Lt Gen Raj Shukla Explains Israel-Hamas War, What’s Happening Around the World We Should Worry About
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 11 сен 2024
- Lieutenant General Raj Shukla, PVSM,YSM, SM, ADC is a retired General Officer of the Indian Army who served as the General Officer Commanding-in-Chief of the Army Training Command (GOC-in-C ARTRAC). He assumed office on 1 May 2020, succeeding Lt Gen P C Thimayya. He superannuated on 31 March 2022.
Shukla is an alumnus of Uttar Pradesh Sainik School Lucknow , National Defence Academy Khadakwasla Pune and Indian Military Academy. Shukla was commissioned into the Regiment of Artillery in December 1982. He has also attended the Defence Services Staff College, the Higher Defence Management Course at the College of Defence Management and the National Defence College.
Raj Shukla has commanded a Medium Regiment in the Eastern theatre as part of a Mountain Division. He later took the regiment to the Desert as part of a Strike Corps. He has also commanded an Infantry brigade in Counter-insurgency operations and an infantry division in the Kashmir Valley, along the Line of Control. He is a qualified aviator and has flown along the borders in Sikkim and in the North-East.
In his staff appointments, Shukla has served as the General Staff Officer, Grade I (GSO-I) of an infantry division as well as two tenures in the Military Operations directorate at Army Headquarters. He has also served in instructional appointments in the School of Artillery and the Indian Military Training Team in Bhutan.
On 5 July 2018, Shukla took command of the X Corps at Bhatinda from Lt Gen P C Thimayya. After an year's stint at the helm of X Corps, he relinquished command on 30 July 2019, handing over to Lt Gen Ajai Singh. He subsequently took over as the Director General Perspective Planning (DGPP) at Integrated Headquarters of the Ministry of Defence.
On 1 May 2020, Shukla took over as the General Officer Commanding-in Chief Army Training Command from Lt Gen P C Thimayya.
Shukla has been a Research Fellow at the Institute for Defense Studies and Analyses and a visiting fellow at the Centre for Land Warfare Studies.
He can be reached at : / gen_rajshukla
We can be reached at: / vaibhavup65
.
If You liked the Video, Kindly Support Us:
Paytm & Google Pay: 9118410704
paypal.me/defe...
/ vaibhavsingh
If You liked the Video, Kindly Support Us:
Paytm & Google Pay: 9118410704
paypal.me/defensiveoffence
patreon.com/VaibhavSingh
🥰
Please Sir English Thora kam bola kro .
India supplies weapons to Israel
Zionist killed thousands of innocent
Arunachal Pradesh part of china
❤
@@DefensiveOffence please invite Rajeev Krishna Sharma..
Why so anti israel... #Israel will come out with solutions.. At any cost..!!! The question is on India.. It's already DAR-UL-HARAb What India could have make.. if JIHAD will start LIKE KASHMIR IN INDIA... So called 25Cr population still mention as minority in india.. By Stupid leadership of Maulana MODI gone be the ever blunder forever
आज के टाइम अगर अंग्रेज भारत पर अपना कब्जा बरकरार रखते, बहुत से चाटुकार बुजदिल अंग्रेजो का साथ देते और बोलते, they have right to defend, कब्जा किया हुआ है तो किया हुआ,
और एक बात आप समझ ले के ukrain और इसराइल ये युद्ध हार चुके है चाहे कुछ भी हो
The best thing about this talk is Vaibhav's ability to listen rather than talk.
इजराइल अगर अपने दम पर लड़ रहा होता तो कबका हार चुका होता है अमेरिका साथ है तो इतने दिन टिक पाया
Har to ab chuka hai lekin America sath nahi hota to Israel ka wajood hi nahi hota
It's always pleasure to listen Lt Gen Shukla sir's insights about geopolitics.
अल्लाह फलस्तीन और हमास और मुस्लिम और हुती और सारे मुजाहिदीन की हिफाजत और मदद फरमाए आमीन
Worthy to note that ....we are in peace ,we must develop ourselves.
