Это видео недоступно.
Сожалеем об этом.
Yasir Qadhi Doubts in Islam
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 14 авг 2024
- The story of how academia can destroy even a scholar's faith in Islam.
Yasir Qadhi has doubts in Islam regarding the preservation of the Quran and regarding evolution.
👉 IMPORTANT: SUBSCRIBE TO MY NEW CHANNEL HERE: bit.ly/friendl... 👈
► My blog: friendlyexmusli...
Yasir Qadhi always struck me as a rational individual, a person of academic integrity. I always suspected that he may end up agnostic one day.
He has come out and said his faith has taken a major blow. That he has come close to a crisis of faith. This is an important development because it shows that even the most strong believers, ones who studied the religion in depth, are not immune to the problems in Islam.
The narrative of Islam we have been taught is false, and it falls apart under scrutiny.
Yasir Qadhi says:
"I am personally aware of around a dozen muslims in academia who had major crises of faith (and perhaps one who has left the faith) because of this issue, and i have also confessed on this list that my own personal crisis of knowledge (I wouldnt really call it a faith crisis, although perhaps it came close) was when I entered into this realm, during my first year at Yale, and felt my world come crashing down in front of me. I didn't know what to believe about the hifdh [preservation] of the Quran anymore, because there was no alternative.
You either had non-Muslim views, or these simplistic, standardized triumphalistic claims that a rational mind simply cannot acknowledge as true."
He also says ": the 'preservation' of the Quran cannot, then, be a 'letter for letter, tashkil for tashkil' narrative that later scholars verbalized and the Muslim Ummah is taught"
Sources:
Original emails posted by Yasir Qadhi leaked here:
/ transcription_of_the_l...
Our Future as Muslims in the West, Noman Ali Khan, October 2010:
• Our Future as Muslims ...
Theological Debate on Evolution, Yasir Qadhi, January 2013:
• Theological Debate on ...
Inheriting a Complex World, Yasir Qadhi, May 2015:
• Inheriting a Complex W...
Who's watching this in 2020 after Yasir Qadhi's disastrous and revealing public conversation with Muhammad Hijab that's blowing up the internet?
Me 😀
He is being exposed. Fake.
Lilian Davis Haha even shabir Ally is confirming this. Islam is falling apart as more people is leaving it than converting according to researchers. And keep in mind that there are plenty in Islamic countries that can not openly say they left Islam. #IslamDownhill
@@emperor7580 let me teach you something. In Islam there are 73 sects which there shouldn't be. But prophet mohammed pbuh told us this. He said all will in hell except one. Who are they? They are the ones who follow Qur'an and hadith. Entirely. They don't add, subtract, or change any thing of the faith that was revealed. So the people who say they have left Islam were never Muslim in the first place. Go and do your research on this my man. They just had to admit they were never Muslim in the first place that's all. 😁😁😁😁
Lilian Davis I pray everyday more and more people find a relationship with the Lord Jesus Christ and leave Islam
Yasir Qadhi is one of my favourite sheikhs. If he comes out as an agnostic he could virtually save humanity.
they will kill him
He is not a sheikh at this point. He is a misguided dupe that Allah left to go astray.
bmrigs bit sadistic this 'allah'. I guess you know more than him 😊
John Smith not really. Ur friend Abdullah is proof that atheists and apostates are not being killed everywhere. Historically too, not all apostates were killed.
A successful recipe to make a believer stay with their faith:
1. Tell them that their cult / religion is the truth.
2. When they find facts that contradict “the truth”, refer to No.1.
I think Yasir Qadi is a good man who admits evolution is a fact unlike others who interpert Koran to suit evolution.
he is e a liar, because in the same email it says "He is not saying the 'recitation' is not preserved, but he is saying that some elements of the recitation have some human influences." and he said that Qadi doubts the preservation!!
and also said " despite the fact that he repeatedly stated that he was only posing certain questions and the fact that he refrained from making any claims about the preservation of the Quran." so he does not doubt the preservation but rather some elements in recitation
The 'reinterpreters' have to cherry pick verses and perform Olympic-level mental gymnastics to turn that narration 180 degrees. Not to mention loads of very explicit contradicting hadith.
lol yasir qadhi doesnt believe in human evolution but admits that it is good science, so in other words he's delusional.
Is evolution a fact? The concept of absolute time and space existed from 5th July 1687 until 1887. It was overturned by Einsteins Special Relativity in 1905, General Relativity in 1915. For 200 years it was taught as "fact" when it wasn't. Now I believe in microevolution and there is evidence for that. Darwin's Finches on the Galapagos islands change beak shape from generation to generation. But so far, NO ONE has observed macroevolution where one species evolves into a completely different species.
Frequently scientists discover laws and that is a good thing. But they indulge in un-scientific behaviour to hang onto their results. A true scientist would be dispassionate about laws discovered and would only consider evidence based results. I repeat, NO ONE has observed once species evolving into another and we dont have skeletons of the intermediate results.
The theory of evolution is a fact only concerning the natural selection processes underlying it (that were discovered, btw, much earlier than Darwin), the conclusions deriving from them, however, are far from being factual (albeit they usually get lumped together, as if they were the same). I sincerely believe that 90% of average atheists that continue with this facade of "evolution is a fact" never even for once researched actual papers of evolutionists and just read books from Dawkins and the like that selectively chose which information to tell them, discarding everything they would not like to hear. You don't need to search far to discover the huge (incredibly huge) problems the theory of evolution carries, you just need to look at the cell and DNA/RNA. The structure of the latter, especially, is totally unexplainable through processes of natural selection. Until our knowledge of the cell was primordial it was pretty simple to believe that an albuminous combination of carbon could form easily out of random mutations from simple aminoacids, the thing completely changes when the cell becomes as a sophisticated city containing within itself millions of strands of information the origin of whom is impossible to decipher throughout natural processes.
And don't let me even start on abiogenesis or cosmogony models because there things are even worse (and that says it all).
However I'm happy that Qadhi has finally started having doubts on Islam. I wonder why it took him so long given how Muhammad is the clearest false prophet in all of the history of religion. Neither scientology has such a messed up doctrine as Islam.
Being challenged can be very constructive.
Yasir reached the same conclusion ibn sina and ibn rushd arrived at they both were also ostracized. At least yasir has science to understand the world.
"There are holes in the standard narrative"
Yasir Qadhi
This video just shocks me. This dude was my Imam before I became Ex-muslim. Its so weird to see how confident and articulate is was in the masjid for things he had doubts in.
Invalid IQ sooner or later Y.Qadhi will shave his beard.....dumping Islam.
The hearts of beleiver are between the two fingers of Allah according to a hadith. He can be a disbeliever the same day.
@@zarfanhussain I pray that Christ Jesus reveals himself to you and saves your soul
@@NathanKwadade amen. I do believe he's going to reveal himself.
Almost like people don't care much about providing others with truth and would rather do what is necessary for self preservation 🤷♀️
Question what you're being sold and what's in it for the person doing the seller. Everything is up for sale in this world even God and faith.
I doubt he believes anymore. However he stays in the Muslim world because that's his bread and butter. There could also be hell to pay if he leaves. Muslims are not very forgiving of people that walk away.
Well said! The penalty for apostasy in islam ☪️ is death!
