Although the mahler vid is mostly accurate, it glosses over the tenth symphony as “incomplete”. In reality, it exists as a complete and performable work with all music written by Mahler. When it comes time, you should give the Cooke version of it a listen, it properly caps off Mahler’s symphonic works Also, when it comes to it, you should go back and listen to the full Das Lied Von der Erde. For some reason, they only gave you the last movement the last time
@@georgepantzikis7988 no, not “as sketches”. It’s one continuous two-piano score that needed orchestrated. Quit making it sound like he left a bunch of incoherent scribblings
@@georgepantzikis7988 do you want Gidi to hear it or not? Bc if you don’t and wanna keep pretending mahler 10 isn’t a real piece, what you said makes sense. But if you do, then what’s the point in saying that?
@@steveM-r2o In music, we call a piano reduction of a symphony that hasn't been orchestrated yet a sketch. That's the term for it. I didn't mean he just wrote a few ideas
@@georgepantzikis7988No we don’t, we call it a short score. There is a seperate document with sketches which are actually mostly incoherent, you can even see a primitive version of the opening viola line. Let's be honest here, there exists a for all intends and purposes complete 1st movement, a 2nd and 3rd movement which are orchestrated in parts but fully composed in short score elsewhere, and a 4th and 5th movement composed beginning to end in short score with instrument markings. It is absolutely more than sketches
Alma was for the streets lmao. Also, don't worry about the AI music sounding just like real composer's music. These are very short clips, with no context. AI can't compose any long, larger scale pieces. It would struggle to write even something like a minuet
Oh no, you insulted all the Swifties saying her music sounds like AI... 😬No but for real, I also thought it was AI. Second one sounded more real for me, it could play in the radio without me noticing
Although the mahler vid is mostly accurate, it glosses over the tenth symphony as “incomplete”. In reality, it exists as a complete and performable work with all music written by Mahler. When it comes time, you should give the Cooke version of it a listen, it properly caps off Mahler’s symphonic works
Also, when it comes to it, you should go back and listen to the full Das Lied Von der Erde. For some reason, they only gave you the last movement the last time
@@steveM-r2o Mahler only finished the first movement. The remaining movements exist only as sketches, which is why there are different versions
@@georgepantzikis7988 no, not “as sketches”. It’s one continuous two-piano score that needed orchestrated. Quit making it sound like he left a bunch of incoherent scribblings
@@georgepantzikis7988 do you want Gidi to hear it or not? Bc if you don’t and wanna keep pretending mahler 10 isn’t a real piece, what you said makes sense. But if you do, then what’s the point in saying that?
@@steveM-r2o In music, we call a piano reduction of a symphony that hasn't been orchestrated yet a sketch. That's the term for it. I didn't mean he just wrote a few ideas
@@georgepantzikis7988No we don’t, we call it a short score. There is a seperate document with sketches which are actually mostly incoherent, you can even see a primitive version of the opening viola line. Let's be honest here, there exists a for all intends and purposes complete 1st movement, a 2nd and 3rd movement which are orchestrated in parts but fully composed in short score elsewhere, and a 4th and 5th movement composed beginning to end in short score with instrument markings. It is absolutely more than sketches
Alma was for the streets lmao. Also, don't worry about the AI music sounding just like real composer's music. These are very short clips, with no context. AI can't compose any long, larger scale pieces. It would struggle to write even something like a minuet
Oh no, you insulted all the Swifties saying her music sounds like AI... 😬No but for real, I also thought it was AI. Second one sounded more real for me, it could play in the radio without me noticing