Nepal's Kalapani border dispute with India: What is the crux of the issue. A detailed analysis.
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 сен 2024
- Nepal and India have always been friends, the Gorkha Regiment has fought wars for India; but suddenly there has been a dramatic pro-China shift in KP Sharma Oli's stance and unnecessary aggressiveness towards India. What more is in store in the dispute of Kalapani, Liplulekh and Limpiyadhura. #nepalindiaborder #kalapani #lipulekh
Twitter: @bisboworld
Sources
The Times Of India
China Occupies Nepal Village, Land; Deafening Silence from Oli Govt; IANS; June 24, 2020
Nepal fears China encroachment; June 24 2020
Nepal eyes citizenship law tweak, may hit ties with India; June 22, 2020
Nepal blocks Bihar anti-erosion projects; Chandra Bhushan Pandey & Abhay Mohan; June 22 2020
Now playing on Nepal FM stns: Anti-India songs, June 21, 2020
‘Nepal’s move myopic and serves Oli’s limited agenda’; June 14 2020
Villages that Nepal is claiming are home to a string of IAS, IPS & state bureaucrats; Kautilya Singh & Prem Punetha; June 12 2020
Villages get sat phones to curb Nepal SIM use; June 13 2020
Nepal pushes for talks, India says need to create trust first; Sachin Parashar; May 29 2020
Oli’s map plan gets Nepal oppn backing; Indrani Bagchi; May 31 2020
Nepal may open more border outposts; Prem Punetha; May 22 2020
Dispute over Kalapani is continuing since 1960s; May 22 2020
Nepal restarts work on border road after 12 yrs; May 24 2020
Nepal puts up armed police outpost for 1st time near border, by Prem Punetha, May 16, 2020
Mount Kailash facts: mind boggling things you may not know about Lord Shiva’s home, Resham Sengar, May 17,2020
Hindustan Times
Nepal govt ignored India’s efforts for dialogue on map; Shishir Gupta; June 17 2020
Nepal to add 100 border outposts amid tensions, Neeraj Chauhan; June 16 2020
Length of Indo-Nepal border could change after re-demarcation: Officials, by Nihi Sharma, December 12, 2017
Economic Times
Not the Right Time to Talk to Nepal; Ranjit Rae; June 15, 2020
After Straining India Ties, Nepal Looks to Reject US Aid; Dipamjan Roy Chaudhary; June 15, 2020
Nepal will Reclaim Lipulekh, Kalapani, Limpiyadhura from India: Oli; May 20 2020
New road will shorten Kailash Mansarovar yatra by six days, by IANS, May 8, 2020
Livemint.com
India leaves the door open for talks with Nepal amid map row; Elizabeth Roche; June 16 2020
The shorter route to Kailash Mansarover, by Nandita Mathur, June 23, 2015
Orfonline.org
A view from Kathmandu: Deciphering the Kalapani-Lipulekh conundrum, by Sumitra Karki, May 21, 2020
The Hindu
Why are India and Nepal fighting over Kalapani?, by Kallol Bhattacherjee, May 24, 2020
The New Indian Express
Nepal objects to new India map, says Kalapani in their territory, by PTI, November 7, 2019
Will reclaim at any cost: Nepal PM Oli on contested land, by Yubraj Ghimire, May 20, 2020
The Wire
India Should Realise China Has Nothing to Do With Nepal’s Stand on Lipulekh, by Biswas Baral. 19 May 2020
India Today
Lipulekh: What is Kalapani dispute between India and Nepal, why is it news now?, by Prabash Dutta, May 19, 2020
Manifestias.com
The Kalapani Issue. January 23, 2020
Scroll.com
As China opens border connections to Nepal, it is time for India to take stock, by Nicola Contessi, February 3, 2019
The Kathmandu Post
Original copies of both Sugauli Treaty and Nepal-India Friendship Treaty are missing, by Anil Giri, August 13, 2019
Reuters.com
Nepal pushes to end dependency on India with China rail, tunnel deals, by Gopal Sharma, October 13, 2019
The Print
Not Nepal map, the real conflict is within KP Oli’s Communist Party, Seshadhari Chari, May 22, 2020
Lipulekh Pass & why Nepal is protesting over India’s new road to Kailash Mansarovar; Shekhar Gupta; RUclips; May 11, 2020
Why Kalapani is a bone of contention between India and Nepal, by Srijan Shukla, by May 19, 2019
JagranJosh
Kalapani Territorial Dispute: Origin, history, significance, territory map, Nepal's objection, by Sangeeta Nair, November 7, 2019
Nepalitimes.com
There is precedent to settling Kalapani, by Prabhakar Sharma, December 2, 2019
Business Standard
Laser fence installed at certain points along open border with Nepal, December 17, 2017
www.nepalitime...
www.manifestia...
I like your video very much, my friend. It was very informative and lots of historical facts and knowledge.
But, the problem now i have with the anchor of the video is that he is too biased, and the video is not from a neutral point of view.
the anchor seems to be blaming Nepal for everything, that has led to tensions between the relation of these 2 countries. You have also portrayed Nepal as naive and gullible, which can be exploited by China.
As a Nepali, i know people of Nepal have no animosity or anything against China. China has never interferred in nepals internal matters and have respected Nepal as a sovereign nation.
while, on the other hand, India is the biggest bully in south Asia region. The fact that every indian made video claims, nepal as its small brother, says a lot. you can say that, it is the love you have for Nepal. But that is not the way you respect a sovereign nation.
Nepal will never progress or see any signs of development, as long as Nepal tries to make good relation with India.
India doesnt even allow Nepal to use one of its port, to import goods from other countries. what kind of big brother does that sort of thing, where you dont allow your brother to progress and be independent. india wants nepal to be dependent on them and completely sub- ordinate.
Your point is noted Sumit ji.
@@BisboWorld Thank you, Sir. I hope I didn't offend any of Indian brothers and sisters. We dont want war in comment section.
In fact, my friends hate me for my love for India. That doesn;t mean I love Indian government, which tries to put Nepal under their feet, all the time.
Its not the same with Indian people. We talk, laugh, how governments fight and people just follow, without any reasoning.
to let you know, i am avid student of Indian history. ancient indian hisotry is fascinating.
And for you guys, i am a firm believer that Buddha is more Indian than nepali as well, and i can give my supporting statement to support my claim.
This is something lot of nepalese will not accept.
Yes "China respects sovereignty".......🤣🤣 of its neighbor countries as it has done with Tibet...It runs on an AGGRESSIVE EXPANSION POLICY...IT CLAIMS EVERYTHING UNDER THE SUN..IT CLAIMS INDIA'S TERRITORIES, BHUTAN'S, SOUTH CHINA SEA AND MUCH MORE... VERY SOON YOUR NEPAL MAY END UP IN CHINAS "DEBT-TRAP"...
FYI CHINA has encroached on 10 places comprising about 33 hectares of Nepali land , by diverting the flow of rivers which act as a natural boundary as reported by the SurVEY DEPT of the govt of Nepal...AND THE OLI-LED Nepalese govt. Is mum over it...You should read THE HIMALAYAN TIMES report...
BE DOUBLE-SURE BEFORE EVEN BEGINNING TO TRUST CHINA ...
@@BisboWorld yeah i too came here to comment the similat stuff. I have been your dedicated viewer for a long time, but this time the information was so messed up and you were even using conspiracy theories as fact that now next time i am watching you video, i am sure i will be doutibg you.
@hobgoblin1216 First of all, big LOL.
- India considers Nepal as a friend ? That's a big joke. A friend wouldn't block access to essential materials. In 2015 India did exactly that and that wasnt the first time, in 1989 India blocked Nepali imports from entering Nepal through the Calcutta ports.
- Nepal signed 1816 Sugauli Treaty with British Empire NOT with India so the land mass Nepal lost during the war with British is still legally belongs to Nepal. (If Modi government s still saying that they don't follow the treaty regarding the Kalapani issue)
- REMITTANCE MONEY:
According to Government of India:
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Remittances_to_India?fbclid=IwAR3d_fP9yWwxpYOyeQXhaZz25KJ1aQH-SRwHOv7p-CAVUH4rzjMaCyeai0s
It shows that each year, Indian workers in Nepal send 3 times more money (3 billion US dollars) to their country India than Nepali workers in India to Nepal which is only 1 billion US dollars.
When you see two fish fighting in a pond, you know that the British passed by.
😂😂😂 yes
LOL
Lol.. you mean European..
Wrong quote. Two fisherman fighting*
Dear Indian friends, the very long issue can be summarized this way (apologies for the length):
India in 1962: Hey Nepal! we are fighting a war with China and since your military presence in Kalapani and nearby bordering area is minimal, can we station around there for the period of war to monitor Chinese movement?
Nepal: Sure, we have the best of relations and if it helps in your defense, why not?
India: Thank you. we are establishing 18 military camps in Nepali land bordering China.
Nepal in 1969: Hey bro! the war is already finished but your camps are still around, could you withdraw your forces?
India: Okay! (removes 17 posts, but remains in Kalapani and controls Lipulekh area because it is strategically very significant to monitor China)
Nepal: Kalapani?
India: (to then King) Don't forget you are economically too dependent on us, also we can seize you from power by influencing the revolutionary forces. You remain quiet, you aren't using that area anyway.
Nepal after democracy in 90's: Hey bro! now we are a democracy and we now have access to historical evidences and facts, could you withdraw the army and settle the issue as the land is on the east side of river Kali?
India (Under Gujral and Bajpayee): Okay lets solve this and all other border issues with help from experts.
(Experts reach on agreement in 98% border area except Susta and Kalapani area, recommend it be settled on high political level, remains an outstanding issue)
India in 2015: Hey China, wanna trade from Lipulekh and make Mansarovar quickly accessible?
China: Okay!
Nepal: But it's our territory and we have been claiming it all along? (sends diplomatic protest to New Delhi and Beijing). Hey bro (to India) let's solve the issue first among us before any agreement with third party.
