Who else? Every single player on both those Giant teams genius. The Pats only scored 31 points total in those 2 Super Bowls. That's not a credit to Eli.
Measuring individuals by team success is the most absurd sentiment in all of sports! A guy caught a pass with his helmet, what does that have to do with Eli? A guy shanked a kick, what does that have to do with Jim Kelly? A coach passed the ball, what does that have to do with Russell Wilson? A team had a meltdown, what does that have to do with Matt Ryan? A kicker made three deciding kicks, what does that have to do with Tom Brady? A defense was the best ever, what does that have to do with McMahon?.....and on and on and on, not to mention ten thousand other variables throughout every season. Why people buy into this is beyond me, teams win games, not quarterbacks!
You measure a quarterback by team success because an elite quarterback elevates the team. When you are overly concerned about your own stats to the exclusion of the team, you end up winning mvps for those sparkling qb ratings, but you still can't get very far in the playoffs.
"Is this mid QB with two rings better than one of the greatest to ever throw it who only has one ring?" Are we serious with this question? Slow news day? We have to invent insane topics? Even as a Rodgers hater, it's so incredibly obvious how much better at the game he was than Eli. Just take a glance at their career stats. 1 more SB win doesn't come anywhere close to erasing the massive TD-INT ratio discrepancy between the two. Eli barely stayed above 60% completion for his career, Rodgers is above 65%. Anyone picking Eli is straight up delusional.
While we remember great season players, but Super Bowl and big moments have a bigger impact on our memories. Dan Marino was a great QB, but more people remember John Elway going out in back-to-back Super Bowl wins than Marino's 5000-yard seasons in the 80s. Do you remember an in-season game with 300+ yards, or John doing a helicopter when running to get his team to the promised land in the Super Bowl?
I'd take Eli Manning's career over Aaron Rodgers's career, because team success is more important than individual success. At the same time, Rodgers is a HOFer and Eli isn't.
Aaron Rodgers had far better team success actually. Eli was a .500 QB and had two great playoff runs. Rodgers has a much better record on top of more playoff wins
@@cc-ec1if Very fair point. It comes down to how much you weigh that (and Rodgers's far superior individual accomplishments) against getting to play in and then win a second Super Bowl. If we're only looking at team accomplishments, I still give the edge to Eli, but I won't argue if others see it differently.
Eli was a .500 QB and Rodgers is a .500 QB in the playoffs 1 ring, 4 MVP's vs. 2 rings, 0 MVP but beat an undefeated team in the final game. Eli did not over perform however, he was a #1 overall pick. It's heads or tails, really
Aaron Rodgers because he has MVPs and regular seasons stats is better than Eli only two seasons plus he is top ten in INTs if he stayed long he would have more INTs than Brett Favre lol
Eli was the top pick of the draft and refused to go to the team who drafted him. Aaron was picked in the 20's and had to sit for 3 years and still put up insane numbers. Saying you would rather have Eli's career because he overperformed is just plain stupid.
Good question. Didn’t Eli and the Giants beat Rodgers in Lambeau during their 15-1 season on the way to the 2nd ring? While Rodgers has the better stats and regular season performances, Eli was clutch in some of the biggest moments you can have whereas Rodgers doesn’t perform well in the playoffs when it counts most. And this last season of Rodgers has shown he shouldn’t be considered In the same discussion with a Brady or a Montana; Rodgers lacks the leadership and team first mentality. Eli all the way - it was always team first. When did Eli ever throw a teammate under the bus? Rodgers does it at least once or twice a game.
This is the dumbest debate I have ever seen. Rodgers is on so many levels above Eli. Rodgers is a 4 time MVP and has the some of the best stats ever. Eli isn’t even a top 20 QB all time.