I felt thesame, the more i studied, the more i disbelieved
To all religious Muslims and Christians : Even if a God existed, why would he burn you in an "eternal Hell" for not believing in ancient texts that are clearly nonsense and there is absolutely no evidence that it was "revealed" by a Creator? Just because it doesn't make any sense to you, you will be punished for all of eternity? Come on.....
That's the reason, in our South Asian countries it's never allowed for ordinary people to read quran with translation.
Great job brother keep doing it..... 👌👌👌
It is allowed... The reason why everyone reads the Arabic version is cause the other versions are considered translations and not the proper source material from which you get "thawab/sawab" from reading.
@@sarban1653 then what's the point of reading it when it's in a language utterly alienistic to me if I was God I had solved that problem,I can do it now as well suppose I God the most powerful creates books in all languages & I command those books to be unchangeable from their true meaning now Muslims say no but what is the test in it. Why do The God even want to take a test then Muslims come to purpose teacher & student example which is again utterly meaningless cuz a teacher shouldn't punish a child & tell him to do what ever he wants cuz it promotes helplessness you can search on RUclips what helplessness is & if punishment is the only way then why only one chance. in school or any institute Good institute supervised in good hands they would promote trail & error & not if you will fail this year you have the only one chance & you'll go to the hell then why is there free will at the first place. Islam isn't true nor any other religion. I also have a base logic why Allah isn't true God.
@@alihaidarshah1255 The point is that it's considered far more spiritually rewarding. I don't agree with that as I'm not a Muslim, but I was explaining why Muslims do that. It's not practical of course, but that's the religious logic used by them.
Jubair Ahmed..you lie
Who told u? We read Quran daily, and now my country increasing muslim ALHAMDULILLAH
This is something that I have always pondered. Can it be that a rational, intelligent, qualified person such as Yasir Qadhi (who by the way I have met) does not have even an inkling of a doubt? Can it be that you dedicate a large portion of your life, especially, in the West and have the freedom of thought, expression and speech. But yet there are no cracks in the seams?
This is impossible I say. Of course he has doubts, of course there are things where he simply does not know and has to concede defeat.
I attended the event shown about evolution and Islam at which he was speaker. And he could only barely deny evolution (and even then it was only for humans). He said during the Q&A and I paraphrase "I cannot speak for the science or biology of evolution", but he could and did speak for the Islam and what the limits are; which were that you can believe in evolution just not for homo sapiens. Even at the time I thought this was troublesome and all the other speakers outshone the apologist speakers and even a large majority of the educated crowd thought so with their intelligent questions of evolutionary mechanisms. There was a religious woman donning a hijab who was crying after the event because she did not know what to think.
So if we can doubt our faith, be disturbed by it and bring us theological trouble. Is it possible for someone that studies Islam for a living to be troubled by aspects of there religion? If not doubt the whole premise of it? For Yasir Qadhi (and I do not represent nor speak for him) I would say resoundingly; yes.
I deeply sympathise with them in a way. When he said his world came crashing down, I felt like that when I learned more about religion. It literally broke my heart.
I am quite surprised, I have to admit, that Yasir Qadhi had actually admitted in Singapore that he was baffled to learn what he did about the 7th, 8th, and 9th centuries of the common era in relation to the rise of Islam.
Surely he knows that the Arab conquests did not happen the way the Islamic tradition would have it. There are no debates about this in academia anymore. We know how the conquests took place. Muslims have to accept this.
Could you please advise a well sourced book to read about this from experts in the field (which is even quite accessible)?
Platypus Paws do you know arabic language ?
FAT cat I wanted to recommend for you listening to Ahmad Zayed’s lectures, he is the most knowledgeable person i know of in the Middle East about this subject, and he is totally unbiased when it comes to analyzing the history and what not. He mention the sources as he goes through his lectures.
ruclips.net/user/alexandriabeacon
Look at what the quran says not what “muslims” do
@@maxter1334 Such as the following?
Qur'an, Surah 9:29, Mohsin Khan translation:
"Fight against those who (1) believe not in Allah, (2) nor in the Last Day, (3) nor forbid that which has been forbidden by Allah and His Messenger (4) and those who acknowledge not the religion of truth (i.e. Islam) among the people of the Scripture (Jews and Christians), until they pay the Jizyah with willing submission, and feel themselves subdued."
love your honesty about the truth bro.
Super Amazing. Finally I can share something to the muslim friends.
the quran was preserved in aisha's goat's stomach.
No science it's bullshit . Too vague
@The Media Lies Against Islam it's a few months later now. Did you look at the science in the Qur'an lately?
@@SaintOtter no lol
Tell me what science ur talking about
@@joseguerrero1144
It's a year ago I posted this as a reply. I don't know the original post I replied to of course.
But there are no scientific miracles in the Qur'an.
The only miracle is that Muslims believe the Qur'an contains miracles
Great video, we need to challenge traditional islamic scholarship and their views. 👍👍
Amen brother..
Veedu Vidz why don’t you just concentrate on being an atheist waleed, or better still showing the light of atheism to the rest of your family.
Have you convinced others in your family to leave Islam?
cris pynadeth christianity is even more load of RUBBISH
Bits'N Bobs islam should hold up to scrutiney not just be followed blindly.
+Veedu, exactly. One of the best effective modern-day Crusade against the spread of Islam, is-->unbiased education system (so long as its not taught by a practicing Muslim)on religious studies, apologetics, scholarly public debates, and "dawah" to Muslims using their own sources(Qur'an, Hadith, Sira) against them. It has already proven to be quite effective.
I saw this guy a couple years ago on how science and islam cooperate, he is very articulate and i give him alot of respect for his honesty. To bad the muslims are just gonna come out and say him and these universities work for israel
Zack Smith well good for you sir, would love to hear why you converted and what part of islam you want reformed
The story of Adam and Eve is in bible and Christians are free not to believe in it but muslims are not free to do the same.
I mean. There is a Y chromosome Adam and a mitochondrial Eve. Science says that there was no evidence they were together but they did exist.
Who told you that about bible?
Guidance comes from Allah alone. Not madinah university or the Islamic studies dept of Yale.
Btw, evolution is not a scientific fact but a theory.
Alhamdulillah, i am happy tht it is clear for myself as a muslim of which islamic speaker to listen to and which to discard.
May Allah guide Yasir Qadhi. If he does decide to leave Islam, it does not cause any loss or any profit for Islam. Islam does not need yasir qadhi but it us yasir qadhi tht needs Islam.
Despite ppl who leave islam and the falsehood mongers of the world, Islam continues to be the fastest growing faith in the world, and the largest practised faith in most regions in the world.
Alhamdulillah! 😊
The words of Allah were never preserved. The Quran as a book was composed under the ruling of Uthman and according to hadiths, and scholars, the Quran is missing chapters and verses, and verses were added to the Quran. Also, just the fact that the Quran was compiled years after the death of Muhammad and that many words were missing and forgotten and verses were added should be enough evidence to convey that Islam is a man made religion.
True reality of things is still hidden from you.
500 references to hell - directed to whom? Completely false.
"There is no stone in all the ego's embattled citadel that is more heavily defended than the idea that sin is real." - A course in Miracles
Borrowings are blatantly obvious :
Sura 18: Story of the Companions of the Cave = a borrowing
from the legend of the Seven Sleepers of Ephesus
Lotus Petal Don't forget that most Muslim scholars agree that Dhul Qur Nayn in the Quran is supposed to be Alexander The Great. Also, there's myths predating Judaism that are similar to Noah's ark, Adam and Eve, Samson, Jesus etc.
