PM Modi doesn't know any economics: Subramanian Swamy | ThinkEdu2020

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 21 сен 2024
  • Subramanian Swamy tells TNIE Editorial Director Prabhu Chawla what he thinks is the way forward for India's economy and why a $ 5 trillion economy is not possible to achieve at this rate
    #ThinkEdu2020 #SubramanianSwamy #PrabhuChawla

Комментарии • 2,9 тыс.

  • @kushalsharma55
    @kushalsharma55 4 года назад +447

    7:28 - he said 2 months from now (Jan 2020)the stock market will crash , and it crashed exactly in March 2020 , he is a real gem 💎 Respect 🙏🏻

    • @SauravBhagat20
      @SauravBhagat20 4 года назад +33

      It wasn't a prediction per se. He basically meant that the portfolio investors, profit minded top investors would invest and then take out money in a few months. As a result the stock market would rise and then fall. He was talking about the 'trend'.

    • @saiharshan7505
      @saiharshan7505 4 года назад +11

      It was because of lockdown too.

    • @kushalsharma55
      @kushalsharma55 4 года назад +10

      Saurav Bhagat easy to say now , not many people knew this in Jan 2020

    • @kushalsharma55
      @kushalsharma55 4 года назад +6

      sai harshan before lockdown the economy was already in deep trouble , fall was bound to happen

    • @SauravBhagat20
      @SauravBhagat20 4 года назад +10

      @@kushalsharma55 Bhai I am not criticizing or correcting what Swamiji said. I am implying that people here have taken it in wrong context. It wasn't a future prediction about economy rather he was pointing towards a 'trend' of ups and downs in economy due to Foreign Portfolio Investors. They put money, make a kill and when they have made enough profit then lets say after two months from now they withdraw it. This is a trend he talks about. A trend isn't a prediction.

  • @vasdgod
    @vasdgod 4 года назад +1638

    Why does the interviwer looks like a child born out of Manmohan singh and modi

  • @parth654
    @parth654 4 года назад +564

    Nowadays we miss this kind of journalist, having in depth knowledge Nd humble attitude...

    • @mayanknaudiyal2508
      @mayanknaudiyal2508 4 года назад +33

      That is Prabhu Chawla the anchor ..... Don't mistake his as a humble person 😂... Watch his early work and you will be surprised.
      He is humble because it's Mr.Swami.... noone dares to talk stupid with him 😅

    • @malladipradyumna1650
      @malladipradyumna1650 4 года назад +4

      Did I miss something? He was very irritating to me

    • @mayanknaudiyal2508
      @mayanknaudiyal2508 4 года назад +2

      @@malladipradyumna1650 That's because he is.

    • @snehadewangan
      @snehadewangan 4 года назад

      They manipulate people..

    • @harshjain3122
      @harshjain3122 4 года назад +1

      @@snehadewangan they even edit out the interview and distort it as they please or/and pertaining to their ideologies (the ideologies depend upon which party invested in them more)

  • @nageshbabukm1099
    @nageshbabukm1099 4 года назад +114

    I'm the only person thinking swami sir should be a PM of India.

    • @rashidrazakhan9153
      @rashidrazakhan9153 4 года назад

      @Diptasree Choudhuri is that sarcasm on our Honarable pm modi.

    • @himanshujindal1004
      @himanshujindal1004 4 года назад +3

      He is a great person but he is more than 80 so it will not a good decision to make him pm

    • @ed8676
      @ed8676 3 года назад +6

      @@rashidrazakhan9153 Not honorable but Puppet PM of Ambani and Adani. Just search where did all the funds collected in PM care fund during covid-19 went.

    • @techarjee4743
      @techarjee4743 3 года назад

      No he should be our FM

    • @ayushmishra2419
      @ayushmishra2419 3 года назад

      i also think the same way.

  • @tejas6925
    @tejas6925 4 года назад +148

    He is a GEM . the man who actually has some balls . I hope he lives a very long and very healthy life.

  • @SatishKumar-cp1wv
    @SatishKumar-cp1wv 4 года назад +850

    I voted BJP because of Swami...very much dissatisfied that Modi govt is not utilizing Swami to revive the economy.

    • @soulslayer59
      @soulslayer59 4 года назад +25

      that is so true man!! i support bjp mostly cuz of him. lately i pretty disappointed by the govermnent i was supporting ...sigh!! ....wish we had some other party we could choose better off !!

    • @harshjeetvatsalya2583
      @harshjeetvatsalya2583 4 года назад +1

      Is he from your constituency?

    • @anandhegde3229
      @anandhegde3229 4 года назад +16

      He's an idiot.. if he becomes FM, he'll abolish entire income tax, .. such an idiot decision

    • @dandalasuman
      @dandalasuman 4 года назад +22

      Subramanya Swami was disappointed with Modi Government's poor economic performance ,
      Ram Jetmalani was disappointed for not doing anything to bring back black money
      Arun Shourie & Yeshwant Sinha were disappointed with Modi's dictator style leadership

    • @dandalasuman
      @dandalasuman 4 года назад +14

      @@anandhegde3229 He told to abolish income tax of individual tax payers, earlier Prime Minister Narendra Modi said that of a total population of 130 crore people, only 1.5 crore pay income tax. In a series of tweets, the CBDT said: “Only around 1.46 crore individual taxpayers are liable to pay income-tax. Further, around 1 crore individuals disclosed income between Rs. 5-10 lakh and only 46 lakh individual taxpayers have disclosed income above Rs.10 lakh”.
      www.financialexpress.com/economy/how-many-people-in-india-actually-pay-tax-income-tax-department-clarifies-pm-modis-claim/1867332/

