My top 5: 1. Hasek 2. Brodeur 3. Roy 4. Fleury 5. Lundqvist Hasek was a demon in his prime and changed the style of play for his position making him a milestone in hockey history. He also did a fair bit of it in a sub par team. Not even taking in to account what he did while playing for his national team. Brodeur, the backbone of a good team in the best era for goalies. Very close second. Roy, amazing career and goalie that influenced the game. Close third as his teams were less dependent on him to be successful than the first two. Fleury, what a career in two eras of hockey. Always among the best in two good goalie eras. Lundqvist was the Rangers for a very long time. Always showing up always impacted games and made the team better. A proper leader as well and that's a rare goalie trait. Lacks team awards in the NHL but remains an outstanding individual. Not taking into account his resumé with the national team. If I did he would edge out Fleury. I'll put the oldies behind these five as they were the best in a different game.
Modern goalies as good or better than Lundqvist and Fleury Carey Price (Better than Lundqvist but equal level with Fleury) Prime Vasy Prime Jonathan Quick 2015 Andrew Hammond
Dom Hasek is the greatest of all time, hands down! Watched everyone one of his games growing up in Buffalo. The Dominator win six Veznas, a gold metal, two Stanley cups, the GOAT!
He doesn't match Brodeur, Roy or Fleury! Check out Ken Dryden's stats, the man had almost as many shutouts as losses! Hasek was good, but he would have trouble cracking the top 5.
Bruins fan here. The man I have on net for my all time team is Tuukka Rask but Frank Brimsek was an absolute beast as you so clearly illustrated here. However, one of the most painful aspects about Tuukka was that (for whatever reason) he just couldn’t win a big game when they needed him to. True, the blame can’t be placed entirely on him but again, (as examples) the 2010 Eastern Conference Championship was an epic choke job and the 2013 and 2019 Stanley Cup Finals were PAINFUL series meltdown failures. When they won the Cup in 2011, he was the backup to Tim Thomas, a silver medalist for Team USA in the 2010 Olympics and the eventual Stanley Cup MVP. His regular season stats were very impressive but his playoff motif (quite possibly as well as the whole team) seemed to be as if he/they ran out of gas when it mattered most. For those of you that are curious about the rest of my all time Bruins team, I have: Patrice Bergeron - C Brad Marchand - LW Cam Neely - RW Bobby Orr - D Ray Bourque - D In all likelihood, David Pasternak will probably replace Cam Neely
I disagree. Dryden, Smith, Plante, and Fuhr all have better career winning percentages. Roy would be fifth or sixth on my list. Just because he has played more playoff games doesn’t make him better.
It means that in must win games he was trusted more then anyone, and he delivered. Its not that he is first, its the lead in the category that seals it. 151 to 113 and in 42 more games played he only has 3 more loses then Brodeur. 3 times playoff mvp, 4 cups. Its fine to pick whoever you like but give credit where its due@@Jimbob35775
Firstly, stop adding incorrect subtitles at 3:21 and stop adding throughout the entire video if you don't know how to write captions. Also it is blocking the video view.
Hasek is great. He was under 6ft tall small frame but acrobatic and amazing to watch. 7 vezinas wearing a cage mask and pads no bigger then an actual Maxi pad (probably) . Now goalies are like 6.5 ft.
@@nathanadrian7797 Have your eyes checked and your likely fan-boy blindness relieved. All the goalies on this list won both the Cup and Vezina trophy (with all goalies on this list winning either the SC or Vezina multiple times) , besides being named either to more than two all-star teams or being a first team all-star. Luongo in 20 years never won the Vezina or a Stanley Cup, and he made only 2 all-star teams on the second team. Marc-Andre Fleury has a 20+ year career and only made the all-star team once. Fleury was a 2nd team all-star in the same year he nudged out Vasilevskiy for his only Vezina. Fluery only won it because of his comeback story in Vegas after he was a back-up/benched in Pittsburgh for several seasons (Vasilevskiy was the first team all-star goalie in that same year Fleury won the Vezina) . Please differentiate between a good-very good player and an all time top 15 list of goalies on which Luongo and Fleury have no legitimate place being.
@@type4647 Nice try, but I am neither a fan of Luongo nor Fleury, nor do I root for any team that they have played for. Winning the cup is a team accomplishment, and although Luongo got close with Vancouver, he never played for a team able to get it done. Being in the top 5 winningest goalies of all time, should be enough to make the top 15!
