"she's off rhythm" "she's only good in her lower register" "she can't sing" "AUTO TUNE" "she needs to stop doing that with her voice" you guys need to understand that she's still trying to figure out her sound, and she's still learning new things. she's human, she's gonna make mistakes, you just have to let her learn and grow. she's still trying to find herself. i personally think her voice is outstanding and just overall beautiful.
Katie Doorley a lot of artists use auto tune even if they have a great voice so I dot see what the problem is? yeah she might not be the best but she can sing.
yes they do. Some people like Ariana Grande for example do not need much auto tune because she is actually talented (unlike a lot of singers these days). Ariana has a very nice voice, thats why she sounds very similar in real life/ without auto tune.
Her tempo is so off, she's off rhythm and beat so props to the guitarist for keeping up, and if she had a softer voice for this song it would be better, but it's still good
You're right but I think she is improving, she used to be pretty bad so I don't think she's gonna be amazing or anything. But yeah she should really work on it since she considers herself a professional singer
Elle S it sounds like there is alot of reverb in the room i think she might not be used to hearing her music through the ear piece instead of next to her. that makes the most sense why she was off tempo the entire time. usually people can catch up if they just suck.
its the guitarists fault, as an accompaniment hes supposed to match his playing to her singing, shes just using emotion otherwise the song would sound boring
Ellie Hernandez Oh yeah, I totally hear that! I think practising on a softer falsetto in her higher register or staying powerful in her lower register would make her sound much better!
Dymanni Lovell I mean, it's not unpretty. She just gets pitchy and flat when she hits her higher register which is why her lower register is more her comfortable range and sounds nicer.
@@higuystodayimgonnabeshowin5579 Omg y'all Madison stans piss me off. Like this comment was made 3 years ago. At least reply to this person 3 FUCKING years ago. 🙄
kalesea ya but she's completely off beat she might be trying to make it her own or whatever but u would think she could add the riffs and runs while staying on beat
its the guitarists fault, as an accompaniment hes supposed to match his playing to her singing, shes just using emotion otherwise the song would sound boring
I feel like she actually has an extremely unique sound but she's having a hard time releasing it. At times I hear a really hearty sound that i've never heard before but then it like switches to the typical pop sound quickly
@@induranibyju4738 Look, I'm not a hater, she's very talented and obviously gorgeous. But this was not good. She has a good voice, all singers have bad performances. We're not haters, we're just honest.
She really can! This is a great performance, she improved a lot since this but here she did good. didn't strain at the high note, vibrato was good too.
The look of this video is so 90s to me. But damn she's so beautiful and a good singer! People really don't give her credit for how far she's come. Wish people could leave things in the past. Kinda sucks people are like that :/ bc she deserves more
this was actually really good i don’t understand how people are like “off key” and “off beat” bc on the contrary. she stayed on beat for almost the entire song except for one part in the beginning but that’s it. she stayed on key too and managed to hit the high notes well enough.
Bc she wasn't on beat for most of the song and she's trying to do her own thing witch is fine but she didn't stay on key when she did so if she want to make it her own she should consider actually being on beat and being in the right key
She really wasn’t on beat at all if you listen to the real song. She’s incredibly flat and her vibrato sounds like a horse having a seizure. Her belting makes me cringe and it’s awful.
This is not it. To anyone who doesn't know how to sing, this might sound good, but she is off key. Having range and high notes is nothing without good tempo, melody or pitch.
it's not confirmed. no one knows if they've broken up or not. one of the pics floating around is fake. I'm just waiting for one of them to speak out and let us know what's going on. 😟
she did lol. she improved a lot since this but here she did good. didn't strain at the high note, vibrato was good too. but they saw that dude's tiktok who clearly he knows shit bout singing but just hates Madison so they believe what he said just cause they hate Madison and need to find something to hate her for. sorry for eventual grammar mistakes
I don't know why people saying she's off Rhythm I mean come on guys she still did her best here and live singing is often different from originals. Peace✌
"she's off rhythm" "she's only good in her lower register" "she can't sing" "AUTO TUNE" "she needs to stop doing that with her voice"
you guys need to understand that she's still trying to figure out her sound, and she's still learning new things. she's human, she's gonna make mistakes, you just have to let her learn and grow. she's still trying to find herself. i personally think her voice is outstanding and just overall beautiful.
