VVIP chopper scandal. How kickbacks happen in defence deals
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 сен 2024
- #ChristianMichel the key middleman in the #AgustaWestland VVIP #chopperscandal was recently extradited from Dubai. He forms the key link between several accused, one of whom is a former IAF chief. How and why were the helicopters were ordered? How the running away of an Emirati princess led to Michel's extradition and what are the facts about the case in this detailed investigative report by Bisbo. And yes...stay for the limerick right at the end.
Sources:
------------
Economic Times
Julie Tyagi, Italian middleman were close; Raghav Ohri; Feb 19, 2019
#VVIP chopper case: Rajiv Saxena ‘agrees’ to become approver; Raghav Ohri; Feb 14, 2019
Michel made to write answers in won handwriting; Jan 7, 2019
22 days, info not coming easy from ‘cold’ Michel; Raghav Ohri; Dec 26, 2018
Had access to internal UPA meetings says Michel’s letter; Dec 25, 2018
Michel’s claim of paying E6m to cos/individuals for consultancy false, claim CBI; Raghav Ohri; Dec 21, 2018
PwC found serious deviations says CBI; Raghav Ohri; Dec 20, 2019
Times of India
Lens on Michel role in UPA stalling Rafale deal; Pradeep Thakur; Mar 4, 2019
Augusta accused gets bail, 24x7 security from ED; Aamir Khan; Feb 25, 2019
No chargesheet filed, give bail: Middleman Michel tells Delhi court; Feb 9, 2019
India got Michel from Dubai in exchange for sending Princess Latifa? Naomi Canton; Jan 16, 2019
CBI finds docs establishing 54m euros payment to Michel; Neeraj Chauhan; December 31, 2018
NDTV:
How India Scored Christian Michel's Extradition: The Ajit Doval Project; December 5, 2018; Nidhi Razdan, Neeta Sharma
The Guardian :
Escape From Dubai: The Mystery of the Missing Princess review - a shocking tale of complicity and betrayal; Rebecca Nicholson; December 6, 2018
Missing Emirati princess 'planned escape for seven years’; Emma Graham- Harrison December 4, 2018
New York Times
Video offers clues to mysterious disappearance of Princess Latifa; Feb 12, 2019
The Week:
Gone with the wings; Namrata Bibi Ahuja; December 25, 2016
Business Standard:
ED issues order to attach Paris property of Michel’s ex-wife, PTI; Mar 12, 2019
ED attached Rs8.4 crore assets of Gautam Khaitan in black money case; PTI, Mar 12, 2019
Govt scraps AgustaWestland chopper deal; Ajai Shukla; January 2, 2014
The Hindu:
Former IAF Chief Tyagi refutes bribe allegation; Chopper deal has makings of a second Bofors scam, says BJP; February 13, 2013
Charge sheet says €100,000 given to Tyagi brother; Vaiju Naravane; February 16, 2013
ED zeroes in on Michel’s contacts; Devesh K Pandey; May 1, 2016
AgustaWestland VVIP helicopter deal: Middleman Christian James Michel extradited to India; December 4, 2018
Stuff:
Runaway princess 'swapped' for British arms dealer
January 14, 2019; Saptarish Ray
Bisbo's other related stories:
--------------------------------------
What next in Kashmir? • What next in Kashmir?
Lack of transparency in the Rafale fighter jet's deal gives rise to conspiracy theories: • Lack of transparency i...
Doklam standoff: 1 year since the Doklam crisis: • Doklam standoff: 1 yea...
Can India's S-400 triumf missile purchase from Russia result in American sanctions? • How India managed to r...
What next for the Iran Nuclear Deal? Why Trump junked it: • What next for the Iran...
Bisbo's Limerick:
---------------------
Don't forget to watch Bisbo's Limerick at the end of each video, that neatly sums up the topic.