  • @IM-ep1be
    @IM-ep1be 4 года назад +1484

    When he wants to speak on some religious issue, godi media interviews him. But when he wants to speak on economy, godi media ignores him.😂

    • @bharat9837
      @bharat9837 4 года назад +10

      That's y u r able to see this video

    • @Unnecessarily_Honest
      @Unnecessarily_Honest 4 года назад +2

      @Susmita Nath ghatia channel

    • @tommichael5819
      @tommichael5819 4 года назад +31

      @@bharat9837 this is a youtube channel not any major news channel

    • @sanojdeepak4287
      @sanojdeepak4287 4 года назад +28

      @Sun Ray Modi may not make money for himself but it is a proven fact that he only cares for the well being of BJP party even at the expense the country and its economy.

    • @sanojdeepak4287
      @sanojdeepak4287 4 года назад +22

      @@tommichael5819 The real media has sold out its ethics and integrity in favour of the ruling party. If you want to know what's really happening in India, you should see some of these genuine RUclips channels. It's the only place where the government has not been able to influence.

  • @narayanjha735
    @narayanjha735 4 года назад +261

    It's such a candid interview that I have ever seen...
    Currently he is the only leader in BJP who is audacious enough to criticize own Govt.
    Said very well, keep your friend close but keep your enemies closure.
    I am damn sure he would be better FM than Nirmala Sitaraman. How innocently he replied last question, "meri baijati ho jayegi agar wo nahi sunega to"
    I must confess here one thing, I was sceptical towards you and your points of view but now I am getting impressed as much inetrview as I am seeing of yours.

    • @kevinmenezes8386
      @kevinmenezes8386 4 года назад +8

      Dr. Swamy needs to be respected and India needs leaders like him. He has disagreed with the Prime Minister or with his party policies basically because he has more knowledge in that subject (economics) and unlike many who would have just agreed and gone with the flow. We should respect that very fact that in a democracy it is ok to disagree on views.
      I don't agree with some of Dr. Swamy's ideology but I appreciate that he puts forward his view and very calmly explains his side of the plot. And in a country as diverse as ours, we need to atleast give the other person a chance to speak and we should be patient to listen to it. And then come to a solution which will lead us to progress.

    • @raah.e.ishq99
      @raah.e.ishq99 4 года назад +1

      2 hi behtr economist hain hamare paas ek Subramanian Swamy aur 2sre Manmohan Singh

    • @shreeshshukla8638
      @shreeshshukla8638 4 года назад +1

      Keep your enemies closer not closure

    • @srikanthyadav9507
      @srikanthyadav9507 4 года назад

      He would better PM THAN MODI

    • @abhishekk7777
      @abhishekk7777 4 года назад +1

      Any day better than Nirmala Sitharam

  • @MrTanmaydeepak
    @MrTanmaydeepak 4 года назад +13

    Great Economists of India-
    Dr. Ambedkar, Manmohan Singh, Amarya Sen & Subramanian Swamy

  • @rahularya1803
    @rahularya1803 4 года назад +84

    Swamy is man of very broad knowledge base. He is kind of old Rishi.

    •  3 года назад +1

      He was bought on Shushants case and agrees with Dr Gupta. He said baby penguin is innocent without proof

    • @ankitaaarya
      @ankitaaarya 3 года назад +1

      Totaly agreed absolutely

    • @ankitaaarya
      @ankitaaarya 3 года назад +1

      He should write books to spread knowledge

    • @ankitaaarya
      @ankitaaarya 3 года назад +1

      More book

  • @manojvarughese4337
    @manojvarughese4337 4 года назад +187

    The problem with this individual is he speaks truth to a point that it's so blunt. And that ends up triggering every parties.

    • @epsibaepsiba9392
      @epsibaepsiba9392 4 года назад

      @@kolanvelu3420 ö. 8

    • @mehtabsinghdhaliwal3113
      @mehtabsinghdhaliwal3113 4 года назад +1

      So what?

    • @adamburakowski2508
      @adamburakowski2508 4 года назад +6

      It's not a problem, he is working for the public.

    • @srividyadhardantu6
      @srividyadhardantu6 4 года назад +1

      tats a good character others should also speak like that and lean to tolerate others

    • @user_1abc
      @user_1abc 3 года назад +1

      He only speaks the truth when he has an agenda. He has been sidelined by Modi govt and hence he has become vocal. Modi govt perhaps doesn't like anyone too well educated. Why? The wavelengths of highly educated people don't match with Modi govt top Ministers may be? That's why top DR Raghuram Rajan never sought another term, and equally capable and well accomplished guys like Dr Urijit Patel and Dr Viral Acharya quit. Considering Swamy's elite educational background and illustrious career, he'd still be a better choice as FM/C&I Minister than any other candidate the NDA govt has had in the last 7-8 yrs. Again, his age is becoming a problem now...or does India only want septagenarian and octagenarian leaders?

  • @sanojdeepak4287
    @sanojdeepak4287 4 года назад +462

    If Modi doesn't know economics, he should keep away from it and appoint real economists as finance minister and let them do their job and don't micromanage them.

    • @sudarshan3965
      @sudarshan3965 4 года назад +55

      He loves controlling everything like dictator. That's why he appointed nirmala aitaraman

    • @sanojdeepak4287
      @sanojdeepak4287 4 года назад +25

      @@sudarshan3965 The common trait of all dictators are that they don't take kindly to unpleasant feedback. You might have heard the term "kill the messenger". Modi is an expert at that.

