For Jennifer it's a gospel song baby, you don't sing pop songs the same way as gospel, she oversings too but for that precise moment it's a pass kindof
this video just shows how oversinging is good when the singers are creative and smart enough to do it. performances would be so plain if there aren't these amazing runs and riffs by these singers.
Listen to real talents and professionals like Aretha, Streisand, Karen Carpenter, Gladys Knight. Anita Baker, Linda Ronstadt, Diana Ross, Donna Summer, Sarah Vaughn, Billie Holiday, Jennifer Holiday and to many others to mention. Compare them to the crap and over use of ridiculous runs and fills by the likes if Mariah Carey, Aguilera, Grande, Beyonce, Hudson and many of today's average talent hacks, and its a joke. The professionalism, musicianship, vocal range and understanding of scales and when to use them is on another level.
@@veronica5080 lol, sorry! Not a big fan of MC. Even before she lost her voice, at her best, she was always throwing in ridiculous runs and over singing. I lost it with her when i heard that NYE disaster, live!!. She was so bad and off key, that it was amateurish!!!! Hey, we all have our opinions!!! Stay safe!
@@robmorrison1043 Ariana does not oversing. Especially in comparison to Jennifer Holliday who you cited as not oversinging who is known for doing the most.
Ariana Grande said that Kristin Chenoweth taught her "Does this serve a purpose?" Does the extra note and riffs and runs serve a purpose? Usually it's to flex or impress an audience. There's nothing necessarily wrong with that at all, especially Mariah's Vision of Love that ending is legendary. For me, when runs serve the lyrics and express an emotion that transcends even the music, it's the soul expressing itself. That's when you get to "flex" and it serves a purpose, the true emotion of a song that can only be captured in that moment.
I like oversinging, but the singer must also sing the song. I dislike when singers let the backup vocalists singing the entire song while all fhey do is oh's and ah's.
Beyoncé was giving in 2:40 !!! Omg? What? All that? And The belts? resonant, The riffs? Fluid The head voice? Magnificent The lows? Beautiful all that in a minute? She a killer
5:04 breathin climax is probably on the top three of most iconic vocal moments of the past decade in mainstream music, idc what u think, argue with tte wall. Keep it iconic ponytail queen ❤️❤️
Yeah her voice is really heavy so I guess it’s just not for everyone. I find fantasia’s voice a little lighter and more soothing to my ears when she over sings tho. Just mostly preference.
Got a thumbs down when it came to J Hud's part. Gospel and pop music are two different styles so comparing the two genres doesn't match the critique. Gospel is for the emotion and pop deals with average technicalities.
Rachelle Ferrell is vocal titan. She is a jazz singer. She can do all kinds of things with her voice. Jennifer Hudson is a vocal beast. She has grown so much vocally. Jennifer roots are in gospel. I don't find neither of them annoying. In fact Jennifer and Chris Stapleton CMA performance was so magical that I had to get up and shout like I was in church. Gospel singing and jazz singing is way different then singing to the pop standard. Gospel and jazz involve improvisation. A lot of things you can get away with in gospel you can get away with doing in pop music.
@@takemyhand1988 Actually gospel singers do it right all the time. We sing hymns and gospel songs differently then a traditional pop singer. You can't compare how we sing gospel to a pop standard, cause that not how we sing gospel music in the church. Example The Clark Sisters would be consider as over-singing if they were in this video, but people look past the fact that that is how they sing in the COGIC church. They grew up singing in the Pentecostal church. Their mom Mattie Moss trained them to sound like one voice. Twinkie Clark honed her sisters talent by a skill called call and response. That's when you throw a run, riff or note out and they will repeat it back. Overall my point is what's considered over singing in pop is not considered over singing in gospel. You can be more vocally free with gospel and jazz.
