I love her from the core of my being! For everything that she is and represents and owns and expresses and her crystal clear viewpoints. Listening to her for sure is a non-traditional meditation for me
Filter Coffee: The coffee maker puts it cup and uses his other hand to put it in another cup...and keep repeating to make froth. So authentic filter coffee has froth on top!!!
This particular episode of yours made me subscribe to your channel. Although I am quite unsure why is it so difficult to directly comment on your video (instead of choosing to do the same on a viewer's reply section).
Arjun was living in the forest for so long so he definitely did not miss the forest. When he focused his eyes on the aim it was needed in order to get the victory otherwise he would have failed. Focus on the aim/goal is very important when we want to achieve something.
Your comment carries an undertone of elitism and a belief in the superiority of knowledge. Even if the host (Vaibhav) has a zero content knowledge base, he has the right to learn and understand various perspectives, including content recommendations from the guests. I strongly dislike individuals who intentionally mock and degrade content creators instead of uplifting them for their strengths.
@1:08:55 Ratna Pathak talks about Arjun ki Ankh. Arjun didn't miss the beauty of jungle. He was practicing archery not site seeing. In archery you have to have Lakshya Shuddhi. When Ratna Pathak goes to Olympics Archery competition, she will not focus on the Bulls-eye which is to be shot at but will see whole stadium saying 'Oh, why ek hi lakshya jab itna sundar aur bada stadium is there!" and will shoot arrows everywhere!😂
@@rm3015 her conversation is anti-Hindu, to discredit everything Hindu. She married a Thurak admi whose ancestors killed Hindus and destroyed Hindu Mandirs.
@@Summerblur @Summerblur you completely missed that Arjun's Ankh does not fit into this narrative about life. Don't defend for defending sake because you don't understand the point. She is well known woke liberal and anti-hindu. That is why she uses Arjun's lakshya as an example without realising it does not fit here.
One of the best interviews of Ratna Pathak Shah. Was skeptical initially on reading the comments, but I'm so glad I stayed on to discover the gem this interview truly is! Great questions, great answers! Kudos to the host❤❤
Arjuna never told to focus on one thing only. He told that the your focus should only be on your target and avoid distractions. This is such a simple thing and she is just creating unnecessary controversy. People like her look down on all the Indian teachings and philosophies.
Another gem from an 'intellectual' - Ratna Pathak says that Arjuna missed out on the beautiful nature around him while focussing on the bird's eye. Was that worth it? -- Well I believe, if we were to ask the man whose one of 10 names came to be as "Vijay" - the embodiment of victory itself, the one person who satisfied Rudra in battle, who had a dilema so great, that led to the revealing of the Bhagavad Gita, the man who could attain the status of a sakha to Narayan himself and the man who the lord identifies as, among pandavas - पाण्डवानां धनञ्जय:, he'd definitely say - yes it was definitely worth it. The curse of being an intellectual is real.
Arjuna never told to focus on one thing only. He told that the your focus should only be on your target and avoid distractions. This is such a simple thing and she is just creating unnecessary controversy. People like her look down on all the Indian teachings and philosophies.
@chalchitra team - let's please work towards collaring all the recommendations and references in the description. Your work is phenomenal but it's painful to go back and scrub the episode for that one movie/book the guest suggested. Keep up the great work, it's amazing to be a following the great work you do.
How to prove that this is an amazingly engaging interview? The fact that I was nodding and exclaimed 'YESS!! ' a couple of times while listening to both of you. I truly enjoyed it. Keep up the good work. #monisha
A bs book , and mind I ask does she not have her own thinking to actually question that perspective ?? India is full of you people who treat actors like gods
As per Ratna Pathak Shah, Arjun was focused on hitting the bird's eye and spent 100 years on focusing on that eye and missed out on beauty of nature...etc. 😭😭 Let's forget about Arjun now. Sachin Tendulkar was so focused on becoming the best batter in the world that he missed out on nature's beauty. Was it worth it for Sachin Tendulkar? Neeraj Chopra was so focused on winning Gold Medal in Olympics that he missed out in nature's beauty. Was it worth it for Neeraj Chopra? Ratna Pathak Shah is an avg actress who did not achieve anything remarkable in life but she enjoyed nature's beauty. Was it worth it for Ratna Pathak Shah?
