San's vocals are so much diverse it blows my mind. You can hear his angelic smooth velvet voice. Then again you can hear his raspy growls. He's so great a vocalist ❤
Love to see some appreciation for San's vocals! He really doesn't get enough of the credit he deserves. And yeah he's definitely not utilised that well in their songs, I'm not 100% sure why. You can hear more of his skills in their slower songs/b-sides but I still wouldn't say there's a crazy amount of it, and title tracks are the ones most people will know so I really wish he'd get to show off his vocals more in those🥲 Well I guess we'll see what happens in the upcoming comeback👀
@@acesani yeah because it fr pains me how little recognition he gets for them, I honestly think he should be part of discussions regarding the best vocalists in kpop and the fact that he basically never is makes me sad lmao (and it definitely doesn’t help that atinys themselves never mention him in those discussions😑) p.s. love your username lol, San is an ace indeed
I definitely recommend - Be with you, Mist, Turbulence. San's voice is like an angel. He works so hard on everything he does, whether it's singing, dancing, performing, education. He is always striving to be better. San is the definition of masterpiece and to top it off, he has the most precious soul and loveable character. My absolute favourite human ever! Thank you so much for your reactions to Ateez. I'm enjoying your journey.
Most of the slow songs are b-sides... Be With You, Mist, Star1117 for example. Slower songs with MVs: Turbulence, Utopia, maybe Aurora. San is such an underappreciated vocalist. People see his dancing and stage presence, but he has an absolutely beautiful voice. If you want to hear San take the lead vocal you should check out the San/Wooyoung/Yeosang unit song IT's You. San actually struggled a year after debut because his voice actually dropped quite a bit, which caused him to strain on the higher notes. San was considered a bridge between the rest of the group and Jongho's extreme highs. He said he had to retrain his voice to continue to reach higher notes in a safer way. (He actually has a fairly low speaking voice now.)
Utopia's slow in some places but it's definitely still an upbeat song. It's a good song to hear more of their vocals though! Edit: also I second the IT's You recommendation!
San said his singing voice changing was NOT because of changes through puberty, but because he was singing outside of his natural range in order to be the bridge between the other vocalists and jongho. What he was able to do then was not natural for him, but since then he has mastered a wider vocal range. He still sings those songs which are quite high and still masterfully hits high notes.
Eden is to blame for San almost losing his voice in the early days. Basing every song around Jongho was a stupid move. If San didn’t already have the natural singing talent that he came to KQ with, remember he was originally supposed to be the main vocalist before Jongho got there, the story would’ve ended differently. He was well aware enough to catch it and correct it, and then become an even stronger vocalist after it. That takes skill. And otf8kes better not use this as another tactic to diminish him as an artist like they’ve tried to do with his dancing.
Loved your reaction. The Choi Brothers are my fave voices. They are such amazing hardworking and talented vocalists. San singing this song always gives me goosebumps. I listen to it almost daily. ATEEZ is blessed with 8 amazing artists. 🏴☠💜
If you want to see san's vocals and ateez members' vocals as a whole i recommend Turbulence, Take me home, Mist, Star1117, Dreamy Day, Be With You, etc. In Mist, San is supposed to sing the main chorus but he gave his part to his best friend Wooyoung and took the intro part, cuz wooyoung wanted the chorus and practiced so diligently for it. Both of them get to shine! Take Me Home performance is a must-watch! The utilization of mirrors and the storytelling in the performance is immaculate. Also New World performance where you'll see San and Jongho's perfect harmonization. As another Atiny said, he's supposed to be the bridge in vocals between jongho and other members but he struggled a lot cuz of his lower tone. He said he got blood coming out of his throat and almost developed vocal nodules! So he had to retrain and now he's reached this point. On stage, he focuses a little bit more on performing, like he doesnt sing some parts, as in he literally dances harder and doesnt lip sync. But when he sings, he's so stable and it's filled with emotions. Seonghwa and Yunho are also known to be extremely stable vocalists. ALSO haha, if you want to be surprised more by ateez, i highly recommend Yeosang's Hug Me cover. He's the one with the very deep voice in Halazia. He's one of the members who gets less lines. He's getting more lines in the previous cbs tho.