@@NIJEECAPRICORN23 no. What I'm saying is nowadays the gospel singers just sing to impress and do nothing worth to remember. Compare it to old school gospel singers like Mahalia who could the very little and still makes us remember it forever. Or singers like clara ward, who would get the "spirit of god" and sing like it's end of the world. Nowadays both of those styles is almost non existent in gospel where simplicity is now bad and singing to the spirit is just about how many complex runs they could do
@@takemyhand1988 👏🏾 definitely different eras compare the Mahaila Jackson or Clara Ward to these modern day gospel singers. Most of these gospel singers of today are heavily influenced by The Clark Sisters. So their skill set is way different from those legends and pioneers. Your gospel singers of today would be Jekalyn Carr, Kierra Sheard- Kelly, LeAndria Johnson, Jessica Reedy, Christina Bell, Kim Burrell, Shelea Frazier is another example of a singer who's roots are in gospel. I love Mahaila and Clara too.
it’s a pleasure listening to rachelle - on records. her singing live is mostly oversinging and serious vocal opportunism. she’d butcher any tune at the expense of showing her impeccable singing and that is not what an artist should do. so yeah, just because you can sing better than anyone, still does not mean you’re a better artist. and being a jazz singer is no excuse. the greats such as ella fitzgerald and sarah vaughan always knew when, where and how to improvise. they also always knew where to stop.
If yall only to pop and pop vocalist please leave gospel and gospel vocals out of your conversations.. its so annoying when pop fans always call gospel annoying or over done because they dont understand how its supposed be sung or works but calls Christina A. over sone garbage “ amazing and beautiful
I think that when oversinging is done to have fun or to deepen the expression of emotion, it's nice😊 if I go to a concert of a fine singer, I love seeing them have moments of enjoying their gift. If they oversing all the time, it becomes mundane and not that exciting.
What I don't get about the negative connotation with oversinging is... Instrumentalists esp guitarists get applauded for showing their skills and virtuosity by pulling crazy strings of notes together crazy fast, going up and down the scale. Even when it get's overboard and fails to be expressive or doesn't really connect with the song they don't get as much shit as singers doing the same. And it's the exact same thing, there's no difference between melismatic singing and playing an ornamented solo. But why is the ornamentation with instruments so much more appreciated than ornamentation in singing. This seems to be a general thing.
Of course doing riffs with a voice is not the same as doing it on guitar, but so is soloing on drums, piano, flute, violin, saxophone etc - they're all different. U didn't actually say WHY singing doesn't count, ur point seems to be "it just is" but that's not a good argument, that's just a statement. It's totally fine if you're entitled to this point of view... But if u can't explain why, then there's no argument.
Yes, there is oversinging and there are creative extensions, adlibs, and melismas. The difference is that oversinging is rarely pleasing to the ears. 1:50 was amazing and incredibily pleasing. 2:50 Beyonce did amazing here & showed her creativity. 4:02 &4:11 Both displays of creativity and not oversinging. There are plenty of example of oversinging in the video & you nailed them. Love your content!
Oversinging goes both ways its both good and bad Good because sometimes oversinging sounds beautiful, bad because its like we get it you can sing. and at certain points you gotta let the high note go you cannot keep sustaining onto it and nobody wants to keep hearing oooooo and ahhh its like you gotta let the note go cause at the sametime oversinging is sometimes doing too much , like you dont gotta do all that its uncalled for. & I LOVE IT WHEN SINGERS ARE EXTRA AND OVER SING & SOMETIMES I DONT BUT I DO KNOW IF I COULD SING I’D BE EXTRA, AND OVERSINGING TOO.😂😂😂😂
The way they disrespected Jennifer. God I hate Xtina stans they think that Christina, as a legend she is dont get my wrong, is not annoying at times. Jennifer just cuz she sings different from pop doesn’t make it annoying
Jennifer is just basically being so soulful and she is singing gospel song. And it's pretty common for those type of singers to those things. It's not annoying its very soulful and xtina was a bit annoying cuz of that run.
7:46 Um.. over singing doesn’t really count in a church setting. Gospel singers sing where the spirt takes them. It’s not always about a “perfect” performance.
I think some ppl don’t understand that gospel singers oversing and don’t have to match the musicality of the song because gospel isn’t pop. It’s singing for God. So the expression is different.
