if any of u r confused since there’s basically 3 names, Jenny Lind~ the character singing Rebecca Ferguson~ actress who plays Jenny Lind Loren Allred~ actual singer
@@martincisneros8507 stop introducing yourself to people on the internet. YOU CAN'T BE FRIENDS WITH THEM. you did the same thing on the comment above this one. STOP
If there's an Oscar for "Best Lip Sync Performance" this lady should get it. Loren Allred is the actual singer. But Rebecca Ferguson deserves the credit for this performance being in the movie. She knew it was better than she could possibly sing.
This whole scene has to be one of the finest bits of cinema ever. Musical aside, the amount of subtext and narrative is staggering. Truly magical. I utterly love it
Me too! That loud HD stereo sound in a theater went into your ears, down your spine and out your fingers and toes -- consuming your whole body. You just couldn't believe what you were hearing and seeing! A rare cinema moment. The audience in my theater actually applauded along with the audience on the screen. 😲😱👍
@@markmh835 I really wish I had seen this movie in the theater when it first came out. I had so much going on at the time and just didn't get a chance. I ended up renting the DVD a couple of years ago and was absolutely blown away! I watched it over and over again for maybe 2 months! I watched it again earlier tonight. And now here I am at 2am watching "Never Enough" again and again! It's like Lays potato chips...you can't just watch it once!
This is on the highest level of human emotion. Never before have I felt a video literally reach out and squeeze my heart to the point I gasp. Unreal, absolutely unreal 👏🏼
The actress is singing for the camera, but the audio is overlayed by Loren Allred's voice. When characters are "singing" in a scene, the actors really are singing for the camera, the audio is just replaced later. Or else it'd look really weird lol.
Upon close analysis of P. T. Barnum's reaction during Jenny Lind's performance, he was actually overwhelmed by the astounding reception of the audience' to his protege'. It was a sense of triumph and pride for him, not attraction to her at all. Remember, the people there were the elites who snobbed his freak show. That concert earned him the respect from this snotty class.
The irony here is that everything she’s singing about is something that P.T. already has, but he can’t see it. Jenny represents everything he’s ever wanted: fame, fortune, recognition. That’s why he looks at her the way he does. Like you said, he’s finally found something that will get him the recognition and respect he so desperately thinks he wants; he sees his dreams being lived out through Jenny. Whereas Jenny has it all, but it’s not enough because she has no one to share it with. Meanwhile, Charity sees the look on P.T.’s face and it’s not jealousy she’s feeling. At least, not jealousy of Jenny. She’s not worried about losing him to Jenny. She’s worried about losing him to his ambition. She’s worried about how far he’s willing to go to achieve the recognition he wants. There’s so much going on in this scene; and it’s so beautifully tragic.
At first hearing, many might think this is a song of an ambitious person who will never be content with what they have achieved. That is, until you realise the majority of the song is prefixed by the phrase 'Take my hand, will you share this with me, cos darling without you...' This is actually a cleverly hidden love song. Everything sung in the chorus will never be enough...*if the person is without their darling sharing it all with them*. The way the music places much more emphasis on the 'Never Enough' part instead of the 'Darling Without You' part is pretty clever and really works well with the story of PT Barnum not realising till later that it would all never be enough...at least not without his darling wife.
Yeah, she was black and he was white and ofc that wasn’t excepted back then and she tried telling him that but he wouldn’t listen so when she finally decided to accept him she did that and pretty much made her feel like a fool.
This was a pivotal moment - we never heard Lind sing before and Barnum invested everything in her. Then, she sings... and it's pure bliss. Hugh Jackman reaction is perfect.
Then she assumes that Barnum has feelings for her. He calls him a player when she knew for a fact that he had a wife & children. Her idiotic & naive behavior almost cost Barnum his marriage.
Not only is OPs comment correct.. the comments in this thread are so idiotic it’s unbelievable. 1. OP was talking about the *characters* singing and reactions 2. It’s a film.. obviously it’s not the actress Rebecca Fergusson singing.. and if it was, which in reality, when filming.. she was singing.. it would be further dubbed over with her singing in a studio. 3. Yes, we know it’s Loren Allred voice being used, not Rebecca’s. 4. Nothing of the a above takes away from the scene itself.. which is incredible. 5. Are you people *really* that gullible to think that when a film has singing in it… especially a musical.. that the cameras actually film an actor or actress singing in that moment and thats how it’s done? Really? Use some critical thinking for once in your lives you dimwits.
I don't think it was a physical attraction that she feared. From the moment she started singing he knew he had found his big ticket. He saw fame. It was (IMHO) really never about money but how the spotlight can draw you in as an addiction. You desire it and lose track of all around you. She knew her husband was hungry for the spotlight and all she wanted the whole time was him.
Its a good sounding song and her singing in general is pretty awesome, I just dislike the obvious edited effects (although autotune in this case doesnt seem that big which is great), and how repetitive the lyrics are (although thats most of the songs in the movie lol)
Hope he’s okay now. My friend was very ill for a few months and died from brain tumour in 2017 and he was only aged 14. Me and Charlotte nearly lost it at his funeral
Seriously, I've already watched this video more than 20 times now, and it still sends chills down my spine. Gosh! Just magnificent performance! And I don't care if it's lip sync-just seeing their facial expressions melts my heart.
So many things are happening here beyond the musical performance. We see a frightened Jenny Lind about to sing for the first time before an American audience who never heard her perform. We see PT Barnum first worrying that he spent a fortune to arrange the concert tour of a woman without any firsthand knowledge of her skills as a singer. Then we see ever so much the hint that his attraction to her may be more than professional. We see Charity Barnum recognizing that her marriage may be in trouble. We see Barnum's partner (can't remember his name) daring to hold the hand of the African American woman until he sees the withering gaze of his shocked parents. We see the stunned reaction of the newspaper critic who viewed Barnum, until this moment, as a huckster and a fraud and is now completely mesmerized by Lind's performance and finds himself joining in the standing ovation. All of this during a four minute song. Stepping outside of the movie for a moment, we recognize that the actress portraying Lind is not actually the singer. We never actually hear the singing voice of the actress. Ironically enough, no one today knows what the actual Jenny Lind sounded like. She lived and died before the technology was available to record her voice. Sadly, the real performances of Jenny Lind are lost forever.
