This performance shows their real live vocal even with less effect and more raw than the one that SM uploaded. But it just sounds even better lol so to those haters u really need to admit that they’re all great vocalists
They’re an SM group I’m not surprised that they all can sing. But I am surprised that Karina hit that falsetto flawlessly and so effortlessly, she’s the main dancer and can be a lead vocalist. Even Giselle she sounds so good. She’s the groups rapper but has a beautiful singing voice.
@M.Y. Mystic girls • Please don't say that, not everyone are the same maybe that person are good in vocal or maybe that person are good in dance , maybe both? Respect both of them ;) at least all of them are already successful and they are happy with their lives
I think so far they're the best vocal group of 4th gen, they have the technique that will make them last longer in the industry. They're not straining and forcing their vocals which is important for their career. We can really trust SM with training
Ikr! She is such an insane visual there is no idol like Karina! She is the visual explosion and she is the perfect Korean girl! She fits the beauty standarts perfectly 101%
Coming from a taeyeon's fan.. thank you so much for your beautiful words... she just needs to be more confident about her voice.. her voice got better in each performances, i think she has a versatile voice..
@@foreverinsfired kinda reminds me of joy somehow, her voice got to shine more in each comeback, i hope karina will be too.. she actually can be a really good lead vocalist like joy in rv (i'm not comparing both artist ofc, i love them both).. i hope SM will not limiting her potential
things can never go wrong with sm girl groups. im convinced it is why it takes them so long to find the best girls for a girl group. snsd, fx and rv are all vocal queens and even sm's GG seniors before them and now aespa. man, this is why i never regret stanning sm esp growing up listening to musicians who are REALLY GOOD LIVE. hands down good job uri aespaaa
It’s so hard to focus on just 1 attribute of Karina, her visuals is perfect. Her dancing is a masterpiece. Her vocals is so unique. Her personality is refined. She’s THAT one damn shot in a lifetime.
karina is just a standout, this concept isn't something that should visually compliment her this well but she still manages to attract your attention easily with her elegance and soothing voice. sm has hit a jackpot.
WINTER should release a solo song or a cover so we could hear more of her voice... I see the next Taeyeon in her and Ningning is Jessica in terms of career path.. looking forward to them
@@fairynjun Too many years of theatre, I suppose! Honestly, I think she's quite professional about it--it always makes me anxious, but her face is so composed. I assume she does it in every performance, considering the placement is important for the synchronized/more heavily choreographed bits to look right, but most stages cut to a closeup when they move the mics. You can see her do it in the Cozy Winter Cabin stage, too. The Glitter Snowball stage lets you see their marks pretty clearly because they stand out--just white/silvery tape against the dark floor.
Winter with short hair and Giselle with that hair colour is looking so pretty. And their stylist need a raise....how beautiful their dresses are.I love Winter's outfit most, LOVE AESPA
@@triptisarker9539 do you think i hate aespa :) BIG NO i dont hate them i love them so much but i dont like their outfit bcs u know (sm is bad at giving the best outfit for stage) 👀 lol thats why sm need to fired their stylist tho its literally teribble 🙄✊🏻
@@sschvryy I don't know about the other grps bcz Aespa is the only sm grp I stan. And I liked almost all their outfits in Black Mamba era and also in this oneeee :))
Winter vocal is so perfect, maybe she is not powerfull as ningning. But she has good control and make her vocal stable than any main vocal in 4gen. Don’t forget she can reach highnote too
sorry to say, but this video is not live. I love Aespa but i'm getting angry with SM. They keep preteding to make lives and making people fool. See when Karina go to the mic at 3:05, she didnt reach the mic at the right time. IF was live, her voice should be lower and get higher after she really stand in the mic. i want to see Aespa singing live in some radio. Not these pre recorder things
Giselle's bangs, her wide and round eyes, tall nose, and her sweet smile make her really look like a living barbie. also her voice is so soothing when she sings
와 진짜 노래는 진짜 좋다ㅋㅋㅋ.. 진짜 좋다 와.. 생라이브로 들으니까 신인 아이돌이 이런 발라드를 라이브로 멤버 모두가 성공적으로 물론 음정은 안 맞는 데도 있지만 어쨌든 해낸다는 게 좀 놀랍기도 하고 윈터 음원보다 힘 뺀 라이브를 처음 듣는데 좋아서 놀랐고 카리나 생각보다 안정적이어서 놀랐고 지젤도 놀랍고 닝닝은 그냥 역시 음색 좋고 아니 솔직히 진짜 좀 여러모로 놀랍다
I wouldn’t call them a flop but...... This has 11k views and took them 5 HOURS to do so. If they aren’t a flop they should’ve gotten AT THE LEAST 50k. But talent wise they aren’t a flop🌝
I love Karina’s darker tone. They’re all so good at singing, but to me Karina stands out so much cause the others have brighter voices, whereas hers is darker, kinda like how Jisoo is in BP
Why is Karina so beautiful?! I remember ppl saying she's not that beautiful during her debut and exo-ls in twitter making fun of her face but wth are they saying? She is THAT beautiful. She gives me Irene vibes and I think she's part of those idols with unrealistic visuals
It's the first time they performed Forever for a show. Imagine if there wasn't a pandemic, they would've performed overseas and met international MYs 🥺
Aespa is a VOCAL group, Periodt.