I really loved this channel it always educated me in music janra. Can you also make a video about female who had a big voice & what their strenght & weakness like xtina, beyonce, charice, jennifer hudson & many more big voice that sounds like guys becoz of their voice.
This account is a huge Christina fan, because Christina most definitely over sings and it’s annoying. Jennifer oversings and it’s annoying. Rachelle Farrel baby oversings and it’s amazing.
The video's theme is interesting, but the thumbnail implying that Christina Aguilera's "yeyeyeyeahs" are OK while JHud's amazing gospel singing is "annoying" threw me off. I understand this is a Xtina fan account, but come on. You could be less biased.
Why aren't there clips of Whitney n Celine... Mariah, Whitney n Celine r the supreme performers coz even when they oversing, they still sound pleasant n captivating... 3 other prominent vocalists who can oversing excellently to me are Tori Kelly, Leona Lewis n Pink... Most singers featured here sadly sound screechingly irritating when they are doing prolonged runs at their top notes...
I think over singing is very fun but also can be very annoying to most people listening lol. I enjoy doing it... But there's a limit to how long you do it. With creativeness it can be iconic also.
You have "oversinging in pop music" as the title but then include Jennifer singing a gospel song?? She was not oversinging she was ministering which is something you don't understand. You can't really compare gospel and pop singing, those are different. You kinda missed the ball on that
Well to clarify, the first half of Jennifer’s clip here before she actually began to exhort was pretty annoying. Before you come at me with the race thing, I’m black myself, Jennifer just needs to make better choices vocally when she wants to show off because though she indeed gets a pass because she’s singing a gospel song, she does this sometimes in normal settings which is not appropriate
@@LiTim17 Who are you to decide what's appropriate and what's not?? You can say it doesn't sound good to you but it can sound good to others. You don't know what was going on, if she felt moved by the spirit to sing a note or a run then that's just the way she feels. I will say she does too much, in my opinion, sometimes but it's not my place to say what's appropriate and what's not. You said it yourself, you're black and if you grew up in the church you would know that the spirit will move and sometimes you just can't help it, and if it makes them wanna sing and shout than that's what they do. Gospel singing has no comparison with Pop singing. One is a spiritual experience and the other is not.
Christina tiene una voz tan dulce, sus notas bajas son hermosas... pero a veces m satura tanto grito seguido y tanto cambio en las cAnciones iconicas... menos es mas y con esa voz deberia d probarnos q con poco tmbn enamora
Can you do a video of Hispanic female singers hability's? I give you examples Rocio durcal, amaya Uranga from Mocedades, cecilia, Mon laferte, Ana gabriel, shakira, Gloria trevi, Amanda miguel, amaya montero from la oreja de van gogh, Lucia galan from pimpinela, Gaby moreno, Joy huerta from jesse y joy, Carla morrison, Julieta venegas, Ana torroja from mecano, Natalia lafourcade, yuri, Lucero, thalia... they're mostly vintage but goldies might i say.
5:03 all time best "oversinging" imo, Ariana just knows where to put a high note and match the song's energy, bc not all song should have a lot of high notes like this, and plus it is iconic tho
Jennifer-Annoying Next one(I don't know who she is)-Annoying Christina-Always amazing Christina, Mariah, Beyonce are not annoying period. They can't switch easily from belting to falsetto to riffing with ease which makes it enjoyable to listen to.
I get your point, but I think (as I believe you suggested with the question marks) that wether oversinging is more annoying than amazing is really up to personnal preferences. I didn't find Jennifer Hudson or Rachelle Ferrell annoying at all. Jennifer was singing a gospel song, and in gospel, especially live, you expect a LOT of oversinging. And Rachelle is living a world of her own musically, and her thing is playing around with her voice, doing the most. But I understand that these types of music are not to everyone's taste, especially if you are more pop oriented.
