I think part of why the "Before the Line" video works is BECAUSE of the improvised nature of it, really. Like, it's such an emotionally chaotic song, with so much anger and sadness and desperation, and that means that the much rougher feel to the video adds a huge amount to the song.
I remember when dodie made a video where she talked about how she had been going through old pictures and home videos and I knew as soon as I saw the When lyric video that's what she had been looking at them for and it made my heart hurt so much. The whole visual album really hit close to home for me and I'm still watching and listening to it constantly. Well done to all involved!
i love how much you did manually like ciaran physically holding the camera to the side of the car and sophie holding the projector for the montage and you changing the lights on an app. those things are still technical but just feel more personal and intimate? because they were done live and not in the edit. congrats, it’s such a gorgeous piece of work.
Such interesting stuff!!! That red light moment was so satisfying, and to hear that it was an accident.. the frenzied energy of Before the Line really works, I think it's my favorite of all the videos for that reason alone
the stuff about the car being a journey makes so much more sense now because I saw the arc as someone going from being in the backseat to be in control/driver's seat and the helplessness that comes with the stuff the songs talks about... and so I was confused that she left the car in the last one cause i thought, but you're finally in control why would you leave... loved the vids, loved the music (goes without saying but gonna say it anyway)
Your comment about the intent of Dodie walking right-to-left vs. left-to-right in "?" immediately took me back to my days studying Herbert Zettl's theories of right screen dominance and up/down diagonals, so bravo.
I cannot explain how much I loved the visual album - it complemented the beautiful, complex, heartwrenching music so well and you did a BRILLIANT job. Thank you!
Instead of saying 'get the hell out of my room' you could've said 'I'm cutting you off, go on, out ya get' cuz like... you're a bar 🙃 Also as someone who has studied film and whose hobby is music, this video was super interesting. Love the album, love the visuals, 10/10.
What an absolute privilege to direct these videos. And what a good job you did!! As much as love the songs, I really love the videos. Dodie is so talanted, and it goes for her songwriting as well for her actingperformance. What a girl!!! Such a joy whatching this behind the scene video :)
This was such a fascinating video! Thanks Jack for all of these insights. I love the album and thought the visual album perfectly conveyed the songs whilst also adding something additionally special to them too. Really great to learn more about it.
Such a beautiful and compelling way of tying together all these wonderful and heart wrenching songs. I want to make detailed lists and spread sheets of all the details and how they connect to each other now
I loved sorry. The video and the music were just so beautiful. I have to say tho, I didn't even realize there was blood on her hands, I was just confused about that dark stuff and wether it's makeup or something... Seems really obvious now
The album is really lovely! Some great tracks and I can't wait too see her live in glasgow! The lyric videos are also awesome they really suite her music.
So interesting! Really loved hearing all this bts stuff. I've been meaning to make a video essay on interdisciplinary arts and this visual album is for sure going in it once i do, such a cool concept!!
Hey Jack. Have u heard about P.E.M acting technique? its like a way to reach emotion without having someone have to feel the emotion in a sense. It brings the emotion into the physical. Maybe something to look into, for directing. I'm studying film myself, and yeah find the whole bringing people into emotions quite iffy at times.
I loved getting to hear about the creative process! Thanks for going through it for us! Big old long time listener / watcher of you both, this shit is some of the best stuff you guys have made. It was cool to see how you personal connection with each other informed the way things were made,
"I don't have the right answer just because I made them". I am such a nut job trying to get the 'true' meaning behind things and music and movies. I need to know what the artist intended, so that I feel I understand what they're putting out there, and whether I resonste with that or not. The need to know is kinda limiting, to be honest, and it annoys me, but that's how my brain works. But this, do you truly believe that? That there's no wrong answer? When I heard that I could take a breath of air, like "oh, ok then", like finally willing to relax a bit, maybe.
I wasn't sure if Sorry was about a murder or finding someone after su**ide. With Before the Line, I thought it was about her feeling su***dal after seeing whatever she saw.
with capital T capital S he means that "The Situation" is like written with capital letters. With the situation he means the pandemic/covid. The capital letters are like meant to mean not just a situation but The Situation that everybody knows and is the main thing that is happening. it's like how you would write The One when talking about the love of your life. I hope that explenation is kinda clear.
