loved the thing that he forgot everything, from how his grandson looks to when his last hearing was ...but remembers exactly in which colour box her wife kept poha for him this morning. The love and bond is fantastic 😅
@@LargeShortFilms Having been a full time carer for my mother who had dementia, I would like to stress that more on this topic is required so as to bring wider public awareness of this horrible disease that is now afflicting not only the aged, but also the younger population. It is especially important to open this topic to discussion in south Asians who are usually in denial of this affliction. This cause unnecessary suffering in families and communities. The message should perhaps be played out in a series of plays detailing - causes, diagnosis and care of dementia, in addition to lifestyle changes that minimise the risk of dementia. May all be happy.
What a beautiful storyline!! She was called to help the Alzheimer's patient but instead she found help for her own depressed state of mind. Life comes with a lot of unexpected twists and turns at times. ❤
I watched this movie just because of Naseeeruddin Shah sir. He is one of the most talented actor and an institute for learning in acting. Every time he comes with betterment no matter he is in short film or in a movie the perfection is every where . we are proud of you sir and feeling lucky to have incredible actor like you in Indian Cinema.
The happiness I got in the end when I found out that his wife is alive,, is so precious that I can't explain,,a short story gave me immense pleasure,, wow
This is the Hallmark of an Intelligent Script Writer. He made viewers Think that his wife was DEAD and perhaps that Aggravated his Condition: that may be he Was Hallucinating- another disorder! I am a writer myself, a good one too, but even i Was Taken by surprise when his Wife Walks In!!! That was The High Point in the story. Initially seemed like He was Hallucinating as usual but the caregivers Confused and 'Controlled Shocked' Reaction revealed the Twist in the tale - 2 people cant be Hallucinating....at the Sametime...about the same person! Saw it twice to see if the writer had fooled the viewers in some way but he had all ends covered...he even talked about his wife in the PRESENT TENSE...all in all, a good, engaging story with an unexpected and unpredictable End- another Convincing Hallmark of an Intelligent Writer
Hire a caregiver. Your wife is not your parent's personal maid. Not talking about you, but the majority of asian culture imposes daughter in law to take care of the husband's parents.
@@vipulgupta6949 It was all about acceptance. When two people are together, they shall be open about both good and bad of each other. Hiding something from the other just to make sure the relationship goes fine will not really help. Similarly, expressing likes and dislikes is fine but that shall not impact the kind of person someone is. Deepti didn't wear the nose ring because Dhruv didn't like it on her and he felt she looked like an idiot. When she wears it at the end of the story, that signifies her realization of this.
Beautiful film in every sense! Ah! This hits home. My mother is 67.. she got early onset Alzheimer’s at 57. These 10 yrs have been totally devastating for the whole family as she was the main pillar. It’s been 4 yrs since she stopped recognizing us.. it’s gut wrenching and extremely painful for us when she looks at us with a blank expression… knowing that she is the same person whose eyes would sparkle and have a big smile on her face looking at her family! How can god be soo cruel !!
Naseeruddin Shah's profound impact on the world of acting is a testament to his immense talent, dedication, and versatility. With his powerful performances and passion for the craft, he has become an inspiration to aspiring actors around the world, leaving an indelible mark on Indian cinema and theatre.
@@amritrao882 Your actions and beliefs are unacceptable and do not align with the values of a tolerant and respectful society. Everyone deserves to be treated with dignity, regardless of their religion or beliefs. Your hateful behavior only fuels division and intolerance, and has no place in a civilized society. I urge you to reflect on your actions and work towards empathy and understanding for people of all backgrounds.
Thank God, stumbled upon this gem if not so late. No matter what the political ideologies one person holds, one should not overlook the talent the artist possesses; deserves the due credit always.Naseeruddin shah has once again proved that he still comes in the top 5 great actors of cinema. Well acted by Rasika duggal too.
What do you mean by political ideologies ? Is he not respecting the law of land aur is he not respecting Indian constitution, you have any valid proof about going against the idea of India, our constitution depends on secularism and if he support secularism what is problem ❤ nafrat k bazaar m rahul ki mohabat ki dukhan jindabad
Life's lesson summarized in 20 mins. What a thought "No matter how you are or what you are, you are enough". What an actor Naseer Saab ... I seldom think why age & time takes away all what which we always wanted to cherish forever .... 😐
Age and time doesn’t ever takes away the things and the people you love , passage of time only adds up more memories and beauty to them which gets embodied in ours spirits. They are always with us. Ultimately we are the byproducts of them only. 🌸🦢. This short film is sheer piece of humanity. Thank you for this piece of Art.🌷.
Great story - never make assumptions. It appears Dipti (who is actually us) are more lacking in perception and understanding than the Alzheimer patient. In our smugness of thinking 'we know better than the poor dementiac' we made assumptions about Giri and fell flat on our faces. The Alzheimer patient was wiser than us! 😊
But it's not about who is wiser...also the watchman's statement can deceive anyone coz ladki ki baat ho hi nhi rhi thi, if u'll add such a sad music after a talk about prabha sabko yahi lagega his wife's dead Assumption shouldn't be confused with perception of a falsely presented stimulus so...yes she wrongly jumped to conclusions simply by seeing the circumstances and what rubbish like noting it on a book carelessly lying around No doubt CASE HISTORY exists!
