docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLScqjJqT0Zaiiq2r9dprQD6U0K59RLOLQfqq0gh-TBKax1vQAw/viewform?usp=sharing Join Current Affairs Plus Course by Sumit Rewri Sir www.pw.live/study/batches/current-affairs-plus-by-sumit-sir-708041/batch-overview?activeSection=Description To Practice Daily MCQs & Daily Mains Answer Writing - Click Here - physicswallah.onelink.me/ZAZB/qws9lxfg
Ye ek complex ethical dilemma hai, jo development aur tribal rights ke beech samadhan dhoondhne ki maang karta hai. Infrastructure project se economic growth aur thousands logon ko faayda hoga, lekin tribal families ko unki ancestral land se displace karna unki cultural aur spiritual identity ke liye ek bada khatra hai. Sabse pehle, stakeholders ke saath dialogue sueu krunga, jisme tribal communities, NGOs aur local leaders shamil ho. Is samvaad ke zariye unki needs aur concerns ko achhe se samjunga. Compensation aur rehabilitation ke liye ek transparent aur effective plan banaunga, jisme unke rehne ke liye alternative land aur livelihood provide kiya jaye. Dusra, Cultural preservation par focus karunga. Tribal land ka ek hissa unki cultural aur spiritual practices ke liye preserve kiya ja sakta hai. Iske saath hi, unki traditions aur values ko document aur promote karne ke steps uthaye ja sakte hain. Lastly, agar possible ho, to project ka design is tarah modify karunga ki displacement minimize ho. Sustainable development ka matlab wahi hai jo development aur social justice ke beech samanta banaye. Is approach se me ek balanced aur ethical decision le sakta hai.
Approach badiya hai, isme- NGT ko shamil for pre approval, creation of roop way ( like Africa constructed in their National park for ECOLOGY DIVERSITY AND DEVELOPMENT) and Employment guarantee , and no land should allocate for any personal use . Thank you 😊
Or bro local tribe k liye infrastructure project mai reservation ka bhe parvhdhaan karna hoga taki rojgar ki problem bhe solve ho ske . For example hamre gaam ki lend mai polytechnic college mai local ki seat reserve ki hai
Ethical Issues 1) Region Development vs Tribals Interests 2) Ends vs Means Debate 3) Displacement of tribals & will effect livelihood of them 4) Duty vs Dereliction of duty 5) Social Wellbeing & justice Course of Action 1) Firstly, I will try to persuade tribals in line with Discourse ethics 2) I will follow Inclusive approach by considering the interests of all sections & Gram Sabha 3) If Tribals are not agree with me, then I will report the matter to my superior 4) Overall I will ensure that Interests of tribals should not be undermined in line with social ethics in long term while focusing on development
Ethical dilema As a DM.....mai first of all tribal community ke mukhiya se personally jakar baat karungi and project ke bare bataungi, project ke kya benifit iske bare me bhi bataungi jisse ki mai tribals ko convince kar saku and finally convince hone ke baad mai unke rahne ke liye ek accha si jagah alot karungi jisse unhe shift hone me koi bhi problem ka samana na karna pade, unhe shift hone ke liye time bhi dungi jisse unhe rehabilitate karne me kisi bhi parkar ki dikkat na ho.....
@@sushmarajpootsushmarajpoot354 Answer ko aur behtar banane ke liye community engagement ko badhawa dena zaruri hai, jisme sirf mukhiya hi nahi, poori tribal community ke sabhi stakeholders ki baat suni jaye. Cultural preservation ke liye unke rituals aur traditions ke liye ek specific land reserve kiya ja sakta hai. Displacement minimize karne ke liye project ka alternate design explore karna chahiye. Compensation ke alawa, unke rehne, rozgaar aur social security ke liye long-term rehabilitation plan banana bhi zaruri hai.
Ethics dialema As a DM , step-1----tribal sarpanch se milker unhe project ke benefit bataungi and tribal people ko convience karne ko bolungi step-2------trible village ko land ke badle me harjana double dena and unki livlihood insure karaungi step-3-----project developement se tribal ka n sirf economic condition better hoga balki society me equality bhi aygi or unhe unka culture protection ka aswasan diya jayga
गुजरात में जब स्टैचू ऑफ यूनिटी बनाया गया तब भी यही प्रॉब्लम सामने आई थी कि ट्राइबल लोगों की संस्कृति भी बनी रहे और रोजगार भी मिले। आज वहां के लोकल लोगों में सबसे ज्यादा लड़कियां EV रिक्शा से रोजगार पा रही है। क्योंकि गवर्नमेंट ओर ऑफिसर्स ने अपना मास्टर प्लान सही से लोगों के सामने रखा। उस वजह से इन्फ्रास्ट्रक्चर भी विकसित हुआ और प्रवासन भी, बदले में लोगों को अपने culture identity की हैंडलूम चीस बेच के रोजगार प्राप्त हुआ ओर कुछ चीजों में सरकार के प्रयास से इनर conflict खतम हुए।
Dilemmas associated are- Infra Development vs ecological balance Economic benefits vs tribals right Modernization(uniform culture) vs tribal culture (Diversity) As a DM first of all I will try to identify whether is there any other places then the tribal habitate for the project, if there is scope for any such site near to the proposed place I will send it as a proposal to respective authority, and will talk to them at a personal level to convince the respective department for shifting of the project to another site. If there is no scope for such changes then I will talk to the tribal community along with all other stakeholders associated, and will try to convince and ensure for their proper and right rehabilitation, income source, preserve their tribal culture, their sustainable livelihood coexistence with nature.
