Dr. Subramanian Swamy on the current state of Indian economy, CAA, constitution and much more
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 фев 2020
- In 1970, Subramanian Swamy presented a plan: a demand that socialism be sacrificed for a competitive market economic system, so India can grow at 10 per cent per year, achieve self-reliance, full employment and produce nuclear weaponry. Then Prime Minister Indira Gandhi denounced this plan as dangerous.
Now, fifty years later, Swamy redefines his path-breaking ideas on India-specific economic development in his seminal work, Reset.
We host a highly topical conversation with the ex-Commerce Minister and MP in talks with Shoma Chaudhury for an evening centered around India & the future of the economy.
Respect for the security guy !! He stood still for 2 damn hrs !! Hit like for this guy !!
Exactly and nobody commented about him!! 😑
He only *_sits_* in bathroom.
@@manavprotimburagohain4257 He squats
Its colonial mind set...don't know why they are not asking him to sit...
Hit like for you.
this man should live for another 40 years love this man
Just 40?
@@manteshsharma3863 hahaha... You made me laugh, Mantesh. Anyways, seriously speaking, after 115 years (75+40), anyone might get dementia or alzheimer. Hence they can not be independent, also, they wont be able to enlighten others. In other words, they would not enjoy their life. Bottomline: I believe 40 is good. Please watch the Julianne Moore movie about Alzheimer. She is brilliant! Also, I have tried to be mentally more active ever since, because I would like to avoid getting these 2 diseases, lol.
Another 100 years:)
@@malladipradyumna1650 at least
@@mohanapandianraju1120 who told you he's 75? He's 80.
"Every Hindu is a RSS man then." Killing it since 1939, Swamy Ji.
Couldn't understand Swamy wasting time with an idiot.
She said one thing right" i sounds like spokesperson of the opposition "
she's damn right 😂
She is ......just watch other interview candidate
Sure she is.. Interviewer against Modi
Brother, as soon as we vote for the party we believe in, we should become the opposition to question it. Not to be a fan of the party.
She did not give her stance on CAA..whenever she was cornered she said running out of time..let's not get into it....look at her impatience when Swamy had kick-ass answers for her questions...poor lady..you should have finished that wine before you start. Dr. Swamy is always a delight to hear.
So true ! What a waste of time... journalism having a beating!
atleast with that handicap, the debate looked equally matched
Exactly
Educated but religious bigot
@@mdjaffer3286 Not a bigot like Musalmans
We would never have another politician so truthful and blunt like Swamy
Ya 1 dollar 40 rupee statement ...then 72 rupees now
@@asifiqbal5397 yaa ram mandir and p chiddabaram statement and now... National herald
@@asifiqbal5397 only scatterbrain will comment like that...Swamy said that if structural reforms as suggested by him are made then this will be the outcome...So read first and then comment..
@@asifiqbal5397 Owaisi brother.
The only person who is capable of debating Swamy is Mr owasi.and I think they are good friends..
Anchor: Congress is not in the Power
Swami: Thank God
Me: 😂😂😂😂😂
@@anshumansingh8358 but he also backs Modi ji
@@anshumansingh8358 swami coz he backs BJP but every one is sure that Muslim appeasing party should not come ..⛳⛳⛳let we move towards in retaining our Bharat golry...
@@anshumansingh8358 q
"I only spank when necessary." This guy is savage af.
*Mr. Swammy beautifully destroyed her propaganda,*
*Loved it.*
Puneet Singh she has busted him off piece by piece!! For his double standards
@@nupurchoudhary1183 really? She couldnt come up with a single argument based on facts.
Abhijit Bhagwat all were facts which is questioned over.. Mr Swamy kept dodging over them trying to sound amusing.. and straying away from topics she was asking him..
@@nupurchoudhary1183 I have compiled the facts from most of the people's comment for your easy reference:
1. Every time Dr. Swamy counters her with facts on a topic of HER choosing, she says - let's not go there... or I don't want to talk too much about that... etc etc. Don't ask a question if you can't take the answer!!