    • @blaisevegas5367
      @blaisevegas5367 4 года назад +11

      Our PM is Jack of all master of none .

    • @sanojdeepak4287
      @sanojdeepak4287 4 года назад +12

      @jvn Yes you are partly right, modi will continue to kick ass. Not corrupt ass as you said but he is kicking the ass of poor workers. Ask the workers.
      Acche din is here. Ask Ambani and Adani.

    • @rockrani945
      @rockrani945 4 года назад +9

      Modi degree is gobarnomic, you are asking about economics how will he know .

  • @noname-sk3hl
    @noname-sk3hl 4 года назад +366

    BJP and opposition both know nothing about Economics.
    *Swamy ji for the next finance minister*
    Edit: Idk, months of following him, I realised, with all due respect, that Swamyji likes talking big. Idk if can actually backup his claims or not. So I m not so sure, bit confused.

    • @kanchansharma2608
      @kanchansharma2608 4 года назад +32

      Unfortunately time is running out and Dr Swamy us getting old....I also want to see him as our FM

    • @yash3022
      @yash3022 4 года назад +12

      True we need him as FM. Our economy will be quite strong

    • @urshanksthakur
      @urshanksthakur 4 года назад +2

      True.

    • @vaishnavijahagirdar5116
      @vaishnavijahagirdar5116 4 года назад +8

      Swami ji for the next Prime Minister!

    • @wanderingsoul457
      @wanderingsoul457 4 года назад

      Next march we want swamy ji

  • @danielpani8003
    @danielpani8003 4 года назад +22

    5 trillion economy idea was given to him by Rana Kapoor, ex head of yes bank who is now behind bars. So much for BJP!

    • @psychout3481
      @psychout3481 3 года назад

      lol. You Indians never cease to amaze me with your politicians and politics.

  • @RJ4277
    @RJ4277 3 года назад +94

    "It's not economics, It's fraud"
    -Dr. Swamy. Member of Parliament(BJP) 2020

    • @AnkitSingh-vi3qr
      @AnkitSingh-vi3qr 2 года назад

      Are bhai PhD in economics from Harvard University 🤣🤣

    • @shobhitdagur1086
      @shobhitdagur1086 Год назад

      ​@@AnkitSingh-vi3qr Harvard University and Assford

  • @ph6263
    @ph6263 4 года назад +117

    Swamy :- Phd from Harvard, economist, Statistician, 0 Scripted interviews, never ran from press
    Modiji :- MBBS from baba ramdev university, LLB from Pragya Singh University and MTech from university of Modiji (The new invention of theory of Clouds and Radars), Better mathematician than Shakuntala devi (invented the new formula of (a+b) square, better poet than Atalji (Watch deepak Choursia interview with question and answer as poem written on cheat note)
    100 Press conferences
    1000 :- scripted interviews

    • @shezadahmed5656
      @shezadahmed5656 4 года назад

      Definately

    • @vedika6260
      @vedika6260 4 года назад +7

      But he is the lion of majestic INDIA

    • @ph6263
      @ph6263 4 года назад +14

      @@vedika6260 lol lion never afraids to the press, neither Neharu, Indiraji, Rao sir nor Atalji, manmohan singh

    • @ph6263
      @ph6263 4 года назад +8

      @Sridhar B modi afraids the press you muppet thats why he attends scripted interviews I you still not believe then may be you are the same guy who believes wwe is not scripted 😁

    • @deepsvlogs9808
      @deepsvlogs9808 4 года назад

      Former IIT DELHI professor .

  • @DevSingh-bz1fv
    @DevSingh-bz1fv 4 года назад +125

    he is crystal clear in his thoughts and actions

  • @shreyanskumar6656
    @shreyanskumar6656 4 года назад +211

    At first, I thought the interviewer was mimicking Modi, like in those TVF videos. XOXO.

    • @roynotintown
      @roynotintown 4 года назад +11

      😂😂😂. Actually he is wearing wig. He was an hindi anchor he used to do Seedi bath for ajtak

    • @shreyanskumar6656
      @shreyanskumar6656 4 года назад +1

      @@roynotintown Holy shit 😂😂😂😂

    • @virtualatall
      @virtualatall 4 года назад

      Yeah.. He used to appear as bald and clean shaven at that time!

    • @neharai4927
      @neharai4927 4 года назад +1

      He would look fine without wig. More natural. Thumbs down to his wig specialist

    • @ImSANK29
      @ImSANK29 4 года назад +1

      Shivankit😂😂😂

  • @athensmajnoo3661
    @athensmajnoo3661 4 года назад +1

    What a straight forward person!!
    I respect him for his knowledge and guts!!
    The interviewer is horribly irritating, he spoke most of the time, not letting Mr Swamy finish his sentences.

    •  3 года назад

      Straight forward my foot. He clears baby penguin and agrees with Gupta on Shushants suicide. The person can be bought

  • @PankajSharma-lo3md
    @PankajSharma-lo3md Год назад +1

    Dr. Subramanian Swamy should be the finance minister of our country

  • @dmkhasim8819
    @dmkhasim8819 4 года назад +26

    When he speaks, he speaks with facts on his front🙏🙏♥️💐🌹
    Best line from swamy sir : This government don't have/like critics 🥀🙏

    • @termsconditions4299
      @termsconditions4299 4 года назад

      What is the use. ....... When he cannot make him understand ......