What to each there own , it's a dumb thing she said.. Virat Kohli missed out on so many things because he focused on ball made century@@shaktibhat7601 bruh stop the celebrity asslicking
Arjuna used to live in that forest so missing surroundings is like missing traffic while living in Bangalore. Mam, we do need to focus while performing given task at hand and enjoy surroundings rest of the time. What is with the anchor! Why is every sentence so amazing for him that he has achieved nirvaana 😂
Ratna Pathak Shah is one of the most amazing actors I have seen and has been able to create her own unique identity while growing and living around other great actors in her family. She has so much to offer in this interview as an artist. But unfortunately, some people as I see in the comments got stuck to just that one thing about Arjun that she said. Shows the incapability of people being able to look through the perspective of an artist who doesn't necessarily think alike and that's what makes her different from others. And I love the way Vaibhav laughs.
Also, the entire idea of a philosophical approach to art/stories is that we derive different meanings from what's told. We're free to feel differently about it. Very rarely will two people have exactly the same experience about art, neither will the thoughts that are triggered by it, be the same.
Bhai iski kon si acting acchi hai....isko koi nhi janta itna. Nasser sabhi ke naam se hi isko jante han...koi Mahaan actor nhi hai....btw it's my perspective....
It's beautiful here in Germany(Its summer Time :)), and I completely agree with what she is saying about the winter in European countries. I am listening to this and thinking about how different it is from the winter we experience in India!
I can't comprehend the stupidity of these people and their followers. The story of Arjun shows that you will even fight your family to protect the Dharma for the greater good.
Kauravas were greedy, deceptive, and just wanted power in any case. Duryodhana used Shakuni against Yudhisthira and took everything from him. That's why Krishna was on Arjun's side and gave "updesh" to Arjun where he talks about Karma.
Sorry for the confusion, but I know the real story as you very well narrated from Mahabharat by Vyasa. I wanted the time stamp when Ratna Shah talks of that in this interview. I surfed through but couldn't find it and didn't have the patience to listen to all the conversation.
1:09:52 Well I would like to enlighten this actor with the things the mighty Arjuna was able to achieve with his focus, & those are as follows- (1) Mastery in archery: He became an unparalleled archer, capable of hitting targets with extraordinary precision even under challenging circumstances. (2) Success in battles: Arjuna's focus on his training and skills made him a formidable warrior on the battlefield, leading to numerous victories in the Mahabharata war. (3) Fulfillment of his duties: His focus helped him fulfill his duties as a warrior and prince, protecting his kingdom and upholding righteousness. (4) Spiritual enlightenment: Through his dialogue with Lord Krishna in the Bhagavad Gita, Arjuna attained spiritual wisdom and understanding, transcending the dilemmas of life and gaining clarity on his path and purpose. If you don't cleary know about the sacred history, don't manipulate it as per your own mind.
People who are talking about her point on the Arjuna part.. let me share my point of view about what I think she probably meant to say. Arjuna was not the only one who became successful and achieved his goal. There were multiple other characters like his other siblings who also reached their goals at the end. The wisdom of Mahabharata is all about living your life aligned with Dharma by following your own path of karma. At the end everyone reaches the same destination. Definitely she didn't need to explain her point any further. Lastly I want to say, what a passionate conversation about cinema. Loved it and Ratna Pathak mam is just awesome ❤️
I remember Maam giving a talk in VJTI(Yes the same college she mentioned in the answer for the first movie experience) and it was a pleasure, glad its all heart and no-nonsense great episode!
Dude your hmmmmms are thoda sa irritating to listen i mean i feel sometimes they are not the right reaction for something the guest says i love u guys for what u are doing and wish to be like u but that hmmmss are thoda sa misplaced yaaar
इंटरव्यू लेने वाला भी इस तरह उछल रहा है जैसे उसे गीता के ज्ञान की प्राप्ति हो गई है 😂😂 इन भांडो को क्या पता लक्ष्य क्या होता है खुद उनकी ही इंडस्ट्री में बनी हुई फिल्म लक्ष्य को देखकर यह समझ सकती हैं और आप महाशय जो इनका इंटरव्यू ले रहे हैं लक्ष्य क्या होता है जा के जरा उनसे पूछिए जिन्होंने अर्जुन की तरह सिर्फ अपने लक्ष्य पर फोकस रखकर बहुत कुछ पाया है सचिन तेंदुलकर निखिल चोपड़ा विराट कोहली पी टी उषा सानिया मिर्जा साइना नेहवाल मिल्खा सिंह और वे सारे बच्चे जो बोर्ड एग्जाम्स में और वो सारे बच्चे जो बोर्ड एग्जाम्स में TOP करते हैं
