Obviously just one match and Harry had bad draws, but interesting to see that MH2 cards dominated and the banned cards outside of probe were hardly relevant.
@@axvd2105 Decklists also are by far not optimized. As they said it was a very spontaneaus thing. I think for example the new affinity lists with mox or kci with saga and stuff could be a real problem
It was way too much for me. I agree voice over would have been easier to watch, for me at least. I like having interesting lines explained, but not every single decision on the game. Also, having it cut away made it feel somewhere between a reality TV show and trying to watch Crunchy Roll without paying for the service. No offense to the players or anything, just my thoughts.
as someone who doesn't play modern I think the extra detail really helped me understand what was going through their minds and that gave me a lot more entertainment value than if it was just a couple complicated lines being explained or if it was a brief voiceover during the game
@@regular_ian to be clear, I don't suggest the voiceover explanations to be shorter than what they did. I would just prefer a freezed boardstate screen instead of cutaways to people talking, so I can follow what they are saying more easily.
I think the silent MVPs here were the counterspells, a lot of the broken banned cards are a lot less unfair when you have cheaper interaction. I'd add the pitch elementals to the list as well for how good they are as answers.
That was a lot of fun to watch. I would like to see more No Ban List games in the future just to see how broken the format really could be if left unregulated.
Definitely love the video. Kind of crazy that Gab only played one banned card in the games from his deck, git prob. UR decks are so strong, also seemed like a harder match up. Really liked the explanations on decision points. Great video
Would love to have seen some Uro action, with Mystic Sanctuary, Top, Oko, GitProbe, CCommand, Counterbalance, JTMS, Mental Mistep etc. The artifact angle was cute, but clearly not strong enough. Perhaps next time ask to take a current T1 deck and allow banned cards to improve it as building a deck in 1 hour with no meta is quite hard.
i would love to see jeskai phoenix or izzet storm in a banless modern video. I think those decks could be extremely fast and fun with some of the banned cards like: gitaxian probe, faithless looting, rite of flame etc
I get that both of these guys are known for playing the kind of decks they came up with here. Still, in a new format, I would go for the fastest combo deck. Unsure whether that's Hogaakvine with Death Rite Shaman, Blazing Infect or Storm, or maybe even KCEggs (I actually think Hypergenesis is quite a safe unban), but I am surely not playing a control deck in an uncertain meta.
After watching this it would be interesting to see if a deck made of banned cards could even beat a regular modern deck! I propose: MH2 versus the Ban List
I've waited a long time for a solid paper modern or pauper gameplay show, came upon this show about a week ago, and I think it's great! Good fun episode too. The end bit was so corny and I loved it haha.
Looking at the modern banlist, they both probably could have played the good cantrips, like ponder and preodain and the delve big card draw spells, treasure cruise and Dig through time, especially without Merktide in the deck. Expressive Iteration might still be better, though 🤔
I would like to see: No ban list modern VS MH1 and MH2 modern... So you can play any banned card, even if they are in MH1 or MH2, but none of what we can play today of this sets (no ravagan, no elementals, etc). And the other deck can play "normal modern".. Lets see who wins xD
@@dogekage not really a bad take, i mean, obviously you're not going to meet unhappy people with the format, since they don't play it anymore. why play something we don't like?
The camera transitions seemed like they were upside down from the top down view. I thought when it was panned out that they were in opposite seats every time. It took a while to get used to it but at the start it was very jarring.
I'm curious. How do you guys record the midgame through process commentary? They sound so in the moment during it. Do you drag them out of the room mid game to give their thoughts, or is it recorded afterward?
You are allowed to make mana with mana abilities during casting the spell (as opposed to making mana before casting it). Determining the amount of mana you need to pay happens in CR (comprehensive rules) 601.2f. This happens before actually making the mana, which is in CR 601.2g.
You could say that after the match, Harry no longer had any skin in the game. He lost his guts, his vision, and his mind. That game chilled him to the bone.
The rules on casting spells are as follows: declare the spell, declare costs, pay costs (tapping necessary lands, etc). So when you declare the cost of emry, you count the top AND the food token, even though you're sacking the food token, since sacking the food token is step 3. You can see this demonstrated in MTGO especially.