As a DM 1st communicate with tribals and gram sabha, understand their issue and their demands.And also discuss infrastructure benefits that available for them. 2nd communicate with stakeholders about tribals demand, when infrastructure project in tribal area important but it's more important tribal concern 3rd -if possible change project design that helps tribal To stay in their land.or provide secure area with livestock facility, economic support to tribals. And try to full fill their demands. Thank you sir 🙏
Dielma- sir mai as DM sabse pahle un tribals ke leader se milungi aur unhe samjhne ka prayas karungi ki ,is infrastructure development se sabhi ko profit hoga aur sabko employment bhi milega mai unhe is baat ka yakeen bhi dilaungi ki aap sabko compensation aur sari facilities dilaungi jo aap sabko milni chahiye . Eske baad ek awareness campain ke through logo ko aware krne ki koshish karungi jisse log meri baat samjh ske . Aur agar wo samjh gye to easily gram panchayat se approval mil jayega aur infrastructure project stablish ho sakega. Thank you so much 😊 amezing discussion sir 😊😊
Sumit sir pahle to thank you aapke itni achhi tarah se kisi v topic ko samjhane or batane ke liye.... Par aaj mai bahut upset hu...kal jo kuchh Patna me hua...usko dhyan me rakhte huye aaj ke aap ke is ethical question ka answer mere anusar yahi ho sakta hai ke.... Kabhi v kisi v office ke samne koi v ethical dilemma hota hi nahi hai ..koi v dilemma kewal us office ke personality or carecter ke karan uske samne aata hai...har office wahi karta h jo uske upar wala office ya neta bolte hai ....jiska jita jagta example kal ka Patna incident hai...pichhle kai dino me maine bahut achhi tarah dekha or samjha hai ye office or leader kisi bat ko apne interest me kaise ghumaya jata hai...😢😢
Yes you are Right ye sab ethics sab sirf ethics k paper me marks jada uthane k lie karte h aur phir ground me public k paise se aish karte h aur political parties k pich laggu ban jate h aur phir dande barsate h dusre aspirants pr wo v berahmi se.
Solution video dilemma As a DM- 1. Try to convince tribal people 2. Arrange proper rehabilitation for them with proper facilities 3. Ensure proper job for each family 4. Analyse project that environmental issues are addressed Thank you sir 😊😊
Dilemmas involved: Development vs Tribal concerns Tribal emotions vs materialistic well being of tribals Tribal rights vs developmental economics Stakeholders involved: #District Magistrate #Tribal people # Senior politicians/head Solutions: # Taking approval from gram sabha without much convincing tribal people Merit- Time saving approach Demerit- Ignoring tribal issues #Making tribal people understand for their benefits involved through this project in their style Merit- Giving time for betterment of tribal Demerit- Time consuming approach #Rejecting approval as tribal people concerns are important at some context and wait Merit- Giving priority to tribal individuals Demerit- Development delays progress of tribals #Providing source of livelihood or making such arrangement so that their migration would not result in their distress situation and approval would be easier to gain Merit- Tribal concerns involved and project approval made easier Demerit -Effort taking , requires extra funds for providing livelihood Decision making:- I would prefer last approach as it presents a balanced approach considering tribal issues.
1) To gain the confidence of tribal communities, it is crucial to assure them that their customs and beliefs will be protected and that development will be sustainable. 2) Minimize harm to the environment and the community's traditions. 3) The resettlement place should have all the basic amenities required for a decent life. 4) Sufficient compensation to be given.
Dilemma Culture, livelihood vs development Mujhe lagta hai people rhne ka place chhod sakta hai jab money ka achha amount mile iss se life style bhi Change ho jata hai Logo ko uss place par chhodne ke liye try karunga because devlopment aane se facility bhi badengi aur iss mahgai me log infrastructure development project ko chunna pasand karenge thank you sir
As Dm,My course of action- 1) Ethical impact Assesment, ensuring tribals right 2) Adopt land for land approach,providing land nearby 3)Engage with village panchyat and tribal community,hearning diverse concern 4)Demonstrate empthethical leadership,ensuring alternative livelihood 5)Gandhi's talisman approach,Facilitate Policy or Action alinging with poorer..
