Daniil Trifonov - Bach: Contrapunctus 14, BWV 1080, 19 (Compl. by Trifonov)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 14 окт 2021
- @daniiltrifonov is intrigued by Bach’s attempts to base the work on the Fibonacci sequence and the golden ratio, but observes that the result is “far more than a scientific experiment: as always with Bach, he managed to make music of indescribable beauty and emotion”. Trifonov’s imaginative interpretation captures the sense of the work as a cycle, treating it as a living, organic whole. This chimes with the inspiration he takes from spending time in nature, whether hiking or practising Qigong, a form of meditation that values the healing energy of trees. “And the tree is a good metaphor for The Art of Fugue’s overall structure,” he notes. “The theme is the trunk, the fugues are the branches, all the permutations within each fugue are the leaves…”
Bach did not live to finish The Art of Fugue’s final contrapunctus, and a number of musicians have attempted conjectural completions. For this recording, Trifonov, himself an accomplished composer, has created a seamless, stylistically respectful conclusion worthy of Bach’s genius. It reflects the extent to which he has absorbed and internalised every nook and cranny of Bach’s valedictory masterpiece.
Daniil Trifonov - Bach: Contrapunctus 14, BWV 1080, 19 (Compl. by Trifonov)
Listen to 'The Art of Life': dgt.link/Trifonov-Bach
Subscribe here for more classical video clips - The Best Of Classical Music: bit.ly/Subscribe-DG
Discover full concert performances on DG Premium - registration and basic library are free: www.dg-premium.com
Get your front row ticket here for exclusive streams and world premieres with leading artists: www.dg-stage.com
_______________
Find Deutsche Grammophon Online
Homepage: deutschegrammophon.com
Facebook: deutschegrammophon
Twitter: / dgclassics
Instagram: / dgclassics
Newsletter: deutschegrammophon.com/newsle...
_______________
最优质古典音乐 - 此处订阅: bit.ly/Subscribe-DG
Le meilleur de la musique classique. Pour vous abonner cliquez ici: bit.ly/Subscribe-DG
最高のクラシック音楽―登録はこちら: bit.ly/Subscribe-DG
최고의 클래식음악을 구독하세요: bit.ly/Subscribe-DG
Подписаться на лучшую классическую музыку:: bit.ly/Subscribe-DG
La mejor música clásica - Suscríbase aquí: bit.ly/Subscribe-DG
#DaniilTrifonov #Bach #Piano 
Видеоклипы
![Víkingur Ólafsson - Bach: Organ Sonata No. 4, BWV 528: II. Andante [Adagio] (Transcr. Stradal)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/h3-rNMhIyuQ/mqdefault.jpg)
What is your favourite performance ever by Daniil Trifonov?
His Rachmaninov 3rd Concerto
Chopin : concerto for piano and orchestra, op.21
bach-brahms - chaconne for left hand
Rachmaninoff Concerto 2
Rachmaninoff - Chopin variation
Diese Musik ist Logik, Gehirn, Inspiration , Wissenschaft , Gefühl und Herz zugleich
Dizzying camera work -- sheesh. Changes frames every 7 seconds or so -- what a wreck.
Wenn man Musik von Bach hört, fuhlt man das Gott ist möglich.
@@prometheusrex1 that's the current style-fad. An attempt to be "relevant" to our ever-changing world. I agree with you; it is a wreck.
So impressed by Daniil Trifonov. He is such a treasure and I feel grateful to have the chance to listen to him.
Daniil looks more and more Russian, quite dostoievskian. He escapade from The Brothers Karamazov. This video is a dream in perfect harmony with the nature. Close your eyes or buy the cd if you do not want to watch the film. And please ask no more about Daniil’s finger nails, his hair and his beard. Let him be what he is, a genius.
I completely agree with you.For Daniil it has bever been about him as a person,the music is what is of prime importance to him,not his image (like some other wellknown pianists).He is a sensitive,expressive and emotional player and of course supremely gifted!
An unkempt genius, then. 😎🎹
How can you not recognise he is being marketed to you as a stereotypical "genius" and just fall for it hook, line, and sinker?
@@bodhisattvaoflazyness
Well, most probably because through the years I attended numerous concerts or recitals with Trifonov which convinced me of the superpower of his way to perform music. I do not care about marketing. Of course, this clip is not essential , but you are not oblige to watch it. By the way, Daniil will perform his Bach recital on Wednesday evening in Monaco, without any clip.