Would have preferred to see decks built around cards that were never legal... Skullclamp.. Full power affinity.. Full power dredge.. (or some decks that use cards that were banned after a month)
This really illustrates to me a thought I've had for a while now. Oko shouldn't have been banned. He's really good, but hardly unbeatable. Infact, he's super easy to play around. WotC just knee-jerk reacted to the card and banned it.
I have no idea why play Goose over Deathrite Shaman if you are in no-banlist anyway. Seems like a no-brainer upgrade, even counting with the oko-food interaction.
can’t believe how ragavan escaped the bans, it’s unreal. it’s only there because it’s a new card and they want to keep selling. also, where are your mental missteps guys.??
@@TehSeksyManz really?? you’re gonna give me the ‘dies to removal’ argument. let’s also unban deathrite, since that also dies to all removal. and mental misstep, since that’s ‘just an answer’ right? anyway, we’ll see in a year when mh2 is really out of the market
@@alexstef6965 Deathrite doesn't have to attack to provide value, also doesn't die to wren and six or lava dart. Mistepp is a fundamentally broken card, that is why it is banned in every fomat except for Vintage, where it is restricted
You could essentially just play Legacy UW miracles in this format. Jace, Top, Ponder, Preordain, Mystic Sanctuary, and miracles. Mental Misstep, Counterspell, and MH2 cards to interact. Seems good.
Honestly at this point, half of the banlist could be unbanned and Ragavan/DRC/elementals/cascade/EI would still be the best cards in the format. At this point Twin is so far from bannable it's funny, Dig and Cruise are not obviously better to be casting than Murktide Regent, Deathrite would not even the best 1-drop in the format, hypergenesis is just worse than footfalls or living end... Obviously a lot of the cards on the banlist would make the format worse even if they wouldn't be overpowered, but it just goes to show how insane MH2 was.
7:20 when he tries to cast emry hes not suppost to as after cracking the food for a mana his artifact count will be back from 2 to 1 no making emry needing 1blue and a colourless to cast no?
17:49 if you try to float the mana from the saga you lose it on the end of your draw step no? Then how is he playing karn for 4 mana with only 3 lands and none floating? Cardmarket thats 2 missplays already
@@anomalieno27 Both of these plays are legal. Sacing the food is in the cost of paying for the spell meaning Emry has the recduced cost. Urzas Saga triggers in your mainphase not drawstep. None are misplays
“Splinter Twins vs Oko” Splinter Twins nor Oko hit the board
Plays no ban list modern : Ragavan is still the best card in the deck
DRC and expressive iteration are insane
Ragavan is absurd and I can't understand how it isn't banned yet.
@@DakonBlackblade2 money. Mh2 ain’t out of print yet
@@DakonBlackblade2 Money
To update everyone here who didn't already know, he's banned now.
Obviously just one match and Harry had bad draws, but interesting to see that MH2 cards dominated and the banned cards outside of probe were hardly relevant.
if Harry had a turn 1 chalice hand on the play, game coulda been pretty different I think! we might have seen Twin come through in that case lol
@@axvd2105 Decklists also are by far not optimized. As they said it was a very spontaneaus thing. I think for example the new affinity lists with mox or kci with saga and stuff could be a real problem
Exact!
After release of MH2 I doubt that we really can justify that most of the banned cards are still in the ban list xd
Back in the day the mono red deck spashed green and blue for Oko
Now simic Oko decks should splash red for Ragavan
Love these! The cut away's explaining decision points is great
I'd prefer voiceovers tbh
Thank you for your comment and support!
It was way too much for me. I agree voice over would have been easier to watch, for me at least. I like having interesting lines explained, but not every single decision on the game. Also, having it cut away made it feel somewhere between a reality TV show and trying to watch Crunchy Roll without paying for the service. No offense to the players or anything, just my thoughts.
as someone who doesn't play modern I think the extra detail really helped me understand what was going through their minds and that gave me a lot more entertainment value than if it was just a couple complicated lines being explained or if it was a brief voiceover during the game
@@regular_ian to be clear, I don't suggest the voiceover explanations to be shorter than what they did. I would just prefer a freezed boardstate screen instead of cutaways to people talking, so I can follow what they are saying more easily.
