Your discourses are absolutely phenomenal! I can’t wait to see more on literature and books. Your knowledge deserves to be shared, and your thoughts should be voiced, whether people like them or not.
Strangely, I have read all these books you are dealing with on RUclips...! Yes, you are interesting... Keep it up for a larger audience... People must know about these books... My best wishes....
میری رائے میں کافکا نے اپنی اس تحریرمیں انسانی زندگی کی اس بے مقصدیت اور لاچارگی کی طرف اشارہ کیا ہے جسے ہر انسان نہ چاہتے ہوئے بھی گذارنے پر مجبور ہے یہی وہ فلسفہ ہے جسے وجودیت کہا جاتا ہے یعنی زندگی کا کوئی مقصد نہیں ہے تمہیں ہر آن ایک مقدمے کا سامنا ہے اور تمہیں کسی بھی لمحے موت کی نیند سلایا جا سکتا ہے اور تم یہ سب کچھ جانتے ہوئے بھی اس زندگی کو گذارنے پر مجبور ہو دیکھنے کی بات یہ ہے کہ کافکا نے کس خوبصورتی سے اپنی بات کو بیان کیاہے یہی ایک عظیم لکھاری کی پہچان ہوتی ہے، آپ جو کام کر رہے ہیں وہ بہت قابل تحسین ہے
शायद काफ्का इस उपन्यास में दो दुनिया का एक साथ जिक्र करता है एक बाहरी दुनिया और एक दिमाग के अंदर चलने वाली दुनिया दोनों में ही पता नहीं चलता कि अपराध क्या है पर खुद को सही साबित करने की कोशिश करता इंसान एक दिन सजायाफ्ता जाता हो जाता है l
Beshak 2 ghanty ki video ho jaye..par apany tafsel se "Divine comedy " bian karne hy....mainay or logu ki be suni hay..par maza nea aya ..apkay side nots kaml hejan angezi paida kartay hain...
Uska case to bohot pehle hi sot out ho gaya tha...use ruk jana chahiye tha..ab eske sath uska koyi nata na raha....lekin wo bar bar ake usi matter pe apni nak ghuserne laga aur anjane me apne dher sare dushman bana liye... or baad me apni jaan se hath dho baitha...😮
Hahahah I just finished reading that last week - it is great. But it is very American, I mean that historical north south conflict, not sure if people would like to listen to that - will see. Thanks
Haan kafka apna novels incomplete chor deta tha....kafi kaam jala bhi dia...kafi zaya ho gaya....agar Max Brod na hota tou shayad kuch bhi na bachta---he had self doubts about his ability as a writer
अस्सल में, Kafka राइटर है यथार्थ (reality) का, जिंदगी की कड़वी सच्चाई का, इस कायनात में इंसान के मामूलीपन का, उसकी बेबसी और लाचारी का, बेरहम दुनिया में एक आम आदमी पर नाइंसाफी का, उसकी बदनसीबी का ..😢😮
Bilkul yahi halat hai hamare khaskar diwani dawe ki kutte se bad tar mera sivil thoda sa rood ke paiso ka 11 sal huwe 2014 se abhi calu hai kes ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉
@@3rd_POVI live in Makli, Thatta home to an amazing historical site with ancient tombs and incredible architecture. If you ever visit I will show you around. It’s a UNESCO World Heritage Site super peaceful, and full of history You will love it and by the I'm a government elementary school teacher.
Two men from different times, Josef K. from Kafka's timeless classic '' The Trial'' and Imran Khan, share a similar fate. Both are caught in a web of injustice where the truth is twisted, and they are left to struggle through a never-ending maze of despair. Josef K. faced a trial without knowing his crime, just as Imran Khan is persecuted without a clear reason. Both are victims of a system that values power over justice, punishing the innocent while protecting the guilty. Kafka wrote, "It was as if the shame of it must outlive him." Let's ensure this shame doesn’t outlive us. Let’s raise our voices for Imran Khan, for the truth, and for justice. Kafka reminds us, "The truth is always an abyss." In this abyss, we must find the courage to stand up for what is right. _______Courtesy Sardarzada Sahir from his Facebook page ❣️
Have some respect for people, it appears that you are narrating about some mean person. Don’t forget that you are trying to earn money by using novel of Kafka , show some manners
Ali bhai, I wait whole week for your video
Your discourses are absolutely phenomenal! I can’t wait to see more on literature and books. Your knowledge deserves to be shared, and your thoughts should be voiced, whether people like them or not.
Thx
You are soooo good man and in the end the poetry of Faiz was a cherry over the cake.