Lotus Petal You left out my favorite: The goat that ate some of the Quran! Sure, it’s hasan, but when else do Muslims throw out a hasan Hadith??
Alexis Jankowski Hasan is used to describe hadith whose authenticity is not as well-established as that of ṣaḥīḥ hadith, but sufficient for use as supporting evidence. But regardless of that, in sahih al-bukhari 5686, book 76, hadith 9 says that camel urine is good as a medicine.
One thing will never change, God is one and we are all here for a reason. If you think, you don't have the intelligence to understand the creator, I don't think you will go to hell because crazy people don't go to hell.
And if you think people are Muslim because of Yasir Qadhi then wake up brother.
If I'd believed there is no God, I would have already killed myself.
As for the preservation of the Quran, how could you not understand, reciting a book written in easy, poetic Arabic language for 23 years is easy to memorize. I am not even an Arabic speaker and it took me 2 years to memorize.
I hope you get guidance from Allah. But Allah gives guidance those whose sole purpose is to find the truth.
GALAS they are blind to the truth. Ppl find comfort in remembrance of Allah. As for the Quran, four of my near relatives memorized the entire Quran. It's laughable that anyone says it was not preserved when many Muslims including 3 of the Prophet's wives memorized it. That's easy for many youth now and even was easier in the past bc they had no TV or Internet and distractions. Atheists are the worst liars #imho
you sounds like a shallow guy who want's to believe in god so bad so he doesn't kill himself
One thing will never change. Islamic apologists will always read arguments and then make statements with no evidence as they believe it shows them to be strong. ‘God is one’. How can a human being possibly know god even if god existed. Even if the Quran was true, even if Mohammed was a prophet - who are you to declare you know with certainty what god is or is not? How arrogant. Even if there was a god you would know nothing of him / her / it. Merely stating your belief in any one religion is just you patting yourself on the back for how important you think you are. You worship the religion of your friends and family - you memorised the Quran. Excellent - now come back when you’ve memorised another few hundred religious texts from other faiths going back over the centuries and I’ll be slightly impressed. I do not believe there is a god because instead of evidence apologists make infantile statements like ‘god is one and we are all here for a reason’ or try to impress because they read one short book, with precisely nothing than their opinion to back it up. Muslims, Christians, Jews, Hindus - it’s all self-worship. Your statements about how quickly you memorised it only serves to show how you view yourself. ‘Allah gives guidance to those whose sole purpose is to find the truth. My friend - you are. It interested in truth. You are interested in belonging, in showing off, and in ensuring that you ask as few questions as you can in your one and only life.
Is the Quran A Plagiarised book?
Why are you reading a plagiarised book? The quran is 70% copied stories that existed before Islam!
For example:
The story of Abraham being thrown into the fire & Solomon talking to ants come from the jewish Talmud !
The Talmud was written after Jesus time! And was never accepted as the word of God neither by Jews or Christians! It is simply commentaries by jewish priests with jewish myth!
Muhammad heard jews talk about these stories & put them into his quran without knowing that it came from a fake source !
The story of Jesus talking as a baby & making clay birds alive & St. Mary being under a palm tree all come from the Fake gnostic gospels!
These gospels were written from 150 AD to around 500 AD!
Way too late to be authentic!
And the Christian church never really accepted them because they were obviously fake! Even people at the time did not consider them real!
Muhammad heard them from the heretical Christians around him & put them into his quran without knowing that they come from a fake source !
The story of the men in the cave, is a Christian myth story written about 300 years before Islam! It never happened! It's just myth!
The story of Zul Al Qarnien was a popular legend that was known from before Islam!
Most muslim scholars say it's Alexander the Great. And the quran says that he was a good man & a good muslim!
But history shows that he was a wicked pagan man, a polytheist, & a drink! And we never found the people who live next to the muddy spring that the sun sets in! Nor did we ever find that iron gate or mountain!
Just pure myth!
There are other stories that also have their origins in things that existed before Islam!
The quran is not pure Arabic as it falsely claims!
It has MANY Syriac & Aramaic words, a greek word and at least one Coptic word!
The people around Muhammad were correct in accusing him of copying "tales of the ancients"!!
Because that's exactly what he was doing!
All these fake stories got mixed up with corrupted stories from the Bible with some of Muhamad life & made into fancy Arabian poetry!
And that's how he brainwashed 7th century Arabian pagans and that's how he brainwashed the entire islamic nation up to today!!
1- Muhammad lived with Jews & Christians & pagans & others long before becoming a prophet! Surely he must have talked, done business & argued about religion & other things!
That's what people do!
That's how he would have been exposed to these stories!!
(Perhaps this "waraka ebn nofel" told Muhammad some of these stories)!!
2- When he becomes a prophet, he tells them these stories! They tell him we already know them! & we reject you as a prophet!
And accuse him of telling tales of the ancients!
3- In modern times, we discovered many manuscripts that have all of these quranic stories in their original form!! And they date from way before islam !
MUHAMMADAN PLAGIARISM EXPOSED.
Here is where some of those supposed Allah's revelations as found in Qur'an came from:
Many of the stories in the Qur'an come from the Jewish Talmud, the Midrash, and many apocryphal works. This was pointed out by Abraham Geiger in 1833, and further documented by another Jewish scholar, Dr. Abraham Katsh, of New York University, in 1954 (The Concise Dictionary of Islam, p. 229; Jomier, The Bible and the Quran -- Henry Regency Co., Chicago, 1959, 59ff; Sell, Studies, pp. 163ff.; Guillaume, Islam, p. 13).
1. The source of Sura 3:35-37 is the fanciful book called The Protevangelion's James the Lesser.
2. The source of Sura 87:19 is the Testament of Abraham.
3. The source of Sura 27:17-44 is the Second Targum of Esther.
4. The fantastic tale that G-d made a man "die for a hundred years" with no ill effects on his food, drink, or donkey was a Jewish fable (Sura 2:259ff.).
5. The idea that Moses was resurrected and other material came from the Jewish Talmud (Sura 2:55, 56, 67).
Thank you Abdullah for bringing up the Yasir Qadhi video. Indeed he truly checkmated his own religion by clarifying how Evolution absolutely contradicts Islamic scripture
Exactly. This is a silver bullet
Just a thought, do you know what is Asadullah Ali's stance of Evolution? Denier or Reconciler?
Absolute Proof The Quran Is Wrong.
ruclips.net/video/GNKWBD3k77s/видео.html
I never wanted to leave my religion but taking a deep dive made me question every thing
the more you study deeper you will find the truth.....
Are you suggesting Allah cannot handle vetting from these ''Kufar'' Universities?
Abdulla
After 100 years people will remember Abdulla's statement and will say how stupid he was.
Education and science are the greatest enemies of islams.
Not really, stupid people are the enemies of their own destruction
I agree with you
I would claim that the scripture of Islam also is a big enemy of Islam.
One example, there such a large number of things where the hadiths and the quran contradicts each other, that both can't be considered as canonical at the same time.
And it that case the hadiths must be the one that loses the status as canonical, which will have so huge impact on Islam as we know it today that the mind spins when you think about it.
