Futile hypocrisy! The world merely envisages to instrumentalize Taiwan for its interest and take the civilians in hostage. Furthermore, semiconductors escalade exclusively the industrial bias in Taiwan and even elevate the prize of immobilities. As a result, both of the phenomenons eliminate the diversity of occupations indirectly.
Well, China is also part of the UN, but stakes are high, just like what the US did to Japan, let history repeat itself to say let Taiwan be fully support of Israel 100% and then let Israel do to China to what the US did to Japan in 1945, the only difference is that Taiwan will be incorporated by the new government formed in China that is backed by Israel.
@@Embargoman Israel does not support China taking over Taiwan. Also Israel is a tiny country with very little global political power. The UN is corrupt. And the USA is not helping Taiwan like it does to Japan.
USA and the West agree Taiwan is part of China. People in Taiwan don't see China as enemy. They just worry that China's system may not be suitable for them.
Some interesting facts of Taiwan many people don't know ❤️: Its Constitution: "Constitution of the Republic of China". Its flagship air flight company: "China Airlines". Its biggest oil company: "China Petrol". Its biggest steel company: "China Steel". Its postal Service: "China Post". Its biggest telecom provider: "China Telecommunications". Its flagship medicine university: "China Medical University".
As an employee of TSMC, I must say that a significant part of TSMC's success comes from the diligence, resilience, and responsibility of its Taiwanese workforce. Moreover, these employees are highly educated. Many even prioritize the company's importance over family. This dedication is precisely why it is challenging for other countries to replicate this success.
@@wellowline6480 The PRC gained power through force. The ROC (Taiwan) is a sovereign state authorized by voters. The Communist Party launched an armed rebellion in the ROC and split the ROC. In 1949, Chairman Mao declared independence and established the PRC. Chairman Mao was telling the world that there was not only the ROC in the world, but also a new country, the PRC.
Taiwan is different from Japan and Korea in that it is a small economy. Japan and Korea are among the top 10 economies in the world and they develop their cities and industries based on huge capital. However, Taiwan is a small economy and does not have much capital. In fact, Taiwan is more amazing!
TSMC is one of the top 10 largest companies in the world, and Nvidia, founded by Taiwanese, is one of the top three. No company in Europe, Japan, or South Korea is among the top 10.
@@黃先生-p2l I don't know if what you say is true, but Taiwan's economy is definitely undervalued... Taiwan is probably one of the most vibrant emerging economies in Asia. Taiwan have a great potential to become a developed country.
@@StarSystem-p3i The total income revenue of Samsung is 1900 billion USD in 2023 but the net profit is 4.8 billion USD in 2023. However, the income revenue of TSMC is 670 billion USD and the net profit is 27 billion USD in 2023. Although Samsung is excellent for her phones but TSMC focuses on technique solution and authorizes patents, IC layout and technique for her clients. That is why TSMC can earn more money than Samsung. MTK, which is a TW smartphone CPU and chipset company and has the highest market share (39%) of smartphone CPU, better than 25% of Qualcomm and 6.2% of Samaung.
I learned something new about Taiwan's economic miracle, even as a Taiwanese. I often wonder which policy helped Taiwan become such a wealthy nation, even after the United Nations abandoned us in the 1970s
@@Lanlousman, Japan is going thru crisis tho. They’re stagnant due to this mentality of savings. The government has been easing rates, but Japanese don’t spend. Japan has a much bigger problem to worry about. Yen is depreciating and Japan holds mostly USD as reserves. Japan is not hedged.
Cách thức Đài Loan trở nên con rồng châu á củng giống như Hàn Quốc , là sự kết hợp của nhiều yếu tố : 1. Được Mỹ , Nhật, Phương Tây hỗ trợ về tiền bạc và công nghệ và cả các đơn hàng để trở nên mạnh về kinh tế , Để làm thành trì chống lại khối XHCN lúc bấy giờ . Mỹ rất cần điều này. 2. Là yếu tố, tố chất con người , các nước như Hàn Quốc, Đài Loan mang gen Đông Á ,họ rất mạnh mẽ , thông minh, rất ham học tập, khôn ngoan trong thương mại và siêng năng , chăm chỉ , tiết kiệm và ý chí làm giàu cao. Khác với một số nước như thái lan, Philippines mặc dù là đồng minh Mỹ như con người rất kém cỏi. 3. Có những nhà quản lý, lãnh đạo giàu ý chí và khát vọng lớn. 4. Phát triển trong giai đoạn ít phải bị cạnh tranh như bây giờ, hiện tại.
@@genuinennessbefitting4734 Do you know the former president of Taiwan Tsai was a mix of Hakka and Paiwan aboriginal? Taiwanese aborigines are Austronesian people like many Southeast Asian. Besides, most of Southeast Asian Chinese populations are Hokkien, Cantonese, and Hakka people like many ethnic Chinese in Taiwan. What "facts" do you have?
@@bctvanw Taiwan's aboriginal people only account for 2.5% of the population. Almost all of Taiwan's high-tech companies were founded by the old Chinese who retreated from China. TSMC, UMC, FOXCONN, and many other high-tech companies are almost all from other provinces in China. You don’t know anything about Taiwan. I assisted Taiwan Semiconductor in raising funds in 1987.
I am a Taiwanese, and this video does an excellent job of explaining the topic in an easy-to-understand way. Taiwan is an island nation deeply influenced by the Dutch, Japanese, and Chinese. Terms like *import substitution, export expansion, and science and industrial parks* are often mentioned in Taiwanese textbooks regarding the country’s economic history. Although Taiwanese people occasionally criticize the government for its slow administrative efficiency and bureaucratic rigidity from a business perspective (for example, the high tariffs on automobiles meant to protect domestic production. In contrast to South Korea, where high car tariffs fostered the globally renowned Hyundai, Taiwan’s high tariffs over decades have not significantly improved its automobile industry. The domestic car brand, Luxgen isn’t even popular among Taiwanese people. -we mockingly nickname it LE SE JUN -a pun meaning "garbage germ.")- overall, most people still trust the government’s long-term economic policies. We continue to work hard toward achieving the "Taiwanese Dream" of owning the "Five Essentials to Success"-savings, a car, a house, marriage, and children.