  • @manajbanerjee1124
    @manajbanerjee1124 4 года назад +69

    The problem of this fateless country is that we do not lay emphasis on the "beginners" level, unlike western economics. Here everything begins at a high level but not at "basics." There is not any option here who are broke.

    • @aasiqkumar732
      @aasiqkumar732 4 года назад

      Fateless country. Atleast have some respect for the homeland. Don't be foolish. This country gave us everything. So don't act oversmart.

    • @koushlendrapatel5100
      @koushlendrapatel5100 4 года назад +1

      Hey don't call this country a fatelass country.
      And remove your profile pic
      It looks like cartoon

    • @koushlendrapatel5100
      @koushlendrapatel5100 3 года назад

      @Last BlueMountain any doubt??

    • @aasiqkumar732
      @aasiqkumar732 3 года назад

      @Last BlueMountain 2014 se nhi khae abhi tak kya laure

    • @LetsbeHonest97
      @LetsbeHonest97 Год назад

      boom! You hit the nail on the head

  • @anilkumar-ff2ml
    @anilkumar-ff2ml 4 года назад +167

    Wise man wise words. Daring man who speaks the truth without hesitation

    • @HeartistMurali
      @HeartistMurali 4 года назад +2

      What's the truth he speaks???

    • @aaqibkar71
      @aaqibkar71 4 года назад +1

      murali bro he ( anil kumar) must be illiterate he was just impressed by the way he speake English 🤣🤣🤣

    • @HeartistMurali
      @HeartistMurali 4 года назад +3

      @@aaqibkar71 well, his English is also not impressive for a man who taught in Harvard.......

    • @anilkumar-ff2ml
      @anilkumar-ff2ml 4 года назад +3

      Aaqib Kar ur reply shows how uncultured you are

    • @srivathsamarella7505
      @srivathsamarella7505 4 года назад +1

      @@HeartistMurali Truth; which means Facts.

  • @saurabhsable4856
    @saurabhsable4856 4 года назад +1

    Haters will hate...but no doubt he is capable of being the best prime minister of India😇 he is always very clear about what he says...Huge respect to you sir.

  • @nyanlem1471
    @nyanlem1471 3 года назад +6

    A well educated and experienced politician, who knows a lot about Indian politics.

  • @Beekmannn
    @Beekmannn 4 года назад +66

    He outlived all the people who question his age efficiency 😂! “Jinhone kaha vo mar gaye 65 me” 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @glavincrasta4095
    @glavincrasta4095 3 года назад +8

    This is most underrated political interview

  • @souban2008
    @souban2008 4 года назад +6

    I prey to God, Swamy must live more 40 years.🙏

  • @ShivamSingh-xk3dt
    @ShivamSingh-xk3dt 4 года назад +1

    Subramanyam Swami is the world's best leader and its and his should be a great finance minister of India

  • @kernainstruments1248
    @kernainstruments1248 3 года назад +2

    Swamiji says Nehru failed in his exams. Nehru passed his Cambridge exams with honours where he stood second. He cleared the barrister exams in 1912. I never thought that Mr Swamy could lie about such things

  • @YG-ib1ho
    @YG-ib1ho 4 года назад +8

    He is an intellectual....his views should be respected... He has taken constructive corrective actions on lot of issues and brought them to conclusion...

    • @premmanjunath1032
      @premmanjunath1032 4 года назад

      True

    • @oxymoron9580
      @oxymoron9580 4 года назад +1

      Lmao a religious extremist cannot be an intellectual😂

    • @YG-ib1ho
      @YG-ib1ho 4 года назад

      @@oxymoron9580 OK moron

    • @oxymoron9580
      @oxymoron9580 4 года назад

      @Dark Assassin Killing in the name of a particular religion isnt the benchmark for extremism. That bigot believes in hindu supremacy and does not respect the secular nature of the country. My point though is believers can never be intellectuals as they are sure about something about which there is no concrete evidence.

  • @surindermohan9247
    @surindermohan9247 4 года назад +6

    This is what each & everyone knows since his joining the office. Surprised😳 that subramanyam could know the facts after so long.

    • @billarakesh4311
      @billarakesh4311 4 года назад

      Swamy from the beginning saying this thing

  • @jeevankg
    @jeevankg 4 года назад +15

    I like his confidence he is a man of action, responsible, conviction. I will.love to see him being Finance Minister of India.

    • @plamwahlang3065
      @plamwahlang3065 4 года назад

      Jeevan Kumar. G he should be PM and finance ministry to his own portfolio

    • @dhamkulkarni
      @dhamkulkarni 4 года назад

      That is never going to happen bcoz he is a good guy

  • @jacobgeorge2998
    @jacobgeorge2998 3 года назад

    Respect for Swamy's knowledge. Wish he was not prejudiced.

  • @antriksh_05
    @antriksh_05 4 года назад +4

    He is one of the interviewer who at least asked sensible questions

  • @vithaldasnayak1564
    @vithaldasnayak1564 4 года назад +74

    Economics is only one of Many Components .
    Manmohan Singh, P Chidambaram, and many
    We're having having Knowledge of Economics.Nehru, Indira Gandhi and Rajeev Gandhi were also not economists Even a layman Can run the Government Successfully
    if his team is good and intentions are pure.