Yes, Ken Dryden was very s.Uccessful, but you gotta remember.He played for an All Star team.Dominic Hasek put his numbers up with very little in front of him.He was the all star team
From my era, my favourites! Patrick Roy Ron Hextall Ed Belfour Dominik Hasek Felix Potvin Curtis Joseph Martin Brodeur Mike Richter In No specific order😉👌 Honorable mentions Arturs Irbe Miikka Kiprusoff Mike Vernon John Vanbiesbrouck
Best ever. Jacques Plante. Made the mask part of a goalies regular equipment. Was the first to leave the crease to help the defence. Six Stanley cups. Six vezinas when the vezina wasn't a popularity contest and meant something. Remember Hasek won a second cup but got pulled because he was a sieve and was replaced by Osgood. Plante. Not just statistics but the top goalie innovator.
I prefer lists that match certain era's in hockey. And while stats and awared are the major factors when assessing the best, its not the whole story for goalies playing on mediocre teams. With that in mind, my list for the 70s (the best decade in the history of human kind) would include Gilles Villemure, Ed Giacomin, Gerry Cheevers, Gilles Gilbert, Roggie Vachon, Roger Crozier, Doug Favell, Dan Bouchard, Michel Larocque, Gary Smith. Am I missing any? I loved that era of goaltending with the outlandish masks, rudimentary equipment and amazing acrobatic skills. They played on instinct and reflex. Nowhere near as effective as modern goalies but more spectacular. And after all, its the spectacle that counts.
This would be my pitch for the 10 best NHL goalies. 1. Patrick Roy 2. Dominik Hasek 3. Martin Brodeur 4. Marc-Andre Fleury 5. Roberto Luongo 6. Ed Belfour 7. Henrik Lundqvist 8. Terry Sawchuk 9. Jacques Plante 10. Ken Dryden (BONUS) Best ever international goalkeeper: 1. Vladislav Tretiak - Sovietunion.
@@daman9780 That is why I presented it as international = representing a players country on international tournaments against other countries. Not a national league!
So as a life-long Boston Bruins fanatic, Ken Dryden, IMO, might be a litter closer to the top of the heap. As a kid, my list of enemies was, in order: 1. Montreal Canadiens 2. Satan 3. Ken Dryden 4. Montreal fans 5. Montreal steak seasoning
Who is Grant Furr? People won’t take you seriously if you mispronounce names of players that well known. Not hard to learn how to pronounce the names before you do the video.
@@icebox.hockey It’s possible that there are different pronunciations depending on the country, but it’s an NHL list, so it’s safe to use the NHL pronunciation. It’s not hard to RUclips or google a certain player to get that pronunciation. And Fuhr isn’t nearly as old school as most on that list. And btw it’s pronounced fewer not Furr.
@@icebox.hockey Yup, Dryden had won a pile of cups and left the NHL in his prime to pursue other interests, nothing more to it than that. Gotta admire him for quitting the game at his peak!
I'd put Sawchuk at number 1, had he played as many games per season that Marty and Roy did, he'd have unbreakable records, also missing from the list is Georges Vezina...he played in an era where Goalies were not allowed to drop to the Ice or it was a Penalty and he still has awesome numbers. Btw I have Mike Vernon as the greatest Flames Goalie ever, considering he won a Cup with the Flames and is in the HOF, as Miikka Kiprusoff is neither.
pffffff ROY won the conn symthe trophy (mvp in the playoffs) 3 times...THE ONLY PLAYER TO DO SO....beat martin brodeur in the 2001 stanley cup finals and ...5 time winner of the jennings award.......most playoff games played and career playoff WINS.!!!!...played in 11 National Hockey League All-Star games....Roy won over 200 games with two franchises (Montreal and Colorado).....and who can forget the "WINK" at tomas sandstrom in the stanley cup final!!! .....record for games played by a goalie (1,029), victories (551), minutes played (60,235) and most 30-plus victory seasons (13).......first NHL goaltender to win 500 games.......most NHL playoff wins by a goaltender (151).....most NHL playoff games played by a goaltender (247) (third-most playoff games of ALL players !!!).........4 time stanley cup winner......every record that was set by roy took brodeur LONGER to break......only reason brodeur beats roy's records was broduer played 22 seasons in the league and roy 19......and roy ranks second??.......THIS LIST IS A JOKE!
it is impossible to rank any position because we have seen so much greatness over the years that it really comes down to preference... I mean in a game 7 do you take prime Hasek or prime Roy?.... It comes down to preference. For me I take Hasek, because he had/has way more experience in situations like that - but you cant go wrong with Roy either.... It's like Lemieux vs Gretzky .... I suppose my point is that some of these goalies are so good that you will get the same result out of both, so it doesn't matter and you cant rank them... It's all subjective...
