Это видео недоступно.
Сожалеем об этом.
Tough PLA Throwdown!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 26 янв 2022
- You may have heard claims of "Tough" or "Impact Resistant" PLA. In this video we put those claims to the test using our patented, "super-scientific", Smasherizer Ball Drop-Omatic! Watch plastic chips fly in slow motion as we figure out which PLA is truly the toughest.
ECOstruder@HartSmartProducts.com
www.HartSmartProducts.com
Follow ECOstruder on Social Media:
/
/ hartsmartprod
/ ecostruder
Filaments Used In This Video:
- Push Plastic Standard PLA: bit.ly/3475EeP
- 3D Printlife Pro PLA: bit.ly/3geIS76
- 3D Printlife PLAyPHAb: bit.ly/3s7CMLy
- 3D Printlife OMNI: bit.ly/3ujLitt
- 3D Fuel Pro PLA: bit.ly/35tgz2G
- 3D Fuel Glass Filled: bit.ly/3AP6uZr
- VO3D High Impact PLA: vo3d.us/
Hey, this was so much fun to watch. You gathered some good data and it is very clear there are PLA's that are much tougher than others. Thanks for all the print time and setup this took to do!
Thank you! This was a fun one to do. We'll definitely have to do more of this type of thing going forward. Are there any particular materials you'd like to see tested with our high tech ball dropper? I've already got a few in mind. ;-)
3D-Fuel is my jam!
Great video! Looking forward to more content.
Thanks Adam!
Tbh, this test followed the scientific method very well. Control, using the same ball for each drop, using the same design for each test that was basically a hollow mesh. If you put an impact force meter under the test samples, this test would have provided very solid data!
I appreciate that, and adding a force meter under the test samples is a great idea. I'll have to look into one of those. If they don't cost too much then I may have to add that to the test setup in the future. I definitely want to do more of this type of toughness testing.
@@ecostruder I'm subscribed to see that happen! 😁 I'd be super interested to know if different colors behave differently, specifically Snow White vs natural. I've noticed that most white filaments leave more layer artifacts than other colors, and my hypothesis is that titanium dioxide pigment changes the thermal properties of the filament just enough to make it melt unevenly, and I think that would change the strength measurably.
Gotta love that 3D-Fuel Pro PLA toughness!
I can only imagine how tough it would be if I had annealed it! In fact, that gets me thinking...
@@ecostruder yes! Do it!
Do you have anything that lists the print temps for these? Looking for a good PLA + with 230-235 print range so we can alternate between PETG and PLA + with less worry about hotend jamming
Print temps are going to vary based on the base resin used, as well as printing speed, nozzle size, resolution, and several other factors. The 3D Fuel Pro PLA we used in this video has one of the highest printing temperatures of any PLA, due to the Natureworks Ingeo 3D870 resin used to make it. The printing range on that material is listed as 210-240C by the manufacturer. So that might be a good option based on the range you mentioned. And it obviously performs very well also!
@@ecostruder awesome! Thanks for that information! We have a print farm with over 300,000 hours but it’s frustrating having machines sectioned off for PLA, ASA or PETG.. this will let us use a Material that is less glossy than PETG and easier to print than ASA. I just wish There was a material like PETG (heat resistance , easy print) with less gloss 😂
@@oneheadlight8000 Very nice! I'm not sure if there is a "matte PETG" option besides the types with Carbon Fiber or similar materials added into it. But it may be worth a google search to confirm. Otherwise I think you'll be quite happy with the 3D Fuel Pro PLA!
@@ecostruder yeah I am going to give it a test.. 3DXTECH used to have a matte PETG but whatever additive they were using pushed the print temp up to 270-285 for good layer adhesion.. they discontinued it.
What a about annealing the samples?
Get out of my head! LOL, yes that's exactly what we're planning for a future video. These types of videos take a long time to prepare for so it may be a while before we get it done, but the intention is to test the results of annealing various materials, including some that were shown in this video. I think annealing is a poorly understood process that we'd love to shed more light on. Thanks for the suggestion!
@@ecostruder I came across the video while looking for Vo3D reviews. I know they talk about annealing it.
I appreciate your use of PPE
#safetythird!
now do flexibles to see how high you can bounce!
Haha, 3D printed trampolines!