2. This lady Runs out of time starting from 20". Steering away every time she gets to get exposed.
3. Whenever Mr. Swamy tried to explain she ran out of time...lol
4. Whenever she gets hard hit back, she use to say we r running out of time...
5. She is confused. She laid down rules so many times.
6. Talking to such a Great person you should have some eticates...he is so humble....compare to this annoying lady...
@@ShashwatVikram haha well put, was gonna add a few points of my own but I'm afraid we are out of time
22:24
Swami ji: Relative or absolute ?
Lady : on a scale of 10
😂😂😂😂😂
and she did nt understand the technicallity of it..ahahhhah
Is she dumbo not even read stats in school also
Relative and scaled to 10.
R K 🤣🤣
The clarity of thought that he has is impeccable. All interviewers try to trap him instead of understanding his views but he always comes up
The host is a living example of HOPELESSNESS
Yes. I am fully agree with you
Not the first time .It is perineal.DNA can't be changed
she is just anti-bjp/Modi, all her questions are like begging this guy to say something against BJP or if he has already said than to hear it aloud in front of audience
Shashikant Shukla she cans be very successful if she adopts oldest profession in the world
@@Subudhdh Mr. Swamy is way bigger than BJP when it comes to debate or 'exchange of knowledge'
Dr. Swamy is so polite in his answers. On the other side, a very impatient lady!
Because she has an immutable agenda whatever the answer!
Arrogant and ignorant
I agree with you
Very true!
She's a swine, mulla sympathiser. Presstitutes!!
Legend has it that she's still saying "We're running out of time"
she is de kind of girls who doesnt like forplays
😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂🙃😂😂
She is so biased that when every time Swai Ji gives her a good lesson, she jumps onto another topic. She is so full of propaganda, hate, and breaking India force....You can fee it.
This lady is using her journalistic platform to push an agenda rather than interview a Member of Parliament. Though she desperately tried to push her agenda, Dr. Swami handled it with ease. The intellectual advantage Dr. Swami brings to the interview is even more exaggerated when next to someone far less blessed.
Very true... I have seen her two interviews with Swamy she did the same thing...
Anchor: (Irrational question)
Swamy: (Answers it)
(After 10 rounds of question and answers, swamy destroys all her arguments)
Anchor :(with a burnt ass) Hehe! let's leave this sir ,we are running of time.
Marvelous Swamy...
Dear Mr Prime Minister Modiji, please hear the voice of a brilliant politician and an exceptional economist... please put him on the portfolio of a finance minister. Let him set at right the economy of our country in a stable position.
Well he does hear him, but he's too bold and 'naughty' to be in cabinet
What is difference between economists and astrologers
2 year down the line and we now know Nirmala is way visionsary than anyone ,
He is intelligent but he has to be played properly
"Speaking English Flawlessly doesn't make you an Intellectual".
😡
LMAO exactly! Unfortunately we Indians have such great respect for fluency in English! How Chidambaram reached centre directly ? By Bloody English!
True. I hope one day we are extremely proud of our own culture and these leftists are absolutely cleaned from our India.
Agreed 100 percent
@@VarunSharma-cf7ir leftist is also so the right dosen't go mad
I love Swamy. He has his own independent thought. He doesn't bend to one party or the other. That's how all politicians in a parliamentary democracy should be. None of this two party bullshit like the US.
I hope he lives for many more years.
I have never seen such a decent conversation in recent times and so modest moderator....
And to me Mr.swammy is a great politician, human being ...He always has my respect...I always hold him high....
Hats of to the Guard standing behind Mr.Swamy ... He is standing still looking after everyone without even moving his legs. Wow !!! Very great .
34:22 Are you Congress? - No. - But everybody perceives you as Congress. LOL such a simple illustration of Godse/RSS situation. Hats off to your quick wit Swamiji!!
My heart goes out to the person standing in the back for close to two hours or more!!! 👏👏
LOL.. Only Indians will think of it.. America will not even care.. That is why I love my country..
I respect your surname ✌🏻
That's d job.
Dr. Subramanyam was very articulate in the responses, to the questions which were clearly put forward to get a headline out of, the journalist herself brings Congress slyly into the discussion, and when Dr. Subramanyan begins to bash them, she takes the high ground and says let the bygones be bygones. 😆
All in all a good interview as there were pressing questions asked, and answered.