The map shown at the end of the video, which paints both China and Taiwan in red, is erroneous. Taiwan, an independent state with sovereignty of its own, should be highlighted with another color! On the other hand, the Hai-Nan Island located southern of China with a size a little short of that of Taiwan is part of China, and should be colored red!
Because Taiwan people work very hard !!! And for parents hard working, most of Taiwanese grandparents take care of their grandchildren . So, this is a really special social situation. “Everybody works really hard!” When people retire from their jobs, they don’t really retire. Because they will take care of grandchildren. Even many women still work when they have children.( Because they get supported from family!)
I am Taiwanese. Thank you to the United States, Japan, the Netherlands and other countries that have helped Taiwan. Taiwan upholds gratitude, peace, co-prosperity, equality and democracy and does its best for the world. Thank you❤
It is very difficult for china to capture taiwan because taiwan have support of usa in every field of economy military softpower in every ways and one of the biggest reason usa military are so strong 840 billions dollars and very Advance military tactics 🇺🇲❤️🇹🇼
@@MuhammadAhmad-db6sf No No No ～ Taiwan is real in Republic of China 🇹🇼，and declares that the Republic of China 🇹🇼 is the「only」legitimate “China government”，Not recognizing the sovereignty of the People's Republic of China 🇨🇳
On the contrary to Taiwan’s colonial blessing, Indonesia destroyed her colonial positive legacies. We ‘destroyed’ our train network, urban planning, and even education system left by the Dutch. 🤷🏻♂️
Thank you for making this video! However, some errors in the Chinese subtitles should be corrected. 6:34 “SC Tsiang” is 蔣碩傑 7:13 “Tsiang's idea” is "蔣碩傑的想法" not "蔣介石" (a huge mistake). "KY Yin" is "尹仲容"
At 7:14 , the picture shown needs to be revised. The picture shown is Mr. K.T. Lee, another important policy maker instead of Mr. Kwo-Yung Yin. And the Chinese subtitle also needs revision, the policy designer K.Y. Yin name in Chinese was 尹仲容. After this small revision, the title will become more perfect.
Chinese National Party(KMT) bring the longest martial law in the world to Taiwan(1949-1987), Taiwanese suffered "White Terror" and manny people got killed during the martial law and Whithe Terror times. We the Taiwanese people are not Chinese, and of course Taiwan is not part of China(nor only PRC but also ROC). We are still fighting for democracy and freedom, We are still fighting and looking for Taiwan Independence.
In fact, Taiwan’s legal government is not only ROC but also U.S. from the content of the Treaty of Peace with Japan signed in San Francisco in 1952. If current government cannot keep its legal position in Taiwan, then U.S .can claim that she owned the island.
Great video, and your side stepping of the issue of sovereignty by simply mentioning that Chiang's regime fled to Taiwan is leagues ahead more accurate than media giants such as the Econimist and DW.
It's different from what I know of. The 4 little dragons are Hongkong, Singapore, Taiwan and S.Korea. The 4 tigers are Malaysia, Indonesia, Thailand and Philippines. In terms of strength, dragons are better/stronger than tigers.
After DPP gain power definitely. Nothing wrong if want to distant from China but DPP is too liberal and ultra left wing. Their anti nuclear power plant causing massive eletrical shortage also their weird pro criminal and light sentence. KMT is the opposite which they are good on economy and tough on crime laws, but too pro on Beijing even sacrifield Taiwan or even ROC own interest.
@@bookmakie8607 There is no English name for the Four Little Dragons! The Western world always calls Taiwan, South Korea, Singapore, and Hong Kong the 4 tigers. In Taiwan, it is translated as 4 little tigers and 4 little dragons. 是台灣把the 4 tigers翻譯成4小龍😁😁😁
The huge amount of money is mostly only on very few people's hands, the majority of ordinary Taiwan workers' salaries now are much lower than they should be. So there are lots of problems of the government's system and policies.
As a Taiwanese, I am grateful to Japan for helping us establish the foundations of public infrastructure, such as healthcare, sanitation, education, and agriculture. Japan is an amazing country, and I am glad to have such a nice neighbor ❤
Essentially, the development of Taiwan's industry and economy from the mid to late stages to the present has little to do with Chiang Kai-shek's regime. It is more substantially related to the policies of Presidents Chiang Ching-kuo, Lee Teng-hui, and Tsai Ing-wen. As for President Ma Ying-jeou, his political approach of yielding to the Chinese Communist Party, along with his actions in weakening Taiwan's economy and defense, makes him a leader who betrayed Taiwan.
Don't mistake it. Whenever a country succeeds, PRC people say it's because of the colonizers. Don't mistake it. The two East Asian countries with the lowest average wealth are North Korea and China.
The Manchus as the colonizer did not care much about Taiwan until late 1800s...That's almost 200 years later after the Manchus conquered Taiwan. It's not until Qing and France had a war over Vietnam in 1884, and the French attacked the Pescadores and Formosa islands that Qing finally found out the importance of Taiwan's location. However, Qing lost Taiwan 10 years later to Japan through the first Sino-Japanese War over Korea in 1894. It's interesting to know that it's also the war in Korea and Vietnam that changed Taiwan's fate after WWII. After Korean War(USA and China/USSR fought over Korea) started, USA decided to defend Taiwan. After Vietnam War started, USA decided to make a lot of USA bases on the island of Formosa. Taiwan used to be like Okinawa in the past.
