Hi Doc, I’ve just watched black belt barristers take on Heard’s statement, he asks if anyone with psychological knowledge would be interested in doing an episode with him. I’ve written in his comments and suggested you! Please give it some thought as I’d definitely be watching it, your both brilliant within your own expertise. Depp is the victim in this case, Heard has done far more damage. Great video, truly professional as always 🌹
Hard agree with this. You'd be a really helpful asset to contribute your experience and knowledge, doc. Especially because of your expert witness experience.
If AH was being "robbed of her freedom of speech" HOW IS SHE RELEASING A STATEMENT VIA WORLDWIDE TELEVISION. ..!? As a survivor I'm sickened by her behavior and feel AH is tainting the value of truth.. She has reopened wounds in me that I've worked 10 years to close. 😳
I know the feeling she did the same thing to me I saw my abuser and Amber Heard and she has open wounds that I thought I had overcome Amber Heard is such a evil looking person
You're correct. Freedom of speech relates to being able to speak out against the government without legal repercussions. There are many limitations to freedom of speech INCLUDING defamation. This is an erroneous argument.
That lady is a full house of cluster b disorders. She is narc, borderline, histrionic, anti-social, and SADISTIC. one of the worst psychopaths that I've ever seen. The only person that is still there for her that continues to take her abuse is her sister. And she is severely abusive to her sister. She used her sister as a punching bag (literally and metaphorically) she was also very abusive to her parents as well. She has shown to have zero empathy for any of her family or close friends. And she seems to enjoy feeling powerful in the way she abused and used everyone who has ever cared about her. She is a psychopath of a severely dangerous level. My two cents.
The truth is 1. She lied lied lied. 2. She is so narcissistic she can’t believe her lies weren’t believed. 3. She is hated because of the narrative of not only being a victim, which she is not, but that she had the audacity to get out there and act like a spokesperson for real DV victims and 4. We are all woke to the devious, maliciousness and evil intent of narcissists and are tired of them always getting away with what they do because they are able to lie their way out of their own doing. We are happy to see one go down…FINALLY!!!!
The Johnny Depp on the stand is the same Johnny Depp in the audio & video recordings, & the same Johnny Depp we've seen in interviews going all the way back to the beginning of his career. He's far from perfect, but he IS consistent! The Amber on the stand is WILDLY different from the Amber we saw & heard in those recordings, & different from the Amber we see in the media. I suffer from Borderline Personality Disorder, so I understand that we are chameleons who can adapt our whole persona according to the circumstances. But I also understand this sort of behavior does NOTHING but damage where our authenticity is concerned. She's the frightened victim. She's the raging b**ch. She's the courageous & proud survivor representing all women everywhere (uh, yeah, no thanks, I don't want you representing me). Who IS Amber? No one really knows, coz unlike Mr Consistent, Johnny Depp, Amber is ALL OVER THE PLACE!!! THAT is what hurt her credibility more than anything. THAT is why the jury didn't believe her. Nevermind the evidence (or lack thereof), The jury, just like the rest of us, could not reconcile the persona that sat before them on the stand with the person they saw & heard in those recordings. Meanwhile, Johnny remained consistent every step of the way. She destroyed her own credibility by not choosing a persona & sticking with it. You can't be that raging b**ch AND that shrinking violet. One of those is a lie. She lies. She pretends to be things that she is not. THAT is why she lost the case, period. She can blame Johnny all she wants, his attorneys, social media, an unfair world...whatever. She did it to herself. No one else is to blame. And thank you, Dr Das, for pointing out that she lacks many of the core indicators of BPD. The one that stands out the most to me is her lack of shame & guilt over her behavior. It's almost a necessary part of the cycle that feeds into our ever-changing self image, that switch from knowing we are right to where our self-esteem bottoms out. Yeah, that happens because we feel shame & guilt about our behavior. Without that to knock us down again, we'd just tear an unrelenting path of destruction through the world! The unstable moods, yeah. The chaotic relationships, you bet! The intense fear of abandonment, yup. The co-morbid risky behavior like substance abuse, uh huh. The black & white thinking/splitting, plain as day. But no shame or guilt. I don't really see any self harm or suicidal gesturing either. And she hasn't come out with a story of abuse or neglect as a child. We don't get this way by happenstance! I'm not saying she doesn't suffer from BPD. She certainly has many BPD traits, but overall, I see her aligned better with Histrionic Personality Disorder. You know, it's in the same "dramatic" cluster, & there are some similarities, but that need to be the center of attention, & desire for male validation, bringing Elon Musk & James Franco into that penthouse that belonged to her husband, before the divorce papers were even filed! I can TOTALLY see the HPD running deep in her. I think mostly I just don't want people to think that I share the same personality disorder with Amber Heard since MY BPD manifests itself quite differently than hers. I read somewhere that there are 256 ways to be Borderline. I believe it. There are 9 characteristics used to diagnose BPD, of which you need only display 5 for a diagnosis. The symptoms you DO have vs the ones that you don't, & the severity of each symptom, in what order they disrupt your life the most, makes for a wide variety of combinations & overall manifestions. Just like NPD, many people who suffer from BPD do extremely well in their careers (while others can't hold down a job) because they are able to utilize their ability to manipulate to climb that corporate ladder. We can be quite different. That's all. Great upload. Great analysis. You are my go-to RUclips psychiatrist! Keep doing what you're doing! ✌🏼
Really? I never knew the Depp who texts his (also accused of dv) friends about hoping to find Amber's rotting corpse in a car, or fucking her corpse, existed. In fact I didn't mind Depp at all until what I saw of him in the private videos, the texts, and the way he presented in court. The man I saw there is very much like the man who abused me. How ready people are to excuse his behaviour speaks volumes about how we have not come very far at all on this issue. You don't have to not have a personality disorder to be a victim, nor even be a likable person. Nor do you have to always be honest. I have no doubt my former partner could convince you all either. You would like him, he's a very likable guy. Depp promised global humiliation of Amber, and got it.
Well, there is always Dr Tracy Marks...excellent wide-ranging content, check it out. 256 ways of being Borderline - where did you get that information from? Why if you claim to have the features of BPD do you call her a "raging bXXth?
I love your insight here. I have multiple female friends with BPD and Amber is radically different. None of them is this bad, even at their worst. The worst-affected friend I've had wasn't this bad, and I needed to combine the traits of somebody else I knew, who I believe is a malignant narcissist, in order to get anywhere close to what we've seen from Amber. So many of the borderline traits cross over with other Cluster B disorders. Fear of abandonment might be the only one Amber seems to have that is purely BPD-specific.
Totally agree. Like she never admitted any bad behavior, but when asked about it on TV, THEN she said she did horrible things. It's only when she knows what face to show that she morphs into it. Interested to see what's ahead she'll never shut up
I was neutral on the AH v JD thing prior to the trial. Ah came across as a liar and was, frankly, very unlikable. I'm now fully on team JD and it is completely because of her own testimony.
Agree totally with you. I had no idea of them before this case, so no preconception. I do recall my sons talking of Johnny and the pirate thing. When the film was released, that's all I ever heard about either of them. I am not into celebrities or celebrity gossip.