The only little things that annoyed were constant disruptions and urge to steer the answers to comply them with the biases of the journalist.
Still the Dr was a true gentleman about it and the way he handles them truly brings out the art of conversation.
Great work guys, throughly informative.🤘👍
Excellent talk by Dr. Swamy. Logic, intelligence, information. This lady journalist has been scoring self goals through the entire session.
You can start from 05:00
You can save your 5 min...Atleast
CA Aspirant you are a legend
You comment was so down, that it took me more than 5 min.
This one should be pinned.
@@RaviKant-uk5ok I'm sorry for that
Sahi kaha aapne
I'm glad Hindus are asserting themselves. Its better for India.
Yes, I am glad she did it. This type of injustice has to be seen by all humans to unite behind Hinduism
In fact stronger Hindus will always mean stronger secularism....Hindus will always be secular🙂
@rajendra bareto
Dear apologist,
Ever suggested this to muslims ? What was their reaction ?
@@garavsg8154 👌
Brahmins always keep Hindus as slaves incapable of asserting their viewpoint. Brahmins would never let Hindus rule India because they consider it their birthright to rule over other Hindus.
It is so much a pleasure to listen to a Harvard jewel💎.
His smile burns the opponents🖤
Two Words For This Lady by me:-
"Idiot" and "Irritating"🙏🙏🙏🙏
Dr.Swamy Again Nailed it 😇😇😇
As usual expected from leftist...
She’s absolutely annoying . I suspect her backing .
FireBuzz Hub ...Candidly shoed..her on the face. Well commented..sorry
that itself is a complement for this communist sycophant..
As usual Dr. Swamy nailed it.
I want this man to even take my years and live another 80 years
I hope it happens 😂😂😂
Yeah.. he's fire 🔥.
If somebody asked me to argue with Dr. Swamy, I would have left the country ASAP!
😂
Subramanian Swamy is correct regarding Raghuram Rajan and his policy.
chacha tumhe economics ka kuch abc bhi pata hai ?
@@Parmindersingh-rk8cd Swami don't no nothing about economic . He say print money and bild road. And he say increase fd interest rate and lower loan rate. Now tell me how is that possible.
@@Parmindersingh-rk8cd I can tell that Rajan's policy was a disaster in terms of inflation. And yes, I used to teach Economics to people and i'm an MBA in Finance.
So, you are questioning it as if you know ABC in Economics, lmao
@@Parmindersingh-rk8cd lol Bhuri Kaaki ko Pata Tha...isiliye MM unki sunta Tha na ? 😆 🤣 😂
@@devengrover2787 bhai jo tm likhe ho wo to pura galat hai wo harvard university se phd hai aur IIS kolkata se statistics m padhai kiye hai
Swami- ''I only spank when necessary'' this man is witty..hell witty.
Gives a punch on the face of liberandos.
Big fan.
Salute to the man who has been standing behind Dr. Swami all through the interview :)
He is so straightforward and says without mincing his words.We want such type of people in every institution of the country!This type of attitude comes from honesty from the core👏👏
Let’s set the parameters of the conversation..lol. Swamy is brilliant. He has facts loaded..
Shoma Chaudhary : “ BJP is inciting hatred and is communal “.
Dr. Swamy : “ Please give me an example
Of where we have incited violence”
SC: “ Sir we neither have the time nor space to discuss this please stay on topic”
Sc = Sonia corporation
If 1984 genocides of Sikhs by hindus and 2002 Gujrat riots against Muslims are not instances of the hindu rashtar extremist and terrorists outfits rss and snatan Sanstha led violence then you could trust brahmin made mythologies as gospel truths. King Ashok rejected hinduism due to its inherent violence.
@@madnr9150 totally agree with you👍
Gurinder Singh khalistan is nearly extinct
@@gurindersingh8109 mr gujrat riots was started by muslim Hindus in retaliation did that. 1984 happened as Indra Gandhi was murdered you should listen what rajeev Gandhi has said it was done by him(congress)not some Hindu leaders
Mr swamy is the man. May he live another 100 years. I wish he becomes the PM someday. Jai shri ram 🙏
Dr Swami
"I will educate the Supreme Court" - Subramanian Swamy.