India: Ok then, No official visit for your PM Koirala (first time a Nepali PM does not make an official visit to India) and a blockade!
India in Novemeber 2019: New Political map released (8th edition) with Kali river marked well inside it's territory when it should be a border.
Nepal: Yo bro! You say East of Kali is Nepal but it is well inside your territory on the map?
India: Oops! (9th edition is quickly released with river's name erased)
Nepal: Let's solve it with foreign secretary level talks, there is pressure from general public after the blockade. This way the relation is only getting worse.
India: We don't care, you are too dependent on us. ( Inaugurates the road during Covid-19 pandemic, despite the construction not being completed and with presence of high level Military and Defense personnels)
Nepal: Come on! at least sit down and talk before doing things unilaterally!
Indian Army chief: China has made Nepal speak.
Indian Media: Nepal ki ye aukat ki wo India ko aankh dikhaye, Inhe fir blockade karna chahiye!
Nepal: Ok then we'll issue our own map with disputed territory (Will benefit the increasingly unpopular Oli govt as well as address public outrage due to India's consistent big brotherly attitude)
Indian Media: China, China, China, China!
A reply to Bisbo and message to Indian friends:
Very nice presentation. I understand your position of taking a pro-Indian stance, but let me point out to some flaws in your presentation. I would be happy to be proven wrong with facts from the Indian side, but please refrain from throwing insults, it does no good to both of us:
1) 2015 Blockade: You conveniently blamed the Madhesi parties of Nepal for blocking the border, leading to shortage. But the area they were protesting doesn't even cover 25% of the border. Why was supply stopped from all other border points where no protest was happening?
2) Origin of Kali is Limpiyadhura and it has been proven by your own recent map, if not for many historical maps. Just look at the 2019 political map (8th edition) of your own country and see where river Kali is marked. The British cunningly manipulated the maps after the treaty once they realized that Lipulekh was very significant for trade and security reasons. So, present Indian establishment can not be held directly accountable, but Kalapani was openly encroached and forcibly taken control over after 1962 due to its strategic significance.
3) Streams coming from the Lipu Ghat or Kalapani area are so small that it is an embarrassment to river Kali if you say they are the sources. Just check (even google maps will do) what looks like the head of the river? Besides, this can easily be solved if experts are employed.
4) India has asked Nepal for permission to establish 18 check posts in Nepal-China border including Kalapani during Indo-China war 1962, as Nepal had minimal military presence in those areas. Before that, Not only in Chhangru & Tinkar but Nepal's national census was carried out in Gunji Nabi and Kuti villages. People there participated in first general election of Nepal in 1959 and paid taxes to Nepal (Nepal has documents to prove all this). Later upon request from Nepal, these check posts except one at Kalapani were removed, as it allowed India to take control of Lipulekh.
Multiple requests were made later but never acted upon as India had too significant role in internal power politics and anyone govt. openly raising the issue would be toppled.
5) There are letters from acting Governor General John Adams, after the Sugauly Treaty that state that Gunji, Nabi and Kuti are parts of Nepal.
So, Conclusion: How can it be solved.
It was too easy before, a bit complicated now. To be honest, Nepal had only wanted Indian army posts to be removed from Kalapani to Indian territory West of that, even if that meant Lipulekh and Limpiyadhura unofficially remained controlled by India . Keeping it in Kalapani when every Nepali now knows it is a Nepali land even under your definition of the borders, is seriously undermining Nepal's sovereignty. But the big brotherly arrogance (Duryodhan like when he didn't even want to give five villages to Pandavas) worsened the relations. It has pushed Nepal to claim up to Limpiyadhura now. If impartial investigation and only technical aspects are considered, it clearly falls under Nepal, as no signed agreement has ever happened after Sugauly Treaty. However, ground reality, social and political considerations make it complicated, as the people have been disconnected with the Nepali state for over 50 years. If you argue that controlling a land with military presence for over 50 years makes the land yours, why bother fighting with China for Aksai Chin, when it has assumed its control from literally the same time?
( Now don't jump over me because China comes in here, just fits in the analogy perfectly)
So, keeping the issue under the carpet and threatening with military prowess or economic sanctions wont solve it, only postpones the issue with more negative feeling towards India growing up in Nepal and vice-versa. Sit down for talks, quietly relocate the posts and continue other things as it is, win win (my understanding). After all, the 'border' is almost insignificant in an open border. India-Nepal can jointly benefit from trade via the Lipulekh Pass. Blaming China in every small matter in Nepal is only covering up your state's failures in handling the issue properly and undermining Nepalese people's sovereignty and sentiments. The Indian media has been quite successful in doing that by sensationalizing the issue. So, quiet negotiations it is!
So Nicely Written Man. Hope the long term allies turn together Again. Love.
Mottainai very true.
Nepalese are our sole brothers. I have really trustworthy friends in Nepal. come-on Indian government, don't push-around our brothers. China is just playing on their frustration. keep your friends on your side don't abandon them.
I'll sum it up in fewer words.. "bloody communists"
Itna research kiya hai sunlo thoda kam karlo meh sikata huh ,ye kiska hai 10 sec mai pata lag gayega
Step 1
Goto google map and use satellite mode
Step2
Search Gunji and follow one river ,which looks more main river
Note 1816 was only official treaty of border between Nepal and India.Doesnot matter how many new map were published after that, thats not official.1816 treaty states Limpiyadhura as source of kali river.Also bakwas mat karlo river changes courses ,not in origin but in plains.
Nepali ho kya
It's showing in Uttarakhand, India.
As a nepali i used to adore this channel for its ability to show both side of the story , but today you guys only showed the indian government perspective rather than both side of the argument on this topic . you can search for the Sugauli treaty of Nepal of 1815 with the then British East Indian Compnay, Nepali western border starts from source of the mahakali river lipulekh and your highway clearly breaches the international border according to that treaty. The road was unable to be built in the Manmohan period because of the mutual understanding of the both government of Nepal and India that the land belongs to Nepal
only a few will see this comment but those who truly see nepal as a friend they will atleast listen to both the side of the story.please be informed.
Fool that is only the dispute.
You dont know anything and telling about this. The dispute is only that which is the source of the river
Bro when people have unrestricted movement between India and Nepal this dispute seems silly. As an indian I never even felt Nepal is a separate country. Please dont let your country fall to china. Ccp does nothing but destruction of culture
CCP is trapping you and you aren't understanding and are only blaming India.
Abhi Nischal how much you have mind you can think only that much
@@Sandesh.1994 exactly Bro!
8 Facts that Indian friends are not hearing from their medias;
1. Current international border between Nepal and India is defined by The Sugauli Treaty between the British East India Company and the Kingdom of Nepal in 1816 AD. Nepal lost 1/3 of its territory due to this unfair treaty.
2. At the outset of the 1959 Tibetan uprising, fearing for his life, the Dalai Lama and his retinue fled Tibet with the help of the CIA’s Special Activities Division, crossing into India on 30 March 1959, reaching Tezpur in Assam on 18th April. During that time of PM Jawalal Nerhu at 1960s, India-China relation got worsen and it let PM Nerhu to request Late King Mahendra of Nepal to keep troops in the Kalapani region to protect India from Chinese intrusion.
3. Since early 1960s, Indian army camps were in Kalapani region as per request to Nepal King Mahendra and India’s leadership did not withdraw army camps from the region after 1962 Indo-China war highlighting security issues. Gradually, Nepalese are blocked from going to those areas and slowly collecting tax and census by the Nepal government has stopped. It also completely stopped infrastructure development plans by Nepali side. There should be no issue on this matter today if India wants to solve it and leave its baseless claims of territory.
4. In the 1970s, under the leadership of PM Indira Gandhi, she made a foreign policy to annex Sikkim and Nepal into India. Sikkim became part of India on 16 May 1975 as the 22nd state of the Indian Union, and the monarchy was abolished. In the same year (1975) during the early period of King Birendra of Nepal, a new map of Nepal was published without inclusion of the current disputed territories of Kalapani, Lipulekh and Limpiyadhura for the first time. All previous maps of Nepal had inclusion of currently claimed territories with similar pointed shapes.
5. The issue was sidelined during the early regime of King Birendra and only after establishment of democracy in 1990, a member of parliament from Sudur-paschim province of Darchula district, late Prem Singh Dhami, raised his voice against the encroachment of Nepali land by India in the Nepal parliament.
6. Since then, there have been several talks at different levels between the two countries but the border issues have not become important to India. After 2015, Nepal became the Federal Democratic Republic with a new Constitution and the following year took the path of ‘Prosperous Nepal and Happy Nepali’ national vision for development with the foundation of elected stable Nepal Communist Party’s majority led government.
7. Nepal’s relationship with China has grown with the increase in Chinese investment since 2015 and involvement in the Belt and Road Initiative. On the current border issue between Nepal and India, Indian Army Chief’s political statement dated 16th May 2020 of “Nepal acting behest of someone else”gave spin to the reality and it misleads general Indian citizens that China is doing this border issue in Nepal. In fact, Nepal wants to keep the international border clear between India & China, and wants to focus on rebuilding its economy which became laggards due to Indian hegemony policy.
8. Nepal, India and China will make a tri-junction border point in the Limpiyadhura of Kalapani region which is not done until to this date. Nepal wants to solve this issue through bilateral talks with India and complete border demarcation with India and China where some areas are still pending for a very long time. Until now, India has been avoiding talks with Nepal on this matter and issued a statement to hold talks after Covid-19 pandemic ends. Nepal believes in friendly bilateral dialogues between two countries and resolved issues diplomatically.
How can this issue be solved?
According to an interview of an Indian-born academic based in Sweden Mr Ashok Swain, on this issue upon the question of “If India constantly denies holding talks to resolve the boundary issues, what other options Nepal will have to raise the issue? Nepali people have been asking the government to internationalize the issue. Do you think Nepal should think about other options too ?”
