ICC Announces It Has Jurisdiction Over Palestinian Territories | The Mehdi Hasan Show
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 фев 2021
- Prof. Noura Erekat and Rabbi Abraham Cooper join Mehdi Hasan to debate whether the ICC should be able to investigate and prosecute Israel for its actions in the West Bank and Gaza, and whether the court is holding Israel to a different standard than other nations.
The Mehdi Hasan Show: Insightful reporting and probing interviews that examine the day's events and provide a deeper level of context for the politics of our interconnected society. Watch The Mehdi Hasan Show on The Choice channel on Peacock TV, weeknights, 7 p.m. ET. Subscribe to the channel for more interviews.
peacocktv.com
The Rabbi refused to use the name *Palestine,* dismissively calling it "the other side" and no one took offense. Yet when the professor refers to the Rabbi as "the guest," the Rabbi seizes on it, feigns offense, talks over her, and steals the last word from her. Hypocritical much? Entitled much? _False, opportunistic, self-indulgent and pompous_ much?
What do you expect from a people who has stolen everything they have and twist anything to their liking. Lets talk about the Atlantic Slave Trade Holocaust.....for a change.
You're damn straight!
@Ian Lev i guess when "you" people stop playing the victim always.
@Ian Lev time will tell. I got to get to work. You enjoy your day and peace be with you.
It's crazy how this argument is still so complicated these days. There was a time when it was like "ehh.... IDK bro".
It then eventually progressed to sort of a "hold up what is happening to these Palestinians, they are getting jacked up by the enemy *and* their own people"
Then over time it was like "ok whatever but maybe Israel should stop those illegal settlements right?"
.... "Hey can you guys stop that tho."......
"OK yea America+Israel BFF true true but hey what's up with those settlements tho y'all are like dropkicking families out of houses"
How come now we're sort of at the advanced stages of "I mean yea that's cool but you're still over there with the illegal settling."
100 points to whoever can guess what the next stage will be
"Building for peace" means supporting each other's big arms deals and overlooking each other's human rights abuses
They should change their name to International Criminal Court for African and Third World Countries.
Bush son n father with Donald Trump are war criminal n the ICC could not do a darn thing bout it. Not to mention Henry Kissinger one of the biggest criminal the world has to face
The world can't be called civilised until everyone is equal before the law.
Absolutely.
but what law?
Israel and America believe they ARE the law, therefore above it and not subject to it. The Truth will be a grievous reckoning for both empires.
@@neilburnside398 Not yet but the time will come, for both!
@@L98fiero the time will come for all of us
If one wants to hold China to account, and Myanmar too, then one has to hold Israel to account, too!
and Saudi Arabia, and of course, the U S A has plenty of war crimes to answer for
Gunk Wretch he who has the biggest guns gets to call the shots.
As an Israeli, I am completely fine with ICC investigating Israel for "war crimes" as long as they'd do the same to China which they rejected saying China isn't a signatory of ICC. Well, guess what? Neither is Israel.
@@Elivinu Palestine isn't also a sovereign state the ICC only applies physical states.
@@francishallare204 It doesn't matter whether you recognize Palestine as a sovereign state. It only matters whether the ICC and it's signatories consider Palestine a sovereign state...which they do.
Why does asking the question make it anti-Semitism.
@Ian Lev Again, calling ppl names and spewing hatred and false facts
@Ian Lev Why does it have more resolutions against Israel? It's because it has been the most consistent violator of International law. U can take up the challenge of comparing any of those countries against Israel. We can start from 48
@Ian Lev Have u directed ur question to the Jordan consulate?
@Ian Lev Talking about Israel isn't a discussion about Jews. Stay focused please.
@Ian Lev There was a Palestinian state. All the class A mandate territories were countries and considered states.
"We know too well that our freedom is incomplete without the freedom of the Palestinians."
Nelson Mandela
Free Palestine now!
palestine is free,
South Africa under black rule = government crime, ANC crime, street crime. Black freedom.
@@user-cq8ih4hj1u “free” really?! Since when? How? It’s news to me and and everyone who cares about human rights!