san is the lead vocalist and initially his job was to sing in a middle range (?) between jongho and the other members. he often had difficulty singing out of his range and even developed a fear of singing when ateez was in their earlier days bc he had a lot of responsibility to sing outside his range and was afraid he would mess up. he had throat difficulties and a nodule scare (throat bleeding) but thankfully he overcame it and is more comfortable with his range - hence why his tone sounds a bit different between now and in their earlier music. for instance, nowadays when ateez performs "stay" from their 1st album, san has to adjust his tone because he originally sang that in a higher tone than what he's comfortable with now. however, i think it's very impressive because i think now his range is even wider than it was at debut - he can still do falsetto but in a much healthier way. i also think naturally his tone, even when speaking, has gotten deeper. he said in a live that he likes his tone now and that difficulty with his vocal cords allowed him to become a more skilled vocalist and take care of his vocal cords now. i really wish they would let him show off his vocal skills more in ateez's music because he has the markings of a great vocalist. i've always said san sings with his soul and this cover is proof of that! it's not a surprise he used to sing in his church's choir. a lot of the time people know him more for being the 'stage genius' of kpop that they forget to appreciate him as a lead vocalist. san has been singing since he was a kid and he auditioned as vocalist, so i really hope he gets more recognition because singing is something he really loves
Thank you!! I was about to explain this all as well. New people discovering Ateez tend to look over San’s vocals not knowing that is main position is Lead Vocalist. While, yes, his stage presence is amazing, his vocals are even better in my opinion. I think that is one reason I love their softer b sides. Because you hear their voices more.
@@StaceyM0710 yeah i love his stage presence, i think he’s the best 4th gen performer and one of the best in kpop overall but what drew me to him most were his vocals. they’re so under-appreciated
Yes I quickly noticed his vocal ability when I took the chance and reacted to his "Dear Name" with Jongho. One of the best decisions I made. Was very impressed.
The next video you clicked out of (Etham - 12:45) is actually Woo Young's solo cover. I highly suggest you check that out in a future video. 🙂 Great reaction, as always! Thank you for checking out San's lovely voice and talent!
San is outstanding. I always have loved what he adds to every ATEEZ song. I hope you will also react to YeoSang’s cover of Hug Me by Jung Joonil. It’s gorgeous. Our Doberman’s voice is just like Carmel. Smooth and beautiful.
Thank you for the reaction! This cover is a very special one, since it was the first one he did in 5 years since debut. He truly knows how to deliver emotion and make the audience connect to the song with his voice and interpretation. Glad you enjoyed it and let's hope we can get more vocal parts in future releases :) As for some recomendations where you can get a better look at Ateez's vocals: Turbulence (I recomend the live version from "it's live" channel), utopia (it is an upbeat one but very vocally-focused), promise, be with you, star 1117 (i recomend the live version of this one too), better, still here, dreamers, limitless, take me home, mist... and to add a personal one where san's shows how well his voice goes with r&b: It's you (it's a unit song with wooyoung and yeosang).
On this song and onSans slow song if you really want your expectations to be shattered, watch immortal songs, too Jongho performance to the song So You for me this performance beats everything I’ve ever heard him sing I choked up. I got the chills and I cried performance. This is a must must see.
The problem is that the producer they’ve been working with, Eden, is unprofessional and has had no formal training. He has modeled every song after the main vocalist and the main vocalist doesn’t even have to audition for parts like the other 7 members do which is unfair. San has the most versatile and soulful voice in the group and along with the main vocalist has the best technique. That’s why he’s their only lead vocalist, but for whatever reason, Eden never lets him utilize it to the fullest unless they’re singing cover songs. San’s fans had been asking for an official cover for YEARS (this is the only one so far) meanwhile other members have gotten multiple. He came into the company as a vocalist with a church choir background and as a composer but to this day we still don’t have any original compositions written by him. Eden only allows certain members to express their artistic abilities and San hasn’t been one of them. Given his vocal skill set he’s been treated the worst by Eden.