He replied, “I think India will soon agree to talk. If not, Nepal has no option but to internationalise the issue. In the past, Bangladesh had internationalised the Ganges water sharing issue, and that somewhat pushed India to sign the Ganges water-sharing treaty with Bangladesh in 1996.”
Let’s hope these issues will be solved in time despite unnecessary escalation by ill-researched Indian media and focus for multi-sector developments for equitable prosperity by both friendly nations. Having a clear border between Nepal & India meets security concerns for both countries and it stops all sorts of illegal trades and activities in the area. On the other hand, it also builds up healthy trust and relationship between both governments and peoples. Long live Nepal-India friendship.
Link for background border story of NepalIndia : t.co/x0kFEgn1Op?amp=1
Mr. ASHOKA SWAIN!! Hahahaha😂😂
Sure, we should listen to that GUY who doesn’t even live in INDIA and always gives out China and Pakistan supporting statements. Sure Sure! 👏
Ur first point, the traty which was signed by british with the king of nepal is not valid,according to the peace treaty signed by India and Nepal in 1950.
hobgoblin1216 The Sikkim issue was another conspiracy, and i’m sure nepal isn’t asking for sikkim or greater nepal portion quoted in the history , it’s just asking for indian side to stop illegally occupying borders and brainwashing its citizens to stop war or war like environments in the near future. What other alternatives are there if they keep delaying negotiations, the talks have been held back for a decade and now they’re blaming Chinese interference, if we talk of Interference Indian interference can be seen not just in Nepal but also in Bangladesh, Sri Lanka and pretty much every other neighbouring country, and they still don’t acknowledge even in the slightest bit there might be something wrong with the indian administrative procedures.
@@binaydhawa7666 Nepal's previous maps did not include that region right?
MY GALLERY the issue was hugely debated it was put out as a dotted line as far as i can remember as the issue wasn’t resolved, if ur asking for the text books in classes no it wasn’t shown, but there are excerpts about kalapani war written all over the history, surely you would understand why you wouldn’t like to lose the land your ancestors bled to death to protect, even on indian maps the territory claim was listed out as dotted lines until they started to officially project it on other official documents, nepal’s government had lodged its protest, there were several attempts for peace talks regarding the issue but India just ignored it, so we’ve been told until recently few parts of Nepal officially appeared on google maps and the road inaguration occurred with little or no consideration of Nepal.
Being a resident of Garbyang village, I must say that u have not missed anything . Great work .
Nepal is claiming Limpiyadhura, Lipulek, Kalapani, Gunji, Tinkar, Tinkar Bhanjyang on the basis of a factual incidence of Treaty of Sugauli signed between Nepal and East India Company in 1816 A.D. Due to the Treaty, Nepal lost its one third of its total territory to East India Company. In the Treaty of Sugauli it has been clearly mentioned that the banks of MAHAKALI(KALI) river which originates from the LIMPIYADHURA marks the boundary (Border) or Line of Control (LOC) between the two countries Nepal and India. In the Treaty of Sugauli it has been clearly mentioned that all the territories on the EASTERN BAND (Not the western as said in the video) of the Mahakali River will be Nepal (that includes, Limpiyadhura, Lipulek, Kalapani, Gunji, Tinkar, Tinkar Bhanjyang & many other small places in between)
Also, please watch this video to understand the issue better.
ruclips.net/video/vgJP5EheY5o/видео.html
India in 1962 (PM Jahawar Lal Neheru): Hey Nepal! (To the Monarchy) we are fighting a war with China and since your military presence in Kalapani and nearby bordering area is minimal, can we station around there for the period of war to monitor Chinese movement?
Nepal: Sure, we have the best of relations and if it helps in your defense, why not?
India: Thank you. we are establishing 18 military camps in Nepali land bordering China.
Nepal in 1969: Hey bro! the war is already finished but your camps are still around, could you withdraw your forces?
India: Okay! (removes 17 posts, but remains in Kalapani and controls Lipulekh area because it is strategically too significant to monitor China)
Nepal: Kalapani?
India: (to then King) Don't forget you are economically too dependent on us, also we can seize you from power by using the revolutionary forces. You remain quiet, you aren't using that area anyway.
Nepal after democracy in 1990: Hey bro! now we are a democratic nation and we now have access to historical evidences and facts, could you withdraw the army and settle the issue as the land is on the east side of river Kali?
India (Prime ministers Indra Kumar Gujral and Atal Bihari Bajpayee): Okay! lets solve this and all other pending border issues with the help from border Experts. (Expert: Joint Border Committee) reach on agreement in 98% border area except Susta and Kalapani area, recommend it be settled on high political level, remains an outstanding issue)
India in 2015: Hey China, wanna trade from Lipulekh and make Mansarovar quickly accessible?
China: Okay!
Nepal: But it's our sovereign territory and we have been claiming it all along with our evidences? (sends diplomatic protest to New Delhi and Beijing both). Hey! bro, (to India) let's solve the issue first among us before any agreement with the third party.
China Upon receiving the diplomatic note sent by Government of Nepal: Its ok!, If its Nepal's territory then we will rethink on the Trade agreement with India.
India: Ok then, No official visit for your PM Koirala (first time a Nepali PM does not make an official visit to India) and India imposes an inhumane economic blockade in the tough times of Devastating earthquake of 7 Richter scale in Nepal.
India in Novemeber 2019: Cashing the great opportunity when Nepal was totally devastated and ruined by the natural disaster, New Political map released (8th edition) with Kali river marked well inside it's territory when it should be a border.
Nepal: Yo bro! You say East of Kali is Nepal but it is well inside your territory on the map?
India: Oops! (9th edition is quickly released with river's name erased)
Nepal: Let's solve it with foreign secretary level talks, there is pressure from general public after the blockade. This way the relation is only getting worse.
India: We don't care! you are too dependent on us. (Inaugurates the road during Covid-19 pandemic, despite the construction not being completed and with presence of high level Military and Defense personnel)
Nepal: Kalapani and Lipulekh region are ours, then how could you built a road in the Nepali territories without even asking for a permission or informing us?? Stop it!
India: Come on Nepal! We are like Brothers, isn't it?? And if it helps us to earn huge amount of money through religious holy pilgrimage to Mansarovar Kaislash then why not build a black topped road there?? Although 35 Kms of the road still completely lies within your territory. But, why you shout deliberately let us rape your motherland in the name of trade route and religious Pilgrimage route. You know one thing, Nepal?? China is a Dragon it will capture your nation...Be aware! and forget our rape on your sovereignty. After all, we are like Brothers, No??
Nepal: Come on! Get matured now. At least dare to sit down and talk with us before doing things unilaterally!
Indian Army chief: China has made Nepal speak.
Indian Media: Nepal ki ye aukat ki wo India ko aankh dikhaye, Inhe fir blockade karna chahiye!
Indian Government (Rajnath Singh) to Nepal: We will sit for talk with you all only when the Pandemic of Covid19 gets over. Until then no talks regarding the border issue, got it??
*(In the mean time, India and China has a border conflict at Laddakh region)*
India then humbly & quietly sits for a diplomatic talk with China during the Pandemic of COVID19. (Clearly a Double Standard shown by India)
Nepal: Ok then we'll pass our issue our own map in the Parliament including the disputed territory ( it will address public outrage due to India's consistent "Big Brotherly attitude")
Indian Media followed by the Indian People: China, China, China, China!
ruclips.net/video/vgJP5EheY5o/видео.html
A well documented video, kuddos to team behind it. However it lacks some vital information.
-> the land of lipulekh, limpiyadhura officially belong to nepalese kingdom after 1816 treaty and was shown as Nepal's part
-> for the first time in 1860's, both sides came into an agreement which was showing kalapani as Nepal's part
->In 1875, britishers tricked Nepal and was showing Kalapani as india's part without Nepal's consent since they realized it to be strategic location to counter china in future
->Nepal didn't object to the move since Nepal was ruled by Rana's that were proxy rulers of britishers
-> Nepalese troops were staying in that area till 1960's until Nehru officially requested king of Nepal to hand over nepal's 117 border points to counter china in 1962 war
->after humiliating defeat in 1962, Nepal requested india to withdraw its troops from Nepal since war was over and had no use in border points of nepal
-> India withdrew its troops from 115 border points except kalapani and susta points which has now resulted in indo-nepal border conflict.
-> even Nepal has proof of conducting various population census, voting proofs of nepalese in lipulekh and kalapani over Nepal's panchayat rule.
->even before map was issued, India didn't show any intention of meeting over the issue but rather ignored it.
@@रफ्तारपटेल ok so can u name them
Try book review
very good @Desh Bhakta Gorkhali
@@रफ्तारपटेल except doordarshan all news channel are banned.are indian news channel worth watching? They show provocating fake news propoganda news without any full proof of evidences. They always talk about mandir masjid hindu muslim and india pakisthan. india should ban its news channel as well..its not stopping indian women marrying nepalese in citizenship but law was made any foreigner who married nepalese can only get citizenship after 7yrs.
@@im4rush Yes most of media in ind is not good but we can solve this issue through talks we have open border so we can share kalapani region no pblm , but why so much anti- ind sentiments 🤔
Thank you for making the video but you chose to speak the "Indian government" view rather than an "investigative view". Sorry but the information given in this video is biased in many ways and despite ur effort to make the video, I disagree with u on many levels on this video.
True
Agreed. Brisbo is biased when it comes to international politics.
Mister, have we met somewhere before?
Let me get this straight, Bisbo.