Damn right never change yourself for the ones who love you because they will love you the way you exactly are... And always be self satisfied and complete... Only then people will look at you the same way... What beautiful masterpiece this movie is
If you are reckless then only lunatics will love you the way you are. A wise person's love is not there for the wishful thinking of an individual. One is ok with inevitable flaws but those that can be improved or removed must not be kept with the expectation that others are obliged to adopt to your perversions. "Practical life has boundaries which are nearly impossible to describe in words. It is a phenomenon like you can text the name of a scent to someone but you can't text the sent itself through words. Description itself has limits." (Javaid Ghamidi) That is why sweeping comments about life are hardly accepted by a properly reasoning mind.
There is no better actor or rather artist than Naseer Sir, who could have performed this role with perfection. Actors like Naseerudin Shah takes cinema to another level.
One fine example of how great writing, brilliant direction and excellent performances can turn the simplest of concepts into masterpieces. Kudos to the team!
We really need someone who say “No matter how you are or what you are you are enough ” Love is the thing that made us to live the life .. otherwise there is so much pain and sorrow in this world. Beautiful short film , giving this profiund message so delicately .
watching this short film is a roller coaster for me. I thought she starts hallucinating prabha too, that's how much she empathized with him. But, then when the gatekeeper told it was his daughter, and saw that pohe ka dabba, It again made me think how we( like Rasika Dugal) just live in our own world and listen half things and built our perceptions and start living our life with those half baked truths and then again it got me when she wore that nose ring that told me she has always liked wearing the nose ring but she has consoled her that she too doesn't like it. How often we curtail ourselves according to people and console ourselves that this is right. It is always tricky to strike a balance between how much we have to listen to people after all they are our loved ones and how much we don't' have to listen to people. Some one yesterday said to me " struggle is a constant and will always be a constant, today you are doing it for yourself, tomorrow you will do it for the society", So, Don't go through it hoping that it will end one day just embrace struggle and live through it.
My father was dementia patient he behaved same like this. I well know how to handle it's so difficult but love to spending to him, he was died since 2014 in age 69 💖
Wow!!! Perfect story: Kande pohe,prabha ma'am, janvi(hostel), nose mole,nose ring,Alzheimer patient and client problem and solution. Best story writing.. 👍👍
My mom too suffered with dementia really it is heart churning to see our loved going through this. An incredible performance by Naseeruddin sir . My eyes are welled up.
A great respect to Sarda sir and his total team, thanks to Naseeruddin Shah sir for his incredible acting.Thanks to D.O.P, casting & Story writer..love from West Bengal.
Such an amazing short story and the journey of Deepti who intended to work for someone at the end exits with her work done . And how a misunderstanding gave this whole plot a twist is mind-blowing.
This made me tear up, what a heartwarming film❤ Also as an aspiring psychologist, it made me understand what I'd read somewhere. While helping a client trying to understand themselves and cope with their problems, you sometimes also get to know and understand yourself better. And I think that's really beautiful. Will be coming back to this a lot for comfort
There couldn't be a better film! What a concept and twist! This is so perfect and always a treat to watch Naseer. Rasika Dugal, you just rock with your lesser expression, which is just enough. 11 out of 10.
Thank God, stumbled upon this gem if not so late. No matter what the political ideologies one person holds, one should not overlook the talent he/she possesses; deserves the due credit always.Naseeruddin shah has once again proved that he still comes in the top 5 great actors of cinema. Well acted by Raaika duggal too.
After "The Miniaturist Of Junagadh" Naseer Sahab and Rasika are back with bang, love their bonding and good message "No matter how you are or what you are, you are enough"
I feel so happy I have learned hindi and am able to understand these beautiful short movies without subtitles! Just please add subtitles for the whole world to enjoy this beauty. Such an amazing story and the ending! Actors' acting is also incredible!
@@romanslays3317 I'm from Greece and I am bilingual, Greek and Turkish. I fell in love with everything about India but aaj tak never been there. I was very lucky to have a hindi course at my university ☺
Read it. "You might think you don't matter in this world, but because of you, someone now likes themselves a little bit more because you made a passing comment that made them feel good. Someone has read a book you recommended and they got lost in the pages. Someone has remembered a joke you told them that made them smile to themselves on the bus. Someone has tried on an outfit and felt beautiful because you complimented them on it. Never think you don't have an impact, your fingerprints can't be wiped away from the little marks of kindness you've left on the world." *** ❤️ ㅤ ˡᶦᵏᵉ
Chintan Sarda's 'The Broken Table' is a masterpiece of visual storytelling. The way he explores themes of loss, regret, and reconciliation through the metaphor of a broken table is both innovative and evocative. The use of symbolism is profound, adding layers of meaning to every frame. The performances are outstanding, particularly in conveying the unspoken emotions that resonate long after the film ends. Sarda's direction is commendable for its ability to create a powerful narrative arc within a short runtime. 'The Broken Table' is a testament to the director's skill in crafting compelling stories that resonate deeply with audiences.