Exactly! All members can sing😌💗
@@Marstatoy
Toxic
Agree
@@ningning9339 Don't mind them, a Twice fan talking about pre-recorded vocals is just hilarious 😂😂😂
@@yveo IKR 🤣🤣
This performance shows their real live vocal even with less effect and more raw than the one that SM uploaded. But it just sounds even better lol so to those haters u really need to admit that they’re all great vocalists
Truuu
Indeed
@Vi na exactly
Exactly! 😌💗
It's better and this is what we need to hear
They’re an SM group I’m not surprised that they all can sing. But I am surprised that Karina hit that falsetto flawlessly and so effortlessly, she’s the main dancer and can be a lead vocalist. Even Giselle she sounds so good. She’s the groups rapper but has a beautiful singing voice.
she's an ace
That's aespa for you: ACES & ALL ROUNDERS 💜
@@Marstatoy someone salty
@@Marstatoy Your faves do need more vocal practice 🤭
@M.Y. Mystic girls • Please don't say that, not everyone are the same maybe that person are good in vocal or maybe that person are good in dance , maybe both? Respect both of them ;) at least all of them are already successful and they are happy with their lives
그리고 당황스러울정도로 퀄리티 높은 알앤비 보컬 그룹 애스파 ;;
진짜 천상지희 느낌이 있음
I think so far they're the best vocal group of 4th gen, they have the technique that will make them last longer in the industry. They're not straining and forcing their vocals which is important for their career. We can really trust SM with training
Aespa vocals is no joke, they’re so pretty omgg!!! Winter like a princess
Yes 💕💕💖💞
She's my queen tho
Why is no one talking about giselle's soothing and beautiful voice
Ikr! It's so beautiful ❤️
Her voice is really stable heree
I love giselle voice🥰
@@nurleninurleni2165 same
@@Marstatoy tell that to momo, tzuyu, chaeyoung, sana, dahyun. Not giselle.
I almost forgot that Giselle's a main rapper and Karina's a main dancer. They're so good.
well for now Giselle didnt really rap yet..so we dont know if she is really the main rapper
@@MaxPower-wf6ky it’s stated on their profiles that she is the main rapper and also she was the only one in her introduction video who rapped...
SM artists are trained for everything lol. There's no surprise that they can sing, dance, and rap. Just look at Seulgi.
@@ejslax of course I know that...its just she didnt proof yet that she is the main rapper...I have no doubt on her
Giselle like Loey rapper with great vocal
Karina's visual is literally like in a webtoon. And that is not an exaggeration.
to me she looks like a very pretty ai. I can’t believe a face like her exists tbh
Ikr! She is such an insane visual there is no idol like Karina! She is the visual explosion and she is the perfect Korean girl! She fits the beauty standarts perfectly 101%
For me she look like wang jarim from webtoon love revolution 😍
Is it just me but it's refreshing to see a 4th gen group singing live with minimal gestures and choreo like this ♥
Precisely!
Precisely!
uhm gidle
SM always be doing something different. They will always make sure their groups are always ahead of their time.
true
Ningning sounds likes a princess!!
Yes i agree
She has beautiful voice ❤️
yes👏
*queen
Karina's tone and vocal colour is so pretty, she will gain more confidence with time and shine brighter as a singer as well.
Coming from a taeyeon's fan.. thank you so much for your beautiful words... she just needs to be more confident about her voice.. her voice got better in each performances, i think she has a versatile voice..