1. The reason behind the issue:
The primary reason of the border issue which was cool before was provoked by Modi when the indian government revoke "Article 370" in 2019 and came up with a new map, an intension to add Kashmir as an union territory. The Indian government expanded its land by adding the disputed land of Limpiyadhura-Kalapani-Lipulekh which was clearly not necessary because the Indian government knew that those land were already in conflict and this was the very reason Nepal never include those lands in its map. As a response to the Indian government, Nepal issued its new map containing Limpiyadhura-Kalapani-Lipulekh as their part, the core intention was to shows that nepal is not accepting the so-called "new map of india"
2. Anti-India Songs:
We had songs about patriotism, the song which is mentioned in your video is a patriotic song to remind our citizens that, this is not a small issue that we are dealing and we need to fight for our lands. These are just songs, when it comes to India, Indian media have completely ripped off the image of our PM and our country without any actual facts. A "rowdy unprofessional journalism" which has created narrow-minded journalists like "Arnab Goswami", providing wrong information to citizens and I don't want to think about the mindset of the kids who grow up watching these media.
3. Facts about the issues:
This issue would not have gained this much critics if the government of India had talked with the Nepali government before constructing the road. Maybe both sides would have come up with a solution that could help both countries but India showed a bully and unprofessional behaviour by adding the disputed lands on its map. If you say that "those disputed parts were already in India, so why do we require to ask permission to Nepal?". If it so, then why don't those disputed land were not in the last map of India. The Nepali government has its own facts and proofs with their respective departments and so does India. So both country representatives should have an official meeting toward this matter and solve this issue with facts and proper manners.
4. Present situation:
The government of Nepal has already sent many official requests to the personals of Delhi to resolve this problem but the Indian government has not responded yet.
Suruwal
P pop
People who work in fast food centres of our country, gurkhas and beauty parlour employees don’t deserve this shit
i never expected this from bisbi. but it turns out bisbo is biased too.
Yei BJP Sarkar aur china ddono Madarchod hai
So basically
Mai bhi changa, mera padoshi bhi changi bas china madarch😀d
Yep
Love from Nepal
.इंडिया का अत्याचार अब नहीं बरदाश्त होगा. जमीन के लिए अब काट भी डालेंगे और chod भी.
@@youtuberimage7304 yep love from India.
Now I wonder why the road was on paper in Manmohan singh goverment.
Sonia Gandhi ka chamcha kya kar sakte
@@mysorehathayogakendra1510 bro it means ..he already know that this will be disastrous for india nepal relation
@@divyanshuchauhan4234 These people won't understand. They think an iron fist will always work while it doesn't. A prosperous India comes only alongside a prosperous Nepal and vice versa. We need friendly relations. Why can't we just negotiate Army stations in that area while recognising it as a Nepali territory? Do we really need more land? This is egoistic and childish. But yes, Nepal's intentions need to be studied properly before making such a move because its not that Nepal is an innocent child wanting what its his/hers and won't come for more. Although nationalist Nepalese might rule out any Chinese interference, it remains a truth that they are hatching plans there. Anyway I hope people at New Delhi don't bow down to overly Nationalist govt and refrain from taking steps which could drastically impact relations. All in all, nationalism remains a real problem in all countries.
@@breadandchampagne7176 bro this is not childish This area is used as a surveillance area to keep a eye on china border. and second a country never gives a area even a inch to a country because they are saying its there,its make them look weak internationally and why not say it the past or used your voice internationally. Nepal is only backstabing india after receiving every kind of help from india to grow as a country.As for not building road by congress, reason was curruption nothing else.
People of Nepal: It's our land, give it back to us
People of India: China China China
People of Nepal: We just want our land back
People of India: China China China
People of Nepal: Are you listening?
People of India: China China China
exactly ... why are they running
What's your source of information for this comment
@@ksravish1545 simply look at indian private news
Because Indians don't consider Nepalese as enemy. This is why we blame China not you.
@Yash Singh while indian government signed contract with chaina regarding the lipulak and limpiyadhura...nepali government issued diplomatic note to both india as well as china.
Its issue of india nepal border then why are you involving china in it?
If so then indian government why are u not keaving kasmir???
Ur kasmir is a big deal for u
So as lipulak and limpiyadhur is ours.
No matter what nepal and india is always brothers and this issue will be solved too God bless both great nations
7:25
Younger Brother of Manisha Koirala's Grandfather, first democratically elected Prime Minister Bisheshwor Prasad Koirala विश्वेश्वरप्रसाद कोइराला. Their older brother Matrika Prasad Koirala was first prime minister affiliated to a political party and not royal court. Manisha Koirala is from a powerful family. Bollywood career was basically her hobby like playing football or cricket, fashion designing, etc.
You put so much of effort, still underrated, why?
Thanks Abdul, hopefully one day...hum honge kaamyaab ek din!
@@bruyhbruh8687 that way all the news channels shouldn't have any subscribers or viewer
@@BisboWorld I think role of time is very crucial factor. Your videos are coming little bit late.
Keep it up! We are with you👍
@Suraj, its taken us at least 6 weeks to get this out
@@BisboWorld indeed 😁👍🏻
Here are the main issues why the distance between India and Nepal is growing...
1) In 2015 when Nepal introduced its first Constitution, India interfered which is disrespectful to any sovereign nation. After they became unsuccessful Indian government imposed an economic blockade on landlocked Nepal which resulted in hundreds of deaths of sick and old people due to lack of medicines. India has done it before but this time the World has already developed huge equipment to build roads and tunnels through the Himalayas. Not just Nepal any other landlocked country would seek alternative way to bring essential goods into the country. After seeing India's inhumane behavior, Nepal asked China to send essential materials.
2) Border issues in the Terai region of Nepal where people from Bihar (India) have been illegally encroaching Nepali lands by pushing the pillars (border demarcation) further into Nepali side.
3) Bihari people from India getting Nepali citizenship illegally to get voting rights to vote for in Nepali elections.
4) Koshi River Barrage is being controlled by Indian government which lies in Nepali land, which was signed 50 years ago believing that India would allow water to flow freely during mansoon season without flooding lands in the Nepal side. In recent years, India deliberately shut the barrage gates to flood Nepali lands saying if opened, it would flood Indian side.
5) Kalapani, Limpiadhura land which lies in the Nepal side (according to the 1816 treaty signed by the British and Nepal). India has already violated the treaty. So that means if the 1816 treaty is void then the size of Nepal would be three times of what it is now.
6) Modi government has not taken back its 500 and 1000 Indian notes from Nepal which totals around 1000 crore rupees.
Love from Nepal brothers
It's not Nepal vs India . Its just 2 government who can't adjust . India and Nepal share alot of similarities in culture , religion and work ethics .
Too much baised filled misguiding information..totally interpreted in indian favor..
Dhoti haru madarchod sab eutai kheetko mula hunn.
@@prabinkarki707 dude your your language shows your upbringing, always behave in a decent manner in an serious online forum.
its by indian for indian hhahahaa
Tell us your version
You could have gone the Dhruv Rathee’s “India vs Nepal Border Dispute”route.Sort of neutral but tilting a little bit Indian Side but still a Good analysis.I like Bisbo as a Whole but here You guys were not being an impartial Judge & not analyzing from a neutral point of view without bias.You could have said these disputed territory belongs to India but Nepal Government has Valid claims too so its better to Solve this Issue soon through Dialogue not outright dismissal of the other Party
Baba are you kidding first take as much help from india to grow as a country and then start saying this is my territory. Nepal only want to make strong ties to china for that have to break ties with india.But they know among people india is very popular so they are bringing this up now.A country never give a territory to any country it makes them look weak in international politics.
@@user-bh6mz2kf6o Help from Indian ??? LoL .
If not for the British ( East India Company )many parts of current India would be ruled by Nepal.Read History.
@@devendramalla bro many Nepal people work in india and india helped nepal for infrastructure project almost 90 percent tourists comes in nepal from india. Trade goods export does does not gets taxed as other countries. In any natural disasters they get help from india. East india gave territory to india thats final you cannot change that after 50 years.Why didn't they raised the matter internationally if really cared about the matter earlier
@@devendramalla what are the proofs tomorrow ,sri langa say lakshadeep is our
@@user-bh6mz2kf6o that maybe true but u can’t say i helped u with this this this so we can take ur land & u do nothing
This Nepal depends on India for foreign aid.We should stop all foreign aid to them.Then only they can understand.
Yes bro , not nepali should punished
I would request my fellow Indians to have patience and not bully or verbally abuse the nepali people.Soft power goes a much longer way, especially in this case.We already have a number of enemies,we wouldn't want nepal to be one of them!
This mess wouldnot have happened in first place when Nepal alerted in 2015.India itself has said 2% border dispute is remain to solve(kalapani and susta).Knowing it is disputed territory India should have asked Nepal permission to build mansarovar road.Being HIndu state Nepal would have agreed but INdia wants to show power but with China its helpless.Even India only 3 times small than China in size,equal in population,5 to economy cant stand against India.
Now India bullying and thinking bigger size and economy can win against Nepal.Then we Nepali have nth to say.It will only push Nepal further away.
Nepali abusing India
Nice Explanation....I wonder what makes people dislike the videos which are made after much research and efforts.....If they have any issues in content they can humbly comment......only losers can do this ...never mind Bisbo....Go ahead....please cover Hagia Sophia Museum story....recently in news ...along with Roman Empire and Ottoman Empire
Thanks Karan. Yes, we get lots of people commenting who's only interest is in finding some fault, however trivial and often imaginary!
Look at this doo, river courses change in middle and lower course, not upper course😂😂😂😂
How can a river change it's course in mountains?? Nonsense.
The map you used, didn't even put a disputed line on kalapani border😂😂
Until both sides come up with an agreement, bhai, map se video banao-ge to gad-bad ho sakta he..