He strikes me more like a busy Alchemist passionately slaving away at following up on his various inspirations then some raskolnikov type glued to a mattress or a couch trying desperately to cook up some scene of great drama by which to give some Outside Agency to his internal suffering.
This is my favorite fugue played by my favorite living pianist!🎶🤩 It is complex, beautiful, elegiac, consoling and hopeful at one time. I think Bach wrote this fugue with the knowledge that his days were numbered. Rest in peace Johann Sebastian Bach ❤️
JSB, the greatest of them all.
"elegiac, consoling and hopeful at one time" - lol
The beauty of this rendition is beyond words.
Beyond words indeed! It reminds me of Einstein's quote: "Regarding Bach's music, I have this to say: listen, play, love, revere and keep your mouth shut!"(In The Ultimate Quotable Einstein, Alice Calaprice(editor).
@@georgesmelki1He has simmilar quotes about Mozart, which was his favourite favourite composer of all.
"Mozart is the greatest composer of all. Beethoven created his music, but the music of Mozart is of such purity and beauty that one feels he merely found it - that it has always existed as part of the inner beauty of the universe waiting to be revealed."
And "One shouldn't despair about mankind knowing Mozart was a man" and more.
Trifonov is doing the right thing! According to J.S.Bach himself, his music is not scholarly - but for the heart. This sounds organic, self grown - freshly sprung from Bachs imagination.
I'm perfectly agree.
Very often the contrapuntal technique is pulsating life, in Bach. I see a very strong metaphor in it, which perhaps is the one captured by this pianist. Each person comes into the world necessarily conditioned by the inheritance of the past of the person who brought him into the world and the context in which he finds himself. There are patterns that are at the same time the conditions of our existence and what binds us into a feeling of anguish. The variation, the counterpoint are metaphors of the soul that with difficulty, through its bonds, tries to build a self beyond itself to reach authenticity.
A man like Bach, a son of his time, interprets in the search for God this realization of a soul that is necessarily born separated from its creator and that struggles against his limits (sin, for example) to rejoin him. In today's vision of this pianist, perhaps there is no longer a God who ensures a safe haven for the authenticity of human existence, but the sensation that each of us experiences at least once, in feeling evanescent, inauthentic if he does not test himself to go beyond what is taken for granted, beyond the "given song" remains. And I think this author's reinterpretation of Bach's work is enchanting.
@@lethalgiada 👍
no
Woah and WOW...what beautiful intuition in beautiful chosen words. Thank you
Would you know the source of that quote (for the heart, rather than scholarly).
This piece is new to me AND it is J.S. Bach. Since I first heard a performance of his “Jesu, joy of man’s desiring” when about twelve years old I was immediately transported into a realm of celestial, gracious beauty the likes I had never experienced. It is an indelible, precious memory that has since grown into an inspirational spark of lyricism when some years ago I composed a verse to that great chorale and sang it at a wedding anniversary celebration. I am moved by every piece I have heard by this great musical genius. PWG
Loved the ad for dairy milk chocolate at about the six minute mark. Transmogrifying. My planetary body was Vivifyied to an unprecedented degree
This contrapunctus is one of the most amazing creations in the history of music.
To run ads during BACH anywhere anytime is such an Atrocity!!! Degradation of humanity in bloom and Bach rhelps to feel it even more. Superb performance and interpretation. Thank you Спасибо. Рахмат.
Use Brave browser and you won't get ads.
He is the best. Virtuoso in concerts, perfect in Chamber músic, the perfect student of the Bach family. Complete and superb.
Absolutely lovely -- understated and wonderful . . .
Trifonov, like Gould and Fray, is considered one of the greatest Bach interpreters.
Lloré. ¿El final? Es como a vos más te guste y lo sientas; Bach te lo permite, te concede ese regalo, te otorga esa libertad después de haber transitado todos sus _contrapuncti_... Esa es la sonrisita de Daniil, la gracia adquirida. Gracias por tanto!
Legis jugum.
Libertas Evangelii.
beautiful music and images that match that beauty. Bravo Daniil.