So the issue remains unaddressed by scholars of islam and it's left to grind away one Muslim at a time from faith.
As to any bigotry :-)
may Allah keep my faith strong and protect me from people like yasir qadhi who will destroy Islam.
Yasir Qadhi hasn’t actually done anything wrong.
@@kyliereed200 maybe no wrong, but dangerous
@@simemble9342 Other people pushed him.
Miraculous Preservation of the Quran: Burying the Myth.
ruclips.net/video/lH6M-iLVcKM/видео.html
@@simemble9342
Dangerous to unproven, undocumented, unfalsifiable concepts that is. While Islam is a danger to human rights and lives.
Yasir Qadhi needs to leave islam and join the freethinking community...
I became Muslim because i am a freethinker. My family raised me hardchor atheists i am from a christian country but i vvas able to think free and to inform myself vvithout prejudices and i became a muslim. Atheists are often very arrogant believing that they vvould be the only people vvho are able to think free.
Gerhard Löwenherz
Since you have no evidence that Allah even exists so you're not a free thinker rather you have been brainwashed.
Avinash Kumar jha well what's the evidence that your emotions exists?
Avinash Kumar jha the Quran is the evidence. The message in it is clear and simple to understand.
Faris Ibrahim
Emotions are caused by hormones. And Quran is not evidence of Allah. Quran is a claim. By your logic Harry Potter books can be evidence of Harry Potter's existence.
I love muslims so much but after that 2o2o interview, my family and myself choose to become ex-muslims. We now become Christians and believe Jesus Christ is the son of the living GOD
We can criticize Yasir Qadhi but he still have some integrity to say some of his doubts . It takes courage to do that . Of course it would be better if he would say that Islam is a Fraud but we still have Ex muslims youtube channels to do that .
He is walking a thin line.
A great video, thank you for this Abdullah. I hope for the best for you and Yasir.
Yasir Qadhi on Islamic genesis analysis: "... fun to look at but of no practical value." Indeed, and I want also to know his opinion on Islamic analysis of the flat Earth :D
I have been following you for the last 2 months . You have pushed out great content, especially the live talks.
Now I have an inkling of doubt here . How do I know these are the actual Yasir Qadhi emails? You posted a Reddit link of all things as a source, and that is deleted from a year ago. Post and updated source. Also, it seems you are stretching his talks. Abdullah, I like your content so far, but without the proper evidence, it is a stretch to call it severe "doubts".
Brother watch Darwinian delusions look at that he is a Muslim that has a PhD in Evolution. There is why Darwinian evolution has 13 theories in itself and many don’t believe it. This is all propaganda
Baheer 1 I have a question. If the human body is created by god, why is it not perfect at all?
@@baheer156 lol
@@bunnystrasse really god has ultimate wisdom firstly then why does it matter. what does perfect mean god has the picture I can only see a pixel and can never tell you the exact reason. maybe we are perfect for a system to function and society to prosper. Your missing an important point we are on earth to be tested so god is testing us with illness and health. In the hereafter then god will give us perfection. As in the hereafter those in heaven there will be no more tests.
He admitted it with mo hijab. You should have watched it by now
وَ اِنۡ کُنۡتُمۡ فِیۡ رَیۡبٍ مِّمَّا نَزَّلۡنَا عَلٰی عَبۡدِنَا فَاۡتُوۡا بِسُوۡرَۃٍ مِّنۡ مِّثۡلِہٖ ۪ وَ ادۡعُوۡا شُہَدَآءَکُمۡ مِّنۡ دُوۡنِ اللّٰہِ اِنۡ کُنۡتُمۡ صٰدِقِیۡنَ ﴿۲۳﴾
اور اگر تمہیں شک ہو اس میں جو ہم نے نازل کیا اپنے ( برگزیدہ ) بندے پر تو لے آؤ ایک سورة اس جیسی اور بلا لو اپنے حمائتیوں کو اللہ کے سوا اگر تم سچے ہو۔
سورة البقرہ: 23
Animal evolution is true but not human evolution. Think about how could those animals just appear. Allah said he dispersed animals throughout the land not brought them down magically.
It is true.
sincere question (if u want to respond plz read sincerely i don't want the repetitive/mockery or dismissive narratives)
According to islam, we are here for the test but in the quran everything is already writen ever since our souls were created and blown into as fetus
Allah already chosen where each souls ends up(heaven or hell) and the ONLY reason we are on earth is to see that god is right when he chooses us to be hell or heaven so do we really have free will? if we do how much free will do we have or are accountable for? because
without Allah permission, we can't be guided
without Allah permission we can't understand certain concepts especially when Allah guarantees every human will sin and we were created with hast...
If the answer is because Allah can do whatever he want than is God actually merciful? especially because
Allah doesn't need us to worship him but we punished for not worship him?
Guys, wake up this is old!! Very old! He rebuked his own self and did a whole public speech also on you tube where he said these emails and allegations were false and he fully believes in Islam and worships Allah and believes in the messenger.
Evidence please? Do you have this in writing?
Abdullah Sameer your proof is a screen shot of some emails. This can easily be made up and a photo taken, you know it’s easy to do. Also Yasir Qadhi totally denied this and said he is firmly a Muslims and he is doing dawah talks and Jumma sermons weekly all uploaded to you tune. Shaitan is there to put doubt in the minds of everyone. It’s Shaitans classic trick. Doubts are from Shaitan and never take anyone out of Islam.
Also your claim that those who leave islam are killed is totally false. Many many scholars as you know say that if a person leaves Islam it’s their own issue and no one does anything or cares. You like to give yourself importance with the whole exmuslim thing but does anyone really care?
Evolution occurs because Allah allows it to. That does not mean your grandfathers were baboons!
No one really cares about you leaving Islam. It’s like your desperate for Muslims to want to attack you as it gives you some self importance.
Buchille ne prove it. Which ones got killed with real documented evidence. Not hearsay or media hype. Actual legal cases with over 2 billions on planet let’s see how many cases you can prove. What your saying is a myth to boost your own importance. Reality is, no one cares.
cessna caravan not even all western atheist scientists agree on evolution!! Check your evidences first. It’s only a theory and not everyone agrees on it. Just read up on Skell2005 however it’s way above your pay grade.
Shaq. Is satan more powerful than god if he manages to override or exert a greater influence over people? Why doesn't god get rid of him? How can satan possibly thwart the plan of an all powerful being?
It’s non-intuitive to understand that all this complexity is just natural and no intervention of any being is required, it’s much much simpler and easier for humans to believe that some being did it magically, especially when we are indoctrinated to believe from a very early age by our parents, teachers, leaders, elders practically everyone. And if we don’t conform to our parents religions then we can be shunned, disowned and possibly harmed. originally from Karachi Pakistan and Teer Haripur Hazaara, now ex-Muslim Atheist ., ,
Even if Quran is preserved for word to word,doesn’t matter,it is a book written by man or men like many other books,and claimed as word of God.
Great video Abdullah.
This is essentially the problem between ibn Rushd and al Ghazali. And is partly why I think al Ghazali wrote The Incoherence of Philosophers, in order to try and quash the exploration of the corpus using rational/empirical (in the Aristotelian sense) means.
Sometimes, I imagine that some of the great scientific thinkers of the Islamic Age were crypto-religionists, paying lip service to the faith in order to survive and still be able to practice their science.