Sahi kaha, inko kya hai na...idhar udhar bhatkne ki...idhar udhar muh marne ki aadat hoti hai na...inse 1 cheez par focus nahi hota...ye bore ho jate hai 1 cheez se isliye ye aisi bakwas karne aa jate hai social media par. Aur jo interview le raha hai inke to kya kehne ??😅😅
The way she talks so fluently and eloquently makes it a delight to watch and hear. Lovely conversations have become a rarity these days. Thankfully this was an exception. Cheers ❤
I'm liking this video just because you invited her. Thanks to people like you, we atleast get some insights to their world views. When we listen to people of such stature and experience, it does make us think of different possibilities of looking at life. We may agree or disagree with them, but it is always a joy to come across the varied thoughts and experiences.😊
फासीवादियों ने सिर्फ comnt सेक्शन में उन्माद फैलाया है, किसी और धर्म की किताब को quote करके कोई फिलोसॉफी झाड़ी होती या अपना प्वाइंट ऑफ व्यू रखा होता तो सर कट गए होते कईयों के,इसलिए थोड़ा शुक्र मनाओ की सत्ता फासीवादियों के हाथ में है और देश की मेजोरिटी में सनातनी है ।
I find Ratna Pathak to be tremendously talented and such a fine human being. She’s so well read and she has so much integrity and respect for herself. I love the way she carries herself. I wish to find a friend like her. Much love and respect from Pakistan. ❤
Great interview/podcast. One thing that could have made it better is if the anchor would not have said hmmm, ahhh oooo.. all the time. It breaks the flow as a listener. This advice is more of a request please. :)
Dear Madam, Arjuna was not there for picnic. He was a warrior, training for being the best Archer in the world. His sacrifice to miss out on the pleasures of the world paid out by him becoming a formidable warrior and defeating his enemies in one of the deadliest wars to have been ever fought.
She’s always a treat to listen to, what a beautiful conversation full of lots of lovely recommendations. Could listen to her for hours and hours. The book of a Gond artist she mentioned while talking about Arjun missing out rest of the things while aiming for birds eye might be ‘Creation’ by Bhajju Shyam
I have rarely commented on any video ever... But THIS one warranted ONE... And it has nothing to do with the brilliant Ratna Pathak Shah... I think you should come and live in the US, ESPECIALLY New England... And THEN you might appreciate WHITE lights!
1:10:21 smartly change the topic..so that atleast he doesn't look stipid😂😂.. he responded there as per situation needed and shift the conversation smartly to whole different side.😂😂
Ratna Pathak totally obscures the interviewer who really needs to learn even if a little from her in his communication skills - such a contrast between them .... need for better interviewer . Please get someone better- hats off to Ratnaji ❤
Perhaps that would make it more of a conversation rather than an interview. I must admit Naseer and Ratna would make for a great conversation. That said, there is power in vulnerability, to surrender to what the other has to say, this creates a softness where thought is more expansive and the experience more wholesome.
She is like madam muh se kaise hugte, main batayegi, phir aise poscast karne wale bhi mil jaate hai, main bhi batayega muh se hugne ka kya faida. Aise log to kuch bhi kar sakte hai, paise ke aur intellectual hone ke naam pe.
In the Arjun's perspective, I can clearly sense that she didn't mean to negate or disrespect what the ideal lakshya saadhna theory has been taught to us since centuries, through Arjun's example. She just wanted to point out the sacrifices one has to make to chase that one lakshya like Arjun did. That's all!! Geeta ka uchchatam gyaan apni jgaah sahi, surakshit, aur undoubtedly sahi hai. Don't fall for this misunderstanding that she pointed out anything on purpose. Everyone has the right to present perspectives. All it takes is to respect the other side, which she clearly did. We can welcome her thoughts too without any harm.
Why are you justifying her Whats the point then you can clearly see her other interviews she always use to demean culture and show off her like and intellectual which she definitely is not. I mean if there is need of justifying or defining an intellectual then they are idiots
जब सनातन धर्म की बात समझ नहीं आती टिप्पणी क्यों करते हैं। न हिन्दू रही न इस्लाम अपना पाई इनको अपनी स्वेच्छा से चुनी इस्लामिक पहचान जाहिर करने की हिम्मत नहीं होती है पर दुसरे धर्म पर टिप्पणी करते हुए उपहास उड़ानें से नियत झलक जाती है
# Monisha.......oh , this is magnificently good interms of general long interviews.... Because I am a bibliophile so for me specially the literary recommendation part was the best. Keep doing this good works for us🌼.
Khud to HIGHLY INTELLECTUAL saabit krne k liye log kuch v gyaan dene lgte h Madam for your kind information Arjuna was best warrior of his time and he lived his life holistically by achieving excellence in every aspect of life and this was only possible because of his focus and dedication.