Some might argue that Barnum's attraction never went past professionalism--he was more attracted to her talents and what it would do to prove the people who spat on his success wrong. Charity might've been worried about the extent in which her husband would finally decide that he had everything he wanted, since he spent his life trying to prove people wrong.
@@jamiemorgan6490 It's a bit frustrating that we know what musical pieces Lind performed but we don't know what she sounded like. Of course, those pieces would likely not be commercially popular with today's audience. (On the other hand, while no one today knows what Abraham Lincoln sounded like, no one would rewrite those speeches to use contemporary slang.)
Most people say that the wife's face was knowing that she wasn't the one anymore,I personally thought the look was more of a "you will never have enough" look
Typical Sarah Pretty much. Charity was never worried about losing P.T. to Jenny. She was worried about losing him to his ambition, because Jenny represents everything he’s ever wanted: fame, fortune, recognition.
This entire scene was, is and a will forever be riveting. It’s as if the angels have descended from the heavens to sing. How anyone can hit the not like button shocks me
neil stucky i was amazed at how fascinated i was by this scene. She was breathtaking. I was disappointed when i discovered that she wasnt actually singing. But she was still very captivating.
I literally screamed at the screen when hugh Jackman looked at her like this... I mean he has a wife and kids, a man shouldn't watch another woman except his wife like this!
This is movie magic 👌 the way his wife looks sad as she sees the way he looks at her in awe. It was never about love... it was about opportunities for him.
yeah. So basically PT wasn't looking at Jenny with genuine love. He just saw all the profit and opportunities he could get out of her singing talent but Charity (PT's wife) misunderstood it as a love.
@@des1748 I don’t think Charity misunderstood it at all. She sees the way he’s looking at the crowd, after all. She knows exactly how important fame, fortune, and success are to him. I think she was more concerned about losing him to his ambition, not to Jenny.
@@NeverendingTori Yes; I've read several accounts about the nature of the relationship between Barnum and Lind, and it was not romantic, Barnum was all ego and ambition, and Lind could only stand nine months of touring at his pace before she got out of her contract.
I'm trying to hold my breath Let it stay this way Can't let this moment end You set off a dream with me Getting louder now Can you hear it echoing? Take my hand Will you share this with me? 'Cause darling without you All the shine of a thousand spotlights All the stars we steal from the nightsky Will never be enough Never be enough Towers of gold are still too little These hands could hold the world but it'll Never be enough Never be enough For me Never, never Never, never Never, for me For me Never enough Never enough Never enough For me For me For me All the shine of a thousand spotlights All the stars we steal from the nightsky Will never be enough Never be enough Towers of gold are still too little These hands could hold the world but it'll Never be enough Never be enough For me Never, never Never, never Never, for me For me Never enough Never, never Never enough Never, never Never enough For me For me For me For me YOUR WELCOME
this has to be one of the most amazing movie scenes ever! its so much more than just performing an amazing song, so many emotions in that theatre for different reasons! it gave me goosebumps the first time i watched this!
Agreed. Beautifully written song, magnificently performed, with masterful editing. I hope I live long enough to see this show performed on stage, and to watch a theater audience while this song is performed live. It will be epic.
I never had a desire to watch this movie. It was playing on HBO and I just kept watching it....so good. Can’t believe I went this long without seeing it!
This whole Scene is great. First of all, it’s an incredible song, sung beautifully, and I have never seen such a good lip sync. Barnum looked at Lind like that because she is his ticket to impressing the rich people, but both she and his wife mistake it for something else. And you got other stuff going on too.
I'm trying to hold my breath Let it stay this way Can't let this moment end You set off a dream in me Getting louder now Can you hear it echoing? Take my hand Will you share this with me? 'Cause darling without you All the shine of a thousand spotlights All the stars we steal from the nightsky Will never be enough Never be enough Towers of gold are still too little These hands could hold the world but it'll Never be enough Never be enough For me Never, never Never, never Never, for me For me Never enough Never enough Never enough For me For me For me All the shine of a thousand spotlights All the stars we steal from the nightsky Will never be enough Never be enough Towers of gold are still too little These hands could hold the world but it'll Never be enough Never be enough For me Never, never Never, never Never, for me For me Never enough Never, never Never enough Never, never Never enough For me For me For me For me
A lot of beautiful voices but her presentation, acting, expression is stunning. Standing in one spot, unlike other performers, and her expressions, eye contact, subtle body movements, hand and arm movements......she is directing the orchestra and the crowd. She is reaching deep into their hearts and bringing forth all the goodness and love deep inside everyone. WOW!!!
The greatest showman is one of those movies that makes you feel like when you are there and watching it, you feel every move and the power and magic of the movie urges through you as if you are there. Idk how to explain but that was me describing how I feel
I also got the feels👌. The cast is amazing, the songs is amazing, the story line although it was based of a true story was amazing, just to sum it up, the movie as a whole is amazing😂👌
Kaleigh Liller. No she's right Loren Allred is the real singer Rebecca is the actress the directors took Loren's singing and placed Rebecca's face but she never recorded her actual singing
Kaleigh Liller As it is stated on IMDB: Rebecca Ferguson's voice was dubbed by Loren Allred. Ferguson had studied music and admitted that she can carry a tune but since Jenny Lind, her character, is considered the best singer in the world, dubbing her voice would be in service of the movie. However, in order to get into the role, Ferguson insisted on singing the song in front of the extras while filming.
That's because when they filmed her she was actually singing, that's no imitation and that's why it looks so real. It is. In post they replaced her voice with Loren's, but she is not lip syncing, there's a difference.
I’m crying. The lyrics of the song say ‘These hands could hold the world but it’ll never be enough’ and I made a connection. Zac was holding Zendaya’s hand, but then he let go because Zendaya was his world, but she wasn’t enough..
@@scooterboivevo3185 exactly, she's not "enough" for his parents cause Zac's family comes from higher class and Zendaya is just a no one, from a freak show on top of it.
Bruh this whole scene... his breath be6 taken away, which is expressed in such beautiful manner as the audience roars in bliss, they are out of focus until she gazes at him... Beautifully done.
Imagine there are no recordings, no radio. All music is live, so exposure is limited. You hear about this fantastic singer from overseas. You invest a fortune promoting her and getting her on stage. She shows up to perform, and it's Whitney Houston. Everybody had high expectations, but she exceeds them 100 fold and brings the house down. You're not in love with her, you're in awe of how much money you're going to make.