For Jennifer it's a gospel song baby, you don't sing pop songs the same way as gospel, she oversings too but for that precise moment it's a pass kindof
True and ppl seem to 4get that
That’s what I’m saying, she literally putting that soul into it. That wasn’t annoying to me
Exactly
They’re uncultured
Xtina , Beyonce y Miriah They are the ones who make complicated melismas without overdoing it 🤩
Who is Miriah?🙄
I would argue that queen Xtina over does it sometimes
@@zeda6742 More often than not
Xtina over does it like half of the time, completely different that fighters like that
they are so boring singers
this video just shows how oversinging is good when the singers are creative and smart enough to do it. performances would be so plain if there aren't these amazing runs and riffs by these singers.
Listen to real talents and professionals like Aretha, Streisand, Karen Carpenter, Gladys Knight. Anita Baker, Linda Ronstadt, Diana Ross, Donna Summer, Sarah Vaughn, Billie Holiday, Jennifer Holiday and to many others to mention.
Compare them to the crap and over use of ridiculous runs and fills by the likes if Mariah Carey, Aguilera, Grande, Beyonce, Hudson and many of today's average talent hacks, and its a joke.
The professionalism, musicianship, vocal range and understanding of scales and when to use them is on another level.
You tucking lost me ar mariah carey Rob 😒
@@veronica5080 lol, sorry! Not a big fan of MC. Even before she lost her voice, at her best, she was always throwing in ridiculous runs and over singing.
I lost it with her when i heard that NYE disaster, live!!. She was so bad and off key, that it was amateurish!!!!
Hey, we all have our opinions!!!
Stay safe!
@@robmorrison1043 Ariana does not oversing. Especially in comparison to Jennifer Holliday who you cited as not oversinging who is known for doing the most.
@@EricSmith-qc6oy lol, to put Grande in the same Stratosphere as Holiday vocally is an insult to Holiday and anyone with ears or an once of musicality
Ariana Grande said that Kristin Chenoweth taught her "Does this serve a purpose?"
Does the extra note and riffs and runs serve a purpose?
Usually it's to flex or impress an audience. There's nothing necessarily wrong with that at all, especially Mariah's Vision of Love that ending is legendary.
For me, when runs serve the lyrics and express an emotion that transcends even the music, it's the soul expressing itself. That's when you get to "flex" and it serves a purpose, the true emotion of a song that can only be captured in that moment.
Yes!
Just don't destroy the natural rhythm and melody of the song
I like oversinging, but the singer must also sing the song. I dislike when singers let the backup vocalists singing the entire song while all fhey do is oh's and ah's.
Beyoncé was giving in 2:40 !!! Omg? What? All that? And The belts? resonant, The riffs? Fluid The head voice? Magnificent The lows? Beautiful all that in a minute? She a killer
Don’t play with her
0:56 you know Melody got her ass beat by Nicole for pulling that stunt 😭
frrr
😆
5:04 breathin climax is probably on the top three of most iconic vocal moments of the past decade in mainstream music, idc what u think, argue with tte wall.
Keep it iconic ponytail queen ❤️❤️
It's so nice to see a Mariah's fan supports Ari 😍💕💕💕
@@mooblink4ever899 all young Mariah fans are Ari fans lol
Oldies are the ones who hate her
facts! it's such an intense climax and Ari always delivered it live on tour
@@drewm.2790 And she was also changing it and adding more and more things each night, truly amazing singer
@@joanquintero4670 not all young mimi fans are also an ari fan
I didn't find Jennifer Hudson's performance annoying
Yeah her voice is really heavy so I guess it’s just not for everyone. I find fantasia’s voice a little lighter and more soothing to my ears when she over sings tho. Just mostly preference.
The problem with that performance is that she did almost all the high notes in pure scream. But is not annoying tho
Got a thumbs down when it came to J Hud's part. Gospel and pop music are two different styles so comparing the two genres doesn't match the critique. Gospel is for the emotion and pop deals with average technicalities.
Omg Mariah's vocals😍😍🌟🌟👏👏👏👏
The Breathin climax is the perfect example of oversinging without overstepping it😍
Basically slayed your whole existence flop.