Omg “Heard immunity “ I feel both entitled to that apology and also can’t say I didn’t smile at the pun!😁 Mostly I love that you said it at all!!.. even tho you know how cheeseball it is to say😂👏👏👏👍
She reminds me so much of my narcissistic ex roomie and my sociopath ex husband. "Don't tell me no lies and keep your hands to yourself."- The Georgia Satellites, Keep Your Hands To Yourself
Is it possible that her repeated assertions that she is a representative of women is an indicator of grandiose thinking? ( I mean, she is no more a representative of me that a crocodile is a representative of leather shoes). Or is it a manipulative technique to save her ego where she can be seen as a martyr character who lost but for something bigger than herself. Either way, I guess both concepts are steeped in the kind of over inflated sense of self and entitlement.
This isn’t the first time AH declared herself the representative, spokesperson or advocate- even aside from the case, and aside from her op-Ed claims as a spokesperson and advocate for DV and SA, she has claimed this authority/position for other non-profits and even in defense of The Playboy Club, a TV show that when heavily criticized AH who had a supporting role in the show as a bunny said in interviews that she felt like an “unintentional spokesperson” for the show when defending it to the media. As a survivor of IPV/DV and SA, her assertion of being a “public figure representing victims” has always felt grandiose and disingenuous… it also created a feeling of distrust of her for me, because as a survivor, I felt my voice was silenced and mocked for so long that speaking for other survivors without their request like AH has done would be perpetrating the abusive denial of their voice and autonomy. I guess I just see it as a situation where you can’t claim to be a representative for a community if all you are doing is using your voice to tell your own story and not for change or to uplift others who are within the community also.
I guess the big problem is if she can't help it, should we blame her,? At the same time is she allowed to hurt and damage others? And what about here little baby if she really exists?
I love how you analyze things. My mom is a psychologist so really grew up with this kind of stiff from her. But she's 65 now and didn't get into the case at all so very nice to hear it from someone who is more up to date on psychology. I do think it's a field that's becoming more of a hard science so I do think younger professionals are a bit better then older.
I don't know many people who claim(in Ambers case)or are victims of domestic violence would be so defensive or not admit to their foibles,or own acts of aggression. She was so defensive as to come across angry and insincere.
As a lawyer, I can say you had it right on analyzing the legal principles in this case and Amber's claims. It actually had nothing to do with freedom of speech because she defamed him.
Narcissist's It Didn't Happen And If It Did, It Wasn't that Bad And It It Was, It Wasn't A Big Deal And If It Is, It Wasn't My Fault And If It Was, I Didn't Mean It And If I Did, You Deserved It Wow, wow! It dose sound like AH‼️
She counter sued Johnny for statements his lawyer made and she won two million dollars for that, and yet she still wants to say she should be able to say whatever she wants because...freedom of speech.
My ex was just like her and made my life hell for years by turning everyone against me. I'm worried about Heard's child that's going to be raised by a narcissist. The way she twists everything to her narrative turns my stomach and there are still people who believe her.
Heard is fascinating. She's clearly intelligent so I find it hard to believe that she thinks there is nothing wrong with her. Her father is aggressive and nasty and when Depp turned the cash machine off to Amber, her father threatened to shoot Depp!! Camille Vasquez pointed out to everyone including Amber that while Depp had a plethora of support from all sorts of people, she had only her sister. She must at least suspect that she has a disorder, surely. What I find absolutely fascinating is when people do bad things, whether it's murder or making up lies to destroy your spouse's career after he turns the cash machine off, they then decide to slip into the role of victim. I had the pleasure of seeing Ross Kemp give a speech and he's seen everything! He was once tasked with interviewing a man in India who had raped and murdered around 200 women (he lost count!!). Kemp said he didn't want to go anywhere near this creature but was eventually persuaded to carry out the interview. He said when he entered the room, the man immediately burst into tears and claimed it wasn't his fault!!! Kemp left the room without speaking. What is this victim business about? Why do people who do bad things slip into the role of victim ONLY when they get caught out??
Wow I didn’t know that the dad threatened to shoot him . I didn’t watch beginning of trial was it said then ? I did know her father had made some money by hosting illegal dog fights .
@@summertimesunshine2444 No, it wasn't part of the trial. Heard had tried to get Depp to pay for work done on her car. The mechanic said he had been instructed by Depp's finance team that they would no longer be financially supporting any work to this particular vehicle. When the mechanic mentioned this to Heard she tried to manipulate the mechanic. He made the modification to the car, then delivered it to Heard. She came down, got into the passenger seat and tried to seduce the mechanic. He ignored her advances and she then became aggressive. She was clearly trying to get this guy to come on to her or touch her in some way so she could blackmail him into repairing her car for free. Nice! Her father subsequently contacted the mechanic and said he has a gun and would use it on Depp!! Lovely family!!
@@OMG21ization "your question about if she knows she has a disorder, lIMO, absolutely not, she lacks self awareness." Respectfully I disagree. AH is a classic narcissist, and narcissists know that what they are doing is wrong, it's just that they don't care and sometimes (if not always) they have the compulsion. They cannot claim diminished responsibility in any way
I don’t know if intelligence is really a factor with personality disorders. I think in a lot cases the PD kind of overwhelms intelligence. There are some very very smart people who believe ridiculous things, or behave in ridiculous, illogical ways. It would be interesting for Dr Das to talk about this. Does Amber at this point know she’s lying? Has she told her far-fetched stories so many times she thinks they’re true? Or has she with BPD experienced certain interactions with Depp as so dreadfull & painful that it doesn’t matter to her whether it’s true or not? Or it’s all conflated in her mind? (meaning Johnny caused her great trauma and it’s immaterial whether it was from rejection or SA?).
Hi, I just watched you on Blkbelt barrister. Great episode. Now, I’m subscribed to both of you. Question: ppl diagnosed with BPD and/or histrionic personality, do they actually believe their own lies? AH has to know she told plenty of lies throughout the last 6 years and she keeps holding onto them. Even after a jury sided w/JD. The ppl across the world could see/hear the lies and again, she holding on to the lies. Why? Is this part of the illness? Is it possible for her to get help & become a truthful person? At this point does AH know the difference between fact & fiction? Thanks for the podcast. I’m enjoying it. Stay safe & healthy!
@gwensden I gathered that much from your post. I truly know very little about it. Your post was definitely informative. Again, thanks. Stay safe & healthy.
@gwensden sooooo agree. I have BPD and I know what’s a lie and what’s the truth and don’t believe my lies are not lies. I doubt that anyone with BPD believe their lies are not lies. I know darn well when I’m lying and know it’s a lie. So does she! She doesn’t believe her own lies, as her stories keep changing. If she did believe her lies were not lying, and were in fact the truth, I’d think she’d keep the same story for all of her testimonies over the years. But she can’t keep the same stories straight no matter what the subject matter is.
Love your content! You should create shorts from these larger episodes. Shorts have taken my channel from 700 to 6,400 subs in a little over a month. You could easily eclipse 100k subs with your content. Keep up the great work!
@@APsychForSoreMinds My pleasure! I enjoy your channel. I cover this guy named Jeremy Dewitte, I'd LOVE to hear your thoughts on his Police Impersonation cases. He was arrested over 30 times and is now in prison.