People still do the same today...until given permission to be honest about their doubts.
There is a category in the Quran for that
"Munafiqoon"
You are claiming they consciously chose to be munafiq?
Yes. I think that it was a similar phenomenon to that which we see today, or saw with Jews in the time of Maimonides for instance. The Guide for the Perplexed mentions it.
And these days, there is a wealth of sources that speak about this-hiding their true conclusions for fear of persecution. I myself have heard over a hundred testimonies.
It is true, Al Ghazali seems like he invented “elm alkalam” or “science of talk” as the literal translation, which is basically irrational arguing while sounding like a philosopher defending the believes of his religion.
And regarding the great “muslim” scientists we were being fed all our life that they were muslims, turned out they didn’t believe in islam, ibn sina for example
People who are plagued by superstition go to study in countries that are not plagued by it.
Who is making progress and who isn't? Everyone knows.
I am ex Muslim. I left Islam 3 years ago after realizing that universe is working according to universal laws and laws of attraction,not on religious beliefs.those old stories are no longer working in this modern age.
Would you like some more information about that? And may I ask what your talking about?
Great job with all these videos. We need new narratives
he is e a liar, because in the same email it says "He is not saying the 'recitation' is not preserved, but he is saying that some elements of the recitation have some human influences." and he said that Qadi doubts the preservation!!
and also said " despite the fact that he repeatedly stated that he was only posing certain questions and the fact that he refrained from making any claims about the preservation of the Quran." so he does not doubt the preservation but rather some elements in recitation
Abdullah Sameer
you are a brave man best wishes to you
Most doubtful is the sun setting in a muddy spring
Have you ever heard of figurative language?? Or do you really believe that Muslims believe that the sun cools off in a spring??
Please read it in Arabic look for meanings and uses of root words used.
While reading keep in mind black holes.
@@mansoorahmdExplaining what the verse actually meant is a futile effort to cushion the impact.
Yasir Qadhi should leave islam. He is just hanging in there with out any believe.
Rual
Bro it’s better if he stay as disguises Muslim and destroy the faith by exposing it from within. That is a better strategy to put this religion to an end.😊
Why did anyone ever believe in the perfect preservation of the Quran? Christians have been comparing manuscripts of the Bible for centuries. The preservation is very good, but not perfect.
Religion leads to spirituality, spirituality leads to reality, reality leads to bliss, bliss leads to infinity and infinity is that condition of this universe which existed prior to creation & which shall prevail after complete dissolution of this universe !
Yasir Qadhi when he come out of Islam he can be his own person and have his own purpose in life rather worshiping Allah. Good luck to him and his studies
It is true that when under scrutiny Islamic argument falls apart man I myself going thru a faith crisis and man it's difficult at times I'm deeply shaken and scared
Aj Dz enlighten me what Islamic argument falls apart under scrutiny? Then explain to me why Islam has the highest number of converts from people of religious and academic backgrounds.
Aaron Schwartz
Bro on this comment I'm expressing my own opinion if u wish to know then do your own researches and ask your own questions I'm not here to turn people from their faiths or such everyone is free to believe whatever they want .
Aj Dz you said it falls apart under scrutiny that makes it a statement not a personal view hence I asked the question. When something falls apart under scrutiny it becomes objective and not subjective. But now you have clarified what you meant I bid you good day.
Aaron Schwartz if that's how u see it then be it bro I honestly find a lot of flaws and contradiction but I guess it's a matter of perspective .
Aj Dz it's not how I see it it's how the world of academia sees it. I think it's best you speak to someone who is learned in the area and neutral to get a better understanding than making up your own conclusions than make a decision on if it falls apart.
I would be interested to see what some of the contradictions and flaws you have found, so humor me.
But thank you for the videos they give us all a lot to think about, even as a Christians
People may tell you that your belief is weak if you keep crying. Your parents may tell you if you prayed more, you would't be depressed.The imam at the masjid may say if you read Quarn more, you'd be a better believer and would't be sad and have these problem but then you pray, and your're still unable to cry.And then you read Quarn, and your depression is crippling.And you make dua-sincere,overwhelmingly emotional,present dua-and yet you don't feel better and you feel like nothing has changed and so you yourself wonder: is god angry with me? is Allah not answering my duas because i am not good enough? Am I going through all of this because Allah is punishing me? What have i done wrong? why me? Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) prayed with the most intense concentration and with the strongest relationship with god possible, yet still missed khadija 10 years after his death.he didn't ''get over her'' He moved forward with life, but missed her instensely. And it's okay that it hurts.He (PBUH) cried at his mother grave decades after her passing.it didn't diminish the strength of his belief. He wept as he held his dying son, and it didn,t decrease his trust in god's wisdom.When you have thses thoughts remember : Prophet jacob (PBUH) cried so much at the loss of his son jacob.He wasn't sad for a day.Or a month.Or a year.His tears flowed so intensely that his eyesight was depleted.And despite his tears,despite his human sadness,he was the amongst the best believers god placed on earth.His tears did not mean his belief in god was weak or his trust in him wavered And know that despite the negative ways other believers may make you feel,Allah is the one to whom you can vulnerable.Where we can shatter.Where we can show every insecurity and know that we are still worth because He loves us no matter what.So when people say ''Hasn't it been long enough? let them know:For the prophet sometimes it was longer.The prophet have shown us that even when others don't understand,even with worship the struggles of life are incredibly immense.With Allah you always have safe place
Evolution was the thing that made me doubt Islam in the first place.
There’s a lot of gaps in evolution stoll
@@googletalks4416 there’s not
أسعى إلى الحقيقة أبعد من عقائد الدين
Yasir Quadhi is a reflective and intelligent man. He knows more than he openly directly can admit to his listeners. That’s why he so cautiously weighs his words when he is lecturing on these topics, but he may already feel that disturbing cognitive dissonance. However, he knows that a more open and direct expression could cause unrest in the Ummah, and even outrage in the Muslim community; so he has to select his sentences and wordings with great care.
Lol, Yasir could never publically leave Islam, it's his money maker and i don't blame him for that.
Ex Muslim great than Hindu men. . .
Because exmuslim logics is great than Hindu men. .. . .
1 treatment 1 solution 😆😆😆
JAI HINDU RASTRA 🙏🙏🙏
How come Zakir Naik is still hanging there?
Zakir Naik is a complete moron that's why
Li'l Squeak Agreed.
When people talk about reconciling science and religion, that is only an issue with people who have preconceived ideas, but scientists cannot/should-not have preconceived ideas they must believe the evidence. All scientific models must conform to NATURE or REALITY, If there is any tiny evidence for some unnatural forces then they must include that in their paper and account for it. originally from Karachi Pakistan and Teer Haripur Hazaara, now ex-Muslim Atheist ., ,
I have now listened to Yasir Qadhi's description of his "doubts". What a disappointment!
Whatever Islamic education he had before going to Yale, it was clearly inadequate.
Apparently they had not trained him in any sort of critical thinking, (such as the logic and philosophy textbooks that used to be a part of Islamic education); they had only taught him to follow orders and to repeat what he had been told. He did not have te confidence to investigate anything for himself, but was content to see what choices others had left for him.