Follow #Bisbo on Twitter:
--------------------------------
@GoBisbo
Disclaimer
The videos uploaded on this channel are a dramatised / caricatured version of real events based on sources (news or otherwise) and / or other information and data freely available in the public domain. Artistic liberties may have been taken with respect to dialogue bubbles; however, the content includes edited versions of actual words spoken, re-worded for space and time constraints but good faith conveying the intended meaning or assumed words spoken. We compile and use information freely available in the public domain and from credible news media organisations to the best of our knowledge. The links of all such sources from which information has been gathered to create the videos is provided in the description section to ensure transparency.
The views and opinions expressed in such videos do not necessarily represent those of Bisbo. Therefore, Bisbo cannot be held liable and / or responsible in any manner for the accuracy or reliability of the data and / or information gathered from external sources, databases, etc.
The videos uploaded on this channel are only for informative purposes; are an expression of data on a fair bona fide interpretation; and are not in any manner aimed at derogating and / or offending any person, entity or thing.
The viewer confirms that he / she is accessing the channel and watching this video after fully understanding and appreciating the provisions of this Disclaimer.
I feel sad for the Bisbo Team. They are unbaised and talk about both sides. However, when they are exposing Congress - they are termed as BJP supporters. When they expose BJP - They are termed as Congress supporters. There’s just no pleasing anyone, lol.
How true, like you are are a "loner"! lol
Well, being accused by both sides of being biased is indicator that bisbo is unbiased
Your right bro I also commented on his previous video that he is Congress IT cell but after seeing his all videos I m ashmed on my comment 😶😶
Manoj very heartening to read your comment. Only the courageous can say those words.
Kaihtheloner bisbo is a BJP supporter for sure his team is biased in every way ,his video on Rafael doesn't depict many facts also it looks like bisbo was trying not to state them !!! I haven't labelled bisbo yet but surely bjp propaganda is some what incorporated in bisbos work!!!
Why Italy, Gandhi, Rahul and Congress name comes in the History of Indian Scams !?
Man, you are the most underrated animator/news reporter I have ever seen, with the amount of the work you do, you can easily surpass vox and vice
Thanks Vatsal...your words inspire Team Bisbo to continue on their journey.
vatsal I agree with you on terms of bisbos work but not on ethics !!!
@@kamineniprabhu6411 why?
@@vatsalsrivastav5175 well everybody has freedom of speech so bisbos using it which is good but I don't believe in what ever bisbo shows me because I feel his videos are somewhat biased and some of them tweaked in order to convince wrong in to right so i am not going to fall for a screen propaganda
@@kamineniprabhu6411 well, I have no prior knowledge about most of the topics bisbo talks about so I get my first impression from his videos only
Ajit Doval - take a bow sir. You are brilliant. Nobody could've pulled off that deal with UAE but you! Truly brilliant quid pro quid. Modi govt is insanely tough on these scamsters who had their run in previous govts of Gandhis.
Really? by giving up n innocent girl? you call this brilliant?
@@TChowdhury00 It is a diplomatic move. If that girl with that kind of family is not safe in her own country with powerful rulers - they can get her anywhere in world. It would be very stupid to strain the diplomatic ties with UAE merely because a girl wanted to feel free lol.. diplomacy has no place for individual emotions. Millions of lives are at stake and diplomats cater to that. If India had refused, UAE has 70% Indian expats, it could have done any policy change to make them suffer. Do not be immature in your thinking.
@@deadnlovingit So it okay to harm a innocent persons life in the name of diplomacy? anyways you will continue to give this so called, in name of the country excuse but you accept it or not.
So you will decide what is good for that person? Just like today Patrol is priced at 100 with n excuse of development!!
@@TChowdhury00what innonect girl ?
She is one daughter and has no responsibility of India's govt
Had she taken permission from India before coming??
The Italian prince is now
In Italy 🇮🇹 stashing the Antonio’s looted money 💰
Quality content! I never comment, like, share on RUclips but this Channel made me do it.
Wow, thanks Karan
She was the daughter of the King still she tried to run away. She had the best of lives still she wanted to start a fresh. It is absolutely false that The Princess Exagerated her problems. She wanted freedom from her fathers cruelity thats why she ran away
Yes, it is important to solve corruption cases by any means so that the big ones can be exposed but is it right to send back a women facing oppression in such Islamist country escaping to India on the hope of finding peace.