@@EXPECTATIONSSHATTERED Kpop fans in general like to sugar coat things and will often pamper members that don’t have much talent. Atinys are no different, and I’m sure a lot of reactors are aware of this which is why they say things fans want to hear. I can tell by this video that you mean what you say. San told us a couple weeks ago for the first time ever that because of the neglect of the vocal teachers at KQ, he almost developed a vocal nodule within the second year and was bleeding from his throat because Eden always had him singing outside of his range in order to bridge the gap between Jongho’s extremely high range and the rest of the members. Thankfully, San had had training prior to joining the company and was able to catch it before things got worse, he changed up his vocal style and now he’s an even stronger vocalist than he was when the group first started out.
If you want to listen to ATEEZ's song which more to vocal, I recommend - Mist, Utopia, Take Me Home, Dazzling Light, Star1117, Turbulence, Dune (this one omg, you need to react on this!)
San's sincere personality shines through so strongly whenever he sings. I can understand though, in a group of 6 strong vocalists, the songs are maximum like 4 minutes long so trying to share the stage as such in such a small time, i actually thought that San gets a lot of airtime in songs because he is so versatile. I absolutely LOVE his voice that had that breathy whistle... please watch that one you almost clicked onto.. that our Wooyoung solo cover it's beautiful!
can you react to jongho’s cover “i will go to you like the first snow” its not an official cover he did it on idol radio but its such a beautiful song and he sounds amazing
Hi! Binge watching your ateez playlist, and I'm just thinking I'd really love to see more reactions for these members solo projects, like Hongjoongs Lemon Tree and Yeosangs Hug me, of course if you don't have enough time I understand, but I'd still love to see you appreciate them too and maybe even "see" them better. Thank you 💜
Recently San said his vocal change a lot from their debut day because apparently, a year after debut, he felt something wrong with his throat. Blood came out of his throat and he can't reach his usual range. If he force it, it would be cord nodule. So, he change his singing style. It still sound good. ❤
He said he found a more dynamic and wide range. He said he appreciated going through that because it pushed him to do this. Hes a much better vocalist after overcoming that. Lets be proud of him and also be careful give full information . This is the most important part 🎉
Can y’all stop saying this without providing context? He clarified that he was able to overcome that, and his range is still high, he has sang high notes since then and can do them effortlessly. He did not tell us this so we can use it for fodder for pity, he told us this to show that he overcame something and is better after it.
@@0E7V1A0 eh did I said something negative? I just stated the reason about how he vocal change from the debut day and despite what he going through his voice still as good as before. And this is something that he said it himself. You read my comment with negative interpretation tho.
@@mufuu0 did I said something negative about it? I proud he can get through his difficulties. You are the one who read it with negative interpretation. 🤷🏻♀️
@@d_n_na Where did I say it was negative? I said give the full information. Just saying he once almost got a vocal chord nodule is empty information. He overcame that, and told us because he overcame it. He’s been in ateez for six years and he’s telling us his story about a time one year after debut. He sounds amazing. Lets praise his vocals more so more people know about him🤝
People saying that he is under utilised are the people who don’t listen to b-sides. Ateez touch most vocally diverse songs for their b-sides, people just check title tracks and categorise them only through that.
As the only lead vocalist he SHOULD be utilised in title tracks. And if you are a fan you know what those sound like, including the bsides where they underutilise him. The earlier albums are a different story. Also underutilised doesnt always refer to the length of time the vocalist sings, but the way in which their vocals are used. That’s why the word “utility” comes into play rather than saying we wish he had more lines.
![THE CLIMAX I WAS WAITING FOR! | [SPECIAL CLIP] ATEEZ - JONGHO WILDFLOWER COVER | REACTION](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/fAAaAp2qqFc/mqdefault.jpg)
![THE CLIMAX I WAS WAITING FOR! | [SPECIAL CLIP] ATEEZ - JONGHO WILDFLOWER COVER | REACTION](/img/tr.png)
![OKAY SAN, I SEE YOU! | [SPECIAL CLIP] ATEEZ SAN & JONGHO - DEAR NAME COVER | REACTION](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/RdA8pUAUJB8/mqdefault.jpg)
![K-OG reacts to ATEEZ(에이티즈) 산 '이하이 - 한숨 [] Breath ...or a sigh done wonderfully in his way!!](/img/1.gif)
San truly is one of the most passionate idols out there. He doesn’t do anything half-a$$ iykwim. Love this reaction
San's vocals are so much diverse it blows my mind. You can hear his angelic smooth velvet voice. Then again you can hear his raspy growls. He's so great a vocalist ❤
Love to see some appreciation for San's vocals! He really doesn't get enough of the credit he deserves. And yeah he's definitely not utilised that well in their songs, I'm not 100% sure why. You can hear more of his skills in their slower songs/b-sides but I still wouldn't say there's a crazy amount of it, and title tracks are the ones most people will know so I really wish he'd get to show off his vocals more in those🥲 Well I guess we'll see what happens in the upcoming comeback👀
agreed!! kq need to let him show off his vocals way more!