Such a fabulous acting by Naseeruddin Shah ! His energy to portray the character is unmatched. The story also gives a silent but important message that one should not assume without complete details. (Deepti just assumes that Prabha was dead, whereas the guard meant it for Giri's daughter) Loved how the therapy worked in the opposite way for Deepti in the end.
Amazing piece of work...d thot, concept, screenplay everything...and d most important thing, I never realised how time has turned me from a small kid in 90's, not understanding a thing from Naseer Sir's work of art den, into someone who adores n admires his craft, n every project he's been a part of...He's like a wizard, putting life into every single character dat he plays....👍👍👌👌👏👏
I have a cousin with this disease. She doesn’t remember her own daughter who takes care of her all the time and never allowed any care taker.But whenever I go and meet my cousin she remembers my name as well as my mothers name how we are related. But her daughter’s positive & jovial mood astonishes me with out any “uffs.😊 Direction story and acting hats off.
The central thread of the story is listening and how deceving can be our understanding of other feeling. As usual Nasiruddin Sha and Rasika acting is of different level, just fits into the character so well. Another good short film.
Worth watching short film it's such a great short film the best I've seen till now and will remember it for a very long time it's so beautiful 😍 ❤ the Way Naseer Sir acts has so much depth in his acting and Rasika Ma'am is one of the best such a fine actor at her art but still she doesn't gets the roles she deserve and her due as an actor till now I've seen her many roles and sometimes I feel Bollywood doesn't deserve any good actors
I have a cousin with this disease. She doesn’t remember her own daughter who takes care of her all the time and never allowed any care taker.But whenever I go and meet my cousin she remembers my name as well as my mothers name how we are related. But her daughter’s positive & jovial mood astonishes me with out any “uffs.😊
Please please cum up with more such films...the world badly is in need of these life elevating lessons...what a timeless story this is...❤❤❤ Naseer Saab and Rasika...hats down 🙌❤
Naseer-saheb is always the BEST actor... I genuinely desired to cast him in my project back in 2004 but it didn't work... Amazing movie, impeccable performances by all actors especially Naseer-ji... I hope and wish I get to work with him one day... Bravo!!!
Excellent piece of cinema. Short. Crisp. Deep. Great direction. Brilliant writing and gajab ki acting. Now this is the experience we have been craving for long. Kudos to the whole team
A visual feast that is soothing to the soul and pleasing to the eyes. The movie encourages us to search within and mend ourselves with the true intention of progressing to the good.
Fabulous incredible story. Bravo Naseer Saab, you are indisputably most acclaimed methodical Actor in our Film fraternity. I cried and cried for your performance. A tight salute to Alchemist to another Alchemist. Rasika ji regards and affection to you. Bravo to all team
Moral: we must face challenges,and accept truth how hard it is...and always tell truth to ur partners,relatives etc because they help them to heal and support ur problem...nice concept....like it
What an emotional storyline , gives goosebumps every minute. Naseerunddin Shah is really a great artist and wonderfully matched by Rasika Duggal in expressions and acting. Rule number one is the crux of the story !
Naseeruddij Shah's acting is amazing as usual. Omg. He has my ❤️❤️❤️. So real! Rasika Duggal also is great. Not east to act in front of a veteran. Great film.
Amazing story line...beautifully depicted emotions...took me also to a shock when Prabha appears on the screen. Life is always having answers to our problems. We have to seek for it.
Sir Nasiruddin Shah is a great actor. He has become an inspiration to aspiring actors around the world, leaving an indelible mark on indian cinema and theatre.
An excellent work of Art. We are thankful that Nasir is still active in work-field to give us limitless great performance. Background music is fantastic. Waiting for more this kind of genius film.
Wonderful movie..but it's always what I say from my side..royal stag awarded short movies are fantastic superb..thank you so much for making these types of movies..
I am medical student bsc nursing .exam ki bhag dodh me Subhe ki 5.33 par yhe video mujhe ek apna zindagi zing kaa trikaa sikhaa gyi ❤ love you lots❤❤!!!!!!
no words man, this was such a heart touching movie, i usually don't cry much but this film seriously made me cry..kudos to the team who made this wonderful masterpiece, no words :)
What a great story. Everyone going through some sort of issues in their life but most important is how they handles the situtation by accepting the facts. If we are able to recognize our flaws and tries to understand ourselves first everything fall into line. however, sometimes we can even give a try to accept it. This masterpiece told us that no matter what we will be there for ourselves❤❤ Blessed to watch naseer sir broken table story.
"Rule No. 1: Tum jaisee bhi hoo, kaafi hoo" is not the gist of this great short but life as well. One must accepts God's gift of life as gifted by Him. Both Naseeruddin saab and Rasika mohtarmah have given a tremendous performance. Title is a bit confusing, because more appropriate title would have been: "RULE NO. 1." On the whole engrossing Short with burning issues of Alzheimer's and misconceive.