This is my first time hearing this. WHAT.........A.............VOICE! It is so moving to hear this song that its like a religious experience--- like something out of mythology. And those lyrics. I was overwhelmed by this. Maybe the most beautiful song ever written, and my standards are high when it comes to that. I could not hold back the tears.
I'm trying to hold my breath Let it stay this way Can't let this moment end You set off a dream in me Getting louder now Can you hear it echoing? Take my hand Will you share this with me? 'Cause darling without you All the shine of a thousand spotlights All the stars we steal from the nightsky Will never be enough Never be enough Towers of gold are still too little These hands could hold the world but it'll Never be enough Never be enough For me Never, never Never, never Never, for me For me Never enough Never enough Never enough For me For me For me All the shine of a thousand spotlights All the stars we steal from the nightsky Will never…
I’m a 70’s rock fan and an 80’s heavy metal fan, but this gives me goosebumps all over the place every time I watch this. First few times I saw it I welled up. Absolutely moving piece of wonderful music and vocals.
I think it was Phillip (Zac) who let go of Anne's (Zendara's) hand, because he spotted his parents whispering disapprovingly about Anne, which caused him to automatically let go of her hand. That would have hurt Anne that he let go, but another reason she walked away was most likely because she also saw the parents whispering disapprovingly about her, would have been hard for her to stay when she knew they were watching. I'm really glad that Phillip stood up to his parents in a later scene, though, and, instead of letting her go after she walked away, like this time, he followed her, to try to comfort and reassure her.
I know it’s not her but I love how well she portrayed her vocals. Really highlighted her voice with the cries and power without trying to hard. Great job tapping your lower register voice. Best voice in the movie
This is just spectacular. I listen to it every day. And this is by far the best lip sync performance I have ever seen on film. Until I looked into it, I had not idea she was not the original singer... And in turn, I am now a Lauren Allred fan! AMAZING!
This gives me chilss EVERY TIME she's so goooooddd. And the way Barnum (Hugh Jackman) was so astounded by her amazing voice never fails to get me. He's in tears because he knows she will save his show. 😭
She is so much talented I couldn't believed that she was just lipsing the whole song . She was so good I was feeling like I was literally present there and cherish every moment as her voice was touching my soul with so much power ❤️😭. Can't get over that feeling ❤️
I’m into metal and I’m talking the nastiest metal, rock hardtrance only the fattest wake your neighbours up beats and gangsta rap. I never ever in my life thought I’d say this but this song is beautiful and carries an immense feeling of power. Proper music, sort of thing you do a standing ovation before it’s finished cos you can’t help it
It was about class, they used (mixed famous actor/actress) race to emphasise and visualise it I think for the audience so in same ways it was the same.
miss RUclipsr fun on the run I can Never enjoy a song without crying 😅 when that song started playing “Oh this is my favorite” And that song played “Crap now this one’s my favorite” And Theeen That song hit me “Dang it, I love them all I can’t choose” 💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘
Love this movie. Im watch it so many times. Love all the music. The music is very moving and powerful. Which means a lot the people now a days. Wish they would make another one some day. Love musicals
![YoungBoy Never Broke Again - Sneaking [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1ILUps2zDFU/mqdefault.jpg)
Can we talk about her acting skills,
Never thought this is not her own voice.
She made me believe it was her own!
What a great actress 😍
The actress practiced lip syncing this song a million times. ( as I have watching this video😅)
LOVE THIS SO MUCH.
Ukr
This actually her voice she performed it live on saturday night live
yeah and she is stunning looking woman and a great actress
Then you should watch Hindi movies lmao
if any of u r confused since there’s basically 3 names,
Jenny Lind~ the character singing
Rebecca Ferguson~ actress who plays Jenny Lind
Loren Allred~ actual singer
wait.. you mean the person singing this was actually loren? i thought she was just the original singer?
@@maia6507 yea loren was the one to sing this she's just mouthing the words.
@@daisyguo3354 zbzwqďc
Eee 97
Alex Efeyini zbzwqd’c
Eee 97
Still confused
Hugh deserved an Oscar just for his expression
What is your name I guess I am the only one I have a friend named Haley and my name is Katie
Yeah and i think you didnt have to act when see this kind of oerfornance the wow factor was act for itself
@@martincisneros8507 stop introducing yourself to people on the internet. YOU CAN'T BE FRIENDS WITH THEM. you did the same thing on the comment above this one. STOP
I'm saying
I'm saying girl or boy
If there's an Oscar for "Best Lip Sync Performance" this lady should get it.
Loren Allred is the actual singer. But Rebecca Ferguson deserves the credit for this performance being in the movie. She knew it was better than she could possibly sing.
Absolutely correct - ruclips.net/video/oTw8AECmUNA/видео.html
She did actually sing live they just replaced it with the other singer.....
I can listen to this song 100 times but it will never be enough for me. Never. Never.
Pedro Rivera Nice 👍
Hahahahahha that was funny and true Pedro lol
Meh too and congrats I’m it 299th like
Lol
Pedro Rivera wow
Wooaahhh the zac and zendaya scene had me
random commenter dude legit I felt that...whoosh
I felt that, but the scene with Carlyle's parents was worse but he reacted better.
Why’d he let her hand go?
Mia Thompson because he didn’t want his parents to think he was in love with her because he knew they would’ve 100% disapproved of their relationship
Same hereeeeee🥰😭😍🤤
This whole scene has to be one of the finest bits of cinema ever. Musical aside, the amount of subtext and narrative is staggering.
Truly magical. I utterly love it
neuk01642 I uTterLy LovE iT
I have to agree. A whole story being told during the song. Absolutely brilliant.
Ghosdbusds
neuk01642 same.
Erin Dunn LMAOOODBIDUSSU
I just saw the real voice of this beautiful song at AGT stage ...it's simply amazing 😍
she was on BGT not AGT just saying, but her voice is truly amazing
@@mayarodriguez618You're the person nobody wants at Thanksgiving
in a world filled with hate, why add to it?@@SirZachariahlll
@@SirZachariahlllI love this comment
Can we Talk about her dress 😍
No chance only voice 😀
Yessssee
Like a Princess 😍😍😍😍
Beautiful!!