Only for my reference and record to track consistency: Tribals v. Development dilemma Political pressure v. Integrity Taxiway- Yellow Runway- White Goa incident Air India Airbus Dec 5 2024 runway confusion raises concern on the safety of Civil Aviation in India Questions basic training Historical pattern of runway Confusion, runway overrun and systematic issues. Issues in Civil Aviation safety: 1. Poor Training and safety Standards 2. Non Compliance with ICAO standards 3. Failed DGCA and AAI safety audits; role not clear, lack of accountability. 4. Flight crew pressures 5. Flight duty time limitation: causes fatigue. Focus on Operation rather than safety. 6. Inadequate infrastructure Safety and fatigue most imp and role of DGCA to ensure both. Blame game by DGCA 100 years of belgaum session Kohat (Pakistan) communal riots during second half of 1924 and committee of Gandhi and Shaukat Ali to investigate causes behind Kohat Riots Gandhi 21 day fast due to riots Sitaramayya wrote kohat broke the backbone of India Juhu Conversation : Negotiation for truce b/w Pro Changers or Swarajists and No Changers in Belgaum Session to unite pro changers to Congress. Dialogue held with Swarajists and Gandhi in May 1924 called Juhu Conversation but failed. Later pact between Gandhi and Motilal-Das in Ahmedabad finally established and this was ratified in Belgaum session presided by Gandhi and working secretary JLN. Significance of Belgaum Session Sahel Region Crisis and Implications on India Resources rich but poverty and instablility? Factors behind coup? Role of External factors?
14:21 Pravasi Bharatiya Divas (PBD) is celebrated on 9 January every year to mark the contribution of Overseas Indian community in the development of India. January 9 was chosen as the day to celebrate this occasion since it was on this day in 1915 that Mahatma Gandhi, the greatest Pravasi, returned to India from South Africa
As a district magistrate, growth and development along with welafare of the people is main concern. A middle path will be reached out after consulting all the stakeholders,and no biasness will be followed in this case.
Belief are the personal matter but national interest are parellel. Convience them by granting suitable land,Wages and money guarantee . And added their local issue with legal method.
9 जनवरी 1915 को गांधीजी अफ्रीका से भारत लोटे थे इसलिए भारतीय प्रवासी दिवस के रूप में सेलिब्रेट किया जाता है। इस दिन भारतीय प्रवासियों को भी आमंत्रित किया जाता है। Thank you sir 😊
Sir issue ko resolve karne ke liye phele hame village ke sabse older person se bat Karni hogi kauki oo village ke sabse old person honge aur village ke sare log unki bat nhi talenge fir isske bad sab ko yek sath bula kar unko surety our security dono provide karne ka promise karenge aur government se unke habitable ke liye suitable place recommend karenge .
Sir kya jis tarah se itni thand m bpsc aspirants ke uper water canon ka use Kiya gya, itni berahmi se mara gaya,ef female student ke dress ko phad diya gaya.... kahin se v ek beaurocrate ko shobha deta h. Hm ethics m padhte to itni achi baten h phir ground m ye officer aisa kaise kar dete h. kya IPS miss sweaty sehrawat aisa unethical pratice sikhi h upsc jaise exam se?
Rehabilitation of tribal people Proper livelihood and favourable conditions Culture preservation of tribals Effective management and engagement with all the stakeholders involved
It is a delimma between duty and faith , religion vs development. As a District magistrate i will make sure that the place should be used for infrastructure for hospital and school whuch meant to be developed .But if it would be some kind of business or an unnecessary plan tograb the place then. I will try to bargain with bith the parties . Gramsabha,tribals ,and the person wants to make infrastructure and labours are stakeholders . There should be a decision which is a good conduct , good for all . Conclusion - its necessary to develop a place but to make trust and development in positive manner is more important.
persuade tribals by explaining the benefits of development like education, hospitals, jobs etc for their children increase compensation amount and livelihood at another place persuading them with the help of village elders and religious persons that their forefathers will be happy to see their land bearing fruits of development for children
Solution to this delimma..... greaveance redress mechanism ...understanding tribal issues I detailed manner ...making proper guidelines.. implementation of tribal Dev.programme and tribal counselling for 2 to 3 weeks nd there are many other way of tribal persuasion
as a dm m 1. Gramsbhaa k saab baat kruga unka ganw m jakr and unki hr ek issu ko a6ha se address krena ki kossi kruga 2. Ek committe bnauga or esa lga phla k project ka serva krne ko khuga taki unko phla lge projet k baara m janne ka moka mila 3. Unko wqt diya jana chaiye
Sir Is project me sabse pahele me social and environment impact assessment karke uski report gav valo ko dekhaunga Us project ke banifits bhi unhe batavuga aur unke liye sarkar ne kya ayojan kiya he taha unko livelihood kese provide hoga ye sab bhi samjavuga Aur department ko unke liye aur emphaty se kam karne ke liye suggest karuga
In this dilemma, I will take into consider all this stakeholders, Melly, the travel people because they are more prone to the effect of this developmental project. for course of action, I would follow. I will assure them that this project would be a game changer for their future generation. I will try to a lot Best rehabilitation for the tribals. I will also try to make a museum of the culture so that their lease can be safeguard of their ancestor land. I will assure and promises given to them will be provided in the legal manner so that they will get confident.
sir as a dm me sabse pehle to vaha ke logo ko samjhane ka try karungi ki development kitna jaruri hai unke liye aage badhna jaruri hai aaise nbahut se tribal group ka example bataunghi ki pehle vo bhi aaise hi mna kar rahe the ynke purvajo ki dhareti hai isliye mna kar rahe the per baad me vo samajh gaye aaise examples dunghi aur unka jaha rehne ka niwas hoga vaha try karunghi ki unko aachi lifestyle mile atleast unki basic needs puri kar sake women ko bhi empower karunghi . mere jo seniour hai unse bat karke tribal logo ko help ho aasi scheme lane ke liye boliungi
पहले जनजाति की बात सुनेंगे अगर प्रोजेक्ट यही करेंगे तो पहले जनजातियों को नई जगह मुहैया करवाएंगे । और जो सरकारी लाभ है जैसे राशन पढ़ाई सब मुहैया करवा के उस लोग को नई जगह शिफ्ट करेंगे
Sir I will talking with tribals group and try to convince them by justifying all the advantages of project and I assured them that the tribals group also giving some other location for their living and spiritual exercises but when they are not convincing then I will talk to the project manager to modify the project location in some other nearest region.....