Western scholars of Islam say some of the silliest things imaginable -- it is frankly, idiotic to doubt that Islam originated in Mecca, yet that is a doubt these Orientalists keep peddling -- but Dr. Qadhi apparently had no idea how to deal with such matters. He had neither the training, nor the mentality, nor the zeal for independent investigation to deal with some very stupid ideas from the Orientalists
Dr, Qadhi's response to his doubts was very disappointing. In his place, Imam Ghazali, may Allah be pleased with him, would have said "I want knowledge of the reality of things; hence, I must first seek to grasp what knowledge is." You can read about Imam Ghazali's journey from that point on in "Deliverance from Error". www.aub.edu.lb/fas/cvsp/Documents/Al-ghazaliMcCarthytr.pdf
Instead of undertaking his own journey to certainty, as Imam Ghazali did, Dr. Qadhi has made himself -- along with other Muslims -- a target for attacks from mediocre frauds like Abdullah Sameer, who nobody can even prove was ever a Muslim to begin with. He just assures us he was -- in his effeminate-sounding high-pitched voice -- yet nobody can testify to seeing him in a mosque on a Friday. I'm not even convinced that woman who appears with him was ever his wife -- she always manages to smirk on camera as if she was having fun with some secret.
but brother Sameer this is what I found in another video explaining what he really meant-
"A response to an over simplistic misrepresentation that Yasir Qadhi has 'doubts with regards to Islam being the truth.' Why was not the video of the statement that Yasir Qadhi has 'doubts' cut and pasted from this lecture? In this lecture he explains these 'doubts' in a comprehensive and intelligent way.
Additionally, if one examines other lectures that Yasir Qadhi has given, one will find that each of the other 'reasons why Yasir Qadhi is wrong' are also thoroughly and intelligently explained. "
Obviously Yasir Qadhi is still a believer. He has put his doubts aside. The point of his video is not that he has left Islam, just that studying the evidence has put holes into his faith
thnk u, are u sure about the leaked email, is it really his email and what was his statement after this leak. By "Doubt" did he mean "doubt in Islam".
One thing you agnostic should remember that there is a creator who has created the universe and if he can do that he can create a simple creature like Adam and Eve. If you don’t believe in Islam other religion saying saying the same thing.
Because Islam copied from them.... They all are stupid
Not true. Hinduism, Buddhism, Jainism, Chinese Folk Religion dont share such values - so 40% of Humanity do not believe in creator.
Who created creator? Where he stay inside or outside the universe? What is the purpose of creating universe? Why creator wanted to crate Adam, Eve, Dinosaurs etc? When, where and how did you met the creator?
Perween Khan if the creator can create himself.....the universe can also create itself!
Many people who convert to Islam or revert back to Christianity is because religious organizations provide a sense of community, comradely, fellowship and a sense of belonging. These powerful emotional needs are fulfilled, even if religions are not historically and scientifically accurate or just myths. "ignorance is a bliss" Matrix-quote., ,
A scholar in any religion is the same as a scholar in Zues or Odin or any other myth. Choosing to major in theology or becoming in scholar in religion is like marrying your kidnapper, because you are becoming an expert in myths you were brainwashed in as an innocent child. originally from Karachi Pakistan and Teer Haripur Hazaara, now ex-Muslim Atheist,, ,
Wow shocking statement from prominent Islamic scholar!!!
He showed us that he did not have a solid Islamic education before going to Yale.
@@omarmirza9957
Why do you believe that, could you explain?
Have you considered that his credentials show that he has a very good education in this, and that he is actually correct?
It fits my own experience.
I myself often have sincere, respectful conversations about islam & mohammed with people who believe that, and they almost always leave the conversation once we start talking about basic facts about islam & mohammed and the belief whether or not the voice in his head which forced** itself upon him "came from God & was true" or did not.
And then they always say "oh, the others where not true Muslims".
So that's my experience.
**What kind of a character forces himself on another, for starters?
@@omarmirza9957
I'm NOT saying you should be different or must agree. I'm just saying that I can't agree with what you claimed about his education or understanding, and why.
@@pebblepod30 A solid Islamic education is meant to give one a grounding in the philosophical foundations of knowledge of the religion, such that one can handle the kinds of baseless doubts in which modern academics indulge. This was the domain of the traditional science of kalam, which apparently Dr. Qadhi did not master or study in any depth -- otherwise he wuld not be in this situation.
Omar Mirza
He can not digest bull shit.
We don't need proof that the Quran has been preserved. We need proof that Abdullah Sameer was even a Muslim to begin with. That's the only matter on which I have serious doubts: who is this guy who claims he was once a Muslim?
He was lol. There’s soooo much proof
Just so you know, Islam has a God who protects it. And your negative opinions about Islam will never affect the strong heart of a true believer who has faith in Allah. Every comment I read about your ignorance and idiotic arguements you fling only increases my faith towards Allah and help me unite with my brother Muslims against the true enemies of Islam. And don't you dare give false claims about Sheikh Dr. Abu Ammaar Yasir Qadhi!
Excellent work man...love from India
@@rr8966 Islam ke kelaf he oo
Analogies to Adam and Eve are found in many other cultures, with several fancy details... it indicates the limited knowledge people of those days possessed and somehow made up a tale to silence the many questions kids ask.
Yasir can no longer live with his false teachings of islam ...
Its better for him to leave islam or just silently move away from Islam.
Peace be to all my brothers and sisters.
Amen
I don’t see any evidence for anything un-natural, therefore I am not convinced that there is anything unnatural or supernatural like magic, ‘jadoo’, spirits, ghost, ‘jins’, ‘rooh’ and gods . originally from Karachi Pakistan and Teer Haripur Hazaara, now ex-Muslim Atheist , , ,
He never had faith he studied at yale University.
before Shabir Ally said that quran was preserved word for word, letter for letter and dot for dot but now even Shabir Ally is changing his narration that there's some quran version. Thanks Abdullah Sameer and Abdullah Gondal.
Who Wrote the Quran? What Sources Were Used?.
ruclips.net/video/-SGzYrGzBlA/видео.html
Qur’anic Dilemma:
If Allah revealed the Quran through supposedly Jibreel, then the Quran is Jibreel’s word, not Allah’s.
Then, who is this Injeel who choked Muhammad?
Who wrote any of the chapters of the Quran? Present your CLEAR proof from the Quran itself! Otherwise, it’s just a Man-Concocted Book.
I love him
Did you keep a copy of that transcript? The link you gave is to an islammic run page so unsurprisingly the person that originally posted it deleted it. It seems your screenshot is all that is left?
It's been scrubbed from the internet. I'll give it another go and try to find and report back.
+Abdullah you should have saved it.. It was probably scrubbed because ex muslims used it, it's obvious with something like that to save it. At least you got two screenshots so got some of it which is more than most did though still very silly and careless of you.
Christians are better in this kind of realm.. they know their Bible has holes here and there and yet still bind to it. As a muslim, I find that my interpretation toward the Qur'an varies over time.
He is headed to the same road that free thinkers like Hassan Radwan ended up in.
He is way too smart to be in Islam.
Hey Sameer, appreciated content as always. But I fear for Yasir Qadhi's life. What do you think, will he be killed? Just curious. 😟
l Anonymous I
yes there is a very high possibility. When they cannot convince a person to remain they will try to finish them off silently eliminating, their classic method is poisoning be careful from taking drinks and food.