It's always a great experience to listen to Gen. Shukla. This proves that our soldiers and commanders are still working for the defence of the motherland. Through such talks they enlighten us on the fore coming dangers for us.
Jai Hind
A
A
A
Abhi naandan yaad hai
@@Arsikhan-f6eparliament m tange kaap rhi thi. Yaad h??
ਜਨਰਲ ਸਾਹਿਬ ਨੇ, ਬਹੁਤ ਵਧੀਅਾ ਜਾਣਕਾਰੀ ਦਿਤੀ ਹੈ., ਨਾ ਕਿਦੂਜੇ ਬਖਸ਼ੀ ਵਰਗੇ, ਮੂੰਹਫਟ, ਜਨਰਲ??❤❤❤
Even though my opinion has no weight, I still want to express it. Vaibhav Sir will understand my point. Mostly it is said by senior officials of Indian Army that they are with Israel but the strategy of their army (IDF) is proving to be wrong. I don't know why Indians do not know or they deliberately do not want to accept that no kind of army can capture Gaza because Hamas has the full support of common Palestinians. Common Palestinians are Hamas. You are not fighting with the people only, you are basically fighting with the ideology. In Kashmir so many Indian Soldiers give their lives so that peace can be maintained in the area. But I am 100% sure that if tomorrow If we remove our Army from there, Bloodshed will happen again, because Indians do not want to acknowledge that This Is an ideological war.
Do we Pagan Mushriqs understand what you said? We still vote for Satkari Nokri
Rightly said. And it is matter of time that the events of Kashmir are going to occur on Pan Bharat basis!!
Everyone knows this but you can't say this in public.
@@jitujitu9157 They want to do it but never will be able to do it.. As u know almost all military is Hindu and in times of such situation.. Chain of command doesn't matter.
Let me tell you one important thing about the community you are blaming here, As a Muslim we can give our life and soul if you respect us, but the way Israel and Indian RW are behaving with Muslims, this isn’t going to work in a long run, neither Israel nor Indian RW ideology has the potential to keep on fighting this war until the last Muslim standing but even the last Muslim has this potential to keep on fighting this war until he is standing. The only way for a better future is mutual respect, you can not win by making Muslims your enemy. Learn from Russia and China, they tried to be against Muslims as much they could but now they have changed their strategy and are accommodating Muslims in their society and giving them respect.
This guy doesn’t realize that Kashmir is at same state as Gaza .
Nothing works with community .
Only answer is behave same way as they do
And some clowns among us wants you people to come back. i don't know how they can trust a community which used to occupy all the higher posts and suck the blood of kashmiri muslims before 1990's with the help of india.
Even that doesn't work because these people are sadists they don't look at the World in a way we do , so the only way is to stop radicalisation by infiltrating their religious institutions and change content
ये इनको अभीतक समझ मे नही आया हे इफ्तार करवाने वाली फौज हे भाई।
I 100% agree.
Your surname shows what you or your family have faced in Kashmir of Rishi Kashyap. When a common man knows what Kashmir is, then why this retired army official is trying to be politically correct?? He knows it, but is hesitant to speak owing to reputation, having Muslim friends (who at first instance will side with other Muslims and dump him) etc.
We must learn from Muslims regarding uniting against infidels like us.
A man who says: "Aspataal pe operation hona chahiye" is seriously and sincerely not A human in any way.
Because you didn't listen carefully. Unhone aage kha k civilian nahi marne chahiye. Agar dushman hospital m chhipa h to obviously operation hoga hi.
I think such type of discussion related to international and national issues should be arrenge every week ❤jai hind
India and West wale china items pe mems bnate hai...lekin jab critical analysis karte hai to sabse aage Nikal rha hai spaces, technology, medicine, electric, microchip, internet etc
I want to ask a question
Sir said that dil pr dimag dono par control
And comparing Indian army in Kashmir with idf in gaza
It's ok apne sab kuchh compare kiya how our army operate
Or unki kaise bluntly operate kr rahi hai
But kya apne casualties compare ki humne kitne apne jawan khoye hai or idf ne poore opration mai kitne khoye abhi tak ?