@@MrArchlight450 great. so fight the terror organization that highjacked the civilians in Gaza, and use them as human shields
@@user-cq8ih4hj1u Hamas are a piece of human trash 🗑 so is the Zionist regime. Hamas is abhorrent for targeting civilians but so is the raid by the Israeli police on the Aqsa Mosque in Jerusalem which lefts hundreds dead. Both use children as decoys. The Israeli government needs to stop pretending to be Oprah and give makeshift lands to Israeli citizens. To reiterate Hamas needs to stop sending missiles and Israel needs to stop stealing lands.
This woman has put the frame work of truth around the unfair subjugation of Palestinians by the Israeli nation state.
They, Israel, complain that they are attached by anti Israeli and antisemitism but never look at how are Palestinians mistreated by Israel.
The seeking of accountability is not antisemitism. No country should be above another in the eyes of justice!
The Israelis have the capacity to eliminate the Palestinians entirely, but don't want to. The Palestinians want to eliminate the Israelis entirely, but can't.
@@jonlenihan4798 I would disagree with your assessment of the situation.
I would argue that the Israeli leadership of today would like you to believe that the Palestinians are at fault for everything so they can continue to take advantage of their very vulnerable situation.
The Palestinians have been mistreated for a generation and more. There are good people on both sides. They are just never in power to do the right thing when it's needed.
For a people who like to bring up how they have been persecuted, they seem to have a blind eye to there own persecuting.
@@anonimuse6553 If the last sentence refers to Arab nationalist racists or Islamists, I agree.
If the Palestinian situation is so bad, they ought to surrender and end the war.
Who is really has the RIGHT of the Palestinian land ?
Palestinian answer ... MUST WATCH!
ruclips.net/video/5iUgYldi9OI/видео.html
@@jonlenihan4798 I've recently come to find that Israel is committing an ongoing genocide in the name of nonsensical scripture that only a fool will take seriously.
By recently I mean over 30 years ago and I'm 44.
I must be "antisemitic" if I dare point out the obvious!
This is rare and I hope it will not be the last open discussion with points of view on Israel's domestic policies and what Palestinians are advocating today. I just wonder if Israel ever get weary of pulling out "anti-semitisim" accusations whenever Israeli policies or Jewish prejudices are legitimately criticized?
Gaddafi was a hit job and Libya had the highest human development index rating on the African continent before the NATO-sponsored coup abetted by the ICC.
Preach!🤗
This is true.
@@neilburnside398 That is n9 where true or close to accurate, Make that US-led/influenced NATO enforcing a UN resolution. There was a savage civil war going on and US wanted revenge on Gadaffi for Pan-Am bomb.
True...you teach these bastards!
Libya under Gaddafi was the most prosperous nation on the African continent for example university education was free and if a course was not available in Libya, Gaddafi's government would pay for that student to study abroad. Also when newlyweds married the government would give the couple a equal to $46,000. It was that witch Hillary Clinton that was responsible for the destruction of Libya.
He basically said you can't be critical of the Israeli government.
Talking about jurisdiction why you think Israel is not a signature to the nuclear organization they don't want there nuclear facility inspected.
This is the sort of topic where Mehdi Hassan really excels! He knows his shit, has courage, and guides the debate towards truth.
Mehdi Hasan can hardly be regarded as unbiased ,the clue is in his name.
@@davidfrench6521 Ha! Your bigoted reaction toward his name says nothing about his bias and everything about yours!
@@heidihogshire Hogshire, I think you will find that Hasan has track record of distorting the truth when it comes to the Israel and Palestine debate. I'm sorry if I have hit a nerve but that's the truth.
@@davidfrench6521 What clue you're talking about, I don't see any.
@@davidfrench6521 Wow... Talk about racism and Islamophobia... What does his name have to do with anything?
Mr. Hasan has my favorite shows on tv/internet.
@RedEyeOf Jupiter this comment shows you know less than nothing about Allah's Law (Shari'ah) according to the Qur'an.
You should read it. You can finish the whole thing in less than 30 days. Then come back and share with the class what you've learned.
@RedEyeOf Jupiter are you okay? It appears that you need a doctor.
Mind Begs the Question:
Racial Apartheid State - Wrong
Religious Apartheid State - not Wrong?
Religious apartheid comes from Allah and is therefore holy, righteous.
What is hilarious is netanyahu has prolly zero semitic blood, let's get a DNA test , my guess a mix of southern and eastern european
His from Brooklyn in New York and so are all his settlers,they are all so ugly...eeeuw.