Taiwan got rich 35 years ago. In case you people don't know about, in 1995 Taiwan hold $800 billions (US dollars) foreign currency reserves, the number one in the world. Right now down to a little more than $600 billions, the number five in the world. With just a population of 22 millions, Taiwan is in any mean a healthy county.
The reason Taiwan is so prosperous is due to the hard-working labor force and the high standard of education that produces many elites. Taiwanese people's quick learning ability and vocational education are very successful. Additionally, the relatively low wages contribute to this success. Japan once analyzed that Taiwan's culture tends to be more submissive and obedient, which indirectly makes workers in Taiwan more diligent and treat their work as a top priority. Taiwanese people are accustomed to getting things done rather than expressing themselves, which is quite the opposite of the work culture in some countries like India. However, this also contributes to Taiwan's silent success, with the CEOs of Nvidia and AMD both being Taiwanese, and TSMC being a true pride of Taiwan.
Cách thức Đài Loan trở nên con rồng châu á củng giống như Hàn Quốc , là sự kết hợp của nhiều yếu tố : 1. Được Mỹ , Nhật, Phương Tây hỗ trợ về tiền bạc và công nghệ và cả các đơn hàng để trở nên mạnh về kinh tế , Để làm thành trì chống lại khối XHCN lúc bấy giờ . Mỹ rất cần điều này. 2. Là yếu tố, tố chất con người , các nước như Hàn Quốc, Đài Loan mang gen Đông Á ,họ rất mạnh mẽ , thông minh, khôn ngoan trong thương mại và siêng năng , chăm chỉ , tiết kiệm và ý chí làm giàu cao. Khác với một số nước như thái lan, Philippines mặc dù là đồng minh Mỹ như con người rất kém cỏi. 3. Có những nhà quản lý, lãnh đạo giàu ý chí và khát vọng lớn. 4. Phát triển trong giai đoạn ít phải bị cạnh tranh như bây giờ, hiện tại.
Taiwanese respect gods and believe in God. Taiwanese people still remain kind and caring. Taiwanese cherish their traditions and preserve their culture. Taiwanese people are gentle and kind.Taiwanese can be friends of the world. Taiwanese people can work with the democratic and free world to safeguard world peace.Taiwan needs a chance to stand with the world.
Well…my parents used only took 2 days off in a month (running their own small business), raised 3 kids and put the rest money into real estate. Working super hard+invest in the right thing+most important-no any bad addictions (booze/cigarettes/drug). And that’s HOW THEY GET RICH😢
We are very friendly and accept diversity , willing to help and share , also wish world peace . not perfect either. Typhoons and earthquakes can also happen here. development environment is very difficult and restricted, and the journey has not been easy.
1946 TIME: (6 Months after KMT China took over under US tutelage) "the Chinese Army that took over the island, under U.S. tutelage, last fall. But the resumption of trade with tropically lush, industrially rich Formosa was a sweet-&-sour business. Formosans complained that the Chinese occupation army was looting stocks, letting crops, refineries, railroads and power plants go to rack & ruin." "Japan Got the Atom. Chen Yi rounded up scores of “collaborators” while his pooh-bahs made themselves snug. Last week “Down with the Governor!” posters appeared all over the island. In two towns, hungry natives burned sugar godowns. Formosans greeted the few visiting Americans with: “You were kind to the Japanese, you dropped the atom on them. You dropped the Chinese on us!” Thoughtful Chinese on the mainland began to agree with the Formosans. Said Ta Rung Pao, China’s counterpart of the New York Times: “Fundamentally speaking, China was not qualified to take over . . . she lacks the men . . . technique . . . commodities . . . capital. She governs, but is inefficient. She takes, but she does not give. This is the government’s shame.” Most foreign observers in Formosa agreed that if a referendum were taken today Formosans would vote for U.S. rule. Second choice-Japan." 1949 TIME: After the "refugees" arrived "In Washington, Formosa assumed an increasing prominence in discussions of future U.S. strategy in Asia. With the help of U.S. sea and air power it could be held against Communist attack. It flanked the line of a possible Communist advance across the South China Sea. But Formosa had its drawbacks as an anti-Communist redoubt governed by Chinese Nationalists. Mostly these boiled down to the simple fact that 6½ million Formosans did not like the Chinese. Last week TIME Correspondent Wilson Fielder cabled this picture of the island in its new, unwanted role: Good Old Days. Cool breezes drifted gently across the golden grain of rice paddies that step up the lush green tropical mountains ringing Formosa’s capital. Farther south, water, buffaloes dragged plows for peak-capped farmers turning soil for one of their three yearly rice crops. Nearby lay fields thick with sugar cane and vegetables. At night, electric lights -rare in rural Asia-twinkled from the modest huts of tiny villages. By day many villagers not needed in the fields worked in the small industrial plants that dot the island. Compared to mainland Chinese, the Formosans were well off. Nevertheless they were grumbling. In guarded whispers they spoke of the “good old days” of Japanese rule. The years since V-J day had taken with them much of the sting of iron-fisted totalitarianism. The islanders now remembered how Japan had given , order to their lives, while China had brought them to the brink of chaos." "Thousands of Chinese soldiers, with the defeat of Shanghai just behind them, camped in the cavernous railroad station or roamed the streets. Civilians and soldiers (1,500,000 in number) were refugees from the communism now flooding south across China. They were also a troublesome burden to a people who wanted their island home for themselves." "Pigs Just Eat. This resentment is grounded partly in the psychology of a colonial people whose standards of living, general educational level and technical proficiency were raised well above the standards of their mainland Chinese brethren. The Japanese, for example, trained 30,000 Formosan doctors, more than the number in all the rest of China. But when the mainland Chinese took over the island, they did not even treat the Formosans as equals, but as “liberated” inferiors. The result is that even thoughtful Formosans now say: “We think of the Japanese as dogs and the Chinese as pigs. A dog eats, but he protects. A pig just eats.” Many Formosans want complete independence for their island-to be gained by revolution or any other means. Others talk of “autonomy under a good Chinese government,” neither Nationalist nor Communist. A third group favors a U.S. mandate." No thanx
Refugees and a large number of kidnapped illiterate soldiers. Before WW2, China was a third-world poor country and Japan was a developed country and that's why Taiwan was chosen by Chinese Nationalist.