Exactly. Thank you
now shes found it!
she's so freaking pretty
demarloves she is
demarloves she is ✨
She looks like Liza Soberano in some angles.
+Liane Santiago omg same hahahaha I thought about that too
EQ-smoove Amen
Her voice has really improved throughout the years!
Why does this look like it was filmed in the ‘90s?
Fr tho😂💀
It doesn't tho
It doesn t
I don't understand how people can say that she autotunes or that she sucks, I mean, the proof is in this video!
Katie Doorley a lot of artists use auto tune even if they have a great voice so I dot see what the problem is? yeah she might not be the best but she can sing.
Katie Doorley a
Katie Doorley everyone autotunes 😂😂😂😂 ur obviously not very educated in this topic
maia mercado not everyone does love
yes they do. Some people like Ariana Grande for example do not need much auto tune because she is actually talented (unlike a lot of singers these days). Ariana has a very nice voice, thats why she sounds very similar in real life/ without auto tune.
I think if she did a softer voice it would sound a lot better.
Either way I think the song fits her voice!😊
All Things Arista same
Beatriz Goncalves right? I'm not the only one
yeah, she should've sung a lot softer or without the guitar. It wasn't complimenting her voice.
Beatriz Goncalves yeah it was hard for her to stay on tune
Her tempo is so off, she's off rhythm and beat so props to the guitarist for keeping up, and if she had a softer voice for this song it would be better, but it's still good
You're right but I think she is improving, she used to be pretty bad so I don't think she's gonna be amazing or anything. But yeah she should really work on it since she considers herself a professional singer
Thought it was just me. But anyway yeah she is improving throughout these years!!
Elle S it sounds like there is alot of reverb in the room i think she might not be used to hearing her music through the ear piece instead of next to her. that makes the most sense why she was off tempo the entire time. usually people can catch up if they just suck.
how about u can u sing
its the guitarists fault, as an accompaniment hes supposed to match his playing to her singing, shes just using emotion otherwise the song would sound boring
Her vocals are getting sm better but her timing ....
It wasn't off. She made it her own
tanisha wattimury yeahh but she's getting better :))
look at her now!! shes so great
her voice is incredible
didnt know she was so good. her lower register is awesome
Very offbeat and sometimes offkey but her singing voice sound has a lot of potential! Pretty gal
shes just starting out
+Tomboy lol not really. she's been singing for a while
She’s a better singer than Rihanna that’s for sure lol
@@ashb9083 girl byee
@@ashb9083 girl you don't know what talent is. Do your ears finally work after 2 years?
from tiktok ...
same...
she improved a lot since this but here she did good. didn't strain at the high note, vibrato was good too.
Jajajajaja me too
Same-
Same 👁👄👁
She's off beat the whole time....
true
aye Jane its hard to sing a song like this with guitar lmao chrck yourself
kayleigh Check*
kayleigh so? Then she shouldn't sing this song
aye Jane she's not off beat she's just trying to make her own version so that it isnt the same as rihannas. SHE'S BEING ORIGINAL
she is not off beat. sheś doing a cover, a cover means their own version of the song. shes fucking amazing
It’s off key there’s no beat here
She has such a lovely voice and she's beautiful 😍 I just adore Madison
same i love her!
Bella Castellanos why
She's only good in her lower register. The higher she goes the flatter and more off key it gets. Her lower register is her key to success.
Renee S she's an Alto it's kind of hard to hit those high notes, so yeah. I'm an alto and it takes a lot of practice.
Ellie Hernandez Oh yeah, I totally hear that! I think practising on a softer falsetto in her higher register or staying powerful in her lower register would make her sound much better!
She has a beautiful head voice and falsetto. I prefer it to her lower register
Dymanni Lovell I mean, it's not unpretty. She just gets pitchy and flat when she hits her higher register which is why her lower register is more her comfortable range and sounds nicer.
Renee S you can always learn anyways, she lacks control the higher she goes
Who’s here from that one Tik Tok video?