@@mogamadgreyson143 Here I disagree, I grew up in a majority Jewish area , I love the people , the culture etc. I have many Jewish friends , my family is not Christien Jewish or Muslim, i get turned off by all the Abrahamic religions equally , but the people claiming to be Israeli are not ethnically semitic and have zero claim to the land
If they never committed war crimes, what is bibi worried about.
@Ian Lev Maybe so, they are the only ones whom can assassinate you without any repercussions. When you own both political parties in the U.S., you can do no wrong. People just want to see fairness around the world...not one sided rules because you want to be thought of as Holy, but you people are far from that. Everything has its time!
@Ian Lev Israel is the definition of terror. They have used phosphorus and have bombed civilians.
@Ian Lev not all do, and to say that is very ignorant but you knew that when you wrote it. Maybe Israel should compromise and have a two state party since Palestinians was on that land and living there before Israel became a state and even was one of the only ppl not only to welcome Jews but also live with them peacefully. Hence why Jews admit to being safer under Muslim rule then by their OWN people. Talk about things that make you say hmmm 🤔
@Ian Lev is killing kids right? Do you support the bombing of occupied territories. Do you support the murder of innocent people. And dont turn this around. We can bring real life stats to show you how one side is fighting with a knife, and the other has a tank.
@Ian Lev perhaps the great israel should open up the blockade
I voted and totally support President Biden but I was hoping he would take a harder stance with Israel about their treatment of the Palestinians , it’s just wrong and it needs to recognized and it’s not being anti Semitic to say so. All it has done is create terrorism, there has to be a better solution. The Palestinian people are entitled to liberty and justice just like everyone else.
Good luck with that
He has barely been in the position for 3 weeks right now. Normal people don't ASS-U-ME anything and they definitely KNOW that it takes time to transition into a new administration. 3 weeks into a 4 year term and he hasn't done what YOU expect him to do. Why don't you get off of your computer and ACTUALLY do something about that issue instead of just complaining on social media which doesn't accomplish ANYTHING.
But...again biden hasn't even been in office 3 full weeks yet. Geez. This hot mess left by the previous administration plus a pandemic which was ignored by the last president would normally be all someone needed to know to not be making these kind of assumptions and actively upsetting their own selves over non existent slights they perceive they have which don't actually exist in reality.
Israel will not be held to account by the USA for the racist actions of her government. Israel is the whitest nation in its neighborhood, and 50% of the US population is deeply racist. I think Biden knows this, as did Obama, and so they know the best they can do is try not to make the situation worse. If Biden tries to step in and actually prevent the genocide in Palestine, it will doom our own country, because the GOP will use that to take over the House and Senate, and then they will impeach and remove Biden and Harris.
if you think america has any plans of arguing with israel you really dont know the whole history and situation. it doesnt matter who the president is
@@MattMajcan well actually I do know the history and your probably right but I still think the Palestinians need help and are treated badly and would like to see some solution. Aside from Biblical beliefs which I’m not going to argue if it’s right or wrong they are still an invaded and misplaced people. I have nothing against the Jewish people but I don’t like their government.
Proverbs 14:31 he who oppresses the poor shows contempt for their maker, but whoever is kind to the needy honors God.
Maybe they could read their own religious books and start treating Palestinians more fairly.
On point, hey!!!
Maybe Americans could to.
Proverbs 15:32 he who fire rockets at her neighbours with intent to kill women and children shows contempt for their maker. but he who retaliates to prevent such actions is kind to the needy honours God.
Those in power wrote that book to control the ruled, and are not, nor were they ever, meant to be constrained by it. Hypocrisy isn’t an issue for these people. As the Rabbi said, “This is a game.” Take him at his word.
@@benniecrawford6876How do we define “Americans?” As a U.S. citizen, by birth and residence, I have a hard time with this question. My experiences here have taught me that power begets power, history is written by those who can afford the pen, and truth is dependent upon whatever resources an individual commits towards the search for it. This was never the standard public school curriculum; we were taught to hope, trust in the basic good will of others, and with hard work anything was possible. Many took this to heart, and now this ‘truth’ has been shattered by the realities of life. We are not just “Americans,” we are human beings that must share and compete with others globally. No longer can we rely on the myth of American exceptionalism. As a country, we cannot hoard the world’s resources to divvy up amongst ourselves. We now are competing with our neighbors, for much less relative to our parents’ standards of living, and yet, we bombard ourselves with images of that which we can never attain. To be an “American,” is really just a term of citizenship; our culture has been torn apart by the same people the masses have been struggling against around the world, those who control the resources, who are always developing new ways to divide us so that we squabble amongst ourselves for any scraps without any sense of the long-term security necessary to realize our true enemy. “Americans” are not the enemy, even if some of the enemies happen to be American.
