I Solved FNAF Security Breach (Part 2)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 8 янв 2025

Комментарии • 2,8 тыс.

  • @IkerUnzu
    @IkerUnzu 2 года назад +6820

    I need to see MatPat react to this

    • @coldshock5181
      @coldshock5181 2 года назад +90

      Casual 4.6m subs

    • @supernova5934
      @supernova5934 2 года назад +52

      chill he will react to it but like wait a while for it

    • @LycanWitch
      @LycanWitch 2 года назад +75

      worse part is all the hundreds of times he'll squeeze his knobby over this video

    • @Ms.FortuneTeller
      @Ms.FortuneTeller 2 года назад +23

      The video will be 3 hours long.

    • @michaelcarlton1484
      @michaelcarlton1484 2 года назад +5

      @@GalacticaWisp Can you provide a link to his reaction?

  • @Zory13
    @Zory13 2 года назад +2770

    I don't even mind if this theory is accurate or not, complicated theories like this, and looking super deep into tiny things in the game reminds me why I love following fnaf lore.

    • @spooka8468
      @spooka8468 2 года назад +36

      exactly what i was thinking

    • @Mike14264
      @Mike14264 2 года назад +26

      Reminds me of the old days of theorizing, but y'know, in a good way, where the theories made sense.

    • @xmattar
      @xmattar 2 года назад +2

      Hell nawh he doxxed a ghost

    • @tararosabelle7368
      @tararosabelle7368 2 года назад +4

      Yep this

    • @1Woofer1
      @1Woofer1 2 года назад +11

      Yeah don’t get me wrong, I love matpat, but it seems like he’s lost his way a bit and doesn’t go as in depth, videos like this really bring me back

  • @AstralSpiff
    @AstralSpiff 2 года назад +2562

    Bless this man for using IN GAME details to prove his points. Every SB theory I’ve seen has done their best to avoid playing the actual game at all costs. You da best John, thanks for not hurting my brain too much

    • @AdhvaithSane
      @AdhvaithSane 2 года назад +16

      Don’t worry Craziness and Insanity are planning a new plan to ruin your brain’s function and they also told me to tell you
      Craziness: Hi Astral where gonna f*** with ya mind soon enough
      hehehe
      Insanity: -DON’T LISTEN TO THEM YOU- A-
      Insanity’s message has been suspended.
      and that’s all as for me I’m only gonna spectate the experience and saved in the book that has your mind experience’s title I’ll basically write down the results of the mind and mental battle you will fight in and whatever happens happens either way you’re the one in control how do you know that you are?
      Well you have to answer this question by yourself and might need to be quick in doing so….

    • @Fibss
      @Fibss 2 года назад +6

    • @AdhvaithSane
      @AdhvaithSane 2 года назад +10

      @@Fibss Wow for some reason your ”only heart comment” sacred the living devil out of me

    • @Fibss
      @Fibss 2 года назад +7

      @@AdhvaithSane lmao what can i say im a scary guy

    • @AdhvaithSane
      @AdhvaithSane 2 года назад +7

      @@Fibss Scary? WITH A HEART???
      That literally makes no sense man this is the first time in my life that I don’t understand the gravity of the situation

  • @E.h.a.n
    @E.h.a.n 2 года назад +2610

    Finally, this honestly feels like a theory from the golden days of fnaf. Thanks for re-lighting the fire

    • @JoseLuiz-di1yg
      @JoseLuiz-di1yg 2 года назад +19

      ITS A CODE RELIGHTING THE FIRE GAME THEORISTS GOGOGO

    • @devinddanielski3522
      @devinddanielski3522 2 года назад +10

      it is but i do like game theorys newest theory but it feels like theres two timelines the one that game theory originally made and these fuhnaff made
      and then game theorys newest theory

    • @gotti2985
      @gotti2985 2 года назад +2

      Tru

    • @Queijo3082
      @Queijo3082 2 года назад +1

      I feel the same Bro

  • @CBLOfficial
    @CBLOfficial 2 года назад +10305

    "Need more proof," is going to be as iconic for John as "A GAME THEORY" is to MatPat, I swear-

    • @AudieAnimates
      @AudieAnimates 2 года назад +58

      YESS

    • @deathmauler181
      @deathmauler181 2 года назад +71

      Nope. Its going to be matpat's "final"

    • @goossey2307
      @goossey2307 2 года назад +31

      I love that for John honestly 🥰

    • @desumanu_
      @desumanu_ 2 года назад +18

      Reminds me of the old movie " Starship Troopers " :D They used that qoute quite often " Would you like to know more ? " in the propaganda commercials :D

    • @hydroarchonfaker
      @hydroarchonfaker 2 года назад +27

      Matpat said that one the gtlive where he watched the other video. Love this for John he's so cool.

  • @DJStarzify
    @DJStarzify 2 года назад +2843

    Looks like Matpat isn't the only one going insane

    • @thomasdiaz918
      @thomasdiaz918 2 года назад +13

      😂😂🤣

    • @ionelalexandra
      @ionelalexandra 2 года назад +95

      I mean unlike Matt, John seems more calm and... sane. Idk maybe that's just me, maybe he's going crazy too 🚶

    • @justajely7372
      @justajely7372 2 года назад +137

      It’s because John is new
      He hasn’t lost his sanity yet
      Mats been doing this back and fourth with fnaf for basically almost a decade

    • @ionelalexandra
      @ionelalexandra 2 года назад +12

      @@justajely7372 lmao true

    • @samherken
      @samherken 2 года назад +33

      Trying to explain FNAF lore makes you sound insane.