@@acesani yeah because it fr pains me how little recognition he gets for them, I honestly think he should be part of discussions regarding the best vocalists in kpop and the fact that he basically never is makes me sad lmao (and it definitely doesn’t help that atinys themselves never mention him in those discussions😑)
p.s. love your username lol, San is an ace indeed
I definitely recommend - Be with you, Mist, Turbulence.
San's voice is like an angel. He works so hard on everything he does, whether it's singing, dancing, performing, education. He is always striving to be better. San is the definition of masterpiece and to top it off, he has the most precious soul and loveable character. My absolute favourite human ever!
Thank you so much for your reactions to Ateez. I'm enjoying your journey.
Thanks for reacting to Ateez San. I just love his voice so much😊
Most of the slow songs are b-sides... Be With You, Mist, Star1117 for example. Slower songs with MVs: Turbulence, Utopia, maybe Aurora.
San is such an underappreciated vocalist. People see his dancing and stage presence, but he has an absolutely beautiful voice.
If you want to hear San take the lead vocal you should check out the San/Wooyoung/Yeosang unit song IT's You.
San actually struggled a year after debut because his voice actually dropped quite a bit, which caused him to strain on the higher notes. San was considered a bridge between the rest of the group and Jongho's extreme highs. He said he had to retrain his voice to continue to reach higher notes in a safer way. (He actually has a fairly low speaking voice now.)
Utopia's slow in some places but it's definitely still an upbeat song. It's a good song to hear more of their vocals though!
Edit: also I second the IT's You recommendation!
San said his singing voice changing was NOT because of changes through puberty, but because he was singing outside of his natural range in order to be the bridge between the other vocalists and jongho. What he was able to do then was not natural for him, but since then he has mastered a wider vocal range. He still sings those songs which are quite high and still masterfully hits high notes.
Eden is to blame for San almost losing his voice in the early days. Basing every song around Jongho was a stupid move. If San didn’t already have the natural singing talent that he came to KQ with, remember he was originally supposed to be the main vocalist before Jongho got there, the story would’ve ended differently. He was well aware enough to catch it and correct it, and then become an even stronger vocalist after it. That takes skill. And otf8kes better not use this as another tactic to diminish him as an artist like they’ve tried to do with his dancing.
Thank you for reacting to San, his voice is really good and versatile especially his r&b tone which is really good in songs like ateez it’s you
Loved your reaction. The Choi Brothers are my fave voices. They are such amazing hardworking and talented vocalists. San singing this song always gives me goosebumps. I listen to it almost daily. ATEEZ is blessed with 8 amazing artists. 🏴☠💜
Honestly all of Ateez are amazing vocalists, def suggest more of their individual covers
If you want to see san's vocals and ateez members' vocals as a whole i recommend Turbulence, Take me home, Mist, Star1117, Dreamy Day, Be With You, etc. In Mist, San is supposed to sing the main chorus but he gave his part to his best friend Wooyoung and took the intro part, cuz wooyoung wanted the chorus and practiced so diligently for it. Both of them get to shine! Take Me Home performance is a must-watch! The utilization of mirrors and the storytelling in the performance is immaculate. Also New World performance where you'll see San and Jongho's perfect harmonization.
As another Atiny said, he's supposed to be the bridge in vocals between jongho and other members but he struggled a lot cuz of his lower tone. He said he got blood coming out of his throat and almost developed vocal nodules! So he had to retrain and now he's reached this point. On stage, he focuses a little bit more on performing, like he doesnt sing some parts, as in he literally dances harder and doesnt lip sync. But when he sings, he's so stable and it's filled with emotions. Seonghwa and Yunho are also known to be extremely stable vocalists.