I really think she could be promoted to lead vocal position in the future she really has a beautiful voice
@@foreverinsfired kinda reminds me of joy somehow, her voice got to shine more in each comeback, i hope karina will be too.. she actually can be a really good lead vocalist like joy in rv (i'm not comparing both artist ofc, i love them both).. i hope SM will not limiting her potential
yess
watch her forever focus, it's so damn good
giselle looks so much like a doll omg she’s so pretty!!!!
Pure and cute
Winter's voice sounds like a disney princess!
things can never go wrong with sm girl groups. im convinced it is why it takes them so long to find the best girls for a girl group. snsd, fx and rv are all vocal queens and even sm's GG seniors before them and now aespa. man, this is why i never regret stanning sm esp growing up listening to musicians who are REALLY GOOD LIVE. hands down good job uri aespaaa
Ningning's vocals are crazy good 🤍
Yes she is the best vocalist in the 4th gen
So so good !!!
It’s so hard to focus on just 1 attribute of Karina, her visuals is perfect. Her dancing is a masterpiece. Her vocals is so unique. Her personality is refined. She’s THAT one damn shot in a lifetime.
yess
She's also intelligent ✨
you're right, watch her forever focus you'll be amazed
Ikr 💙
a goddess
Karinas voice, visual, her hair, everything is sooo soooo beautifully shown.
yes
Where's the lie tho
I like all their vocals but I think Winter's voice I love the most!
Winter's vocals r really good
Ning ning's vocals never Disappoint! She's the 4th Gen vocal queen!!
5th
Yes she is the vocal queen of the 4th generation
Listen to her high notes make me chill
@@iamsnowiee Watch yutube ningning and Gisel rap
I think Monday is better
@@dreamies2006 I like Friday
Karina looks amazing with this black hair 😍
yess
Ikr
a goddess
idk why but karina's voice gave me chills
same
Sameeeee
i like her tone
3:37 admit it, in all forever live performances, winter's high pitch always become your favorite, stable clean powerful n addicting so much!
Winters voice is relaxing
karina is just a standout, this concept isn't something that should visually compliment her this well but she still manages to attract your attention easily with her elegance and soothing voice. sm has hit a jackpot.
she REALLY stands out in the girl crush concept but also stands out here too, best center
she's center for a reason
yes
@@Hana-zd1ek aespa dont have center
@@sschvryy even if they dont have a center shes still considered as a center by the public
Wow great vocals, now I'm their fan 👌❤️✨
Stan
welcome to MY ( aespa fans )
Thanks❤️ welcome
Welcome
Welcomee
aespa and purple kiss 🤝 best vocals of gen 4 ggs
SAME
Yes
True
Oh yess of course
frrr
Winter’s soft soothing voice sounds so good and she looks so cute😭😭❤️
WINTER should release a solo song or a cover so we could hear more of her voice... I see the next Taeyeon in her and Ningning is Jessica in terms of career path.. looking forward to them
Omg Ningning voice...
This performance proved that one doesn't need to shout and execute a powerful dance to deliver a quality performance.
true
*When there is only one main vocalist in the group, but you see four main vocalist member*
Their tiktok videos said: 4 Main Dancers too 😂 (WINNING are fighting for it while Giselle is as chill and laidback as usual)
머ㅓ야 지젤 레전드로 예쁘네
거봐라 어두운 머리 하니까 인물이 살잖냐..스엠아..젭알... 일해...
aespa has 4 visuals and 4 vocalists, not many groups can boast such a display of raw talent. congrats girls!
Arghhh my winter is si pretty and cute.it’s been a month since i heard your sweet and angelic vocals
I REALLY LOVE KARINA'S VOICE tone.
me too
Same
Winter looking for her mark to place her mic at 3:17, so cute and focused
She is so cute
@@fairynjun i wonder too lmao
@@fairynjun Too many years of theatre, I suppose! Honestly, I think she's quite professional about it--it always makes me anxious, but her face is so composed. I assume she does it in every performance, considering the placement is important for the synchronized/more heavily choreographed bits to look right, but most stages cut to a closeup when they move the mics. You can see her do it in the Cozy Winter Cabin stage, too. The Glitter Snowball stage lets you see their marks pretty clearly because they stand out--just white/silvery tape against the dark floor.
Winter's voice is so soothing, I could listen to her voice all day.
Winter’s voice is so bautiful😍✨💕
Yes 💗
OMG Giselle vocals 🥺🤍💜
Melting...
i don't know but SM know how to choose a center, KARINA you did a great job, always huhu
SM casting is another level.
yes, love her
🤗❤️
definitely
Ikr she's on another level
Winter with short hair and Giselle with that hair colour is looking so pretty.