  • @ahmetnesim5100
    @ahmetnesim5100 2 года назад +605

    Dude made a theory out of an extended soundtrack, mad respect

    • @vipersnek3141
      @vipersnek3141 2 года назад +2

      what

    • @Quackmire_Dingle
      @Quackmire_Dingle 2 года назад +12

      @@vipersnek3141 He's probably talking about the song in the FNAF 6 Security puppet minigame. When John says the name of the song is "Alchemist's fantasy"

    • @Quackmire_Dingle
      @Quackmire_Dingle 2 года назад +10

      @@vipersnek3141 never mind just remembered it might also be about the Freddy and friends on tour theme which is extended.

  • @shroomdudeshades
    @shroomdudeshades 2 года назад +319

    Dude this is insane. Your theory is fnaftastic. I really want you and MatPat to get together. This is my favorite solve ever and you deserve his and everyone else's attention.

  • @danizoar
    @danizoar 2 года назад +984

    An actual theory what relies on in-depth analysis with more or less hard evidence instead of well-known tropes and random ideas. It's like 2014 again.
    Great job!

    • @ShySamSky
      @ShySamSky 2 года назад +16

      Aghh to be in 2014 again, Good times ✨✨

  • @spriggomancy
    @spriggomancy 2 года назад +706

    The tiny closet door in Security Breach was what really got me. I love this theory because it's so different from anything we've heard so far. I cant wait to see what Matpat thinks!!

  • @gorg5232
    @gorg5232 2 года назад +900

    The one thing that always stood out to me in this game was all the puppet stuff, like the arms in the arcade, all the puppet collectibles, and the hidden plushies. Now it’s crazy to believe that all of it has a purpose and connects to each other. And now it’s good to know that they ACTUALLY ARE connected! Good job on this theory!

    • @fuzzylittlespider
      @fuzzylittlespider 2 года назад +26

      I thought the same thing when I was playing the game. But I just thought, "man the developers really like the puppet for some reason?" The puppet is a fan favorite so at the time I just thought it was a character they knew the fans loved.

  • @twobats
    @twobats 2 года назад +164

    absolutely stunned. I tend not to agree with many fnaf theories anymore, but I was enthralled by this one the moment you mentioned the nightmarione plushes around the pizzaplex. I hadn't noticed them before and hadn't seen _anyone_ talk about them up until this point, and with every additional piece of evidence, I got more and more convinced. This is genuinely a solid theory, and definitely one that's gonna be rotating around my head for a while

  • @CactusMaractus
    @CactusMaractus 2 года назад +105

    God I cant believe steelwool hid the evidence so well the whole internet thought they didn't care enough about the lore

    • @vixen7227
      @vixen7227 2 года назад

      I dont think many people really care about Charlie or the puppets character

    • @joshgroban5291
      @joshgroban5291 2 года назад +20

      @@vixen7227 it’s not that they don’t care, it’s just that many people thought her story was done. Sent to heaven in fnaf 6. By comparison, crying child was a lot more open, and even Baby as for some reason, Scott keeps using her design in other media

  • @DSiren
    @DSiren 2 года назад +607

    1 thing, that room with the binary sticky notes isn't the only area down there with binary sticky notes. There's one in the pipe in the first Chica boss fight generator room, in a room you are able to explore extensively before spawning chica. We're supposed to find it and it's important to solving Security breech.

    • @eironyy
      @eironyy 2 года назад +35

      give this man likes so John can see

    • @imronnyy7700
      @imronnyy7700 2 года назад +17

      how tf do you know “we’re supposed to find it and it’s important to solving Security Breach.” you say that like you were the one who made the game but the problem with that is you couldn’t even spell it right.”

    • @yagizsahin_
      @yagizsahin_ 2 года назад +53

      @@imronnyy7700 had a bad day my man?

    • @LycanWitch
      @LycanWitch 2 года назад +36

      @@imronnyy7700 even if the person made the game or not, the fact that you expect a game developer to be an English and grammar expert and have perfect spelling always makes zero logical sense.. Game designers typically go to school for specifically for game design/creation, art, or computer science majors, not as English, Literature, or Communication majors. So much like a doctor with a literal PhD under their belt but who write like trash, I expect game designers to also write like trash, as much like doctors, they didn't go to school to become expert writers.

    • @DSiren
      @DSiren 2 года назад +41

      @@imronnyy7700 Sorry, I talk about naval artillery a lot, used the wrong 'breech/breach" and the reason I say we're supposed to find it is that almost every lore clue we have in the game so far is observable without being chased by any enemies. From the broken glass, to the tape room, to the interior of the pizza place, to Vanny's room, to kid's cove, the stickynote room, even the destroyed employee's cafeteria only has an enemy if you get seen by a staff-bot. The only strong exception to this rule is the endo area, which you can return to in freddy.

  • @Cptwinter
    @Cptwinter 2 года назад +1263

    never knew a 27 min video would bring back my passion for this game........ a whole HECK of a lot is reveled and said those past months that i couldn't keep up with

    • @SkyBlew
      @SkyBlew 2 года назад +14

      Exactly! 😃🙌🏾 I feel the same way. And I also feel that these 2 videos FuhNaff released, provided the *MUCH NEEDED* spark for both the community & Steel Wool! It's about to get even more interesting from here on out... 😎

    • @BonusDuckie
      @BonusDuckie Год назад +1

      I am super confused.
      Isn't Charlie in the birthday party a human and robot versions are Henry coping with it?
      Why would robo child charlie remember those details?
      I am so confused at this point. I know there's robo charlies but why is this robo charlie going to therapy sessions?