1:09:28 Arjuna never told to focus on one thing only. He told that the your focus should only be on your target and avoid distractions. This is such a simple thing and she is just creating unnecessary controversy. People like her look down on all the Indian teachings and philosophies.
I love her from the core of my being! For everything that she is and represents and owns and expresses and her crystal clear viewpoints. Listening to her for sure is a non-traditional meditation for me
Totally agree.
Filter Coffee: The coffee maker puts it cup and uses his other hand to put it in another cup...and keep repeating to make froth. So authentic filter coffee has froth on top!!!
Tell me, Who did her HALALA? 😅
Tell me Who did her HALALA 😅
This particular episode of yours made me subscribe to your channel. Although I am quite unsure why is it so difficult to directly comment on your video (instead of choosing to do the same on a viewer's reply section).
With focus Arjun achieved impossible things when he was still in his twenties. And after all this he has 100 more years to live free
Which time point in the video
@@NatarajanGanesan 1:09:25
Thanks @@samsid504
Thank you so much. Wanted to get the context to see if missed anything. Can't believe the point she is making.
1:08:45
Arjun was living in the forest for so long so he definitely did not miss the forest. When he focused his eyes on the aim it was needed in order to get the victory otherwise he would have failed. Focus on the aim/goal is very important when we want to achieve something.
Tiir maar ke wo Rajasthan sift ho jate the :acc to ratna 😂😂
Acc to her roti khaya to bhaat chor diye,- panner khaya to idli pe dhyan nahi de paya 😅😅
This anchor seems to live under a rock. He does not seem to have any knowledge of his own, and therefore everything surprises him.
😅. Yes. Same with beer biceps. Everything is latest news
@@mini3460so true. This host has very poor conversation skills, beer bicep guy is actually very immature and inexperienced.
Tune theatre play Kiya h kya kai saalon tak?
Your comment carries an undertone of elitism and a belief in the superiority of knowledge. Even if the host (Vaibhav) has a zero content knowledge base, he has the right to learn and understand various perspectives, including content recommendations from the guests. I strongly dislike individuals who intentionally mock and degrade content creators instead of uplifting them for their strengths.
@@manisshthakur621 exactly. This is how people learn. Through conversations. This just happens to be one that is filmed
@1:08:55 Ratna Pathak talks about Arjun ki Ankh. Arjun didn't miss the beauty of jungle. He was practicing archery not site seeing. In archery you have to have Lakshya Shuddhi.
When Ratna Pathak goes to Olympics Archery competition, she will not focus on the Bulls-eye which is to be shot at but will see whole stadium saying 'Oh, why ek hi lakshya jab itna sundar aur bada stadium is there!" and will shoot arrows everywhere!😂
Perhaps you missed out the conversation. She's actually appreciating an illustration drawn by a painter.
@@rm3015 her conversation is anti-Hindu, to discredit everything Hindu. She married a Thurak admi whose ancestors killed Hindus and destroyed Hindu Mandirs.
@@Summerblur @Summerblur you completely missed that Arjun's Ankh does not fit into this narrative about life. Don't defend for defending sake because you don't understand the point.
She is well known woke liberal and anti-hindu. That is why she uses Arjun's lakshya as an example without realising it does not fit here.
@@Bhadruduhmm, this so called fanboys will defend anything for their idol actors
Most probably a fangirl, its know facts wokism appeal more to girls due to it more sentimental nature less factual.@@ankurkhare6185
One of the best interviews of Ratna Pathak Shah. Was skeptical initially on reading the comments, but I'm so glad I stayed on to discover the gem this interview truly is! Great questions, great answers! Kudos to the host❤❤
Wth ...Arjuna literally lived in jungle for 12 years. 😂....koi inko batao he wasnt just looking into that birds eye for 12 years. 🤣😂🤷🏼♂️
Arjuna never told to focus on one thing only. He told that the your focus should only be on your target and avoid distractions. This is such a simple thing and she is just creating unnecessary controversy. People like her look down on all the Indian teachings and philosophies.
Another gem from an 'intellectual' - Ratna Pathak says that Arjuna missed out on the beautiful nature around him while focussing on the bird's eye. Was that worth it?
-- Well I believe, if we were to ask the man whose one of 10 names came to be as "Vijay" - the embodiment of victory itself, the one person who satisfied Rudra in battle, who had a dilema so great, that led to the revealing of the Bhagavad Gita, the man who could attain the status of a sakha to Narayan himself and the man who the lord identifies as, among pandavas - पाण्डवानां धनञ्जय:, he'd definitely say - yes it was definitely worth it.
The curse of being an intellectual is real.