@@TrueCrimePhenomenon I'm no doctor but Jeremy Dewitte or as I like to call him...the wit less...lives in his own fantasy world. I loved it when he shouted at a driver to pull over and he turned out to be an off duty cop. I think he banged his fist on the roof of his car and he had his children in the back. He's done a lot of stupid crazy stuff but he's also dangerous to other road users especially when his brother ( I think its his half brother ? ) crashed his bike and Jeremy told him to lie and say it was Jeremy driving because of insurance. His many relationships and his Egyptian wife are brought into all his stories too. Oh I would love if Dr Das did a piece on him. You should get his book " In Two Minds " . It fascinating and unlike Jeremy the wit less is 100 % fact based. Military distinction and covert ops my ass
WONDERFUL INSITE SOHOM!!1 I AM AN AMAERICAN WHO CAME TO JAPAN TO SEE MY BEAUTIFUL DAUGHTER BORN AND LIVE PEACEFULLY AND HAS A JAPANESE WIFE WHO HAS BPD BUT I HAD NO INDICATION ABOUT WHO SHE REALLY IS IN MY FIRST 3 MONTHS AFTER MOVING HERE TO JAPAN........ I FOUND OUT THE HARSH WAY WHAT IT IS LIKE TO LIVE AND DEAL WITH WITH THESE TYPE OF DISORDERED PEOPLE ON A DAILY BASIS!!!! LIVING HELL!!!! ESPECIALLY I HAVE A DAUGHTER WHO SHE IS JUST STARTING TO MANIPULATE MENTALLY AND TURN AGAINST ME......... SUCH A STRUGGLE BUT I HAVE BEEN LEARNING SO MUCH ABOUT THE HUMAN MENTALITY THAT WILL HELP ME IN MY FUTURE 🙂 I LOVE YOUR CONTENT !!!!!
Excellent analysis - thank you! Her statement was thoroughly disingenuous and her post-trial behaviour has been shocking. I'm amazed someone hasn't taken her to one side and just advised her to let it go, and to get serious help for herself.
Let's make clear and distinguish how men may purpotrate more physical abuse, but this is potentially 50/50 men and women purpotrate psychological abuse, which is not better or worse, and it gets overlooked when men go through it, that's what this whole case represents for many people, and myself.
If you limit it to domestic situations, then women are responsible for FAR more abuse against men than vice versa. Women are responsible for FAR more child abuse, too. Most men stay their hands. They've grown up wrestling with each other, playing sports, using sticks as swords on each other, and so on. As they grow, they see their strength grow, and they see how girls cannot keep up. Most men know that they can easily kill a woman or child, and so they stay their hands. Women don't stop.
No one knows how much violence women perpetrate against men. There's a high chance there are more incidents than male against female violence. Much of it is less severe but extreme violence from stabbings and thrown objects should not be underestimated
I have bpd and I hate conflict, I cant even take shouting. I do have trouble with handling emotions but never anger. Amber Heard is manipulative and nasty.
One of the women said, “You’re going to have a lawyer paying a malpractice policy if the verdict isn’t overturned.” Say what? Is she saying that AH will sue her lawyers for malpractice if she doesn’t get an appeal and win?
Freedom of Speech says the government can't prevent you from speaking without a compelling reason with a high bar to overcome, BUT does not make you free of legal and social consequences. In Amber Heard's situation, her defamation AND her apparently repeating may give Johnny Depp cause to ask the government for an order prohibiting Heard from saying certain things. Moreover, losing one suit does not immunize Heard from future suits. The same applies to Depp.
That does not mean she isn't a narcissist. All that means is that her behavior fit into the criteria of BPD better than NPD according to the DSM. Heard has a pathlogical need for CONTROL which is a dead give away of a narcissist. Her behavior has been consistently manipulative and fake. Her innocent victim facade was fake as hell; just like a narcissist trying to hoover the victim by expressing false contrition or undying love. It is all done as a gaslighting technique. That is one of the way narcissists assert control is by manipulating the perceptions of others to preserve the facade. Realistically, she is likely both a borderline and a narcissist. She has patterns of both.
@@theb2694 not disputing what you are saying, just pointed out that psychiatrist on this clip reported her diagnoses differently to what they were reported in court
She said that it is a satback for women to have freedom of speech etc. But what she doesn't say is that it would be her fault that women are seen as liars and overreacting freaks. She showed the whole world that women can be mean when they don't get their way. At least, that is what the majority sees. So every step back since this lawsuit is her own stupid fault. I know she knows it is her fault. But admitting she made a mistake is too painful for her. She just cannot do it. She keeps lying to protect her own feelings. She kind of believes it too. She feels the truth in the lie, if that makes sense. And that part is what she is holding on to. So she gets angry if people call her a liar. She is a liar, definitely. Her content is just not the truth. But the truth for her is the feeling in the lie. Complicated to explain.
Sorry to correct you dude but I believe she was diagnosed with “Histrionic Personality Disorder”. Not “Narcissistic Personality Disorder”. I’m not an expert on an HPD, but after looking at the symptom criteria for it, it does share some similarities to NPD. And based on my unprofessional opinion, I think she really does have traits from NPD. Funny enough, I was surprised that there is a lot of disagreement among medical professionals surrounding this disorder as some believe that it’s just another manifestation BPD and that it should be removed from DSM-5 because of it. (Edit: Oops. Saw the end of the video. I noticed that you corrected yourself. My bad. Lol)
Actually, I think that you accidentally got it RIGHT. I think that she exhibits the behaviors of classic Narcissistic Personality Disorder. But then there is a consensus among many psychiatrists that BPD (unless confused with another disorder) is really just NPD for women, or as some have called it, NPD-Lite. I think that the classification of BPD arose at a time when it may have been deemed too severe to classify women with such a severe diagnosis, and the gender differences probably result in some different nuances in how that diagnosis is displayed. I think that not accounting for these subtleties is the real failure in recognizing that women are just as likely as men to have NPD. The evidence lies in the fact that a much higher percentage of women are diagnosed with BPD, and that should alarm everyone in the field, because statistically, there should be the same percentage of men and women with NPD, and there should NOT be a much higher percentage of women with BPD. Something is wrong with the model.
First - rate analysis. Millions of women are in reality disgusted by her and her self - presentation and promotion as a representative of abused women. Her every gesture, never mind word, screams deceit.
You’re sort of correct about the 1st Amendment but in the words of Dr Curry, “That’s not quite…correct”. None of our Constitutional rights is absolute. But for 1A especially, our courts and legislatures have only allowed some narrow exceptions. We want people to have the greatest latitude for speaking their minds without government regulation or interference. (Sorry that was soap-boxy). You’re even free to lie, for the most part. But we draw the line when you lie and your lies cause damage to the reputation or economic well-being of another. That’s defamation. There is one more protection for freedom of speech and freedom of the press (which also falls under 1A) related to defamation. This is from a landmark Supreme Court case, NYT vs Sullivan. If the person bringing the defamation claim is a public figure, then they must prove the false statement was made with ‘actual malice’. Confusingly, ‘actual malice’ doesn’t actually mean ‘malice’. The plaintiff doesn’t have to show the falsehoods were because of evil intent. It just means you have to show the person made the statements knowing they were false, or with ‘reckless disregard’ for the truth. (here ‘reckless disregard’ actually means reckless disregard, lol). All in all it’s a very high standard for proving defamation. That’s why prior to the start of trial most legal commentators thought Johnny had barely a snowball’s chance in hell. By the end of trial though - after seeing and hearing the evidence -those same commentators were putting his odds well over 50/50.