I think the silent MVPs here were the counterspells, a lot of the broken banned cards are a lot less unfair when you have cheaper interaction.
I'd add the pitch elementals to the list as well for how good they are as answers.
That was a lot of fun to watch. I would like to see more No Ban List games in the future just to see how broken the format really could be if left unregulated.
pr the more regulation we need with oko, haha
You guys really do a great job! I love how this is progressing! Keep going this route.
Big thumbs up!
Thank you! Will do!
Best overlay I've ever seen. Great job!
Wow, thanks!
This channel is getting better and better by the day. Already deserves more attention than it gets atm, but we'll get there soon!
Agreed! Share the videos with everyone!
Definitely love the video.
Kind of crazy that Gab only played one banned card in the games from his deck, git prob.
UR decks are so strong, also seemed like a harder match up.
Really liked the explanations on decision points.
Great video
Glad you enjoyed!
Cardmarket's shelves must be the most organised thing on the planet, I'd have blown my hour of deckbuilding time just looking for the cards
Thank you!
@@CardmarketMagic seriously though how did they manage to physically locate the cards for their decks after coming up with the lists within an hour
@@davidy22 Movie Magic. They came up with the lists within an hour but played much later ;)
@@CardmarketMagic oh ok that makes a good amount of sense
I really like the idea of no MH Modern. I hope you try it out at some point
No banlist modern. Just play cards that came out the last year and wreck everyone.
All the years SCG did the Vs series why could they not figure out this production format? This is excellent.
Would love to have seen some Uro action, with Mystic Sanctuary, Top, Oko, GitProbe, CCommand, Counterbalance, JTMS, Mental Mistep etc. The artifact angle was cute, but clearly not strong enough. Perhaps next time ask to take a current T1 deck and allow banned cards to improve it as building a deck in 1 hour with no meta is quite hard.
the artifact path is actually really strong. you can T1 oko, and idk if youve watched some vintage with oko, but a t1 oko is devastating.
Would love to see some more esper reanimator in modern on cardmarket, with the griefs and solitudes! Love the videos
I plqy esper reanimator! i love the new card tainted indulgence!
@@TheSynisterMinister Haven't tried it in my list yet but it looks great!
Thanks for the idea!
excited to see my boy deathrite shaman in one of the future videos. great videos!
So cool you got gabe nassif come by. love to see pros play in paper and talk about it
That was really cool indeed!
Omg the end was amazing. I love it
All the video is! ;)
i would love to see jeskai phoenix or izzet storm in a banless modern video. I think those decks could be extremely fast and fun with some of the banned cards like: gitaxian probe, faithless looting, rite of flame etc
Good idea, why not?
Especially storm (you got me, combo fan here)
Would love to see more of these types of no-ban Modern!
I get that both of these guys are known for playing the kind of decks they came up with here. Still, in a new format, I would go for the fastest combo deck. Unsure whether that's Hogaakvine with Death Rite Shaman, Blazing Infect or Storm, or maybe even KCEggs (I actually think Hypergenesis is quite a safe unban), but I am surely not playing a control deck in an uncertain meta.
After watching this it would be interesting to see if a deck made of banned cards could even beat a regular modern deck! I propose: MH2 versus the Ban List
I feel like gab should probably have put ponder and cruise into his deck as well as some number of misstep. But I they did only have an hour
Yeah cut the Twin package and just play all the broken blue cards
I've waited a long time for a solid paper modern or pauper gameplay show, came upon this show about a week ago, and I think it's great! Good fun episode too. The end bit was so corny and I loved it haha.
Hope you enjoy it!
Lol the ending was great! Keep up the great vids!
The end was pretty funny 😁
I am at the beginning of the video (deck introduction), so I wonder:
Are there any mental missteps in their decks? :)
Very good video editing. Would love to see that kind of editing on tournament stream
Thanks! They should call us then!
Not too into modern content but the video quality and the editing is good. Subscribed 👌
Welcome aboard!