Great answer
It's not her pov but the illustrator's
@@mishalusman2813 what do you mean? It's she who's saying.
Arjuna never told to focus on one thing only. He told that the your focus should only be on your target and avoid distractions. This is such a simple thing and she is just creating unnecessary controversy. People like her look down on all the Indian teachings and philosophies.
@@pranaya2800 true 🙌
Aargh , so jealous he got to spend so much quality time with her ! Though truth be told I'd just be dumbstruck around her 😛
Such an amazing interview. She is a veteran. So effortless in front of camera. Such a class act
😂
Such an honest person. This conversation ♥️
Gadhi h ek number ki
That one english literature professor that we need😭
Tell me Who did her HALALA 😅
Sanghi terrorist, she is happy.@@R_Sanatani
You*
You need her. We don't need an ignorant person like her. Today every second person is able to speak English fluently.
the only woke professor which is not needed today
@chalchitra team - let's please work towards collaring all the recommendations and references in the description. Your work is phenomenal but it's painful to go back and scrub the episode for that one movie/book the guest suggested.
Keep up the great work, it's amazing to be a following the great work you do.
How to prove that this is an amazingly engaging interview? The fact that I was nodding and exclaimed 'YESS!! ' a couple of times while listening to both of you. I truly enjoyed it. Keep up the good work. #monisha
Can listen to her for hours, she reminds me of Frances mcdormand
One of the most entertaining and educational podcast from chalchitra talks! Love you Ratna mam! ❤
Educational?
She can be whatever she likes and we love and adore her forever ❤
She’s talking about a book. Let’s not take it out of context both these women are amazing. ❤
Bewakoof aurat hai ye...
A bs book , and mind I ask does she not have her own thinking to actually question that perspective ?? India is full of you people who treat actors like gods
She is phenomenal. Would love to have her as my literature guide
As per Ratna Pathak Shah, Arjun was focused on hitting the bird's eye and spent 100 years on focusing on that eye and missed out on beauty of nature...etc. 😭😭
Let's forget about Arjun now.
Sachin Tendulkar was so focused on becoming the best batter in the world that he missed out on nature's beauty. Was it worth it for Sachin Tendulkar?
Neeraj Chopra was so focused on winning Gold Medal in Olympics that he missed out in nature's beauty. Was it worth it for Neeraj Chopra?
Ratna Pathak Shah is an avg actress who did not achieve anything remarkable in life but she enjoyed nature's beauty. Was it worth it for Ratna Pathak Shah?
To each their own
What to each there own , it's a dumb thing she said.. Virat Kohli missed out on so many things because he focused on ball made century@@shaktibhat7601 bruh stop the celebrity asslicking
yes
Seems people are here to nitpick. Listen to what she says about the book.
Solid bro!
She has such an elegant way of speaking, both in Hindi and English. I loved her performance in Khoobsurat.
Why is this host making strange noises, when responding..?
He's a dolphin
Her knowledge and intellect is beyond his understanding and ability.
@@rm3015😂😂
Overacting ker raha hai .
Jo usese ho nahi rahi😂
Is that all that you took away from the conversation? Sad
Queen is here 🎉
Tell me , Who did her HALALA 😅
Lmao pls stop ..she acting like karen aunty 😂
Yess.. The dumbest Queen
Queen without brain...🤣🤣
Amazing interview! The host is so calm and professional.
You are still very much relevant ma'am! Love hearing your views ❤
Good to see u both on same page... It is rare to see this now a day..
Arjuna used to live in that forest so missing surroundings is like missing traffic while living in Bangalore. Mam, we do need to focus while performing given task at hand and enjoy surroundings rest of the time.
What is with the anchor! Why is every sentence so amazing for him that he has achieved nirvaana 😂
I like her work in Sarabai.
Ratna Pathak Shah is one of the most amazing actors I have seen and has been able to create her own unique identity while growing and living around other great actors in her family. She has so much to offer in this interview as an artist. But unfortunately, some people as I see in the comments got stuck to just that one thing about Arjun that she said. Shows the incapability of people being able to look through the perspective of an artist who doesn't necessarily think alike and that's what makes her different from others.
And I love the way Vaibhav laughs.
For you just an actress and her "wanna be intellectual stupid talks" matter more than actual history and life lesson.
👏👏
Also, the entire idea of a philosophical approach to art/stories is that we derive different meanings from what's told. We're free to feel differently about it. Very rarely will two people have exactly the same experience about art, neither will the thoughts that are triggered by it, be the same.
Bhai iski kon si acting acchi hai....isko koi nhi janta itna.
Nasser sabhi ke naam se hi isko jante han...koi Mahaan actor nhi hai....btw it's my perspective....