  • @5MadMovieMakers
    @5MadMovieMakers 2 года назад +764

    And here I was thinking the Princess Quest arcade games were about freeing Vanny from Glitchtrap

    • @survivordave
      @survivordave 2 года назад +108

      I still think that's the best way to understand it, especially since completing all 3 games leads to the peaceful Vanessa ending. It is worth noting that the developers did specifically go back and remove Cassidy's name from the Princess Quest files after it went public so the canonicity of Cassidy being associated with the Princess Quest games is iffy to say the least

    • @TheRealYezBox
      @TheRealYezBox 2 года назад +21

      @@survivordave true, however they could have just removed Cassidy’s name to make it less obvious

    • @survivordave
      @survivordave 2 года назад +8

      @@TheRealYezBox I guess, but then how does saving Cassidy make Vanessa free from Glitchtrap?

    • @TheRealYezBox
      @TheRealYezBox 2 года назад +16

      @@survivordave It's a stretch but I believe that it could just free Cassidy, who then proceeds to free vanny (vanessa)

    • @TheRealYezBox
      @TheRealYezBox 2 года назад +2

      She could be able to do this based on evidence from what she's done to afton in the past

  • @davetheduck9115
    @davetheduck9115 2 года назад +28

    Just noticed the wristbands in Charlies death mini-game match the colors of the lights perfectly in Baby's room in Sister Location

  • @demete1230
    @demete1230 2 года назад +61

    This is genius. I love this theory, it feels very fresh and finally brings new ideas that don't feel like completely random facts made up to fill the gaps. You can tell the attention to details that went into creating this theory, and as others have already said, it really takes us back to the old days of over-searching for tiny clues, and it feels very good.

  • @EvanTubeGaming
    @EvanTubeGaming 2 года назад +2540

    This was great. Usually with fnaf theories I'll find myself thinking so many things said are a stretch, yet with this one I found like maybe one??? And it was the green text at the end which was mentioned for like a second.
    Great job, loved watching these 2 theories they're really solid vids.

    • @fourthyboi
      @fourthyboi 2 года назад +19

      hello evan

    • @FuhNaff
      @FuhNaff  2 года назад +124

      Thanks Evan!

    • @TK--ev7wx
      @TK--ev7wx 2 года назад +7

      Hope you're family is doing well!

    • @WillBinge
      @WillBinge 2 года назад +4

      Holy shit I haven’t seen one of your videos in ages, I used to love your Lego videos.

    • @Alt3zza
      @Alt3zza 2 года назад +1

      Great to see you again man, I used to watch your Lego review videos.

  • @deconstructor3582
    @deconstructor3582 2 года назад +215

    Dude my mind isn't just blown. You threw literal nuclear weapon on it. More than tremendous job, I can't even describe how good this theory is. Very, very good job mate

  • @dr.pringle9568
    @dr.pringle9568 2 года назад +338

    I freaking love this man’s theory’s. He’s going in depth with everything possible about security breach. Man’s is absolutely mind blowing!

  • @chadlikespasta3142
    @chadlikespasta3142 2 года назад +59

    I think we really needed this kind of groundbreaking new perspective. A fresh face in the fnaf theorist community. Keep up the fantastic work, you're probably the only one who could have put this all together.

  • @KaishaLouise
    @KaishaLouise 2 года назад +6

    Everybody always asks "Who is patient 46?", but no-one ever asks "How is patient 46?"

  • @xlordzz8740
    @xlordzz8740 2 года назад +802

    John, you should seriously consider making more theory videos. You’re takes are brilliant and this felt like watching a MatPat video.

    • @jamessaad1271
      @jamessaad1271 2 года назад +4

      Literally tho the next generation is nigh

    • @lobstermilk
      @lobstermilk 2 года назад +26

      honestly? it feels BETTER than watching a matpat video.

    • @Joshuathegreen
      @Joshuathegreen 2 года назад +11

      Its less clickbaity and cringy too.

    • @santiagovargas254
      @santiagovargas254 2 года назад +1

      i cant tell if were discrediting matpat here or respecting fuhnaff or both

    • @emilyroberts4067
      @emilyroberts4067 2 года назад

      FR

  • @thelonepianist17
    @thelonepianist17 2 года назад +191

    I'm amazed that everyone, even MatPat, overlooked the amount of evidence that the Puppet was indeed in this game.

    • @JoeWithTheHoesBiden
      @JoeWithTheHoesBiden 2 года назад +14

      I'm amazed fuhnaff hinted at explaining why it couldn't have been charlie (the lone window being shut in her death cutscene sealed her fate, so why on earth would she prefer keeping windows shut?) but never actually did it :(

    • @Smiuley
      @Smiuley 2 года назад +12

      @@JoeWithTheHoesBiden Well I assume, she just doesn't like the outside in general, so she doesn't like open windows. She died on the outside, she doesn't want anything to do with it.