Basically, main body of the river can change its course but the point of origin of the river never changes and according to the article 5 of the Sugauli Treaty between Nepal and India in 1816 A.D. states clearly that Mahakali river originating from Limpiyadhura marks the border between Nepal and India. All the territories and regions on the eastern belt of the Mahakali river is the sovereign regions of Nepal and that Nepal won't claim its rights over the territories or regions on the western bank of the Mahakali river. This article clearly specifies not only Limpiyadhura, Kalapani and Lipulekh but also the entire Mahakali regions belongs to Nepal. Yes, there have been several maps published by the East India Company on the contrary to the soul of the mutual agreement of Sugauli Treaty but those maps have been published by East India Company unilaterally. There is no any valid signature of Nepal. Hence, the only basis is Sugauli Treay where Nepal has signed a valid signature. And there hasn't been any amendments in the Treaty of Sugauli itself in the history. So, these regions are undoubtedly sovereign regions of Nepal.
11:48 Your limerick/song at the end is the best part. No matter how much someone may agree or disagree with your videos, the song near the end adds a lot of joy, it can't be explained. Truly unique characteristic of this channel.
Lipulekh belong to nepal go watch dhruv rathe video he is from India but he is support of truth Any Nepali like
Chinese ambassador to Nepal is the real prime minister of Nepal
Ya too much control assertive control it's not good
@Whats in THE name bro don't let your media fool you. We know our government is weak and we know who were meddling in our every political matters. But us we never gave up and will never ever give up against mighty power. India don't follow angrez encroaching policy.
@@ashishbk8233 if we wanted we could have but we do not want that. How does Chinese encroachment feel by the way??
@@abhishekdev258there is no encroachment done by china all border issue with china has been already solved in king Mahendra era and what you guys talking about rui village was 60 years back issue which has already been solved and Nepal even got more 302 sq km land of china more
This is the fruit of watching godi media😕
Very Original. I appreciate your creativity (clap clap) :)
This my understanding of the issue. Per Sugauli Treaty, the India-Nepal border in the west is the Kali River and the debate is WHERE THE RIVER STARTS. Nepal's contention is that Kali river is the rivulet that starts in Limpiyadhura. India says (as you pointed out @5:35) it starts at Kalapani where all the rivulets from the watershed merge to form Mahakali river. This dispute has been going on since at least 1950 when independent India and "democratic" Nepal signed India-Nepal Friendship Treaty. This issue flared up every now and then, esp. when Nepal's politics takes a nationalistic tone usually for inter or intra-party reasons. I guess this is one of those periods. But whatever the reason, India must appreciate the depth of anti-India sentiment given India's over and covert intervention in Nepal's domestic politics for 50+ years. It is best for both India and Nepal if India were to pursue Gujral Doctrine on its foreign policy i.e. peace and non-intervention in neighbor's internal politics.
As any citizen every one has their patriotic feelings for their motherland i hope each nation will solve the border dispute in a bureaucratic way as we all are in pandemic stage.We all should be united in this hour neither be carried away in the political scene as each politician has their own selfish ideology.Lets all be united
United we stand divided we fall!
This channel is watched globally so in future good social no biased informative videos will be uploaded in future we all will be eager to view in coming days
Superb presentation. Deserve a lot more viewers 👍
Thanks a lot Antony 😊
@@BisboWorld fuck off..biased content..reply to constructive comments rather than replying to compliments.
Sources not valid.
The lands you are saying China took was an exchange of land between nepal and china in the 60s where Nepal left with an extra 300+ sq kms of land.
China fully supports the american mcc grant.
the songs were not anti india.
and i dont see any harm for nepal to be trading with china. as you said we are dependent too much on india which is why it treats us like shit. its time we find news ways to stay supported when you deploy another blockade.
i dont like this video being a NEPALI but i have to request my people from INDIA a few things:
Dear Indian friends/brothers/sisters... peace and love from nepal. it might sound awful but please get rid of your ridiculous and pro modi media which makes baseless remarks on any country's sovereignity and people. secondly, this thing can be solved with help of sugauli treaty which embarks boundry of Nepal & India. the name of river is MAHAkali , MAHA means big, right? so if we are able to solve river dispute, which your media never mentions or talks about; how can we resolve the issue? keeping all the hatred aside, please take care of the fact the we are one of the few countries to continue friendship for years, but we cannot tolerate the fact that we are being dominated unilaterally for years now and indian public are not responsible for for that. in reality it is the indian establishment which has been ignoring Nepal's request to sit for the talk. INDIAN people and NEPALI people will remain as BROTHERS for life, our friendship journey was not started on will and it wont end on will of STUPID & ARROGANT politicians, will it ?
after the day dispute has started , more than 50 NEPALESE have died in INDIAN ARMY! come on politicians and indian media, end your hatred; let love flourish between world's most emotionally connected people of NEPAL- INDIA. i hope this ends soon. if it doesn't i will blame politicians of both NEPAL and INDIA , not our dear brothers/sisters of INDIA. PEACE and never ending LOVE from inner core of all NEPALI people!
And I request you to urge your prime minister KP Oli to stop causing the problems between India and Nepal in times of distress like this for both of our countries. And also look into the interventions of the Chinese in your country's politics. Don't always shout India is interfering in your politics, raise your voice against the Chinese as well, else your entire country will be gobbled up the Chinese.
Rahul Mathew u have all been brainwashed by indian media propoganded by indian gov .In todays world no country can gobble up(in ur word) another country. It isnt possible. U all think nepal is a communist country .No it isnt its a democratic country .to be fair we love communist believes (common , no religion, secular) in fact we are surprised our communist pm s statement about ram we dont care about whats inside ur country .or no any statement from nepal gov side has been done in saying of china we dont care about china (dont give a damn) its between india and nepal.# STOP GETTING UR BRAIN WASHED
How naive can you be. Ever heard of Crimea which was in Ukraine now in Russia. Russia has been sanctioned by the US and other major world powers for their actions. They won't be able to do that with China because the world is heavily reliant on China and also China has already taken Nepalese village by crooked means. Wake before you end up in a concentration camp or end up living in India as refugees like the Tibetans.
Very nice channel . you have a new subscriber . love from lahore .
This channel is so good , only thing to get better it is to use Hindi medium to deliver their information
Thanks Kabeeraa. We have Bisbo Hindi channel. In fact we have Bengali Malayalam Telugu Marathi others as well.
@@BisboWorld this is so good 🙂👍, loads of love to ur efforts 👏👏🙂
Look, this is what India did to its neighbor countries.
---Swallowed up Kalapani from Nepal in 1962;
---Swallowed up Turtuk from Pakistan in 1971;
---Separated Eastern Pakistan from Pakistan to become Bangladesh in 1971;
---Swallowed up Tin Bigha from Bangladesh in 1972;
---Swallowed up Sikkim to become one of its states in 1975;
---Tried to invade Mauritius but failed in 1983;
---Captured territories of Sikhism and suppressed Harmandir Sahib so its believers assassinated
its Prime Minister Indira Gandhi in 1984;
---Invaded Sri Lanka in 1987;
---1st times invaded Bhutan and failed in 1990, but has controlled its defense and
diplomatic affairs till now;
---Supported and financed the terrorist organization Tamil LTTE to rebel against Sri Lanka government
but gave it up later under great international pressure. The betray triggered huge anger of LTTE so it
assassinated its Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi in 1991;
---Swallowed up Dooars from Bhutan in 2006;
---Swallowed up Moreh from Myanmar in 2013;
---2nd times invaded Bhutan but failed in 2017;
---Tried to invade Maldives in 2018;
---Invaded Nepal and one of its soldiers was shot dead by Nepal Security force in 2020;
---Keeps nibbling lands from ChinaTibett and Kashmir that led to a war in 1962 and border conflicts
with China till today;
---Keeps nibbling lands from Pakistan Kashmir that led to daily border wars and gun fights;
and more…..
Peter Riley Earlier India extended from Pakistan to Myanmar..Kashmir to Kanyakumari..we have lost much of our land for formation of these Countries..so swallowed is an inappropriate term..Reclaiming its land is a better term.
Nepal is unconditionally claimed in No documents.
Different countries are trying to suppress india but will not, we , india are the fastest growing country.
Don't be jeleous.
India in 1962 (PM Jahawar Lal Neheru): Hey Nepal! (To the Monarchy) we are fighting a war with China and since your military presence in Kalapani and nearby bordering area is minimal, can we station around there for the period of war to monitor Chinese movement?
Nepal: Sure, we have the best of relations and if it helps in your defense, why not?
India: Thank you. we are establishing 18 military camps in Nepali land bordering China.
Nepal in 1969: Hey bro! the war is already finished but your camps are still around, could you withdraw your forces?
India: Okay! (removes 17 posts, but remains in Kalapani and controls Lipulekh area because it is strategically too significant to monitor China)
Nepal: Kalapani?
India: (to then King) Don't forget you are economically too dependent on us, also we can seize you from power by using the revolutionary forces. You remain quiet, you aren't using that area anyway.
Nepal after democracy in 1990: Hey bro! now we are a democratic nation and we now have access to historical evidences and facts, could you withdraw the army and settle the issue as the land is on the east side of river Kali?
India (Prime ministers Indra Kumar Gujral and Atal Bihari Bajpayee): Okay! lets solve this and all other pending border issues with the help from border Experts. (Expert: Joint Border Committee) reach on agreement in 98% border area except Susta and Kalapani area, recommend it be settled on high political level, remains an outstanding issue)
India in 2015: Hey China, wanna trade from Lipulekh and make Mansarovar quickly accessible?
China: Okay!
Nepal: But it's our sovereign territory and we have been claiming it all along with our evidences? (sends diplomatic protest to New Delhi and Beijing both). Hey! bro, (to India) let's solve the issue first among us before any agreement with the third party.
China Upon receiving the diplomatic note sent by Government of Nepal: Its ok!, If its Nepal's territory then we will rethink on the Trade agreement with India.
India: Ok then, No official visit for your PM Koirala (first time a Nepali PM does not make an official visit to India) and India imposes an inhumane economic blockade in the tough times of Devastating earthquake of 7 Richter scale in Nepal.
India in Novemeber 2019: Cashing the great opportunity when Nepal was totally devastated and ruined by the natural disaster, New Political map released (8th edition) with Kali river marked well inside it's territory when it should be a border.