Well it's not really confusing and I understand that the table was just for a very short period of time but it has a great impact. And although the whole story might not really revolve around it but the message of the story does. The table was painted by his wife to beautify it. The wife could have easily be disgusted at the very sight of the broken table but she didn't. The broken table depicts we as humans who have so many broken parts in our personality. We ain't perfect but can be beautiful if we accept who we are. The painting that she made was not to hide that the table was broken but to show that flaws are what that makes us human and we are beautiful. ❤
@@k_chirsoo1729 I completely endorse your views. Thanks. Hum jaisee bhi hain, kaafi hain, achae hain, because He made us like that -- perfect human beings; He never does anything wrong. We humans are full of flaws and always look the same in others without appreciating person's qualities. Thanks once again.
@@nareshdev4119 ohh it's ok please don't thank me. But there's one thing I wanna correct. God never made us perfect nd that's the difference between us and God. We are meant to be imperfect and that's what is beautiful about us. Well hope you have a nice day ahead ✨
this is not easy to handle a person who is suffering from forgiveness !! even i am also gone through this where my grandmother was suffering from this 😢 she was yelling , forgive things and many more this was happened about 3 years after that i was also done 😔 but i remember the day when she takecare of me !!
So wholesome!!!! Please keep making short movies. I have watched all of them from your channel and now I have run out of content to watch while I am eating.
The Rule no. 1- “Tum jaise bhi ho…kaafi ho” such a deep message. Worth watching film. ❤
The Rule No.1 - "Tum Jaise Bhi Ho Kafi Ho "
What ever you are.. It's fine
The line is for the doctor, caretaker.
The line is not for everyone in everytime.
To whom it is saying it's depends.
@@soumyaprashanth1452Regardless of how you are, you are ENOUGH!
True❤
loved the thing that he forgot everything, from how his grandson looks to when his last hearing was ...but remembers exactly in which colour box her wife kept poha for him this morning.
The love and bond is fantastic 😅
Beautiful characterization. She came to take care of and study a patient, but the patient treated her through his conversation. And what an ending.
Your appreciation moves us to create great content! 🖤
@@LargeShortFilms Having been a full time carer for my mother who had dementia, I would like to stress that more on this topic is required so as to bring wider public awareness of this horrible disease that is now afflicting not only the aged, but also the younger population.
It is especially important to open this topic to discussion in south Asians who are usually in denial of this affliction. This cause unnecessary suffering in families and communities. The message should perhaps be played out in a series of plays detailing - causes, diagnosis and care of dementia, in addition to lifestyle changes that minimise the risk of dementia.
May all be happy.
I'm eating
खूप सुंदर ❤😊धन्यवाद @@LargeShortFilms
Yes beautiful....but if there was no watchman at the house....patient would have left the house kabka ...so she failed as a caretaker
What a beautiful storyline!! She was called to help the Alzheimer's patient but instead she found help for her own depressed state of mind. Life comes with a lot of unexpected twists and turns at times. ❤
❤
Soooooooo beautifully, explained, you are right
If it’s a whatever is beautiful for, of course I would love to pray 🙏🏻 Bhagwan, bring it in life of Account-user podcast wala.
🙏🏻 amen 🙏🏻
❤❤❤ĺ❤❤❤
Aa@as a😊aaaaaaaaaaaa@@@tanmaycreations3609
We don't need to loose a person to know their worth...Loving each other when you have them along can make life more valuable...a adorable story 💗
Lose.
lose
Don't ignore yourself. You are more important to your own self than anybody else's.
I watched this movie just because of Naseeeruddin Shah sir. He is one of the most talented actor and an institute for learning in acting. Every time he comes with betterment no matter he is in short film or in a movie the perfection is every where . we are proud of you sir and feeling lucky to have incredible actor like you in Indian Cinema.
He is obviously talented but try to watch others ' short films also who are trying to establish themselves and not dependent on giving oil to anyone .
The happiness I got in the end when I found out that his wife is alive,, is so precious that I can't explain,,a short story gave me immense pleasure,, wow
This is the Hallmark of an Intelligent Script Writer. He made viewers Think that his wife was DEAD and perhaps that Aggravated his Condition: that may be he Was Hallucinating- another disorder!
I am a writer myself, a good one too, but even i Was Taken by surprise when his Wife Walks In!!! That was The High Point in the story. Initially seemed like He was Hallucinating as usual but the caregivers Confused and 'Controlled Shocked' Reaction revealed the Twist in the tale - 2 people cant be Hallucinating....at the Sametime...about the same person!
Saw it twice to see if the writer had fooled the viewers in some way but he had all ends covered...he even talked about his wife in the PRESENT TENSE...all in all, a good, engaging story with an unexpected and unpredictable End- another Convincing Hallmark of an Intelligent Writer
Ppp00😅@@sherrymalik7481
A son taking care of his father. That's us. That's who we are. We don't leave them behind. Thank you for this.
Also daughter can take care
why u say *we* isn't it universal?
Hire a caregiver. Your wife is not your parent's personal maid. Not talking about you, but the majority of asian culture imposes daughter in law to take care of the husband's parents.
Us & who we are doesn’t mean anything at all,caring for once parents is universal, different people do it in different ways
What about a daughter?
God... The details.. Rasika wearing that nose ring at the end.. That was so subtle and meaningful. Wish there were so many of such stories.
that was the part i didnt understand. what does it means?