Meeeee
Nicole D. Same
Me
SHE HAS IMPROVED SO MUCH IM SO PROUD
she looks like megan fox
zjm m I KNOW
zjm m duuude right!
She looks like everyone
zjm m To me, she resembles a bit like Liza Soberano.
she is much pretty
Her voice is absolutely perfect!
she sings too fast, noch syncron with the melodie
Sebastian everyone has their own pace while singing
go to bed
@@higuystodayimgonnabeshowin5579 Omg y'all Madison stans piss me off. Like this comment was made 3 years ago. At least reply to this person 3 FUCKING years ago. 🙄
kalesea ya but she's completely off beat she might be trying to make it her own or whatever but u would think she could add the riffs and runs while staying on beat
its the guitarists fault, as an accompaniment hes supposed to match his playing to her singing, shes just using emotion otherwise the song would sound boring
lol why is no one singing along
Mschelle Sandra cuz they want to hear the amazing voice of madison and don't want to ruin this performance
Melissa Horan
i wish all fans were like that
They edited it out
Because this is just the mic feed so you can only hear her
Monica it's coz they can't. She's always off beat they can't keep up lmao
her voice fits this song so well omg
Christa Fontenot I thought the same
she's not singing to the beat of the song but she has a good voice
Damn she's improved so much
This sounds so amazing. I love her voice.
She has a very unique voice. Her voice is strong and rough and I like that veeeeeeeeeeeeeery much! You have a beautiful voice, Madison!
sœmêthïñ íñ thé wæ ÿœu mœvé
her voice is wow😍😭
she sings way too fast
She sounds so perfect 😍 her voice makes me relax
I love her voice so much, she sounds amazing.
I feel like she actually has an extremely unique sound but she's having a hard time releasing it. At times I hear a really hearty sound that i've never heard before but then it like switches to the typical pop sound quickly
IM SO FREAKING PROUD OF HER ! AND WORDS CANT EVEN EXPRESS IT LOVE YOU BABE!
Her voice is just amazing!!
anyone else from tiktok?
her choker omgg 😍 shook
"I WONT CHEW THE STEEEEAAAAK"
I just want Madison to sing her own songs.😭😭😭😭
She's my queen😍💗😩
Ava Kouras
Credit to the guitarist for keeping up with her whack rhythm hahahah but you go girl!
SHE GETS BETTER AT SINGING AND MORE GORG EVERYDAY
she has a nasally voice but other than that she's good!
EditingFlop I love your profile pic
Irish Carter e
EditingFlop so does Britney but where is Britney now? Exactly.
All these comments from three years ago but I came here from TikTok
emma mcadams sameeee
How can she beautiful and talented? I'M UPSET.. but I like Madison, so I guess it's ok.
When people say Madison Beer can't sing, I just show them this, they won't change their mind but still
they're jealous haters prob
@@induranibyju4738 Look, I'm not a hater, she's very talented and obviously gorgeous. But this was not good. She has a good voice, all singers have bad performances. We're not haters, we're just honest.
@@misschanandlerbong1637 ok then
She’s better than this performance she’s so off beat the whole time and she’s goes off key and ends up being flat
3:35 THIS GAVE ME CHILLS SHE'S SO TALENTED
pmbtndojzl yes.. she's talented.
Faith Perry you mean when she went completely flat and squeaked? Alrighty then...
Faith Perry Beyoncé or Adele can do that in their sleep
You got chills from that lmao? from a vocal point of view, the note was very flat. A mess
she's not even singing in time at the beginning lol
she's an angel
She's like a mix between Megan Fox and Sierra Furtado
Man, she's hella good!
yaas
Serving vocals and LOOKS👸🏻
She's so perfect 😭😍
I follow her since Melodies, she improved a lot! Can't tell how proud I am. keep singing Mad, sure I will meet you on your tour some day, I love u 💕
she sounds really good and yes shes gorgeous
This is so good and shes so pretty!
Omg i'm crying, it's soo good. Way too proud
when she didn't she's like arrogant but when she smile she lit up the whole world
She’s so offbeat I think that if I was the guitarist I would’ve thrown the guitar across the stage it’s so frustrating!!!