Heard was born in Austin, Texas, to Patricia Paige (née Parsons), an internet researcher (1956-2020) (taken from wikipedia) wtf is an internet researcher? Am I one too since I'm an shinfo junkie?
Dr. Das, I thinks it’s possible a doctor diagnosed AH with having BPD while they were married. JD brought it up in one of their audios, AH basically ignored him. It is not a condition that non- psychology people know about. Most people tend to know or have heard about narcissism or even bi-polar disorder. AH also seems to have seem many therapists/ psychiatrists over the years, how likely is it that none of them wouldn’t have noticed any behavioral traits?
She also says a lot that jd "splits " even though she's dumb enough to use it incorrectly. And she does that when she splits on him. Which is so funny to see. "Johnny you're splitting again COME BACK BITCH YOURE SPLITTING". it seems like a therapist told her she's splitting and because she's dumb and has bpd, she projected it onto him
Bipolar and borderline disorders are distinct and different. MANY people will admit to being bipolar, because being bipolar is (fallaciously) connected with high intelligence, emotional sensitivity, and creativity. Look how many people try to claim that this or that famous or artistic dead person "almost certainly was bipolar." No one wants to be borderline. That's a syndrome that's all about being a horrible manipulative nuisance to other people 24/7. It's about outbursts of rage, suicide threats, chaotic behavior. That's not at all about being intelligent and creative. Amber described _herself_ to either Erin Falati or Debby as _bipolar._ Amber would never describe herself as borderline, that's like popping up a red flag.
She was given the right to state her case, her freedom of speech was not infringed. I agree, neither came out looking great. BTW, I'm so glad you assess the mentally disordered so I don't have to. As a nurse, I find psych is not my forte, I educate young people on reproductive health. I have some interesting stories about the misconceptions I have heard, but none as interesting as your patients. Cheers. (omg, 'achieved Heard immunity' LOL)
Freedom of speech doesn’t allow lying and destroying another person’s life and career. The thing that spoke volumes about NPD was the time she told about the plane incident. She was upset about “embarrassment” not the abuse. Everything she would say was related to humility, embarrassment, etc and not about true impact of abuse. As an abuse survivor I knew she was lying pretty quickly. But I also felt very connected to him on the stand recalling his childhood experiences because I had an abusive parent. If Amber wants to experience true ptsd I’ll gladly send her my dad for a few years.
Now it's the country's fault that false alligations are against the law...this woman sure can twist things, wonder if she will try to twist her head around next like in the exorcist; she definately has internal issues with sound reasoning.
Excellent succinct, intelligent (obviously but as we've recently seen, not always #heardimmunity )and interesting coverage. Looking forward to watching the other videos on a range of cases. Thanks so much PS. It's safe to say you don't have histrionic disorder 😆
In the US, if you lie about someone and it does damage to them (their life, reputation, or livelihood), you can be sued for slander or libel depending on if it's spoken or written.
Well you totally summed it up in my view. Freedom of speech is not a licence to tell lies. I think despite the enormous wealth and celebrity of the parties involved which them very privileged compared to the rest of us, this case has drawn attention to how men two can be victims. Its like when we discover women can also be paedophiles. Gender stereotypes don't help.
Your videos are so informative and interesting. And funny: Heard/herd immunity! By the way, do you think we will ever reach herd immunity regarding COVID-19? Have a great week!
only issue with this vid is you said she was diagnosed with narsacistic ( spelling?) personality disorder but it was histrionic personality disorder. love the vids though
Now that her deposition is out and its use is free from Andrea Burkhart There is a segment were there are 10 or 12 LAWYERS And if they dont all loom at her she gets mad and calls them out for not listening to her Although her lawyer is anoying also thats might be something to lok at especially since that lawyer might be on Britney Spears board that along with Jamie alevedlg stole money from her and both together sound like they are kinda of same in personality.
Nothing is her fault, she lies constantly, and she won't cork her pie hole. As a feminist, and the mother of sons, I recognize that women can be as abusive as men. Everyone needs to keep there hands to themselves.
their first amendment says you're free to speak without being pursued by the government. But you're not free to bad mouth libel slander defame anybody else.
![ATEEZ(에이티즈) - [GOLDEN HOUR : Part.2] Preview](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/X4PfgRPBUVo/mqdefault.jpg)
Hi Doc, I’ve just watched black belt barristers take on Heard’s statement, he asks if anyone with psychological knowledge would be interested in doing an episode with him. I’ve written in his comments and suggested you! Please give it some thought as I’d definitely be watching it, your both brilliant within your own expertise. Depp is the victim in this case, Heard has done far more damage. Great video, truly professional as always 🌹
YES!!!!
Just watched too. Yes yes please!!
@BlackBeltBarrister
Hard agree with this. You'd be a really helpful asset to contribute your experience and knowledge, doc. Especially because of your expert witness experience.
Yes Please!!
If AH was being "robbed of her freedom of speech"
HOW IS SHE RELEASING A STATEMENT VIA WORLDWIDE TELEVISION. ..!?
As a survivor I'm sickened by her behavior and feel AH is tainting the value of truth..
She has reopened wounds in me that I've worked 10 years to close.
😳
And she's getting a tell-all book deal, too. She's so oppressed!
Hang on in there. No one is allowed to de-rail your recovery.
@@mariaorourke5866 thank you Maria. I’m trying my hardest not to allow ppl like her to effect me so negatively.
I know the feeling she did the same thing to me I saw my abuser and Amber Heard and she has open wounds that I thought I had overcome Amber Heard is such a evil looking person
You're correct. Freedom of speech relates to being able to speak out against the government without legal repercussions. There are many limitations to freedom of speech INCLUDING defamation. This is an erroneous argument.
Thank you - facts of law
That is right, you are not allowed to lie and destroy someone’s life, that is defamation.
Heard is a malignant narcissist. The rage episodes and criminal involvement make the difference from histrionic.
Fully agree, she planned this from the start, she was after his money and status
So happy she failed
That lady is a full house of cluster b disorders. She is narc, borderline, histrionic, anti-social, and SADISTIC. one of the worst psychopaths that I've ever seen. The only person that is still there for her that continues to take her abuse is her sister. And she is severely abusive to her sister. She used her sister as a punching bag (literally and metaphorically) she was also very abusive to her parents as well. She has shown to have zero empathy for any of her family or close friends. And she seems to enjoy feeling powerful in the way she abused and used everyone who has ever cared about her. She is a psychopath of a severely dangerous level.
My two cents.
She fabricated her “mountain” of “evidence”. She was unbelievable! From experience, you don’t taunt or berate an abuser.