The next time she boards a flight from Mumbai to Delhi, I want the pilot to follow her philosophy 🙌.
Why go to Delhi when you can land in any city?
इसे कहते है लेफ्ट लिबरल सोच 😄😄
😂😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂
This was bulls eye..
Y'all religious fanboys really didn't understand the context :|
@@anoopjprakash flawed analogy
Even though she is just getting into podcast but she se got the jist of it bang. podcast are an evolved form of live radio started by Howard Stern
An interesting depiction of the theatre is ‘Drive My Car’.
It's beautiful here in Germany(Its summer Time :)), and I completely agree with what she is saying about the winter in European countries. I am listening to this and thinking about how different it is from the winter we experience in India!
Please bring Sanjay Mishra on your show❤
I can't comprehend the stupidity of these people and their followers. The story of Arjun shows that you will even fight your family to protect the Dharma for the greater good.
Can you time stamp that Arjun segment?
Kauravas were greedy, deceptive, and just wanted power in any case. Duryodhana used Shakuni against Yudhisthira and took everything from him. That's why Krishna was on Arjun's side and gave "updesh" to Arjun where he talks about Karma.
Sorry for the confusion, but I know the real story as you very well narrated from Mahabharat by Vyasa. I wanted the time stamp when Ratna Shah talks of that in this interview. I surfed through but couldn't find it and didn't have the patience to listen to all the conversation.
@@kishoretiwari8141 1:09:25
1:09:52
Well I would like to enlighten this actor with the things the mighty Arjuna was able to achieve with his focus, & those are as follows-
(1) Mastery in archery: He became an unparalleled archer, capable of hitting targets with extraordinary precision even under challenging circumstances.
(2) Success in battles: Arjuna's focus on his training and skills made him a formidable warrior on the battlefield, leading to numerous victories in the Mahabharata war.
(3) Fulfillment of his duties: His focus helped him fulfill his duties as a warrior and prince, protecting his kingdom and upholding righteousness.
(4) Spiritual enlightenment: Through his dialogue with Lord Krishna in the Bhagavad Gita, Arjuna attained spiritual wisdom and understanding, transcending the dilemmas of life and gaining clarity on his path and purpose.
If you don't cleary know about the sacred history, don't manipulate it as per your own mind.
Are you deaf? She’s mentioning someone ELSE’s interpretation. Maybe listen to the interview first before writing an essay in the comments.
People who are talking about her point on the Arjuna part.. let me share my point of view about what I think she probably meant to say.
Arjuna was not the only one who became successful and achieved his goal. There were multiple other characters like his other siblings who also reached their goals at the end. The wisdom of Mahabharata is all about living your life aligned with Dharma by following your own path of karma. At the end everyone reaches the same destination. Definitely she didn't need to explain her point any further. Lastly I want to say, what a passionate conversation about cinema. Loved it and Ratna Pathak mam is just awesome ❤️
That means don't focus and see other things around the targets. You liberals and leftist already ruin the culture of many countries 😂
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Arjuna never told to focus on one thing only. He told that the your focus should only be on your target and avoid distractions.
Her body language is so adorable 🌠
Was planning to watch Roshomon for a couple of days. That's my sign.
Ratnaji is an encyclopedia can listen to her all day 🫶🏽
Nd become dumb like her
I remember Maam giving a talk in VJTI(Yes the same college she mentioned in the answer for the first movie experience) and it was a pleasure, glad its all heart and no-nonsense great episode!
The host could do more than Random Hmms and Yeahhs.
Dude your hmmmmms are thoda sa irritating to listen i mean i feel sometimes they are not the right reaction for something the guest says i love u guys for what u are doing and wish to be like u but that hmmmss are thoda sa misplaced yaaar
she is an intelligent n experienced person
I love her so much! Thanks for a long interview
I feel each person has their own point of view, but the great part about ratna ji is she is firm n expressive about her point
इंटरव्यू लेने वाला भी इस तरह उछल रहा है जैसे उसे गीता के ज्ञान की प्राप्ति हो गई है 😂😂 इन भांडो को क्या पता लक्ष्य क्या होता है खुद उनकी ही इंडस्ट्री में बनी हुई फिल्म लक्ष्य को देखकर यह समझ सकती हैं और आप महाशय जो इनका इंटरव्यू ले रहे हैं लक्ष्य क्या होता है जा के जरा उनसे पूछिए जिन्होंने अर्जुन की तरह सिर्फ अपने लक्ष्य पर फोकस रखकर बहुत कुछ पाया है सचिन तेंदुलकर निखिल चोपड़ा विराट कोहली पी टी उषा सानिया मिर्जा साइना नेहवाल मिल्खा सिंह और वे सारे बच्चे जो बोर्ड एग्जाम्स में और वो सारे बच्चे जो बोर्ड एग्जाम्स में TOP करते हैं
Sahi kaha, inko kya hai na...idhar udhar bhatkne ki...idhar udhar muh marne ki aadat hoti hai na...inse 1 cheez par focus nahi hota...ye bore ho jate hai 1 cheez se isliye ye aisi bakwas karne aa jate hai social media par.