    • @ph6263
      @ph6263 4 года назад +10

      If the layman is somewhat intelligent or educated not the one who runs from the press and don't want to utter own words before people

    • @cynmurthy8343
      @cynmurthy8343 4 года назад

      Right Perception...GBY.🤝🌹🤝

    • @poojajoshi9784
      @poojajoshi9784 4 года назад +4

      Person shouldn't be a photogenic or additict to photography too much like PM

  • @One.L.S
    @One.L.S 4 года назад +19

    Lead without Titles, Swami ji. For the sake of Bharat Mata, please help the PM to boost the Economy. Bharat Mata and its citizens have already thanked you enough. Humble request.

  • @Kgn12349
    @Kgn12349 4 года назад +14

    Subramanyam Swamy is a genius and a straight forward person. I salute him.

  • @princedua8746
    @princedua8746 4 года назад +11

    7:27 he said that market is going to crash in 2 months and we know exactly what happen on 25th march and main thing is that he has given the reason that why de he feel market is going to correct. Respect🙏🙏
    anyone agree?

  • @sukhWins
    @sukhWins 4 года назад +21

    Wow a person who doesn’t event understand basics of economics is running over country! How did we let that happen

    • @archsubs3573
      @archsubs3573 4 года назад +2

      You let an extremist run the country.

    •  3 года назад

      He does not have to know everything. He has good advisors.
      We have the best PM ever

    • @sukhWins
      @sukhWins 3 года назад +1

      @ he has to know something lol. Some education should be mandatory for a pm. Would you let a doctor without proper education who has the best nurses let operate on a patient.

    • @Harry.B.W
      @Harry.B.W 3 года назад

      Bro Modi is Prime minister not finance minister 😂 is run country but all different minister are helping them
      For example in our house dad is Prime minister. and mummy and sis,bro is like other ministers 😂

    • @Indrauta
      @Indrauta 3 года назад

      @@archsubs3573 cope

  • @sunderkennady5445
    @sunderkennady5445 4 года назад +8

    Swamy was well suite for this interview, despite I don't understand Hindi, the Speaker just making Swamy boring to ans the same question bombarded to Swamiji before, In fear that I m writing this comment, as Swamiji may not appear to answer patty question again and again, please I seek Swamiji can be brought into question, that no man dares to dive into area more, and has paramount importance only, that the common man need to enlighten about. Of greatest of last leader, Lee Kuan Yew of Singapore passing , No doubt he, Subramaniam Swamiji has captured the World Class spot that vacated by the last great leaders and he stand next. And I m proud we are common in veins n ideas to change the course of Nation to where Nation should stand to lead, than our greed.

    • @wren4077
      @wren4077 4 года назад +1

      English isn't your language either apparently

  • @raknaskihtrak8266
    @raknaskihtrak8266 4 года назад +42

    When he says , " Chidambaram is a C grade student ! " ...." They call Nehru , "Pandit Ji " .... he failed all exams .....shame on pandit ji" ...........it just cracked me up hardcore.

  • @kaur13
    @kaur13 4 года назад +35

    Somewhere in between interview feels like two uncles chilling and discussing politics in a parks.

  • @kartiknayyar1134
    @kartiknayyar1134 4 года назад +1

    Everyone should tweet with hashtag #MakeSubramaniyamSwamyFinaneMinister.
    I already did❤️

  • @rudrakshsharma1893
    @rudrakshsharma1893 4 года назад +1

    This is how a journalist should be intelligent calm and talks with knowledge. Love Swamy ji Too...!!

  • @jkyotikhiphop4730
    @jkyotikhiphop4730 4 года назад +13

    One thing I like in Subrahmanyam Swami, He lies quaintly and does not flinch!

  • @emmanueltamang7847
    @emmanueltamang7847 3 года назад +10

    Swamyji is real swamy of knowledge, expression and communication

  • @dewytwilight7434
    @dewytwilight7434 4 года назад +9

    Finally I saw him talking some truth about economy

  • @wanderingboi
    @wanderingboi 3 года назад +1

    When India's pm (not modi.. but in future if some person gets elected) will have discussion over economics like this in the interview and not mangoes we will witness the growth.

  • @tapasrukun16
    @tapasrukun16 2 года назад

    Intelligent, daring,knowledgeable speaks his own view fearlessly,pm should utilize his talent

  • @satishkulkarni2399
    @satishkulkarni2399 4 года назад +4

    He is sincere and if made FM will change d economy...just announcement if made making him as FM will get reflected in SENSEX.

    • @nitinpatle722
      @nitinpatle722 3 года назад

      the thing is swamyji can't be controlled

  • @roseesor9451
    @roseesor9451 4 года назад +98

    Why is the anchor interrupting? Let him speak!

    • @sav3nad
      @sav3nad 4 года назад +2

      chawla is a no.! idiot,that's why he always interrupts the good ones.

    • @himanshusaxena8639
      @himanshusaxena8639 4 года назад +1

      He is prabhu chawla that's y

    • @samsrock2009
      @samsrock2009 4 года назад +9

      U must watch republic tv then u will know what is interruption

    • @aminulhassanbtcl
      @aminulhassanbtcl 4 года назад +1

      Interupting is bad, but it appears the anchor is old and informed enough to ask him question. But few anchor are young and agressive and ready to show off thier knowledge.

    • @fairwind3058
      @fairwind3058 4 года назад +2

      I thought so too. Anchor was desperate to show his penny worth of knowledge.

  • @klshorejain582
    @klshorejain582 4 года назад +40

    He is perfect for finance minister.

    •  3 года назад

      No he was congress and only got into BJP to be somebody. Although he is knowledge able. He is not the best for our country. Where as Modi Ji is very intelligent and works for the poor and our country.