    • @JoeWithTheHoesBiden
      @JoeWithTheHoesBiden 2 года назад +4

      @@Smiuley that's not a very good explanation

    • @Smiuley
      @Smiuley 2 года назад +5

      @@JoeWithTheHoesBiden I'm not saying, it's a great explanation, but it's the logic that Fuhnaff probably follows

    • @brocclarsen9489
      @brocclarsen9489 2 года назад

      makes sense why, matpat talks about something like it in bendy, where theres so much "noise" in a game its hard to see what matters lore wise and whats an asset to cover space

  • @SeoLink
    @SeoLink 2 года назад +118

    “Sounds like the perfect candidate to be a re-built Micheal Afton”
    *Shows Mark Zuckerberg*

    • @Sorta8
      @Sorta8 2 года назад +2

      I mean, that's pretty close

  • @jeepgirl1732
    @jeepgirl1732 2 года назад +7

    HOLY CRAP MY THEORY HAS BEEN BACKED UP. Everyone I've talked to about this theory thought I was crazy and grasping at straws. Thank you for finding evidence!

  • @lunakon5911
    @lunakon5911 2 года назад +73

    The amount of work you’ve put into this one is staggering.

  • @rat-yt
    @rat-yt 2 года назад +344

    Forcing the spirit of the most benevolent character in the game to inhabit what is essentially an evil killer robot version of herself is hitting some wacky levels torment, even for this series

    • @ivysaur2thefirst
      @ivysaur2thefirst 2 года назад +2

      I still don't get that. Where did he say she was?

    • @johndoe24328
      @johndoe24328 2 года назад +9

      While I agree it is wacky and feels bad, it is a new & fresh horror element to the story.

    • @rat-yt
      @rat-yt 2 года назад +21

      ​@@ivysaur2thefirst ​Basically, John's theory is that:
      1: Henry built a robotic version of Charilie when she died, but ultimately decided to scrap it
      2: William, (in the form of Glitchtrap,) commands Vanny to go and steal that scrapped Charlie robot and use it for their own evil purposes.
      3: In order to escape his purgatory, William needs to stop the two spirits that are keeping him there: Charlie and Cassidy. He, (by commanding/possesing Vanny to do so,) traps Cassidy in the princess quest arcade machines, and traps Charlie inside of that evil robot version of her child self, where her soul is now doomed to witness the evil doings of the robot body she's trapped in, while being powerless to stop it.
      He explains 1 & 2 at 9:15 - 9:36, and he explains 3 at about 17:58 - 19:49

    • @rat-yt
      @rat-yt 2 года назад +14

      @@johndoe24328 Agreed! I actually really like this new storyline, but I do think it's a bit amusing to take a step back and just soak in the ludicrous, chaotic complexity of it all

    • @ivysaur2thefirst
      @ivysaur2thefirst 2 года назад +2

      @@rat-yt ok, but, where does Vanessa get Cassidy? He mentions she gets her from the Blob but I don't recall the Blob having Cassidy in it

  • @HayyanPro167
    @HayyanPro167 2 года назад +581

    I’d love to see MatPat, FuhNaff and Dawko in a single video making theories together

    • @BaseTyir
      @BaseTyir 2 года назад +18

      and RyeToast

    • @gunnersg2700
      @gunnersg2700 2 года назад +19

      i guess the closest we've gotten was that chat they all had on GTLive after Security Breach

    • @Derplantern10
      @Derplantern10 2 года назад +2

      Would love to see them in a bad bunny music video

    • @HayyanPro167
      @HayyanPro167 2 года назад +3

      @@Derplantern10 yoo how’s it been

    • @protion_2312
      @protion_2312 2 года назад +6

      The Mark appears and solves the whole story on accident

  • @bluskyjaay4607
    @bluskyjaay4607 2 года назад +127

    Oh my gosh John… I’m speechless and mind blown lol I never even considered Charlie is still around, but it makes so much sense. Wherever William goes, Cassidy and Charlie seem to follow.

    • @toons8744
      @toons8744 2 года назад +1

      "I am still here"

  • @phiaanon
    @phiaanon 2 года назад +26

    I can't even imagine the amount of research you put into this, I wouldn't have even thought of the kid's bracelet colors as matching the colors from the post-it room, I'm definitely subscribing!

  • @sukmahdik.9316
    @sukmahdik.9316 2 года назад +20

    This basically tells us that souls of the children never left the animatronics, possibly due to a sense of Afton's soul still lingering in the mortal plane

    • @lucaswilson4626
      @lucaswilson4626 2 года назад +1

      as much as fnaf 6 was an epic ending. I love the idea that the children's souls (specifically cassidy and charlie) will not rest whilst Afton can still roam. I cannot wait to see how it goes, hopefully we get to actually speak to one of the child's spirits properly (personally I want to hug Susie because she sounds the nicest of all of them lol)

  • @Sketchtrastrophe
    @Sketchtrastrophe 2 года назад +290

    The fact you made all of these connections and that this theory is literally rock solid is insane, I really hope more people find this. It's incredible

  • @johndoe24328
    @johndoe24328 2 года назад +373

    At first “no way AT ALL is this credible!”
    After awhile “… omg this is beautiful “
    Even if it’s all wrong, it brings SO MANY layers of great depth to what was such a let down for fans. You deserve significant credit for this

    • @aikesscs
      @aikesscs 2 года назад +7

      Of course, it was only a letdown because people judged it by it's cover and didn't look into it properly, glad that fuhnaff was here to do that though, and matpat... kinda.... really kinda

    • @TMS-Oddbot
      @TMS-Oddbot 2 года назад +2

      I think the main thing this guy brought to the table was pointing out the puppet dolls. If MatPat noticed those, or at least as more than an Easter egg, he would have probably gotten here too. The problem is, as MatPat has said (somewhere), it’s harder to tell what is a lore clue and what's just an Easter egg than ever before with Security Breach, because it's such a massive game

    • @TMS-Oddbot
      @TMS-Oddbot 2 года назад +1

      @@aikesscs
      You're not giving MatPat enough credit. The biggest issue I see with what MatPat came up with is Patient 46. I will say that I think there are holes there just shown by the surface level plot of the game which he should have noticed, but the game is so crappy and those puppet dolls seem so hidden and like Easter eggs that I can't blame him for not considering them

    • @G12G4
      @G12G4 2 года назад +2

      If I was the creator and this wasn't my original plan, honestly I'd be nodding while writing it down and saying "Yes... yes... that's exactly what we were going for, you figured it out - could you repeat that last part please?"