(Please forgive me for going on about this. I am ashamed of so many actions my government has taken and I have no control over anything beyond my own behavior. I am sorry.)
Expose the truth Noura and put in their face! We all love you!
The way Mehdi trapped this Rabby in Covid and ICC word salad was epic
That clip of Netinyahu's speech, was pure sophist rhetoric, conflating the word "Against", with the word, "Of". That was the core of the logic, and is nonsense. But, people will hear it emotionally, be convinced, and call it a great speech.
He also uses the country of Israel, to represent the Jewish faith, which again is a fallacy as a country cannot also be a religion ; at most, it can be the spritual home of a religion, otherwise, by extension, evrywhere a Jewish person lives would also be Israel. Which we know not to be true.
It was for this kind of rational arguement, that Jeremy Corbyn was smeared as an anti-Semite by the Conservative and Labour parties of the UK , striving to unseat him as leader of the Labour party.
His crime (s) : being a man of principal who sought a fairer society, that had a place, and support for everyone. Or in other words : derail the political gravy train.
Yeah, Jeremy Corbin was relentlessly targeted with false accusations of anti-Semitism. Even after he proved otherwise, he was relentlessly slandered with false accusations that he was _tolerant_ of anti-Semitism (which was _also_ BS; he just understood - from personal experience - that not every accusation is true, so he made a point of investigating accusations before expelling members).
Corbyn was the best thing Britain had, but Israel's defamatory deflection-reflex has poisoned the world's weakest minds, and a lot of those weak minds reside in Britain.
Yes.. the Law they wrote... to suit them... that's why the injustice... people are questioning that unfair standards
Netanyahu said the quiet part out loud in that clip you played when he tied "anti-semitism" to "the one jewish state", which has always been the Israeli perspective; the one state solution. Israel is applying Orwellianism to expel any notion of a two state solution.
Also, a side note, if Israel succeeds you can also say goodbye to Ukraine. 🤷♂️
Many countries will be affected by letting the bully win
They getaway with daylight murder.with an arrogance like no other.they should be shown there not untouchable.firsty jail netenyahu.
wow. I have never seen a Rabbi just fully embrace evil like that guy just did. That was sad to see.
Rabbi=clergyMAN.
What's so exceptional about him?
Don't beat yourself up about it.
There are a lot of so-called Zionist Rabbi's that preach evil and violence. That's the Zionist way. The Jews and the Zionist are 2 different things. That's why Jews in the United States and other places never stand with Israel. Only the Zionist that have taken over our government stands with Israel, and the Zionist in other countries stand with Israel. The true Jews don't stand with them. The true Jews know how dangerous they are.
Palestinians and Uighurs deserve Justice as do the Kurdish people and the POC's here in America.
i saw Kurdish people holding the Zionist state flag in Iraq, i saw Kurds helping the Iranian Army, during Iraq Iran war, talking about Iraqi Kurd's, so give me a fucking break.
lol im sorry but including poc in america in that group is kinda hilarious, those other groups are literally being genocided while poc in america are becoming presidents, scientists, doctors, lawyers, artists, etc and have a higher standard of living than most of the world
Please cite your independently-reliable sources, "@@takismail".
Also..
*Wasn't the “Irāq-Irān war” actually triggered by the Irāqi invasion of newly-reconstituted Irān?*
@@maazkalim where do you get your Info. no Iraq did not start, Iran started sending agents to start what they call Islamic revelation in Iraq, that was the reason for the war.
You should cite your own info, before going _Tu Quoque_ like a "mEMe" image of some random enemy-politico, "@@takismail".
Since this is the first-strike, you've max 2 more chances to start obeying with the Laws of Scientific-Reasoning, for the sake of genuine-engagement with myself.
"For God so loved Jacob's awesome wrestling moves, he made criticizing Israel illegal"
Amen
That's ridiculous, yet hard to believe, I understand what you're saying
Muslims never have anything good to say about Israel, or about anyone else.