I think the mountain was an illusory mole hill. Lay off the MDMA
I absolutely hate the hypocrisy in todays society if a man had been accused of some of the things she has done he would have been arrested ages ago
The truth is 1. She lied lied lied. 2. She is so narcissistic she can’t believe her lies weren’t believed. 3. She is hated because of the narrative of not only being a victim, which she is not, but that she had the audacity to get out there and act like a spokesperson for real DV victims and 4. We are all woke to the devious, maliciousness and evil intent of narcissists and are tired of them always getting away with what they do because they are able to lie their way out of their own doing. We are happy to see one go down…FINALLY!!!!
The Johnny Depp on the stand is the same Johnny Depp in the audio & video recordings, & the same Johnny Depp we've seen in interviews going all the way back to the beginning of his career. He's far from perfect, but he IS consistent!
The Amber on the stand is WILDLY different from the Amber we saw & heard in those recordings, & different from the Amber we see in the media. I suffer from Borderline Personality Disorder, so I understand that we are chameleons who can adapt our whole persona according to the circumstances. But I also understand this sort of behavior does NOTHING but damage where our authenticity is concerned.
She's the frightened victim. She's the raging b**ch. She's the courageous & proud survivor representing all women everywhere (uh, yeah, no thanks, I don't want you representing me). Who IS Amber? No one really knows, coz unlike Mr Consistent, Johnny Depp, Amber is ALL OVER THE PLACE!!!
THAT is what hurt her credibility more than anything. THAT is why the jury didn't believe her. Nevermind the evidence (or lack thereof), The jury, just like the rest of us, could not reconcile the persona that sat before them on the stand with the person they saw & heard in those recordings. Meanwhile, Johnny remained consistent every step of the way. She destroyed her own credibility by not choosing a persona & sticking with it. You can't be that raging b**ch AND that shrinking violet. One of those is a lie. She lies. She pretends to be things that she is not. THAT is why she lost the case, period. She can blame Johnny all she wants, his attorneys, social media, an unfair world...whatever. She did it to herself. No one else is to blame.
And thank you, Dr Das, for pointing out that she lacks many of the core indicators of BPD. The one that stands out the most to me is her lack of shame & guilt over her behavior. It's almost a necessary part of the cycle that feeds into our ever-changing self image, that switch from knowing we are right to where our self-esteem bottoms out. Yeah, that happens because we feel shame & guilt about our behavior. Without that to knock us down again, we'd just tear an unrelenting path of destruction through the world! The unstable moods, yeah. The chaotic relationships, you bet! The intense fear of abandonment, yup. The co-morbid risky behavior like substance abuse, uh huh. The black & white thinking/splitting, plain as day. But no shame or guilt. I don't really see any self harm or suicidal gesturing either. And she hasn't come out with a story of abuse or neglect as a child. We don't get this way by happenstance! I'm not saying she doesn't suffer from BPD. She certainly has many BPD traits, but overall, I see her aligned better with Histrionic Personality Disorder. You know, it's in the same "dramatic" cluster, & there are some similarities, but that need to be the center of attention, & desire for male validation, bringing Elon Musk & James Franco into that penthouse that belonged to her husband, before the divorce papers were even filed! I can TOTALLY see the HPD running deep in her.
I think mostly I just don't want people to think that I share the same personality disorder with Amber Heard since MY BPD manifests itself quite differently than hers. I read somewhere that there are 256 ways to be Borderline. I believe it. There are 9 characteristics used to diagnose BPD, of which you need only display 5 for a diagnosis. The symptoms you DO have vs the ones that you don't, & the severity of each symptom, in what order they disrupt your life the most, makes for a wide variety of combinations & overall manifestions. Just like NPD, many people who suffer from BPD do extremely well in their careers (while others can't hold down a job) because they are able to utilize their ability to manipulate to climb that corporate ladder. We can be quite different. That's all.
Great upload. Great analysis. You are my go-to RUclips psychiatrist! Keep doing what you're doing! ✌🏼
Really? I never knew the Depp who texts his (also accused of dv) friends about hoping to find Amber's rotting corpse in a car, or fucking her corpse, existed. In fact I didn't mind Depp at all until what I saw of him in the private videos, the texts, and the way he presented in court. The man I saw there is very much like the man who abused me. How ready people are to excuse his behaviour speaks volumes about how we have not come very far at all on this issue. You don't have to not have a personality disorder to be a victim, nor even be a likable person. Nor do you have to always be honest. I have no doubt my former partner could convince you all either. You would like him, he's a very likable guy. Depp promised global humiliation of Amber, and got it.
Well, there is always Dr Tracy Marks...excellent wide-ranging content, check it out. 256 ways of being Borderline - where did you get that information from? Why if you claim to have the features of BPD do you call her a "raging bXXth?
I love your insight here. I have multiple female friends with BPD and Amber is radically different. None of them is this bad, even at their worst. The worst-affected friend I've had wasn't this bad, and I needed to combine the traits of somebody else I knew, who I believe is a malignant narcissist, in order to get anywhere close to what we've seen from Amber.
So many of the borderline traits cross over with other Cluster B disorders. Fear of abandonment might be the only one Amber seems to have that is purely BPD-specific.
Totally agree.
Like she never admitted any bad behavior, but when asked about it on TV, THEN she said she did horrible things.
It's only when she knows what face to show that she morphs into it.
Interested to see what's ahead
she'll never shut up
OMG!! Thank you! I’ve learn so much just reading your post.
I was neutral on the AH v JD thing prior to the trial. Ah came across as a liar and was, frankly, very unlikable. I'm now fully on team JD and it is completely because of her own testimony.
Agree totally with you. I had no idea of them before this case, so no preconception. I do recall my sons talking of Johnny and the pirate thing. When the film was released, that's all I ever heard about either of them. I am not into celebrities or celebrity gossip.
"Buy my goddammed book" hahaha, totally unexpected ending.
Abuse victims spoke out against her online saying they don't want her and telling her to shut up.
Omg “Heard immunity “
I feel both entitled to that apology and also can’t say I didn’t smile at the pun!😁
Mostly I love that you said it at all!!.. even tho you know how cheeseball it is to say😂👏👏👏👍
She reminds me so much of my narcissistic ex roomie and my sociopath ex husband.
"Don't tell me no lies and keep your hands to yourself."- The Georgia Satellites, Keep Your Hands To Yourself
I just clicked after hearing you on the Blackbeltbarrister, which was a very interesting discussion.
Love your videos, you're a great communicator.
cheers famalam. buy my book!
Is it possible that her repeated assertions that she is a representative of women is an indicator of grandiose thinking? ( I mean, she is no more a representative of me that a crocodile is a representative of leather shoes). Or is it a manipulative technique to save her ego where she can be seen as a martyr character who lost but for something bigger than herself. Either way, I guess both concepts are steeped in the kind of over inflated sense of self and entitlement.
This isn’t the first time AH declared herself the representative, spokesperson or advocate- even aside from the case, and aside from her op-Ed claims as a spokesperson and advocate for DV and SA, she has claimed this authority/position for other non-profits and even in defense of The Playboy Club, a TV show that when heavily criticized AH who had a supporting role in the show as a bunny said in interviews that she felt like an “unintentional spokesperson” for the show when defending it to the media.