She’s neither listening to him nor letting him speak
Yes exactly
She's not listening to him but he's speaking perfectly as usual
She wants to dominate! Sir please do not address her questions!
She is presented herself as congress rep.
.
@@ushaiyer6686 Well said. She has already made up her already closed mind!
Cause she is not getting the answer which shuits her agenda instead of it she is getting what is truth.😁
Swami ji ki jai ho🤟🚩🚩😎
Never take a person seriously if they wear their glasses on the top of their head instead of over their eyes😂😂😂
Apt
I am amazed to see the efforts of this journalist who is continuously trying to put her words and her sense of understanding in the mouth of Mr. Swamy, she is so irritated and agitated that rather than playing the role as an anchor she is playing the role of an investigator. Amazed to see an old man like Swamy bring so calm and composed during all these talks , even on some questions I had to pause the video to calm myself ......
I wish we have capable journalists to interview a genius like Swamy.
NRC in Assam was conducted on the instructions and under the supervision of the supreme court. You cannot blame the BJP government for this.
This lady is true congress loyal. Her loyalty is making her not stand with her comment then She chooses to be selective
tell me one stance maam where she was a congress loyalist.
was it when she said emergency was bad?
If she is a true Congress loyal so what, Congress are not part of India, it's not political party as for Constitution
She must be one in the pay roll of the cong party
@@MegaOrkay there is most people in BJP.
So at least she is Congress.
No one cares if she supports INC, BJB, JDU, AIMIM or regional parties for that matter. But she shouldn't impose the person against her in the conversation with Pseudo intellectual / Liberal and half known thoughts. She should be open to listen to a different ideology and not expect every answer her way. Her agenda was bleeding through her questions which was clearly not to interview Dr. Swamy about the solutions, but to disrespect Modi and Amit Shah. She was pathetic.
Full respect for you Sir. I admire the knowledge of the topics and presenting things with no fear👏👏
_Mr. Arnab Goswami doesn't deserve any civil rights.. If I had my way.…_
_-Subramanian Swami_
Your clarity, composed, honest, sharp, brave and truthful responses to every question is a testimony to this bharat culture. Pranam for educating us on the richness of this land. I am proud of being born in this tradition. And more proud of having an intellect like you to voice this tradition to this world.
She has a bloody 100 times that she will run out of time.... She never wanted the truth.... She just wanted favourable answers....
Agreed !👌
Yeah. This is the longest video put up by Quorum and throughout the 2 hours this twisted woman we are running out of time. She wanted to do a hit and run conversation.
Prakash P very true. though swami screwed her well by shortest answer possible👍🏻
Her agenda was purely anti modi...
B MAHESH CHANDER All these hypocrites Comrades are on the “Pay rolls” of
so called reformist. Claear...pertinent...agenda is anti Modi...& thus Anti Nationals
the democracy is misused by these biased leftist sycophants. They can’t even pass
Urine at their Will..in China ..Russia.& other Gulf countries but in India ..secular
etc. etc. is only for destruction of the Country. When there is no check & balance
in media even God cannot Help. Media professionals first be a INDIAN..honest
and then all your agenda.
Most Awesome interview, I have seen in some time. Even from his criticism, he teaches something.
The lady herself is wasting so much of time and continuously says to Mr Swamy don't waste time. She wants Swamy to speak what she likes, which he will not do.
She has taught me a trick of her trade . When one is losing ground ,use the trick of " we don't have enough time " !
Ha ! Ha ! Ha !
What a journalist !
If at all she is !
She has a 2 hrs slot still she keeps on repeating ," we don't hv time" blah blah lol
😜 😜
she is the most stupid who is whining like a crybaby whenever she is told she is wrong
Anchor trying hard to trap Dr. Sahab but she miserable failing every time...
वो अपना काम कर रही है. ये अंधभक्तों वाली conspiracy theory फैलाना बंद करो. 35 रूपया डॉलर होना था, आज 70 पार है. ये सवाल वो पूछ रही है. जवाबदेही तो बनती है.
@@bobinpune I admitted what you saying but Their are more many points where I felt unfair anchor.