Yesh Pandey sad...
We, India had to send her back anyway, its a smart way and win win situation.
else she would have been killed here, Islamist dont take any shit and bad publicity from anyone.
India is not the place for someone who wants to hide from its government or its crimes.
@@bullseye6969 yes, you are right about it.
Yes
you are the most underrated animator/news reporter I have ever seen, with the amount of the work you do, you can easily surpass vox and vice
3:44 spilled the beans 😂
Good catch!
I'm addicted to your videos, one of the best animators and story tellers on RUclips and one of the best content creators from india.
Shame on india for sending back the princess though. It's disgusting we should have treated her like a proper human being and let her do what she wanted to do.
To whom those are saying bisbo is biased for how long are you following this channel???
Bro ur the best... pls do cover current affairs, national security and foreign affairs .. so it'll be useful for us as we can understand easily through your videos
10:20 yes! I'm here to listen to those 2 words.. bisbo's limerick
Lol 😂 thanks !
Very well made. It's light, humorous and most importantly, it's fact based. Keep up this good work. Your followers will grow for sure. Jai Hind.
Perfect Analysis and true info by Bisbo., Everyone seeing Indian Defence as money spinning Factory., That's what we are lagging with everyone and we can't make enough weapons of ourselves
Thanks Santhosh
Great info and art video, keep them coming!
Well Keep up the good work Bisbo. You will stand up one day from your organic growth.
Thanks Arun
Why does he change his accent to suit the perceived nationality , smh 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Seriously that’s fucked up my ears... his vids are good but the accent shit is ear rape
@@sajjadhussain9724 lol ear porn for you would be Kim kardashian?
You are more interested in his accent ? While your Italian catholic Antonio has looted our beloved india? Being a converted Indian shame on you
the 101 purchase to Indonesian Airforce also troubeled with briberry allegation. it seem Agusta Westland trying really hard to sell it
Ok. We did. It know that
Do one for Enron Dabhol Power scam as well, very interesting.
Yes. Absolutely.
every chor fear to be in India now , why 😂
Can you do a sum up of all political party
With both pros and cons
For 2019 elections
Takes too much time to do the video in time before election. May be for next one!
Well done! Appreciations from Singapore! Keep going, don't let the view count bother you!
Pappu. Ka mama Michael mama 😂😂😂
*Bisbo* ,What about "Rafael" why chokidar handed India's money to an already wealthy man who's company which doesn't have any experience ,when Indian government owned HAL could be a perfect company with lots of experience to manufacture "Rafael" ?
Sharing to educate:
Friends, nobles and countrymen.
The biggest offset partner in Rafale deal is DRDO with ₹9,000 crore. Not Ambani. Rest ₹21,000 is split in three main manufacturers Thales ₹6,300 crore, Dassault ₹8,400 crore & Safran ₹6,300 crore. Offset for Thales is given to 12 Indian companies. Offset for Dassault to 55 Indian companies. And offset for Safran to 22 Indian companies.Ambani's Reliance is one of these 89 companies, clocking only about 3% of the total i.e. around ₹900 crore. Guess who else is there? Among the known ones, L&T, Mahindra, HCL, TCS, Cap Gemini India, Titan, Wipro & Godrej. To add a cherry to the cake, HAL is there too, via a JV (Joint Venture) with Safran.
Share it maximum. Translate in the languages you may know. Spread it across.
No media will do this. Social media is the only hope.
@@Emperor-Of-Karma Any source to support your statement?
@@Emperor-Of-Karma Even the govt didn't disclose the total deal amount so how come you have deal amount splitting and all these numbers??? any credible evidence to support your reply
Kamineni Prabhu only idiots think rafel is scam each m every Indian knws if in case congress is in d power soniya n Rahul might do looting 1 lakh cr. Bt modi govt vry scam free Nd clean govt
HAL has already many projects which have been delayed , this point has been mentioned by govt many times . No solid evidence has been found till now of Rafale being a scam . And you brining a alleged scam in a video mentioning about real scam tells about your political stance . Don't defend congress so much that you have to even defend their scams . Rahul and Sonia are already on bail . And entire country knows about their misdeeds .