Unfortunately you missed probably the most important factor of Taiwan’s success - it’s people, education and workforce culture. What you called “refugees” from Chinese civil war in 1949 are two million of the top scientists, engineers, educators, finance, economic, business, arts and literature professionals and civic leaders and essentially the top percentiles of every cross sections of the Chinese population. We are talking about adding the “cream of the crops” of 500 million population to an island of 6 million. This infusion of intellects, skills, culture and genetic pool formed the foundation of a special people destined for achievements. The arrival of this population and the immediate subsequent implementation and later expansion of mandatory education for the whole population to increase literacy, workforce development, and cultural learning including civic responsibilities, eventually created a workforce that’s capable of carrying out many of the successes in the video. I think omitting people development in Taiwan’s story is not only an insult to its people but also misleadingly implying similar governmental steps in another part of the world can achieve the same results.
Tiger economy? That is in the past. We are facing bigger and deeper problem to our future society. I can tell you as one of 23 million people in this island, we do not have next generation. With extremely high housing price and lowest fertility rate in the world, we are not going to have enough human resource to maintain our military power and logistics. This problem has been in this island for long time, but no parties try to solve it.
Chinese bot, Taiwan's economic growth in the first quarter was 6.51%, an 11-year high, much higher than China. TSMC’s 2nm chips have not yet been launched; orders are already full until 2027. Taiwan is the biggest beneficiary of AI.
@@genuinennessbefitting4734 Sorry, I am resident living in Taiwan. I just tell what I see in Taiwan. Our fertility rate is extremely low and housing price is way too high. These are fact. Only 1/4 of my colleague have one baby, others do not even have marriage. Ask DDP and KMT, facing this problem, how do you fight this war with less and less young generation?
@@genuinennessbefitting4734His statement is true. Despite having significant economic growth, we indeed have housing problems and fertility rate just as high of S.Korea.
During World War II, Taiwan was a substantial military base for Japan, and the U.S. military carried out intensive bombings. All Japanese colonial railways, road construction, and economy were entirely destroyed by American bombing. After World War II, Taiwan did not even have an inch of railway. The construction during the Japanese colonial period has nothing to do with Taiwan's economic miracle. It was the ten major construction projects carried out in the 1960s, 15 years after World War II, that truly paved the way for Taiwan's economic miracle, leaving a lasting impression on the island's history.
India will become superpower India will become space superpower 21st century is Indians century Indian will dominate the world’s economy India will surpass every country in terms of AI India will rule the world India is set to be superpower India will have toilet by the end of 21st century Cow God will descend to India.
I want to thank you for explaining it clearly. I feel quite ashamed, because as a 50-year-old Taiwanese, I don’t know much about Taiwan as you have said.
How important do you think is Taiwan to the world?
It's GDP is small compared to any G20 nations!
Futile hypocrisy!
The world merely envisages to instrumentalize Taiwan for its interest and take the civilians in hostage.
Furthermore, semiconductors escalade exclusively the industrial bias in Taiwan and even elevate the prize of immobilities. As a result, both of the phenomenons eliminate the diversity of occupations indirectly.
Taiwan just an province of of china
VERY VERY VERY IMPORTANT INDEED
Small democratic country withstands Huge dictatorship China so long time, it's story of David and Goliath.
Taiwan people have kind hearts. And Taiwan is the place where god bless.
詐騙島
That’s why it’s called heart of Asia.
You're not serious
謝謝你❤
How come Taiwan is not a member of the UN? Also, Taiwan, surrounded by enemies is exactly like Israel... which is a member of the UN.
Well, China is also part of the UN, but stakes are high, just like what the US did to Japan, let history repeat itself to say let Taiwan be fully support of Israel 100% and then let Israel do to China to what the US did to Japan in 1945, the only difference is that Taiwan will be incorporated by the new government formed in China that is backed by Israel.
@@Embargoman Israel does not support China taking over Taiwan. Also Israel is a tiny country with very little global political power. The UN is corrupt. And the USA is not helping Taiwan like it does to Japan.
TW under ROC lost sovereignty to PRC but still considers itself part of China
USA and the West agree Taiwan is part of China. People in Taiwan don't see China as enemy. They just worry that China's system may not be suitable for them.
Some interesting facts of Taiwan many people don't know ❤️:
Its Constitution: "Constitution of the Republic of China".
Its flagship air flight company: "China Airlines".
Its biggest oil company: "China Petrol".
Its biggest steel company: "China Steel".
Its postal Service: "China Post".
Its biggest telecom provider: "China Telecommunications".
Its flagship medicine university: "China Medical University".
As an employee of TSMC, I must say that a significant part of TSMC's success comes from the diligence, resilience, and responsibility of its Taiwanese workforce. Moreover, these employees are highly educated. Many even prioritize the company's importance over family. This dedication is precisely why it is challenging for other countries to replicate this success.
工作大於家庭 實在不是個好方式。好好享受家庭生活，才是做人根本。不然跟鍋子上的鹹魚差不多，讓公司翻來翻去。😢
工程師辛苦了💦
@@vs741臺灣在敵人的逼迫下，要先整體渡過到強經濟強軍事，不會被入侵的情況下，才能步入你說的那種家庭優先的悠哉狀態。
台灣幸運有你，我會以生命保護你
笑死了，这是什么鬼企业文化😅
我是驕傲的台灣人
我驕傲❤
你是可愛的台灣人
我也覺得很驕傲😂
我也是驕傲的台灣人
驕傲的把所有機組改成燃煤然後在國營考試作文問如何碳排清零 傻眼🙄
when the whole world abandons you, you are on your own! that's Taiwan!