Unki policy minimum loss ke sath opration krna hai
Hamari priorities alag hai hum to apne jawano ke balidan gin hi nahi rhe hai
Achivements to gina rahe hai but kis cost par uska dhyan hi nahi hai
Idf gaza me 70 ton ke tank ke bina nahi ghus rahi hai unka ek javan bhi evan armed personal vehicle jo rpg ke hamle bhi jhel leta hai usko Tak bhi vo battlefield me nahi ja rahe ..
Jaaega to sirf markava 70 ton ka....tab jake vo apni casualty ko kam rakh paae hai....
Ab aap batao kya kashmeer me indian army ka ek ek senik sirf Arjun tank me hi ghumega Kashmir me ???
Agar haan to fir har 5 soldiers par apke hisab se ek Arjun tank kashmir me indian army ko provide karane chaiye..aapki akal se...
Gandu force h 😂
@sumitghosh2778 Israel ki Jo hawa thi vishav m Jo uska Naam th wo hamas hizbullah n khatam kr diya Israel diaper force ladne s inkaar kr rhi h mere bhai
Sir ji Gen Sagat sir and FM Manekshaw episode is still pending 😢
जय हिंद वैभव सर🙏❤️🇮🇳❤️🙏
Let me be very clear, sir. I think you didn't talk about the occupation by Israel state.
57:00
Valid point by vaibhav
General forgot about the terrorist who called his father and told him that he killed 10 people in esarael and what his father told him ? He blessd him and told him that he did a great work .
The majority of this community has jehadi mind set then how to decide who is innocent and who is culprit ?
Was Bhagat Singh condemned or congratulated after he killed the British official?
People like you are highly problematic because of your communal and castcism mindset .
You don't know meaning of Jehad and start misusing it .
This communal tendency will cost India dearly .
You never talk of sanatani terrorism , you never ponder over the disloyalty of hindus towards nation and loyalty of muslims towards the nation .
In last 10 years all people arrested for spying for China and Pakistan against their own country were hindus none was muslim , even then pointing finger towards muslims loyalty .
Communal tool adopted at present for gaining power will be existential threat of country .
Change mindset be inclusive and just .
जय हिन्द जय भारत वंदेमातरम 🚩
Excuse me sir every one is neglecting the moral upper hand of the axis of resistance as u rightly pointed that what our army did in Kashmir.Israel knows only use of discriminate power which has created backlash even in universities of USA and Europe .
I m confident that Iran will never produce WMDs bcoz according to Iranian leadership it is morally not allowed.So Iran and its allies has moral ground whereas Israel is losing this ground day by day.
Thank you for a wonderfull and informative podcast. Vaibhav ji , Aap ka Tripund miss kar rahe hain sriman.
Israel is fighting alone with all the communist and Islamic world with Hamas. At least give that credit to Israel. War is unpredictable. Israel is doing the best can be done. Israel will achieve its objective.
Usa Europe lobby supporting with weapons and everything
@@persiancat2921yes, Israel is not alone, nato nation's weapon and boots are always there from the birth of Israel.
@@zahidtambe4011 yes
Iran is fighting alone against qrabs india europe america
Ha ha ha jo are tge biggest joker
In fact is a damn shame Israel can not defeat a resistance group inspite Israel is getting lot of weapons from USA almost 50 years back to back
Your take is very STUPID
Israel did not say it will finish Hamas in a few days. It always said it will take a long time. Such operations take long. Look in your own background
Israeli expansionism through genocide and evacuation of locals to settle zionists is supported by US and West and people fighting for their land are treated as terrorists , what a mean ideology ?
वैभव भाई राम राम प्रणाम ⚘️🌷🙏🙏
Vibhav Ji major Gourav Araya Ko invite kro Bahut Din hoo gye sir ko dekhe aap ke sath
Listening to Gen Shukla is a pleasure always.
It is like classical music listening to Shukla sir! A very balanced and honest view indeed.