Men tribal community ko btaungi ki ke is project se unko bhi fayeda hoga or unhe usme job bhi dilwaungi taki unki rozi roti chal sake or unhe vishavas dilaungi ki unhe ek betar jagah par rehne ke liye jagah di jayegi jaha school or hospital jesi basic suvidhayen mil sake or unka poora dhiyan rakha jaye.
Ethical Dilemma Firstly I will talk to the tribal leaders about their problems in detail. Secondly I will assure them that the displacement will happen to the place where they sustain their lives. While this will also talk about benefits of the project that will take place. This will create an atmosphere where dialogue will prevail and both the project and tribal population will be satisfied
Pw onlyias customer service is pathetic i order my book 1 week ago on 23 December and in got Message that the books are undelivered call on the number but the delivery agent nor any customer service reply me and pick my call it is very irritating and worst service. I am an aspirant and my time is waste and no one care about it I call continuously to the pw helpline number n book store but no one reply only email but not my problem solved.
sir mai sabse phele waha ka jo mukiya mnta ha usko help lunga or unka baat mn jayenge ku ki unlog us par biswas krte h tab hi village k mukiya hoga fir wo convence krega ghao k
Tribals there main issue is rehabilitation and livelihood (I) I will write a letter to higher ups ....after negotiation with the tribals .....if they agreed to job offer in development project. And it would not be difficult to be approved as development project offer diverse job offer and later work under MGNREGA. (II) Tribals 2 nd demand rehabilitation.....they would be given Living place in district in some other nearby location. If higher ups approved. (Iii) Ayushman card for all to be made for health. (iii) Enrollment of children in nearby government run school....whose education quality to be ensured by myself personally. (Iv ) Utilize civil society like NGO to help them make SHG to get benefits of various government schemes. (V) Redressal mechanism to ensure better implementation of the demands of tribals .
docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLScqjJqT0Zaiiq2r9dprQD6U0K59RLOLQfqq0gh-TBKax1vQAw/viewform?usp=sharing
Join Current Affairs Plus Course by Sumit Rewri Sir
www.pw.live/study/batches/current-affairs-plus-by-sumit-sir-708041/batch-overview?activeSection=Description
To Practice Daily MCQs & Daily Mains Answer Writing - Click Here - physicswallah.onelink.me/ZAZB/qws9lxfg
Ye ek complex ethical dilemma hai, jo development aur tribal rights ke beech samadhan dhoondhne ki maang karta hai. Infrastructure project se economic growth aur thousands logon ko faayda hoga, lekin tribal families ko unki ancestral land se displace karna unki cultural aur spiritual identity ke liye ek bada khatra hai.
Sabse pehle, stakeholders ke saath dialogue sueu krunga, jisme tribal communities, NGOs aur local leaders shamil ho. Is samvaad ke zariye unki needs aur concerns ko achhe se samjunga. Compensation aur rehabilitation ke liye ek transparent aur effective plan banaunga, jisme unke rehne ke liye alternative land aur livelihood provide kiya jaye.
Dusra, Cultural preservation par focus karunga. Tribal land ka ek hissa unki cultural aur spiritual practices ke liye preserve kiya ja sakta hai. Iske saath hi, unki traditions aur values ko document aur promote karne ke steps uthaye ja sakte hain.
Lastly, agar possible ho, to project ka design is tarah modify karunga ki displacement minimize ho. Sustainable development ka matlab wahi hai jo development aur social justice ke beech samanta banaye. Is approach se me ek balanced aur ethical decision le sakta hai.
Approach badiya hai, isme- NGT ko shamil for pre approval, creation of roop way ( like Africa constructed in their National park for ECOLOGY DIVERSITY AND DEVELOPMENT) and Employment guarantee , and no land should allocate for any personal use . Thank you 😊
@@DhirendraKumar675👍
Or bro local tribe k liye infrastructure project mai reservation ka bhe parvhdhaan karna hoga taki rojgar ki problem bhe solve ho ske . For example hamre gaam ki lend mai polytechnic college mai local ki seat reserve ki hai
@@parveendahiya9065 good Idea ✍️
Sumit sir please raise the voice for removal of BPSC chairman and conducting BPSC re exam.... ruling govt. acts like dictator 🙏🙏🙏
🙄
Yes sir pls
Sahi bat h
5kg ration will making DEMOCRACY 😊
Sir koshish kariye
Ethical Issues
1) Region Development vs Tribals Interests
2) Ends vs Means Debate
3) Displacement of tribals & will effect livelihood of them
4) Duty vs Dereliction of duty
5) Social Wellbeing & justice
Course of Action
1) Firstly, I will try to persuade tribals in line with Discourse ethics
2) I will follow Inclusive approach by considering the interests of all sections & Gram Sabha
3) If Tribals are not agree with me, then I will report the matter to my superior
4) Overall I will ensure that Interests of tribals should not be undermined in line with social ethics in long term while focusing on development