👍👍👍👍👍👍
謝謝！
每個人都該為自己國家感到驕傲
可惜台灣不是國家
@@wellowline6480
你的存在確實讓人厭惡。.
不一样 我作为🇨🇳人 常常因为自己的国籍自卑😂 🇨🇳的护照走哪里都会受到歧视😂 很羡慕你们TaiWan的护照
@@wellowline6480 你的留言是精分吧？？？
@@wellowline6480 The PRC gained power through force.
The ROC (Taiwan) is a sovereign state authorized by voters.
The Communist Party launched an armed rebellion in the ROC and split the ROC.
In 1949, Chairman Mao declared independence and established the PRC.
Chairman Mao was telling the world that there was not only the ROC in the world, but also a new country, the PRC.
Taiwan is different from Japan and Korea in that it is a small economy. Japan and Korea are among the top 10 economies in the world and they develop their cities and industries based on huge capital. However, Taiwan is a small economy and does not have much capital. In fact, Taiwan is more amazing!
TSMC is one of the top 10 largest companies in the world, and Nvidia, founded by Taiwanese, is one of the top three. No company in Europe, Japan, or South Korea is among the top 10.
The total stock capitalization is large than south korea.
@@黃先生-p2l I don't know if what you say is true, but Taiwan's economy is definitely undervalued... Taiwan is probably one of the most vibrant emerging economies in Asia. Taiwan have a great potential to become a developed country.
@@StarSystem-p3i Yes, it's true. The overall market capitalization of Taiwan's stock market is greater than that of South Korea.
@@StarSystem-p3i The total income revenue of Samsung is 1900 billion USD in 2023 but the net profit is 4.8 billion USD in 2023.
However, the income revenue of TSMC is 670 billion USD and the net profit is 27 billion USD in 2023.
Although Samsung is excellent for her phones but TSMC focuses on technique solution and authorizes patents, IC layout and technique for her clients. That is why TSMC can earn more money than Samsung.
MTK, which is a TW smartphone CPU and chipset company and has the highest market share (39%) of smartphone CPU, better than 25% of Qualcomm and 6.2% of Samaung.
I learned something new about Taiwan's economic miracle, even as a Taiwanese. I often wonder which policy helped Taiwan become such a wealthy nation, even after the United Nations abandoned us in the 1970s
其實是美國要和中共建交，才沒有繼續支持中華民國留在UN，但你如果去看聯合國憲章，ROC還是列在創始會員國的第一順位，這是為了凸顯中華民國在第二次世界大戰中莫大的犧牲，只是UN中的中國代表權被美國默許給了中華人民共和國(PRC)了，這就是國際列強博弈的現實，然而美國又不允許台灣獨立，這樣才好讓台灣繼續成為美國的籌碼。
@@我行我攝台湾人没资格享有中华民国二战胜利的荣耀。他们是日本殖民地，和帮凶。二战的胜利牺牲属于大陆
@@我行我攝 你說的美國不允許臺灣獨立，是 not support Taiwan independence 嗎？
我覺得美國這句話只是想讓解釋空間變得更大，但並不代表美國"不允許"臺灣獨立。
臺灣已經是獨立的民主國家，沒有需要美國的允許。 另外他們的這句不支持臺灣獨立，是在刪除他們原本的 "反對臺灣獨立及承認只有一個中國"這個內容
當然如果有我誤會的地方，再麻煩你提一下
我常去中國．．雖然說那些所謂的一線城市，例如上海深圳．．那也只是某些區域高樓大廈．＂走到小巷弄又臭又髒又亂．．電瓶車到處跑．．說台灣買不起汽車…你應該是活在50年前吧⋯⋯笑死
很多人到處亂吐痰，抽煙，普遍素質很低。
真的,還好，我在疫情前跑掉
嘴台灣是行人地獄的真該去看看中國的交通，各種二輪四輪行人全部亂七八糟，要不是還有些高樓陪襯的背景，我會以為是印度
台灣就算是拿法定最低薪資的人，都買的起車。 這是人家要不要買的問題，而不是買不買的起的問題。
去過的人都知道 中國人的水準極高
Taiwan is trying to be a country of resilience.
我寧願台灣成爲和瑞士一樣不參與戰爭的中立國，也不要變成什麼禁得起打的韌性國家。
👍👍👍👍👍👍
We already did. 😊😊
🇯🇵🤝🇹🇼
🇯🇵❤
日本人是惡魔～到處強略各國殺害人
No,Japan is much much better than Taiwan, so Taiwan should be the little brother
@@Lanlousyou never been to Japan or Taiwan 🤣
@@Lanlousman, Japan is going thru crisis tho. They’re stagnant due to this mentality of savings. The government has been easing rates, but Japanese don’t spend. Japan has a much bigger problem to worry about. Yen is depreciating and Japan holds mostly USD as reserves. Japan is not hedged.
7‘16” 的台灣經濟擘劃者K.Y.Yin（ 尹仲容），照片卻是K.T.Lee（ 李國鼎），但這兩位經濟官員對台灣貢獻都很大，沒有他們，就沒有今日的台灣。
行政院政務人員1976-1988
李國鼎先生7：16
zh.wikipedia.org/zh-tw/%E6%9D%8E%E5%9C%8B%E9%BC%8E
張忠謀是孫運璿請回來的 沒有老孫 沒有今日的護國神山 !