A man who reads tge Quran is a muslim, a man who understands the Quran is an ex- muslim, just ask Dr. Y.Qadi
Everybody keeps saying he studied in Yale and his faith was shaken but no one says what was the information that made him question Islam.
There might be an after life. Happiness in this life can never be attained or least likely. Lets humble ourselves and ask God for guidance.
And if it is not, and this life is all we have? Do you realize the damage and harm you would have done?
How to believe/trust?. How to believe what books/people say or write? Firstly, we have to find which religion is truth/true/right. How? We must have same definition or meaning of the truth/true/right. We must use same method to determine the truth/true/right. Believe => claim = test/check = see. This is normally practice by everybody when we buy/accept something/good which is expensive from other people(we see or we do not see).
Example: We buy a black pen in the shop was produced/manufactured by Marker(do not see) cost around 10K USD. Producer/Manufacturer(do not see) claim, It is a black pen. The salesperson(can see) also claim, it is a black pen. Outside (can see), the apparent is black in colour. Inside(ink, can not see), we not sure, it is black or blue or other colour. So, we have to test/check it. Take white paper and write to it to confirm it. It is black. When I see, it is black. It is true/right. I believe/trust it. So, I buy/accept it without any doubt. If you do not want to test/check, it is up to you. It is your money. It is your life. Our life is only one chance given by god(can not see). When we die, we see the truth, we can not go back in this world(can see). It is too late. I obey what Allah say in Al Quran surah Al asr (The Time) 103(30): recommend one another to the truth. If everybody can see god and his power, there is only one religion. No free will. Have to ask permission, when to do something. Everybody fear to god. Everybody have to obey the command/law/rule from that god only. No arrogant people/man. Man become humble. like plant, bee, animal, moon, sun, stars. For sure this world is peacefully.
Our faith is very expensive.Please open Al Quran Surah Al Hujurat 49: 6. O who believe! If a Fasiq (liar-evil person) comes to you with and news, verify it, lest you should harm people in ignorance, and afterwards you become regretful for what you have done. Please open Bible John 4:1. Beloved, do not believe every spirit, but test to see whether they are from God, for false prophets have gone out into the world. We test and verify the claim/message words of god from Bible (can see), Torah (can see), Al Quran(can see), and other religion books(can see). We must get/see same result(claim=test/check=see) or not. God(can not see) create man(can see). Man worship god. Question: How is god create man? What Method? God create man from ground dust(Torah,Bible, Quran) or man rib(Torah, Bible,Quran) or woman only(Bible,Quran) or Nutfah(mix drop of male (sperm) and female sexual(female egg cell/ova) discharge)-Quran, 1440 years ago, they did not see it, but now, we can see it by using electron microscopy. Or other religion books or other book?. We do testing/experimenting/checking to verify it, by using these method to create man. Everybody can test/experiment/check, verify and see it. Which method can create/produce man?.Answer: The claim/message/words of god in Al Quran is truth/true/right.
Conclusion: Certainly, we can create man by this method (claim by Al Quran). Al Quran is truth/true/right. Allah create man. Man belong to Allah. Man have to obey Allah rule/law. Prophet Muhammad s.a.w was the last prophet sent by Allah to us. This religion is truth/true/right. So, we have to believe/trust it . Please, read Al Quran and think. You get the answer. Sorry, my English is not very good.
As george Carlin said education does not make you think for yourself
Important point to mention. Yasir Qadi is a Salafi/Wahabi. They are a sect who came 200 years ago with their own ideology (influenced by Britain and Zionists). They hold blasphemous beliefs that totaly contradict Islam and have broken off from the main stream Sunni Islam, this includes the Saud Family and the heresey they are teaching in their universities. Understand people that there are 73 sects in Islam. And only 1 will be riteous and that is the main body Ahle sunna wa al jamaat. Yasir Qadi is not from thr main body. And it is clearly stated in our books that when one leaves the main body and joins with the heretics then he loses his faith. And this is EXACLY what has happned.
Few loose faith and it’s been going on beginning of the time. Most importantly, what is your purpose in life,When the life is going to end.
Most important what is the truth.
Truth matters but yeah believing things which makes your life good is good
Is the Quran A Plagiarised book?
Why are you reading a plagiarised book? The quran is 70% copied stories that existed before Islam!
For example:
The story of Abraham being thrown into the fire & Solomon talking to ants come from the jewish Talmud !
The Talmud was written after Jesus time! And was never accepted as the word of God neither by Jews or Christians! It is simply commentaries by jewish priests with jewish myth!
Muhammad heard jews talk about these stories & put them into his quran without knowing that it came from a fake source !
The story of Jesus talking as a baby & making clay birds alive & St. Mary being under a palm tree all come from the Fake gnostic gospels!
These gospels were written from 150 AD to around 500 AD!
Way too late to be authentic!
And the Christian church never really accepted them because they were obviously fake! Even people at the time did not consider them real!
Muhammad heard them from the heretical Christians around him & put them into his quran without knowing that they come from a fake source !
The story of the men in the cave, is a Christian myth story written about 300 years before Islam! It never happened! It's just myth!
The story of Zul Al Qarnien was a popular legend that was known from before Islam!
Most muslim scholars say it's Alexander the Great. And the quran says that he was a good man & a good muslim!
But history shows that he was a wicked pagan man, a polytheist, & a drink! And we never found the people who live next to the muddy spring that the sun sets in! Nor did we ever find that iron gate or mountain!
Just pure myth!
There are other stories that also have their origins in things that existed before Islam!
The quran is not pure Arabic as it falsely claims!
It has MANY Syriac & Aramaic words, a greek word and at least one Coptic word!
The people around Muhammad were correct in accusing him of copying "tales of the ancients"!!
Because that's exactly what he was doing!
All these fake stories got mixed up with corrupted stories from the Bible with some of Muhamad life & made into fancy Arabian poetry!
And that's how he brainwashed 7th century Arabian pagans and that's how he brainwashed the entire islamic nation up to today!!
1- Muhammad lived with Jews & Christians & pagans & others long before becoming a prophet! Surely he must have talked, done business & argued about religion & other things!
That's what people do!
That's how he would have been exposed to these stories!!
(Perhaps this "waraka ebn nofel" told Muhammad some of these stories)!!
2- When he becomes a prophet, he tells them these stories! They tell him we already know them! & we reject you as a prophet!
And accuse him of telling tales of the ancients!
3- In modern times, we discovered many manuscripts that have all of these quranic stories in their original form!! And they date from way before islam !
MUHAMMADAN PLAGIARISM EXPOSED.
Here is where some of those supposed Allah's revelations as found in Qur'an came from:
Many of the stories in the Qur'an come from the Jewish Talmud, the Midrash, and many apocryphal works. This was pointed out by Abraham Geiger in 1833, and further documented by another Jewish scholar, Dr. Abraham Katsh, of New York University, in 1954 (The Concise Dictionary of Islam, p. 229; Jomier, The Bible and the Quran -- Henry Regency Co., Chicago, 1959, 59ff; Sell, Studies, pp. 163ff.; Guillaume, Islam, p. 13).
1. The source of Sura 3:35-37 is the fanciful book called The Protevangelion's James the Lesser.
2. The source of Sura 87:19 is the Testament of Abraham.
3. The source of Sura 27:17-44 is the Second Targum of Esther.
4. The fantastic tale that G-d made a man "die for a hundred years" with no ill effects on his food, drink, or donkey was a Jewish fable (Sura 2:259ff.).