@@DaydreamCarey1234 WHY ARE YOU EVERYWHERE OMG
@@Fishriah_Ari no your the one that's everywhere. Also why are u being here and not praising ur flop vocals tho?
@@DaydreamCarey1234 I can stan other people and also I'm not self absorbed like you hun 🌝♥️
@@Fishriah_Ari i guess your vocals is not good enough to prais it yourself lol.
Aw Mariah is just so good to listen to...clean, melodious.. She amazes me everytime☺ ..musix box.. Daydream..
Christina Aguilera, the most vocalist. Legend ❤❤❤❤
I dont mind Jennifer Hudson's voice. Her performance at the CMT awards was pretty magically. The lady after her... I'll never understand the hype.
I agree I loved her CMA performance
Isn't Rachel famous for her polyphonic notes?
@@takemyhand1988 yes and range
Rachelle Ferrell is vocal titan. She is a jazz singer. She can do all kinds of things with her voice. Jennifer Hudson is a vocal beast. She has grown so much vocally. Jennifer roots are in gospel. I don't find neither of them annoying. In fact Jennifer and Chris Stapleton CMA performance was so magical that I had to get up and shout like I was in church. Gospel singing and jazz singing is way different then singing to the pop standard. Gospel and jazz involve improvisation. A lot of things you can get away with in gospel you can get away with doing in pop music.
But nowadays gospel singers are just not doing it right compared to the 60s and before singers
@@takemyhand1988 Actually gospel singers do it right all the time. We sing hymns and gospel songs differently then a traditional pop singer. You can't compare how we sing gospel to a pop standard, cause that not how we sing gospel music in the church. Example The Clark Sisters would be consider as over-singing if they were in this video, but people look past the fact that that is how they sing in the COGIC church. They grew up singing in the Pentecostal church. Their mom Mattie Moss trained them to sound like one voice. Twinkie Clark honed her sisters talent by a skill called call and response. That's when you throw a run, riff or note out and they will repeat it back. Overall my point is what's considered over singing in pop is not considered over singing in gospel. You can be more vocally free with gospel and jazz.
@@NIJEECAPRICORN23 no. What I'm saying is nowadays the gospel singers just sing to impress and do nothing worth to remember. Compare it to old school gospel singers like Mahalia who could the very little and still makes us remember it forever. Or singers like clara ward, who would get the "spirit of god" and sing like it's end of the world. Nowadays both of those styles is almost non existent in gospel where simplicity is now bad and singing to the spirit is just about how many complex runs they could do
@@takemyhand1988 👏🏾 definitely different eras compare the Mahaila Jackson or Clara Ward to these modern day gospel singers. Most of these gospel singers of today are heavily influenced by The Clark Sisters. So their skill set is way different from those legends and pioneers. Your gospel singers of today would be Jekalyn Carr, Kierra Sheard- Kelly, LeAndria Johnson, Jessica Reedy, Christina Bell, Kim Burrell, Shelea Frazier is another example of a singer who's roots are in gospel. I love Mahaila and Clara too.
it’s a pleasure listening to rachelle - on records. her singing live is mostly oversinging and serious vocal opportunism. she’d butcher any tune at the expense of showing her impeccable singing and that is not what an artist should do. so yeah, just because you can sing better than anyone, still does not mean you’re a better artist.
and being a jazz singer is no excuse. the greats such as ella fitzgerald and sarah vaughan always knew when, where and how to improvise. they also always knew where to stop.
Xtina ❤️ she’s the most creative when it comes to runs and riffs, her musicality is out of this world 😍
Man, how Xtina is simple amazing talent! Go Girl!
If yall only to pop and pop vocalist please leave gospel and gospel vocals out of your conversations.. its so annoying when pop fans always call gospel annoying or over done because they dont understand how its supposed be sung or works but calls Christina A. over sone garbage “ amazing and beautiful
Christina does overdo it sometimes but her her falsetto is the best in the busines.