  • @toasteebagelz
    @toasteebagelz 2 года назад +94

    this is an INSANELY good theory. i went from being skeptical to pretty convinced!! solid evidence, and this was put together so well. i can tell so much effort went into this

  • @greyygoblinn5639
    @greyygoblinn5639 2 года назад +13

    This is one of the best theories ive heard in a while regarding the tapes, bringing the sister location cartoons in the loop!! It pulled from everywhere and I love it

  • @Just.A.L1ttle_Rand0
    @Just.A.L1ttle_Rand0 2 года назад +41

    May I say. Jaw. On. The. Floor.
    This is so amazing? Actually made me change a lot of what I thought. Matpat gotta react to this asap, and honestly more people should see it. It's an amazing theory

  • @hudsonthejojo2825
    @hudsonthejojo2825 2 года назад +180

    As someone whose usually against the idea of the "x person is a robot" theory for the games, this actually is a pretty decent way to make it work.
    The evil Charliebot idea seems like a slight stretch though given the amount of Nightmarionne references, I definitely could believe Charlie is present in some form.
    The idea of Gregory being a chosen target for Afton's rebuilt family is definitely interesting, and I could see it being possible.

  • @WhatsEndoDoing
    @WhatsEndoDoing 2 года назад +454

    Wow! Your theory videos are insanely good, solid evidence. Can't wait to see MatPat react to this!

    • @kingauther7812
      @kingauther7812 2 года назад +2

      But how did Afton get rid of Cassidy and Charly?

    • @char5379
      @char5379 2 года назад

      @@kingauther7812 he said it in the video..

    • @wheel4155
      @wheel4155 2 года назад

      @@kingauther7812 He's the same dude who managed to import himself into some fucking hard drives that was scanned in Help Wanted, I'm pretty sure he would be able to use the same scanning tech to take Cassidy and Charlie's souls out of the blob and import them elsewhere

  • @sourpatchkiiddoo1582
    @sourpatchkiiddoo1582 2 года назад +174

    Can’t wait to see what matpat has to say abt this one… just watched the group live of his reaction to part 1. I absolutely LOVE the community that y’all have created where you reference each other and react to each other’s theories. It makes for a super interesting watch because you can directly reference and compare theories knowing that y’all watch each other’s content and know what each other is theorizing about

  • @axelblyat7705
    @axelblyat7705 2 года назад +8

    OH MY GOD im in the FNAF community since the first game and THIS video made me jump on my seat and sweat with exitement like decade ago. This is incredible thanks for bringing this feeling back.

  • @Thefunkymunky619
    @Thefunkymunky619 2 года назад +7

    6:53 I like how he didn’t talk about the LITERAL SPRINGTRAP HEAD next to that game

  • @cipherfiedart7338
    @cipherfiedart7338 2 года назад +76

    Mat should invite you on the show for a co-theory!!! You’re great!!

  • @Dot_dot_dot891
    @Dot_dot_dot891 2 года назад +36

    This is the most convincing theory I’ve heard come out of any FNAF in years. Extremely thorough and an insane amount of evidence. It’s hard not to see this as confirmed!

  • @therealestunforgivable
    @therealestunforgivable 2 года назад +114

    Thank you so much for taking your time to do this. Not many people have this devotion to this series. Thank you so much, keep doing what your doing

  • @lydiaperson7251
    @lydiaperson7251 Год назад +1

    love how you’re looking more at the game details and just using the books as little explanations. i like this theory!
    would love to see how you think about this with the dlc going over everything one to one

  • @SimplyEnvi
    @SimplyEnvi 2 года назад +8

    " *Need more proof?* "
    " *Don't believe me?* "
    best new memes.

    • @eymenelyan8110
      @eymenelyan8110 6 месяцев назад

      We got fuhnaf memes before gta 6💀💀💀💀

  • @LemonAide2024
    @LemonAide2024 2 года назад +63

    Honestly, the most convinced I’ve been with any fnaf theorist, ever. You really are incredible!

  • @migasgt638
    @migasgt638 2 года назад +12

    This even ties in with the line of "And if you fail me, you will, both of you, burn". Its William talking to Charlie and Vanessa!! This theory is amazing, it ties everything together!!

  • @domhopper7402
    @domhopper7402 2 года назад +79

    The part where you explained what year the game takes place I can actually confirm that. On the level for Monty Golf that showcases Security Breach with the Glamrock band there is a hidden 55th anniversary balloon showing that Security Breach takes place 55 years after the opening of Fredbear's Family Dinner. If you add 55 years to the year 1983 you get 2038 so if you shift the year 3 years back you'll get both the year Fredbear's Family Diner opened (1980) and the year Security Breach takes place (2035).

  • @winnierza
    @winnierza 2 года назад +3

    John this whole video theory IS INSANELY GOOD. I was so excited that I had to tap the screen to see if I was near the end because I was running out of breath every time you say NEED MORE PROOF? SO GOOD. you convinced me!!!