Nepal: Yo bro! You say East of Kali is Nepal but it is well inside your territory on the map?
India: Oops! (9th edition is quickly released with river's name erased)
Nepal: Let's solve it with foreign secretary level talks, there is pressure from general public after the blockade. This way the relation is only getting worse.
India: We don't care! you are too dependent on us. (Inaugurates the road during Covid-19 pandemic, despite the construction not being completed and with presence of high level Military and Defense personnel)
Nepal: Kalapani and Lipulekh region are ours, then how could you built a road in the Nepali territories without even asking for a permission or informing us?? Stop it!
India: Come on Nepal! We are like Brothers, isn't it?? And if it helps us to earn huge amount of money through religious holy pilgrimage to Mansarovar Kaislash then why not build a black topped road there?? Although 35 Kms of the road still completely lies within your territory. But, why you shout deliberately let us rape your motherland in the name of trade route and religious Pilgrimage route. You know one thing, Nepal?? China is a Dragon it will capture your nation...Be aware! and forget our rape on your sovereignty. After all, we are like Brothers, No??
Nepal: Come on! Get matured now. At least dare to sit down and talk with us before doing things unilaterally!
Indian Army chief: China has made Nepal speak.
Indian Media: Nepal ki ye aukat ki wo India ko aankh dikhaye, Inhe fir blockade karna chahiye!
Indian Government (Rajnath Singh) to Nepal: We will sit for talk with you all only when the Pandemic of Covid19 gets over. Until then no talks regarding the border issue, got it??
*(In the mean time, India and China has a border conflict at Laddakh region)*
India then humbly & quietly sits for a diplomatic talk with China during the Pandemic of COVID19. (Clearly a Double Standard shown by India)
Nepal: Ok then we'll pass our issue our own map in the Parliament including the disputed territory ( it will address public outrage due to India's consistent "Big Brotherly attitude")
Indian Media followed by the Indian People: China, China, China, China!
ruclips.net/video/vgJP5EheY5o/видео.html
Thanks for your contribution
@@SubeeKarma This is not only contribution but facts mentioned to counter India's fake claim on Nepalese territory. There are other more than 120 strong evidences which proves the land to be Nepalese but including them all will make it lengthy so shortened the dialogue screenplay! Thank you that you took your precious time to calmly read & reply.
No MCC.
You have put effort on making this video but many information are wrong.
@@Sandesh.1994 Nepal puppet of China.🐕🐕🐕
I met lot of Indian people here in USA . They don’t know about nepal. Even they don’t know northeast India.
@@naturalist9448 India is democracy of 1.3 billion population., any simple individual don't travel the whole country., Since ur in the USA., Have u been to all 50 states?
Purandar Shetty stfu when Nepal was in Asia . There was not any country called india.(puppet of America)
Your documentation is very good. I am supporting your channel from 2019. I found your videos are very interesting but this video lacks many information like Shree Pach Maharaj Diraj Mahamahim Sarkar Shree Mahendra Bir Bikram shah dev (king of Nepal Mahendra Bir Bikram shah ) had good relation with India and he gave permit to the Indian soldiers to petrol in the disputed areas and British tricked Nepal also for it(sugauli treaty) and the two countries are waiting for the pandemic to be over and do the negotiation. The country's politics is that the pushpa kamal dhahal (prachanda) is the one who killed 17000 people in Nepal so he just want prime minster's post. Nepal's citizens have supported the government in this step in Kalapani, lipulekh and limpyadhura and the new map was also passed with full majority in Nepal's parliament. So, none is the dirty politics done by china. And just remember that we have shared our blood with your soldiers in many wars in support of India so you cannot speak what you want (to the Indian media).
@Subrat lamichhane what had nepal government done when china captured the lands of its villages. It's simply clear and evident that it is controlled by communist party of china
@@Sandesh.1994 you fool we kicked british out of sub continent not like nepal who is slave of china
@@Sandesh.1994 Better don't give lame excuses man. If nepal waited for pandemic to end then why have it ignited and broken the friendly relations with India which has its 64 % revenue from India trade ports. For truth India doesn't acquire any countries land , we only protect our sovereignty. We never captured nepal territory. It's obvious nepal can't wait till end of pandemic to held talks with India ,but it can wait for china . It's clear that nepal government is dancing on China's moves. Nepal government must understand that they are doing on the basis of china which does not treat its people as human beings and has disputes with every country. Come on I think you need some dareness to speak truth than some almonds.
@@ridicolousfish218 Language please.
We don't talk to anybody like this. And Nepal is our brother.
Hey Bisbo, lovely work but as an Indian I feel like this only shows our side of the story. If I have learned anything, it’s that there are two sides to a story. I think you should also speak about what Nepal believes in this
You are right.
Nepal's act is merely a stunt.
Kalapani is Rightfully Uttarakhand's and republic of India's territory.
The song has been wrongly translated.
It says " It is our's kalapani, lipilekh and limpiyadhura too"
No mention of wake up, brave people
India played a good role in changing power in Malaysia,maldives now it's turn of Nepal.
Was desperately waiting for Bisbo's view in this matter
_Proud To Be Nepali
7:00 Indian mainstream media won't tell you this
But bisbo will,
Well done neighbour👏
Kudos for being as unbiased as possible
Sure, we have to give Nepal's view as well
@@BisboWorld 9:20
If so India sent RAW chief to have ( so far )classified and mysterious meeting with KP Oli, which is against protocol. The meeting was not even covered by media and everything has been quietly kept a secret. Meeting foreign ambassador is nothing wrong, Indian and American ambassadors do it way more often than Chinese.
@@BisboWorld
To be bluntly honest with you. We Nepalese and our foreign policy does not care about problems among our neighbours or their internal problems. India and China, India and Pakistan, China and USA,etc. May have problems with each other but it isn't our thing to bother about. That's why Nepalese summitted Mount K2, that's why we have relations established with both Koreas on same day,etc. And yes, as someone mentioned we get triggered when someone views us as Naive and gullible. Yes, we have population and area smaller than a lot of states of India or China but we are a sovereign country in top 50 of world population and top 100 of area.
I am just amazed and impressed with your teams creativity .. such serious issues explained in simple terms. The simplicity yet detailed. Thanks for making these.
I am from nepal and watch hindi channels a lot and love indians..I Dont want dispute between Nepal and India..But what to do..
Hey I don't want to hurt your feelings but I just want to ask, how do your people feel about Oli right now?
@@4ltrz555 well he did good job bring alot of medicine, fuel etc from china in 2015 otherwise million of people would have died due to lack of medicine.
@@naulojankari5841 you nail it bro😂😂
@@4ltrz555 🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵If you indian want to know truth why KP oli going against India... Nepal & India had many unresolved issues and problems since decades ..No nepali PM had the guts to raise & question the Indian government since decades... Now KP oli got full support from China so these past border & many other issues was highlighted in present times... India has always been ignoring the Nepali concerns so this that to erupt someday....This major issues not shown by biased Indian media to indian public.... Nepali loves indian people & culture but hates indian politics...Indian goverment should seriously address Nepali concerns and issues to minimize the anti indian sentiments in Nepal... India has lots most of its ally neighbours Pakistan, China, Bangladesh,Maldives and even Bhutan. THINK ABOUT IT....
BHUTAN STOP FREE VISA TO INDIA BUT NEPAL GIVE FREE VISA TO INDIA ruclips.net/video/4QcAOv6pvsw/видео.html
Ok, let keep Kalapani issue away for a while.But I will honestly ask you few questions.
1) Why this new map is passed when there this Corona Pandemic and India-China tension on galwan valley.
2) Why is Nepali Government not questioning China over its hijacking of villages of Nepal.
3) Why is Mr. Oli's Government saved by Chinese ambassador by meeting with his opposition leaders.
4) Why Nepal's Respected PM giving Anti-India statement like Corona virus came from India is more dangerous than China .
5)Why the new citizenship act has been passed as government was knowing that Maveshis were culturally connected between both nation.
5) Why he made useless statement over Lord Ram that ayodhya is fake in Indai. His intentions was just to bring the rift between nepalese and Indians by simply saying to his people that no need to go India for worship of God we have our separat Ayodhya.
Sorry to say but I am not saying that Nepali people are influenced by China but your Government seems to be highly influenced by China. If they really wanted to solve this issue diplomatically then why they are making such hateful and racists comments. Sorry to say but your communist party just want to create hate between Hindus of India and Nepal. And what you are saying that threat of economic sanction was not given by Indian government it was given by our Media and don't take our Media seriously. You can watch some good channels like print and NDTV
If kalapani region is strategically important for india, Nepal should be offered land in other areas along india-nepal border. Similar to the land swap deal with Bangladesh.
I do not write comment on videos that I watch, but for this video I am made to smile with funny charaterization such as raise of eyebrows and flexing of muchles by Nepali leader. You are creative provide insightful knowledge. Hugely appreciate it.
It ll not solve untill Oli is in power, no matter our PM ll remain as modi or any one of his place, but those who is aligned with China cannot be our friend . The China who already claimed many of nepalese land and also captured it.
11:39 Consider those efforts done. The Nepali Congress Has taken over and Sher Bahadur Deuba Controls Nepal
When you make the videos : forget you are indian , just think you are just a youtube blogger and do proper research then you can make fair videos.
fact1- Kali river position is same. Rivers position can be changed by few meters. you saying its moved 18 km from its original position hahhaa. fact2 - Its is not the first time , 2nd time, 3rd time or 4th time. Its been so many times we have raised this kalapani issue. Its not only raised in kp oli's time.
fact3: If you dont know anything then don't insert third country. its not and it was not ever about china and your bullshit. Its the only issues between nepal and india. We nepalese people just claiming our land. Nothing else.
fact4: India is showing his villain character to Nepal as every powerful country or every powerful people does.
fact5: its all about power vs truth. But it looks like power wins in todays world. Power has the voice. No one can listen the voice of countries like philistines, syria their people. But every one can listen the voce of countries like USA, UK, india etc.....
fact6: Indian media and indian gov, please dont take it personally. But its worst and because of that many countries do not like india not only us.