沒國民黨在日劇或美據會更好
我是謙卑的台灣人
Cách thức Đài Loan trở nên con rồng châu á củng giống như Hàn Quốc , là sự kết hợp của nhiều yếu tố :
1. Được Mỹ , Nhật, Phương Tây hỗ trợ về tiền bạc và công nghệ và cả các đơn hàng để trở nên mạnh về kinh tế , Để làm thành trì chống lại khối XHCN lúc bấy giờ . Mỹ rất cần điều này.
2. Là yếu tố, tố chất con người , các nước như Hàn Quốc, Đài Loan mang gen Đông Á ,họ rất mạnh mẽ , thông minh, rất ham học tập, khôn ngoan trong thương mại và siêng năng , chăm chỉ , tiết kiệm và ý chí làm giàu cao. Khác với một số nước như thái lan, Philippines mặc dù là đồng minh Mỹ như con người rất kém cỏi.
3. Có những nhà quản lý, lãnh đạo giàu ý chí và khát vọng lớn.
4. Phát triển trong giai đoạn ít phải bị cạnh tranh như bây giờ, hiện tại.
Taiwan is a mix of East and Southeast Asian people.
The location and it's people are about in between.
Phân tích của bạn tốt hơn video.
@@bctvanw Not consistent with the facts.
@@genuinennessbefitting4734
Do you know the former president of Taiwan Tsai was a mix of Hakka and Paiwan aboriginal?
Taiwanese aborigines are Austronesian people like many Southeast Asian.
Besides, most of Southeast Asian Chinese populations are Hokkien, Cantonese, and Hakka people like many ethnic Chinese in Taiwan.
What "facts" do you have?
@@bctvanw Taiwan's aboriginal people only account for 2.5% of the population.
Almost all of Taiwan's high-tech companies were founded by the old Chinese who retreated from China. TSMC, UMC, FOXCONN, and many other high-tech companies are almost all from other provinces in China.
You don’t know anything about Taiwan. I assisted Taiwan Semiconductor in raising funds in 1987.
6:33 S. C. Tsiang (Sho-Chieh Tsiang, 蔣碩傑)
7:13 K. Y. Yin (Kwo-Yung Yin, 尹仲容)
I am a Taiwanese, and this video does an excellent job of explaining the topic in an easy-to-understand way.
Taiwan is an island nation deeply influenced by the Dutch, Japanese, and Chinese. Terms like *import substitution, export expansion, and science and industrial parks* are often mentioned in Taiwanese textbooks regarding the country’s economic history.
Although Taiwanese people occasionally criticize the government for its slow administrative efficiency and bureaucratic rigidity from a business perspective (for example, the high tariffs on automobiles meant to protect domestic production. In contrast to South Korea, where high car tariffs fostered the globally renowned Hyundai, Taiwan’s high tariffs over decades have not significantly improved its automobile industry. The domestic car brand, Luxgen isn’t even popular among Taiwanese people.
-we mockingly nickname it LE SE JUN -a pun meaning "garbage germ.")-
overall, most people still trust the government’s long-term economic policies.
We continue to work hard toward achieving the "Taiwanese Dream" of owning the "Five Essentials to Success"-savings, a car, a house, marriage, and children.
The map shown at the end of the video, which paints both China and Taiwan in red, is erroneous. Taiwan, an independent state with sovereignty of its own, should be highlighted with another color! On the other hand, the Hai-Nan Island located southern of China with a size a little short of that of Taiwan is part of China, and should be colored red!
臺灣國旗就是紅色的沒錯啊～再加上一片青天和一顆白日
‘’青天白日滿地紅‘’歡迎認識我們國家的國旗
中華民國 Republic of China (ROC), TAIWAN 🇹🇼🇹🇼🇹🇼
依照中華民國憲法，台灣地區和大陸地區確實是同一國的領土啊，AI還算是忠於史實，只是這國是ROC還是PRC就不好說了 XD
👍👍👍👍👍👍
民主才能繁榮 獨裁只會貧窮 除非有大量的自然資源 否則獨裁就是窮苦的代名詞
中國千年傳統就是愚民化政策，大部分人至今還在當人礦、韭菜，只有這樣才適合獨裁者的統治。而且不自由也限制科技文明的發展，大部分人覺得沒希望只好躺平，真是讓人絕望。
Taiwan No.1
Because Taiwan people work very hard !!!
And for parents hard working, most of Taiwanese grandparents take care of their grandchildren .
So, this is a really special social situation.
“Everybody works really hard!”
When people retire from their jobs, they don’t really retire.
Because they will take care of grandchildren.
Even many women still work when they have children.( Because they get supported from family!)
I am Taiwanese. Thank you to the United States, Japan, the Netherlands and other countries that have helped Taiwan. Taiwan upholds gratitude, peace, co-prosperity, equality and democracy and does its best for the world. Thank you❤
It is very difficult for china to capture taiwan because taiwan have support of usa in every field of economy military softpower in every ways and one of the biggest reason usa military are so strong 840 billions dollars and very Advance military tactics 🇺🇲❤️🇹🇼
taiwan ==Rep of CHina?
@@wyong0210 are you from china 🇨🇳
@@MuhammadAhmad-db6sf No No No ～ Taiwan is real in Republic of China 🇹🇼，and declares that the Republic of China 🇹🇼 is the「only」legitimate “China government”，Not recognizing the sovereignty of the People's Republic of China 🇨🇳
@@wyong0210Although this is not exactly the case, it is roughly the same
@@wyong0210 是沒錯,就是聯合國創始國之一的中華民國,只不過因為政治因素我們被剔除我們創立的聯合國
On the contrary to Taiwan’s colonial blessing, Indonesia destroyed her colonial positive legacies. We ‘destroyed’ our train network, urban planning, and even education system left by the Dutch. 🤷🏻♂️
Details what was removed
@@FirstLast-lq4xf some rail routes were closed, Dutch urban planning tradition was abandoned, foreign university lecturers were deported.