Thank you brother ❤
@@devishankaryadav7295 Most Welcome bro
9 January 1915 me aaye the and is day ko celebrate Kiya jata hai - Paravasi Bhartiya Diwas.....
Ethical dilema
As a DM.....mai first of all tribal community ke mukhiya se personally jakar baat karungi and project ke bare bataungi, project ke kya benifit iske bare me bhi bataungi jisse ki mai tribals ko convince kar saku and finally convince hone ke baad mai unke rahne ke liye ek accha si jagah alot karungi jisse unhe shift hone me koi bhi problem ka samana na karna pade, unhe shift hone ke liye time bhi dungi jisse unhe rehabilitate karne me kisi bhi parkar ki dikkat na ho.....
@@sushmarajpootsushmarajpoot354 Answer ko aur behtar banane ke liye community engagement ko badhawa dena zaruri hai, jisme sirf mukhiya hi nahi, poori tribal community ke sabhi stakeholders ki baat suni jaye. Cultural preservation ke liye unke rituals aur traditions ke liye ek specific land reserve kiya ja sakta hai. Displacement minimize karne ke liye project ka alternate design explore karna chahiye. Compensation ke alawa, unke rehne, rozgaar aur social security ke liye long-term rehabilitation plan banana bhi zaruri hai.
@@baldevbhakal101great 😊
Ethics dialema
As a DM , step-1----tribal sarpanch se milker unhe project ke benefit bataungi and tribal people ko convience karne ko bolungi
step-2------trible village ko land ke badle me harjana double dena and unki livlihood insure karaungi
step-3-----project developement se tribal ka n sirf economic condition better hoga balki society me equality bhi aygi or unhe unka culture protection ka aswasan diya jayga
गुजरात में जब स्टैचू ऑफ यूनिटी बनाया गया तब भी यही प्रॉब्लम सामने आई थी कि ट्राइबल लोगों की संस्कृति भी बनी रहे और रोजगार भी मिले। आज वहां के लोकल लोगों में सबसे ज्यादा लड़कियां EV रिक्शा से रोजगार पा रही है। क्योंकि गवर्नमेंट ओर ऑफिसर्स ने अपना मास्टर प्लान सही से लोगों के सामने रखा। उस वजह से इन्फ्रास्ट्रक्चर भी विकसित हुआ और प्रवासन भी, बदले में लोगों को अपने culture identity की हैंडलूम चीस बेच के रोजगार प्राप्त हुआ ओर कुछ चीजों में सरकार के प्रयास से इनर conflict खतम हुए।
Dilemmas associated are-
Infra Development vs ecological balance
Economic benefits vs tribals right
Modernization(uniform culture) vs tribal culture (Diversity)
As a DM first of all I will try to identify whether is there any other places then the tribal habitate for the project, if there is scope for any such site near to the proposed place I will send it as a proposal to respective authority, and will talk to them at a personal level to convince the respective department for shifting of the project to another site.
If there is no scope for such changes then I will talk to the tribal community along with all other stakeholders associated, and will try to convince and ensure for their proper and right rehabilitation, income source, preserve their tribal culture, their sustainable livelihood coexistence with nature.
सर आप पिछले दिन का जो केस स्टडीज है उसको बता दिया करिए
As a DM 1st communicate with tribals and gram sabha, understand their issue and their demands.And also discuss infrastructure benefits that available for them.
2nd communicate with stakeholders about tribals demand, when infrastructure project in tribal area important but it's more important tribal concern
3rd -if possible change project design that helps tribal To stay in their land.or provide secure area with livestock facility, economic support to tribals. And try to full fill their demands.
Thank you sir 🙏
Dielma- sir mai as DM sabse pahle un tribals ke leader se milungi aur unhe samjhne ka prayas karungi ki ,is infrastructure development se sabhi ko profit hoga aur sabko employment bhi milega mai unhe is baat ka yakeen bhi dilaungi ki aap sabko compensation aur sari facilities dilaungi jo aap sabko milni chahiye .
Eske baad ek awareness campain ke through logo ko aware krne ki koshish karungi jisse log meri baat samjh ske .
Aur agar wo samjh gye to easily gram panchayat se approval mil jayega aur infrastructure project stablish ho sakega.
Thank you so much 😊 amezing discussion sir 😊😊
बिल्कुल 😊
9 january 1915....bhartiya parvasi diwas
Sumit sir pahle to thank you aapke itni achhi tarah se kisi v topic ko samjhane or batane ke liye....
Par aaj mai bahut upset hu...kal jo kuchh Patna me hua...usko dhyan me rakhte huye aaj ke aap ke is ethical question ka answer mere anusar yahi ho sakta hai ke....
