Thank you for these comparisons! As an Asian myself I always have difficulty finding the right mascara. I love the Heroine Make micro mascara for lower lashes and as a base coat for upper lashes ❤ How difficult is it to remove CLIO one? I loved the effect of Etude mascara but it was very difficult to remove. 😅 I’m curious to try CLIO
Thanks for this review! It has been my quest to find the perfect waterproof mascara. I used Heroine Make for a long time because for years that was the only one you could find in the States but I agree it makes your lashes look spidery and feel crunchy. Now I use a Japanese brand called Leanani - volume and curl mascara and it's much better. Just as waterproof but the brush is fuller so the formula goes on more evenly. I recently went to Seoul and bought the Peripera, Etude House and Clio Kill Lash mascaras so can't wait to test them! I have used the Clio Kill eyeliner and it is 🔥
I love asian brand mascaras because their wands are small and since I have small and hooded eyes, they're just perfect. I only tried the heroine makeover one, but I'm tempted to try out the CLIO one.
Tried it finally .. Love it. It definitely holds a curl. It is not as goopy as the heroin make one. I would say it's a little bit lighter and more natural unless you build it up. But it definitely works
It’s amazing how much of a difference mascara makes on any kind of eye shape! I can go without lipstick or blush. As long as I have my mascara on, POW! I’m awake and ready for the day. If I don’t have mascara,on, I never woke up.
Two minutes after watching this video, I had the Clio Kill Lash in my cart. Got it this week and it's been one of the best mascaras for holding a curl that I've used. I still have to re-curl later in the day, but my lashes are awful. They're super straight, hard to curl and almost impossible to hold a curl. I've used the Kiss Me Heroine and Etude Curl products in the past with mixed results. Thanks for the great review!
this video was so helpful to me! I was looking for reviews for both clio and etude house mascaras and yours really answered some of my questions. thank you!
If you ever want to show off a lash product while wearing eye makeup, you can take an index card and put between your lid and the lashes for a couple seconds of the review to show them off.. But it's also kind of important to see how it looks with eyeshadow on
I haven't tried the other brands but the Heroine one is the only one I can get to work when compared to the Western mascaras. I'm not Asian but I have straight lashes that don't curl no matter what I do so its heroine or nothing. Curious to try others
How I wish Clio will make brown version of their Kill Lash mascaras (especially the Long Curling) I'd prefer to use a (medium to dark) brown shade as my natural hair color is dark brown 😅
I have hooded Asian eyes that push the first third of my lashes down and my lashes in general are super stubborn and straight. The etude lash fixer as a primer is a game changer-but only the clear one, I brought the black one because the clear one hardens and leaves a white residue, but it doesn’t have as strong of a hold. In addition, I’d suggest getting a heated eyelash curler. If you don’t, use a hair dryer but be careful when it comes to anything going close to your eye, test it with your hands or something first to make sure the temperature is safe. Lastly, for the mascara itself, I used the heroine mascara and it’s great, definitely gives you anime lashes, sadly my tube is running dry since it’s been almost a year. I will say the wand could be smaller for me because I end up getting some of it smudged around my eyes, and it’s more difficult to use it on my lower lashes because of the larger wand. I used rom&nd’s mascara, and I like it too, but it works best with a heated lash curler or else it will just weigh down my lashes. Innisfree skinny mascara is good for a natural look and I love the small wand so much. I’ve had my eye on the clio and etude mascaras.
I've been using kiss me heroine for a year now, love it so much but I'm considering to switch to klio as my tube is running dry now. Love the lighter look on klio side! Was wondering tho, does it last as good as the kiss me one? Because I use it daily and at the end of the day I never have to deal with smudged panda eyes.
I know that what I'm going to say is probably against the common opinion but I prefer shorter lashes than to the long spider lashes any day of the week no man in this world has ever said wow she'd be hotter if eyelashes were longer😅
Great to see a variety of brands tested and compared but going for like-for-like makes the exercise more useful and legitimate. Heroine Make does a Length and Curl also, so that is what you should have made the comparison with. That formulation is pretty much holy grail material
Not related to this video but I love how you do your foundation, have you made a video on how you do your base routine? Do you mind sharing how you did it? Thank you ❤
tired both kiss me and clio before, clio is definitely the favorite mascara I've ever used! Romand is a pretty good k beauty brand as well, highly recommend their mascara too! its very similar to clio
Heimish mascara is great. It’s tubing so it works for my monolids better -everything else smudges. The formula is wet so it doesn’t hold curl right away, but you can curl it after it dries and it holds then.
i use cerve ointment or petroleum jelly followed by miceller watter to remove the heroine mascara! i actually combine the heroine mascara with the clio mascara to get volume with length:)
What's your favorite Asian brand mascara? I'm on a mascara kick 😁
Thank you for these comparisons! As an Asian myself I always have difficulty finding the right mascara. I love the Heroine Make micro mascara for lower lashes and as a base coat for upper lashes ❤ How difficult is it to remove CLIO one? I loved the effect of Etude mascara but it was very difficult to remove. 😅 I’m curious to try CLIO
Thanks for this review! It has been my quest to find the perfect waterproof mascara. I used Heroine Make for a long time because for years that was the only one you could find in the States but I agree it makes your lashes look spidery and feel crunchy. Now I use a Japanese brand called Leanani - volume and curl mascara and it's much better. Just as waterproof but the brush is fuller so the formula goes on more evenly. I recently went to Seoul and bought the Peripera, Etude House and Clio Kill Lash mascaras so can't wait to test them! I have used the Clio Kill eyeliner and it is 🔥
I love asian brand mascaras because their wands are small and since I have small and hooded eyes, they're just perfect. I only tried the heroine makeover one, but I'm tempted to try out the CLIO one.