@@vipulgupta6949 It was all about acceptance. When two people are together, they shall be open about both good and bad of each other. Hiding something from the other just to make sure the relationship goes fine will not really help. Similarly, expressing likes and dislikes is fine but that shall not impact the kind of person someone is. Deepti didn't wear the nose ring because Dhruv didn't like it on her and he felt she looked like an idiot. When she wears it at the end of the story, that signifies her realization of this.
@@nishantsingh650very well explained 🎉🎊..
there was nothing subtle about it, it was so damn obvious unless you lack brain cells.
Beautiful film in every sense!
Ah! This hits home.
My mother is 67.. she got early onset Alzheimer’s at 57. These 10 yrs have been totally devastating for the whole family as she was the main pillar.
It’s been 4 yrs since she stopped recognizing us.. it’s gut wrenching and extremely painful for us when she looks at us with a blank expression… knowing that she is the same person whose eyes would sparkle and have a big smile on her face looking at her family!
How can god be soo cruel !!
🙁🙁 More love and power to your family..🤍🤍
@@avishekbiswas855 🙏
More power and strength to you and your family 💖
@@ankitajoshi1379 🙏
i wish all the strength and best for you and your family.
Naseeruddin Shah's profound impact on the world of acting is a testament to his immense talent, dedication, and versatility. With his powerful performances and passion for the craft, he has become an inspiration to aspiring actors around the world, leaving an indelible mark on Indian cinema and theatre.
@@amritrao882 Your actions and beliefs are unacceptable and do not align with the values of a tolerant and respectful society. Everyone deserves to be treated with dignity, regardless of their religion or beliefs. Your hateful behavior only fuels division and intolerance, and has no place in a civilized society. I urge you to reflect on your actions and work towards empathy and understanding for people of all backgrounds.
@@amritrao882.... instead of praising one of the greatest actors, you are worrying abt his religion???!!!.... stop being so pathetic n petty!!!!!
@@amritrao882u r being sarcastic?
Naseer Sahab is an institution in himself..
@@amritrao882 I hope you are just being sarcastic because if not then you are definitely either drunk or mentally not well 🙄🤔
Thank God, stumbled upon this gem if not so late. No matter what the political ideologies one person holds, one should not overlook the talent the artist possesses; deserves the due credit always.Naseeruddin shah has once again proved that he still comes in the top 5 great actors of cinema. Well acted by Rasika duggal too.
Ji
Rasika is an amazing actor love her in A Suitable Boy ❤
What do you mean by political ideologies ? Is he not respecting the law of land aur is he not respecting Indian constitution, you have any valid proof about going against the idea of India, our constitution depends on secularism and if he support secularism what is problem ❤ nafrat k bazaar m rahul ki mohabat ki dukhan jindabad
Well said 😊👍
My thoughts exactly. 🙏🏻
Life's lesson summarized in 20 mins. What a thought "No matter how you are or what you are, you are enough". What an actor Naseer Saab ... I seldom think why age & time takes away all what which we always wanted to cherish forever .... 😐
Age and time doesn’t ever takes away the things and the people you love , passage of time only adds up more memories and beauty to them which gets embodied in ours spirits. They are always with us. Ultimately we are the byproducts of them only. 🌸🦢. This short film is sheer piece of humanity. Thank you for this piece of Art.🌷.
@@priyasangwan1538 Beautifully wrote!
Great story - never make assumptions. It appears Dipti (who is actually us) are more lacking in perception and understanding than the Alzheimer patient. In our smugness of thinking 'we know better than the poor dementiac' we made assumptions about Giri and fell flat on our faces. The Alzheimer patient was wiser than us! 😊
But it's not about who is wiser...also the watchman's statement can deceive anyone coz ladki ki baat ho hi nhi rhi thi, if u'll add such a sad music after a talk about prabha sabko yahi lagega his wife's dead
Assumption shouldn't be confused with perception of a falsely presented stimulus so...yes she wrongly jumped to conclusions simply by seeing the circumstances and what rubbish like noting it on a book carelessly lying around
No doubt CASE HISTORY exists!
Naseer Saab, what can I say about his talent. He is the soul of each and every character.
Damn right never change yourself for the ones who love you because they will love you the way you exactly are... And always be self satisfied and complete... Only then people will look at you the same way... What beautiful masterpiece this movie is
If you are reckless then only lunatics will love you the way you are.
A wise person's love is not there for the wishful thinking of an individual.
One is ok with inevitable flaws but those that can be improved or removed must not be kept with the expectation that others are obliged to adopt to your perversions.
"Practical life has boundaries which are nearly impossible to describe in words. It is a phenomenon like you can text the name of a scent to someone but you can't text the sent itself through words. Description itself has limits." (Javaid Ghamidi)
That is why sweeping comments about life are hardly accepted by a properly reasoning mind.
There is no better actor or rather artist than Naseer Sir, who could have performed this role with perfection. Actors like Naseerudin Shah takes cinema to another level.
One fine example of how great writing, brilliant direction and excellent performances can turn the simplest of concepts into masterpieces. Kudos to the team!
We really need someone who say “No matter how you are or what you are you are enough ”
Love is the thing that made us to live the life .. otherwise there is so much pain and sorrow in this world.
Beautiful short film , giving this profiund message so delicately .
