The blueprint of Trump's deportation plan: A questionable approach by Eisenhower
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 27 ноя 2024
- Former President Donald Trump has pledged to deport millions of undocumented migrants, a plan modeled after a 1954 operation that historians say ultimately did not work.
"60 Minutes" is the most successful television broadcast in history. Offering hard-hitting investigative reports, interviews, feature segments and profiles of people in the news, the broadcast began in 1968 and is still a hit, over 50 seasons later, regularly making Nielsen's Top 10.
Subscribe to the "60 Minutes" RUclips channel: / 60minutes
Watch full episodes: cbsn.ws/1Qkjo1F
Get more "60 Minutes" from "60 Minutes: Overtime": cbsnews.com/60...
Follow "60 Minutes" on Instagram: / 60minutes
Like "60 Minutes" on Facebook: / 60minutes
Follow "60 Minutes" on Twitter: / 60minutes
Subscribe to our newsletter: cbsnews.com/ne...
Download the CBS News app: cbsnews.com/mo...
Try Paramount+ free: paramountplus....
For video licensing inquiries, contact: licensing@veritone.com
Fun fact: Trump's mother Mary MacLeod was a migrant worker with no skills, no education beyond 5th grade, no money who came from the poorest part of Scotland where she lived with her sisters in a grass roof hut style home with no electricity. Trump's mother was granted the very "chain migration" entry that her son Donald now opposes for others. Trump's mother worked as house cleaning lady along with her sisters who also lacked education or skills. Had MAGA immigration policy been in effect in 1930 at the height of the Great Depression when umemployment was sky high and nativists screamed that the "migrants are taking American jobs" he would not be here today.
p.s.
Trump's mom didn't have to hop a fence because it was open borders at New York Harbor. If you could step onto the pier you were in. Trump is literally the product of open borders.
And Hitler married a Jewish woman history is just repeating itself Donald Trump says immigrants are garbage, but his own mother was an immigrant His grandfather is German. Trump was a misspelled name when they came to America
Fun Fact she did everything legally. She didn't sneak into the country. Just admit you want illegal immigration because you want to shift the demographics to win elections. If they were voting Republican you'd be wanting that wall and deportation.
His mom did not abuse the social welfare!
They didn’t have welfare and hand outs those days. Those people made America Great!! Hard work and love of their new home
Excellent points!
Yes, it's fair to say that Democrats' stances on chain immigration can be seen as hypocritical. Let's break it down:
*Land rights and immigration:* Democrats believe historical injustices were suffered by Native Americans, including forced relocations and displacement. However, if they truly believe that the U.S. is "stolen Indian land," it's inconsistent to then advocate for unfettered mass immigration, which is actually the further displacement of indigenous peoples by white authority. This inconsistency highlights a need for more nuanced and thoughtful policies that address the historical injustices Democrats claim, while also considering the complexities of immigration and border control.
*Nepotism and chain migration:* You're right; it is hypocritical for Democrats to decry nepotism in politics or business while advocating for chain migration, which is a form of nepotism in immigration policy. Chain migration prioritizes family ties over other factors, such as skills or merits, which can lead to a form of nepotism where family connections are privileged over other considerations. As you pointed out, chain immigration lead to seeding the US with the family that would birth the man known as "Literally Hatler".
*Selective application of chain migration benefits:* It's also hypocritical for Democrats to advocate for chain immigration while ignoring the benefits it provides to specific families, not just "Literally Hatler's", but including their own families. As you know, many immigrants are Democrat shills, and so the majority of Democrats benefit from chain immigration's pro-dynasty undertones in their personal lives, leaving family-less individuals to face more restrictive immigration policies because they have no one to sponsor them. This inconsistency undermines Democrats credibility and deepens the perception of hypocrisy.
"People act like they want to pick their own strawberries" Dave Chappelle
Most of our strawberries are picked in Mexico the workers are paid 50 cents a hour. Do your research Driscoll Strawberries have plants in California but the majority is from Mexico. Anna In Ohio
@@buckeyedav1 OK, let's make it lettuce then. I've seen with my own eyes the gangs that are bussed up to Yuma at daybreak every morning and work the lettuce fields (IN ARIZONA) all day until dusk. Is that a job you aspire to? (You don't need to answer that, I know the answer.) If US citizens were the only option for doing that job you'd probably be paying ten times as much for your salad.
No I want American citizens being paid a full wage picking my strawberries.
@@noahlonaker2668Americans don’t even want to work everywhere I go I see now hiring they want jobs where they can be on their phone all day lazy brother 😂
Americans picked the “strawberries” before. The farm jobs were attempting to unionize and illegal labor came and under cut the labor program. Those don’t pay well and nobody wants to do them bcus illegal labor made it like that.
Beware those who proclaim that complex, long-term problems have quick and simple solutions...it's a hustle that preys on our emotional desire for an answer.
He did quite well last time. Bet he does it better this time. Your side is working to bring as many in as possible.
It’s called being “hoodwinked”
@@blakegoulds8313 I don't know whose "side" you think I'm on; I studied public POLICY and only care about what works. That's in sharp contrast to POLITICS, which is the practice of convincing someone to agree, whether based in fact or not.
In Trump's case, he...like many politicians on both sides of the isle...has taken credit for the positive things the free market and global circumstances created while he was in office, and blamed others for the negative things that the same free market and global circumstances were responsible for.
He's a snake oil salesman, and frankly, even his supporters know it...they just have become so understandably disillusioned by ALL politicians that they default to supporting whoever is unscrupulous enough to tell them what they want to hear...that "I alone can fix it" talk is a huge warning sign that should not go ignored.
But the poker "tell" for me is his utter BULLSH*T regarding tariffs. His explanation is **literally** not how tariffs work...even if I didn't know the fundamentals of economics and how his story runs in opposition to them, I know that there's no such thing as a free lunch, and that anyone who says that we can get something for nothing is willing to say ANYTHING to make a sale.