👑👯 Decklists: bit.ly/3P4m0aP
🎧 Listen to the Midweek Metagame: soundcloud.com/midweekmetagame
would love links to decklist that still work a couple weeks after upload lol
Let's see who dies this time :D
Funny Idea lifeline :D
Also no Ban Modern was fun before and still is fun to watch! 🙂
Cheers
Looking at the modern banlist, they both probably could have played the good cantrips, like ponder and preodain and the delve big card draw spells, treasure cruise and Dig through time, especially without Merktide in the deck. Expressive Iteration might still be better, though 🤔
nah, it's not better than either of those.
More about this kind of content. With different banned list decks
Aaahh... how I've missed, "I'm gonna shock and probe you." in Modern~😈😈😈😈
reluctant "uummmm?" followed imediately by "So this hand is great!"
I would like to see: No ban list modern VS MH1 and MH2 modern...
So you can play any banned card, even if they are in MH1 or MH2, but none of what we can play today of this sets (no ravagan, no elementals, etc). And the other deck can play "normal modern"..
Lets see who wins xD
Also it's very interesting how the new cards dominated so much more than the banned cards!
Woah Gabriel!? Maaaan you guys are throwing everything but the kitchen sink into this channel!
Moral of the story, Ragavan is more Op than Oko
Moral of the story: This is a tiny sample size that doesn't indicate very much.
I’d like to see a no ban dredge game.
Come on, no Oko and Splinter Action? Bring it on! New Round!
Instead of a no ban list Modern, how about we have a no Modern Horizons 2 Modern, Jesus, the banned cards barely did anything.
Modern horizons destroyed modern. This format has become very expensive in addition of being homogenized by mh1/2 cards.
@@abusus75 except for the vast majority of people that actually play modern think its the most fun/ diverse that its ever been
with the exception of perhaps ragavan, most of mh1/2 opened up new archetypes. in particular the pitch elementals have really interesting gameplay
@@abusus75 pretty bad take. Every event I go to people love the new brewing space.
@@dogekage not really a bad take, i mean, obviously you're not going to meet unhappy people with the format, since they don't play it anymore. why play something we don't like?
Never got oko out wow
The camera transitions seemed like they were upside down from the top down view. I thought when it was panned out that they were in opposite seats every time. It took a while to get used to it but at the start it was very jarring.
Awesome video
Glad you enjoyed it!
Harry after the 2-0 had me 💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀
weird seeing harry without his glasses
Man I miss Expressive Iteration what a great card!
Awesome.
Shouldn’t temur be good with oko, drc and uro?
I'm curious. How do you guys record the midgame through process commentary? They sound so in the moment during it. Do you drag them out of the room mid game to give their thoughts, or is it recorded afterward?
Before the game
Nah just kidding, after the game!
Wish there was a lgs near me that had no banlist events.
i dont get it. how did he cast emry on 7:43 ? he sac the food to produce blue, so emry should cost 2 right?
You are allowed to make mana with mana abilities during casting the spell (as opposed to making mana before casting it). Determining the amount of mana you need to pay happens in CR (comprehensive rules) 601.2f. This happens before actually making the mana, which is in CR 601.2g.
did you both forget about misstep?
Git probe with double drc is mad!!
The Oko deck is not in the deck list link :-(
No Ban List Modern
10:22 what song is starting here?
You could say that after the match, Harry no longer had any skin in the game. He lost his guts, his vision, and his mind. That game chilled him to the bone.
how did he cast tomads crypt with chalice out? and man gitaxian probe is so nasty when you get to survail of it everytime...
he didn't. it was put into play with urza's saga.
Idk if im crazy but the mic at the beginning has a ton of echo
No Ponder or Mental Miss ? That doesn´t make any sense - did he forgot about it ? ^^
Yeah splinter twin doesn’t stand up in my opinion
Really curious how he sacked the treasure for blue and cast the emry for 1 with only 1 artifact in play game 1
The rules on casting spells are as follows: declare the spell, declare costs, pay costs (tapping necessary lands, etc). So when you declare the cost of emry, you count the top AND the food token, even though you're sacking the food token, since sacking the food token is step 3. You can see this demonstrated in MTGO especially.
MH2 Clearly a Problem...