Hi from Bangladesh🇧🇩
Will Bangladesh become rich and technologically advanced?
Hi ,congratulations , Bangladesh restored democracy that's good.
@@soumengorai8346 hmm but not much🤭
@@wushinfu5750 yeah😘
Thank you for making this video! However, some errors in the Chinese subtitles should be corrected.
6:34 “SC Tsiang” is 蔣碩傑
7:13 “Tsiang's idea” is "蔣碩傑的想法" not "蔣介石" (a huge mistake). "KY Yin" is "尹仲容"
重要性的是台灣人民的素質 有24小時的新鮮肝
對岸996比較猛啦ww
大陆台湾韩国日本，世界最肝地区排名，从高到低。肝之一就是工作时长，大陆也有24小时两轮班，996,一周七天全天候响应机制。台湾半导体三班轮班制也只能排第二
Semiconductors baby !
Totally agree 👏👏👏👏👏
謝謝播主加上中華民國美麗的國旗，讓世界更認識台灣，給世人認識台灣國家和中國的區別，不讓世人混淆。
這是你要的台灣留言 請按讚
這部影片最大的敗筆就是把台灣與中國放在同一種顏色!
沒辦法誰叫我們的國旗也是紅色的，唯一不同是左上角12道光芒。
總不能畫成綠色的吧? 藍色的我想你應該也會有意見 到底甚麼顏色 我們自己都搞不定了
青天白日滿地紅本來就有紅色，難道要用那些低學歷文組佔多數的底層台灣綠旗嗎？
自己國家的國旗顏色也要ㄍㄧㄠˇ
青天白日滿地紅不認識嗎？你小學沒畢業吧🇹🇼🇹🇼🇹🇼
要不你自己再創一國 自己畫一個你滿意的國旗 自成一國，開國元老欸 不當當嗎
你的留言夠丟臉的🫣🫣
太可悲了，不認識自己國家的國旗
臺灣現在教育這麼失敗的嗎…😅😅
論談非常中肯。
At 7:14 , the picture shown needs to be revised. The picture shown is Mr. K.T. Lee, another important policy maker instead of Mr. Kwo-Yung Yin. And the Chinese subtitle also needs revision, the policy designer K.Y. Yin name in Chinese was 尹仲容. After this small revision, the title will become more perfect.
true. Thanks to Japan 🇯🇵🇹🇼
Thank you so much for introducing my beloved mother land Taiwan.
Thanks for sharing..謝謝分享，南無阿彌陀佛.
Proud of my country Taiwan!
2:12 Correct, look at how the British build up Hong Kong and Singapore
台灣處境因科技成就越來越險峻，台灣加油！齊心共渡難關，將努力成果留給後代子子孫孫。
Chinese National Party(KMT) bring the longest martial law in the world to Taiwan(1949-1987), Taiwanese suffered "White Terror" and manny people got killed during the martial law and Whithe Terror times.
We the Taiwanese people are not Chinese, and of course Taiwan is not part of China(nor only PRC but also ROC).
We are still fighting for democracy and freedom, We are still fighting and looking for Taiwan Independence.
美國不支持獨立那要承認是美國一州，台灣從來跟蘇維埃支那沒關係
In fact, Taiwan’s legal government is not only ROC but also U.S. from the content of the Treaty of Peace with Japan signed in San Francisco in 1952. If current government cannot keep its legal position in Taiwan, then U.S .can claim that she owned the island.
是
As Taiwanese, TSMC is just a company where many other foundry still can spend more resources to do the same thing by 2 or 2 times.
Great video, and your side stepping of the issue of sovereignty by simply mentioning that Chiang's regime fled to Taiwan is leagues ahead more accurate than media giants such as the Econimist and DW.
🇹🇼 economy = 🇳🇱; 🇧🇪; 🇨🇭; 🇦🇹 economies
既然將日本的統治描述成殖民統治，基於同樣的邏輯，蔣介石也該是殖民統治的描述。
沒錯，中華民國不是合法的佔領台灣。
是否同意台湾是民选之后才是真正脱离殖民统治
@@Mettmettmettmett 是的！我同意
@@jennershu6512 其实这天才是真实意义上的台湾光复日
@@Mettmettmettmett 在李登輝將選票交付人民並且人民完成選擇時
台灣是個海島移民國家,近四百年來受大清帝國,荷蘭,法國,西班牙,英國,美國,日本等各國文化衝擊洗禮才有今日多元樣態.
今日台灣的自由民主體制亦非一日可蹴,歷經帝制,殖民,黨國獨裁專制,戒嚴,228事件,白色恐怖,
民主演化進程也犧牲無數民主前輩血汗與生命換得.
自由民主台灣的特色: 多元多樣,混雜包容,以人為本.
1895年李鴻章在春帆樓上簽署馬關條約,將台灣『永遠』割讓給日本. 從畫押的那一刻起台灣和中國就毫無瓜葛了.
二戰之後,日本將台灣交給美國,國際法上台灣成了美國的託管國.這是目前台灣的現實狀況.
至於台灣未來,是要自立建國,或成為美國的一州,或由美國重新歸還日本,都和1949年才成立的中共毫不相干.
目前國際法上,台灣就是美國的託管國,地位宛如美國交給台灣人自治的特别州！
兩岸具體現實狀況 : 台灣中國,一邊一國,互不隸屬,中共敢侵犯台灣就是侵略！
1911中華民國創立(在中國)
1949中華人民共和國創立(在中國)
1949中華民國(中國)敗逃至台灣
1996中華民國(在台灣)沿用國號舉行直接民選總統李登輝
2000----2008中華民國(台灣)總統陳水扁
2008----2016中華民國(台灣)總統馬英九
2016----2024中華民國(台灣)總統蔡英文
2024----2028中華民國(台灣)總統賴清德
1945二戰後台灣已是獨立政治實體國家,至於"中華民國"國號爭議,
在自由民主體制下須經正名修憲或制憲程序方能消彌.