Bisbo plz research on the intricacies of rafale deal as well & enlighten us
We have already done a story on that but it was 2-3 months ago. After that there have been further developments.
good job on getting verification status bisbo
Thanks. Finally!
Bisbo u seriously represent gud news like police investigate the cases😂👌
Thanks. We try to give full details so you get a rounded view of the topic.
Boss great knowledge provider ...Keep up the good work.. thank you
Welcome Prakhar
TO ALL THOSE WHO SAY DEFENCE PEOPLE SHOULD NOT BE QUESTIONED. WATCH THIS
Go Bisbo Go! you guys are soo good in explaining!
Thanks Manan
Bisbo's vedio r very informative, ur animation is nice. 1 request.. Please make little More story like audio communication it would be more absorbing.. Sometimes it feels like someone is just reading the facts not describing it
hahaahha the way you read when you r are mocking while reading the E-mail is lol
Appreciate your time And work. Thanks
Welcome Pratik
Nice secret reveal. thank u for such an important info of Defense scam in India.
Welcome Jyoti
Felt bad for the princess ... She was a refugee and should've been given aslyum instead of sending her back(she trusted our country) :( . Clearly a human rights violation.
Well that was a very smart and fair explanation. It was all a game by the ruling govt against Congress.
Can you please animate some air accidents? And show us. It would be very very good to watch that
I too think your work is commendable and very high quality but i have an issue today if you emphasized on how the princess exaggerated the story maybe she was right or maybe she was wrong but it would be great if i knew the reason for presumption but good work either way society needs people like you..👍
Thanks Rahulji.
Bisbo do a video about Nazi Germany and holocaust India should know about it.
*India already knows read your textbooks neatly please*
@@netlife792 everything is in the books , so what you doing on RUclips ? !!
@@netlife792 go fuck yourself
Nice presentation, I could watch a Netflix webseries on this.
Love u bisbo
Thanks RRM!
Thankyou for explaining this story. Great video.
Good bisbo keep doing good job never take some ones side
MAKE A VIDEO ON CHANDRAYAAN 2
So bribe was given to put euro fighter above...and I think you missed the point how Mitchell was visited by congressmen when he was brought to India...later why Mitchell run to Dubai...why he not face the investigation with other two? If gandhi family is not involved why they fear about Mitchell so much ? They even hate to bring his name.
Antonio Maino - made India from Riches to Rags.
Go bisbo go 😘Really awsome man so good
Wonderful bisbo and good topic
Thanks Shashi, as usual you always encourage
Go bisbo go hoping for you to reach 1M subs soon!!
Please do a video on QNet
@" 3:35 French English , Superb bro ! :)) :))
When supreme court has found the rafael deal to be ok then why bisbo telling indian govt is hiding something.
PS : videos are good though
See their video on rafale scam......
Under that i asked about cbi JD and his removal who has imp part in investigation of rafale deal....then bisbo said they added that slide but after judgement they removed it
@@SalmanKhan-bl1ok ok bro
@Ankur Bains m.economictimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/rafale-deal-sc-rules-out-probe-says-court-is-satisfied-with-the-decision-making-process/amp_articleshow/67087107.cms
Learn to read first?
@Ankur Bains ha ha wake up bro. You are dreaming. The reality is different. 😂
Brother. The Dubai Royal family has faced allegations of abuse for decades, with the King's recent runaway wife and divorce proceedings in London or recorded interviews of a cousin of this princesses in captivity and subdued by psychotropics. Pretty sure this royal lady wasn't making up a pretty tale to escape on a India vacation. Also she was younger and in her 20s.
Stay unbiased bisbo bro ...🖤🖤
Please don't do the dumb accent it's already hard enough to understand.
Ok
@@BisboWorld no that feels like really indian and suitable when speaking the dialogues of different people. Keep doing it.