I agree that MA-F is a fine choice for the top 15 goalies of all time but you wouldn’t think so the way the LA Kings jumped out to a 5-0 lead on the Wild Wednesday night 🙈
You forgot to mention that Tony Espositio won the cup with the habs in 69. You also forgot to mention that Dryden won the calder in 71 and was also second in Hart voting that year.
please give more feedback on this :)? its easy to say this wouthout further breakdown? also it does not help at all to just make this comment. break it down, put in some effort. im justtrying here too ;)
Your section for Billy Smith is completely incorrect. It has a photo of a goalkeeper from a different sport, and goalies from the 1950’s when Smith played in the 80’s.
Billy Smith should be in the top 5 Bernie Parent should be higher as well. Dryden is in the right spot. But any goalie who wins 4 straight Stanley Cups should be in the top 5.
@@icebox.hockey No the rest are set up in at least my opinion in the right order. But I would definitely put Smith above Furh because of the 4 in a row and no one has beaten his playoff series wins in a row either. But it's your list and again it's my opinion.
YEAH! he was soo great and had to deal with soo much adversity. I mean, when he was on his first team that wasn't a top quarter team in the nhl, he had a bad game, threw a hissy fit, and then got traded to a new team that was a top quarter team in the NHL. That's how you know you're a great goaltender.
@icebox.hockey depends on if you're talking about a career or skill. I'll go off of career 1: Brodeur 2:Roy 3:Hasek 4:Dryden 5:Sawchuck 6:Hall 7:Plante 8:Belfour 9:Lundqvist 10:Fleury Finally, even as a devils fan, I'd be more than willing to move lundqvist up. He didn't get a cup and only captured one vezina, but from 2005-2015, he finished every year in the top 6 in vezina voting. That level of consistent great play is outstanding. It's brodeur like. It's part of the reason I say rask was the best goalie of the 2010s. No other goalie that decade had such consistently good play. Some had great seasons, even rask, but during that time, rask's save percentage never dipped below a 91.2. Every other goalie did. Also out of the top 3, they're more mobile. But, that's my list off the top of my head right now
Look, obviously this is subjective but Hasek was just so amazing... I mean he got peppered at times, meanwhile guys like Roy had a solid defense in front of him and Brodeur played behind "The Trap" so he saw limited shots..... Fuhr and Smith shouldn't be on this list AT ALL.. Both were "adequate" for their respective teams at the time - but nothing "special"... And Dryden is another one.. If you're going to put him on the list then why not "Bunny" Laraque?....... I think (and obviously this is just my opinion) Hasek is #1 - at least as far as goalies I have witnessed.
Hasek is #1 but Check out what Billy Smith did to Gretzky and the Oilers in the 83 Stanley Cup and then try to find someone who did better in all of history. Only one team did better and they did it against Scott Mellanby and the Panthers Not Gretzky's Oilers
Hasek is the best in the regular season but I don't care. There's a lot more pressure in the playoffs and that's where you see the real winners. Roy is the only player with 3 Conn Smythes trophies and he has the most playoff victories. And 4 Cups. He is the GOAT.
Ive got; 1. Sawchuk - Played every single game in barely any equipment and stopped near everything. 2. Roy - 2 Cups, Best of the Best generation. 3. Tretiak - Best International, also honed both Hasek and Belfour. 4. Hasek - The Dominator. 5. Brodeur - Big Stats and 3 Cups. 6. Dryden - Short but Sweet. 7. Plante - OG. 8. Smith - 4 Straight Cups. 9. Bower - 4 Cups/No Mask. 10. Belfour - Personal Fave. 11. Fleury - 3 Cups and Longevity. 12. Quick - Multiple Cups..2012. 13. Esposito - Underrated. 3 Vezinas. 14. Lundqvist - Representin' Scandinavia. 15 - Hall - I guess, I guess he was pretty good.
When he came to Toronto he didn't play every single game. He and Johnny Bower alternated a lot. That year, when they won the Stanley Cup, they were the best tandem in the NHL. Two of the best all time goalies on the same team.
I respect your rankings and appreciate your attempt to honor my favorite position on the ice, but you need to re-do the video with better videos and photos. You botched my favorite goalie Billy Smith showing one photo and no video (I don´t know what that was you put up there) when there´s a ton online to choose from.
My dude, you have got to at least spell the names right. Marty Broder is not impressed. Good energy in your narration delivery, though. Keep at it and learn from the criticism.