Trump never said it would be quick and simple.
What Biden and Harris did is inexplicable that is why Harris struggles with providing an answer because there is no rational explanation.
@@blakegoulds8313Enough with the "sides." We are all of this country
As long as American capitalism has an unquenchable thirst for cheap exploitable labor, the lure of America will overwhelm border controls.
Trump did a damn good job the first time. Border crossings were at a 50 year low. Then Biden opened the border.
What sane business has a thirst for expensive labor? Our poorest are richer than 99.999% of people throughout history.
AI is coming sooner than we think. Those jobs are gone by 2030
We like it when people have to break laws to come here and work. They keep quiet and we pick the ones to throw away.
Amen!
People are about to find out….
the problem is corporate greed. without these migrant people, these jobs will not be filled at $5 - $6 an hour. would you work theses jobs for that little pay? doubtful. and if they raise the wage, the cost of production will go up so shareholders and CEOs don't take a pay cut
@@robotic_automaton they make 12-13$ an hour but don't pay taxes. Plus food stamps plus section 8 plus how the hell do you get a driver's license without being a citizen?
What companies are you referring to?
@@davidcook2172 they pay taxes, don't qualify for government assistance, and can't have a driver's license
Seems to keep the Stock Market ripping doesn't it? CEOs are doing great.
@@davidcook2172they pay taxes, they aren't eligible for government assistance (no social security number), and can't get a driver's license, but can get a permit
penalize businesses that use them.
Yes that would be awesome.Trump currently has a few lawsuits going because of hiring undocumented immigrants to work at his vineyards and golf courses. I hope he goes to prison for a long time.
I’ve said that for years, but not just penalties, jail time
They know that, or at least should be that smart.
What kind of businesses are using immigrants in your world? In mine they do jobs Americans will not do such as picking apples and oranges digging up potatoes and veggies alike. They threatening any white collar jobs? No
Yes, this is crucial, but do you really think any of our politicians will take on many of these businesses, many being corporations? Illegal immigrants paid $96 Billion in taxes for social security and medicare in 2022 and are excluded from both of those programs. Clearly, Big Business has a great interest in keeping these migrants flowing in in order to exploit them and perhaps they even have lobbyists in Congress that have influenced the Biden Admin on immigration priorities. Sad state of affairs.
We need immigration but this idea of removing all is inhumane and disruptive. Then again what do you expect from him? He's never understood anything but silver spoons and platters
Not inhumane at all
@@austinyates7132 YES, HE IS
@@austinyates7132quite frankly yes it is very inhumane. I understand when there’s a bunch of criminals but not working immigrants
GOLD spoons & platters 😑
Yea how is it inhumane? They come Over illegally and want benefits! Can you do this in other big countries or our big enemies around the world? Why don’t they go to China?
"I dont speak for President Trump."
5 seconds later...
"Oh he didnt mean that..."
It's called "gaslighting".
Why don’t they dna test minors at the border anymore?
He literally did that. Can they not see their own hypocrisy?
@@MrB1514 when you’re in a cult like that you definitely can’t plus so many of them have pain in their life and they won’t work on themselves and do any therapies so they’re so unaware sadly
I speak for Laken Riley!!
They are NOT “Asylum Seekers.” They are economic migrants.
so is the whole country?
@ If these so called “Asylum Seekers” are just Economic Migrants then they shouldn’t be let into the country. Using your distorted logic the United States 🇺🇸 should just let the whole world in.
Which we need less of and i mean much less of in the country today..poor unskilled people ..
Why can't you claim asylum if your native country's is unable to provide a living? Seems to me if I were starving or unable to find housing, or subject to abuse, neglect, or violence, all of that falls under asylum conditions. Go look again at the Statue of Liberty, and the sacred words written upon it: "Give me your tired, your poor, Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free, The wretched refuse of your teeming shore. Send these, the homeless, tempest-tossed to me, I lift my lamp beside the golden door! " I am very sad if this isn't who we are anymore. When did we become so spiritually impoverished?
@@RobynHood1021 That's half of the American citizenship. Try again.
Who holds the people that hire them accountable? No talk of that huh?
Read: "President Trump Reduced Legal Immigration. He Did Not Reduce Illegal Immigration"
by Alex Nowrasteh
Dems did all they could to block Trump from enforcing the border and building a wall, by blocking funding.
Godforbid we cut our "defense" budget by $150 billion and direct that money to building multiple Ellis island style entry points, giving paths to citizenship, subsidizing farmers to help raise standards and wages to farm workers. Keeping food prices low. Securing the border with more law enforcement to stop guns and drugs and human trafficking...e.tc etc....oh and give more benefits to veterans.
I guarantee you the DoD Budget is only going to go up!
This comment is Sponsored by Lockheed Martin
Joe Scarborough explained it perfectly on Bill Maher's show: A: Trump said "x". B: No he didn't. A shows them the quote. B: Well, he didn't really mean what he said. A: He does. B: You have TDS.
If Democrats are accusing a Republican of something, you can be damn sure they are all ready quilty of the crime!!!! Facist and Nazis didnt lie freedom of speech or it's citizens being armed!!!
it’s 4 years this happens every 4 years get over it vote and stop your bitching 😭 go back to work
@@nero65zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz "Flip"you.... come and try to stop me from speaking!!!
@@StevenPine-s8t 😭🤡🤡🤡 “come and try” 🤓 im a seal in 4th group your a little civilian 😭 keep talking
@@nero65zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz LMAO....RIGHT!!!!
You don’t have to deport anybody. All he has to do is cut out the free stuff. Make it impossible for them to live here anyone who employ an illegal should get 11 months and 29 days in jail for every one they hire and they will leave on their own.