In other words, the ICC only punishes poor , weak countries but it turns a blind eye to the crimes of powerful nations.
Frightened to are threatened
Mehdi
I like you. We want see you on Aljazeera English.
Are you waking-up just now?
Since..
If not: What you're asking him is to leave his plum-job here and go back at his job at arguably the most-controversial news organisation, and ‘anti-Shiite’ is just mere one of those controversies.
Go Noura!!!!!!!!!
It's as useful to distinguish the Israel people from a particular Israeli government, as it is to distinguish anti-semitism from anti-zionism. These conflations are not helping us get to the real issues?
It's actually the same thing as conflating opposition to any or even all of 200+ Sharia[h]t with Islāmophobia, actually.
@@maazkalim Fully agree.
Good job mehdi
The rabbi could have answered every question with,aaa,The Simpsons did it , its a funnier way of not being serious.
Rabbi been eating too many pies
Someone should educate Israel and the leaders the story about "the boy who cried wolf" they have to stop using the antisemitism card other wise they will face real antisemitism and be ignored
the guys with the biggest guns make the rules
fascinating
Why is it that when they don't have an actual defense they resort what-aboutism as the Rabbi did during this segment.
Because they have no defence for the undefendable
If the ICC doesn't issue arrest of warrant to Israel's leaders, i would argue all nations to withdraw from the ICC
yeah good luck with that lmao
Rabbi cooper reminds me of bill barr
I’m a big fan of Noura but I can’t help but think of how incredibly rude and unprofessional it is of her to be going on her phone during these interviews as others are speaking. It’s such a bad look Noura.
Anyways, free Palestine🇵🇸
I’ve watched a couple of interviews today on Palestine and Israel.
I’m always getting the same results from the Israeli side and it’s classic what aboutism! Kinda puts me straight off their side of debate.
Yeah. Zionists are their own worst enemies. Their racial biology, lebensraum and supremacy cult is straight out of the German 1930s playbook.
They're the perfect ones , we are all animals in their eyes
@@stream2watch How can you say that after 6 million Jews were murdered by the Nazis ? Which by the way led to the UN allocating a territory for the Jews where they can defend themselves. Have you been hurt by Jews that you hate them so much ?
@@frshir That has no bearing on anything I said. Fact of the matter is that Israel is built on ethnic superiority and concepts of Lebensraum and special chosen status by imaginary deities. You could not argue against that and win. I also deride your strawman. I have no hate for the Jewish people. My record collection and my literature collection are proof of that.
@@stream2watch The chosen status thing is BS, I agree. But in fact, the idea of a Jewish state is a direct consequence of Europe's actions against the Jewish minority. After so many men, women and children were murdered (which BTW their number have not recovered to this day!) they only wanted territory for them so they will be able to defend themselves.
Why is it that if one criticizes Israel, the modern nation-state with Jewish, Muslim and Christian citizens, they are called anti Semitic? The fact that the majority of Israelis are nominally Jewish doesn’t give them a Get Out of Jail Card in this game of life.
LOL Rabbi reading a book called the Next Jihad.... was in the background when they zoomed in in the beginning
Wow, a real representation of Palestinian voices ON TV?
Is that allowed?
Assuming you're referring to the US and by most extent, 'Euro Christian'-descending NATO-FVEY television, then..:
Conditionally, it's a regular thing.
it started at 9.11 and never stopped since.
Salute to Noora
The ICC has made no derogatory comments about the Jewish people or about the Jewish religion so therefore it is not anti-semitic. Netanyanu thinks criticism of the actions of his government should be regarded as anti-semitic which shows how desperate he is and how the ICC are on the right track
When you put an israeli or a defendant of israel in the corner they will say but hammas fires rockets toward us, well you committed massacres against the palestinians and they are defending them selves.
and have you seen those rockets? they're the size of a pencil. In Canada, we call them bottle rockets and we shoot them off on the beach. They're about as dangerous as a firecracker.
@@rosestewart1606 Exactly, they also forgets that they are the most armed nation in the world and they have nuclear arsenal.
Talk about being armed to the ass!! With a click if the button they can point their missiles to any Arab Muslim country to show their superiority but by Allah my brother, there's no power and might except with Allah!!
Hot topic
Well done 👍
If anyone looks at the 1948 map of how the land was supposed to have been shared between the Palestinians and the Jews, a child can see, plain as day, there has been a constant encroachment of Palestinian land. It's the Jewish version of Lebensraum.