@ILHAN D5 65 she is lip syncing another person is singing I know because I heard the real person singing it lie dis
Seeing this scene for the first time in theaters gave me absolute goosebumps. Just was... wow.
me too (said about 50 million people)
I think when they filmed it, Rebecca really sang and for the movie they just put the voice over to look for authentic
Loren Allred sang it-
Me too! That loud HD stereo sound in a theater went into your ears, down your spine and out your fingers and toes -- consuming your whole body. You just couldn't believe what you were hearing and seeing! A rare cinema moment. The audience in my theater actually applauded along with the audience on the screen. 😲😱👍
@@markmh835 I really wish I had seen this movie in the theater when it first came out. I had so much going on at the time and just didn't get a chance. I ended up renting the DVD a couple of years ago and was absolutely blown away! I watched it over and over again for maybe 2 months! I watched it again earlier tonight. And now here I am at 2am watching "Never Enough" again and again! It's like Lays potato chips...you can't just watch it once!
This is on the highest level of human emotion. Never before have I felt a video literally reach out and squeeze my heart
to the point I gasp. Unreal, absolutely unreal 👏🏼
Wow well said. It's powerful to the heart.
I think so. This song, I mean this version, has to be enjoyed with the video
Arctic sleeping at last. ^
MaccaFromLA it is, except, Jenny isn’t actually singing at all.
But is it better than somebody to love?
Best bit of the film. Never forget the feeling seeing this scene for the first time.
I saw it at home in 2017/18 and loved it and now loving it again 3/4 years on
It’s unhealthy the amount of times I’ve watched this!
Veronica McEwan Oh come on, just one more time. Watch it with me and we can both get in a good cry today!
Same tho
Love it! The video makes this song, emotion pouring out of it ❤
Me too
Amen! I'm obsessed
Hugh's facial expressions are amazing in this scene. LOVE this song.
Y4J I agree 100% with you, but my favorite face in this scene is Michelle williams!
Sex HOLLIEGRFFIN girlfriend too you looking thsks yes Still remainsp sex yrd the
Noo
Yes!!!!
Y4J for real though
This is some top notch lip syncing wtf actually thought she sang it first time I watched it
The actress is singing for the camera, but the audio is overlayed by Loren Allred's voice. When characters are "singing" in a scene, the actors really are singing for the camera, the audio is just replaced later. Or else it'd look really weird lol.
As the comment above said, she is actually singing, she was dubbed over in editing
@@thepryde3438 still a seamless dub no matter which direction.
Yea it was lorean who sang it
Loren actually matched her voice to the lady on stage singing this. There's a vid on youtube about the making of it that's worth a watch.
Rupaul:
-Now that’s how you lip sync for your life
RuPaul is quaking
Graduate of the Adolf Fredrick Music School in Stockholm Sweden....she's singing it herself!
Shantay, you stay!
Steve White no, it is sang by Loren Allred, which is not the actress for Jenny Lind’s name.
Steve White if this is just a joke comment, then I’m prepared for your r/wooosh
The first time I watched this I broke into tears. Don’t ask me why.
Why
Nobody was going to
Ewok 88 why
Whhhhhhyyyyyyyyyyyyyy???
It’s ok so did I
Upon close analysis of P. T. Barnum's reaction during Jenny Lind's performance, he was actually overwhelmed by the astounding reception of the audience' to his protege'. It was a sense of triumph and pride for him, not attraction to her at all. Remember, the people there were the elites who snobbed his freak show. That concert earned him the respect from this snotty class.
Yes, exactly. His expression of love is directed at the audience where all eyes are focused on Jenny.
The irony here is that everything she’s singing about is something that P.T. already has, but he can’t see it. Jenny represents everything he’s ever wanted: fame, fortune, recognition. That’s why he looks at her the way he does. Like you said, he’s finally found something that will get him the recognition and respect he so desperately thinks he wants; he sees his dreams being lived out through Jenny. Whereas Jenny has it all, but it’s not enough because she has no one to share it with.
Meanwhile, Charity sees the look on P.T.’s face and it’s not jealousy she’s feeling. At least, not jealousy of Jenny. She’s not worried about losing him to Jenny. She’s worried about losing him to his ambition. She’s worried about how far he’s willing to go to achieve the recognition he wants.
There’s so much going on in this scene; and it’s so beautifully tragic.
@@NeverendingTori Love your analysis!
Mark Ballenger thanks dude! I love this movie and this scene is beautifully poignant in several ways.
At first hearing, many might think this is a song of an ambitious person who will never be content with what they have achieved. That is, until you realise the majority of the song is prefixed by the phrase 'Take my hand, will you share this with me, cos darling without you...'
This is actually a cleverly hidden love song. Everything sung in the chorus will never be enough...*if the person is without their darling sharing it all with them*. The way the music places much more emphasis on the 'Never Enough' part instead of the 'Darling Without You' part is pretty clever and really works well with the story of PT Barnum not realising till later that it would all never be enough...at least not without his darling wife.
Poor Zendaya----I guess she felt profound rejection when he let go of her hand, so she had to walk away. Why stay where you are not wanted.
It was also because she saw his parents whispering disapprovingly about her, would have been hard for her to stay there after seeing that.
Yeah, she was black and he was white and ofc that wasn’t excepted back then and she tried telling him that but he wouldn’t listen so when she finally decided to accept him she did that and pretty much made her feel like a fool.
lmao when the actors are too good
Dan Mart that part made me cry
Deep
This was a pivotal moment - we never heard Lind sing before and Barnum invested everything in her. Then, she sings... and it's pure bliss. Hugh Jackman reaction is perfect.
Not her singing
She’s lip syncing from Loren Allred’s song
She didn't sing the song, Loren Allred sang it and the actress lip synced.
Then she assumes that Barnum has feelings for her. He calls him a player when she knew for a fact that he had a wife & children. Her idiotic & naive behavior almost cost Barnum his marriage.
Not only is OPs comment correct.. the comments in this thread are so idiotic it’s unbelievable.
1. OP was talking about the *characters* singing and reactions
2. It’s a film.. obviously it’s not the actress Rebecca Fergusson singing.. and if it was, which in reality, when filming.. she was singing.. it would be further dubbed over with her singing in a studio.