5. The idea that Moses was resurrected and other material came from the Jewish Talmud (Sura 2:55, 56, 67).
Allahmdulilah daily more and more people are converting to islam esp the women from west .😊
Due to internet We can read original translation of Quran. So the more people read it , the more people left islam also..
Iblees was the greatest of the scholars. If he can show disbelief in Allah, then anyone can. Knowledge can't always protect your deen. None of the statements made by Yasir Kadhi shows his disbelief. Doubts are natural to human heart. Arabic word for heart is "Qalb" which means constantly changing. So it is the nature of human heart. He will find strength back in his deen God willing.
Miraculous Preservation of the Quran: Burying the Myth.
ruclips.net/video/lH6M-iLVcKM/видео.html
The Qr'an,Sunnah and Islamic history demonstrate that true Muslims think and ask questions.Islam advocate seeking evidence to establish the truth.The story of Prophet Ibraheem-'alayhissalam-and his pondering over the cosmos,reflections,inferences,etc is well known.Also his rational criticism of his people's false worship is mentioned in details in the Qur'an.Islam demands that believers should think,reason and come to conclusions based on evidence.Islam does not forbid doubts arising from genuine inquiries but encourage the pursuit right answers to satisfy the mind and tranquil the heart.The story of Al-Imaam Abu Haamid Al-Ghazali is instructive in this leading to his writing of "Al-Munqidh Minad-Dalalah" (ie Deliverance from Error".
Even the Prophet Muhammad-peace be upon him-by way teaching his Ummah was told ask those that are familiar with revealed books if he is doubt that he is a recipient of revelation.He replied by saying "I am not in doubt and and as such I will not ask".Here is verse (Qur'an 10:94):
"If thou wert in doubt as to what We have revealed unto thee, then ask those who have been reading the Book from before thee: the Truth hath indeed come to thee from thy Lord: so be in no wise of those in doubt."
He was not told to ignore any doubt,say "I aoodhubillaah,I believe in Islam,I will never leave islam,etc" as Sameer joked irresponsibly in one of his videos deriding himself thinking he is jeering at the believers to his own damnation.May Allaah guide and rescue him.
However,there is another kind of doubt that is not rooted in genuine research and desire for truth but rather to justify the worshiping base desires,drudging the truth,arrogant obduracy and spiritual and psychological attack by the Evil One-Shaytaan-may he be eternally cursed.It is this later one that rather requiring seeking Allaah protection and du'aa.
I can be reached God-willing at:
alltruthseekers@gmail.com
Sallam, Yasir & Zakir don’t make critics against each other. Both of you made great Dawah to the world. Allah bless both of you👍
cc:Zakir
And if you are in doubt about what We have sent down upon Our Servant [Muhammad], then produce a surah the like thereof and call upon your witnesses other than Allah, if you should be truthful.
But if you do not - and you will never be able to - then fear the Fire, whose fuel is men and stones, prepared for the disbelievers.
The Majestic Qur'an 2:23-24
He is a well articulate and highly intelligent person.
God is shining a light in that dark place where he has been lost for too long.
Go towards the light without fear Qadi Sir and bring others with you too.
he is e a liar, because in the same email it says "He is not saying the 'recitation' is not preserved, but he is saying that some elements of the recitation have some human influences." and he said that Qadi doubts the preservation!!
and also said " despite the fact that he repeatedly stated that he was only posing certain questions and the fact that he refrained from making any claims about the preservation of the Quran." so he does not doubt the preservation but rather some elements in recitation
Ahmed Gamal
But he is admitting that part of it is man-made therefore is not the exact copy of the eternal word of God.
see, the man is still teaching what he was teaching.
Ahmed Gamal
Qadi is a very intelligent person and knows how to use diplomacy to put his point across and not get into trouble for that. I have to applaud his way with words.
Let the man do what he wants...it's between him and his creator.
Only God is the author and finisher of our faith.
Islam will dies without lies!
Yeah yeah yeah🙄
If you know Islam and a sane person, you'd reject it.
Very interesting video
@Abdullah Sameer, that is called cognitive dissonance. For Yasir, he's still in denial out of fear (penalties for blasphemy) plus Islam is his gravy train and his only claim to fame. So he has to milk his faith to the fullest. Buuuut....what good it is for a man to gain the whole world but lose his soul (Matthew 16:26.
Agreed.
Christianity is straight bullshit too.....
Patrick Bwibo .yeah and you worship that wich told you to worship something else. "Numbers .god is not human.nor such that is born through human. (God is unseen you cannot see god.bible .messiah says the one who has sent me bears witness of me of whom ye have neither heard his voice or seen his shape at any time . Now ask yourself was messiah son of mary'am seen at all times ? Yes .his voice heard ? Yes . It is god alone who you cannot see or hear.bible .messiah says go into your rooms close the door and pray unto the lord who is ? (UNSEEN) . God 1 not 2not 3- into 1wich is not i say not messiah teaching but a innovation even thrown out by council of nicea .god is 1 and not a human never used such form is not now never will apear in such a form has no parents no offspring and no likenesses.no partners in his divinity his lordship his kingdom. The bible even though it contains certain truths yet much has been re altered .innovations hersy placed within .verses hidden removed twisted .blasphemy placed within against god his attributes re altered slander against his messengers prophets .god is the giver of scripture he requires it not those who are given scripture are called ? (Messengers ) exactly ! .prophet abraham received suhuf scrolls .prophet david received zabur /psalms.prophet moses received taurath .prophet muhammad quraan "prophet esa messiah received (injeel/gospel ) .god prays not but all pray to god.those pray who are powerless who have a dependency who require help .bible .he messiah went a little further fell on his face and prayed .prophet muhammad is the last messenger of god prophisied various passages verses in bible his name his identity his location his description his lineage all given in bible.song of songs 5-16 songs of solomon .isiah . (Google mt sela mentioned in bible its location.research who kedar is .
Dinosaurs ruled the Earth for 150 million years?
@Max Ross, those feeble arguments have been refuted here: facebook.com/AnsweringChristHaters
I will wait for a few days, and read the comments after a week or so. There is going to be lot of fireworks :)). I hope Sameer does not disapprove or remove any comment.
Abdullah Sameer, Islam isn't true, but God IS.
You are still on the path of knowledge. Perhaps in the Qur'an the literalness of the creation of Adam is overemphasised, but the real miracle of his creation is in the LOVE of the work.
Quran say- means calema do u know well
There is no god except allah!
@@mohammadahmad385 maybe you should look at the God of the Bible
I'm a Christian who as most, was once fully indoctrinated into the ideology of Evolution but I'm today a Creationist. Yet do not hate, will not mock nor do I wish to force anyone to believe what I believe as does Islam, and many Evolutionists.
Karl Munford why tho
islam doesn"t force anyone stupid you are just brainwashed
Islam doesn't do any of these things. I'm not sure where you got this from.
I really wanna learn or know what is taught at Yale and Havard about Islam... I wanna know what these Syubuhat are:(
My roommate in during my undergrad was a student of Islamic History and he believes that Quran has never been changed for a single words. I saw his notes but I surprisingly found that those were hateful.
What the Sana'a Manuscript Tells Us About Today's Quran.
ruclips.net/video/XvPMDyBlUPA/видео.html