You mention luongo and Fleury 😂😂😂😂.....but leave out Billy Smith and Mike Richter?? Putting up Numbers may say on paper you're a great athlete...but clutch players are what makes them legendary... I'll give you a gold star for the effort .....but the execution, yikes.....ya got alot to learn kiddo .
@@icebox.hockey my pleasure 😁 always glad to help a rookie out. ( Check out the 96 world cup, Richter was a TREMENDOUS factor in the U.S beating the most brutal & talented Canadian team ...facts)
My top 5:
1. Hasek
2. Brodeur
3. Roy
4. Fleury
5. Lundqvist
Hasek was a demon in his prime and changed the style of play for his position making him a milestone in hockey history. He also did a fair bit of it in a sub par team. Not even taking in to account what he did while playing for his national team.
Brodeur, the backbone of a good team in the best era for goalies. Very close second.
Roy, amazing career and goalie that influenced the game. Close third as his teams were less dependent on him to be successful than the first two.
Fleury, what a career in two eras of hockey. Always among the best in two good goalie eras.
Lundqvist was the Rangers for a very long time. Always showing up always impacted games and made the team better. A proper leader as well and that's a rare goalie trait. Lacks team awards in the NHL but remains an outstanding individual. Not taking into account his resumé with the national team. If I did he would edge out Fleury.
I'll put the oldies behind these five as they were the best in a different game.
Now this is a breakdown i love to see!!
Lundqvist carry the rangers and saved them many times . Stopping so many shots that were meant to go in, Hank deserved a cup
Modern goalies as good or better than Lundqvist and Fleury
Carey Price (Better than Lundqvist but equal level with Fleury)
Prime Vasy
Prime Jonathan Quick
2015 Andrew Hammond
Dom Hasek is the greatest of all time, hands down! Watched everyone one of his games growing up in Buffalo. The Dominator win six Veznas, a gold metal, two Stanley cups, the GOAT!
Good point
Sad. You’re not familiar with better goalies.
He doesn't match Brodeur, Roy or Fleury! Check out Ken Dryden's stats, the man had almost as many shutouts as losses! Hasek was good, but he would have trouble cracking the top 5.
You misspelled Patrick Roy.
@@nathanadrian7797 Ken Dryden still with most Cups.
Bruins fan here. The man I have on net for my all time team is Tuukka Rask but Frank Brimsek was an absolute beast as you so clearly illustrated here. However, one of the most painful aspects about Tuukka was that (for whatever reason) he just couldn’t win a big game when they needed him to. True, the blame can’t be placed entirely on him but again, (as examples) the 2010 Eastern Conference Championship was an epic choke job and the 2013 and 2019 Stanley Cup Finals were PAINFUL series meltdown failures. When they won the Cup in 2011, he was the backup to Tim Thomas, a silver medalist for Team USA in the 2010 Olympics and the eventual Stanley Cup MVP. His regular season stats were very impressive but his playoff motif (quite possibly as well as the whole team) seemed to be as if he/they ran out of gas when it mattered most. For those of you that are curious about the rest of my all time Bruins team, I have:
Patrice Bergeron - C
Brad Marchand - LW
Cam Neely - RW
Bobby Orr - D
Ray Bourque - D
In all likelihood, David Pasternak will probably replace Cam Neely
This list was suspect as soon as I heard Kiprusoff 😂😂 riiight
why suspect lol?
Roy at number one and its not even close. Playoffs matter most and his lead over the competition in playoff wins is absurd, 2 full cup runs of a lead.
Hahahaha no the dominator is number one all the way
Fair enough, what woudl your other top5’s look like
I disagree. Dryden, Smith, Plante, and Fuhr all have better career winning percentages. Roy would be fifth or sixth on my list. Just because he has played more playoff games doesn’t make him better.
It means that in must win games he was trusted more then anyone, and he delivered. Its not that he is first, its the lead in the category that seals it. 151 to 113 and in 42 more games played he only has 3 more loses then Brodeur. 3 times playoff mvp, 4 cups. Its fine to pick whoever you like but give credit where its due@@Jimbob35775
So true. Roy by a mile.
Firstly, stop adding incorrect subtitles at 3:21 and stop adding throughout the entire video if you don't know how to write captions.
Also it is blocking the video view.
Thx for feedback :) was it so frustrating?
Hasek is great. He was under 6ft tall small frame but acrobatic and amazing to watch. 7 vezinas wearing a cage mask and pads no bigger then an actual Maxi pad (probably) . Now goalies are like 6.5 ft.
Good old times, right?
Goalies who play without a helmet should be moved up the list for that reason alone
lol, biggest respect point :P new list?