  • @graceholbert2126
    @graceholbert2126 Год назад +1

    The self-control of this man saying "just a theory" in every video and then NOT saying what we're all thinking is incredible.

  • @knatspray
    @knatspray 2 года назад +342

    God man, this stuff like brain candy to me. A real breath of fresh air for the game in general. Amazingly done! Looks like Matpats got some new material to go off of 👀👀👀

    • @GuardianTiger
      @GuardianTiger 2 года назад +13

      Ah yes, a nice breathe of fresh Hair-

    • @knatspray
      @knatspray 2 года назад +2

      @@GuardianTiger *

  • @HarryKaberry
    @HarryKaberry 2 года назад +65

    I mean come on. You just laid out everything clear and concise. Hard not to consider this the answer we’ve all been waiting for. Incredible video dude!!!

  • @fenrirslip
    @fenrirslip 2 года назад +70

    My mind is absolutely blown even though this is obviously a theory. This is really fascinating and gives a potentially new perspective to the lore of Security Breach.

  • @mailpaper7754
    @mailpaper7754 2 года назад +7

    I've never agreed with the whole Afton side of this game, but this theory gives new light to that. Actually, giving us how this is the Afton family. This is an amazing theory and (IN MY OPINION) is probably the most plausible theory I have seen about these games. I'm excited to see what else you have great work.

  • @Thomas-zk1hz
    @Thomas-zk1hz 2 года назад +29

    Cassidy being trapped in princess quest makes sense, as when she's freed she could have recaptured William/Elizabeth bringing Vanessa back to her normal self, Elizabeth possessing/influencing Vanessa also works as she says at the end of FNAF 6 she wants to make her daddy proud.

  • @HayyanPro167
    @HayyanPro167 2 года назад +59

    This is probably one of the best theories I’ve ever seen. Great work as always, FuhNaff!

  • @TheBiohazardKing
    @TheBiohazardKing 2 года назад +11

    I love the connection of the Nightmare Puppet. I always thought they werent cannon tot he story since the Halloween DLC wasnt cannon either. However, looking at it from your POV, it does make sense that Nightmare Puppet is just the embodiment of the pain that Charlie went through. Never noticed the one hanging from freddy either lol
    Solid theory dude. Definitely got my brain running LOL

  • @laurenkat4261
    @laurenkat4261 2 года назад +60

    You are actually a genius. Everyone in the fandom needs to see this. Best theory yet.

  • @WeaverDudeSkater
    @WeaverDudeSkater 2 года назад +18

    Incredible work man, I really think this is the closest and most accurate theory so far from anyone, major props to you for all the hard work that must have gone into this 💜

  • @enzab9472
    @enzab9472 2 года назад +7

    I have watched both of your theory videos and they have left my mind blown. It all seems so obvious now looking back on it. This was such a great theory and it is a really believable one!

  • @Jikuro_
    @Jikuro_ 2 года назад +26

    You’re actually insane John. Props to you for figuring all this out. Great job.

  • @exoticbeefstew
    @exoticbeefstew 2 года назад +44

    I can’t believe this was all missed until now. Can’t wait to see more theory content hopefully in the future!

  • @kavanht6533
    @kavanht6533 2 года назад +35

    Oh man, it keeps getting better. While I'm not too sure on the theory, meaning I'll need to watch it a couple of time to understand it, I'm really loving that you are look at the games starting from the smallest details, like in the last video with glass making a sound, and the nightmare plush found in several places. This is what makes these lore hunts so interesting for me, how the smallest details can change so much. Keep up that great work man. Can't wait for what is in the DLC or maybe more parts to come.

  • @kinglinc5239
    @kinglinc5239 2 года назад +2

    Fore some reason I've felt like I've out grown fnaf but this game is so fun but mostly the theories and the theory community. it keeps on making me come back especially you john so thanks for making me stay with this franchise

  • @opalmari6147
    @opalmari6147 2 года назад +10

    This is ungodly incredible, you did an absolutely amazing job and I loved watching every second. I’d be very surprised if you’re theories about Luis and the crying child are not almost exactly what the story was.
    Edit: clarification just in case, I ment the whole theories not just those two main subjects

  • @potatonuggets4846
    @potatonuggets4846 2 года назад +46

    I’m exited to see matpat react to this!

    • @jackwilliams8315
      @jackwilliams8315 2 года назад +16

      It’s gonna take like, 2 hours for him to get through the whole thing lol

    • @squaretreasure
      @squaretreasure 2 года назад +4

      @@jackwilliams8315 more like 3

    • @jizzle4snizzle
      @jizzle4snizzle 2 года назад +2

      @@jackwilliams8315 LMAO that’s so true.

    • @chibi_okami
      @chibi_okami 2 года назад +1

      @@jackwilliams8315 Well, he talks a lot

  • @Kageoni187
    @Kageoni187 2 года назад +43

    You are an absolute bloodhound. This was very good and incredibly thorough. I just knew there was so much we were missing. The questions were too big and obvious to be oopses.

  • @XionBrown
    @XionBrown 2 года назад +17

    Putting the theory aside, this is the one of the reasons why I love FnaF. It's about to be a year since this game came out in a couple of weeks, and there's always a new discovery to be had. I didn't know about the hidden Nightmarionne plush or the cut dialogue from the game 'til now.