3. Yes, we know it’s Loren Allred voice being used, not Rebecca’s.
4. Nothing of the a above takes away from the scene itself.. which is incredible.
5. Are you people *really* that gullible to think that when a film has singing in it… especially a musical.. that the cameras actually film an actor or actress singing in that moment and thats how it’s done? Really? Use some critical thinking for once in your lives you dimwits.
That scene when his wife looks at him looking at her is so sad, that feeling when you realize you might not be "the one" anymore
meeran haq facts
Right I felt sad for her
I don't think it was a physical attraction that she feared. From the moment she started singing he knew he had found his big ticket. He saw fame. It was (IMHO) really never about money but how the spotlight can draw you in as an addiction. You desire it and lose track of all around you. She knew her husband was hungry for the spotlight and all she wanted the whole time was him.
@@smellfunny1864 thank you somebody actually realized😅
Doug Miles yep, it was an act he felt proud of because of the high brow acceptance.
Everyone got goosebumps this scene don’t lieee
No but my bff olivia during my middle school talent show for 6th grade chior she gave me MAJOR goosebumps. She was amazing. I love her voice
Naa
Tea spill why would we get goosebumps
Its a good sounding song and her singing in general is pretty awesome, I just dislike the obvious edited effects (although autotune in this case doesnt seem that big which is great), and how repetitive the lyrics are (although thats most of the songs in the movie lol)
Tea spill at the end she got me sooo mad when she kissed Barnum.
My wife: Turn that song off!
Me: Never, never!
🤣🤣🤣
Change ur wife 🙄
🤣🤣
Hahaha
@@mariashahzada8401 never never :)
My Dad’s terminally ill, and after watching this movie together I seriously saw it breathe new life into him. Thankyou Hugh Jackman!! ❤️
So sweet.
Good for you.
Hope he’s okay now. My friend was very ill for a few months and died from brain tumour in 2017 and he was only aged 14. Me and Charlotte nearly lost it at his funeral
But I was right by her the whole grieving period and we pulled through within weeks but I’ll not forget him
Seriously, I've already watched this video more than 20 times now, and it still sends chills down my spine. Gosh! Just magnificent performance!
And I don't care if it's lip sync-just seeing their facial expressions melts my heart.
Sex hollieGrffin girlfriend yes Still remainsp your loved hollie 07505741539 thick bebe xxxxxxx Sexy yes yes yes Still remainsp we your Caunc 20
Hollie 07505741539 thick bebe xxxxxxx Sexy yes yes yes Still remainsp we can get the most caunp thinks
Her incredible emotions plus the real singer's amazing voice makes such a powerful and phenomenal performance.
Me too
@@hollieg4516
Ìii9c9coccpgüp. ,nnoyiyiyi,o,,o887@+1×77×+771__-8- die 8 von 4 8xpy9äy
Hugh Jackman should win an Oscar for his expression alone.
Is this song from a movie ??????
@@rw7094 yeah, The Greatest Showman
in that moment he fell in love
Telio.tragoydi.!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♦♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♦♦♥♥♥♥♥♥
John McFarlane and of course, his wife saw.
Jackmans facial expressions are so perfect in this scene.
there’s so much drama when she is singing even though no one is talking 😭😭😭
It breaks my heart everytime he let's go of her hand.
Same here !! 😫😫😫
YESSSS😂
morgan nicholls same here...
morgan nicholls yes it was so sad when they let go of each others hand so sad😭😭
He let it go bc he likes the girl singing now
So many things are happening here beyond the musical performance.
We see a frightened Jenny Lind about to sing for the first time before an American audience who never heard her perform.
We see PT Barnum first worrying that he spent a fortune to arrange the concert tour of a woman without any firsthand knowledge of her skills as a singer. Then we see ever so much the hint that his attraction to her may be more than professional.
We see Charity Barnum recognizing that her marriage may be in trouble.
We see Barnum's partner (can't remember his name) daring to hold the hand of the African American woman until he sees the withering gaze of his shocked parents.
We see the stunned reaction of the newspaper critic who viewed Barnum, until this moment, as a huckster and a fraud and is now completely mesmerized by Lind's performance and finds himself joining in the standing ovation.
All of this during a four minute song.
Stepping outside of the movie for a moment, we recognize that the actress portraying Lind is not actually the singer. We never actually hear the singing voice of the actress. Ironically enough, no one today knows what the actual Jenny Lind sounded like. She lived and died before the technology was available to record her voice. Sadly, the real performances of Jenny Lind are lost forever.
Some might argue that Barnum's attraction never went past professionalism--he was more attracted to her talents and what it would do to prove the people who spat on his success wrong. Charity might've been worried about the extent in which her husband would finally decide that he had everything he wanted, since he spent his life trying to prove people wrong.
@@yagadoobigidibobbibigabiga38 Nicely put.
Dead City bang on pal, and charity was more concerned about his ambition than the singer
I mean she’s also singing a musical theatre song rather than something operatic so this is nothing like what Jenny Lind would have sounded like
@@jamiemorgan6490 It's a bit frustrating that we know what musical pieces Lind performed but we don't know what she sounded like. Of course, those pieces would likely not be commercially popular with today's audience. (On the other hand, while no one today knows what Abraham Lincoln sounded like, no one would rewrite those speeches to use contemporary slang.)
There is just so much deep soul in Loren Allred's voice
This is the best way to explain our resilience and why we continue to fight! 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
I just want someone to look at me the way he's looking at her and the audience 😍 he looks so amazed.
Wade Torres or you know she means someone who looks at her in awe, why so butt hurt 😂
@@wadeleetorres2585 actually I don't find Hugh Jackman attractive but that's probably cuz I'm a lesbian.✌️🤷
@@wadeleetorres2585 also if you seen my girlfriend you'd cream your tighty Whitey's she's so outta your league.😂
Ashley Dawn I don’t find him that attractive either, I’m not lesbian but I just don’t see it
@@dreamer5013 lol probably true.
Most people say that the wife's face was knowing that she wasn't the one anymore,I personally thought the look was more of a "you will never have enough" look
Typical Sarah Pretty much. Charity was never worried about losing P.T. to Jenny. She was worried about losing him to his ambition, because Jenny represents everything he’s ever wanted: fame, fortune, recognition.