That's what anchor is there for.. Staying neutral
Swami ji... you are visionary, candid person and you replies are sport on. Anchor is biased with no home work, using all her english she know to skirt away unpleasant facts.
true 😆
one big thumbs up for the gentleman standing all this time...
Dr Subramanian Swamy is very very smart n we need him fir another 50 years to be followed by the likes of him forever ..
Jai Hindustan JAI SHRI KRISHNA
My feet are hurting from watching that security guy standing there without moving for an hour & a half! 😣
Exactly ,even I feel very sad about himm😥😥😥
whenever she is in trouble she be like "we don't have enough time"
hahahaha true
😂👍
daru b pee rhi h khulle me🤣😭
Dr. Swamy Sir. You are genius and we certainly need more honest and daring leaders like you. Feel sorry for the lady wen she has nothing to defend or justify but only make sound with half baked information!!! More power to Swamy sir. May you live long and healthy. I am sure this would be the prayers of millions of fans like me.
I admire the intelligence of Dr Swamy. I am also a fan of Dr Swamy. If Dr Swamy can get rid of his self ego and co operate with Mr. Modi it will help future generations In short I request Dr Swamy to follow the path of the great Dhayananda Saraswathy. I believe Dr. Swamy
"We are not Sufficiently HINDU"
THANK YOU SIR
Tum 2000 saal ki ghulami k baad bhi sabak nahi seek paye....fir ghulam banne ko tyar khade ho.....
Whenever she gets hard hit back, she use to say we r running out of time...
This man is a national treasure
Such national treasure that his own party ignores him. They are least bothered with what he says.
i admit staring at his bodyguard for a little longer than the man himself. big ups. swamy ji’s prudence is immaculate, my heart don’t get over the fact that our nation kind of don’t have men like him anymore. pity.
Everytime Congress or Gandhi family is brought up:
"Sir, let's not waste time..."
Dr Swamy is and was always brilliant in front of Urban Naxals
HE'S A LEGEND...!!
HE MADE HER CRY
Aum Adharneeya Dr Subramanny Swamyjee each words have plenty of meaningful thoughts really appreciate that voice of Universal study Subject
He is 80 years old for gods sake. he is more intelligent than anyone in this country.
Most intelligent person I've ever known
True ...
not 80 but 70+
except leftwing hindus and all mullas, everybody is intelligent
Sai deepak
A dull interviewer trying to trap a legend and each time fails miserably.
And the visible desperation.. perhaps she had a bet before commencing this interview 🤭
Its become fashionable to speak against the bjp.
Insignificant people in order get their 5 minutes of fame just say something negative.
Example kunal kamra
@@siddharthasaha133 BBQ. .....m.
Great sir, finally you r talking truth, some how, finally you agreed Vikas tho gaya, vishvas present situation me hai aur sab ka sath b bahut jald.. Thank you
I will educate supreme Court .
This guy is real life south Indian hero.
I feel sorry for the security guy. Had to stand for so much long. Lost in his own world.
Mrinal KD
I noticed the same thing bro. I’ve done the security guard shifts. Not easy to stand at one place for long period of time.
It’s Z+ security which is necessary because he has death threats from LTTE.
@@Vishal- there are still a lot of LTTE sympathisers here in Tamil Nadu.
He is not lost anywhere, he is noticing everything.
@@Vishal- r u tamil ?
Shoma you cant ask a question, and then say let's not waste time
Shoma is such a congressie that she cannot hear even one comment favouring BJP but she wants to applaud Swami on brashing Modiji and BJP
She is with communist and slipper cell of left+China+socialist,
She is very idiopathic.
This lady is a Hindu baiter fit to be parcelled to Pakistan
Stupid argumentative lady
No match for Swamy
Just a pygmy in front of him
What you think the question should be "Aap thakthe kyun nahi hain?", "Aapke paas purse hai?".
whenever Swami exposes congress then she say let's not waste time lol
He's my favorite man now ❤ such an inspiration ❤💯
Yesterday i saw two interviews of him with Shoma ...now third one...Finish this ppl ,Swami ji...