  • @skylarfox_bmb
    @skylarfox_bmb 7 месяцев назад +2

    1:03 "don't believe me?" i do not research these games i'm taking your word for it bro

  • @VailingYT
    @VailingYT 2 года назад +22

    Cant wait to see MatPat's thoughts about all of this

  • @angelic428
    @angelic428 2 года назад +59

    Maybe one need’s for Charlie to be around and continued to be used by them is because her signature ability to “give gifts. give life.” is exactly what Afton and Vanessa are trying to accomplish, rebuilding and giving new life to the Afton legacy. No doubt it’s obviously more than possibly to do this without the entity of the puppet, but again, speaking in the perspective of where we come from, the puppet is one of the strongest entities in the franchise, along with one of the children was about to sustain life in, Cassidy.

  • @zlouvier
    @zlouvier 2 года назад +69

    john, my jaw was dropped for the full 30 minutes of this video. well fucking done, dude. this is seriously canon in my head now lol
    it's crazy how ALL of this shit was in the game, we just needed someone to piece it together. u took one for the mf team

  • @ShySamSky
    @ShySamSky 2 года назад +74

    I honestly think you have knocked it out of the park with this one. It all fits well. But the connections between the books and games is something that even scott has trouble confirming fully and now that there is more creative control involvement every theory needs to be assessed with a grain of salt. That being said this was total worth the wait. ✨✨

  • @AsiasAnimations
    @AsiasAnimations 2 года назад +14

    The attention to detail in these videos is crazy, man. There's no way in he|| I would've been able to figure any of this out. You're doing God's work with the lore & theories in this series because it's soooo hard to understand & put everything together at this point (as a fan of the series that has _never_ played any of the games lmao), but from these theories you've come up with everything is (slowly) starting to make some sense, if this theory is ever confirmed of course.

  • @Peyton_S
    @Peyton_S 2 года назад +6

    FNAF is so darn confusing to figure out, your doing such an amazing job researching and diving into all the pieces that are set out form the games and books to fit together the puzzle of FNAF. Amazing work!!

  • @FayeTwiddleDee
    @FayeTwiddleDee 2 года назад +19

    This all makes a lot of sense! I never wanted to believe that Gregory was the crying child literally, but the evidence that was present didn’t seem to point to any other answer, until this video! The idea of Charlie being behind it all makes a lot of sense when you consider all the evidence and stuff from the books. Great video!

  • @laotasurfs1110
    @laotasurfs1110 2 года назад +47

    So much amazing work here. Just about all the stuff with Nightmarionne and the shipped animatronics, guessing the year the game takes place in, deciphering the stuff on the walls, reading the porting of Princess Quest to arcade cabinets as a way to trap a spirit -- it's completely brilliant and I don't think anyone else could've put it together. So many have just given up looking for clues.
    But the stuff about Gregory just being a normal kid kinda falls apart when you remember all the clues suggesting he's really not normal, and I don't think the cipher on the wall is from the perspective of Team Afton.
    I was keeping it to myself, but I'm just gonna say it: I don't think Afton's the only one with a "team" in play here.

    • @kaden587
      @kaden587 2 года назад +4

      yeah, I honestly think that gregory is not 100% normal, and not 100% crying child. I think he may be in the transition towards the crying child considering he has no memory of his past and does not fit the ideal description of the crying child as yet.

    • @laotasurfs1110
      @laotasurfs1110 2 года назад +4

      @@kaden587 I feel like whether or not Gregory's a robot is important, but only to his motives and place in the grander narrative, not to the "who's possessing what robot" questions.
      If Gregory really is a homeless nobody, then he just picked the wrong mousehole and holds no significance to the grander narrative. End of theory, thanks for playing. But if he's a robot -- sure, he *might've* decided to come to the Pizzaplex of his own volition. But he also could've been sent by someone or lured by something.
      He *might've* just been built by Willaim Afton, but he might've been someone else's creation. He *might've* been a sentimental madman's replacement for a dead child, or he might be a sentient weapon -- a thing that looks and sounds like a child because that's what Afton's creations are programmed to hunt. He might've fought his way into the Pizzaplex, but he might've been there all along. Regardless of the answer, it has narrative signifigance.
      Goofy as it sounds, it's not too Faz Gooey to think that the cipher on the wall might be a message for Gregory, "the breath they hunt now," from the person who built him and sent him to "crush the vile band". And that would change everything. But Team Afton getting stopped by "some random kid in the wrong place at the wrong time" means he has no greater significance. And he doesn't need there to be, but there's no point in theorizing about the meaning of insignificant events.

  • @starchild199x
    @starchild199x 2 года назад +35

    This is insane!! You literally followed the breadcrumbs, looked in every nook and cranny and put the pieces together. I'm convinced that Steel Wool has kept silent because they knew someone would figure it out eventually, even if it took a year 🤔

  • @tirodeesquina6458
    @tirodeesquina6458 2 года назад +5

    When he cut to the The Immortal and the Restless my jaw actually dropped.