Man the relaxed Beyonce showing us all what she's made of
Christina Aguilera amazing voice 👏👏👏🔥🎤🎤🎤🎤🔊🔊🔊 the Best voice of the world 👏👏🔥❤️❤️🔥🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶
Minuto 6:26 amazing voice Christina Aguilera 👏🔥🔥🔥🎤🎤🎤🎤🎶🎶🎶🎶
8:15 I'm sorry, but that is amazing lol
Agree
Agree
Her throat was WIDE open
@@guore9708 wide ain't the word. Her throat was all the way on. 🎤🎤 tap tap is this thing on 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
Rachelle is a goddess. That was incredible
I think that when oversinging is done to have fun or to deepen the expression of emotion, it's nice😊 if I go to a concert of a fine singer, I love seeing them have moments of enjoying their gift. If they oversing all the time, it becomes mundane and not that exciting.
What I don't get about the negative connotation with oversinging is...
Instrumentalists esp guitarists get applauded for showing their skills and virtuosity by pulling crazy strings of notes together crazy fast, going up and down the scale.
Even when it get's overboard and fails to be expressive or doesn't really connect with the song they don't get as much shit as singers doing the same.
And it's the exact same thing, there's no difference between melismatic singing and playing an ornamented solo.
But why is the ornamentation with instruments so much more appreciated than ornamentation in singing.
This seems to be a general thing.
Of course doing riffs with a voice is not the same as doing it on guitar, but so is soloing on drums, piano, flute, violin, saxophone etc - they're all different.
U didn't actually say WHY singing doesn't count, ur point seems to be "it just is" but that's not a good argument, that's just a statement.
It's totally fine if you're entitled to this point of view...
But if u can't explain why, then there's no argument.
Is strange, but I found the Rachel one both annoying and amazing
5:04 I'm just waiting for this!
Christina does it best
Over singing is her thing and Mariah Carey because Mariah will be doing the most crazy ass shit with her voice .
06:25 Christina sounds like a fucking alarm. A beautiful alarm though. Her voice is unreal.
Tell us you don't understand the black church and gospel without telling us you don't understand the black church and gospel.
Yes, there is oversinging and there are creative extensions, adlibs, and melismas. The difference is that oversinging is rarely pleasing to the ears.
1:50 was amazing and incredibily pleasing.
2:50 Beyonce did amazing here & showed her creativity.
4:02 &4:11 Both displays of creativity and not oversinging.
There are plenty of example of oversinging in the video & you nailed them. Love your content!
All this has taught me is what I already know: Xtina is the master, the queen, the legend of over singing and riffs
“There’s not such a thing like over singing when one has proper technique”
That’s completely untrue. Patti Labelle is known for oversinging
@@SuperPianogirl123 according to … ? NEXT
@@denetish Watch ANY of her performances. She literally doesn’t even sing words
@@SuperPianogirl123 agree but she is one of the best of all time. Her ain’t no way tribute to Aretha proves that.
When it comes to oversinging, christina aguilera, beyonce, and jessie j are the only exceptions and are allowed to do so😌😌😌
1:53 I KNEW FAOUZIA WOULD BE HERE
Her voice is amazing omg
@@chrisssajin8913 Ikrrrr
You really think that Jennifer Hudson oversangd??? Please......🙄 Duh
I'm only for Christina Aguilera and that's all❤❤❤
Man, you really tried Jennifer with this.
the way they disrespected Jennifer the legend.
The one u said that are annoying are the greatest..💅
Oversinging goes both ways its both good and bad Good because sometimes oversinging sounds beautiful, bad because its like we get it you can sing. and at certain points you gotta let the high note go you cannot keep sustaining onto it and nobody wants to keep hearing oooooo and ahhh its like you gotta let the note go cause at the sametime oversinging is sometimes doing too much , like you dont gotta do all that its uncalled for.