You forgot Roberto luongo and marc-andre fleury
Ron hextall
@@mikegravel5310 No harsh feelings but Loungo, Fluery and Hextall arent good enough for this list.
@@type4647 Check your stats, Fleury is #2 for wins, and Luongo is #4.
@@nathanadrian7797 Have your eyes checked and your likely fan-boy blindness relieved. All the goalies on this list won both the Cup and Vezina trophy (with all goalies on this list winning either the SC or Vezina multiple times) , besides being named either to more than two all-star teams or being a first team all-star. Luongo in 20 years never won the Vezina or a Stanley Cup, and he made only 2 all-star teams on the second team. Marc-Andre Fleury has a 20+ year career and only made the all-star team once. Fleury was a 2nd team all-star in the same year he nudged out Vasilevskiy for his only Vezina. Fluery only won it because of his comeback story in Vegas after he was a back-up/benched in Pittsburgh for several seasons (Vasilevskiy was the first team all-star goalie in that same year Fleury won the Vezina) . Please differentiate between a good-very good player and an all time top 15 list of goalies on which Luongo and Fleury have no legitimate place being.
@@type4647 Nice try, but I am neither a fan of Luongo nor Fleury, nor do I root for any team that they have played for. Winning the cup is a team accomplishment, and although Luongo got close with Vancouver, he never played for a team able to get it done. Being in the top 5 winningest goalies of all time, should be enough to make the top 15!
Good Lord this is bad...
Yeah, just because you can make a RUclips video doesn't mean you should. LOL
Ken Dryden by a mile... 6 Stanley cup in 8 years !
Yes, Ken Dryden was very s.Uccessful, but you gotta remember.He played for an All Star team.Dominic Hasek put his numbers up with very little in front of him.He was the all star team
From my era, my favourites!
Patrick Roy
Ron Hextall
Ed Belfour
Dominik Hasek
Felix Potvin
Curtis Joseph
Martin Brodeur
Mike Richter
In No specific order😉👌
Honorable mentions
Arturs Irbe
Miikka Kiprusoff
Mike Vernon
John Vanbiesbrouck
thanks dude nice list!! which list next?
Late 80's-90's to early 2000's was loaded with great goaltending. 🤨 Today Nothing! There's good goaltending but GREAT goaltending has gone extinct.
Best ever. Jacques Plante. Made the mask part of a goalies regular equipment. Was the first to leave the crease to help the defence. Six Stanley cups. Six vezinas when the vezina wasn't a popularity contest and meant something. Remember Hasek won a second cup but got pulled because he was a sieve and was replaced by Osgood. Plante. Not just statistics but the top goalie innovator.
I prefer lists that match certain era's in hockey. And while stats and awared are the major factors when assessing the best, its not the whole story for goalies playing on mediocre teams.
With that in mind, my list for the 70s (the best decade in the history of human kind) would include Gilles Villemure, Ed Giacomin, Gerry Cheevers, Gilles Gilbert, Roggie Vachon, Roger Crozier, Doug Favell, Dan Bouchard, Michel Larocque, Gary Smith. Am I missing any? I loved that era of goaltending with the outlandish masks, rudimentary equipment and amazing acrobatic skills. They played on instinct and reflex. Nowhere near as effective as modern goalies but more spectacular. And after all, its the spectacle that counts.
This would be my pitch for the 10 best NHL goalies.
1. Patrick Roy
2. Dominik Hasek
3. Martin Brodeur
4. Marc-Andre Fleury
5. Roberto Luongo
6. Ed Belfour
7. Henrik Lundqvist
8. Terry Sawchuk
9. Jacques Plante
10. Ken Dryden
(BONUS) Best ever international goalkeeper:
1. Vladislav Tretiak - Sovietunion.
is this your worst or best list :P?
said nhl......old tretiak never played
@@daman9780 That is why I presented it as international = representing a players country on international tournaments against other countries.
Not a national league!
@@WarioSaysSo video is about nhl goalies...
Marc-Andre Fleury
Get it right...
Tony Esposito helped Team Canada salvage 1972 Summit Series against the surprisingly powerful Soviets.
You picked Billy Smith and managed to not show a single Billy Smith clip.
Might want to double check your work next tine.
Right?! What the hell was that?
Yup. That was Bill Durnan, Canadiens legend.
Yeah, I noticed that too.
That annoyed me, completely disrespecting one of the best playoff goalies of all time
Billy Smith ? For dirtiest yes.
