a whiny iodine who cannot stand to hear the answers he asked for. If he was a stand up guy he would have never been Hillary’s hand puppet.
He's the sucker of all time. Look how the Democratics hood winked the old fart! The guy's a blind moron...
Just because you don't like the answer doesn't mean he didn't answer the question.
lol..and he is classed as the "honourable" Mick Mulvaney :P...give us a break :D
How can he say this owning three houses surely socialism is about all being equal he is in the top one percent himself he is purely emotionally driven remember Bernie facts don't care about your feelings.!
Give breaks to the employers and cut wic programs that employer can hire the low income mom that doesn’t receive wic anymore.
I love Bernie. But medical insurance is more expensive now with obama care.
Where does Bernie get his "facts"? Does he just make them up?
Bernie sanders doesn't understand that a persons political party has nothing to do with criticizing their performance . It's called integrity
Sanders is like a grumpy old man trying to understand a computer
Damn, sanders’ voice make you want to smack him in his mouth.
Should have asked sanders why he lives in the house and neighborhood when he could live in a mobile home and take a lot less salary.
might as well ask trump post presidency why he still observes a secret service when he was willing to donate his pension soon broke.
This is why Andrew Yang needs to be president.people in office don't respect Bernie enough.i think Bernie is just going through the motions and just arguing just to argue.yang demands respect and speaks in a way where he gets through to people
Why doesn't Bernie give up two of his three houses? Why doesn't he take a pay cut from his 150K salary?
Sanders needs to give up his millions.
Bernie is another bad actor...😂
Sanders needs to retire
bernie doesnt know this is a capitolist country? hes also a millionair
Bernie is crazy AF
TRUMP 2020😎
Sanders is just another blah, blah, blah politician who likes to hear himself speak
I’m so excited to see the circus of the democratic primary of 2019 😀 I’ll make the popcorn
Lol you weren't smart enough to go to college so you had to join the military because you're poor and stupid 😂 I bet you're sexist and racist too
Don Cabán Now that you’ve had time to reflect on it, what would make you say such an ignorant, hateful thing?
Sanders quit against evil hillary and hillary was unelectable due to being mired in scandals thus bringing trump to office the real criminal is the DNC
Bernie should find a home in Russia. He is a fool married to a crook.
Even though it's a low number, I wanna know who dislikes this video because Bernie is sticking up for the wide majority of Americans?
Sanders pretty much revealed as a paper tiger by the end of it
He is only one man if we voted for more with more like him, then maybe we could really get something done. Our legislation is full of corrupt thieves that suck the cocks of corporate America.
So are you saying that congress is full of honorable ethical people?
+gd129
+susynoid remember Of course he doesn't. Chump supporters are uneducated.
I would bet you 1000$ that I'm more intelligent than you by any objective measurement AND more "educated" (I assume you mean universities since they're such a guarantee of practical-minded individuals \kappa)
Trump benefits from this tax break. isn't that a conflict of interest
Just because you don't like the answer doesn't mean he didn't answer the question.