  • @arvindiyer4995
    @arvindiyer4995 Год назад

    Dr. Swamy is beyond politics and truly about growth and prosperity of India. The only reason he is not in the cabinet is because he has the power to question the PM and critic the PM

  • @sabhji9780
    @sabhji9780 3 года назад

    He says he took Modi's name during 2005 election when no one cared for Modi. Now In 2021 I understand his wisdom and awareness to choose a great leader like Modiji to rapt to the position of prime Minister. Look how well modiji is handling this pandemic. We have become role model for entire world in handling covid crisis with the second wave after April.

  • @Rustomhavewalla
    @Rustomhavewalla 4 года назад +38

    Very intelligent replies by Mr. Swamy.
    Jawaharlal Nehru failing so many times and still being called Panditji.
    Jaitley who said Ministers should not be above 75, died just after being 65.
    Putting more money in the hands of consumers.
    Encouraging small industries and businesses to generate more employment and hence more money in the hands of the consumers.
    It's unfortunate that Mr. Swamy is not the FM.
    The interviewer was a big nuisance. He was too loud and irritating.

    •  3 года назад

      Swamy works only for money

    • @Rustomhavewalla
      @Rustomhavewalla 3 года назад

      @ Swamy is not allowed to work because as per the BJP excuse, he is over-age.

    • @6grags
      @6grags 3 года назад +2

      True. Small and Medium industries are suffering very very badly due to ill effects of Ache Dins. No business can have liquidity as Gabbar Singh Tax itself a biggest burden. Businesses have to give credit of 60 days to 120 days for the goods sold to companies. In the case of Gabbar Singh Taxes one has to pay the entire taxes at slabs @18% to 28% with in a month. For whose sake some one is doing is it for themselves or for good days providing Lotus Govt. No will have the luxury of doing nothing on the contrary screw up everything built over decades within a short time yet brag all the time. Enough is Enough of botched good days . God should put an end to this chaos and allow everyone one to have a peaceful and affordable living. We have no support of big business houses to support us. Some are lucky to have listeners though every one knows what one is talking is not relevant or anything with the subject. When we talk like that people brand us as insane.
      Harvard is Harvard and mere talkathon is only talkathon.

    • @Rustomhavewalla
      @Rustomhavewalla 3 года назад

      @@6grags अब मैं क्या करू?

    • @naiyayika
      @naiyayika 2 года назад

      @@6grags Before 2014 India was the Edens garden. True
      What to expect from a woke?

  • @srividyadhardantu6
    @srividyadhardantu6 4 года назад +9

    every time I listen Swamy I learn something

  • @ManpreetKaur-tr6bz
    @ManpreetKaur-tr6bz 4 года назад +14

    18:32 wow! Such a bold Statement.... him before this interview! Though I still hate him...But such fearless answers 😂 #Respect

    • @SatyamSingh-jp3vc
      @SatyamSingh-jp3vc 4 года назад +2

      Yeah I hate him too cause he called bhinderwala is a saint. Come on how can you call a terrorist, a saint.

    • @parmar__12
      @parmar__12 4 года назад +1

      @@SatyamSingh-jp3vc hate him for this small reason 🤣 lol

  • @sunilkirby7860
    @sunilkirby7860 Год назад

    Dr Swami should be a part of the government in decision making when it comes to economics, he has a rich experience in economic development.

  • @shashimenon1000
    @shashimenon1000 Год назад +1

    Prabhu Chawla audio volume too loud. Does not balance with the guest. Makes it difficult to listen.

  • @whiskeyandice7236
    @whiskeyandice7236 4 года назад +5

    He predicted the stock market crash and it did crash😲

  • @sumanth9523
    @sumanth9523 3 года назад +9

    This was even before corona. After corona, Modi has become a bigger joker in terms of financial planning and development.

  • @nirdoshyadav7074
    @nirdoshyadav7074 4 года назад +24

    Mr Swamy is an intelligent man.I would have appreciated if Rahul Gandhi had studied under his guidance.

    • @apurva1589
      @apurva1589 4 года назад +6

      To study from the Teacher of harvard you 1st need to pass some exams :)

    • @satishkulkarni2399
      @satishkulkarni2399 4 года назад +4

      Still there is time to learn. He can and become strong...knowledge wise.

    • @nirdoshyadav7074
      @nirdoshyadav7074 4 года назад

      @Surendra K I appreciate your opinion but I figure I am not cut for politics.😀

  • @hrmn2427
    @hrmn2427 3 года назад

    if anyone in BJP should have been the PM it is Dr. Subramanian Swamy. He has socially and religiously neutral mindset, Actually an intelligent individual knowledge wise, politically experienced, Knowledge about economics, the list goes on.....

  • @harshalsahu2072
    @harshalsahu2072 Год назад +1

    I am not even 0.00000001 % of respected subramanyam swami ji... I support him, and I do respect him...and being a centrist I do not support modi and bjp on certain matter. But my simple point is this that how we have came to 5th in terms of economy in the last 9 year. And when the economist manmohan ji was our prime minister he just took indias from 12th to 11th. How could this possible that india's most educated pm hadn't contributed in terms of enhancing our economy, by his potency. And the chaiwala took us from 10th to 5th largest economy in the world?