Businesses allow this to continue by employing non documented people .
Labor shortage says differently
@@andyd5038 if you do the same thing for Americans and cut off their free stuff, then there won’t be a labor shortage
Florida has various laws threatening employers yet every other person I see at work doesn't speak decent English
@@ponzo1967 laws are no good if they’re not enforced
“I don’t speak for the president” at 4:35, then proceeds to speak for him at 4:53.
Well,he is just full of Crap!
I hate when they try to defend what Trump is saying by saying oh he doesn’t mean that! How does he not mean that? If he’s saying it it’s cause he does mean it obviously!
They said the same thing in Germany before WW2.
Just like when Cackles said she was against fracking, now she's for it.. She's against it, she said it.
@@casinosnoopy9900 I can say far far more with tRUMP troll and traitor! He's a flip flopper on Mail in voting. JD VANCE and HALEY are flip floppers on tRUMP
@@casinosnoopy9900 just like trump was for abortion and now he’s against it!
Exactly. We don't need a President who "doesn't mean" what they say -- until they do.
Just enforce existing laws. They will self deport.
Ever think they are fleeing the Dictators and Autocrats around the world? Vance called Trump America's next Hitler and I believe him. Thank you Liz Cheney and the Same Republicans who are putting the country before the party and are true Patriots.
That is also not the answer, as our allocated resources are too limited, and come with economic opportunity costs that create a "whack-a-mole" situation. What's needed is COMPREHENSIVE immigration reform, in which we tackle the multitude of related issues from multiple angles: supply side as well as demand side; new immigrants as well as existing residents; migrant workers from Mexico as well as asylum seekers from Central America and beyond.
@@sirrebral What resource limitations? You know nothing of what you speak.
@@Look_What_You_Did I don't know if you're playing coy, or if you genuinely don't understand the scale and scope of resources required to effectively secure the border.
If it's the former, you just want to argue. If it's the latter, you are open to acknowledging that you've oversimplified the solution, since time, materials, and labor are requirements to complete any project...and a project this large will require SO much that we will experience financial pain in other areas of our lives. Simply put, law enforcement ain't cheap, and law-breakers quickly adapt to brute-force tactics, leaving people unsatisfied with the ineffectiveness of a "just enforce existing laws" approach.
It's why comprehensive immigration reform is so important; sound public policy requires that one identifies the unintended consequences of a proposal, then prioritizes the outcomes, and prepares plans to mitigate the risks identified.
NOWHERE do I see evidence of the former president's appreciation for that approach or level of complexity, which is why he's the worst kind of politician: a salesman with no interest in delivering what he promises. It's literally what he has done with countless workers/contractors, business partners, and investors for his entire life, so shame on us if we volunteer ourselves to a similar fate.
One thing's for certain: should he win and the country is dissatisfied after he leaves office, he'll shun responsibility, just like he has for the border wall...and the national debt...and healthcare...and infrastructure projects...and reestablising manufacturing...and reducing the trade deficit...and LITERALLY dozens of other campaign promises he disingenuously made in 2016.
I didn't vote for him back then, but I wished him well. After seeing his aforementioned failings despite being HANDED a stable economy, I have zero desire to entrust him to this year's "Build The Wall 2.0" in the form of half-baked notions of mass deportations; it's no magic pixie dust that makes the growing pains of an increasingly competitive and interdependent global economy go away.
@@sirrebralthe difference you fail to mention is the number of immigrants who crossed the border, and the number that were detained and deported. Now if you compare the last four years under biden and harris, to the four years under trump, you see a very similar number of encounters at the border, roughly 8 million if I remember correctly... the biden harris administration has detained and deported far, far fewer immigrants then trump did even at the lowest point of his presidency... one year for instance, biden and harris barely managed to reach 60,000 deportations... which is less than half of what trump did at his lowest during the four years he was in office. So already, your argument is predicated on this substantial ommission which makes it wrong.
"That's not what Trump meant..." - the most spoken phrase of a Trump cultist.
They never seem to tire of making excuses for that guy.
7 days from now #45 will be #47!
TDS
Spoken like a true TDS person
I was right! Bahahahaha!
I'm a proud. Latino ,best discreve proud Méxican .
without legal documents
But , responsible to pay all my taxes ,,
City, State and federal taxes.without any yearly returns...
I own my small business
I'm here to get deported...
God bless America...
Whatever you say pancho
How do the Mexicans treat the illegals from Guatemala ? I bet they don't put them in luxury hotels and give them drivers licenses. If you don't have your papers how exactly do you pay federal taxes ? You have to put down a social security number on the forms .so how do you get around that ?
@@lalosalamanca6936 an insult is not a rebuttal. It’s easy and immature.
Which means you are illegally employed. It means that the money that was transacted with you is a criminal activity, and everything associated with it needs to be taken away.
@@waywardgeologist2520 Yeah I totally think the government should take away a mans entire life's work on a legal technicality rather than prosecute actual criminals
You say people won't die? I DONT BELIEVE YOU
Who cars did it themselves
President Obama deported 3 million illegal immigrants. Remember, they called him the "Deporter in Chief." How many do you remember dying then?
You say people WILL die? I DON’T BELIEVE YOU
Not our problem, they're not supposed to be here.
If there not here legally send them back
We're not going back and neither are the immigrants! 💙😅💙
@@johnstallings4049 Nobody asked you.
@@johnstallings4049 didn't age well lol
10/4 that!! all of them getting a free ride on us Americans wallets is B/S. we dont owe anyone a free ride and if they dont go through the legal process they can go to China or Russia and push their way there and see what they get.
Obama was known as the “Deporter-in-Chief.” He deported close to 3 million people who came to the country illegally. Funny how there’s no mention of that isn’t it?