So as a life-long Boston Bruins fanatic, Ken Dryden, IMO, might be a litter closer to the top of the heap. As a kid, my list of enemies was, in order:
1. Montreal Canadiens
2. Satan
3. Ken Dryden
4. Montreal fans
5. Montreal steak seasoning
I understand except for Satan they’re all the best
I’m glad we have the same enemy in Satan
Buddy cant even Pronounce Grant Fuhrs name lmao
Okay bobby
Grant Fur and Veznas 🤣
Who is Grant Furr? People won’t take you seriously if you mispronounce names of players that well known. Not hard to learn how to pronounce the names before you do the video.
Good point :) thanks, do you think different languages say certain names different?
Also some people on these list are pretty old school, not THAT common names nowadays, wouldnt u say?
@@icebox.hockey It’s possible that there are different pronunciations depending on the country, but it’s an NHL list, so it’s safe to use the NHL pronunciation. It’s not hard to RUclips or google a certain player to get that pronunciation. And Fuhr isn’t nearly as old school as most on that list. And btw it’s pronounced fewer not Furr.
Roy is the Goat Most clutch player of the playoffs.
@@icebox.hockeyThat's exactly why when you make these fucking videos do some fucking research first kid then you don't look like a dumbass
Holy crap Dryden played from 1970 to 1997 lol
Pretty crazy right
He played from 1970-79
@@icebox.hockey Yup, Dryden had won a pile of cups and left the NHL in his prime to pursue other interests, nothing more to it than that. Gotta admire him for quitting the game at his peak!
Hasek is the best golie in nhl history.
Jerry Cheevers,Ken Dryden,Billy Smith,so many.
Ken Dryden won the Conn Smythe Trophy as Playoff MVP in 1971. In 1972, Dryden won the Calder Trophy as Rookie of the Year.
I'd put Sawchuk at number 1, had he played as many games per season that Marty and Roy did, he'd have unbreakable records, also missing from the list is Georges Vezina...he played in an era where Goalies were not allowed to drop to the Ice or it was a Penalty and he still has awesome numbers.
Btw I have Mike Vernon as the greatest Flames Goalie ever, considering he won a Cup with the Flames and is in the HOF, as Miikka Kiprusoff is neither.
Ty dude :) appreciate it
Agreed. And a shout out to Roger Crozier. Won the Calder, the Conny, and was the last goalie to play every game for his team.
Honestly one of the toughest lists to make that there is.
Ty for trying dude’n
Very nice list. Fleury, Luongo, Belfour could easily be on it.
Good call! Part 2 ?
Because of 2001 I would place Roy ahead of Brodeur , And Ed Balfour should be somewhere on the list, he edged out Hasek for the Cup back in 1999.
pffffff ROY won the conn symthe trophy (mvp in the playoffs) 3 times...THE ONLY PLAYER TO DO SO....beat martin brodeur in the 2001 stanley cup finals and ...5 time winner of the jennings award.......most playoff games played and career playoff WINS.!!!!...played in 11 National Hockey League All-Star games....Roy won over 200 games with two franchises (Montreal and Colorado).....and who can forget the "WINK" at tomas sandstrom in the stanley cup final!!! .....record for games played by a goalie (1,029), victories (551), minutes played (60,235) and most 30-plus victory seasons (13).......first NHL goaltender to win 500 games.......most NHL playoff wins by a goaltender (151).....most NHL playoff games played by a goaltender (247) (third-most playoff games of ALL players !!!).........4 time stanley cup winner......every record that was set by roy took brodeur LONGER to break......only reason brodeur beats roy's records was broduer played 22 seasons in the league and roy 19......and roy ranks second??.......THIS LIST IS A JOKE!
Thanks man appreciate your thought ;) which list u wanna see next? Ill use your inlut for it you seem knowledgeable!!
Let's see your video
it is impossible to rank any position because we have seen so much greatness over the years that it really comes down to preference... I mean in a game 7 do you take prime Hasek or prime Roy?.... It comes down to preference. For me I take Hasek, because he had/has way more experience in situations like that - but you cant go wrong with Roy either.... It's like Lemieux vs Gretzky .... I suppose my point is that some of these goalies are so good that you will get the same result out of both, so it doesn't matter and you cant rank them... It's all subjective...
Fair… still fun to debate and reflect on these great players
Patrick Roy is the GOAT
you need to take a look at Osgoods numbers. he also started the series that got Hasek his 2nd ring
Why isn’t Marc-André Fleury on? Cause he still playing ?