  • @shivangchaturvedi237
    @shivangchaturvedi237 3 года назад +3

    I have never seen any politician speak so bluntly on such important issue. Even he acknowledges ki Modi sarkar dhakkan hai

  • @r.balasubramaniam682
    @r.balasubramaniam682 4 года назад +5

    Great ideas on creating good economy from Dr Swamy

  • @debotroy7673
    @debotroy7673 4 года назад +11

    🤣🧡he isn't afraid to speak the truth.
    I am a supporter of bjp and yes nathula isn't a good economist. We need swamy in place of her🧡

  • @CM-hn6oc
    @CM-hn6oc 2 года назад +1

    He is on 🔥
    Straightforward
    Machine Gun
    JNU-- SUBHASH CHANDRA BOSE University

  • @kabita7811
    @kabita7811 2 года назад

    He is boss of Indian politics. He is clear in speech he don't afraid of anybody. He criticizes everybody is he makes mistakes 😊 this is why I love Mr. Swami

  • @bhavichechi8578
    @bhavichechi8578 4 года назад +4

    Great man with Great views

  • @believerone2001
    @believerone2001 4 года назад +4

    Stock market has collapsed by thousand points per day..Dr Swami is right today .Gang of hopeless crowd in the Government.

  • @jojic5048
    @jojic5048 4 года назад +7

    "PM Modi doesn't know any economics:"
    That is why he is Prime Minister

    •  3 года назад

      he is our best PM. Swami can never take his place

  • @Brajesh3
    @Brajesh3 4 года назад +1

    Really a superb interview both of them shree Dr Swami and Mr chawla are so intelligent and conducting a great intellectual debate. But in today's time the debates are so valgur.🙏

  • @m.modwelx6362
    @m.modwelx6362 2 года назад +2

    Trust in Advisers plus Council of Ministers is much higher than Knowledge of Economics.Thanks Swamiji for your valued Concerns.

  • @surinderbedi8916
    @surinderbedi8916 4 года назад +26

    Swami also rejected Jaitley as finance minister as per Jaitley
    Is not fit for post and knowledge
    About finance.

    • @8_adityasinghrawat319
      @8_adityasinghrawat319 4 года назад +4

      Wasnt he right?? In mr jaitley tenure gdp was worst

    • @pappubhai3097
      @pappubhai3097 4 года назад +1

      Jaitly was a burden on our country. ...

    • @xyzpictures9008
      @xyzpictures9008 4 года назад

      @@8_adityasinghrawat319 lol I don't think so,in 2016 and 2017 gdp growth was 8 %.

    • @xyzpictures9008
      @xyzpictures9008 4 года назад

      @@skandas2281ya 2018 was 6-7% (that's not so bad)but from 2019 Nirmala is finance minister.

    • @xyzpictures9008
      @xyzpictures9008 4 года назад

      @@skandas2281 well don't u think GST was necessary? Demonitisation drive u could say somewhat failure ,most of black money is stored as real estate and gold. It impacted only low black money holders. Tax raids were increased
      www.google.com/amp/s/m.hindustantimes.com/v/s/m.hindustantimes.com/india-news/demonetisation-effect-more-black-money-unearthed-as-tax-raids-increase/story-MG8dM08jGtVb7bKdYYu3mJ_amp.html%3famp_js_v=0.1&usqp=mq331AQFKAGwASA%253D#ampf=
      Yes,nothing much. However it does not impacted the GDP as due to "Iran -american crisis"in 2019 we were supposed to show recovery instead we stopped buying cheap oil from Iran and suffered a huge blow and "american-china trade war" added to the cause and 2020 now covid. Sitaraman journey through this 1.5 years had been so rough.we atleast needed a experienced person .Yes, Swamiji could hold the post from 2021 onwards.

  • @surajpanigrahi6540
    @surajpanigrahi6540 4 года назад +8

    7:30 Swamy predicted the stock market crash in March 2020. He said two months from now, there will be a crash and indeed it was.
    We need Swamy as the finance minister.

    • @shauryatuli2241
      @shauryatuli2241 4 года назад

      It was because of COVID, and it recovered

    • @xyzpictures9008
      @xyzpictures9008 4 года назад

      @Aishwarya Janakiraman just wait for this financial year to end ,then he could succeed nirmala as finance minister.

    •  3 года назад

      Agree Shrya Tulia. Cannot trust anyone who after all the evidence says shushant committed suicide and baby penguin is innocent. Obviously he can be bought

  • @geralt1733
    @geralt1733 4 года назад +127

    Why aren't there any comments?

    • @geralt1733
      @geralt1733 4 года назад

      @Adolf Hitler nando kore-wa!!

    • @mohanvvip
      @mohanvvip 4 года назад +3

      Most unpleasant person. It's good that the little respect I had for this man is gone. I can now confidently say that there is no one in BJP that I like.

    • @yevodee4024
      @yevodee4024 4 года назад +7

      +@@mohanvvip
      Why do you find Dr. Subramanian Swamy to be a 'most unpleasant person'? Could it be because he calls a spade a spade, regardless of who is wielding the spade??

    • @mohanvvip
      @mohanvvip 4 года назад +1

      @@yevodee4024 Let me not get into an argument with his supporters. I know very little about politics and the history of Mr Swamy. He can be very nasty when he talks about others. He could have been equally nasty when he talks to his own side and point out their failings - which he does not. This particular interview is typical. So, I formed my opinion. Your mileage may vary, so let's agree to disagree.