& I LOVE IT WHEN SINGERS ARE EXTRA AND OVER SING & SOMETIMES I DONT BUT I DO KNOW IF I COULD SING I’D BE EXTRA, AND OVERSINGING TOO.😂😂😂😂
Xtina @ 6:25 😲
This is definitely more of an opinion, some people just like goin to church, if you can't tell by the audiences
I think the performance of Christina (8:55) was much more annoying than the performance of Jennifer (7:05)
Okay I’m not the only one lol
The way they disrespected Jennifer. God I hate Xtina stans they think that Christina, as a legend she is dont get my wrong, is not annoying at times. Jennifer just cuz she sings different from pop doesn’t make it annoying
Jennifer is just basically being so soulful and she is singing gospel song. And it's pretty common for those type of singers to those things. It's not annoying its very soulful and xtina was a bit annoying cuz of that run.
I think if they CAN do it and WANT to do it, then they should. It’s the kind of thing that can build a career.
7:46 Um.. over singing doesn’t really count in a church setting. Gospel singers sing where the spirt takes them. It’s not always about a “perfect” performance.
Christina is aloud to over does it. I don't want to hear nothing of hers if it's plain and regular. Mariah never does to much.
Sometimes taking a moment from a performance out of context looks like too much when in actually fits that particular song perfectly
I think some ppl don’t understand that gospel singers oversing and don’t have to match the musicality of the song because gospel isn’t pop. It’s singing for God. So the expression is different.
I was over singing and it destroyed my voice and now I going to rest for a week.
Lol
I’m probably one of the rare people that love Melody’s sloppy runs on “Buttons” 😍 XD
The first xtina clip in amazing or annoying, is annoying. But the second one. Oh the second one is so good
People said oversinging..but I love ✨extra✨
come on queen mariah slayy
Xtina is world class but it suits her style to oversing! It blends with her voice well
Ariana and Mariah showcasing their vocal prowess and skill, but never sounded like they oversing. Never annoying as well. I love them both so much.
Xtina is the queen of over singing
I really loved this channel it always educated me in music janra. Can you also make a video about female who had a big voice & what their strenght & weakness like xtina, beyonce, charice, jennifer hudson & many more big voice that sounds like guys becoz of their voice.
Christina Aguilera is the beeeeest vocalist of our generation !!!
Actually I didn’t find Jhud’s annoying , Maybe I love soul so much that’s why
This account is a huge Christina fan, because Christina most definitely over sings and it’s annoying. Jennifer oversings and it’s annoying. Rachelle Farrel baby oversings and it’s amazing.
Jennifer ain’t annoying boy..you are. Fix yo face.
@@buterababe5218 that’s my opinion.
@@raymonwilliams7720 just cuz u a mainstream bitch don’t mean that gospel music runs aren’t any worse
Actually i love that run from Xtina 8:54
Good or Bad? I think it depends on the audience or the listener itself, we got different taste in music. But for me it's technically artistic 😏
Xtiiina 💎
The video's theme is interesting, but the thumbnail implying that Christina Aguilera's "yeyeyeyeahs" are OK while JHud's amazing gospel singing is "annoying" threw me off. I understand this is a Xtina fan account, but come on. You could be less biased.
I like your point. But probably it's the reason you clicked. 55+
Grandes voces ❤️
2:04 link da performance???? Meu Deeeus, pqp
This is why I say Ariana grande is the best because she does not over do it
Depends
Mariah Carey Queen vocal's
Why aren't there clips of Whitney n Celine...
Mariah, Whitney n Celine r the supreme performers coz even when they oversing, they still sound pleasant n captivating...
3 other prominent vocalists who can oversing excellently to me are Tori Kelly, Leona Lewis n Pink...
Most singers featured here sadly sound screechingly irritating when they are doing prolonged runs at their top notes...
I think over singing is very fun but also can be very annoying to most people listening lol. I enjoy doing it... But there's a limit to how long you do it. With creativeness it can be iconic also.
as long as not everyone can do it, i don't find it annoying
Mariah Carey was TASTEFUL chile... whew
Xtina poderosa e insuperable
Jhud Is a Monster😍😍😍😍
You have "oversinging in pop music" as the title but then include Jennifer singing a gospel song??