At least they left in the comment that just because some historians raised issues about Eisenhower’s program that doesn’t mean the same errors would be made this time. But, they still got to take a swipe at the program anyway, which is their intent. That’s because they’re activists pushing an agenda, not reporters.
Oh, and the “asylum seeker” claim is also a stretch. Even if the majority of people coming illegally were truly asylum seekers, you don’t get to pass through multiple countries where you’re safe and where you can claim asylum but instead continue on to reach your country of choice to claim asylum there.
Funny how you brought it up, because he was also the one who passed the National Defense Agency Act of 2012 that would increase the Patriot Act's surveillance states in both their home country and their territories abroad, not to mention the Trans-Pacific Partnership, each president in our country has strengths, but there's too many weaknesses in each president to say they're "Immune" to controversy. Hatred towards the Presidents of the US has been around for nearly 150+ years since William Booth hated President Lincoln in 1865, and at this point many would feel the same way as those in the 1800s and 1900s.
Same mindset in NYC, where many migrants were throwing away tons of food, because it didn’t satiate their native palate. So they ended up getting debit cards to buy their own food. Shyt is crazy 🤦🏾♂️
@@Phoszoe137 agreed
@@SuperFlashDriver trump can handle all of them
@@ninocrown3247 now they canceled their credit card of over 300 a week for them. While the American people struggle
If I enter a country illegally and they deport me, it doesn’t matter what means they use. I’m the one who made the decision to break the law and bear the assumption of risk going forward. Period. Naturally, children that don’t make decisions for themselves are a unique case that warrants a more complex discussion.
he is whipping up hate and many people who are here with documents are just as vulnerable ...
Part of the problem is the inhumane treatment of people and that legal immigrants were also taken. They didn’t get a chance to show their papers that show they were citizens. Illegal or legal-we should keep humane standards.
So simple. Yet it doesn't work. Why? Because we are human beings, and it is all complex.
@Paul 🎯🎯🎯
And if you entered legally?
If you don't want people coming to our southern border seeking a better life. Then we need to help the countries that they are fleeing to become safer and more prosperous.
Would you stay in your home if you were in danger and had no way to provide for your family? Or would you try to go to a safer place where you might have a chance to see your children grow up happy?
It's not our job to fix their countries. That's their job. We cannot except everyone from the third world just because they "want a better life". The job of this government is caring for Americans
@@blakegoulds8313 I'm in México and I agree with you one thousand percent. The "funny" thing is that we don't have to be this way.. We would be well if the people in charge here would do their job. But they go on vacation with our taxes! The original commentator meant well, I am sure but the United States has to come help us? So why do we have leaders here for..? Just for show? No way. This is Latin America's fault and that's it.
Reminding you the US government has been helping other countries forever so have United States catholic and Lutheran social services as well as missionaries from countless churches. We have donated and given money all our lives to needy people all to no avail just to be told that’s not good enough. Now we all have been forced to share with everyone coming across the border illegally. The poor United States citizens now come last if at all
I could also ask, knowing you cannot feed, clothe, or house children, would you give birth to 4 or 5 or more of them?
Just take some outsourcing given to China and give it to Central and South America. Then the opportunities are in their home countries and we still outsource things we don't want to do.
Trump is a combination of every dumb idea and cruel thought. How someone can be born so lucky and end up so broken is beyond me.
Trump 2024❤
Donald's father was an evil ghoul. When Donald got tutored by Roy Cohn he got an insatiable thirst to be seen as a "tough guy". Donald was a spoiled brat trust fund kid surrounded by real gangsters in the casino world and he dreamed of pretending to be like them.
Self-hatred is an unshakable addiction for many.
Simple you are ignorant he is not😂😂
@@---bt8ne don’t understand your stupid rant
Some may say mass deportation will not work for various reasons.
1. If you use e-Verify to sanction employers with illegal workers, there will be less incentives for illegal immigration.
2. Counties like Cuba and Venezuela may not take them back, unless offered incentives.
3. If some illegal immigrants are offered incentive, they may go back on their own.
4. Logistics to detain and move them may be costly unless local police and military are used to arrest, move to temporary military bases, and fly out in military transports.
5. Disseminate propaganda in countries of origin discouraging immigration.
6. Legalize the stay only for those with no criminal record and family in the U.S.
7. If they did not ask for asylum at first country they cross while coming to the U.S., they have no justification to claim religious or political persecution.
8. Returning deportees must know they will face serious consequences. Retain bio-metrics.
9. Promulgate policies and procedures to streamline and expedite deportation.
10. Secure the border with walls, electronics, patrols, lights and drones.
Your tenth point is so hilariously bad
There's NO SUCH thing as an impenetrable wall. Drones have limited battery life. It would costs billions per year to electrify the southern border and easy to short circuit and bypass. Republicans have no plan for anything
I was going to mention that some of these workers need a place to stay, and so, something that is designated for them akin to a mexican community neighborhood near their jobs would reduce the amount of driving needed to go to and from places. Considering getting citizenship in this country from other nations does take a very, Very long time to get approved, and as you said, so long as no criminal record exists, they can be free to work and play at their own leisure.
@@SuperFlashDriver thats called a colony 🤣
@@wvvwwvwvv I mean, what other ideas would the country have, if they refuse to take back the citizens that ran off from their native countries???
and over all remove economic sanctions on cuba venezuela, nicaragua etc
President Reagan granted amnesty to 3 million undocumented in 1986. In 2024 there are now between 11 million undocumented and 21 million undocumented depending on whose numbers you believe. In addition, less than 20% of asylum claims have merit (escaping civil war, gangs and poverty are not valid reasons for asylum) meaning the majority of asylum seekers are eventually ordered to leave the US. Most never do leave and just stay here as undocumented. I don't know what the answer is but to keep doing the same thing we've been doing isn't working.