I am confused of Janvi mam, security says jab se janwi mam gayi Ha inko... Actually prabha ke bare mai tha Nasruden ka pain or Janvi?
watching this short film is a roller coaster for me. I thought she starts hallucinating prabha too, that's how much she empathized with him. But, then when the gatekeeper told it was his daughter, and saw that pohe ka dabba, It again made me think how we( like Rasika Dugal) just live in our own world and listen half things and built our perceptions and start living our life with those half baked truths and then again it got me when she wore that nose ring that told me she has always liked wearing the nose ring but she has consoled her that she too doesn't like it.
How often we curtail ourselves according to people and console ourselves that this is right.
It is always tricky to strike a balance between how much we have to listen to people after all they are our loved ones and how much we don't' have to listen to people.
Some one yesterday said to me " struggle is a constant and will always be a constant, today you are doing it for yourself, tomorrow you will do it for the society", So, Don't go through it hoping that it will end one day just embrace struggle and live through it.
My father was dementia patient he behaved same like this. I well know how to handle it's so difficult but love to spending to him, he was died since 2014 in age 69 💖
💙
@@unsuccessfulfatshow 💓💓💓 Thanks. Naseeruddin Sahab is marvelous actor no words made to describe his talent.
For one minute of stage performance he spent many months abroad ..Such a Passion for his craft!!
Oh this actor!!!! 😍😍😍😍Naseeruddin Shah is a blessing for us audience.
Bada hee bakwas insan hai ye.
Fantastic....Nasserji and radhika Duggal..what an acting..a big thumbs up for writer, director
How can they teach such valuable relationship fundamentals in 20 minutes... commendable 👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻..I am amazed 🥰🥰
Absolutely brilliant . Mr Shah could only pull off such a sterling performance
Wow!!! Perfect story:
Kande pohe,prabha ma'am, janvi(hostel), nose mole,nose ring,Alzheimer patient and client problem and solution.
Best story writing.. 👍👍
My mom too suffered with dementia really it is heart churning to see our loved going through this. An incredible performance by Naseeruddin sir . My eyes are welled up.
A great respect to Sarda sir and his total team, thanks to Naseeruddin Shah sir for his incredible acting.Thanks to D.O.P, casting & Story writer..love from West Bengal.
Hi Soumyadip, I am a senior woman and an Actress too. I would like to be cast in such films. Please tell me how can I approach them?
Mam sorry to say I am also a vfx artist but I have no information about casting 🙂
Great acting by Naseeruddin and Rasika. Naseeruddin is renowned for his acting. Rasika is a gem. Her expressions are excellent!
Such an amazing short story and the journey of Deepti who intended to work for someone at the end exits with her work done . And how a misunderstanding gave this whole plot a twist is mind-blowing.
This made me tear up, what a heartwarming film❤
Also as an aspiring psychologist, it made me understand what I'd read somewhere. While helping a client trying to understand themselves and cope with their problems, you sometimes also get to know and understand yourself better. And I think that's really beautiful.
Will be coming back to this a lot for comfort
There couldn't be a better film! What a concept and twist! This is so perfect and always a treat to watch Naseer. Rasika Dugal, you just rock with your lesser expression, which is just enough. 11 out of 10.
Thank God, stumbled upon this gem if not so late. No matter what the political ideologies one person holds, one should not overlook the talent he/she possesses; deserves the due credit always.Naseeruddin shah has once again proved that he still comes in the top 5 great actors of cinema. Well acted by Raaika duggal too.
Can anybody write the rule no 1 that progga told in english??
Brilliant script, direction, cast, music, and acting. Very tight editing. You guys rock. Keep making movies and telling stories!
After "The Miniaturist Of Junagadh" Naseer Sahab and Rasika are back with bang, love their bonding and good message "No matter how you are or what you are, you are enough"
I feel so happy I have learned hindi and am able to understand these beautiful short movies without subtitles! Just please add subtitles for the whole world to enjoy this beauty. Such an amazing story and the ending! Actors' acting is also incredible!
😶 the subtitles are already there
@@sigmafather Yes, they are now they were not earlier 😊
@@emelosman13 Where are you from? How did you learn Hindi?
@@romanslays3317 I'm from Greece and I am bilingual, Greek and Turkish. I fell in love with everything about India but aaj tak never been there. I was very lucky to have a hindi course at my university ☺
@@emelosman13 Wow! Glad to hear that you love India and have taken serious efforts to learn the language. Much appreciated!:)
Literally, Work of Art.
Most of the Indian Audience still needs another decade to feel this taste.....
Why is it so underrated when the legend is there in this
every role performed by Naseeruddin Shah becomes master piece.
Read it.
"You might think you don't matter in this world, but because of you, someone now likes themselves a little bit more because you made a passing comment that made them feel good. Someone has read a book you recommended and they got lost in the pages. Someone has remembered a joke you told them that made them smile to themselves on the bus. Someone has tried on an outfit and felt beautiful because you complimented them on it. Never think you don't have an impact, your fingerprints can't be wiped away from the little marks of kindness you've left on the world."
***
❤️ ㅤ
ˡᶦᵏᵉ
❤✨❤🩹
My Mother ❤️
That's all it reminded me of...