Eli Manning. The quarterbacks he beat in the 2 super bowl runs he had are Tom Brady Aaron Rodgers Brett Farve Matt Ryan Tony Romo. Also he had to face the 49ers defense who had a top 5 defense that year. Also the two plays everybody talks about are because 1 eli isnt a very mobile qb which him getting out of that sack was crazy 2 The throw to manningham is considered one of the greatest throws in superbowl history Yes eli wasnt consistant but when he made the playoffs he delivered more times than not
Eli is not a hall of fame, his yearly stats are crap, OK let's just put Trent dilfer in the hall of fame, he has one, oh Eli has 2 who cares, just idiots
You guys are stupid Rodgers in his prime got so many bad breaks Did yall forget the onside kick the packers muffed against the seahawks to make the superbowl !!!????
the correlation between people with cartoon characters in their thumbnail and saying stupid things seems to be 1:1 on this platform. Go watch anime, kid. Leave the football to the adults
Eli acts like a man, Rogers acts like a loser
I can hear Todd saying that and afterwards say "but im still taking Rodgers because he reminds me of Elway" 😂😂
Who else can say that they beat Tom Brady in the Superbowl, TWICE ??? Eli Manning is absolutely a First ballot Hall of Famer.
Not a first ballot HOF, but definitely a better career than rodgers. Rodgers will be well known for playoff failure.
@@snowman9642so Eli is better than Tom since he beat him twice right?
A bunch of other New York Giants can say it too. Brandon Jacobs, Ahmad Bradshaw, etc.
What else has he done ?
Who else? Every single player on both those Giant teams genius. The Pats only scored 31 points total in those 2 Super Bowls. That's not a credit to Eli.
Measuring individuals by team success is the most absurd sentiment in all of sports! A guy caught a pass with his helmet, what does that have to do with Eli? A guy shanked a kick, what does that have to do with Jim Kelly? A coach passed the ball, what does that have to do with Russell Wilson? A team had a meltdown, what does that have to do with Matt Ryan? A kicker made three deciding kicks, what does that have to do with Tom Brady? A defense was the best ever, what does that have to do with McMahon?.....and on and on and on, not to mention ten thousand other variables throughout every season. Why people buy into this is beyond me, teams win games, not quarterbacks!
You measure a quarterback by team success because an elite quarterback elevates the team. When you are overly concerned about your own stats to the exclusion of the team, you end up winning mvps for those sparkling qb ratings, but you still can't get very far in the playoffs.
I'll take Super Bowls over MVPs every time.
But you wouldn't say that about Dan Marino
2 SB and 0 MVP vs 1 SB and 4 MVP. Then look at their career stats.
Anyone picking Eli isn't tying their own shoes.
MVP'S are a opinion of sports writers its like winning a Oscar. You can debate any years winner. @@cmillertime7477
This can’t be a serious question
"Is this mid QB with two rings better than one of the greatest to ever throw it who only has one ring?"
Are we serious with this question? Slow news day? We have to invent insane topics? Even as a Rodgers hater, it's so incredibly obvious how much better at the game he was than Eli. Just take a glance at their career stats. 1 more SB win doesn't come anywhere close to erasing the massive TD-INT ratio discrepancy between the two. Eli barely stayed above 60% completion for his career, Rodgers is above 65%. Anyone picking Eli is straight up delusional.
It’s really just Rodgers hate😂
If Eli's vaccinated, I'll take Eli.
💀
I can't believe this is even a question worth asking
no way, Aaron Rodgers is night and day better.
Everyone knows that. But that wasn't the question.
That was a great poll question BTW.
While we remember great season players, but Super Bowl and big moments have a bigger impact on our memories. Dan Marino was a great QB, but more people remember John Elway going out in back-to-back Super Bowl wins than Marino's 5000-yard seasons in the 80s. Do you remember an in-season game with 300+ yards, or John doing a helicopter when running to get his team to the promised land in the Super Bowl?
Aaron will turn this team around
Yeeeesss!!! Let’s get this question floating into the public lexicon!!
I'd take Eli Manning's career over Aaron Rodgers's career, because team success is more important than individual success. At the same time, Rodgers is a HOFer and Eli isn't.
Aaron Rodgers had far better team success actually. Eli was a .500 QB and had two great playoff runs. Rodgers has a much better record on top of more playoff wins
@@cc-ec1if Very fair point. It comes down to how much you weigh that (and Rodgers's far superior individual accomplishments) against getting to play in and then win a second Super Bowl.
If we're only looking at team accomplishments, I still give the edge to Eli, but I won't argue if others see it differently.
Ik he’s been bad, but this really a conversation 😂
“You play to win the game!” Anyone picking Rodgers just doesn’t get it.
Okay, then would you rather have had Leon Lett's career than Aaron Rodgers's career?