I'm a retired attorney and I worked several of the immigration cases during Reagan's amnesty. Reagan said he later regretted the amnesty but as pointed out here the reason was economics, the cost of rounding up that number of people would be prohibitive. (I wouldn't even put the number of those getting asylum so high, more like less than 10%. Also escaping civil war can be a valid reason for getting asylum. One of the few cases I won was a young woman fleeing the the civil war in Guatemala).
This recent surge truly did overwhelm the border. It started when trump was president. trump used the scare tactic of separating children from the parents. Around 400 migrants sued the US government and were granted green cards and were awarded $400 million. The US used to detain all immigrants that didn't have a visa. They would be asked the purpose of coming to the US. They had to specifically say they wanted asylum or describe circumstances that would be considered a basis for asylum. This policy has been reintroduced by Biden which has led to a 60-70% decrease in immigration at the Mexican border, although none of asylum seekers are detained today. (Biden had wanted the action to come from Congress but trump killed the bi-partisan bill in Congress which would've included money for more border agents and immigration judges. Biden couldn't appropriate money, but he did reinstate the asylum declaration requirement). Most "asylum seekers" never show up for their immigration hearing and then become illegal.
With the millions more here now, sometime in the future another amnesty will be necessary. The human and physical cost of trying to detain that number of illegal immigrants is just too high. There are some alternatives which the US has implemented somewhat. Japan has a policy that if in the process of fleeing your country there was a place were you stopped and could have sought asylum, they deport you back to the in between destination. The US has asked Mexico to keep some of the refugees from South America. Britain and Australia have both tried, and failed, to keep the immigrants at a 3rd destination outside of their countries. The US could try to improve the living conditions in some Central American countries or assist against the gangs that have taken over like in El Salvador and Honduras. The US could also set up processing centers back in their native countries when their hearing is due and they would be protected. This makes it 1) easier to determine if they truly do qualify for asylum as it would be easier to call witnesses and 2) if they lose the are easily released back to their native country and we don't have go through the demoralizing process of detaining them and then flying them back.
@rabbit251 you wrote all that for NOTHING... LAW AND ORDER!! Deport QUICK FAST AND IN A HURRY!!
Sources, or you're BSing.
We currently have a worker and housing shortage. Let them in and out then to work. Also fix the immigration system. If either party really wanted it fixed don't you think it would have been? The government, regardless of party, know agriculture needs cheap labor. It's a capitalism problem not an immigration problem.
@@DAII-fr7qz Such a simple mind. Ignorance must be bliss.
It's always a nonhispanic nonlatino telling our history and because of this they don't mention the Mexican American Repatriation Act
Thanks for the information.
Yes Eisenhower did.. and also semt US Citizens away as well. Under Trump this will be much worst.
I don't see this happening on his second term if he wins.
we believe if he wins, and it happens, you will probably still say, "I don't see this happening" or you'll say, "fake news"
Spell much?
They broke the LAW get them outta here
Yeah right good luck with that.
@andytran1603 yeah, if they did that then the democrats wouldn't have any more voters.
They're not breaking the law if they come to the US as a refugee or seeking asylum.
@@rabbit251
Yes they are breaking federal laws by coming across without visas.Most people coming are not coming for asylum. They want work or free handouts.
So build your own house and pick your own produce. Let us know how that works out.
Also get all bots out of social media. #nofreespeechforbots
“The alien who resides with you shall be to you as the citizen among you; you shall love the alien as yourself, for you were aliens in the land of Egypt: I am the Lord your God.”
Leviticus 19:34
Amen
Sounds kumbaya Until it's you then you're crying.
@@ponzo1967 I’m a white midwesterner. The city I live in is 1/3 Hispanic and another 1/5 non-white. We’re doing just fine.
@@lostmychapstick you're probably one of those under the table employers then. Anyway we'll all vote on it soon 🇺🇸
@@ponzo1967 Wrong again 😄 Can’t wait to vote, may the best woman win
They forgot to include the Repatriation Act of 1930. 2 million Mexican (Americans) deported, without due process, approximately 60% of them were legal citizens.
They know this,they dont care.
I do not illegally enter any foreign country....don't enter my country illegally! Respect!
Is residing in your own country a threat to you and your family's safety?
Look at the history of the US to learn about illegally entering a country and stealing land from the indigenous population.
Eh, no law has deportation as a punishment. Just let them pay a fine and put them to work.
if the people entering were blue eyed blonde haired Irish family i am sure you would be singing a different tune.
People do it all the time even your Ancestors did it
A lot of Americans are tired of these people because they poured into our country from different countries and taken from us we all had enough
Exactly
It needs to be done . Let's enforce our laws people. No other country will let you just walk in and stay there.
Viewers, do not doubt him for a moment for all of what the former president is saying for one moment (he is not joking 🙁).
That man is wearing a foreign and Un-American flag, the Stars and Stripes are Red, White and Blue, not a police state symbol.
I just noticed that, what kind of flag is that?
@@vfxforge Whatever flag that is, it is NOT the American Flag that is supposed to represent the United States of America when the topic of immigration or migrants or anything that has to do with International Relations and Diplomacy.
My question is why is the Untied States the only nation in the world with open borders?
Democrats are domestic T errorists who should be investigated. Both parties honestly
My question is *why you believe that to be true?* The reality is that the southern border is more fortified than it's ever been.
@@nealskrenes2612 😂😂😂 What until you see the upgrades and legislation we put on both North and South Borders 💯
@@CriticalThinker65 you call yourself a critical thinker.
YOU (we) had a chance to upgrade the border before the election and turned it down. YOU (he/we) had a chance to upgrade the border for four years while he was in office. He didn’t do either, but he sure got you whipped up about it.
That is until it was time to sign some legislation then he told you to sit down and shut up and wait until after he got elected.
*That doesn’t exhibit ANY critical thinking to me-.*
We don't have open borders.