As a survivor of IPV/DV and SA, her assertion of being a “public figure representing victims” has always felt grandiose and disingenuous… it also created a feeling of distrust of her for me, because as a survivor, I felt my voice was silenced and mocked for so long that speaking for other survivors without their request like AH has done would be perpetrating the abusive denial of their voice and autonomy. I guess I just see it as a situation where you can’t claim to be a representative for a community if all you are doing is using your voice to tell your own story and not for change or to uplift others who are within the community also.
I guess the big problem is if she can't help it, should we blame her,? At the same time is she allowed to hurt and damage others? And what about here little baby if she really exists?
I also believed Amber at first back in 2016 but now there's so much evidence out there proving she's the abuser. I now believe she was the abuser
I sneezed right before you said “bless you”
Love it!!! Imparting knowledge...and humour too !!
I love how you analyze things. My mom is a psychologist so really grew up with this kind of stiff from her. But she's 65 now and didn't get into the case at all so very nice to hear it from someone who is more up to date on psychology. I do think it's a field that's becoming more of a hard science so I do think younger professionals are a bit better then older.
Hello, I just discovered your channel. I would love to see you do a video on the interview Amber Heard did today for NBC
I don't know many people who claim(in Ambers case)or are victims of domestic violence would be so defensive or not admit to their foibles,or own acts of aggression. She was so defensive as to come across angry and insincere.
As a lawyer, I can say you had it right on analyzing the legal principles in this case and Amber's claims. It actually had nothing to do with freedom of speech because she defamed him.
I’m so glad to see a video from you today! I’m off from work and now I have something enlightening to see.
Fantastic insight as always @Psychforsoreminds
Thank you kindly!
Narcissist's
It Didn't Happen
And If It Did, It Wasn't that Bad
And It It Was, It Wasn't A Big Deal
And If It Is, It Wasn't My Fault
And If It Was, I Didn't Mean It
And If I Did, You Deserved It
Wow, wow! It dose sound like AH‼️
She counter sued Johnny for statements his lawyer made and she won two million dollars for that, and yet she still wants to say she should be able to say whatever she wants because...freedom of speech.
My ex was just like her and made my life hell for years by turning everyone against me. I'm worried about Heard's child that's going to be raised by a narcissist. The way she twists everything to her narrative turns my stomach and there are still people who believe her.
Heard is fascinating. She's clearly intelligent so I find it hard to believe that she thinks there is nothing wrong with her. Her father is aggressive and nasty and when Depp turned the cash machine off to Amber, her father threatened to shoot Depp!! Camille Vasquez pointed out to everyone including Amber that while Depp had a plethora of support from all sorts of people, she had only her sister. She must at least suspect that she has a disorder, surely. What I find absolutely fascinating is when people do bad things, whether it's murder or making up lies to destroy your spouse's career after he turns the cash machine off, they then decide to slip into the role of victim. I had the pleasure of seeing Ross Kemp give a speech and he's seen everything! He was once tasked with interviewing a man in India who had raped and murdered around 200 women (he lost count!!). Kemp said he didn't want to go anywhere near this creature but was eventually persuaded to carry out the interview. He said when he entered the room, the man immediately burst into tears and claimed it wasn't his fault!!! Kemp left the room without speaking. What is this victim business about? Why do people who do bad things slip into the role of victim ONLY when they get caught out??
Wow I didn’t know that the dad threatened to shoot him . I didn’t watch beginning of trial was it said then ? I did know her father had made some money by hosting illegal dog fights .
@@summertimesunshine2444 AH dad was depending on AH for money
@@summertimesunshine2444 No, it wasn't part of the trial. Heard had tried to get Depp to pay for work done on her car. The mechanic said he had been instructed by Depp's finance team that they would no longer be financially supporting any work to this particular vehicle. When the mechanic mentioned this to Heard she tried to manipulate the mechanic. He made the modification to the car, then delivered it to Heard. She came down, got into the passenger seat and tried to seduce the mechanic. He ignored her advances and she then became aggressive. She was clearly trying to get this guy to come on to her or touch her in some way so she could blackmail him into repairing her car for free. Nice! Her father subsequently contacted the mechanic and said he has a gun and would use it on Depp!! Lovely family!!
@@OMG21ization "your question about if she knows she has a disorder, lIMO, absolutely not, she lacks self awareness."
Respectfully I disagree. AH is a classic narcissist, and narcissists know that what they are doing is wrong, it's just that they don't care and sometimes (if not always) they have the compulsion. They cannot claim diminished responsibility in any way
I don’t know if intelligence is really a factor with personality disorders.
I think in a lot cases the PD kind of overwhelms intelligence. There are some very very smart people who believe ridiculous things, or behave in ridiculous, illogical ways.
It would be interesting for Dr Das to talk about this. Does Amber at this point know she’s lying? Has she told her far-fetched stories so many times she thinks they’re true?
Or has she with BPD experienced certain interactions with Depp as so dreadfull & painful that it doesn’t matter to her whether it’s true or not? Or it’s all conflated in her mind? (meaning Johnny caused her great trauma and it’s immaterial whether it was from rejection or SA?).
Hi, I just watched you on Blkbelt barrister. Great episode. Now, I’m subscribed to both of you. Question: ppl diagnosed with BPD and/or histrionic personality, do they actually believe their own lies? AH has to know she told plenty of lies throughout the last 6 years and she keeps holding onto them. Even after a jury sided w/JD. The ppl across the world could see/hear the lies and again, she holding on to the lies. Why? Is this part of the illness? Is it possible for her to get help & become a truthful person? At this point does AH know the difference between fact & fiction? Thanks for the podcast. I’m enjoying it. Stay safe & healthy!
@gwensden I gathered that much from your post. I truly know very little about it. Your post was definitely informative. Again, thanks. Stay safe & healthy.
@gwensden sooooo agree. I have BPD and I know what’s a lie and what’s the truth and don’t believe my lies are not lies. I doubt that anyone with BPD believe their lies are not lies. I know darn well when I’m lying and know it’s a lie.
So does she! She doesn’t believe her own lies, as her stories keep changing. If she did believe her lies were not lying, and were in fact the truth, I’d think she’d keep the same story for all of her testimonies over the years. But she can’t keep the same stories straight no matter what the subject matter is.
Love your content! You should create shorts from these larger episodes. Shorts have taken my channel from 700 to 6,400 subs in a little over a month. You could easily eclipse 100k subs with your content. Keep up the great work!
Thanks for the tip!
@@APsychForSoreMinds My pleasure! I enjoy your channel. I cover this guy named Jeremy Dewitte, I'd LOVE to hear your thoughts on his Police Impersonation cases. He was arrested over 30 times and is now in prison.
@@TrueCrimePhenomenon I'm no doctor but Jeremy Dewitte or as I like to call him...the wit less...lives in his own fantasy world. I loved it when he shouted at a driver to pull over and he turned out to be an off duty cop. I think he banged his fist on the roof of his car and he had his children in the back. He's done a lot of stupid crazy stuff but he's also dangerous to other road users especially when his brother ( I think its his half brother ? ) crashed his bike and Jeremy told him to lie and say it was Jeremy driving because of insurance. His many relationships and his Egyptian wife are brought into all his stories too.
Oh I would love if Dr Das did a piece on him. You should get his book " In Two Minds " . It fascinating and unlike Jeremy the wit less is 100 % fact based.