Kabhi v kisi v office ke samne koi v ethical dilemma hota hi nahi hai ..koi v dilemma kewal us office ke personality or carecter ke karan uske samne aata hai...har office wahi karta h jo uske upar wala office ya neta bolte hai ....jiska jita jagta example kal ka Patna incident hai...pichhle kai dino me maine bahut achhi tarah dekha or samjha hai ye office or leader kisi bat ko apne interest me kaise ghumaya jata hai...😢😢
Yes you are Right ye sab ethics sab sirf ethics k paper me marks jada uthane k lie karte h aur phir ground me public k paise se aish karte h aur political parties k pich laggu ban jate h aur phir dande barsate h dusre aspirants pr wo v berahmi se.
2025 is the key of success
जब तक दम है लड़ेंगे और जीतेंगे
Solution video dilemma
As a DM-
1. Try to convince tribal people
2. Arrange proper rehabilitation for them with proper facilities
3. Ensure proper job for each family
4. Analyse project that environmental issues are addressed
Thank you sir 😊😊
Dilemmas involved:
Development vs Tribal concerns
Tribal emotions vs materialistic well being of tribals
Tribal rights vs developmental economics
Stakeholders involved:
#District Magistrate
#Tribal people
# Senior politicians/head
Solutions:
# Taking approval from gram sabha without much convincing tribal people
Merit- Time saving approach
Demerit- Ignoring tribal issues
#Making tribal people understand for their benefits involved through this project in their style
Merit- Giving time for betterment of tribal
Demerit- Time consuming approach
#Rejecting approval as tribal people concerns are important at some context and wait
Merit- Giving priority to tribal individuals
Demerit- Development delays progress of tribals
#Providing source of livelihood or making such arrangement so that their migration would not result in their distress situation and approval would be easier to gain
Merit- Tribal concerns involved and project approval made easier
Demerit -Effort taking , requires extra funds for providing livelihood
Decision making:-
I would prefer last approach as it presents a balanced approach considering tribal issues.
1) To gain the confidence of tribal communities, it is crucial to assure them that their customs and beliefs will be protected and that development will be sustainable.
2) Minimize harm to the environment and the community's traditions.
3) The resettlement place should have all the basic amenities required for a decent life.
4) Sufficient compensation to be given.
Dilemma
Culture, livelihood vs development
Mujhe lagta hai people rhne ka place chhod sakta hai jab money ka achha amount mile iss se life style bhi Change ho jata hai
Logo ko uss place par chhodne ke liye try karunga because devlopment aane se facility bhi badengi aur iss mahgai me log infrastructure development project ko chunna pasand karenge thank you sir
As Dm,My course of action-
1) Ethical impact Assesment, ensuring tribals right
2) Adopt land for land approach,providing land nearby
3)Engage with village panchyat and tribal community,hearning diverse concern
4)Demonstrate empthethical leadership,ensuring alternative livelihood
5)Gandhi's talisman approach,Facilitate Policy or Action alinging with poorer..
Sir kya isi tarah bpsc students per Lathi charge or water cannon chalta rahega?
2 January ...International non violence day
9 January 1915 ...Pravasi Bhartiya Divas
30 January 1948..Martyrs Day
Only for my reference and record to track consistency:
Tribals v. Development dilemma
Political pressure v. Integrity
Taxiway- Yellow
Runway- White
Goa incident Air India Airbus Dec 5 2024 runway confusion raises concern on the safety of Civil Aviation in India
Questions basic training
Historical pattern of runway Confusion, runway overrun and systematic issues.
Issues in Civil Aviation safety:
1. Poor Training and safety Standards
2. Non Compliance with ICAO standards
3. Failed DGCA and AAI safety audits; role not clear, lack of accountability.
4. Flight crew pressures
5. Flight duty time limitation: causes fatigue. Focus on Operation rather than safety.
6. Inadequate infrastructure
Safety and fatigue most imp and role of DGCA to ensure both.
Blame game by DGCA
100 years of belgaum session
Kohat (Pakistan) communal riots during second half of 1924 and committee of Gandhi and Shaukat Ali to investigate causes behind Kohat Riots
Gandhi 21 day fast due to riots
Sitaramayya wrote kohat broke the backbone of India
Juhu Conversation : Negotiation for truce b/w Pro Changers or Swarajists and No Changers in Belgaum Session to unite pro changers to Congress. Dialogue held with Swarajists and Gandhi in May 1924 called Juhu Conversation but failed.
Later pact between Gandhi and Motilal-Das in Ahmedabad finally established and this was ratified in Belgaum session presided by Gandhi and working secretary JLN.
Significance of Belgaum Session
Sahel Region Crisis and Implications on India
Resources rich but poverty and instablility?
Factors behind coup?
Role of External factors?
9th January ko pravasi Bhartiy divas ke name se celebrate kiya jatah thank you so much sir for editorial discussion 😊😊
14:21 Pravasi Bharatiya Divas (PBD) is celebrated on 9 January every year to mark the contribution of Overseas Indian community in the development of India. January 9 was chosen as the day to celebrate this occasion since it was on this day in 1915 that Mahatma Gandhi, the greatest Pravasi, returned to India from South Africa
As a district magistrate,
growth and development along with welafare of the people is main concern.