Jai Bhagwan Parshuram!❤
General Shukla is a treat to listen!
Eagerly waiting for the shukla sir😊😊
Always delight and honour to hear from Lt. gen. Raj Shukla sir.
Plays out like a smash hit blockbuster.Found it so interesting and informative.The Generals verbosity laced with military wisdom is a tour de force .A must watch .
SIR. HOW THE ISRAEL HAS ALL THE RIGHTS TO DEFEND HERSELF IN AN ILLGALLALLY OCCUPIED LAND OF FALASTIN ?.DO YOU FIND ISRAEL ON THE WORLD MAP BEFORE 1948. ?
HRA, HSRA, INA vs British Raj
I literally ignored all the news or update regarding israel-hamas war and thought it's a war very far away from India why to give so much importance 🤔.
But then this so called general made me feel how much correct is IDF😂😂😎.
Invite him to tell the stories only, he is best in that🤭🤫.
First time I saw a comment section with full of valid questions😎👍. Never seen like that before..good to see it🤘.
Hon'ble Shukla sir has been always very informative. Thank you for your great insight on geopolitics, MGBU, JAI HIND 🇮🇳 🙏🏻
Radhe radhe bhai
Great episode, बहुत समय से इसकी प्रतिक्षा थी,next episode,Mr.R.K Sharma🎉
My favourite show DO..,..but sorry to say where is Retd. Maj. Gaurav Arya
Major gaurav Arya is not so much knowledgeable
I can listen to general sir entire day how lucid transparent & sophisticated
Israel defense minister we don't wanna war with hizbullah,but facing a peoples without arms all they are brave and confident,look like tide change
This gentleman's urdu is so classic and genuine.❤
Salute both for good discussion.
Respected sir, If Israel has right to defence for one day than why Palestine hasn't right of defence since 75 years cruelty?
Arey kinse puch rhe ho
Apko lgta hai ye log muslims ka sth denge 😂😂😂
Brilliant ❤❤
Important note. We must develop ourselves to be independent of the West...do not rely on western jet engines, western OS, western phones, western Sm
❤ INDIA 🇮🇳 ♥️
MR. GEN SIR , 💪BEYOND OUR THINK TANK, 🤔,
AT ANY COST , WE HAVE
TO BEYOND 🇨🇳 CHINA ...
❤ HAR HAR MAHADEV ❤
Sir ek point aur , tunnel warfare ko leke kisi military power ne koi specific policy nahi banayi hai aur na hi uske specific weapons hai .
Can't understand why they call Palestinian fighters terrorists?
Was Bhahagat Singh a terrorist? If he was a freedom fighter then why Palestinian fighters are not?
Their ideology is freedom - same as Bhagat Singh's.
@@katchraHRA, HSRA, INA vs British Raj
बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद
This man’s English, Hindi and Urdu - so chaste and elegant. Wonderful intellectual. I hope he gets some responsibility in the government.
Jernail Saab…aur kitna hearts and minds karoge Kashmir mein?! Pichle 75 saal se hearts and minds karti rahi bharateeya fauj…kya faayida hua?🤦🏽♂️
Ladna to 20-22 yr olds ko hi hai! Aap to ivory tower mein baithe ho!
Missing Rajeev Krishna Sharma.. Please invite him.
Vo to kadva sach bolte hai viewer's ko psnd nhi aata
He speaks truth
Jai Hind sir 🇮🇳🇮🇳❤️.
Rightly said
Jay hind sar je ❤❤🎉🎉
General Shukla's podcast are always best
Great Geo- Pol show!
Jai Hind Vaibhav Bhaiya...🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
This is so much better than the last couple of episodes
‼️ Pehle China se to apni zameen lelo, dusro par gyaan baad mai dena..🤬
😂😂😂😂
I think the main obstacle for India is burocracy and ambition of the leadership.
We call it audacity issues in CAARMO Inc.
Gen Raj Shukla is great person. ❤
Israel's Gaza problem IMHO is 10x more challenging than India's Kashmir problem.