ALSO haha, if you want to be surprised more by ateez, i highly recommend Yeosang's Hug Me cover. He's the one with the very deep voice in Halazia. He's one of the members who gets less lines. He's getting more lines in the previous cbs tho.
Still gives me goosebumps a year after. 😍 this is what got me into Ateez ❤
🎵🎶 Simply Beautiful San 🤍
san is the lead vocalist and initially his job was to sing in a middle range (?) between jongho and the other members. he often had difficulty singing out of his range and even developed a fear of singing when ateez was in their earlier days bc he had a lot of responsibility to sing outside his range and was afraid he would mess up. he had throat difficulties and a nodule scare (throat bleeding) but thankfully he overcame it and is more comfortable with his range - hence why his tone sounds a bit different between now and in their earlier music. for instance, nowadays when ateez performs "stay" from their 1st album, san has to adjust his tone because he originally sang that in a higher tone than what he's comfortable with now. however, i think it's very impressive because i think now his range is even wider than it was at debut - he can still do falsetto but in a much healthier way. i also think naturally his tone, even when speaking, has gotten deeper. he said in a live that he likes his tone now and that difficulty with his vocal cords allowed him to become a more skilled vocalist and take care of his vocal cords now. i really wish they would let him show off his vocal skills more in ateez's music because he has the markings of a great vocalist. i've always said san sings with his soul and this cover is proof of that! it's not a surprise he used to sing in his church's choir. a lot of the time people know him more for being the 'stage genius' of kpop that they forget to appreciate him as a lead vocalist. san has been singing since he was a kid and he auditioned as vocalist, so i really hope he gets more recognition because singing is something he really loves
Thank you!! I was about to explain this all as well. New people discovering Ateez tend to look over San’s vocals not knowing that is main position is Lead Vocalist. While, yes, his stage presence is amazing, his vocals are even better in my opinion. I think that is one reason I love their softer b sides. Because you hear their voices more.
u explained san as a vocalist so well!!
@@StaceyM0710 yeah i love his stage presence, i think he’s the best 4th gen performer and one of the best in kpop overall but what drew me to him most were his vocals. they’re so under-appreciated
@@karol-ys5ow exactly. His stage presence draws you in. His vocals melt your heart.
Yes I quickly noticed his vocal ability when I took the chance and reacted to his "Dear Name" with Jongho. One of the best decisions I made. Was very impressed.
San has my favourite type of vocals ❤
The next video you clicked out of (Etham - 12:45) is actually Woo Young's solo cover. I highly suggest you check that out in a future video. 🙂
Great reaction, as always! Thank you for checking out San's lovely voice and talent!
San is outstanding. I always have loved what he adds to every ATEEZ song.
I hope you will also react to YeoSang’s cover of Hug Me by Jung Joonil. It’s gorgeous. Our Doberman’s voice is just like Carmel. Smooth and beautiful.
Thank you for the reaction! This cover is a very special one, since it was the first one he did in 5 years since debut. He truly knows how to deliver emotion and make the audience connect to the song with his voice and interpretation. Glad you enjoyed it and let's hope we can get more vocal parts in future releases :)
As for some recomendations where you can get a better look at Ateez's vocals: Turbulence (I recomend the live version from "it's live" channel), utopia (it is an upbeat one but very vocally-focused), promise, be with you, star 1117 (i recomend the live version of this one too), better, still here, dreamers, limitless, take me home, mist... and to add a personal one where san's shows how well his voice goes with r&b: It's you (it's a unit song with wooyoung and yeosang).
On this song and onSans slow song if you really want your expectations to be shattered, watch immortal songs, too Jongho performance to the song So You for me this performance beats everything I’ve ever heard him sing I choked up. I got the chills and I cried performance. This is a must must see.
thank you for showing so much love for san"s voices. ❤
The problem is that the producer they’ve been working with, Eden, is unprofessional and has had no formal training. He has modeled every song after the main vocalist and the main vocalist doesn’t even have to audition for parts like the other 7 members do which is unfair. San has the most versatile and soulful voice in the group and along with the main vocalist has the best technique. That’s why he’s their only lead vocalist, but for whatever reason, Eden never lets him utilize it to the fullest unless they’re singing cover songs.