A middle path will be reached out after consulting all the stakeholders,and no biasness will be followed in this case.
Radhe Radhe 🪈🦚🙏My Dear Sumit Sir
thank you sir for discussion❤️
Belief are the personal matter but national interest are parellel. Convience them by granting suitable land,Wages and money guarantee . And added their local issue with legal method.
9 जनवरी 1915 को गांधीजी अफ्रीका से भारत लोटे थे इसलिए भारतीय प्रवासी दिवस के रूप में सेलिब्रेट किया जाता है। इस दिन भारतीय प्रवासियों को भी आमंत्रित किया जाता है।
Thank you sir 😊
9 january 1915 ko vapis aate h or ab is din ko pravasi bharat day ke roop me manate h
09 Jan 1915.
Pravasi Bhartiya Divas.
This time - Bhuneshwar.
Now this is biennial conference .
Sir issue ko resolve karne ke liye phele hame village ke sabse older person se bat Karni hogi kauki oo village ke sabse old person honge aur village ke sare log unki bat nhi talenge fir isske bad sab ko yek sath bula kar unko surety our security dono provide karne ka promise karenge aur government se unke habitable ke liye suitable place recommend karenge .
Sir kya jis tarah se itni thand m bpsc aspirants ke uper water canon ka use Kiya gya, itni berahmi se mara gaya,ef female student ke dress ko phad diya gaya.... kahin se v ek beaurocrate ko shobha deta h. Hm ethics m padhte to itni achi baten h phir ground m ye officer aisa kaise kar dete h. kya IPS miss sweaty sehrawat aisa unethical pratice sikhi h upsc jaise exam se?
Rehabilitation of tribal people
Proper livelihood and favourable conditions
Culture preservation of tribals
Effective management and engagement with all the stakeholders involved
Sumit sir it's a request to you please 🙏 raise your voice for BPSC 70 re exam for all
Sir pichhle din wale case study ka appropriate answer bata diya kijiye please.
Please make video on BPSC Re-exam..
It is a delimma between duty and faith , religion vs development.
As a District magistrate i will make sure that the place should be used for infrastructure for hospital and school whuch meant to be developed .But if it would be some kind of business or an unnecessary plan tograb the place then. I will try to bargain with bith the parties .
Gramsabha,tribals ,and the person wants to make infrastructure and labours are stakeholders .
There should be a decision which is a good conduct , good for all .
Conclusion - its necessary to develop a place but to make trust and development in positive manner is more important.
sir current affairs preparation ke beginning se padhna chahiye ya end mei?
persuade tribals by explaining the benefits of development like education, hospitals, jobs etc for their children
increase compensation amount and livelihood at another place
persuading them with the help of village elders and religious persons that their forefathers will be happy to see their land bearing fruits of development for children
Solution to this delimma..... greaveance redress mechanism ...understanding tribal issues I detailed manner ...making proper guidelines.. implementation of tribal Dev.programme and tribal counselling for 2 to 3 weeks nd there are many other way of tribal persuasion
as a dm m
1. Gramsbhaa k saab baat kruga unka ganw m jakr and unki hr ek issu ko a6ha se address krena ki kossi kruga
2. Ek committe bnauga or esa lga phla k project ka serva krne ko khuga taki unko phla lge projet k baara m janne ka moka mila
3. Unko wqt diya jana chaiye
Sir pilots have landed on parallel taxi track also.
Sir
Is project me sabse pahele me social and environment impact assessment karke uski report gav valo ko dekhaunga
Us project ke banifits bhi unhe batavuga aur unke liye sarkar ne kya ayojan kiya he taha unko livelihood kese provide hoga ye sab bhi samjavuga
Aur department ko unke liye aur emphaty se kam karne ke liye suggest karuga
158 days completed
Consistently ❤❤❤
Good afternoon sir and thank u so much sir❤❤❤
Thank you so much sir 😊😊😊
Namaste 🙏 sir 😊😊😊😊
9 January 1915 and celebrated an Pravasi bharatiya diwas
In this dilemma, I will take into consider all this stakeholders, Melly, the travel people because they are more prone to the effect of this developmental project. for course of action, I would follow. I will assure them that this project would be a game changer for their future generation. I will try to a lot Best rehabilitation for the tribals. I will also try to make a museum of the culture so that their lease can be safeguard of their ancestor land. I will assure and promises given to them will be provided in the legal manner so that they will get confident.
airlines vali problem tourism pe bhi direct affect karegi.
Thank you for the video
14:20 9 January 1915 bhartiya parwasi diwas
good afternoon sir very very happy new year
Tribal logo se comunication kar ise samjhana hoga ki infrastructure development se tribal logo ka hi faayda hai jisse economic growth hoga
Mai sumit sir jesi banungi
Aese hi baat karna .....
Bahut accha lagta hai
प्रवासी भारतीय दिवस 9जनवरी ❤❤😊😊
This dilemma is between development and Tribal rights.
We can rehabilitate them to secure place with livelihood opportunity.