Hello from Nepal. It was a very well researched report. Far better than Indian news channels. Kudos to that. But just check the satellite image, It clearly shows Kali river originating from Limpiyadhura, which gives the decision in favor of Nepal.
Biased news report.
Love your videos.
Keep up the great work
Looks like India's 2019 abrogation of article 370 changing the legal status of Ladakh has been a motivator for China and Nepal to produce their own territorial maps. This article 370 abrogation should have been handled in a much better way
Big country or small country doesn't matter. Every country is a sovereign state and due regard / respect should be given for friendly relationships .
Why does the indian government always have border disputes with its most neighbours ? Lipulekh & Kalapani are the nepalase teritorries. Why they are still there? They should feel ashamed, if they are a good neighbour.
The question is, why all our neighbours have a border dispute with us? Why is it so important to have a piece of our land? What is so special about India??
And the answer is, India is the doorway to international trade.... We control the Indian Ocean.
Our soliders didn’t surrender
Our governments did because of their selfishness and greed
In the early 19th century, the East India Company (EIC) that was ruling India began expanding its territories and reached northwards near Nepal. Soon after, on November 1, 1814, a war broke out with the Nepali side.
In 1815, the British general Sir David Ochterlony managed to evict the Nepali soldiers from Garhwal and Kumaon. A year later, the war came to an end with the Sugauli Treaty.
In October-November 1962, the Sino-Indian war broke out. The same year, then Indian Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru wrote a personal letter to the then Nepali King Mahendra requesting the latter to let the retreating India Army stay temporarily in an open area in Kalapani.
India’s encroachment on Lipulekh, another area in the region, first came to light during the Panchayat period, but no effort was made for negotiations. There are no records in Nepal to suggest that these demarcations were done jointly between the British East India Company and Nepal.
King Mahendra is blamed for allowing Indian troops into Kalapani after the 1962 India-China war, at India’s request, even though there are no official records or statements substantiating the blame. According to foreign affairs expert Bhek Bahadur Thapa, King Mahendra never gave written permission but had planned to take up this issue with India when the war ended, but he never came to it.
India and China agreed even as far back as 1954 to allow Indian pilgrims to Kailash Mansarovar to use the Lipulekh pass.
The shifting of the international boundary based on changes in the course of a mountain river does not hold water, literally. Even if these changes in the course of the river were depicted in the maps published by the Survey of India during British rule, they cannot be used as a reference in deciding the international border.
But, in November 2019, India included the disputed area in its official map, the region east of Lipu Khola as a part of its territory. Later, Indian Defence Minister Rajnath Singh inaugurated the Indian road via the disputed tri-junction of Nepal, India and China. These events brought the Kalapani dispute to a new height, and Nepal also retaliated by amending its constitution to include the disputed region on its map also.
The Background music is disturbing like anything.
Stop that,
Your content is very informative, but that background music is destroying the entire video.
Noted
If they are giving 7 years of wait for citizenship. India should also do to the same. Why India continues to distribute citizenship to them..
You deserved way more subscribers
Thank you
Nepal would not take such measures until they are backed by China. This is a sinister move by China to undermine Indian's influence over the region.
Dear Writer,
Government of China spreading its shadow. another side, India is trying to keep Nepal as its child without leaving to grow continuously.
Geographically your nation is bordering around China and India ,and will be used your ground for their games..
Nepal should first return to India Janakpur - the birthplace of Sita
.However
we Indians would always remain indebted to the brave soldiers of Nepal
who have even made supreme sacrifices to protect India - Jaya
Mahakali Ayo Gorkhali.
Very Nice video Presntation and voice Modulation ..Keep ur good work going
Thanks Satish
Bisbo I really like and love your animation with your Excellent research. The mixture of both becomes a amazing video. Bisbo can you please tell me which animating software do you use for animating your amazing and fabulous videos. Anyway love your work.
Love and support from Nepal 🇳🇵
I hope Nepal finds sense and doesn't jeopardize relations with India
Tell that to your GODI MEDIA, they are humiliating Nepal and now they targeting Bhutan also.
finds sense? as in what? being afraid of India just because it's bigger and stronger?
@@naulojankari5841 hooollldddd up no one is targeting Bhutan here.. it's china who r encroaching on Bhutan relax
@@yte4770 he never said that
@@shja0111 what about you media saying that Bhutan is blocking water flow in india. We helped you to stop water flow but you are just bulling us. Even assam minister told Bhutan is helping india, but your godi media has spreaded fake news. No wonder why Nepal, Maldives, Bangladesh are angry with India.
I belongs to Dharchula bro whatever you have said through this video. Everything is correct yr specially anti Indian song. And no network coverage.
What Anti Indian Song, That Song Says Lets Go Fishing In Kalapani (Machi - Fish, Marna - Fishing, Jauna - Lets Go, Kalapani Ma - In Kalapani) 👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼
Some points that educated Nepalese understand...
- Nepal and India r both Hindu majority sharing common culture & way of life.
-nepal & India r two countries but one nation.
-china is only using Nepal to hurt india. Nepal means nothing to china. China is d most deceitful nation.
-india acts as a deterrent for Chinese forces. Without india, Nepal will share d same fate as Tibet, Taiwan, HK, Xinjiang.
-Nepal is a landlocked country & depends on india for survival.
-India has always given preferential treatment to Nepal, be it in trade&commerce, financial assistance.
-India has time & again proven its frindship. Physical & monetary assistance during natural calamities, providing essentials & relief materials.
-India continues to provide technical expertise & funds for development projects, infrastructure, temples.
-India hosts millions of Nepalese providing them jobs, settlements, life of dignity.
-Millions of Nepalese hav also made india their home and r now Indian citizens enjoying all rights and privileges under d constitution.
-By way of remittances, Nepalese expats in india r d biggest contributor to Nepal's economy. Even Nepalese working outside India go abroad using Indian work visa.
-Nepal communist govt is destroying d very fabric of Nepalese society, & hence is unpopular even among Nepalese public.
-For communists, power comes from d barrel of d gun, & not from its citizens.
-India has not much to gain from its impoverished & tiny neighbours. But India continues to help & assist them.
-Indians hav for centuries been subjugated & persecuted. India knows d feeling of being at d receiving end.
-India has & always will stand by it's neighbours, through d bad times through d gud times.
-whether kalapani goes to India or Nepal, it will still remain within d family.
Everyone playing nationalist card
Bisbo, great limerick, but a small grammatical error on the last line. Not "a relationship have scarred" but "has scarred". On a separate note, your themes lately are a bit too political and grave. Hope you will mix the shows with lighter, more entertaining subjects.
Yes right. We did 2 Bollywood vids one on IPL but poor response. BS-IV did well though
lots of information are false. holes Nepali are fighting for their land which are earned by their grandparents. India are not allowed to do this kind of activities to Nepal
editing and animation is good but your presentation on blockade on nepal side by indian government on 2015 and this border dispute issue is not satisfactory .
Noted Satish
Localities living near the broaders are facing actual problem while people in center are playing political card.
We don't about what India said but the kalapani is belong to Nepal and it's true and proud to be Nepali with the new map of Nepal is right 🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵👏👏 good job ! Now nepal government time to teach indian government governments
China ki god mein Jake khel tu
Dear friend before blogging plz find the real truth fact and it’s work good you even don’t know the truth...
go and read all the british documents regarding these borders. they are available on internet. instead of reading what china wants you to, go and find something authentic.
@@sagarkothari5218 Nepal is claiming Limpiyadhura, Lipulek, Kalapani, Gunji, Tinkar, Tinkar Bhanjyang on the basis of a factual incidence of Treaty of Sugauli signed between Nepal and East India Company in 1816 A.D. Due to the Treaty, Nepal lost its one third of its total territory to East India Company. In the Treaty of Sugauli it has been clearly mentioned that the banks of MAHAKALI(KALI) river which originates from the LIMPIYADHURA marks the boundary (Border) or Line of Control (LOC) between the two countries Nepal and India. In the Treaty of Sugauli it has been clearly mentioned that all the territories on the EASTERN BAND (Not the western as said in the video) of the Mahakali River will be Nepal (that includes, Limpiyadhura, Lipulek, Kalapani, Gunji, Tinkar, Tinkar Bhanjyang & many other small places in between)
Also, please watch this video to understand the issue better.
ruclips.net/video/vgJP5EheY5o/видео.html
@@truthspeaker5628 but east india company is not India and right now you are sharing border with India. None the less I love nepali people. Simple and honest. I wish this dispute is settled and India Nepal friendship goes on..
@@trynaru Now you caught the exact point. India is not the East India Company that is why we are saying that India doesn't have any rights to talk over Sugauli Treaty,, its provisions or interpret them. India can only do two things either keep the Sugauli Treaty alive or declare it to be Void. If it declares the Treaty to be void then the lost territories (one-third) because of the Sugauli Treaty will be returned to Nepal as per the Treaty (Just like British returned HongKong to China).
OR India can keep the Treaty alive and move according to the provisions mentioned in the Treaty. And the Treaty says it Loudly and Clearly that those encroached territories belongs to Nepal.