  • @im_not_here_to_fight2744
    @im_not_here_to_fight2744 2 года назад +9

    Once again my mind has been spectacularly blown! You're a genius dude, props to you ♡

  • @CFMeibo
    @CFMeibo 2 года назад +5

    You’ve convinced me of those possibilities! And the theory’s are looking sharp, but there’s a couple of problems that I have.
    (I’m so sorry for the long reply)
    Vanessa being Elizabeth, paying attention to detail throughout the FNAF games there’s something that all the souls have in common. That’s physical contact. The souls have made contact with the vessels they possess and are easily connected with some form of memory. Here’s the examples. Evan (yes I’m calling him that, sue me) made contact with Fredbear before he died. While he died on a hospital bed, that’s the last thing he’s made physical contact with in terms of a vessel. The missing children, stuffed in the suits they possess. Charlie, her body laid beside puppet. William, spring locked in the Springbonnie suit. Michael is an interesting case tho, while Michael’s soul did in fact come back to his body he still didn’t make any kind of contact in terms of a vessel besides Ennard who left his body entirely. With nothing inside, it’s possible his soul still lingered around. If Michael was in fact Glamrock Freddy, then how. He literally has no connection what’s so ever with a Freddy or any memories besides working at the locations, also it’s not like he only remembers Freddy, Chica was around too, but not to mention the fact that if his goal was to keep his father from coming back. Why would he stay in the fire, and more so why go along with Henry’s plan if he had any suspicious it wasn’t going to kill his father. There would be no need for him to stay around since there was no way for William to get a body again since his Scraptrap suit was destroyed in the fire. Alongside with Glamrock Freddy who did in fact clear the path but his memory was erased cause he didn’t remember it cause of Vanny. Michael’s body was destroyed entirely given the condition of the others, there’s nothing at all, so Freddy couldn’t have made any kind of contact with Michael’s body. Vanessa only went along with what William said in those tapes, because it’s what he wants her to do and that was to lie, but something about Vanessa that Elizabeth has no absolutely interest in is cupcakes and beauty products like you explained in your least theory. Also looking at Vanessa’s game model you can see her fingernails are painted. We freed Vanessa by unlocking that door and freeing her from Williams control. Now the second thing, I don’t think Charlie’s soul is lingering around, cause if it was, why work with her killer. Besides, she has no need to linger around as does Elizabeth, and the other missing children, this robotic version of Charlie seems to be entirely programmed by William, and William was also an engineer too. He also spent some time in the system, so it would make sense for him to pick up a thing or two. Sorry for the long response but that’s what I got

  • @nicktheartist1292
    @nicktheartist1292 2 года назад +18

    Wow! Again FuhNaff with the most accurate theories ever. Nobody has patience to know the story except for you. Well done. Love to see more theories from you in the future.

  • @bhjjnhjbunlk
    @bhjjnhjbunlk 2 года назад +28

    Your theories are the only ones that makes actual sense at this point!!! GOOD JOB JOHN! keep up the good work

  • @MidnightRoselle222
    @MidnightRoselle222 2 года назад +25

    I am so excited to see what MatPat has to say about this because, for me, this just rocked my whole world!

  • @livingthemcdream
    @livingthemcdream 2 года назад +3

    Ngl my interest in fnaf lore had been on an all time low, but this video was a perfect reminder on why I enjoyed and probably will keep enjoying these theory’s.

  • @aonalt
    @aonalt 2 года назад +13

    Bro you are a genius! The charlie theory makes so much sense, and you even make these video so frequently. Keep it up man!

  • @alphanumeric_andy
    @alphanumeric_andy 2 года назад +20

    You need more recognition. This theory makes too much sense.

  • @alliesangalli1757
    @alliesangalli1757 2 года назад +14

    Great video! One detail I noticed in the sticky note room that I haven't seen people talk about is that one of the notes reads "grown ups only". The person in that room is clearly a child, so why would they put that note all over their home? Well, if they are the rebuilt Charlie bot, maybe it's actually the older Charlie, not the child version. This would make them a "grown up", but could still have a young, child-like mind inside it. This doesn't really line up with 46's chair not fitting them in the tapes, but that note feels important given that everything else in the room indicates them being a child.

    • @maxattacks3436
      @maxattacks3436 2 года назад +7

      Grown ups only might be a reference to the fourth closest in the novel trilogy. Robo-Charlie calls the fourth closest (Where the adult version was supposed to be) her big girl closet as she is only supposed to open it when she is grown. So the sticky note could be refering to the fourth closest.

  • @Ssyrlx
    @Ssyrlx Год назад +1

    I love how you get straight to the point, the visuals are immaculate and all your theories are open minded and new💕 fav theorist

  • @leagann842
    @leagann842 2 года назад +4

    my immediate thought at 3:32 : ITS CHARLIE SHE'S STILL WATCHING USSSSSS

  • @LuchieSaysHi
    @LuchieSaysHi 2 года назад +55

    I think Scott might want to give the fnaf series to you….You have great story telling and great presentation lol.

  • @jasonlester2251
    @jasonlester2251 2 года назад +4

    The "oh you need more proof" at 12:36 was not needed, you had me since the beginning

  • @Sophies_AU
    @Sophies_AU 2 года назад +7

    You and MatPat are in my top 3 FNAF theorists.
    You have solid proof that backs up your theory
    which is great! keep it up, and I can't wait to finish up the video!

  • @CamKoudo
    @CamKoudo Год назад +2

    John: Gregory was also easy to debunk
    GGY: Are you sure about that? xD

  • @SpottedLabCoat
    @SpottedLabCoat 2 года назад +4

    I can't believe all of the stuff you found in game! That might have been my favourite part of this, reveal after reveal of more in-game clues. This was incredible to watch and obviously countless hours of work. Congratulations on such a triumph!

  • @matthewsfnafworld2958
    @matthewsfnafworld2958 2 года назад +4

    fuhnaff u just broke my brain cause how smart u are and i think u should be the new matpat

  • @AlexMourning5635
    @AlexMourning5635 2 года назад +8

    Honestly, I didn't even notice the similarities to the sewer security bots and Nightmarionne. That seems like such a deliberate detail that so many overlooked.