9 January , 1915 Mahatma Gandhi was came in india from South africa
Tab se 9-January ko ---Pravashi bhartiya diwas celebrate kiya jata hai
sir as a dm me sabse pehle to vaha ke logo ko samjhane ka try karungi ki development kitna jaruri hai unke liye aage badhna jaruri hai aaise nbahut se tribal group ka example bataunghi ki pehle vo bhi aaise hi mna kar rahe the ynke purvajo ki dhareti hai isliye mna kar rahe the per baad me vo samajh gaye aaise examples dunghi aur unka jaha rehne ka niwas hoga vaha try karunghi ki unko aachi lifestyle mile atleast unki basic needs puri kar sake women ko bhi empower karunghi . mere jo seniour hai unse bat karke tribal logo ko help ho aasi scheme lane ke liye boliungi
पहले जनजाति की बात सुनेंगे
अगर प्रोजेक्ट यही करेंगे तो पहले जनजातियों को नई जगह मुहैया करवाएंगे ।
और जो सरकारी लाभ है जैसे राशन पढ़ाई सब मुहैया करवा के उस लोग को नई जगह शिफ्ट करेंगे
9th january ---- Pravasi bhartiya diwas
Thank you sir 😊😊❤❤
1915.january 9 celebreated as NRI day
Sir editorial section wise compile kr k dal de 6 month wala .. uppsc k liye jrurat hai
Sir pls make video on gujrat FIX PAY issue... Govt. Employees exploited by own govt. For 5 years...!
Thank you sir ji
Good afternoon sir🙏
Sir I will talking with tribals group and try to convince them by justifying all the advantages of project and I assured them that the tribals group also giving some other location for their living and spiritual exercises but when they are not convincing then I will talk to the project manager to modify the project location in some other nearest region.....
Men tribal community ko btaungi ki ke is project se unko bhi fayeda hoga or unhe usme job bhi dilwaungi taki unki rozi roti chal sake or unhe vishavas dilaungi ki unhe ek betar jagah par rehne ke liye jagah di jayegi jaha school or hospital jesi basic suvidhayen mil sake or unka poora dhiyan rakha jaye.
Namaskar Sir 😊
Pravasi Bharatiya Divas 14:24
Ethical Dilemma
Firstly I will talk to the tribal leaders about their problems in detail.
Secondly I will assure them that the displacement will happen to the place where they sustain their lives.
While this will also talk about benefits of the project that will take place.
This will create an atmosphere where dialogue will prevail and both the project and tribal population will be satisfied
Pravasi Bharatiya Divas (PBD) is celebrated on 9th January every year since 2003
Gandhiji returned to India on 9 January 1915 and this day is celebrated as Bharatiya Pravasi Diwas
9 January 1915: pravasi Bhartiya diwas.
Pw onlyias customer service is pathetic i order my book 1 week ago on 23 December and in got Message that the books are undelivered call on the number but the delivery agent nor any customer service reply me and pick my call it is very irritating and worst service. I am an aspirant and my time is waste and no one care about it I call continuously to the pw helpline number n book store but no one reply only email but not my problem solved.
9th Jan 1915(pravasi bhartiye diwas)
Is constitution exist in Bihar??
Ye kesa system h jaha government hi seats bech rhi h.aise hi Bharat Vishwa guru banenga kya..
Wo ho jata hai, kya ho jata hai, fatigue ho jata hai, ge line sahi thi😂😂😂
sir mai sabse phele waha ka jo mukiya mnta ha usko help lunga or unka baat mn jayenge ku ki unlog us par biswas krte h tab hi village k mukiya hoga fir wo convence krega ghao k
Mahatma Gandhi came to India on 9 jan 1915 & celebrated as non- resident Indian day🎉
Thank you
Charan sparsh guru ji
9 jan 1915 was the date Gandhiji returned to India and is celebrated as Pravasi Bharatiya diwas .
Namaste sir gi
09 january 1915 "bhartiya pravasi Divas"
Prawasi bhartiya divas 9 to 11 Jan.
sorry sir kuch dino tak apka lecture attend nhi kerpauga dr. ne mna kiya earphone lgane se.. ear m dikkat aagyi sunayi dhang se nhi de rha hai
9 january 1914 known as Parvasi diwas... Gandhi ji came in India...
9 jan 1915
Thik h apka video dekh liya h bakvas
9th Jan 1915......pravasi bhartiya divas
Gandhiji came to India on January 09, 1915. This is celebrated as NRI day.
Thnk u sir
Tribals there main issue is rehabilitation and livelihood
(I) I will write a letter to higher ups ....after negotiation with the tribals .....if they agreed to job offer in development project. And it would not be difficult to be approved as development project offer diverse job offer and later work under MGNREGA.
(II) Tribals 2 nd demand rehabilitation.....they would be given Living place in district in some other nearby location. If higher ups approved.
(Iii) Ayushman card for all to be made for health.
(iii) Enrollment of children in nearby government run school....whose education quality to be ensured by myself personally.
(Iv ) Utilize civil society like NGO to help them make SHG to get benefits of various government schemes.
(V) Redressal mechanism to ensure better implementation of the demands of tribals .
👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍🙏
9 January 1915 perwasi diwas
Excellent
9 January 1915 pravasi bhartiye diwas
9 January 1915 pravasi bhartiya diwas