Of the many, many attempts to complete this sublime fugue, this is the only one of those I've heard that makes sense to me emotionally and structurally. It seems to flow seamlessly out of what has gone before, tying it all up in a completely satisfying conclusion, and with utter humility and reverence for the monumental edifice that Bach has constructed. Thank you, Mr. Trifonov.
Exquisite. Daniil's sensitive rendering of Bach's counterpoint is profound and overwhelming. I can do without the video.
I’d close your eyes then. We’re living in the digital world of audio and video, I thought the video was great, very different, and doesn’t distract. One thing that remains with the video being present, is the music.
Hopefully it'll be released on spotify and other music streaming platform!
@@originunknown3209 I just don't look. The video is weird and desperately reaching for some deep meaning. It fails.
Its good to go outside the norm sometimes.....
@@Bruce.-Wayne: Only when it’s done well. 😎🎹
Eccellente! È un CAPOLAVORO MUSICALE NONCHÉ SPIRITUALE! RIMANE Nel CUORE, NELLA MENTE E NELL' ANIMA Di Chi LO ASCOLTA MOLTO A LUNGO! GRAZIE 💥💯❤
This video is excellent, and the ending, which was composed by Trifonov himself is very well executed. I'm a profesional pianist myself and one thing that always rubs me the wrong way, is the rigidity of the classical music culture. The video is a very creative and personal way of expressing Bach's music, and I like that it has a certain gloom to it that is uncommon when referring to Bach's music, but tells us that not everybody feel's music the same way. Many classical music enthusiasts will get offended when they see their precious Bach being "profanated" by a video like this, which only serves to gatekeep new and original attempts at expressing old music in a new way which is very much needed in this day and age for this new generation.
Couldn’t agree more! And why not! The fashion always changes, there have been always conservative and liberal fans and performers of classical music, the main thing is to keep it alive!
I don't like the video
Very well said bro!!
it's just a commercial. but with poor acting and boring playing. but it's the new DG-stile.
Hé oui, le poncif du génie créateur en lutte avec éléments ainsi que le poncif de la partition-Jacques Loussier, à l'àge de 80 ans, n'en avait pas besoin-Michel Legrand non plus-
Congratulations Daniil. I'm really glad he decided to start playing more and more trascendental pieces from the piano literature. No need for crazy virtuosism, we already know he is a beast at the piano.
I agree with you. Daniil is the best in romantic piano, I hope he plays WTC1 and 2 soon.
@@alindmay That would be nice indeed.
В последние недели эта композиция является для меня источником глубокого и чистого вдохновения. Даниил Трифонов служит примером подлинной реинкарнации, возможно, величайшего гения в истории музыки ❤ браво, маэстро!
Daniil Trifonov clearly has a talent for acting as well! Would like to see him play a role.
Браво!!!!это восхитительно и неповторимо!!!!как прекрасна жизнь,когда в ней есть такая !!!музыка!!!!
映画のような美しい映像…引き込まれました。
amazing! very deep impression! thank you for your invaluable work!🙏
Спасибо за вдохновение и за поиски! Окончание достойное Kunst Der Fuge B-A-C-H
His pandemic living room concert of the entire Art of Fugue was epic. 70 minutes straight through. No words do it justice. It may have been in conjuction with the Verbier Festival.
Какое счастье, что есть такой пианист... Даниил Трифонов.. И 30 января я буду слушать "Искусство фуги" в Москве
в его исполнении в Зале Чайковского... Вот это начало моего Года Тигра!!
Интересно,Вы успели побывать на этом концерте? Я только на канале Даниила тот,что остается ему после записи диска с 'D.J'.), но только звук и нет комментариев.Прекрасное исполнение и восхитительный канон в конце 'Искусства Фуги',сочиненный самим Даней.
Счастливые.Мвслегно мы с вами.
@@user-mh2ey9px6n я слушала концерт Трифонова ( в программе : искусство фуги ,скрипичная Чакона и многое другое в том числе и на бис ) в Чикагской филармонии. Это было НЕЗАБЫВАЕМО . ДАНИИЛ ТРИФОНОВ---- ОЛИМПИЕЦ
thank you!
Daniil, ein Genius und Schöngeist. Seine Art der Welt Musik zu erklären, ihm zuzuhören. Es gefällt mir sehr und trägt mich hinweg in die Welt von Bach. Er war ebenfalls ein Genie und Musikversteher.