I am not sure even Modi & IA leadership could have dealt better with this crisis than Netanyahu and IDF leadership if the former found themselves in the latter's shoes.
IDF cannot afford to spill its blood with the ease with which IA does to avoid collateral damage.
IA is 1.3 million strong IDF is 1.6 lakh strong
H pop is 110 cr, J pop is
Come on शेम , शगत .
We wait.
Thanks for deep explained. ....We should support to innocent Palestinian as well as innocent israeli.........
Good analysis sir you have exposed the real situation in Gaza strip
Jai hind
This post was very very good...
All these topics Dhari ki dhari reh jayegi if there is a govt change towards left ..
the bigger question is - we are seeing rise of autocracies and successful but we have kept ourselves locked into a mindset that democracy is the only solution
Very objective analysis!!!
supporting occupying forces IDF against Palestinian freedom fighters HAMAS is just like supporting British Occupying forces on india before 1947 against indian freedom fighters subhas chandrabose ,bhagat singh and others armed struggle against british.israel was created by british on 1948 for european zionist.
HSRA, HRA, INA vs British Raj
Very informative.
Genral saheb aap israel ki wakalat kar rahe hain. 70 saal se israel unke bachcho awor aworto ko maar rahe hain. Unke bare me bhi kuch bataiye
Har Har Mahadev
Jo pahle hi Kah Raha hai main Israel ka samarthak hun vah sahi baat kaise Karega
How can you win the hearts and minds of people with ingrained ideology of destroying others at any cost? Manner of wars have changed where armies don't fight face to face anymore.
Thank you Sir, for your valuable insights 🙏🏻🇮🇳🙏🏻
Respected mahoday Israel Hamas land conflict he hi nahi , this is the clearly ideological problem and bothe side is clear finish tha opponent
Guruji sabse pahali chunouti aarthik sakti banne ki hai,uske baad hi sab kuch posible hai.😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊
वैभव भाई अगले प्रोग्राम में जनरल साहब से पूछना जी के क्या अग्निविर की वजह से भारतीय सेना मजबूत होंगी या नहीं
General is correct in one way, IDF launched the offensive in haste, especially knowing very well the tactics adopted by the Hamas, human shield and operating from hospitals, schools, UN office and in the midst of a housing colony.. in the bargain IDF also lost too many casualties..
❤❤❤❤❤👌👌👌👌👌✌️ JAI HIND
ram ram bhai
How come everyone believes causality figures 40K given by Hamas ? Also PM Netanyahu had said it is going to be a year or more long campaign. Even before Gaza clearance started. So why call it a failure? IDF causalities has been minimal. The ones in IDF opposing defense minister are bigger hardliners and want annexation of Gaza permanently. Be patient and learn from Israel.
We indians havent fought any long war so we only good at doing bakchodi
Jai Hind
Vaibhav Sar ji Tilak Nahin Lagaya
Beautiful ❤️ love this discussion 👍
Can u really win the heart of Muslims I don't think so
Sir sorry listen d whole but track changes from real topic. A comprehensive discussion required on our national defence issues separately. Jai Hind
Very practical, valuable inputs by knowledgeable guest 🎉
Sir.. tilak nhi lgaye hain aaj 🙏
Please bring Bharat Karnad sir as well on the show 🙏🏻
हम क्यों लड़े, प्रधानमंत्री ने संसद में साफ कहां है कि चीन कभी भी हमारी सीमा में नहींघुसा है, *लगता है यह बात भी एक जुमला थी.*
So, His Military mindset says, civilians should protected of enemy nation in the case of War. Excellent!
But, Pakistani population has weapons as well. What you will do if civilians start attacking armed forces.
Day by day, i am able to understand the reason why we are not able to POK and Aksai Chin back.
Vaibhav bhai hum apka DO New dekhte hai but aap isme b video banaya kare please meri apse request samjo jo b Please 🙏🙏
Vaibhav bhai plz request Raj sir for Sam & Sagat podcast… eagerly waiting for it…
gr8 stuff...hope it gets seen by the people who really matter😊