And their stylist need a raise....how beautiful their dresses are.I love Winter's outfit most,
LOVE AESPA
their outfit is teribble tho, i hate their stylist
@@sschvryy What do u mean🙄😒😂?
I agree but even though winter is my bias, I have to argue that karina got the best outfit. It's just my opinion though :)
@@triptisarker9539 do you think i hate aespa :) BIG NO i dont hate them i love them so much but i dont like their outfit bcs u know (sm is bad at giving the best outfit for stage) 👀 lol thats why sm need to fired their stylist tho its literally teribble 🙄✊🏻
@@sschvryy I don't know about the other grps bcz Aespa is the only sm grp I stan.
And I liked almost all their outfits in Black Mamba era and also in this oneeee :))
윈터 노래 진짜 편하게 부른다,, 소울이 ㄹㅇ 유영진 딸같음
Winter vocal is so perfect, maybe she is not powerfull as ningning. But she has good control and make her vocal stable than any main vocal in 4gen. Don’t forget she can reach highnote too
giselle looks so cute with that bangs omgggg
💓💓💓
winter's voice soothes me😍
Aespa and PURPLE KISS are the only group that shocked me with their vocals so far. 4th gen queens!
Red Velvet and Mamamoo sister👍😀
@@b.tsy.4657 I said that aespa and purple kiss are the younger sisters of red Velvet and mamamoo, I didn't say that red Velvet and mamamoo are gen 4
@@syarmasdaily Exactly 💯!
sorry to say, but this video is not live. I love Aespa but i'm getting angry with SM. They keep preteding to make lives and making people fool. See when Karina go to the mic at 3:05, she didnt reach the mic at the right time. IF was live, her voice should be lower and get higher after she really stand in the mic.
i want to see Aespa singing live in some radio. Not these pre recorder things
@@kakarabreu yups..i think their not live
닝닝이 얼굴 무슨일이야.. 왜이렇게 이뻐..
Winter gives me hope in my life . Karina's voice is really cute . Work of art
Aespa vocals good
Gissele, you're an angel. All of the members.
I'm really in love with Karina's voice. It's so strong very contradicting with her personality which is sweet. Ilysm Rina
yes
❤️
코디실화냐 에스파는 진짜 스타일리스트중에 스파이 없는지 확인해봐야할듯..
에스파뿐이아니여 에스엠은 그냥 스타일링 개쉣
구냥 이쁜데여
아들이 이뻐서 뭘입어도 이쁨
진심 격공...
더 이쁜 옷을 입으면 날개를 달텐데.. ㅠㅠ 지금은 그저 저런 옷도 소화하는 애들이 대단해 보일 뿐..
왜 좋은데
와 이 그룹은 구멍이 없다 카리나는 리드보컬 해도 손색없겠다 라이브에도 전혀 흔들림 없네
감사합니다😿❤️
외국애가 한국말로 댓글을 다네..
@@myluv3912 한국댓글 복사한건가 ㅋㅋ
Karina's stage presence is really outstanding. My ghad!! she is just sitting there but my eyes is so focus to her.
love her
Yes ❤️
Winter is a period. Love u ma gurl
Giselle's hair is so ICONIC
Winter’s voice is so soothing to the ears 🥺
Giselle's bangs, her wide and round eyes, tall nose, and her sweet smile make her really look like a living barbie. also her voice is so soothing when she sings
Visual + Vocal = Aespa
why do I keep on holding my breath everytime winter stares at the camera? there is rlly something about her stares that mesmerize me.
Giselle is so magical girl...
WINTER VOICE AND BEAUTY
윈터 저 머리 진짜진짜ㅣㅈㄴ짜 이쁘다 ... 찰떡이야 너무 잘어울리고 이쁨
I'm really in love with Karina's voice
me too
Yes, me too 💙
Which one is Karina?
@@user-hb4zz4gh5e 1:13 she is Karina
ÆSPA vocals maybe perfect. 💗
maybe? ITS PERFECT.
Love and support for kpop's future girl group
진짜 컨셉부터 후속곡까지 정통 smp..