Danke für deine Interpretationen.🎹💐
Самый причудливый микс впечатляющей кинематографии и нестриженных ногтей,10/10.
Наверное он любитель читать Делёза.
Мне тоже первым делом бросились в глаза ногти. И не клацают? 😯
@@annagolovko-lv4mz8nt4w запись же в студии... с соответствующим маникюром пианиста
Дыши ровно,слушай музыку,расслабься...
и я поразилась его ногтям...
Das ist sehr komplex. Danke schön. Sie zeigen klar Komplexität, Tiefe und eig. Genialität vom Bachs Werk
Thanks, Dan, for the wonderful performance last night for Gil Shiva ar Carnegie Hall..
JS Bach brings me closer to God whilst make he realise that we are not so bad as humans to create and play such heavenly music as Daniil Trifonov does.
Beautiful completion with this ghostly yet majestic ending.
Ciekawa stylizacja pianisty . Utwór do filmu stwarza wrażenie --zmiennej emocji i zamyśleia nad losem człowieka
Brawo!!!!🌹🌹🌹🌧️🌧️⚡⚡
By far the greatest pianist of this era. His name should be mentioned along with Rubenstein, Rachmaninoff, and HOrowitz. The more he ages, the more he looks like a Russian monk - I wonder if he would write any Russian choral music for the Orthodox church.
I was moved at the practice struggle with the entire Art of the Fugue, the work that Bach, blind and mind humming, is said to have dictated to his son. The wonderful TRIFONOV with his beautiful Fazioli Pianoforte 20th century instrument in a room next to the fire in the hearth, the wall filled with the score to the fugues like a detective examining the record of the event that led to Bach’s final gift to us all. The performer struggles to get into Bach’s mind and find the “Affect” for every note. It leads him to dreams and not to a machine, like the modern Pianoforte but into the organic world of all life and yes to the tree as well, but most of all the resolution to the question Bach posed for us all.
Bravo to the artists involved in bringing this heritage of western civilization into the present when it was not so long ago mankind’s political ego and warlike nature bombing the libraries, architecture and paintings that was the legacy of the past to the world. I’m thankful for the shards that are left as we still contemplate war for fun and personal profit. Ray Evans Harrell,
Beautiful, thank you!
Merci de me faire découvrir ce morceau absolument magnifique!!
This piece has the same sense of valedictory wisdom as Chopin's Nocturne Op 62 no 2. Both are beautiful blends of sadness, reconciliation and hope.
BRAVO! What an incredible production. Beautiful recording and stunning visuals. The colors are so rich! And an engaging story to tie it all together?! Wow! I am truly impressed and moved.
Wow ein Meisterwerk auf allen ebnen. Auch wie schön das umgesetzt wurde vom Video und alles noch mal verdeutlicht. Wirklich großartig. Mir hat vor allem die Szene gefallen und wo er das Stück Rinde verschiebt, dem Stück so ein stück seiner Seele einplanzt.
Nash 😌
I was working and had this in the background. I stop myself to see who's playing. Excellent!
Я понимаю и тех, кто пишет, что музыка Баха намного глубже, чем какое-бы то ни было изображение её в видеоряде.
Но, с другой стороны, мне понравилось, как с момента, где началась часть, сочиненная Даниилом, звук как-бы "провалился в сон", и ещё что когда он дописывал ноты в лесу, он рисовал только паузы и дорисовывал палочки, обозначающие длительности к листикам, которые уже были на бумаге, как-бы метафора того, что музыка уже растворена в природе и "берётся, добывается" из неё.
В общем, если рассматривать эту работу не как попытку передать музыку средствами кино, а наоборот, как мини-фильм (клип), в котором звучит музыка Баха (звучит же музыка в фильмах, раскрывая нам смысл происходящего на экране глубже), то это интересно.
MVの雰囲気もあるとは思うけど、この方の演奏は深く心に刺さってくるものがあります。
Genius from Bach and Trifonov.
The beauty of music is that it can be interpreted endlessly and in this case, completed in thousands of ways. We will never know what Bach intended, but we can be inspired to try as Daniil has done here and for that, we should applaud and thank him.
Powerful music and poetic visuals, congratulations to all people involved.
Trifonov is one of my favorite performers.