This girl doesn't know enough about our Constitution.
aunty
Aunty*😁
She got a little educated that day
Because of the anchors like this we still support Modi and BJP even though they're failing in economy
We will always support MODI and BJP !! Only party that not works for minority appeasement.
@Arid I second that.
They are not failing in economy.
We are 3 Trillion economy now.
Yes...She is definitely smart and knows her job... right...? To stand against Swamy, single handed for two long hours is fighting an army of a thousand men but she has honestly rattled him at times here. Good... Hats off to Ms.Shoma Chaudhury. Keep it up.
I love the knowledge and confidence of Dr.Swamy
This lady is a bad listener she is just thinking about the next question in her head.
@Astha Singh actually all the Leftist's & Communists have this type of problem
i.e ( Sardesai , Thapar ,Nidhi Razdan many more....)
This lady has a name and she is Shoma choudhary
Nah she is just a urbal naxalite and pro Congress and she is just pushing her propaganda
Not only tht she speaks more thn the guest speaker..... i dnt understand why even they invite people if not interested in listening.
@@abhyudaysinghparmar6055 she pushing her propaganda but not like baktas (like you) fake propaganda
This guy should be the PM..
Not sure of PM but Finance Minister for sure
I'm the biggest Swami Sir's fan
I hope I get a chance to meet him
I want to touch the feet of such a learned Man.
Rather than being a blind believer .. this is a man who has got facts and logic ....no matter how brutal the questions are...he is prepared for anything..and especially when he roasts the person in the end who seemed to have posed an intelligent question
people like him can only take on the forces which threatens our culture and identity...
Whenever Mr. Swamy tried to explain she ran out of time...lol
The most honest and intelligent person I have ever listened to.❤
What I enjoy about this man is that he is very honest. He doesn't overly and blindly protect his own. He speaks the truth, whether it is for or against the party and policy. He seems to take criticism well and seems very bright. He is one who lives and dies by logic.
This was a nice informative interview. Will order his book now
swamy slapped again and again, whenever she tried to corner him using the leftist tactics. poor thing she is left sad faced :)
Absolutely
Poor security person. He had to stand in one place for two hours.
Lol
@@techsmith939 : THATS NOT SOMETHING FUNNY . :-/
Yes, its not funny
thanks, for your concern but that is our duty. you don't have to feel pity but feel pride that we are unshakeable from our grounds
@@jagdishtechs we are proud of you 👍👍
This lady.. she's has right to think whoseover she is but ma'am do check once whom you're sitting in front of. Huge respect for Dr Swamy. Love this great man ♥️
I came here to listen the Subramanian Swamy Ji🙏.but after listening this lady ,will surely miss what Swamy Ji said in this conversation
Swami is legend--"that jnu character" lol
Swami is absolutely outstanding man with great interllect. He exposes everyone even if they are their party members, and rightly said the truth.
A very good debate and good sincere answers given by Dr Swami. I would like to meet him and discuss issues of India prosperity and FdI.
Fantastic interview. Left me with not taking any sides but thinking of the situation as a whole.
I wish more of the media shows such interviews. I also wish more of the top leaders sit for such interviews. Country first!
Jamaat-E-Librandu will never like MODI but that's not a problem actually that is the one thing which will make MODI PM once again in 2024.😅
Economy will make.disaster
Bhakts will become bhikari,
Still they'll say...
Modi ji ne accha kiya
Modi ji ne accha kiya
@@trick_er aur Librandu try karte karte thak jayenge phir bhi PAPPU ko PM nahi bana payenge 😅😂🖕✋🖕
@@asifiqbal5397 TRUE...that is the only option for Opposition to rise if present GOVT will not fix it as quick as possible.the 🙏
@@asifiqbal5397
Already in disaster
1:36:34. Superb answer 👌 by swamy. There is a process anchor jii. Please don't be panic democracy is superb in India.🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Brilliant interview. God Bless him. Jai Hind. Jai Bheem....
You can love him or hate him... but you can't ignore him...... Dr. Swamy befits this quintessential proverb....... He speaks his mind, without mincing words, there is always truth to what he says & India needs people like him... So, ladies & gentlemen, fasten your seat belts.... to take on Mr. Swamy... I foresee him to be our next P. M....