Jay Hind Jay bhart Jay Modi 🙏🇮🇳🙏🇮🇳❤🇮🇳💖❤🇮🇳
Ban congress
Such an educational video, just 700 likes. No wonder we can't digest good food
I really like your animation 🤣
Thanks Aayush
Whatever be the case, the Eurofighter was a much more advanced fighter than the Rafale. And cost much less than what India ended up paying for a Rafale eventually.
bruh all three euroconards are pricey...and eurofighter is only capable in the air-to-air role...i have talked to some high some high level officials in the IAF...They clearly stated the eurofighter had bonkers pricing for systems.
Its right 50%, govt. never reveals full info then do you claim what you said is 100% right and how?
Second, MODI Security to Country has won hearts what COngress always look for money, not people and country as Italy is their country.
people better vote for one who looks for INDIAs Security and Saftey and Vote for BJP looking only MODI.
We should have traded her for Daoud as well
Agreed
If you know how bad the Indian judiciary system is one will keep their cards as close to them as possible , modi and co are making sure they have a air tight case against Gandhi's before they start or do anything in the courts.
Best explanation bro
Thanks Aditya
Your videos are great
Thanks Jeyanthi
@@BisboWorld please leave a like and THANKS
You definitely need to drop the Indian accent for sure bud! Good luck!
Lol
Why should someone drop their accent? Everyone has an accent and it's totally fine
I like your story.
Bisbo nice explaination
Thanks Karthik
How many videos u come up with real situtations. People still will vote for the corrupted politicians. Dat is is greatness of dis country.
And the bottom line is ?????
Hey bisbo....Tell me something where do u get all this information
See Sources in Video Description
That accent is on point
Nice content
Thanks
make in hindi plz , cos we understand english but there are some village olders who can not understand english but are curoious to listen your story . so plz make in hindi
Hey bisbo can u do a video on balakot strike and the use of it as a political tool by Indian parties
Yes we are planning but it will take a month
Politics influences Defence to commit corruption, at the end of day it is the matter of honesty to the Nation. Work hard and earn for what you deserve and not for what you haven't meant for!!!
Great animation though sad to see you show the Princess's story as make believe rather than sympathize with her. It makes me question all your other research too!!
i feel he is more biased to bjp, he twisted facts of the case , in favour of congress
Spr, kindly add more in Malayalam language
Yes we will add 8 per month from now on
Gautam Khetan's 'rice-exporting company' is a great unintended pun!
That Tamil air chief actually speaks proper English - not Pandi style English.
Please make a video on the SSR case
BRO U R BEST
Thanks boss!
T series vs PewDiePie video pls!
Hi Bisbo
Can you please do a video on Pewdiepie bs T-series?
Thanks!
Folks - it’s never about a particular party. It’s always about politics!
Best comedy I've seen.
What happened to those 3 choppers received ?
Please do a video on N-mart scandal
What is that?
@@BisboWorld it was a MLM fraud
www.business-standard.com/article/pti-stories/n-mart-owner-arrested-in-mlm-fraud-case-113050300045_1.html
At that time i hearted that it was backed by robert vadra. But this never came in news.
Yes Uday, we have been wanting to do a video on MLM and ponzi frauds
Bhai itni information kaha se 😂
Don't say against IAF
Amazing
Thanks Rishit
Can we have hindi version of bisbo
Already there BisboHindi
What about Rafael ? No one knows
For the quality of content I see here, the pronunciations and the accents used by the narrator are poor. Please act upon this constructive criticism.
Yes agreed, we don't have budgets to get foreign accents
@@BisboWorld It's ok.let the world get used to Indian accents.
Don't we adjust to theirs..
Lol
Trump the great president himself doesn't know how to speak English bro. Why should we put in correction efforts. Make a video on him next :)
Can be a little slow pitched so people can follow your accent.
Also make your videos in top 5 Indian languages or subtitles atleast to get more views.
All the best.
Bhai sab thik tha aakhir mein kya keh gya fir fadda kyon dalna woh karenge jab kerna hoga
Bhai Ajay devgn sir ka khan's brigade jesa video bana na plz 🙏🙏
This shit is interesting then Bollywood movies, Ajit doval is really smart man. thats why all criminals fear him.