9
WONDERFUL performance! Thank you, Daniel! You have a true gift for the world! :)
Beautiful! Thank you for posting this. xxx
Прекрасное очень выразительное исполнение Баха. Благодарю. Я бы назвала его " Собеседники".
une tres belle version des derniers contrapunctus de Bach. J'en felicite Trifonov para sa originalité
Love the story in the video and the twist is brilliant. I didn't see it coming, and I thought I'm quite good at spotting them.
this clip fully reflects the life of a musician and how much work and sacrifice there is behind such a high level!! I don't know in this world how much we have understood that this guy the greatest pianist in the universe right now no one right now is better than him and I don't think in the last 30 or 40 years there has been anyone better than him just a musician can fully understand the level of this guy who is extremely stratospheric he is such a complete pianist as one rarely hears when he plays he practically found himself in another dimension both mental and physical and we have all seen this it is useless for anyone to do the hypocrite, this guy is the best in the world by far, there are many great pianists but no one like him !!!!🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼
Vielen Dank für Ihr treffenden Worte ! Sie drücken aus, was ich fühle, höre und sehe bei Daniil Trifonov, dem begnadeten Musiker und liebenswerten Menschen ! ❤
Большое спасибо за Ваше очень верное понимание Даниила Трифонова.Я рада, что у него так,много настоящих ценителей его музыкального гения.
Петербург.
Can't believe there are so many whinging people here complaining about the video and Trifonov's fingernails. Why worry about these things, if it doesn't affect the music...
Because they don’t understand the music. #idiocracy
You really can tell when Bach ends
@@lukeluke7082Когда он просыпается ночью,берет ноты и уходит в лес.Тут музыка становится глуше.Это где-то 8мин..41сек.
Annoying video but...Boys, what a pianist!
Loosers
How graceful and mysterious mood! I like this video very much. Awesome!!
His musicality seems to be getting deeper and evolving to a higher level. Very impressive.
Мне все нравится . Пусть будет и видео . Не усложняйте ничего . Слушайте без видео , слушайте с видео , лишь бы слушайте это исполнение .
Super vid! Dramatic 🥲
divine and pure art
Thank you for this emotion and this awesome musical touching vid
When the pieces of Bach are completed (which is the case for all of them except this one), they look (or rather listen) obvious until their last note. But when they are not, it is such a struggle to complete them, even by a genious musician like Daniil Trifonov. But the result is there: congratulations! This is a great moment of music (and of cinema).
I love love love the complementing video to the dreamy music. So tastefully done, so intense the entire whole of it.
I signed in just to sub and like this performance. It was a visual and audio masterwork. Thank you for sharing this gift with the world.
Thanks Daniil
Performance and the video production of the best ever! Thank you for sharing such beauty for all.
Our pleasure!
Speechless
I feel that this beautiful performance is trivialized by this video. Daniil doesnt need gimicks to make his work appealing. His playing and expressions are spellbinding in and of themselves. fascinating.
It's not a gimmick. It's just different.
Its DG's marketing (which he accepted).
I love the video. the expression. and of course the rendition of Bach music.
Wow so Great very nice God bless you
His playing is magnificent, as always.
Yet another outstanding recording from Deutsche Grammophon.
Smashing.
Bravo… bravo!! 🥹🙌🏻
Потрясающе!
The pure soul of a genius composer and a genius artist
Yes, he is very talented, very!
Отшельник...
Maravilloso video.
Maravillosa interpretación.
Una pena que en RUclips, a los pocos minutos de música, éste video fue interrumpido por una ruidosa propaganda. No sé si la propaganda es aleatoria, pero es un crimen interrumpir una música que transporta, con un reclame indeseable y totalmente inapropiado.
Daniil Trifonof un genio.
Danila sam slusala uzivo...Njegov ton ima nesvakidasnju boju...on je kao madjionicar,sta god da uradi ,to zvuci sjajno...prema Bachu duboka poniznost i prekrasna interpretacija...Bravo!💐👏❤️
Очень приятная музыка 🎶👏 Браво
Stylistically, his completion, which begins at 8:40, doesn't really convince me, but I do really like how he wove in subjects from earlier contrapuncti.
Nobody cares about John Harrington being convinced. If you want to write your ending, go for it. I just can't stand armchair critics that can't find anything better to do. Who else in the past 300 years ever even Attempted to write an ending for this piece by Bach, let alone Complete one, Record it and make a Video of it for our benefit? So I guess Trifonov is still Way Beyond what You've accomplished in our lifetime!