    • @excuseme1911
      @excuseme1911 4 года назад +1

      @@mohanvvip lol ...he started the video by criticising Modi

  • @victorkadnar3331
    @victorkadnar3331 3 года назад

    May not be good at economics, but as a prime minister the strength and foresight as well as courage that he has demonstrated , India has not seen in any other leaders since 1947. Mr. Swami has his own opinion, we have to respect that. Nobody is perfect in everything, we all have weaknesses, but we have to appreciate the strengths as well.

  • @mohammedabdulkhader977
    @mohammedabdulkhader977 3 года назад

    Dr subramanyam Swami is very honest person in our entire india and his suggestions are the best. Hope our government will follow him to improve our economy.

  • @kaushalk3754
    @kaushalk3754 4 года назад +21

    LEGEND..... ಸ್ವಾಮಿ ಜಿ... 👌😀

  • @aditya-fx9fp
    @aditya-fx9fp 4 года назад +6

    I wish we treat Kashmir as a land with people on it, rather than a mere border extension.
    Sure it is a part of India, but so are its people.

    • @faizaan2804
      @faizaan2804 4 года назад +1

      Good to hear there are still people ĺike you out there who can call a spade a spade.

    • @aditya-fx9fp
      @aditya-fx9fp 4 года назад

      @@faizaan2804 Sure there are, so many who are allergic to bullshit. We need to be more vocal though, than those with comments like one above yours

    • @faizaan2804
      @faizaan2804 4 года назад

      @@aditya-fx9fp I fully agree with you.

    • @faizaan2804
      @faizaan2804 4 года назад

      @MooHamMAD Atankvadi faceless moron,the language you have used clearly shows your bigotry, culture and upbringing.

  • @VikashSharmaji
    @VikashSharmaji 4 года назад +9

    after Atal ji, the only other politician that I adore and respect. Subhramaniam Swami. :)

  • @rowansadasivan403
    @rowansadasivan403 2 года назад

    It is very engaging to see Dr Swamy speak. The man is an intellectual rational and upon close consideration his ideas are revolutionary for India in terms of economic growth.

  • @nildev7264
    @nildev7264 4 года назад

    Sir Prabhu Chawla was an alumnus of the Delhi School of Economics! The kind of a journalist we need...

  • @Sschasgkndhbsbshehdh.
    @Sschasgkndhbsbshehdh. 3 года назад +7

    I love this man for his honesty... no matter in which party he is in he just he just speak his heart

  • @nikhilgupta-yq7bj
    @nikhilgupta-yq7bj 4 года назад +25

    Anchor is like childhood friend.

  • @SuperMayankdogra
    @SuperMayankdogra 4 года назад +36

    Rare case when the interviewer talks more than the guest.

  • @niharikakusuma8223
    @niharikakusuma8223 4 года назад +2

    Dear respected swami ji I salute your knowledge and confidence sir.👏👏🙏

  • @jay19chandra77
    @jay19chandra77 11 месяцев назад +1

    Why should PM Modi know economics, isn’t that why he has FM and council of economists serving under him? What he is good at is an excellent administrator who knows how orchestrate a good team of ministers and policy specialists and decide what is best for the country!

  • @faizhashmi4112
    @faizhashmi4112 4 года назад +6

    I wish if I could be his student.🙏

  • @Farooqueakhan
    @Farooqueakhan 4 года назад +10

    The only person in India, who understands economics according to Mr Swamy, is himself. Something is wrong with him or with the rest of them.

    • @user-wh5nj8uz5v
      @user-wh5nj8uz5v 4 года назад

      🙄

    • @adip8
      @adip8 4 года назад

      He's from ISI and Harvard. He's has a rigorous mathematical education. He's not some engineer who hasn't seen any math outside approximations and calculations. He knows economics.

  • @shahrukhshaik2471
    @shahrukhshaik2471 4 года назад +3

    Imagine Subramanian swamy as prime minister. Damn it would be great place to live.

  • @onthego22
    @onthego22 2 года назад

    Why don’t Modi government makes him Chief Economic officer of Indian government. His subject matter and understanding of it is crystal clear.

  • @srinivasyanamandra9019
    @srinivasyanamandra9019 2 года назад

    PM was as a small child part of his father Tea shop. BASIC economics was learned by him at that time. He was over a period of time a good learner and practised as a CM of Gujarat. GREAT economists failed during COVID, but luckily indian economy is doing well.
    THIS can be a proff of PMs knowledge. MOST EXPERIENCED governor of good governance.

  • @nishant_4213
    @nishant_4213 4 года назад +90

    This man is amazing

    • @HeartistMurali
      @HeartistMurali 4 года назад

      Amazing in his idiocy

    • @joyjoy442
      @joyjoy442 4 года назад +3

      @@HeartistMurali Shut up you idiot. He was a lone warrior against Indira Gandhi when she was destroying Indian democracy. Maybe you are a blind Congress supporter but he won all the cases in courts on his own. Respect even your enemies.

  • @AWhistleblower
    @AWhistleblower 4 года назад +23

    *swamy should be deserve as a PM. Twitter need to start stance*

    •  3 года назад

      No. Modi ji is our best PM

    • @fury1435
      @fury1435 3 года назад +1

      @ He isn’t the best Atal is the best Pm of India.

  • @MdKhan-jf8mc
    @MdKhan-jf8mc 4 года назад +4

    Swami Jee
    You want swadeshi in India, what is brand of your watch, mobile and orther goods that you use.

  • @sonalbais5952
    @sonalbais5952 4 года назад +1

    Dr Swamy should be the finance minister of India.. really he is so intelligent..

  • @naturalkosal6233
    @naturalkosal6233 3 года назад

    Only person of the party who has guts to say truth