YEAH HIS LOVE FOR POETRY SPEAKS LOUD
Aapka, Geet chaturvedi aur Vikas divaykirti sir ka shukriya itne achche se philosophy samjhane ke liye
Thx - yes they are both doing a great job.
Vikas sir is very selfish and clever
Well said
True. Geet sir is legend
मैंने यह किताब अंग्रेज़ी में बहुत पहले पढ़ी थी, फिर से हिंदी में सुन कर, अच्छा लग रहा हैं!!!🎉❤🎉❤
Strangely, I have read all these books you are dealing with on RUclips...!
Yes, you are interesting... Keep it up for a larger audience... People must know about these books...
My best wishes....
Video mat rokna sir . I am really enjoying your narrations
Please forward my videos in your groups
Amazing narration.
It reminds me of situation in our. Country these days
Love the background music, it makes it very interesting to listen;). Great work. Listening in Canada, moving back to Punjab India after 24 years.
Thx
Spellbinding narration ! It was all symbolic, you shall share your interpretation as well.
Bht accha andaz byan
Thanks
آپ کو دیر سے دریافت کیا لیکن پچھلے ایک ہفتے سے آپ کی ویڈیوز دیکھ رہا ہوں
Wah sain wah great explanation of my favorite kafka
Thanks for understandable narration
Excellent video on the Trial novel
Amamual kant ki book "critique of pure reasoning" pe be apny detail video banani hay....
Amazing narration. Keep up the good work
I am really grateful for your knowledge
😯😯😯...
🌹🌹🌹...
Very interisting bro...
Keep posting your videos are enlightening
زبردست ۔۔۔جوزف وھمی تھا
lol
It's like being in a dream. Thanks
thankyou bhai. do continue your workkkkkk sir.
Thank you, I will
Excellent and informative
حقائق سے منہ چھپانے کے لئے انسان تصوراتی دنیا میں رہنا چاھتا ہے ۔
میری رائے میں کافکا نے اپنی اس تحریرمیں انسانی زندگی کی اس بے مقصدیت اور لاچارگی کی طرف اشارہ کیا ہے جسے ہر انسان نہ چاہتے ہوئے بھی گذارنے پر مجبور ہے یہی وہ فلسفہ ہے جسے وجودیت کہا جاتا ہے یعنی زندگی کا کوئی مقصد نہیں ہے تمہیں ہر آن ایک مقدمے کا سامنا ہے اور تمہیں کسی بھی لمحے موت کی نیند سلایا جا سکتا ہے اور تم یہ سب کچھ جانتے ہوئے بھی اس زندگی کو گذارنے پر مجبور ہو دیکھنے کی بات یہ ہے کہ کافکا نے کس خوبصورتی سے اپنی بات کو بیان کیاہے یہی ایک عظیم لکھاری کی پہچان ہوتی ہے، آپ جو کام کر رہے ہیں وہ بہت قابل تحسین ہے
Totally agreed with your statement- thanks
Atleast I am learning alot from you Sir.. Respects for u..
Thx
amazing storytelling ❤
Thank you! 🙂
शायद काफ्का इस उपन्यास में दो दुनिया का एक साथ जिक्र करता है एक बाहरी दुनिया और एक दिमाग के अंदर चलने वाली दुनिया दोनों में ही पता नहीं चलता कि अपराध क्या है पर खुद को सही साबित करने की कोशिश करता इंसान एक दिन सजायाफ्ता जाता हो जाता है l
Good point- totally agree.
One of my favorite frenz kafka
Great work ,
Thx
Sir background music distrub kr rhi hai 🙏✨
good
Very informative 👏 keep it up... love from Gulshan e Iqbal.
kiya hi acha hoo ta aap apni interpretation de te ta ke relate tu ker sak te ke what is it all about.
Beshak 2 ghanty ki video ho jaye..par apany tafsel se "Divine comedy " bian karne hy....mainay or logu ki be suni hay..par maza nea aya ..apkay side nots kaml hejan angezi paida kartay hain...
Ok - will do soon. Thx
लाज़वाब व्याख्या महोदय ❤️
Thanks
6:24 that was a good pun😄 idk if it was intended or not but it does make sense...Quality content as always🤍
Zabardast.
Please upload videos every week.
Thanks
Thankyou so much sir, you are great ❤
Uska case to bohot pehle hi sot out ho gaya tha...use ruk jana chahiye tha..ab eske sath uska koyi nata na raha....lekin wo bar bar ake usi matter pe apni nak ghuserne laga aur anjane me apne dher sare dushman bana liye... or baad me apni jaan se hath dho baitha...😮
If someone wants to read Urdu Translation of "The Trial" it is available in the market: Muqadma (translated by Manzoor Ahmed)
Just watched all your videos, plz do a video on cormac macharty blood meridian.