@@kevindavidson6242 numerous people have completed this fugue. The fact that you're unaware of that reveals your complete ignorance.
I'm as entitled to my opinion as anyone else is. I don't make my career in music, so of course I wouldn't attempt a completion of this fugue, however, if I did, I would make sure that it was as close to Bach as to be indistinguishable from Bach before I published it or performed it. Anyting else is merely an exercise in ego. As to ego, the ridiculous histrionics in this video speak for themselves.
Finally, if I did perform it, I would brace myself for criticism. If I couldn't take criticism, I wouldn't perform it.
@@kevindavidson6242 So you don't know of other attempts to complete this fugue? 🙄
Wasn't it likely intended to be the only 4-part fugue in the set? The piece would have concluded with the 3 subjects of XIV finally combined with the main subject of the Kunst der Fuge. I don't know if Trifonov's ending achieves this, you'd have to listen extremely carefully with the sheets in front of you. But I definitely heard the main subject being introduced at some point. In any case, being able to convincingly complete this composition is a stellar feat in and of itself! Have a good day!
@@vaadwilsla858 absolutely wright! you need to follow carefully music sheet in front of you and analyse subject and counterpoint, but in slow mode as possible.
8:41 is Trifonov's part. The playing is very good I, really think, but I disagree that it's "a seamless, stylistically respectful conclusion worthy of Bach’s genius", it's simply a small addition to just conclude the work, with "not stylistically respectful" octaves on the left hand, for example. If it were to really develop what Bach has set out with his materials, I would imagine that he would still go a long way, a long path of combinatory development, since Bach never shies away from profound and exaustive "florescence" of all the seeds he plants in a way that still amazes us. I appreciate the tree metaphor, but promotional talk should not get too excited, sometimes. Pianists like Trifonov are great players/musicians, but the distance to musicians of the past that could not only play, but compose and improvise is huge. This to show that some current adulation sould be put in context and moderated.
I agree that it isn't a seamless or stylistically consistent conclusion. I don't even think that was Trifonov's intention here. You hear an immediate stylistic and athmospheric shift when his part begins, as if he wanted to make explicit that everything thereafter is but an echo of Bach's piece in the same way that much of music history is an echo of Bach's genius. Personally, I find that more respectful than attempting to imitate Bach.
@@monelleny I will not respond to comments that are below a certain level of courtesy and that misread what is written in my commentary, best wishes
@@monelleny you should educate yourself, yourself. the kind of improvised composition that musicians like Bach, Mozart, and Beethoven did is INDEED a different ballgame from what the wonderful Trifonov does. in many ways, trifonov surpasses the technique and astounding versatility of those 3 masters - but he is not remotely close (like, not REMOTELY) to them in improvisation or composition. that's what Produção Os Músicos do Tejo is talking about. take a seat, listen, and learn
@@monelleny busted - i'm a man, and i'm assuming you're not? you're the one who called out a very intelligent comment. i hope you don't get too distracted by our gender dynamic
@@monelleny you deleted your previous comment because you knew it didn't look good
W.O.W!
Grandissimo ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Bach i rosyjska dusza. Genialne.
that was awesome, thanks
Beautiful and the video concept was superb as well
Huge talented pianist
Questa musica è l'eco di "qualcosa" che accade in regioni infinitamente piu eccelse. La prova che una scintilla eterna brilla nell'uomo. Chi si abbassa e chiede la Luce, diventa vero Tempio ed Altare in cui scende il Signore Dio il Re del Cielo e della terra. Qui, nel silenzio e nel segreto, Egli illumina, insegna, ricorda, spiega ciò che non appartiene più alla terra nell'eterno giardino in cui il Padre torna a stringere al Suo Cuore i suoi figli, Immagine di Sé stesso. 🙏
Excellent 🙏
Brilliant, thank you~ ☀️
Love this, thanks.
i really hope more classical musicians make an attempt to story-tell in this way visually. It adds a whole new unique dimension to the music and since today's younger audiences are so visually focused, it will help reach a new demographic more effectively! cool video!!
It needs lots of money 😂
This vid is sickening. I don't need some dramatization. Just perform the f'ing piece without the stupid MTV horse crap!
Fantàstic!