She was not oversinging she was ministering which is something you don't understand.
You can't really compare gospel and pop singing, those are different. You kinda missed the ball on that
I literally said the same thing. Gospel and pop have two different audiences. Gospel is more emotional singing. Not technical.
Well to clarify, the first half of Jennifer’s clip here before she actually began to exhort was pretty annoying. Before you come at me with the race thing, I’m black myself, Jennifer just needs to make better choices vocally when she wants to show off because though she indeed gets a pass because she’s singing a gospel song, she does this sometimes in normal settings which is not appropriate
@@LiTim17 Who are you to decide what's appropriate and what's not??
You can say it doesn't sound good to you but it can sound good to others. You don't know what was going on, if she felt moved by the spirit to sing a note or a run then that's just the way she feels.
I will say she does too much, in my opinion, sometimes but it's not my place to say what's appropriate and what's not. You said it yourself, you're black and if you grew up in the church you would know that the spirit will move and sometimes you just can't help it, and if it makes them wanna sing and shout than that's what they do.
Gospel singing has no comparison with Pop singing. One is a spiritual experience and the other is not.
Where’s Whitney
The thing is when singers try to many riffs and runs they are going to miss up some notes, Example: most of Xtina videos you showed
I actually like over singing. It's better that a singer does too much than it's to not do enough and bore the audience
True but if it’s too sharp or too flat it can get annoying. At least if you are gonna oversing do it with breath support and resonance.
Yessss it my fav. Maybe that’s why I’m a fan of all the female divas.
Christina tiene una voz tan dulce, sus notas bajas son hermosas... pero a veces m satura tanto grito seguido y tanto cambio en las cAnciones iconicas... menos es mas y con esa voz deberia d probarnos q con poco tmbn enamora
Can you do a video of Hispanic female singers hability's? I give you examples
Rocio durcal, amaya Uranga from Mocedades, cecilia, Mon laferte, Ana gabriel, shakira, Gloria trevi, Amanda miguel, amaya montero from la oreja de van gogh, Lucia galan from pimpinela, Gaby moreno, Joy huerta from jesse y joy,
Carla morrison, Julieta venegas, Ana torroja from mecano, Natalia lafourcade, yuri, Lucero, thalia... they're mostly vintage but goldies might i say.
i love christina aguilera, but yes she does oversing quite a bit
5:03 all time best "oversinging" imo, Ariana just knows where to put a high note and match the song's energy, bc not all song should have a lot of high notes like this, and plus it is iconic tho
Xtina the best vocalist ever
Who is the artist at 1:50 😍 lovely voice!
What song is Christina singing at 2:10
Where was that perfomance??!
It's hot!❤
Rachelle Ferell 😱😱😱
Absolutely good!!
It’s only good if xTina is doing it 🤪
Selon moi Christina est la meilleure chanteuse au monde …
Beyonce's first clip alone is a definition of sanging!!!
JENNIFER BETTA SANGGG
Xtina in 8:58 wooooooooooooooow what's the hell 💎
In today’s day in age as long as the singer is singing high fast and loud theyre deemed “good singers”
Jennifer-Annoying
Next one(I don't know who she is)-Annoying
Christina-Always amazing
Christina, Mariah, Beyonce are not annoying period. They can't switch easily from belting to falsetto to riffing with ease which makes it enjoyable to listen to.
6.07 Celine Dion 😉, not at her best
I get your point, but I think (as I believe you suggested with the question marks) that wether oversinging is more annoying than amazing is really up to personnal preferences. I didn't find Jennifer Hudson or Rachelle Ferrell annoying at all. Jennifer was singing a gospel song, and in gospel, especially live, you expect a LOT of oversinging. And Rachelle is living a world of her own musically, and her thing is playing around with her voice, doing the most.
But I understand that these types of music are not to everyone's taste, especially if you are more pop oriented.
SZUPER DRÁGA BOLDOG KARÁCSONYT
Who Is that girl at 1:50 ?
Faouzia.