& tears...
That's all I have in my eyes now...
Thank you so much for this,
I needed this. ❤️
"Prabha was like a constant" - Giri forgot many things but her never !
Chintan Sarda's 'The Broken Table' is a masterpiece of visual storytelling. The way he explores themes of loss, regret, and reconciliation through the metaphor of a broken table is both innovative and evocative. The use of symbolism is profound, adding layers of meaning to every frame. The performances are outstanding, particularly in conveying the unspoken emotions that resonate long after the film ends. Sarda's direction is commendable for its ability to create a powerful narrative arc within a short runtime. 'The Broken Table' is a testament to the director's skill in crafting compelling stories that resonate deeply with audiences.
What an acting, what an end !! Simply brilliant. Far better than cheap thrills from bollywood. Keep up the good work 👍💐
So true 👍😊
*"No matter what you are, you are enough"*
Let me cry all one in my bed. Thank you.
What an outstanding ending…feels like having finished reading a short story
The line ' tum jaise bhi ho kafi ho ' hits me a lot.. beautiful ❣️
Thank you for making me crying happily! THANK YOU!
🙏🌷
Such a fabulous acting by Naseeruddin Shah ! His energy to portray the character is unmatched. The story also gives a silent but important message that one should not assume without complete details. (Deepti just assumes that Prabha was dead, whereas the guard meant it for Giri's daughter) Loved how the therapy worked in the opposite way for Deepti in the end.
Nasiruddin Shah ji really brilliant actor i have always admired him since my childhood.🙏
Amazing piece of work...d thot, concept, screenplay everything...and d most important thing, I never realised how time has turned me from a small kid in 90's, not understanding a thing from Naseer Sir's work of art den, into someone who adores n admires his craft, n every project he's been a part of...He's like a wizard, putting life into every single character dat he plays....👍👍👌👌👏👏
*Naseer-u-Deen* *Shah* is living legend actor & human
Love you from 🇵🇰✌️
Left me in tears 🥺🥺
Prabha's voice was so calm and healing
The way she said thank you!
What an Awesome Actor Naseeruddin Sir.. 😍😍👍 Hat's off to this Talented Man.. 💕
The relationship between an Alzheimer's patient & his client with a soothing lesson reminds "Scent of a Woman" of Al Pacino ❤Nasir sir ❤
Naseer ji n Rasika , nothing but respect 😊❤❤❤
I have a cousin with this disease. She doesn’t remember her own daughter who takes care of her all the time and never allowed any care taker.But whenever I go and meet my cousin she remembers my name as well as my mothers name how we are related. But her daughter’s positive & jovial mood astonishes me with out any “uffs.😊
Direction story and acting hats off.
ये कहानी और लंबी होनी चाहिए थी ..Such a beautiful and Hearttouching story ❤
Bunnu, ye jo kahani damdar Ho toh uske lambe chote se ky hi farak
@@anubhavmishra8744 Achhha jiii
@@surbhisuman2 Haaan Jiii
Rule number 1:- No matter what you are,You are enough ❣️
i never seen an imazing and full of lesson in a short time movie,
FEROZE ALI SHAH FROM
MY LOVELY PAKISTAN
Wow!!! This movie is worth more than any 2 hours movie. Makes you contemplate a lot about things. Masterpiece!
The central thread of the story is listening and how deceving can be our understanding of other feeling. As usual Nasiruddin Sha and Rasika acting is of different level, just fits into the character
so well. Another good short film.
What a brilliant observation. Thank you for sharing. 🙏
Worth watching short film it's such a great short film the best I've seen till now and will remember it for a very long time it's so beautiful 😍 ❤ the Way Naseer Sir acts has so much depth in his acting and Rasika Ma'am is one of the best such a fine actor at her art but still she doesn't gets the roles she deserve and her due as an actor till now I've seen her many roles and sometimes I feel Bollywood doesn't deserve any good actors
This piece of art should be part of the cirriculum for all acting schools and movie making schools.
We're honored that you thought it is a work of art. Thank you for your encouraging words! 🖤
Incredible……speechless…. What a performance by Naseer and Rasika .
A very interesting, high quality short-film with iconic actors...the topic is really praiseworthy...Alzheimer's patients need love & care. 😊
We're flattered that you found it praiseworthy. Thanks for the encouraging words! 🖤
I have a cousin with this disease. She doesn’t remember her own daughter who takes care of her all the time and never allowed any care taker.But whenever I go and meet my cousin she remembers my name as well as my mothers name how we are related. But her daughter’s positive & jovial mood astonishes me with out any “uffs.😊
Please please cum up with more such films...the world badly is in need of these life elevating lessons...what a timeless story this is...❤❤❤
Naseer Saab and Rasika...hats down 🙌❤
Naseer-saheb is always the BEST actor... I genuinely desired to cast him in my project back in 2004 but it didn't work... Amazing movie, impeccable performances by all actors especially Naseer-ji... I hope and wish I get to work with him one day... Bravo!!!
Excellent piece of cinema. Short. Crisp. Deep. Great direction. Brilliant writing and gajab ki acting. Now this is the experience we have been craving for long. Kudos to the whole team
A visual feast that is soothing to the soul and pleasing to the eyes. The movie encourages us to search within and mend ourselves with the true intention of progressing to the good.