Hahahah I just finished reading that last week - it is great. But it is very American, I mean that historical north south conflict, not sure if people would like to listen to that - will see. Thanks
Please make a video on haruki murakami's novels .
Thanks and Regards
Sir dantay ki Divine comedy poem pe video banye..
Ok - yes it is in my list.
Amazing Narration
Thx
Thx
EXCELLENT
Thanks
*inStructive & inFormative*
Sir pLs explain another book divine comedy.
Yes for sure, divine comedy is in the pipeline. Thx
Sir kafka ke novel me story kya end bagair kisi end ke ho jaata h ..kahin iska reason unka kaam poora na hona h ya wo khud end aisa hi karte the 🙄🙄
Haan kafka apna novels incomplete chor deta tha....kafi kaam jala bhi dia...kafi zaya ho gaya....agar Max Brod na hota tou shayad kuch bhi na bachta---he had self doubts about his ability as a writer
Love the translation of flogging to Chitrol!😂
Please do a video on 1984 by George Orwelll
Presentation acchi h .writer ki nazar us tome ki sarkar k kamkaj ko difine karti h
Yeah he represents the Jewish anxiety of his time
We in India are caught in a similar situation and the judiciary is virtually under the control of present rulers. Entered into dark ages.
Please Lower the music
This is our Life
Zabardast ❤
Tq from India
Why your channel name is 3rdpov
Because I will give you a third perspective on things!!!
Then write 3rd perspective your channel name which give your channel great visibility@@3rd_POV
Hmmm thanks - let me think about it.
Kindly give Respect to the Writer🌻
Its ok bro. These writers are great in their literatures so never mind even we call our supreme God in the same way
अस्सल में, Kafka राइटर है यथार्थ (reality) का, जिंदगी की कड़वी सच्चाई का, इस कायनात में इंसान के मामूलीपन का, उसकी बेबसी और लाचारी का, बेरहम दुनिया में एक आम आदमी पर नाइंसाफी का, उसकी बदनसीबी का ..😢😮
Agreed
मेरे पसंदीदा लेखक, जो मरने के बाद प्रसिद्द हुए!!!🎉❤🎉❤
❤❤❤❤❤❤thanks 🙏
Thanks
Bilkul yahi halat hai hamare khaskar diwani dawe ki kutte se bad tar mera sivil thoda sa rood ke paiso ka 11 sal huwe 2014 se abhi calu hai kes ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉
Haha
Your content voice tone so amazing you helped me a lot to improve my life routine sleep you are great I want to meet you in person
Hey thanks - which city are you based in?
@@3rd_POVI live in Makli, Thatta home to an amazing historical site with ancient tombs and incredible architecture. If you ever visit I will show you around. It’s a UNESCO World Heritage Site super peaceful, and full of history You will love it and by the I'm a government elementary school teacher.
thank you boss
Welcome
Best
Barai maherbani, apni Audio theak karai
Will fix it
Sir, are you from Pakistan?
Yes!
जहां तक यही समझ आया कि koffa ने अपने सपने को शब्दों में लिख दिया बस
Name sir
Bhai mera naam Ali Hassan hai.
❤ vid.
❤❤❤
Bhai ye kya ho rha hai?
❤❤
Sir, where do you live, because how can you speak so openly despite living in Pakistan?
Well people are not less oppressed and suppressed in your own country
Two men from different times, Josef K. from Kafka's timeless classic '' The Trial'' and Imran Khan, share a similar fate. Both are caught in a web of injustice where the truth is twisted, and they are left to struggle through a never-ending maze of despair.
Josef K. faced a trial without knowing his crime, just as Imran Khan is persecuted without a clear reason. Both are victims of a system that values power over justice, punishing the innocent while protecting the guilty.
Kafka wrote, "It was as if the shame of it must outlive him." Let's ensure this shame doesn’t outlive us. Let’s raise our voices for Imran Khan, for the truth, and for justice.
Kafka reminds us, "The truth is always an abyss." In this abyss, we must find the courage to stand up for what is right.
_______Courtesy Sardarzada Sahir from his Facebook page ❣️
Apne unke liye ek achhi bhasha ka prayog nhi kiya hai
Yar that's my normal style- I did not disrespect him
bhai ye to pakistan ki kahani hai 😆
Hahahaha
Have some respect for people, it appears that you are narrating about some mean person. Don’t forget that you are trying to earn money by using novel of Kafka , show some manners
I did not mean any disrespect
❤
Thx
❤❤
❤