와 진짜 노래는 진짜 좋다ㅋㅋㅋ.. 진짜 좋다 와.. 생라이브로 들으니까 신인 아이돌이 이런 발라드를 라이브로 멤버 모두가 성공적으로 물론 음정은 안 맞는 데도 있지만 어쨌든 해낸다는 게 좀 놀랍기도 하고 윈터 음원보다 힘 뺀 라이브를 처음 듣는데 좋아서 놀랐고 카리나 생각보다 안정적이어서 놀랐고 지젤도 놀랍고 닝닝은 그냥 역시 음색 좋고 아니 솔직히 진짜 좀 여러모로 놀랍다
좋은말씀해주셔서 감사해요...😢❤️
유영진노래 리메이크
춤이ㄹㄱㄴㅋㅋㄱㄱ
@@dyun410 춤 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 너도 나도 팬도 아무도 이해 못한 춤....
ㄹㅇ 안정적..
WINTERRRR AND NINGNING SO CUTE
aespa flop? big no, they all can sing live, and they all are vocalist! and of course they're very talented girls, periodt
The one who said they floped just try their best to deny the fact that AESPA is a big hit
I wouldn’t call them a flop but...... This has 11k views and took them 5 HOURS to do so. If they aren’t a flop they should’ve gotten AT THE LEAST 50k. But talent wise they aren’t a flop🌝
@@Jnkfragile i don't think we should call a group "flop" just because of how long it took to gain views in their videos
@@mimosapudica5160 👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
@@Jnkfragile because we already watched it live. And the views goes down when Aespa already done performing
에스파 보컬 완벽합니다
아니 다 좋은데 춤진짜 7월7일 같네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
발라드는 그냥 애들 얼굴보게 냅둬라 집중이 안됨
음원으로만 들어야 더 아름다운 노래....^^
옷도 그지같음 날라리 2천년대 중고딩도 아니고 반투명 검쓰;
에셈의 기묘한 취향ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅍㅋㅋㅋ
7월 7일 모먼트
@@BBuger 이 무대하기 전에 블랙맘바해서 그런 것 같아유
I love Karina’s darker tone. They’re all so good at singing, but to me Karina stands out so much cause the others have brighter voices, whereas hers is darker, kinda like how Jisoo is in BP
Jisoo voice so bad. She can’t sing
@@ebrarsener_56 all I said is she has a deeper voice
Dont be comparing Karina with Jisoo lmao. The latter cannot hold a note.
@@layism3857 I said they both have dark tones, regardless of ability jfc. This is why people hate Kpop stans…
@@123zachstar the people above you are so toxic
Waiting for aespa comeback 🙏
ningning main vocalist and her beautyyyyyy
Winter ❤️🥺
이 영상보니 닝닝 왜 메보라하는지 알겠다 목소리 땅땅한거 여기까지 닝닝이 한국까지 와서 힘들게 연습생활 버티고 데뷔해줘서 고마워
Why is Karina so beautiful?! I remember ppl saying she's not that beautiful during her debut and exo-ls in twitter making fun of her face but wth are they saying? She is THAT beautiful. She gives me Irene vibes and I think she's part of those idols with unrealistic visuals
Honestly, it is because of the rumors, why ppl attacked her :(
@@klaremontefalco5224 yep exactly and also bc she danced with kai
The girls voices are so pretty
Winter so beautiful
라이브 수준 미쳤고...
90년대 걸그룹 노래같음 그시대 감성
유영진 곡 리메이크예요 정확하시넹
다 비주얼은 엄청 세련되고 고급지는데 어딘가 고전적인 느낌이 있음... 천상지희 밀크 같은 컨셉은 아예 다른데 그냥 모던 클래식한 스엠 느낌
KARINA'S elegance.
yes
❤️
There are Visual idol groups, and so are Vocal idol groups. And here's æspa rocking both. Perfection.
💯
I like winter hairstyle and the clothes..so pretty
근데 카리나 은근 음색 의외다. ....
블랙맘바때와는 음색이 다르게 느껴지는 목소리?
You are a great singer when people saying your lipsyncing while actually singing live. And that's on SM artists.
consistent vocals! damnnn got me every frickin time 😭
Didn't think we'd see something like this, so beautiful
It's the first time they performed Forever for a show. Imagine if there wasn't a pandemic, they would've performed overseas and met international MYs 🥺
When Karina went to sm she was actually was supposed to be a vocal but end being the main dancer, she said this before..
she trained to be vocalist in Star academy which the same academy that trained Solar
Winter vocals is so strong
3:38 My favorite part. Winter voice is so good
Damn I really can't get over Ningning's beauty
Winter has a bruise 😔 I hope they are resting well while preparing for their comeback 😭
라이브 잘함
닝닝 왜케 이뻐