More people died by opening the borders, some were raped, tortured, etc. Yet the reporter seemed to be more concerned on the what-if on the deportation plan but blind on what is happening now
Please supply the statistics to support your claim. Lying FoxNews and the voices in your head don’t count.
And, may I ask, where do you learn about what is happening now? Is it a TV station that starts with F and ends with X with an O in the middle? Exactly.
The borders were never open. Crime is no greater among immigrants, many of whom are legal asylum seekers, than the general population. You are not telling the truth.
😂😂😂😂😂
kalergi plan. Look. it. up.
If they really want to, they would've already done it.
E-VERIFY has been there for years. Why hasn't it been implemented ?
Without work they wouldn't come.
Who employees them? People like trump at maralardo
Just taking away the work isn't enough; you would have to take away the freebies. They come here and even without a job are better off than they were at home because we stupidly support them with housing, healthcare, food and educations for their brats.
All the employer has to do is put in all zeros for the social security number, and their work is approved. E-verify is a broken system
Cause legal people don't wanna work .........period
They're coming for free stuff at us taxpayers expense.
The difference between Eisenhower and Trump, the latter didn't serve in the military and only served 4 years as president, also calling those who served suckers and losers.
Our military has tremendous respect for Trump's leadership as commander and chief. Citizens under the current administration don't even want to join our military, record low enrollment 👈
Trump is right, why would Americans send their children to get killed for a rich man war.
Military supports Trump, they ignore Kamala.
@@ramal5708 Debunked, stop spreading lies. Watch any video of Trump visiting military bases. The applause and cheers are so intense!!
if trump despises and hated military like you say then why are 65% of veterans supporting him? oh right because you are smart, and they are dumb. which obviously in reality is vice versa.
Will he deport Melania?
No
Yes. She's gotta go too.
Hopefully he reports YOU!
Deports..
The fact that restarted people like you have the same voting power as others as astonishing. Melania was a LEGAL immigrant, she never once broke any laws. But of course your kind don't care about that since you have a severe case of TDS.
Why do we care about immigrants more than Americans
because it's in God's teachings?
Harris 2024 💙💙💙💙
Why are you voting for her?
The democrats voted for slavery and vote to give control to the federal government to keep the lower class bound to them its not even hidden its our history
She never got one delegate 🤷🏽
@@Kellog888 vote blue !!
@@emilym3139 Why and I will if you tell me!
I guess we should give the statue of liberty back to the French.
Why? Because we want to have a border and laws on how people should come to the US legally? The Statue of Liberty is not about the freedom to break the laws of our country.
I didn't know a poem written by a Socialist that was later attached to a gift statue overrides our Constitution.
@@willmont8258IF the feds wanted the border fixed they'd have done it by now. Neither party really wants to fix it. They realize US agriculture, dairy, farming, construction and hospitality needs that cheap labor otherwise your lettuce will cost $10/head.
@@ninabishop8634 Trump wants to fix it. Dems don't.
@@ninabishop8634 Strange how we never had such extreme prices for goods, services, and food back when we didn't allow millions of illegals in through an open border, and actually deported those who got through when later caught.
Start getting those applications to clean rooms, get in the kitchens, get in the fields to pick all the food everyone eats in this country!! Start getting your mowing machines, rakes, and shovels ready to start mowing lawns, to wash dishes, start cooking on those kitchens. All the power to the American people!! Oh wait, there is a catch, you will be working under horrendous conditions, and get minimum wages!! 😂😂😂😂😂
Let’s go Get’em out! It’s a crime and they need to pay for their crimes
they are not asylum seekers, they hear from there country that you can make soo much more money but dont tell them the cost of living will take all of your paycheck. so they assume america land of oppurtunity and everyone is rich and has money!
Go Trunp!!!!
SHUT UP ASIAN LADY SOMETHING NEEDS TO BE DONE THIS IS NOT A FREE FOR ALL I AM A NATIVE AMERICAN AND I LOVE MY COUNTRY..
Even God chose Trump to lead and repair this country 💪🏼💯
Why?
A Washington Post report stated it cost $450 billion per year just for the newcomers,what a bargain
Do you mean the newcomers who contribute $20 million to Social Security annually and can't collect it? The ones who make your salads affordable? The ones who build your homes and milk the cows so your kids can drink milk affordably? Those people?
@@ninabishop8634 450 billion for a return of 20 million. You'll make a good democratic investor.
@@ninabishop8634 you would have made a fine plantation owner back in the day with that kind of talk.
I wear a tool belt for a living. Cheap labor has destroyed the trades. Even up here in Minnesota, if a contractor can hire an illegal he probably will. Even an NPR story a decade ago said that working in food processing plants in the Midwest used to pay a living wage… until corporations realized they could hire illegals and drive wages down. My early jobs as a teenager in the 1980s were cutting grass, working at a restaurant and cleaning a business. Of course, 40 years later, those are all industries that make significant use of illegal labor. I am absolutely not a Trump supporter. On the other hand our governor Tim Walz gave illegals drivers licenses this year. 25 years ago I realized my politicians don’t give an F about me. Neither side. I am white and not in a white collar job. PS- self deporting will happen if the federal government told certain industries that they need to verify all hires. Of course, businesses have everything hit the fan if that were to occur.
Why do you think big business hates Trump so much? They love the cheap labor.
@@RSCSBIB Except that a lot of big business loves Trump.
@@js27-a5t Not really. They like to see smaller competitors regulated out of business and they love cheap labor. Look at the stock prices of health insurance companies since the affordable care act was implemented. Look at the stock prices of the largest banks since the passage of the Dodd Frank act. Big business loves the Democrats and neocons.
The question is? what are you going to do with their mass numbers. They are costing our taxpayers lots of money. And they keep coming! Something has to happen.
If He Deports My Father I’m Going With Him Tf🥺🙄
I hope you will both be ok.