San’s fans had been asking for an official cover for YEARS (this is the only one so far) meanwhile other members have gotten multiple. He came into the company as a vocalist with a church choir background and as a composer but to this day we still don’t have any original compositions written by him. Eden only allows certain members to express their artistic abilities and San hasn’t been one of them. Given his vocal skill set he’s been treated the worst by Eden.
Really? This is the first I've heard about this. Usually I only hear positive things about their "behind the scenes" team. Thanks for the information.
@@EXPECTATIONSSHATTERED Kpop fans in general like to sugar coat things and will often pamper members that don’t have much talent. Atinys are no different, and I’m sure a lot of reactors are aware of this which is why they say things fans want to hear. I can tell by this video that you mean what you say.
San told us a couple weeks ago for the first time ever that because of the neglect of the vocal teachers at KQ, he almost developed a vocal nodule within the second year and was bleeding from his throat because Eden always had him singing outside of his range in order to bridge the gap between Jongho’s extremely high range and the rest of the members. Thankfully, San had had training prior to joining the company and was able to catch it before things got worse, he changed up his vocal style and now he’s an even stronger vocalist than he was when the group first started out.
If you want to listen to ATEEZ's song which more to vocal, I recommend - Mist, Utopia, Take Me Home, Dazzling Light, Star1117, Turbulence, Dune (this one omg, you need to react on this!)
San's sincere personality shines through so strongly whenever he sings. I can understand though, in a group of 6 strong vocalists, the songs are maximum like 4 minutes long so trying to share the stage as such in such a small time, i actually thought that San gets a lot of airtime in songs because he is so versatile. I absolutely LOVE his voice that had that breathy whistle... please watch that one you almost clicked onto.. that our Wooyoung solo cover it's beautiful!
Ateez doesn’t have 6 strong vocalists, they have 2, 3 if I’m being generous.
@@timemachine5641I agree with this
@@itzmglo892 These fans are so biased and don’t think objectively
@@timemachine5641 right, fr they are and it shows
can you react to jongho’s cover “i will go to you like the first snow” its not an official cover he did it on idol radio but its such a beautiful song and he sounds amazing
Good work!
Hi! Binge watching your ateez playlist, and I'm just thinking I'd really love to see more reactions for these members solo projects, like Hongjoongs Lemon Tree and Yeosangs Hug me, of course if you don't have enough time I understand, but I'd still love to see you appreciate them too and maybe even "see" them better. Thank you 💜
Yes, once the KQ playlist is complete, I will checkout their other stuff.
San is the lead vocalist and unfortunately is very under utilized considering the talent that he has.
Recently San said his vocal change a lot from their debut day because apparently, a year after debut, he felt something wrong with his throat. Blood came out of his throat and he can't reach his usual range. If he force it, it would be cord nodule. So, he change his singing style. It still sound good. ❤
He said he found a more dynamic and wide range. He said he appreciated going through that because it pushed him to do this. Hes a much better vocalist after overcoming that. Lets be proud of him and also be careful give full information . This is the most important part 🎉
Can y’all stop saying this without providing context? He clarified that he was able to overcome that, and his range is still high, he has sang high notes since then and can do them effortlessly. He did not tell us this so we can use it for fodder for pity, he told us this to show that he overcame something and is better after it.
@@0E7V1A0 eh did I said something negative? I just stated the reason about how he vocal change from the debut day and despite what he going through his voice still as good as before. And this is something that he said it himself. You read my comment with negative interpretation tho.
@@mufuu0 did I said something negative about it? I proud he can get through his difficulties. You are the one who read it with negative interpretation. 🤷🏻♀️
@@d_n_na Where did I say it was negative? I said give the full information. Just saying he once almost got a vocal chord nodule is empty information. He overcame that, and told us because he overcame it. He’s been in ateez for six years and he’s telling us his story about a time one year after debut. He sounds amazing. Lets praise his vocals more so more people know about him🤝
People saying that he is under utilised are the people who don’t listen to b-sides. Ateez touch most vocally diverse songs for their b-sides, people just check title tracks and categorise them only through that.
As the only lead vocalist he SHOULD be utilised in title tracks. And if you are a fan you know what those sound like, including the bsides where they underutilise him. The earlier albums are a different story. Also underutilised doesnt always refer to the length of time the vocalist sings, but the way in which their vocals are used. That’s why the word “utility” comes into play rather than saying we wish he had more lines.