Aur jo interview le raha hai inke to kya kehne ??😅😅
🎉GodDamn Beauty❤
I watched FILMY CHAKKAR only because of Her
The way she talks so fluently and eloquently makes it a delight to watch and hear. Lovely conversations have become a rarity these days. Thankfully this was an exception. Cheers ❤
Tell me, Who did her HALALA 😅
Ratna mam is such a charm.....loved listening to her❤❤
Great job by Vaibhav and all CCT team❤️❤️
host's acting - Oooooooo, Damnnnnn, Wowwwwww😂😂😂😂😂 not a good actor 😂😂😂😆😆😆😆
absolutely adore her! Her mind, her acting, her thought process! She's brilliant
Podcast me baith ke osho ka level copy kar rahi hai😂😂
She's one unique personality, it was a treat listening her talk
This has been one of the best episodes so far! Love her and love hearing her ❤
I'm liking this video just because you invited her. Thanks to people like you, we atleast get some insights to their world views. When we listen to people of such stature and experience, it does make us think of different possibilities of looking at life. We may agree or disagree with them, but it is always a joy to come across the varied thoughts and experiences.😊
Arjun missed the forest....😂😂
What a dumb....
She made me realise the need of culture to be taught as education ❤️
इस कमेंट सेक्शन को पढ़कर कोई समझ सकता है कि हिंदुत्व और फ़ासीवादियों ने इस देश में कितना उन्माद पैदा कर दिया है।
फासीवादियों ने सिर्फ comnt सेक्शन में उन्माद फैलाया है, किसी और धर्म की किताब को quote करके कोई फिलोसॉफी झाड़ी होती या अपना प्वाइंट ऑफ व्यू रखा होता तो सर कट गए होते कईयों के,इसलिए थोड़ा शुक्र मनाओ की सत्ता फासीवादियों के हाथ में है और देश की मेजोरिटी में सनातनी है ।
Tere Jaise chutiyon ne peechle 70 saal jo kiya yeh uski tulna mein kaafi kum hai
Sirf dedh ghanta ka interview...should have been atleast 10 hrs....❤
I find Ratna Pathak to be tremendously talented and such a fine human being. She’s so well read and she has so much integrity and respect for herself. I love the way she carries herself. I wish to find a friend like her. Much love and respect from Pakistan. ❤
Always a pleasure watching her talking..can't get enough of her.. Such a unique personality she is..
It’s lovely how Chalchitra talks hand picks their guests . I love Ratna Pathak Shah and I can listen her talk indefinitely 😅
Supeerrrrrbbbb Episode
Big Fan of Ratna ji
Does anyone have the link to the movie, bought myself a father ?
Great one! I loved her interview with Samdish too, but it got deleted
Really?? Why??
I mean why did it get deleted?
@@priyatapal1754 samdish left schoop whoop
0:42 She's the epitome of pseudo intellectual.
Loved the episode. Though You make these weird noises when she speaks is quite irritating.
कोई इस मोहतरमा को समझा दो भाई,आँख पर सिर्फ लक्ष भेदने तक ही फोकस देना था, कुछ लोगो की अकल पर ना जाणे कौन ताले लगा कर बैठा है क्या पता?
Great interview/podcast. One thing that could have made it better is if the anchor would not have said hmmm, ahhh oooo.. all the time. It breaks the flow as a listener. This advice is more of a request please. :)
Apne nhi kafi kuch miss kr dia. Italy ke bars me beauty dikhati, Shah ji wah wah krte
Naahh!! I don't trust the comments 🙂.. Ratna ji is love 😩❤
😂😂😂
Use brain
@@untamedsoul876 if someone is spitting facts and this is wrong according to the people who use brain than I don't want to be like them I'm sorry 🙁
@@khushithakur6657 bla bla....
Bla bla......
@@untamedsoul876 The people who have brain use this language? 👀
Looking fit and lovely. God Bless
Dear Madam,
Arjuna was not there for picnic. He was a warrior, training for being the best Archer in the world. His sacrifice to miss out on the pleasures of the world paid out by him becoming a formidable warrior and defeating his enemies in one of the deadliest wars to have been ever fought.