When ICC has no jurisdiction in Israel, someone just has to do it outside international law.
Salaam Mehdi Hassan⚽️. Currently Dubai ruler his daughter needs protection from his behavior abuses!
Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashid al-Maktoum, the emirate’...... Dubai war leader behavior need look deeper...
Mehdi talked to her...
Palestinians done have a air force, it like goliath vs David. It like when we blame the victim, police have the weapons but we say he didnt put his hand up that bs.
That's exactly what it has become, the children throwing stones against the giants oppressors, very ironic!! Insha'Allah the David throwing stones one day will defeat Goliath.
You take my water, burn my olive trees, destroy my house, take my job, steal my land, imprison my father, kill my mother, bombard my country, starve us all, humiliate us all, but I am to blame: I shot a rocket back. "
U demolish my temples
U convert people on sword
U put extra tax of me
U torture people for not agreeing
U wall children alive
U look women to convert them to concubines
U daily harass me by 5 times prayer
U do not respect any other faith but expect your own to be respected
But still u complain people hate u
@@shriharikulkarni2305 lol nobody has done any of that to you go back to sleep
When that court don't work . . .
set up one that does work!
Those with power and might make the rules. They also modify them in their favor.
It's horrible what happened during WWII. I only wonder why more compassion for other peoples isn't available for Palestinians.
11:00 so whomever critiques Israel is an anti Semitic...
You seem to have understood the crux of the relentless defamatory deflection... I suspect that might earn you a certain familiar disingenuous accusation.
That's pretty much the IHRA definition!
This is essentially as per definition, which will one day be legal definition in a lot more 'free' countries. They already told you they have a covenant with God and are doing what is necessary to ensure their survival in world which wants to go Hitler on them at every perceivable corner. By criticizing what they are doing in order to preserve their culture and livelihood you are being inherently anti-Jewish. If the majority of practicing Israeli Jews decide they want to start nibbling on baby johnsons for some reason you best believe you're destroying their ability to survive by trying to badmouth that. This is how I know that when I'm outside banging on drums and blaring air horns at 3 in the morning because it's part of my survival strategy, the people who call the police on me are a bunch of goddamn racists for trying to stop me from what I need to do to stay alive.
@Frank Peeters Yes, the term "anti-semitic" implies a comment was directed against Semitic speaking people in general which includes Arabs and Jews. It's not coined "anti-semitic" when people are specifically taking jabs at Palestinians though. Guess why that is.
Are you being rhetorical, Mr "@Frank Peeters"?
Israel always has the upper hand and the US will support Israel right or wrong. This is fact
Presidents, like war criminals, come and go. That is also a fact that will not change.
Yikes... why couldn't they bring someone on the same intellectual level as Noura? She is a lawyer. He is not. Who the hell cares what his opinion is lol
Who is noura?
Sorry , i got it. Ignore my early message
I totally agree, he's only there to spin the anti-Semitism rebooters which the right minded people are becoming sick if and are awakening to the real music happening in Palestine!!
@@neilcastro836 Israel is a flailing state. Their propaganda no longer works.
Just hope this ends in justice
It will. Not how everyone might imagine, but Justice is coming.
Kinda amazing in this day and age to see two reasonable people politely arguing and sticking to the points. We used to see this more often, but now, post-Trump, it's tough to find two humans who agree to a governing set of facts (e.g., Hillary Clinton doesn't eat babies) who're willing to appear on a panel and present opposing good-faith arguments... Bravo.
ICC has the same jurisdiction as the mafia😂
Quite simply BDS.
Accountability is not “demonization.”
Thank you.
I’m surprised the Israeli didn’t use the word Holocaust in this interview. Must be the only one ever
Genesis 9:16...Wherever the Rainbow appears in the clouds I will see it and remember the everlasting Covenant between God and all living creatures of every kind on earth....I am Rain...I am what God told me I am.
Hebrews 6:19..I am Anchor....For I am of my father, by my father, His Princess Messenger of God...
This old man is a slippery Sam 🙄 😒 😕 😪 😩
I follow only Mehdi for fearless and neutral reporting. Thanks Mehdi.
All I saw in this interview was the next jihad book by rabbi... Lol
To criticize Israel at all is technically anti-Semitic.
How so. To discriminate Jews is anti semetisn not being anti Israel.