@@NeverendingTori EXACTLY
The song tightrope was her feelings for that look
I agree with you, but a small part of me think she was just thinking about her voice (aka how much moonnneeeyyyy) but i agree with you
Typical Sarah
This entire scene was, is and a will forever be riveting. It’s as if the angels have descended from the heavens to sing. How anyone can hit the not like button shocks me
neil stucky i was amazed at how fascinated i was by this scene. She was breathtaking. I was disappointed when i discovered that she wasnt actually singing. But she was still very captivating.
SashaTheBooklover yeah, besides, she was lip syncing while Loren was the one singing.
I literally screamed at the screen when hugh Jackman looked at her like this... I mean he has a wife and kids, a man shouldn't watch another woman except his wife like this!
I think he was just amazed by her. Nothing romantic🤷🏻♀️
Heyyy...he was looking at her with admiration😑
Gives me chills - the voice and the adoring look.
na i think he looked at her like that cos he know he made some cash lmao
@@elanordigby542 😂
2:58, Michelle Williams should have won an Oscar for that look alone.
Farson79 her realization was the part that made me just start bawling 😭 Michelleeeee
Indeed! 😢😭
yep. It tells so much.... I know that kind of look to.....
yep. It tells so much.... I know that kind of look to.....
TRUE
They don't have cars but they do have industrial lighting
*James Charles has left the chat*
😭😭😭😭😭
He did a wonderful job
I’m Here 😭 dkmm
Myrline Laplante lmao
I’m Here he really did look at him now 2mil gone
This is movie magic 👌 the way his wife looks sad as she sees the way he looks at her in awe. It was never about love... it was about opportunities for him.
yeah. So basically PT wasn't looking at Jenny with genuine love. He just saw all the profit and opportunities he could get out of her singing talent but Charity (PT's wife) misunderstood it as a love.
@@des1748 I don’t think Charity misunderstood it at all. She sees the way he’s looking at the crowd, after all. She knows exactly how important fame, fortune, and success are to him. I think she was more concerned about losing him to his ambition, not to Jenny.
@@NeverendingTori Yes; I've read several accounts about the nature of the relationship between Barnum and Lind, and it was not romantic, Barnum was all ego and ambition, and Lind could only stand nine months of touring at his pace before she got out of her contract.
@@NeverendingToriJenny fired his ass
And what makes the story beautiful is losing sight of what he initially did it for but finds redemption within himself
*i can never get enough of this song*
This kid..
Saaame
Me too😢😢😢😢
I would like this comment but it has 420 likes
Right
Shout out to my The Greatest Showman Fans who came her before James 💙😍
~
[ no shade ]
Me
fk that throw shade that nigga over used auto tune
Yay shout out for me
All shade
Me
Absolute masterpiece musical number. Rebecca's nuanced movements and Loren's voice are both heavenly in every respect. Rebecca is a Goddess on stage.
If they ever do a remake of Philadelphia Story, she has to play the Katherine Hepburn role. She definitely has that goddess style
Even after knowing who originally sang this song still this performance gives me goosebumps every time I listen to it.
I'm trying to hold my breath
Let it stay this way
Can't let this moment end
You set off a dream with me
Getting louder now
Can you hear it echoing?
Take my hand
Will you share this with me?
'Cause darling without you
All the shine of a thousand spotlights
All the stars we steal from the nightsky
Will never be enough
Never be enough
Towers of gold are still too little
These hands could hold the world but it'll
Never be enough
Never be enough
For me
Never, never
Never, never
Never, for me
For me
Never enough
Never enough
Never enough
For me
For me
For me
All the shine of a thousand spotlights
All the stars we steal from the nightsky
Will never be enough
Never be enough
Towers of gold are still too little
These hands could hold the world but it'll
Never be enough
Never be enough
For me
Never, never
Never, never
Never, for me
For me
Never enough
Never, never
Never enough
Never, never
Never enough
For me
For me
For me
For me
YOUR WELCOME
I like what you did. Good job
Wow !!!!
Great job
Shadowmaster 101 sthank you that helped me a lot girl skirt skirt
Shadowmaster 101
How many times can I listen to this song
NEVER ENOUGH
Not grammatical sense but I get what your saying.
Everybody was feeling some type of way during this song
welcome to wonderland yea, that way was complex thinking 😅
True
welcome to wonderland
Joshua Thompson hello
welcome to wonderland it warmed my heart
this has to be one of the most amazing movie scenes ever! its so much more than just performing an amazing song, so many emotions in that theatre for different reasons! it gave me goosebumps the first time i watched this!
I so totally agree. An epic performance for the ages. 😱😁👍
Agreed. Beautifully written song, magnificently performed, with masterful editing. I hope I live long enough to see this show performed on stage, and to watch a theater audience while this song is performed live. It will be epic.
I never had a desire to watch this movie. It was playing on HBO and I just kept watching it....so good. Can’t believe I went this long without seeing it!
It's not even my kind of movie, but amazing.
Out of the ballpark.
@@capnbilll2913 me to this movie was magical, I told a few friends to watch. And my kids loved it
Thats the same with me. I held.off on watching it. Never knew i would love it so much. Glad i decided to watch it again.
you should have seen this scene on a 14' x 24' screen with 7.1 Surround Sound
it was transforming.
Same #sleeperhit
Whilst I was in the cinema watching this, I was just sobbing💕😭 Even my dad cried and he never cries
This is my favorite song in the greatest Showman
Kkevjvbc KDforlife oh definately
Yassss
Kkevjvbc KDforlife mine is rewrite the stars , the other side , tightrope, never enough , and a million dreams, also this is me
Of course!😇😇
100% 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
im here because loren shows off that she is behind this voice....she's really good...always have tears in this song...🥰🥰🥰
Same 😂
Me too..lol
Same
You're not alone 😅
You guys should have known that many years ago. That information is so old.
Disney: we have the greatest songs
The greatest showman:
hold my beer
Disney buys out Fox. Now somebody else is holding the beer for Disney again.
Hold my mic..
says who
Yepp
isn’t greatest showman disney
This whole
Scene is great.
First of all, it’s an incredible song, sung beautifully, and I have never seen such a good lip sync.
Barnum looked at Lind like that because she is his ticket to impressing the rich people, but both she and his wife mistake it for something else.
And you got other stuff going on too.
I'm trying to hold my breath
Let it stay this way
Can't let this moment end
You set off a dream in me
Getting louder now
Can you hear it echoing?
Take my hand
Will you share this with me?