Fabulous incredible story. Bravo Naseer
Saab, you are indisputably most acclaimed methodical
Actor in our Film fraternity. I cried and cried for your performance. A tight salute to Alchemist to another Alchemist. Rasika ji regards and affection to you. Bravo to all team
Nice presentation, my father is also Alzheimer's patient. I can understand this situations.
Moral: we must face challenges,and accept truth how hard it is...and always tell truth to ur partners,relatives etc because they help them to heal and support ur problem...nice concept....like it
Thanks 👍 I don't get that
What an emotional storyline , gives goosebumps every minute. Naseerunddin Shah is really a great artist and wonderfully matched by Rasika Duggal in expressions and acting. Rule number one is the crux of the story !
Naseeruddij Shah's acting is amazing as usual. Omg. He has my ❤️❤️❤️. So real! Rasika Duggal also is great. Not east to act in front of a veteran. Great film.
I'm literally in tears right now, let me touch your feet Chintan Bhai 🙏🏻
i couldn't get the concept but the last line was enough to love this masterpiece......tum jaisi bhi ho kafii ho.....
Nasiruddin is just superb.I admire him from his Akrosh, Manthan and Nishant days. He has no parallel.
This is an eye opener for woman who feel lost and less valued.
Amazing story line...beautifully depicted emotions...took me also to a shock when Prabha appears on the screen. Life is always having answers to our problems. We have to seek for it.
Sir Nasiruddin Shah is a great actor. He has become an inspiration to aspiring actors around the world, leaving an indelible mark on indian cinema and theatre.
….,actors around the world ….?? Wow? ?.?
An excellent work of Art. We are thankful that Nasir is still active in work-field to give us limitless great performance. Background music is fantastic. Waiting for more this kind of genius film.
This is the best thing i have seen for so long , just cannot explain. Movie writing at its best
The way he was looking at door waiting for prabha ji … I would be so mad if director do not let prabha come in through that door
Soo emotional 😭😭😭
Wonderful movie..but it's always what I say from my side..royal stag awarded short movies are fantastic superb..thank you so much for making these types of movies..
I am medical student bsc nursing .exam ki bhag dodh me Subhe ki 5.33 par yhe video mujhe ek apna zindagi zing kaa trikaa sikhaa gyi ❤ love you lots❤❤!!!!!!
no words man, this was such a heart touching movie, i usually don't cry much but this film seriously made me cry..kudos to the team who made this wonderful masterpiece, no words :)
What a great story. Everyone going through some sort of issues in their life but most important is how they handles the situtation by accepting the facts. If we are able to recognize our flaws and tries to understand ourselves first everything fall into line. however, sometimes we can even give a try to accept it. This masterpiece told us that no matter what we will be there for ourselves❤❤
Blessed to watch naseer sir broken table story.
Naseeruddin Shah is really a living legend of indian cinema.
I was looking for something new from Naseer and I found this beautifully presented short…job so well done guys…
"Rule No. 1: Tum jaisee bhi hoo, kaafi hoo" is not the gist of this great short but life as well. One must accepts God's gift of life as gifted by Him. Both Naseeruddin saab and Rasika mohtarmah have given a tremendous performance. Title is a bit confusing, because more appropriate title would have been: "RULE NO. 1." On the whole engrossing Short with burning issues of Alzheimer's and misconceive.
Well it's not really confusing and I understand that the table was just for a very short period of time but it has a great impact. And although the whole story might not really revolve around it but the message of the story does. The table was painted by his wife to beautify it. The wife could have easily be disgusted at the very sight of the broken table but she didn't. The broken table depicts we as humans who have so many broken parts in our personality. We ain't perfect but can be beautiful if we accept who we are. The painting that she made was not to hide that the table was broken but to show that flaws are what that makes us human and we are beautiful. ❤
@@k_chirsoo1729 I completely endorse your views. Thanks. Hum jaisee bhi hain, kaafi hain, achae hain, because He made us like that -- perfect human beings; He never does anything wrong. We humans are full of flaws and always look the same in others without appreciating person's qualities. Thanks once again.
@@nareshdev4119 ohh it's ok please don't thank me. But there's one thing I wanna correct. God never made us perfect nd that's the difference between us and God. We are meant to be imperfect and that's what is beautiful about us. Well hope you have a nice day ahead ✨
this is not easy to handle a person who is suffering from forgiveness !! even i am also gone through this where my grandmother was suffering from this 😢 she was yelling , forgive things and many more this was happened about 3 years after that i was also done 😔 but i remember the day when she takecare of me !!
Well made, well acted, well written, film. 10/10.
So wholesome!!!! Please keep making short movies. I have watched all of them from your channel and now I have run out of content to watch while I am eating.
This film reminds me of this Japanese book I read some years back. It was Yōko Ogawa's The Housekeeper and The Professor. ❤
Watched some months ago first time and can't forget about it all the time... So watched again today when I'm feeling low.
Salute Naseer sahab, once again!
Naseeruddin shah's acting>>>>>
The same with Rasika Duggal 💗✨. Loved this. Make more of this please.