Would have preferred to see decks built around cards that were never legal... Skullclamp.. Full power affinity.. Full power dredge.. (or some decks that use cards that were banned after a month)
We do that as well sometimes, for example here where we played hypergenesis:
ruclips.net/video/X_S6WUWDuSI/видео.html
RIP, Harry
why no cast tormod's crypt from grave with emry :(
Unban oko then 😂😂😂
And also splinter twin… It didn’t win a single match 😂😂😂😂
CARL WEAR THAT JACKET EVERY DAY 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Could you please bring some pre modern gameplays to the channel?
Could be great!
Good idea, we will suggest it!
What’s the music in this?
Disturbing lack of Mental Missteps...
this proves that splinter twin doesnt need to be banned anymore
RIP Harry
The best deck in no banlist modern has to be eldrazi
The link doesn’t work :(
Which link? If it's the decklists, I just tested it. It works 🤔
Probe + drc is NASTY good lord I’m all for a smaller banlist but one of those has to be/stay banned
“I’ll chalice on zero.” 15 sec later: tormod crypt for 0
the tormod's crypt was not cast it was put into play with urza's saga
anyone have the song?
This really illustrates to me a thought I've had for a while now. Oko shouldn't have been banned. He's really good, but hardly unbeatable. Infact, he's super easy to play around. WotC just knee-jerk reacted to the card and banned it.
You think it was a knee jerk reaction when he was banned in legacy?
Someone clearly didn't play modern when Oko was in the format, that or this comment is a complete joke
I have no idea why play Goose over Deathrite Shaman if you are in no-banlist anyway. Seems like a no-brainer upgrade, even counting with the oko-food interaction.
Interesting game
to me, this shows how much bans shoudln't be a thing. I hate bans, this was the most interesting game to watch on your channel so far imo.
The reason for the ban is how it warps the meta. You would only be watching the same deck over and over again at tournaments
Mystic Sanctuary Loop (rip) for days. But i bet no banlist modern could be a real format alongside current modern. I'd play both personally.
honestly, I feel like a Leovold variant of the oko deck would have been better
No ban modern best modern
Turns out you don’t need banned cards when you can have a monkey
I am surprised no one is playing brainstorm
can’t believe how ragavan escaped the bans, it’s unreal. it’s only there because it’s a new card and they want to keep selling. also, where are your mental missteps guys.??
Monkey dies to every removal spell ever, that's why it hasn't been banned. It isn't even over represented in the meta game.
@@TehSeksyManz really?? you’re gonna give me the ‘dies to removal’ argument. let’s also unban deathrite, since that also dies to all removal. and mental misstep, since that’s ‘just an answer’ right? anyway, we’ll see in a year when mh2 is really out of the market
@@alexstef6965 Deathrite doesn't have to attack to provide value, also doesn't die to wren and six or lava dart.
Mistepp is a fundamentally broken card, that is why it is banned in every fomat except for Vintage, where it is restricted
Where is mental missep???
no london mulligans??
You could essentially just play Legacy UW miracles in this format. Jace, Top, Ponder, Preordain, Mystic Sanctuary, and miracles. Mental Misstep, Counterspell, and MH2 cards to interact. Seems good.
Seems like Harry has no skin in the game?! XD
Honestly at this point, half of the banlist could be unbanned and Ragavan/DRC/elementals/cascade/EI would still be the best cards in the format. At this point Twin is so far from bannable it's funny, Dig and Cruise are not obviously better to be casting than Murktide Regent, Deathrite would not even the best 1-drop in the format, hypergenesis is just worse than footfalls or living end... Obviously a lot of the cards on the banlist would make the format worse even if they wouldn't be overpowered, but it just goes to show how insane MH2 was.
ragavan has made a clear statement in modern. play interaction or else! its is a broken card!
Chalice on 0 should have countered tormods crypt
7:20 when he tries to cast emry hes not suppost to as after cracking the food for a mana his artifact count will be back from 2 to 1 no making emry needing 1blue and a colourless to cast no?
17:49 if you try to float the mana from the saga you lose it on the end of your draw step no? Then how is he playing karn for 4 mana with only 3 lands and none floating? Cardmarket thats 2 missplays already
@@anomalieno27 Both of these plays are legal. Sacing the food is in the cost of paying for the spell meaning Emry has the recduced cost. Urzas Saga triggers in your mainphase not drawstep. None are misplays
After Arena and Master Duel, I just can't watch in person matches anymore.