'Cause darling without you
All the shine of a thousand spotlights
All the stars we steal from the nightsky
Will never be enough
Never be enough
Towers of gold are still too little
These hands could hold the world but it'll
Never be enough
Never be enough
For me
Never, never
Never, never
Never, for me
For me
Never enough
Never enough
Never enough
For me
For me
For me
All the shine of a thousand spotlights
All the stars we steal from the nightsky
Will never be enough
Never be enough
Towers of gold are still too little
These hands could hold the world but it'll
Never be enough
Never be enough
For me
Never, never
Never, never
Never, for me
For me
Never enough
Never, never
Never enough
Never, never
Never enough
For me
For me
For me
For me
Awsome
This is a blessing lmao
A lot of beautiful voices but her presentation, acting, expression is stunning. Standing in one spot, unlike other performers, and her expressions, eye contact, subtle body movements, hand and arm movements......she is directing the orchestra and the crowd. She is reaching deep into their hearts and bringing forth all the goodness and love deep inside everyone. WOW!!!
The greatest showman is one of those movies that makes you feel like when you are there and watching it, you feel every move and the power and magic of the movie urges through you as if you are there. Idk how to explain but that was me describing how I feel
I also got the feels👌. The cast is amazing, the songs is amazing, the story line although it was based of a true story was amazing, just to sum it up, the movie as a whole is amazing😂👌
Loren Allred is one of the best singers ever! truly majestic song
Mary J that's not Loren, its Rebecca the original
Kaleigh Liller. No she's right Loren Allred is the real singer Rebecca is the actress the directors took Loren's singing and placed Rebecca's face but she never recorded her actual singing
Mary J she lip synced
Kaleigh Liller As it is stated on IMDB: Rebecca Ferguson's voice was dubbed by Loren Allred. Ferguson had studied music and admitted that she can carry a tune but since Jenny Lind, her character, is considered the best singer in the world, dubbing her voice would be in service of the movie. However, in order to get into the role, Ferguson insisted on singing the song in front of the extras while filming.
Kaleigh Liller she lip sync it Loren was the one singing
Even though she lip synced, she really did well in imitating the breathing while singing
That's because when they filmed her she was actually singing, that's no imitation and that's why it looks so real. It is. In post they replaced her voice with Loren's, but she is not lip syncing, there's a difference.
She was singing, but it was to Loren's pre-recorded playback. She still had to get the timing of each word and phrase down perfectly...and she did.
ohhh ok that's good to know!
flying21 discøs Facts
flying21 discøs good acting
Loved this movie. Not a fan of musicals but it was incredible. This whole scene was fantastic!
You should watch La La Land next
I’m crying. The lyrics of the song say ‘These hands could hold the world but it’ll never be enough’ and I made a connection. Zac was holding Zendaya’s hand, but then he let go because Zendaya was his world, but she wasn’t enough..
Nah it's because he didn't want his parents to see him holding her hand
@@scooterboivevo3185 exactly, she's not "enough" for his parents cause Zac's family comes from higher class and Zendaya is just a no one, from a freak show on top of it.
No it was because of his parents
That's too deep and I don't think everyone can understand the context behind it---
I got the context and i agree.
Bruh this whole scene... his breath be6 taken away, which is expressed in such beautiful manner as the audience roars in bliss, they are out of focus until she gazes at him... Beautifully done.
Expressions of Hugh Jackman deserve an Oskar..what a great actor he is!!
I dont think that was acting..that probably was his first time hearing that song an it hit him
@@n.i.l.8.993 That's my mean,His expression tells us that what you are saying..he's listening her first time and feel amaze.
*Oscar
But yes, I love this song and I sing it without knowing in math class. No matter how many times I listen to this song, it'll never be enough!
TBNRHarris He’s not talking song here but Jackman’s acting. Personally I think same. He is a very good actor. (Song - beautiful, of course!)
Imagine there are no recordings, no radio. All music is live, so exposure is limited. You hear about this fantastic singer from overseas. You invest a fortune promoting her and getting her on stage. She shows up to perform, and it's Whitney Houston. Everybody had high expectations, but she exceeds them 100 fold and brings the house down. You're not in love with her, you're in awe of how much money you're going to make.
This is my first time hearing this. WHAT.........A.............VOICE! It is so moving to hear this song that its like a religious experience--- like something out of mythology. And those lyrics. I was overwhelmed by this. Maybe the most beautiful song ever written, and my standards are high when it comes to that. I could not hold back the tears.
The singer is Loren Allred, in case you were wondering😊
Look for the singer Morisette Amon cover. It will blow your mind.
Agreed!
Watch the whole movie. It's beautiful! It's on disney+ now
Oh boy, wait till you find out the real singer just appeared on Britains got talent.
She’s like glowing
I'm trying to hold my breath
Let it stay this way
Can't let this moment end
You set off a dream in me
Getting louder now
Can you hear it echoing?
Take my hand
Will you share this with me?
'Cause darling without you
All the shine of a thousand spotlights
All the stars we steal from the nightsky
Will never be enough
Never be enough
Towers of gold are still too little
These hands could hold the world but it'll
Never be enough
Never be enough
For me
Never, never
Never, never
Never, for me
For me
Never enough
Never enough
Never enough
For me
For me
For me
All the shine of a thousand spotlights
All the stars we steal from the nightsky
Will never…
Just what I was looking for thanks
And share this with can’t let this moment end
Disney Полнометражки nice
Thank you
Be enough~
I’m a 70’s rock fan and an 80’s heavy metal fan, but this gives me goosebumps all over the place every time I watch this. First few times I saw it I welled up. Absolutely moving piece of wonderful music and vocals.
I dont know why but when Zendaya ealked away i startef crying
BECAUSE THERE MEANT TO BE
I was like WTF ya doing she a fine looking girl OMG !
Misty Westley yup,yup.
ME TOO
Misty Westley yo soell rong
That Zac and Zendaya part had me in tears.
why did they let go?
SavageChewBaka becuase the movie takes place back then and she was black, he was white. and blacks and whites couldn’t be together back then.
@@elsys7546 ah I've never seen it, but I really should
SavageChewBaka yeah, it’s pretty good.