Military distinction and covert ops my ass
@@the-end-of-my-tether It's a crazy story! I'm going to buy his book for sure!!!
WONDERFUL INSITE SOHOM!!1 I AM AN AMAERICAN WHO CAME TO JAPAN TO SEE MY BEAUTIFUL DAUGHTER BORN AND LIVE PEACEFULLY AND HAS A JAPANESE WIFE WHO HAS BPD BUT I HAD NO INDICATION ABOUT WHO SHE REALLY IS IN MY FIRST 3 MONTHS AFTER MOVING HERE TO JAPAN........ I FOUND OUT THE HARSH WAY WHAT IT IS LIKE TO LIVE AND DEAL WITH WITH THESE TYPE OF DISORDERED PEOPLE ON A DAILY BASIS!!!! LIVING HELL!!!! ESPECIALLY I HAVE A DAUGHTER WHO SHE IS JUST STARTING TO MANIPULATE MENTALLY AND TURN AGAINST ME......... SUCH A STRUGGLE BUT I HAVE BEEN LEARNING SO MUCH ABOUT THE HUMAN MENTALITY THAT WILL HELP ME IN MY FUTURE 🙂 I LOVE YOUR CONTENT !!!!!
You have to check out her last interview she had. Very telling
The slap at the end was good, much better than the overplayed “I’ll see myself out”
I’m afraid this will not be the last time we hear from AH and her shenanigans
Amber admitted to abusing him on tape. Amber also has a previous DV arrest record from 2009.
Excellent analysis - thank you! Her statement was thoroughly disingenuous and her post-trial behaviour has been shocking. I'm amazed someone hasn't taken her to one side and just advised her to let it go, and to get serious help for herself.
She has damaged it for wmen because her lies were exposed. Amber cares about Amber. Im glad she was exposed
Of course she’s sad she lost. She’s ten million dollars sad.
"Herd immunity" LOL!!
Trust and believe.... If Amber was wronged, Gloria Alred would've have been all over the television screaming so. 😱
Let's make clear and distinguish how men may purpotrate more physical abuse, but this is potentially 50/50 men and women purpotrate psychological abuse, which is not better or worse, and it gets overlooked when men go through it, that's what this whole case represents for many people, and myself.
Sure but the physical abuse by men would provoke emotional fear and self-devaluation much more in women.....and yes I do have personal experience.
If you limit it to domestic situations, then women are responsible for FAR more abuse against men than vice versa. Women are responsible for FAR more child abuse, too. Most men stay their hands. They've grown up wrestling with each other, playing sports, using sticks as swords on each other, and so on. As they grow, they see their strength grow, and they see how girls cannot keep up. Most men know that they can easily kill a woman or child, and so they stay their hands. Women don't stop.
No one knows how much violence women perpetrate against men. There's a high chance there are more incidents than male against female violence. Much of it is less severe but extreme violence from stabbings and thrown objects should not be underestimated
I have bpd and I hate conflict, I cant even take shouting. I do have trouble with handling emotions but never anger. Amber Heard is manipulative and nasty.
One of the women said, “You’re going to have a lawyer paying a malpractice policy if the verdict isn’t overturned.” Say what? Is she saying that AH will sue her lawyers for malpractice if she doesn’t get an appeal and win?
Amber has and continues to do so much damage to so many. No friends family or victims are safe around her
Beautiful Doc!
Freedom of Speech says the government can't prevent you from speaking without a compelling reason with a high bar to overcome, BUT does not make you free of legal and social consequences.
In Amber Heard's situation, her defamation AND her apparently repeating may give Johnny Depp cause to ask the government for an order prohibiting Heard from saying certain things. Moreover, losing one suit does not immunize Heard from future suits. The same applies to Depp.
Heard immunity. Yes he certainly did achieve that🤣
Her diagnoses were BPD and histrionic personality disorder ( not narcissistic personality disorder), as diagnosed by Dr Shannon Curry anyway
Dr Das clearly thinks only his opinion matters and his ego shines through in every video. I literally can not watch him.
That does not mean she isn't a narcissist. All that means is that her behavior fit into the criteria of BPD better than NPD according to the DSM. Heard has a pathlogical need for CONTROL which is a dead give away of a narcissist. Her behavior has been consistently manipulative and fake. Her innocent victim facade was fake as hell; just like a narcissist trying to hoover the victim by expressing false contrition or undying love. It is all done as a gaslighting technique. That is one of the way narcissists assert control is by manipulating the perceptions of others to preserve the facade. Realistically, she is likely both a borderline and a narcissist. She has patterns of both.
@@theb2694 not disputing what you are saying, just pointed out that psychiatrist on this clip reported her diagnoses differently to what they were reported in court
12:05 priceless!!! I do hope Johnny see's this little clip. 🤣😘
I really appreciate your balanced comments, thank you, it's a pleasure to listen to you 👍🏽🦁
much obliged x
She said that it is a satback for women to have freedom of speech etc. But what she doesn't say is that it would be her fault that women are seen as liars and overreacting freaks. She showed the whole world that women can be mean when they don't get their way. At least, that is what the majority sees.
So every step back since this lawsuit is her own stupid fault. I know she knows it is her fault. But admitting she made a mistake is too painful for her. She just cannot do it. She keeps lying to protect her own feelings. She kind of believes it too. She feels the truth in the lie, if that makes sense. And that part is what she is holding on to. So she gets angry if people call her a liar. She is a liar, definitely. Her content is just not the truth. But the truth for her is the feeling in the lie.
Complicated to explain.
Great reaction!! 👍🏼👏🏻
Thank you!! 😁
Sorry to correct you dude but I believe she was diagnosed with “Histrionic Personality Disorder”. Not “Narcissistic Personality Disorder”.
I’m not an expert on an HPD, but after looking at the symptom criteria for it, it does share some similarities to NPD.
And based on my unprofessional opinion, I think she really does have traits from NPD.
Funny enough, I was surprised that there is a lot of disagreement among medical professionals surrounding this disorder as some believe that it’s just another manifestation BPD and that it should be removed from DSM-5 because of it.
(Edit: Oops. Saw the end of the video. I noticed that you corrected yourself. My bad. Lol)
Hello. You are right....freedom of speech is not a platform for telling lies. She had her freedom to present her case.
Problem is that, there is next to no work or highlighting on how common abuse against men actually is.. that needs to change!!
"heard immunity"?!….. you better get a dad bod to go with that dad joke! :D
Can you do a video on JD re: covert narcissism tactics.
Heard Immunity! I just love you.
Actually, I think that you accidentally got it RIGHT. I think that she exhibits the behaviors of classic Narcissistic Personality Disorder. But then there is a consensus among many psychiatrists that BPD (unless confused with another disorder) is really just NPD for women, or as some have called it, NPD-Lite. I think that the classification of BPD arose at a time when it may have been deemed too severe to classify women with such a severe diagnosis, and the gender differences probably result in some different nuances in how that diagnosis is displayed. I think that not accounting for these subtleties is the real failure in recognizing that women are just as likely as men to have NPD. The evidence lies in the fact that a much higher percentage of women are diagnosed with BPD, and that should alarm everyone in the field, because statistically, there should be the same percentage of men and women with NPD, and there should NOT be a much higher percentage of women with BPD. Something is wrong with the model.