@@KhalidAli-jc7cv Maybe a little hyperbole, but if one in the US does criticize the state of Israel, the label of anti-Sematism will applied to that individual in short order.
Netanyahu's logic:
"We were oppressed, you can't criticize us"
🙄
It is your interpretation driven by hate
Un knowledge them back, and don’t give them curtesy to name them by their name ... as seen here he can’t handle the taste of his own medicine 🇵🇸❤️🕊
Noura is a Gem. The Rabbi us a deceptor!!
Damn Ishrahell.
Religious persons representing a state and telling lies - mhm -
most world leaders are people of faith. not sure what your point is.
@@JonPais the point is that it is the worst hypocrisy.
Chasing Professional War Criminals is difficult.
African nations should just leave ICC for good, because it doesn't bring them any good or justice.
This discussion would be taboo in the US mainstream up till a few years ago, the fact that it is even being discussed is a feat in itself. Mehi had to be extremely deferential to the Rabi unlike he would be on AJ because NBC, this may still cause him to lose this gig.
For one, we should all agree to start using the term anti-jewish because anti-Semitic in this context is inaccurate and it plays into a false narrative that the ashkenazi are related to the Semitic peoples of the region.
They do have some some Levantine DNA, but it's on the Y chromosome, which means it's from patrilineal inheritance. This is despite the fact their own Talmudic law requires that one have matrilineal inheritance in order to be legitimately Jewish.
Im a little confused, aren't semitic people the original culture living in the levant and mesopotamia, arabian peninsula? So would any people living in the near east be considered a semite? Why would Jewish use the phrase antisemite ?
Palestinians people have the right to defend themselves and their ancestral lands against the occupation of Israel and supporting parties.
I've criticized America's foreign policies, prison system, systemic racism & election super PACs for more than a decade. Does that make me anti-American or un-American?
According to Trump and his minions = damn straight it does! According to sane people = of course not, it just makes you a critical thinker
To be for freedom, justice, and equality is to be pro-humanity. Equating that with being anti-American means America is anti-humanity. If that's the case then yes, I'm anti-American.
As someone who has seen, *"Gaza Killings: Who is to blame? | Head to Head,"* this was frustrating to watch.
I understand that this isn't the same format, that your time is limited, and that you're acting as a moderator, but still... FRUSTRATING.
So..
When are you making-up on your mind to cough up premium-subscription for ALJAZEERA®, now that you know that "public choice theory" is sheer bunkum and the corporate-press could never possibly compete with the pubcasters - to say the least?
@Mehdi - I usually dislike your videos because of your bias stands... but on this video, i must admit, you did a great job on moderating the conversation... & didn't appear to swing to one side & wanting to squeeze in your opinion 100xx times :) Respect !
the rabbi is a little disingenuous,one would look ,you would think , to rabbis for a little integrity
Good job with topic selection and she was brilliant
3yrs ago....where is the ICC & The ICJ....What about the Genocide happening now in Gaza & West Bank.
Noura speaks the truth in politics of Palestine & Israel!! Free Free Palestine!!! Freedom Justice and Peace for Palestine ❤❤❤
She is correct..
omg this rabbi shouldn't be discussing politics nor should he be given title "rabbi"
Mind Begs the Question:
If a person - Worships only his Creator
If another person - Worships only his Creator
Both Worshipping - different,same?
THANK YOU SO MUCH MEHDI STAY BLESS
Somebody has to defend the Palestinians!! If you commit war crimes you have to be held accountable!! No exceptions!!!
Hasan is theee best in the media industry
Given the holocaust shouldn't Israel hold themselves to a higher standard? When other nations, with a history of occupation, such as the republic of Ireland, call out Israel shouldn't they loo at themselves in the mirror
Talk talk tack,nothing is evever done about the ocuppation!
Israel is not the problem: the rest of humanity has got it all wrong.
Discuss everything else is but just know that Israel is off limits
@Imam Chungus because they are guilty Ofcourse
Very ironic isn't it... They're right and the whole world is wrong except those who super them blindly in their crimes!!
Norma Harris 1day ago GOD IS IN CONTROL OF THIS WAR NOT THE ISRAELITES THEY R HIS PEOPLE. THEY R FIGHTING THE GOOD FIGHT GOD IS WITH THEM. HALLELUJAH!!!!!❤❤❤❤❤