I agree that MA-F is a fine choice for the top 15 goalies of all time but you wouldn’t think so the way the LA Kings jumped out to a 5-0 lead on the Wild Wednesday night 🙈
Ken Dryden was my hero. Especially that first playoff 70 to 71
You forgot to mention that Tony Espositio won the cup with the habs in 69. You also forgot to mention that Dryden won the calder in 71 and was also second in Hart voting that year.
so Roy was # 2 with no video
I have brodeurs stick what do I do with it
long before forrest gump there was a goaie named "gump" worsley. it is the best goalie nick name.
The sub titles have to be AI generated 😂
Haha they are, u know how much work that is manually?
I will admit that hockey has the most unique names in all North American sports.
Who were you showing in the Billy Smith clips? He never played for the Habs
Love RJ's calls
Please let someone have a look on your work before you put it online
please give more feedback on this :)? its easy to say this wouthout further breakdown? also it does not help at all to just make this comment. break it down, put in some effort. im justtrying here too ;)
Your section for Billy Smith is completely incorrect. It has a photo of a goalkeeper from a different sport, and goalies from the 1950’s when Smith played in the 80’s.
The greatest goalie ever Murray B-A-N-N-E-R-M-A-N!!!!!!!!!!!
helllyesss
Hasek, period.
bahaaaaaahhaaaa
Billy Smith is a hometown hero from Perth ontario Canada
Billy Smith should be in the top 5 Bernie Parent should be higher as well. Dryden is in the right spot. But any goalie who wins 4 straight Stanley Cups should be in the top 5.
Fair, anyone else?
@@icebox.hockey No the rest are set up in at least my opinion in the right order. But I would definitely put Smith above Furh because of the 4 in a row and no one has beaten his playoff series wins in a row either. But it's your list and again it's my opinion.
Brodure is definitely not #1 22 years doesn't make him the best
Patrick Roy is number 1 no one even come close to his playoff record!
YEAH! he was soo great and had to deal with soo much adversity. I mean, when he was on his first team that wasn't a top quarter team in the nhl, he had a bad game, threw a hissy fit, and then got traded to a new team that was a top quarter team in the NHL. That's how you know you're a great goaltender.
What would your list look like?
@icebox.hockey depends on if you're talking about a career or skill. I'll go off of career
1: Brodeur
2:Roy
3:Hasek
4:Dryden
5:Sawchuck
6:Hall
7:Plante
8:Belfour
9:Lundqvist
10:Fleury
Finally, even as a devils fan, I'd be more than willing to move lundqvist up. He didn't get a cup and only captured one vezina, but from 2005-2015, he finished every year in the top 6 in vezina voting. That level of consistent great play is outstanding. It's brodeur like. It's part of the reason I say rask was the best goalie of the 2010s. No other goalie that decade had such consistently good play. Some had great seasons, even rask, but during that time, rask's save percentage never dipped below a 91.2. Every other goalie did.
Also out of the top 3, they're more mobile. But, that's my list off the top of my head right now
So let's say you're at game 7 in a stanley cup finals and you can choose between Roy or Brodeur who would it be? You might have to redo this video ;)
You showed Bill Durnan instead of Billy Smith,but the big bill was one of the best in his era,the only goalie ambidextres.
thanks for headsup dude sharp
Look, obviously this is subjective but Hasek was just so amazing... I mean he got peppered at times, meanwhile guys like Roy had a solid defense in front of him and Brodeur played behind "The Trap" so he saw limited shots..... Fuhr and Smith shouldn't be on this list AT ALL.. Both were "adequate" for their respective teams at the time - but nothing "special"... And Dryden is another one.. If you're going to put him on the list then why not "Bunny" Laraque?.......
I think (and obviously this is just my opinion) Hasek is #1 - at least as far as goalies I have witnessed.
Hasek is #1 but Check out what Billy Smith did to Gretzky and the Oilers in the 83 Stanley Cup and then try to find someone who did better in all of history. Only one team did better and they did it against Scott Mellanby and the Panthers Not Gretzky's Oilers
Fair, maybe make more parts dependant on timelimes
Hasek is the best in the regular season but I don't care. There's a lot more pressure in the playoffs and that's where you see the real winners. Roy is the only player with 3 Conn Smythes trophies and he has the most playoff victories. And 4 Cups. He is the GOAT.
Marty is Lebron. Dude only has the most wins is because he played forever.
In the top all time you don't include the man the award is named after? The Chicoutimi Cucumber himself Georges Vezina ?? Yet you have Turk Broda?
roy 33!!!
now that we ranked the BEST goalies, who were the WORST goalies? comment your top 3 and we might feature you in next video
ZERO footage of your #2 entry?? You've got to be kidding me.
Hasek is the number one what ever you may say. There is or was no one better.