Wow her voice is so powerful and strong
She needs to understand the song but all those “runs” are useless
1:33 that note is so pretty. SHE is so pretty.
girl i‘m sorry she just can’t sing
She really can! This is a great performance, she improved a lot since this but here she did good. didn't strain at the high note, vibrato was good too.
This was 3 years ago, what’s your point 💀
Same she still can’t have u heard her singing now
@@paris6460 she can't? lmfao the fk u are saying? she sings way better now.
Into the details she can’t wtf u should hear her all she does is tries to be Ariana
Does she remind anyone else of sierra furtado?
yess!
Laura no Madisons way prettier
Laura YES
Laura don't disrespect sierra like that 😂
She sounds amazing, she has a perfect voice to me. Her low register is literally sounds like what a low register should sound like.
she looks like she has tears in her eyes 😢😢😢
Everyone in the comments is crazy 🙄 Her voice is freaking amazing, I wish i had a voice like that.
The look of this video is so 90s to me. But damn she's so beautiful and a good singer! People really don't give her credit for how far she's come. Wish people could leave things in the past. Kinda sucks people are like that :/ bc she deserves more
i love her voice you go madison😭😭😭
she's gorgeous and she sings so well
she wasnt off-key she actually sounded so good its the guitar pitch is just not for her
To anyone saying she can't sing lmao haters she is freaking good
Simiane C she was off tune
Simiane C no
Just watched her perform this in London and she's improved so much and is just the sweetest girl ever😍😍😍
3:47 she was really feeling what she was singing about
wonderful voice ! love it !😘😘😘
Queen, I love this and her
this was actually really good i don’t understand how people are like “off key” and “off beat” bc on the contrary. she stayed on beat for almost the entire song except for one part in the beginning but that’s it. she stayed on key too and managed to hit the high notes well enough.
Bc she wasn't on beat for most of the song and she's trying to do her own thing witch is fine but she didn't stay on key when she did so if she want to make it her own she should consider actually being on beat and being in the right key
Which ****
She really wasn’t on beat at all if you listen to the real song. She’s incredibly flat and her vibrato sounds like a horse having a seizure. Her belting makes me cringe and it’s awful.
she gave me goosebumps as fuck and she is such a incredible idol. Madison is flawless
i love her so much
I just love madison so much
_She sounds amazing ♡ ♡ ♡_
she has such an incredible voice
3:31 was actually so beautiful
She's so beautiful 😍😍
This is not it. To anyone who doesn't know how to sing, this might sound good, but she is off key. Having range and high notes is nothing without good tempo, melody or pitch.
Omg this is amazing i love you Madison!
Love her voice
So excited for her album to come out, and im still wondering on if jadison broke up or not.. I honestly thought they were never going to break up
they didnt
They did, she said it on Instagram
it's not confirmed. no one knows if they've broken up or not. one of the pics floating around is fake. I'm just waiting for one of them to speak out and let us know what's going on. 😟
well she's wearing the ring he have her so idk but i hope not
I hope they didn't break up. honestly. I love my two favs being together. maybe they're taking a break. I hope that's the worst thing it could be.
Madison is just . . . Amazing. 💙💎
3:31 my little replay button
It feels like she's singing for jack 😭 #jadisonforever
what happened with her and jack
+heyitsmagda they broke up
karina styles no they didn't that was just a stupid rumor
Meg Espinosa why should she sings this bc of jack? No she didn't she just loves Rihanna
Omg Love this so much❤️
my queen she is freaking slaying every note
she has a beautiful voice 🤩
shes so gorgeous ugh
Why is she so gorgeous!!! I admire her beauty
I see a lot of hate comments towards madisons singing being offkey but in my opinion, she sang the song very well and song for a good cause
she did lol. she improved a lot since this but here she did good. didn't strain at the high note, vibrato was good too. but they saw that dude's tiktok who clearly he knows shit bout singing but just hates Madison so they believe what he said just cause they hate Madison and need to find something to hate her for. sorry for eventual grammar mistakes
She sounds good I love her voice it leaves me in chills I love her
I don't know why people saying she's off Rhythm I mean come on guys she still did her best here and live singing is often different from originals. Peace✌
Look how natural she is, what a great woman! I was on some concerts but never got the money for backstage passes. I hope i will meet her sometime!