India asked for permission from the Monarchy of Nepal to keep the Indian army for a temporary period and since there was political disturbances in Nepal throughout Nepal couldn't raise the voice about those regions. Even though soon after democracy was prevailed in Nepal in 1990, Government of Nepal did had a talk with Indian Prime Ministers Indra Kumar Gujral in 1997 and with Indian Prime Minister Atal Vihari Bajpayee in 2000 A.D. And with Indian Prime Minister Narendra Damodar Modi regarding those regions and each one of them agreed that those regions are disputed territories and they need to be addressed holding the Diplomatic talks. But in 2019 India moved unilaterally and forcefully to include the disputed territories in Indian map for the first time in the history. Monarchy of Nepal had only permitted to keep Indian army in Kalapani regions but not to include Nepalese territories in Indian map. Nepal helped thinking India as a good neighbor but India turned out to become a Dragron which engulfed Nepalese territories in a complete daylight. The most funny thing is that India is hesitating to sit for a diplomatic talk blaming the COVID19 pandemic but in the same pandemic situation India went to hold a meeting with China regarding Laddakh and most recently with Bangladesh as well but not with Nepal. India says itself big brother of Nepal but doesn't give any value and respect to Nepal and its sovereignty. Neither India has talked or showed its evidences that proves those territories belong to them. Nepal has more than 120 evidences other than the most vital Sugauli Treaty. Whereas India only says that it is under the control of India from last 70 years forgetting how Indian army came to settle in Kalapani and who permitted them to settle down there in a temporary basis.
This kind of behavior and attitude is going to take India nowhere. No matter Indian people hate or love Nepal and its people, Indian Government should take an appropriate step to solve this issue which was started by India itself. Moreover, it should respect sovereignty of Nepal at a practical level. India and Nepal holds such a bond that can't be seen entire the globe. It is an example to the global community but India should understand this and move in an affirmative manner. I hope you watched the video link that I had included in the previous comment because it contains the factual incidences.
@@truthspeaker5628 and your take on land grab by China?... Where posts were Shifted?..
Oli is a communist and has been honey trapped. Clearly, either he is being forced to take certain steps or is getting money for going against India. Any Nepali citizen can see that these recent acts are counter-productive to both
Just to appease China, Nepal is willing to worsen ties with both India and United States. Seriously the selfishness of this Nepali PM is gonna cost the country big time
kalapani limpiyadhura and lipulekh matter:
There was a village living 3 neighbors A, B, C
one day a family member of A became ill and A needed to go to take care of that family member
Being a good neighbor B says to A: don't worry I will take care of your house in your absence until you came back, you take care of your ill family member but in return, you have to allow me to use your house since I am taking care of it .
Since B used to be a good neighbor A trusted B and allow to B to use his house
Slowly time passes by year and year it takes a quite long time for A to treat his family member and to return back.
One day when the ill member gets recovered, A wanted to return back to his own home.
when A comes back he understands that B is claiming A's house as his sole property and B and C wanted to use it for the benefit of B and C
when A urges and defends suddenly, B claims to A: no this is mine now, you cannot claim this as yours, you don't have any right authority as well as the power to claim this house .
Who is the real owner now ?
So why indian gov is running away from sitting for dilouge
we dont repond to threats and provocations. You want to talk, first be civil and stop your anti india rhetoric
We have no time to talk , nepal is a communist country controlled by china
India is running because they don't have any prove to call their land . Its Simple
'Loser have many reasons' so they will start making excuses
Amit Tun poonz : you are right my friend.
@@ridicolousfish218 nepal is not a communist country. it is a federal democratic republic country. Little knowledge is dangerous brother. Only the ruling party is communist but we are not controlled by any country. The only problem is we are landlock and we have to relay on someone for import and export. Indian news channel like aajtak and republic ( arnab ) will tell you that nepal is puppet of china and doing this by Chinese order but realistically we think kalapani is a part of nepal so we common people were in strike to pressure government to talk with indian government about kalapani and other disputed land.
Great and very informative video 💯
I would like to request Bisbo to update more and more current affairs which is really helping in shaping one's knowledge.... Love from Nagaland ❤
Sure 👍 and thanks
It was good video bisbo. Will be waiting for your more videos.
More to come!
the animation is just tooooo good .. this channel is sooooo underrated 😭😭😭😭😭😭
Thank you Faizeeeeeeeee
I want some honest feedback from Nepali people. Is the presence of Indian army hindering daily life of Nepali people in the region? Specially when we have a open border? I mean to say, couldn't this just be considered as an Indian army outpost there? And it's not that we are using that land for drilling or mining resources..it's just a road which even Nepali can use for going to Yatra. Would like to hear from the other side. Because honestly it feels bad to be in argument with someone we consider our brother and sister state.
I mean it is not hindering us anything! But it is also not the right way to be done!!
If India have respected our sovereignty, it would have been much appreciated!!
30.2223818, 80.9099745
Check on this coordinates and see how India is threatening our soverenity by making road inside Nepals territory which India didnt ever claimed!!
It is not a good to quarrel in this situation but national soverenity is a thing!!
Galwan valley is also not useful to India but why Indian armies are sacrificing their lives there? You know the answer and same is for us too!!
Kim Yo Jong you guys were under British for years and u guys have so much love for your country ,then we are independent from beginning think how much we love our country.
I understand what you are saying, but the way we see it in India, Nepal is always a part of India( not a part in the way China claims-like something to be annexed eventually) . We see Nepal and Nepali people as part of Greater Indian history and culture. And the British occupation part, as far as I can remember Nepalese King was also defeated by British , they just didn't annex Nepal into British to keep a buffer zone with china. Other than that there's not much difference to the British between kingdom of Bengal or kindgom of Nepal. And that's self evident the way both of our older generations view each other. If you ask any grandma and grandpa in India what or where is nepal, they may not be able to tell you much in detail but they will say that always Nepal is in India or Nepalese are just like another ethnicity like Bengali, Marwari, Malayalam, Punjabi etc etc. That's the level of connection. I'm pretty sure I saw some video on RUclips where I say the same sentiments from old generation of Nepal.
I'm hoping this bad time will pass and Nepal and India will once again become peaceful coexisting neighbours. Because internal fighting will only lead to others exploiting and taking advantage of both of us.
@@Rizu-kc3ze The nepali king was defeated but the resistance by the Gurkha fighters was fierce. That's why Nepal was not annexed.
And when you say Nepal is in India it sounds dominating. Nepal is sovereign and independent nation.
Just because they have raised issues in the past doesn't mean that they were just..duh
India should respect to Sugauli Treaty 1816 between Nepal and British India. According to the Treaty, Nepal's western Border is Kalee River that flows from Limpiyadhura where Biggest tribut to Kalee River starts from and this tribut was called Kalee River in the MAP during the treaty signing time. India manipulated the river, Renamed the river, and rebuilt new Kalee River and new Kalee temple artificially in order to annex Nepalese Territory. India Should feel ashamed of it. Leave Nepalese territories and BACK OF INDIA. It is NOTHING to do with any other country but it is about Nepal's DIGNITY and SOVEREIGNTY. Nepal let India to use that territory during/after India- China War 1962 as a Friend. But India BETRAYED NEPAL ignoring to leave the Nepalese Territory since a long time. India ignored many time of Nepal's request. Nepal has border dispute with India, not only in Kalapani and Susta but 23 of 26 Nepalese districts that touches to India have border problem with India. SHAME ON YOU INDIA. There are two different of Nepalese who work in India. Nepalese origin Indian citizens who are from the territories when Nepal LOST to British India and Now these territories are in India. If you do not want these people, you must return all Nepalese territories that Nepal lost to British India but NOT to India because these territories have been occupied by India illegally because British India should have left these territories to Nepal but not to India. Another thing is, of course, Nepalese Citizens who work in India according to free movement between Nepal and India, there is also many INDIAN CITIZENS who works in Nepal too. India gets much more remittance money from Nepal than Nepal gets remittance money from India. It is NOT Nepal's interest to have free movement between India and Nepal because India has 1.3 Billion and Nepal has 29 millions. who will benefits most when there is free movement ??? Another thing is Nepal was NOT part of British India if you do not have any free movement between India and Bangladesh and Pakistan because you guys were parts of British India. THEN, WHY SHOULD THERE BE FREE MOVEMENT BETWEEN NEPAL AND INDIA ACCORDING TO NEPAL AND INDIA FRIENDSHIP TREATY 1950??? WE CALL IT VERY UNBALANCED TREATY THAT SHOULD BE NULLIFIED AS SOON AS POSSIBLE. SAME TREATY NULLIFIED THE SUGAULI TREATY 1816, WHY HAS INDIA BEEN KEEPING NEPALESE TERRITORIES THAT LOST TO BRITISH INDIA ??? If India does not respect to the Treaty 1816, India MUST leave all territories which Nepal LOST to British India. These territories includes Darjeeling, Kumao and Gadhawal and etc. What do you think ?
Oli already sold Nepal to China..
To much biased .Totally one sided narration. Dhruv Rathi analysis was way better.
Why is this awesome channel still not popular?
We Hate Indian's 😤😤👿 Media Nonsense Topic ,Nepal is always Good Sense Good People and Brave ❤️🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵Jay Nepal Jay Gorkhali ✊✊✊✊✊✊
Some infamous debt trapped nations by china
1)Sri Lanka have to give Hambantota Port
2)Kenya have to give Mombasa Port
3) Pakistan is giving Gawadar Port
4) Montenegro
5) Maldives
6)Dibouti
China invest heavily in small countries infrastructure and later demand interest for their investment which they cannot pay and have to give their land to china.
China invest so much that a country have to pay china by giving their land.
Now china is turning to Nepal.
Just Check The citizenship act of India. It is said to have 7 years time interval in India too. Then What is THE PROBLEM ? Nepal have a Sovereign RIGHT TO Decide it's law. Although International Standard is 5 years of permanent staying in the country in order to get the citizenship of the country.
Anyone who is actually interested in Geographical history in depth..... Can watch videos of
Drishti IAS
U won't end up fighting for sure 😂
Bhai itna effort dala video banane ke liye but why u didn't try to add historical evidence???
Nepal to india : Hey India , if you don't give us our territory back , we will war against you
India to nepal : Hold my beer 🍺
i dont think anyone of sound mind in nepal wants war sir
i hope these two friendly country find a diplomatic solution to their problems