How did you leave out Lundqvist
I’m under two minutes in. I see things like “safe percentage “ and “Fesna” trophies. Unbelievable.
You should be embarrassed.
Why?
He got # 1 right
Ive got;
1. Sawchuk - Played every single game in barely any equipment and stopped near everything.
2. Roy - 2 Cups, Best of the Best generation.
3. Tretiak - Best International, also honed both Hasek and Belfour.
4. Hasek - The Dominator.
5. Brodeur - Big Stats and 3 Cups.
6. Dryden - Short but Sweet.
7. Plante - OG.
8. Smith - 4 Straight Cups.
9. Bower - 4 Cups/No Mask.
10. Belfour - Personal Fave.
11. Fleury - 3 Cups and Longevity.
12. Quick - Multiple Cups..2012.
13. Esposito - Underrated. 3 Vezinas.
14. Lundqvist - Representin' Scandinavia.
15 - Hall - I guess, I guess he was pretty good.
When he came to Toronto he didn't play every single game. He and Johnny Bower alternated a lot. That year, when they won the Stanley Cup, they were the best tandem in the NHL. Two of the best all time goalies on the same team.
Hall was great
Sat through the painful mispronunciation of Grant Fuhr....got to Dominik Hasek being ranked #4 and had to give up. This video is painful to watch 🤣🤣🤣
Dom Hasek at 4 and not one? I'm sure this guy will never be a scout for an NHL team. Dom faced the greatest players in the world.
Number 1 is Dominic hashik
Fleury should be in the top 10.
2 Fesnas?
Spelling mistakes?
Makes u mad?
@@icebox.hockeyProfessional or not?
THACHER DEMKO!!!!!🐐🥅
Letssss get it
Frederik Andersen is the number 1 now!
Sorry. But his name is not pronounced fur.
MARTY MARTY
Where is Patrick Roy?
His name is : Martin Brodeur.
Get it right...
What exactly?
BRODORS and FESNAS
Grant Fur???
Patrick Roy is such a baby.
Yep
Roman Cechmanek B-)
Dominik Hasek is the best
Why?
Obviously Hasek is at 1!
V - E - Z - I - N- A
lol@subtitles
list is a Joke if Hasek isnt 1st
It is if Sawchuk or Plante isn't number 1
I respect your rankings and appreciate your attempt to honor my favorite position on the ice, but you need to re-do the video with better videos and photos. You botched my favorite goalie Billy Smith showing one photo and no video (I don´t know what that was you put up there) when there´s a ton online to choose from.
ty appreciate your feedback. would you rather just see imagre slideshows from these older players and footage?
Ken Dryden is the goat
Why didn't u show any Roy highlights? I'm a Devils fan but Roy is the best.
fair enough..
Was Hank on this list? Hasek was the best of all time.
Put Hasek on the same teams that played in front of Brodeur and Roy and Dom would have won a half-dozen Cups.
Same for Carey Price
Glenn Hall should be higher
Why do you call Grant Fuhr as fur?
Because i wanted to piss you off marty
Because you're a goof.....
6:48 why does it say 70-97
Chris Osgood, look at his stats before you laugh
amen
I looked and still laughed.
Super underrated goaltender for sure.
Osgood? Buddy lay off the meth.....
Where is CUJO
I was hoping this would be good....
and?
Martin Brodeur hahahahahaha
No?
My dude, you have got to at least spell the names right. Marty Broder is not impressed.
Good energy in your narration delivery, though. Keep at it and learn from the criticism.
Thanks for the view!! You mean captions in video itself?
Old man bias
Why? Whats yours look like
You mention luongo and Fleury 😂😂😂😂.....but leave out Billy Smith and Mike Richter?? Putting up Numbers may say on paper you're a great athlete...but clutch players are what makes them legendary... I'll give you a gold star for the effort .....but the execution, yikes.....ya got alot to learn kiddo .
Like what travis :)? Thanks for sharing YOUR opinion though, kiddo ;)
@@icebox.hockey my pleasure 😁 always glad to help a rookie out. ( Check out the 96 world cup, Richter was a TREMENDOUS factor in the U.S beating the most brutal & talented Canadian team ...facts)
I think you had Dryden too far down the list. Where were Potvin, Balfour, Price, Lundqvist, Fleury...
whats your top 10 then?
@@icebox.hockey That is so tough, and there are so many great goal tenders. It would take me a month to of studying stats to come up with a top 10.
i studied for 2 months actually@@nathanadrian7797
I turned off after you couldn’t spell Johnny Bower’s name right. SMH