I think it was Phillip (Zac) who let go of Anne's (Zendara's) hand, because he spotted his parents whispering disapprovingly about Anne, which caused him to automatically let go of her hand. That would have hurt Anne that he let go, but another reason she walked away was most likely because she also saw the parents whispering disapprovingly about her, would have been hard for her to stay when she knew they were watching. I'm really glad that Phillip stood up to his parents in a later scene, though, and, instead of letting her go after she walked away, like this time, he followed her, to try to comfort and reassure her.
She should have won the lipsync battle 😍
dira ar-rhasya yupe she stayed
To old
I love it
Hahahhaha yeah she slayed it!
dira ar-rhasya Sasha velour is quaking
I know it’s not her but I love how well she portrayed her vocals. Really highlighted her voice with the cries and power without trying to hard. Great job tapping your lower register voice. Best voice in the movie
This is just spectacular. I listen to it every day. And this is by far the best lip sync performance I have ever seen on film. Until I looked into it, I had not idea she was not the original singer... And in turn, I am now a Lauren Allred fan! AMAZING!
Hollie 07505741539 thick bebe xxxxxxx Sexy yes yes Still remainsp to Replicate bebe 1
please check this ruclips.net/video/djJJZLyh-TM/видео.html
i felt my heart drop to my stomach when Zac let go of Zendayas hand
Jaycee Wamer I cried! It literally just breaks my heart every time I watch
Jaycee Wamer I almost cried
Me too! Made me cry! He broke her heart!
Jaycee Wamer he did it because his parents were looking and they would of took him out of the will
OoF 2:27 made me cryyyy
I love how she gave justice to the song through her acting ❤ such a very excellent actress.
So much talent! More than Coco, Trolls, and even the Sound of Music!
I find this better than the others too! But Moana is great too
Love this song
You sing so beautiful
Love
A great movie. The message of using your imagination to live the life you dream. And the music, oh, the music. Wonderful.
Bravo so good
Bravo sing so good i like it
I literally ball my eyes out every time I listen to it 😭
This gives me chilss EVERY TIME she's so goooooddd. And the way Barnum (Hugh Jackman) was so astounded by her amazing voice never fails to get me. He's in tears because he knows she will save his show. 😭
Beautiful.
Still Listening December 2018
OBSESSED...........
Just love this song😂👌🤘🙌
Lol
SAME!!
Only heardit 2 wks ago ,n I'm hooked ,must find the chords hahaa.
@Brebisni ace ,good on ye .
When I first heard this song I started to thank God for this pleasure and beauty I can hear😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
You said it ALL!
YES MY QUEEN
Is anyone here just cause you love the song not cause of James?🤷🏼♀️
Me
Me!❤️
You mean who's here because of James Charles but stayed because you actualy like the song
Meee
Yep
She gives me goosebumps all over omg I’m so emotional she’s so angelic ally perfect 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾😘😘
Same😭💕💕🔥
Too bad it’s not her voice
Fionnbarr Casey WHAT
FIRE 🔥🔥🔥
Rasheen Hunter you should watch the fire scene in the greatest showman it's really sad
This really is amazing scene/song, brings tears to my eyes. Such happiness, emotion and turmoil.
*Who still listening this song raise ur hand😘✋*
Me - absolutely!
✋
🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻
Hallo boi 🙌✋
PaxG GT 🙋🏻
She is so much talented I couldn't believed that she was just lipsing the whole song . She was so good I was feeling like I was literally present there and cherish every moment as her voice was touching my soul with so much power ❤️😭.
Can't get over that feeling ❤️
This song was soooo beautifully sung. It's amazing God has definitely given this singer a lovely voice.
EK Ndongo shes lipsyncing
I’m into metal and I’m talking the nastiest metal, rock hardtrance only the fattest wake your neighbours up beats and gangsta rap. I never ever in my life thought I’d say this but this song is beautiful and carries an immense feeling of power.
Proper music, sort of thing you do a standing ovation before it’s finished cos you can’t help it
Same i live for rock music. Particularly heavy metal but this brought me to tears. Not litterally tho. I dont cry
French Fries you just reminded me of this song so I’m gonna have a listen and then listen to some ramstein, have a great day pal
The Zac and zendaya scene 💔 can you imagine how many mixed race couples had to go through that? Breaks my heart 💔
I think mixed race couples are so sweet because even though they are different they can still have those feeling for each other.
@@joweancujohwife she's aware. She was just pointing out the scene they were both in.
When I saw this in the movie theater I was young so I was like whatttt? And I didn’t understand what happened
I don’t think it was about mixed race, it was because she was circus performer. His father makes a comment about that later in the movie.
It was about class, they used (mixed famous actor/actress) race to emphasise and visualise it I think for the audience so in same ways it was the same.
Most romantic interlocking of fingers ever. 😍
And that tiny little nostril flare from Phillip when Anne left, he's on the verge of tears.
My wig just flew to Canada
😂😂😂😂 what????. Oh my goodness
@Ashley Martinez 😂😂😂
😂
Me😂
Lmao your wig just hit meh 😂
Omg I just realized that it was not her real voice ! Her acting is so amazing !
please check this ruclips.net/video/djJJZLyh-TM/видео.html
Wait what! Damn what a beautiful voice
I can not get this song out my head ..... which is ok with me I love it ! 😍😍😍😍😍🙌🎶🎶🎵🎤🎤🎤🎤🎤🎤🎤🎤🎤🎤🎤🎤🎤🎤
miss RUclipsr fun on the run I can Never enjoy a song without crying 😅 when that song started playing “Oh this is my favorite” And that song played “Crap now this one’s my favorite” And Theeen That song hit me “Dang it, I love them all I can’t choose” 💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘
At first I thought this was her real voice-
But she has really good acting skills so I’ll give her a point for that 😚👌💗
Who keeps listening to this song over and over again like this comment
Jewish Jewel me
Fishing for likes but not catching many.
No
Like literally....I feel dumb but I can't get enough
Jewish Jewel me
THIS SONG MADE ME CRY
same here mate. (want to cry)
vincent edward for reals😢
vincent edward me to
I cried during most of the movie and I watched it yesterday for the first time 😂 now I can't stop listening to the songs
vincent edward me too sister
Love this movie. Im watch it so many times. Love all the music. The music is very moving and powerful. Which means a lot the people now a days. Wish they would make another one some day. Love musicals
This is so good, what a perfect Facial expressions and gestures
ABSOLUTELY
PHENOMENAL