@@JackHoward omg thank you I’ve always wondered, never heard that being done before being from Australia! We’re a bit behind lol. It always made sense in context and I got that you were referencing Covid, but it makes so much more sense now. Thanks for replying and for helping a nuffy out 🤘
Late comment but it took me a few watches to finally notice that because it’s a British car, it’s BACKWARDS to what I’m used to a car layout being (North American) and that was disorienting
I can’t even remember the initial idea for before the line lol
And thank u jack ily 😭 we crafted these and I’m so proud of us all WA
It was a pleasure x
LOVE YOU BOTH 💛💛
The "have you seen Tenet" joke is becoming my personal favorite joke of all time. It's a problem.
have you seen it thoXD
I think part of why the "Before the Line" video works is BECAUSE of the improvised nature of it, really. Like, it's such an emotionally chaotic song, with so much anger and sadness and desperation, and that means that the much rougher feel to the video adds a huge amount to the song.
I remember when dodie made a video where she talked about how she had been going through old pictures and home videos and I knew as soon as I saw the When lyric video that's what she had been looking at them for and it made my heart hurt so much. The whole visual album really hit close to home for me and I'm still watching and listening to it constantly. Well done to all involved!
ahh! finally! ive been eagerly awaiting this video! (and honestly, the hair alone was worth the wait. a great director's look)
i love how much you did manually like ciaran physically holding the camera to the side of the car and sophie holding the projector for the montage and you changing the lights on an app. those things are still technical but just feel more personal and intimate? because they were done live and not in the edit. congrats, it’s such a gorgeous piece of work.
Such interesting stuff!!! That red light moment was so satisfying, and to hear that it was an accident.. the frenzied energy of Before the Line really works, I think it's my favorite of all the videos for that reason alone
Bruh aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa did you remember the episode when do the Gay man hahahahaha
”build a problem”
- my brain to me at 3am
the stuff about the car being a journey makes so much more sense now because I saw the arc as someone going from being in the backseat to be in control/driver's seat and the helplessness that comes with the stuff the songs talks about... and so I was confused that she left the car in the last one cause i thought, but you're finally in control why would you leave...
loved the vids, loved the music (goes without saying but gonna say it anyway)
AM I THE ONLY ONE WHO DIDN’T KNOW IT WAS BLOOD ON HER HANDS??? I THOUGHT IT WAS MASCARA-
Your comment about the intent of Dodie walking right-to-left vs. left-to-right in "?" immediately took me back to my days studying Herbert Zettl's theories of right screen dominance and up/down diagonals, so bravo.
I’m so impressed by the whole lyrics playlist, but Special Girl is truly something special. Thank you for this 🥰
i could watch an hour of this. love hearing you talk about stuff you made. beautiful job btw.
Laughed a bit too hard at the cow sounds effects. 🐮
Great video. Excellent bar
Jack your hair looks nice
your explanation of cool girl really reminds me of the cool girl speech from Gone Girl
That’s not a coincidence :)
@@JackHoward yes king love your work
I cannot explain how much I loved the visual album - it complemented the beautiful, complex, heartwrenching music so well and you did a BRILLIANT job. Thank you!
In the video for Sorry, I'm always so focused on dodie's face that I didn't even notice her hands
me too!
loved this found it v interesting tysm for sharing. also the bar is stunning your mum has nailed it x
Jack has fantastic vibes as a person, and I can't put my finger on what it is.
it's definitely the hair, so swoopy
Instead of saying 'get the hell out of my room' you could've said 'I'm cutting you off, go on, out ya get' cuz like... you're a bar 🙃
Also as someone who has studied film and whose hobby is music, this video was super interesting. Love the album, love the visuals, 10/10.
What an absolute privilege to direct these videos. And what a good job you did!! As much as love the songs, I really love the videos. Dodie is so talanted, and it goes for her songwriting as well for her actingperformance. What a girl!!!
Such a joy whatching this behind the scene video :)
This was such a fascinating video! Thanks Jack for all of these insights. I love the album and thought the visual album perfectly conveyed the songs whilst also adding something additionally special to them too. Really great to learn more about it.
Beautifully shot album, Jack! Dodie's lyrical mastery and your vision for the scenes were truly a perfect marriage.
the thing about walking from right to left is genius!!! what incredible work you did together!
So great to learn all the background to these great videos. Off to watch them again :)
lol that was one of the best sponsor transitions ive seen
*bows*
Such a beautiful and compelling way of tying together all these wonderful and heart wrenching songs. I want to make detailed lists and spread sheets of all the details and how they connect to each other now
I loved sorry. The video and the music were just so beautiful. I have to say tho, I didn't even realize there was blood on her hands, I was just confused about that dark stuff and wether it's makeup or something... Seems really obvious now
Oooh how I've been looking forward to this vid
The album is really lovely! Some great tracks and I can't wait too see her live in glasgow! The lyric videos are also awesome they really suite her music.