She’s always a treat to listen to, what a beautiful conversation full of lots of lovely recommendations. Could listen to her for hours and hours.
The book of a Gond artist she mentioned while talking about Arjun missing out rest of the things while aiming for birds eye might be ‘Creation’ by Bhajju Shyam
I have rarely commented on any video ever... But THIS one warranted ONE... And it has nothing to do with the brilliant Ratna Pathak Shah... I think you should come and live in the US, ESPECIALLY New England... And THEN you might appreciate WHITE lights!
01:09:30 - 2 ignorants talking about Knowledge and wisdom 😂
Why can't i find it in audible
1:10:21 smartly change the topic..so that atleast he doesn't look stipid😂😂.. he responded there as per situation needed and shift the conversation smartly to whole different side.😂😂
Is BKL ko kisne bulaya ?? 😂😂😂😂
Ratna Pathak totally obscures the interviewer who really needs to learn even if a little from her in his communication skills - such a contrast between them .... need for better interviewer . Please get someone better- hats off to Ratnaji ❤
Perhaps that would make it more of a conversation rather than an interview. I must admit Naseer and Ratna would make for a great conversation. That said, there is power in vulnerability, to surrender to what the other has to say, this creates a softness where thought is more expansive and the experience more wholesome.
bro, your comment has ghatiya english and indicates a person trying to use words they don't truly know.
So true.
Poty karte waqt sirf toilet par dhyan mat rakhna madam dinning table par v thoda sa poty kar dena 😂
She is like madam muh se kaise hugte, main batayegi, phir aise poscast karne wale bhi mil jaate hai, main bhi batayega muh se hugne ka kya faida. Aise log to kuch bhi kar sakte hai, paise ke aur intellectual hone ke naam pe.
Looking for that 1 comment where I'll get notes of this episode 😂😂
please have a session with Ritesh batra,
When does he talk abt sarabhai in the vd plz tell ?
In the Arjun's perspective, I can clearly sense that she didn't mean to negate or disrespect what the ideal lakshya saadhna theory has been taught to us since centuries, through Arjun's example. She just wanted to point out the sacrifices one has to make to chase that one lakshya like Arjun did. That's all!! Geeta ka uchchatam gyaan apni jgaah sahi, surakshit, aur undoubtedly sahi hai. Don't fall for this misunderstanding that she pointed out anything on purpose. Everyone has the right to present perspectives. All it takes is to respect the other side, which she clearly did. We can welcome her thoughts too without any harm.
Why are you justifying her Whats the point then you can clearly see her other interviews she always use to demean culture and show off her like and intellectual which she definitely is not. I mean if there is need of justifying or defining an intellectual then they are idiots
Bolta bhi deewana, sunta bhi deewana 😂😂😂
Thanks Vaibhav, this was fun! #Monisha.
Thanks so so much chalchitratalks for these episodes. Absolutely loved it. #Monisha
जब सनातन धर्म की बात समझ नहीं आती टिप्पणी क्यों करते हैं। न हिन्दू रही न इस्लाम अपना पाई
इनको अपनी स्वेच्छा से चुनी इस्लामिक पहचान जाहिर करने की हिम्मत नहीं होती है
पर दुसरे धर्म पर टिप्पणी करते हुए उपहास उड़ानें से नियत झलक जाती है
Arey nahi, mundi dhar ke upar bhi to chahiye.
Lovely chat, Adore her. Been lucky enough to watch most of their plays.
this episod is extra Rare of your all … !!!! ❤❤
Kitch expresss must watch 🎉🎉awesome one
# Monisha.......oh , this is magnificently good interms of general long interviews.... Because I am a bibliophile so for me specially the literary recommendation part was the best.
Keep doing this good works for us🌼.
Khud to HIGHLY INTELLECTUAL saabit krne k liye log kuch v gyaan dene lgte h
Madam for your kind information Arjuna was best warrior of his time and he lived his life holistically by achieving excellence in every aspect of life and this was only possible because of his focus and dedication.
Yaar she is so cute I can listen to her all day! Naseer sir too!
Laugh track toh Friends me bhi bahut zyada hai!
1:08:55 Ratna Pathak Playing Monisha Mother in Law as now Became Monisha itself😂😂
1:09:28 Arjuna never told to focus on one thing only. He told that the your focus should only be on your target and avoid distractions. This is such a simple thing and she is just creating unnecessary controversy. People like her look down on all the Indian teachings and philosophies.
6:26 she reacted to my comment 😍😍😍😍
I am just dying to see Imtiaz Ali on here