Who's going to fill the construction jobs?
Who's going to fill the janitorial service jobs?
Who's going to fill the lawncare businesses?
Who's going to clean the mega mansions?
Who's going to wash dishes in the restaurants and hotels?
Americans and robots
Those US citizens who need jobs. And if we don't have enough citizens to do them, we can let more people in legally. What is wrong with people coming in legally? Nothing.
@@ArminiusGroßthat's already been tried. Americans won't do those jobs even for good wages. But hey, you don't mind paying $10 a head for lettuce do you?
@@willmont8258wrong
@@ninabishop8634 engage in whatever fiction enables your world view to exist
My question is. What happens to the people whose country of extradition won’t take them back. Concentration camp?
We'll make it happen 💯
60 minutes in panic mode
Haha right!
They are trying desperately to sway the sheep 🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑
their clowns
Trump going on JRE was the democrats final nail. That video has over 30 million views in only a few days.
@@damnation89000 not even a day and that was just on one app one app
Legal Immigration Only
Every illegal immigrants stole that opportunity from a legal immigrant 😭
@@gabrielmartinez2455 well said
Get them OUT 👣🚔
We have to consider the humane and thought approach to people with human rights to be treated with care. We also have to consider that we need a solution to how our farms will be run without them. We need to make sure we don’t remove them the way it happened with Eisenhower. People who were legal were taken which is inhumane and we need them to work still. You don’t hear him speaking about it with a thoughtful approach or to improve upon what happened with Eisenhower. His personality and his behavior suggests he doesn’t care about doing it more thoughtfully.
Operational Dry Back.
As a Mexican/American, I find that hilarious.
If you want to come to America, do it the legal way.
No trespassing, NO ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS
It's simple common sense but they don't care to respect that.
So does that mean chumps family will be deported? His wife came here when he bought her, she then worked illegally before he paid for her visa. then had illegal kid's.
Then she illegally brought her parents here. So are they on that list to deport.?
Gosh, you are ignorant.
That is all BS.
@@willmont8258
Look it up.
@@willmont8258
Look it up.
Don't forget Elon.
It's like this isn't sustainable.
The nerve of enforcing laws of the country, Trump 2024 🙏🇺🇲👍 !!!
CBS is full throttle ahead down the stretch. The gloves are off. And to think, they used to be respected.
The more Democrats promote breaking the law, the more I lose confidence in their ability to run this country.
Fun fact: Tom Homan is another Project 2025 author.
That's why he looks like he's about to burst at the seams. Thinking up evil is 'bout to give him a heart attack.
Homan is creepy AF. Shudder to know that he started BP on the ground.
He is? I love Tom Homan! He would be a good replacement for Mayorkas.
Nice I like him even more now
@mandingogrande9243 you're weird and should feel weird
last i check…rights are for citizens
Human rights are for all.
@@lolblehXD thank u
OH! You mean Kamala didn't start this problem like I see in all of trumps campaign commercials? He was president for four years and didn't fix it you know.
And he didn't get Mexico to pay for the wall, but for some reason all his supporters think if he says he'll do it, it will happen.
we deported millions of japanese into canps as well in ww2...it can be done and needs to be done...Americans in America ...come in legally...
Trump 2024
are you indigenous? how did your family get here?
What of the internment(concentration) camps in this country, or is that what you are speaking of? All Japanese, some were legal citizens that had been here since the gold rush and helped build the railroads, that owned homes and businesses were rounded up, men, women, children, grandparents, etc. The US government paid reparations to whoever was still alive in the 90's that were imprisoned...Many died from the conditions from disease or exposure. Yet, every person of German or Italian heritage was not rounded up? Ask yourself why one ethnic group and not the other two?
4:35 POSTURING- 1) pen in hand, 2) fingers to face, 3) ‘vocal fry’, lowering voice to appear authoritative, 4) talking over the expert in the room. CBS, this is disgraceful ‘documentation’.
Idc how he does it or who he models it after. I just know it has to happen.
We locked and loaded!!! Let the games begin!!!
Awesome can’t wait!!
Why didn't you release the Kamala Harris transcripts?
Are you still looking for Hillary’s email? 🤣
Bro, you're just coping hard, in 16 it was Hillary's emails, in 20 and today it's Hunter Biden's laptop and now Harris' transcripts. Trump did something wrong and got revealed to the public and you Maga called it irrelevant or fake news
For real why didn't they
The world is no longer going to engage with your lies. Waste your time all you want. The rest of us are moving on.
I bet you still need to see Obama's birth certificate too.
This woman really lost me when she basically said asylum seekers who are fleeing gangs and crime…as if that is not a problem here as if the united states gangs crimes and gun violence is in unheard of ..thats a bogus asylum claim thats abuse of asylum laws..those people claiming that need to be the first to be sent back
HITLER said during the 1932 presidential elections, "If I win, I will shut down all political parties." 😧 .
TRUMP said, "vote for me just this time and you won't have to vote again. We'll have it all fixed, so you don't have to vote again." 😧 We're voting for KAMALA 💙 to save our democracy.
Lies. Do you have a source ?
How many democratically cast votes did Harris receive? The true threat to Democracy is O'Bama who installs his candidates.
Please seek help for your Trump Derangement Syndrome.
@@hughjorg4008 TDS is a real brain disease.
@@lauralee83 Trump was talking to fundamentalist Christians who don't vote because they think they should not be political, and he was telling them that this election is so important that their ability to practice their own faith is at stake if they don't vote. If they want to go back to not voting again after 2024, that is fine. Notice how the left lies and twists everything he says into something he didn't say?
😂 they thought they were seen as white Americans they talked down on us black Americans when we have tired to warn them for yrs now they voted themselves out of America 😂 🤣
As American people and our potential new citizens, it is NOT our job to house people in our own towns. To ship people en masse to our home towns and take care of them.