First - rate analysis. Millions of women are in reality disgusted by her and her self - presentation and promotion as a representative of abused women. Her every gesture, never mind word, screams deceit.
Histrionic is narcissistic. The traits mostly all the same.
Johnny has achieved “Heard Immunity”. Good one !!!!
I fully agree with all your observations on this
You’re sort of correct about the 1st Amendment but in the words of Dr Curry, “That’s not quite…correct”.
None of our Constitutional rights is absolute. But for 1A especially, our courts and legislatures have only allowed some narrow exceptions. We want people to have the greatest latitude for speaking their minds without government regulation or interference. (Sorry that was soap-boxy).
You’re even free to lie, for the most part.
But we draw the line when you lie and your lies cause damage to the reputation or economic well-being of another. That’s defamation.
There is one more protection for freedom of speech and freedom of the press (which also falls under 1A) related to defamation. This is from a landmark Supreme Court case, NYT vs Sullivan.
If the person bringing the defamation claim is a public figure, then they must prove the false statement was made with ‘actual malice’.
Confusingly, ‘actual malice’ doesn’t actually mean ‘malice’. The plaintiff doesn’t have to show the falsehoods were because of evil intent. It just means you have to show the person made the statements knowing they were false, or with ‘reckless disregard’ for the truth. (here ‘reckless disregard’ actually means reckless disregard, lol).
All in all it’s a very high standard for proving defamation. That’s why prior to the start of trial most legal commentators thought Johnny had barely a snowball’s chance in hell. By the end of trial though - after seeing and hearing the evidence -those same commentators were putting his odds well over 50/50.
Beautiful mind 💕J.D. has achieved heard immunity💘 😉
Saw you on black belt Barrister ☺️☺️
Heard immunity, 😂
🤣🤣🤣 “Heard Immunity”
Heard was born in Austin, Texas, to Patricia Paige (née Parsons), an internet researcher (1956-2020) (taken from wikipedia) wtf is an internet researcher? Am I one too since I'm an shinfo junkie?
“ Heard immunity” 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
She's nuts. That's a technical term for bonkers.
Dr. Das, I thinks it’s possible a doctor diagnosed AH with having BPD while they were married. JD brought it up in one of their audios, AH basically ignored him. It is not a condition that non- psychology people know about. Most people tend to know or have heard about narcissism or even bi-polar disorder. AH also seems to have seem many therapists/ psychiatrists over the years, how likely is it that none of them wouldn’t have noticed any behavioral traits?
She also says a lot that jd "splits " even though she's dumb enough to use it incorrectly. And she does that when she splits on him. Which is so funny to see. "Johnny you're splitting again COME BACK BITCH YOURE SPLITTING". it seems like a therapist told her she's splitting and because she's dumb and has bpd, she projected it onto him
Bipolar and borderline disorders are distinct and different. MANY people will admit to being bipolar, because being bipolar is (fallaciously) connected with high intelligence, emotional sensitivity, and creativity. Look how many people try to claim that this or that famous or artistic dead person "almost certainly was bipolar."
No one wants to be borderline. That's a syndrome that's all about being a horrible manipulative nuisance to other people 24/7. It's about outbursts of rage, suicide threats, chaotic behavior. That's not at all about being intelligent and creative.
Amber described _herself_ to either Erin Falati or Debby as _bipolar._ Amber would never describe herself as borderline, that's like popping up a red flag.
@@JM-ot8ux as a med student who has done actually years of psych clinic rotations (volunteeringly), I AGREE.
She was given the right to state her case, her freedom of speech was not infringed. I agree, neither came out looking great. BTW, I'm so glad you assess the mentally disordered so I don't have to. As a nurse, I find psych is not my forte, I educate young people on reproductive health. I have some interesting stories about the misconceptions I have heard, but none as interesting as your patients. Cheers. (omg, 'achieved Heard immunity' LOL)
Freedom of speech doesn’t allow lying and destroying another person’s life and career. The thing that spoke volumes about NPD was the time she told about the plane incident. She was upset about “embarrassment” not the abuse. Everything she would say was related to humility, embarrassment, etc and not about true impact of abuse. As an abuse survivor I knew she was lying pretty quickly. But I also felt very connected to him on the stand recalling his childhood experiences because I had an abusive parent. If Amber wants to experience true ptsd I’ll gladly send her my dad for a few years.
Now it's the country's fault that false alligations are against the law...this woman sure can twist things, wonder if she will try to twist her head around next like in the exorcist; she definately has internal issues with sound reasoning.
I’m came to you channel today because of black belt barrister
Excellent succinct, intelligent (obviously but as we've recently seen, not always #heardimmunity )and interesting coverage. Looking forward to watching the other videos on a range of cases. Thanks so much
PS. It's safe to say you don't have histrionic disorder 😆
Her freedom of speech was not held hostage. She had legal representation and a chance to speak.
What violence did johnny Depp do? And from my life experience women commit more DV then men. Men just never report domestic abuse.
I'm sure she's humiliated that her poop is on the internet
We have freedom of speech; however, not freedom from consequences!
In the US, if you lie about someone and it does damage to them (their life, reputation, or livelihood), you can be sued for slander or libel depending on if it's spoken or written.
Well you totally summed it up in my view. Freedom of speech is not a licence to tell lies. I think despite the enormous wealth and celebrity of the parties involved which them very privileged compared to the rest of us, this case has drawn attention to how men two can be victims. Its like when we discover women can also be paedophiles. Gender stereotypes don't help.
Your videos are so informative and interesting. And funny: Heard/herd immunity! By the way, do you think we will ever reach herd immunity regarding COVID-19? Have a great week!
Good analysis
Oooh sounds good!
only issue with this vid is you said she was diagnosed with narsacistic ( spelling?) personality disorder but it was histrionic personality disorder. love the vids though
Now that her deposition is out and its use is free from Andrea Burkhart There is a segment were there are 10 or 12 LAWYERS And if they dont all loom at her she gets mad and calls them out for not listening to her Although her lawyer is anoying also thats might be something to lok at especially since that lawyer might be on Britney Spears board that along with Jamie alevedlg stole money from her and both together sound like they are kinda of same in personality.
Going back on your video about pathological liars , do you think Amber Heard qualifies as one or is she more of a spin merchant ?
She may be a liar and a fruit cake, but he is fit
@@markjones1337 😂 very true
Heard immunity 😂😂😂😂💀💀💀
Nothing is her fault, she lies constantly, and she won't cork her pie hole. As a feminist, and the mother of sons, I recognize that women can be as abusive as men. Everyone needs to keep there hands to themselves.
"Cork her pipe hole" - fine misygnostic comment.
So what does it mean if a person believes she is a rape/domestic abuse victim?
Really good thanks
Freedom of speech has to be true not lies like she gave. She hurt us real DV/SV and she is a liar and she doesn’t speak for DV Survivor’s
This woman Is full blown crazy
She was talking about her freedom to write the op ed, not the court proceedings.
She held out both as freedom of speech. Wrong on both.
Heard immunity! Ha!
their first amendment says you're free to speak without being pursued by the government. But you're not free to bad mouth libel slander defame anybody else.
Yes insult perfectly said
Bahahaha Herd immunity 🤪