Loved the video, extremely informative and always great to hear more about the creative processes behind masterpieces :)
I truly loved this entire sequence. You and dodie created magic, as always. Cheers! ☺️
Honestly so well done! Thanks for answering our questions ☺️
Off to go watch the whole album again...
loved this thank uuu
god id love to direct stuff someday
This was so interesting! Thank you for making this. Those videos are the most perfect addition to the album.
heyo i'm very interested in this video that i haven't watched yet! excited to dive into dodie's album!
6:40 you should tell this to my english teacher
So interesting! Really loved hearing all this bts stuff. I've been meaning to make a video essay on interdisciplinary arts and this visual album is for sure going in it once i do, such a cool concept!!
Very cool :) excited to see that
this album and its music videos spoke to me from a different universe.. its so gorgeously made
Hey Jack. Have u heard about P.E.M acting technique? its like a way to reach emotion without having someone have to feel the emotion in a sense. It brings the emotion into the physical. Maybe something to look into, for directing. I'm studying film myself, and yeah find the whole bringing people into emotions quite iffy at times.
Ah... In Sorry, I thought that was smudged mascara, not blood. That changes things
I love these kind of videos! Grrrreeeeaaatt!!! - Tony the Tiger
thanks for the cows ben from canada (:
Nice work. Enjoyed your notes.
Thank you for making this, Jack. I love hearing being the scenes stuff 😁
wait i'm positive the champagne in the photo is making a heart or some shape like it
I loved getting to hear about the creative process! Thanks for going through it for us! Big old long time listener / watcher of you both, this shit is some of the best stuff you guys have made. It was cool to see how you personal connection with each other informed the way things were made,
"I don't have the right answer just because I made them".
I am such a nut job trying to get the 'true' meaning behind things and music and movies. I need to know what the artist intended, so that I feel I understand what they're putting out there, and whether I resonste with that or not. The need to know is kinda limiting, to be honest, and it annoys me, but that's how my brain works. But this, do you truly believe that? That there's no wrong answer? When I heard that I could take a breath of air, like "oh, ok then", like finally willing to relax a bit, maybe.
Great work, Ben From Canada!
This is so cool!
Im now gonna go and rewatch it so incredibly interesting hearing the ideas!
Amazing! Please do more of these
i've been so excited for this! Adorable dog. 💛
Really enjoyed this, so interesting!
i love seeing bts stuff and understanding your creative process
3:13 yeaaah sorry to tell you this mate, you must've got confused. That's a picture of Jude Law
Don't you think I didn't hear that Tenet sting
Upset you didn't say get the hell out of my pub
Missed opportunity
jack's mum is the only person i can forgive for the live laugh love bunting
I wasn't sure if Sorry was about a murder or finding someone after su**ide. With Before the Line, I thought it was about her feeling su***dal after seeing whatever she saw.
Dodie: I'm in me mum's car, vroom vroom
Jack: 21:47
Jack you can't sneak the Tenet Soundtrack in and expect us not to notice.
Okay someone’s gotta tell me what “capital T caspital S” means. You, Hazel etc. all say it and I have no idea what it means
It's "The Situation"... Not "the situation". The Situation. Y'know?
with capital T capital S he means that "The Situation" is like written with capital letters. With the situation he means the pandemic/covid. The capital letters are like meant to mean not just a situation but The Situation that everybody knows and is the main thing that is happening. it's like how you would write The One when talking about the love of your life. I hope that explenation is kinda clear.
i adopted this from hazel. hope she doesn't mind haha.
I think it's a UK thing. Cause after moving to the US, I noticed nobody emphasizes words that way
@@JackHoward omg thank you I’ve always wondered, never heard that being done before being from Australia! We’re a bit behind lol. It always made sense in context and I got that you were referencing Covid, but it makes so much more sense now. Thanks for replying and for helping a nuffy out 🤘
so good 😍
The right to left walking 🤯
great video, so insightful!
Loool I thought the blood on her hands was just her make up running 😭
one take
one cake
U no it 😎
i agree, dodie is REALLY good at expressing emotions
✨why car✨
Please review A Quiet Place Part 2!!!
Ciaran always amazes me
a talented man
Brilliant as usual.
Will you please do a video on Bo Burnham’s new special??? Please. I will bake you 22 cookies.
Hello daddy
Noice!
i miss you with Dean
these videos have to be on letterboxd
0 dislikes. Deserved
i have never seen a video before with 1.7k likes and only 1 dislike.
Late comment but it took me a few watches to finally notice that because it’s a British car, it’s BACKWARDS to what I’m used to a car layout being (North American) and that was disorienting
Dad is that you?
CHUFFED
Absolutely chuffed
@@JackHoward omg my dumb comment with no likes just got replied to . 😮
Really enjoyed this! Thank you.