He won one more than him wtf are u talking abt 😂
@@DougPirahna did he start in any of those Superbowls? No, he didn’t. However, I would rather have had Troy Aikman’s career than Eli’s.
@@glocorp2478 we’re talking about Superbowls lil bro.
Eli was a .500 QB and Rodgers is a .500 QB in the playoffs
1 ring, 4 MVP's vs. 2 rings, 0 MVP but beat an undefeated team in the final game.
Eli did not over perform however, he was a #1 overall pick.
It's heads or tails, really
Aaron Rodgers because he has MVPs and regular seasons stats is better than Eli only two seasons plus he is top ten in INTs if he stayed long he would have more INTs than Brett Favre lol
Spectrum Todd!
I can relate 😂
Eli was the top pick of the draft and refused to go to the team who drafted him.
Aaron was picked in the 20's and had to sit for 3 years and still put up insane numbers.
Saying you would rather have Eli's career because he overperformed is just plain stupid.
Good question. Didn’t Eli and the Giants beat Rodgers in Lambeau during their 15-1 season on the way to the 2nd ring? While Rodgers has the better stats and regular season performances, Eli was clutch in some of the biggest moments you can have whereas Rodgers doesn’t perform well in the playoffs when it counts most. And this last season of Rodgers has shown he shouldn’t be considered In the same discussion with a Brady or a Montana; Rodgers lacks the leadership and team first mentality. Eli all the way - it was always team first. When did Eli ever throw a teammate under the bus? Rodgers does it at least once or twice a game.
So Eli better deserves to be in that discussion like bro really 😭
This is the dumbest debate I have ever seen. Rodgers is on so many levels above Eli. Rodgers is a 4 time MVP and has the some of the best stats ever. Eli isn’t even a top 20 QB all time.
That's what Rodgers cares about, stats. That's why he plays cautiously. If That's what you like, alrighty.
@ Eli isn’t better because he got a second ring.
the Rodgers hate is crazy bc this ain’t even close and I think Eli is a HOF
3:28 Arod now makes Eli back then look like a 50 year old 😂
Eli Manning. The quarterbacks he beat in the 2 super bowl runs he had are Tom Brady Aaron Rodgers Brett Farve Matt Ryan Tony Romo. Also he had to face the 49ers defense who had a top 5 defense that year. Also the two plays everybody talks about are because
1 eli isnt a very mobile qb which him getting out of that sack was crazy
2 The throw to manningham is considered one of the greatest throws in superbowl history
Yes eli wasnt consistant but when he made the playoffs he delivered more times than not
3:09 he was not a consistent good qb 😭😭😭🤦🏽♂️ like no way you can say that and claim you know the nfl
Interesting question...
That is not even a question, Eli should not even be in the hol of fame, defense won them
What a stupid question lmaoo
Is Todd Fritz "The Mole"...
Eli first ballot Hall of GOOD?
Eli
About the same. Neither is that great. Both had great people around them
What 😂
Eli is not a hall of fame, his yearly stats are crap, OK let's just put Trent dilfer in the hall of fame, he has one, oh Eli has 2 who cares, just idiots
Is this real? Aaron actually won MVPs
You guys are stupid
Rodgers in his prime got so many bad breaks
Did yall forget the onside kick the packers muffed against the seahawks to make the superbowl !!!????
Oh wow - why don't you just walk across his face with cleats on. Jets and AR fan - this is a d* thing to do right now.
KAaron Rodgers is over.
Been watching NFL since 1972, Eli buy a fu*king mile. I'll take Fran Tarkington over Rogers.
I was boutta say sum but I looked at ur pfp 😂
@@glocorp2478 Say what? Unsure what boutta is, some kind of enima? Sum is a total, what's your total, total of what?
@@wrealini I rest my case 💀
I pick neither one. They both SUCK!
the correlation between people with cartoon characters in their thumbnail and saying stupid things seems to be 1:1 on this platform.
Go watch anime, kid. Leave the football to the adults
@JohnSmith-tk7nt Did I hit a soft spot, jock rider?
@@DD01880 Nothing to do with sensitivity, you're just not very bright. Rodgers has thrown passes that haven't been thrown by anyone in history!
@@DD01880 Things last forever on the internet, kid. Someday youll be older than 13 and youll be embarrassed by this version of yourself