Thoughtful and special beautyful done Video ! Daniil Trifonov as convincing Acter very charming ! To my Opignion , it's supporting the unreached Beauty of this Performance of Art of Fugue ! 🌹🌹🌹
Злиза,добрый вечер! Я прсле концерта в московской филармонии реже смотрю это видео.А еще очень сердита на D.G.за то,что прер
вал с Даниилом контракт после 24 фераля.И я ничего о нем не знала до сентября.,просто с ума сходила. Чи тала все комментарии,а новых не было.
Вот тогда я и ста ла писать свои.
после
@@user-mh2ey9px6n Ich weiss nichts darüber .
Hat er den Vertrag noch mit DG ?
Нет.D.G . даже не включил Даниила в свой ежегодный концерт 2022года.@@elisabethbaumer-sn8go
@@user-mh2ey9px6nI' m so sorry for Daniil ! One Day the DG will regret that. Thanks for Your Answers Irina. If You watch the Rameau Carneghie Recital, You will find my New Answers to You in Your own Comment.❤
Спасибо за интересный опыт.
Идея видео клипа конечно интересна и очень подходит к музыке. Но всё-таки хочется закрыть глаза и наслаждаться гениальной фугой в гениальном исполнении.
Послушайте Г.Гульда.
@@ekaterinablazhkova2215 Исполнение Гульда свидетельствует о том насколько большой талант отягощен умственным заболеванием. Интерпретация Гульда уходит так далеко от Баха и заводит в какие-то необъяснимые дебри болезненной фантазии. Музыкальное творчество умственно больных людей это не частое явление, а в нём Гульд это конечно гений. Только давайте не путать, это две разные категории - творчество умственно полноценных пианистов и умственно больных. Так-же как есть спорт здоровых людей и отдельная категория спорта для инвалидов.
@@pregart001 здесь явно болен кто-то другой
@@reeik7672 Умственное расстройство Гульда является всем известным фактом. Трифонов - абсолютно здоровый и гениальный пианист. Давайте не будем сравнивать инвалидов со здоровыми людьми. Это неуважительно по отношении к инвалидам, в частности к Гульду. Как бы карикатурно не выглядело его исполнение музыки Баха, давайте не будем его за это осуждать.
@@pregart001 вы какая-та темная по части изучения РАС
I have the utmost respect for Trifonov in opting to dedicate so much time and effort to The Art of Fugue. His interpretations often stand with Sokolov's, Gould's, and Zhu xiao Mei's. I particularly love how he sheds new light on the contrapuncti 8 and 11 with his carefully placed rubati and demonic drive.
However, I find the existence of this video utterly flabergasting: if someone didn't already appreciate (or wasn't already capable of appreciating) THE ART OF FUGUE, would this jumpy dream sequence in which the director chose to cut every 2 seconds help them in doing so?
Conversely, if someone already did appreciate the music, does this add anything at all to the experience? Why is the accompanying video to one of the most profound pieces ever written as _about_ the process of the performer's learning it as possible? Can you for a moment see Richter, Gould, Zhu Xiao Mei, Sokolov etc or many other great artists agreeing to such a video and putting _themselves_ center stage in one of their performances? Would not a simple video of the performance have sufficed?
Like I say, I have the utmost respect for Trifonov but simply cannot understand what this video is supposed to add, or why it exists.
It's almost as if different people enjoy different things? Perhaps the video and the atmosphere it portrays could resonate with someone not currently 'into' classical music. Or perhaps some people just enjoy music videos?
You're able to purchase and listen to this CD without any distractions, so why is it such an issue that it's available in another form here, that is both free, and optional to view? I'm not one for music videos, but your comment just screams narrow minded elitism and being completely out of touch.
@@dcytol "The truth of the matter is that the video is simply banale, mindless crap and has no place anywhere within a billion miles (preferably infinitely further) of the music of J.S. Bach" - beautifully put 😂
@@MattCooperKay And you're writing this on behalf of the people who _enjoy_ that sort of videos as if those poor creatures can not speak for themselves. Who's the elitist in here?
There are many forms of art. I found the video to be poetic as well, if a bit different from the music. Please watch it again to see the metaphors.
Obviously, it is supposed to add views, hence money.
Beautiful.
I love the video and think it's cool! Beautiful
По этой записи видно, что Д.Трифонов вступает в пору своей пианистической зрелости.
wunderschön
Восхитительно