It’s still by far, my favorite one 😍
Do it. 12 hours plus a hot bath and it didn't even drop the curl.
Tried it finally .. Love it. It definitely holds a curl. It is not as goopy as the heroin make one. I would say it's a little bit lighter and more natural unless you build it up. But it definitely works
It’s amazing how much of a difference mascara makes on any kind of eye shape! I can go without lipstick or blush. As long as I have my mascara on, POW! I’m awake and ready for the day. If I don’t have mascara,on, I never woke up.
haha so true!
Two minutes after watching this video, I had the Clio Kill Lash in my cart. Got it this week and it's been one of the best mascaras for holding a curl that I've used. I still have to re-curl later in the day, but my lashes are awful. They're super straight, hard to curl and almost impossible to hold a curl. I've used the Kiss Me Heroine and Etude Curl products in the past with mixed results. Thanks for the great review!
Which kill lash mascara did you get?
I have use Héroïne Kiss and Clio. The Clio one is amazing especially for my bottom lashes!
this video was so helpful to me! I was looking for reviews for both clio and etude house mascaras and yours really answered some of my questions. thank you!
No problem! Thanks for watching! ☺️
If you ever want to show off a lash product while wearing eye makeup, you can take an index card and put between your lid and the lashes for a couple seconds of the review to show them off.. But it's also kind of important to see how it looks with eyeshadow on
Try the Romand one, it’s amazing!
omg.. what lip product are you using in this video? It's so pretty
I love the Clio mascara.
I haven't tried the other brands but the Heroine one is the only one I can get to work when compared to the Western mascaras. I'm not Asian but I have straight lashes that don't curl no matter what I do so its heroine or nothing. Curious to try others
How I wish Clio will make brown version of their Kill Lash mascaras (especially the Long Curling)
I'd prefer to use a (medium to dark) brown shade as my natural hair color is dark brown 😅
Great idea!
I have hooded Asian eyes that push the first third of my lashes down and my lashes in general are super stubborn and straight. The etude lash fixer as a primer is a game changer-but only the clear one, I brought the black one because the clear one hardens and leaves a white residue, but it doesn’t have as strong of a hold.
In addition, I’d suggest getting a heated eyelash curler. If you don’t, use a hair dryer but be careful when it comes to anything going close to your eye, test it with your hands or something first to make sure the temperature is safe.
Lastly, for the mascara itself, I used the heroine mascara and it’s great, definitely gives you anime lashes, sadly my tube is running dry since it’s been almost a year. I will say the wand could be smaller for me because I end up getting some of it smudged around my eyes, and it’s more difficult to use it on my lower lashes because of the larger wand.
I used rom&nd’s mascara, and I like it too, but it works best with a heated lash curler or else it will just weigh down my lashes. Innisfree skinny mascara is good for a natural look and I love the small wand so much.
I’ve had my eye on the clio and etude mascaras.
Hi Mae! Can you review tarte mascaras sometime please? :) Thank you
i prefer when u review black mascaras instead of brown ones :( otherwise great vid as always tho
Great video!!
like your lip color, which lip gloss did you wear?
I think the CLIO mascara you linked is different from the one you actually used in the video. The link sent me to Volume Curling, not Long Curling
Just updated it...looks like Amazon no longer sells that one.
What do you remove them with? I have Clio mascara that is amazing but don’t use it because it’s a pain to remove it!
I’ve been loving the Versed Cleansing Balm in the light pink packaging. It works well with the Clio mascaras.
I've been using kiss me heroine for a year now, love it so much but I'm considering to switch to klio as my tube is running dry now. Love the lighter look on klio side! Was wondering tho, does it last as good as the kiss me one? Because I use it daily and at the end of the day I never have to deal with smudged panda eyes.
It lasts really well! No smudging!
I can't get clio off to save my lashes! 😂 I need to get the remover
Mae, what do you use to curl your lashes? Mine are so short, I have a hard time finding one that doesn’t pinch. TIA
Shiseido eyelash curler
@@MaeSitler thank you!
I know that what I'm going to say is probably against the common opinion but I prefer shorter lashes than to the long spider lashes any day of the week no man in this world has ever said wow she'd be hotter if eyelashes were longer😅
Great to see a variety of brands tested and compared but going for like-for-like makes the exercise more useful and legitimate. Heroine Make does a Length and Curl also, so that is what you should have made the comparison with. That formulation is pretty much holy grail material
Ooo I wanna try that etude one. I love my Clio ones for sure.
Not related to this video but I love how you do your foundation, have you made a video on how you do your base routine? Do you mind sharing how you did it? Thank you ❤
I just posted a video on how I perfect my base makeup ☺️
tired both kiss me and clio before, clio is definitely the favorite mascara I've ever used!
Romand is a pretty good k beauty brand as well, highly recommend their mascara too! its very similar to clio
Heimish mascara is great. It’s tubing so it works for my monolids better -everything else smudges. The formula is wet so it doesn’t hold curl right away, but you can curl it after it dries and it holds then.
Hi! Which heimish mascara is it?
CLIO kill lash. Like, wtf?
I wore it for 12 hours AND THEN HAD A HOT BATH and I'm telling you it didn't even drop the curl.
It’s witchcraft 😁
which kill lash mascara did you get?
@@giveitupforbeabadoobee.
i use cerve ointment or petroleum jelly followed by miceller watter to remove the heroine mascara! i actually combine the heroine mascara with the clio mascara to get volume with length:)