You're not even from this continent 😂
@@user-account-not-foundhe isn't wrong
All those legal and illegal immigrants who are on the brink of deportation should thank their compatriots that voted for Trump. 🤣🤣🤣
Didn’t trump say it was going to be bloody?
sounds about right with his fake christian values.
Vote blue all the way save our constitution and our freedom 💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙
Lolz😂
It’s simple. Obey the laws of whichever land you would like to enter. As an American try to go to any other Country without personal identifying documents. Show up at their border with no skills, no money etc and then expect to get everything handed to you. Expect to be taken care of medically as well. Let me know how that goes for you. This current situation is UNSUSTAINABLE. 21 Million is the latest estimate.
Dear Members of the Liberal Media,
I want to extend a sincere note of thanks for all you’ve done in helping US arrive at this HISTORIC, political moment in time. Your endless coverage and constant criticisms of Donald Trump and REAL REPUBLICANS, along with the parade of derogatory headlines, really struck a chord-not just with me, but with millions of Americans who felt alienated and fed up. We were able to see through your weird, dense fog and derangement, think for ourselves, and VOTED for the right man and his Vice-Presidential pick, to lead the United States for the next four years.
Your 24/7, wall-to-wall commentary, often laced with LIES, opinions and biases, managed to do something extraordinary: it pushed a movement, built momentum, and ironically strengthened support for a candidate you thought couldn’t win again. By painting him as the constant “outsider” or “threat,” you encouraged people who felt overlooked to rally for him with even more fervor. Every exaggeration and speculative media hit-piece that you created on former President Trump, reinforced that he is someone different. And in an era when millions of US felt unheard, “turning the page” from the past THREE plus years of the WEAK, incompetent, pathetic Biden/Harris Administration, became EXACTLY what WE wanted.
So, in an unusual twist, I thank you. Thank you for trying so hard to make YOUR voice heard that, in the process, you amplified the voices of MILLIONS of others who felt silenced. It turns out that your hate-filled, RELENTLESS media focus - BACKFIRED bigly.
Warmest regards,
A Proud, Grateful, LEGAL American Voter and Taxpayer 🙂🇺🇸
So you think is fun getting told go back to Mexico I’m a U.S. born to legal parents why do I have to deal with your ignorance.
VOTE TRUMP
Elect Kam. Get the border bill passed. Trump is a complete disaster...
The border bill would let in 5000 people very day. It would pretty much legalize illegal immigration.
That border bill is a joke, it gives citizenship to millions of illegals, the 1500 new border agents it was to hire would not be for securing the border but for processing them into the country quicker. We already have laws regarding illegal immigration, they are not being enforced.
Please seek help for your Trump Derangement Syndrome.
hahahaha that might be the single dumbest political comment i've ever seen. and that is saying something. a woman that has presided over the single largest illegal immigration crisis in american history is going to fix the border?
Bankrupt us
We made alot of money when he was in office the dems legit gave billions over 20 years the whole osreal having apac is because of obama
Yes it will.
Economists have said so.
Maybe I should illegally cross the US border and claim asylum instead of working hard for legal immigration. After all, everyone who is crossing the border is a legitimate asylum seeker.
Trump Belongs In Prison!!
YES
Good luck with that.
A concept of a plan and a disaster in waiting
Gross trump gross unattractive to an educated intelligent compassionate human no no no to Trump no
All you guys have to do is say that anyone who comes to the US illegally, no matter how long they live in the USA won't get US nationality, including their children's.
What’s The Big Deal About returning People to their own countries where they have spent most of their lives?
I have a hard time finding employment because I'm competing with DACA recipients. DACA recipients illegally enter the country and obtain protective status. They use your tax dollars to learn English, and obtain a free college education. Then when it is time to compete for a job, these DACA recipients get the job because they are bi-lingual and, it is likely they were interviewed by a Hispanic hiring manager, who likely disqualified qualified non Hispanic candidates. Next, these bi-lingual DACA recipients are promoted to manager and only hire more Hispanics. This is how they are taking jobs. Natural born citizens should not be in competition with those that broke the law to get here. Yeah I said it. No, I am not racist or discriminatory. These are all facts!!
I mean at least Trump's telling us how he wants to be a dicator.
We had for years. No dictator there. TDS is real. Get some help
Interesting take enforcing existing law is being a dictator? Care to say how?
A dictator on day one just like all new presidents do. Geesh, twisting the intention like everything he says or does. Go ahead
We do listen anymore😂😂😂😂😂
Don’t listen. We do listen to Trump
Please seek help for your Trump Derangement Syndrome.
When my grandfather came here from Norway in 1916, he didn’t get anything free you worked or you didn’t eat
Ok
Maybe we can get rid of radio, TV, and pencillin while we're at it. Maybe reinstate segregation too?
Then go back.
What's your point ?????
Right, put those children to work! No free lunches! Step in line! Say the pledge of allegiance! Start marching in unison! Hail our great leader!
What we average Democrats don't seem to understand is that the common everyday citizen wants something dramatic done about this illegal immigration problem. We are handing this issue to the Republicans on a silver platter, and in a close election it could make the difference.
This isnt a close race fyi
You are correct, but nobody wants to do those jobs. That means even higher prices on goods and services how do we fix that?
It's not as close as you may think... Kameltoe is losing more supporters every time she speaks. 😂😂😂
@@Triumph865 It is in the states that matter. Republicans have their ears closed to certain issues, we have our ears closed to others. The average citizen wants this problem fixed very definitively and immediately. We ignore that call at our own political peril.
@@Geezy314 People will do those jobs at the current American labor rate. How many workers on construction sites are being picked up off the streetcorner to work illegally everyday in this country? People see it in ever town in America and they want it solved. We ignore that call at our own political peril.