1949--2000中國國民黨屬反共政黨,2000以後中國國民黨由親中轉媚共,舔共跪匪,仇台恨台政黨!
曹興誠:台灣從來就不是中國領土 11:17 ruclips.net/video/fQTBnpsMrSg/видео.htmlsi=pdfqV-A1JY7eKTg1
臺灣人是炎黃子孫嗎？｜與李文成對談【知定講堂 曹興誠】EP38
ruclips.net/video/CjRm5QO1ZVQ/видео.htmlsi=oQgSVFC0UJ3Sjrrv
統一必殺戮，和平是欺騙！｜與李文成對談【知定講堂 曹興誠】EP39
ruclips.net/video/x8XBnHgEj7M/видео.htmlsi=cLI53XqJVBdeDrU_
「在國際研討會上，揭發國、共破壞國際法」【知定講堂 曹興誠】EP51
ruclips.net/video/THsRzmRVEt4/видео.htmlsi=h-xnGn9t0mcf9SWy
獨家 ∕ 中國摘活眼角膜不打麻藥 前中國軍醫手術後放棄工作：太殘酷
ruclips.net/video/GtddhqdC-4s/видео.htmlsi=aa0F6rHsinwfka4B
【寶島觀世界】「零日攻擊」讓台灣人長躲避的問題，一起來思考！ │主持人：矢板明夫 │2024/07/28
ruclips.net/video/Y4kNLLvV674/видео.htmlsi=ajjOqaA63i6tDPL5
美國日前曾就聯合國2758號公報詮釋中共建立的"中華人民共和國"取代"中華民國"在安理會席次問題,與台灣人民無關.
1949--1996是中國國民黨以黨國專政獨裁形式統治台灣,所以美國務卿今年在賴總統就職賀詞才稱第五位台灣總統!
可知美國重視與認定的是具有真正代表台灣民意選出的總統!
The Crucial Years: 1945-1949 2024.08.31 | Taiwan History 台灣演義
ruclips.net/video/Voc3TANkGMY/видео.htmlsi=nPO_cOaTaUfH1M6y
護照還給彭文正。
趕快滾吧塔綠班。沒國民黨你還能人均GDP32,000?😂
1949中華民國(中國)侵略台灣
中华民国在台湾写正统汉字
中华民国在台湾继承真正中国传统文化
毋忘在莒，毋忘国父，三民主义，统一中国，反攻大陆，反攻大陆
這部影片很簡要地說明昔日年代國民黨的執政下如何戰略性興起 創造了台灣奇蹟 任何的偏見與政治意識都擋不了抹不去這段中華民國國史
@@wengkuodon4114 对！战略是成为美国的不沉航空母舰，必忘在莒，乐不认蜀，烂泥扶不上墙，被美国弃之如敝履
Taiwan love Everyone ❤
When did Taiwan get demoted from 1 of Asia's little dragons to a tiger?
Taiwan has been one of the four Asian Tigers since the beginning
It's different from what I know of. The 4 little dragons are Hongkong, Singapore, Taiwan and S.Korea. The 4 tigers are Malaysia, Indonesia, Thailand and Philippines. In terms of strength, dragons are better/stronger than tigers.
After DPP gain power definitely.
Nothing wrong if want to distant from China but DPP is too liberal and ultra left wing.
Their anti nuclear power plant causing massive eletrical shortage also their weird pro criminal and light sentence.
KMT is the opposite which they are good on economy and tough on crime laws, but too pro on Beijing even sacrifield Taiwan or even ROC own interest.
@@bookmakie8607 There is no English name for the Four Little Dragons!
The Western world always calls Taiwan, South Korea, Singapore, and Hong Kong the 4 tigers.
In Taiwan, it is translated as 4 little tigers and 4 little dragons.
是台灣把the 4 tigers翻譯成4小龍😁😁😁
@@SalesManualsame as my understanding
The huge amount of money is mostly only on very few people's hands, the majority of ordinary Taiwan workers' salaries now are much lower than they should be. So there are lots of problems of the government's system and policies.
Taiwan is not tiger but a pigeon, messenger of peace.
Surprising lack of mention of Hmong tribesmen in Laos and their bulk money operations
As a Taiwanese, I am grateful to Japan for helping us establish the foundations of public infrastructure, such as healthcare, sanitation, education, and agriculture. Japan is an amazing country, and I am glad to have such a nice neighbor ❤
So true
Essentially, the development of Taiwan's industry and economy from the mid to late stages to the present has little to do with Chiang Kai-shek's regime. It is more substantially related to the policies of Presidents Chiang Ching-kuo, Lee Teng-hui, and Tsai Ing-wen. As for President Ma Ying-jeou, his political approach of yielding to the Chinese Communist Party, along with his actions in weakening Taiwan's economy and defense, makes him a leader who betrayed Taiwan.
I agree
只能說您是被仇恨化、洗腦化的可憐蟲。
天天叫抗中保台，能叫是因為有軍隊，請問軍隊系統從哪裡來，要不要來個去軍隊化？
The years of the above data increased rapidly from 1956 to 1972, which was the time of [Chiang Kai-shek]’s rule.
@@windcold4532
美援時期
當時出口靠的都是台灣糖 米 鳳梨 茶葉 木材 香蕉等農產品出口賺外匯的！
還有就是美國給的紡織貿易配額
再來就是台灣人自己創立的中小企業出口
@@windcold4532当时受美国援助，台湾也是韩战越战时美国重要的后勤生产基地，当时两国有联合防御条约。
As a Taiwanese, I fell so bad that we’re not in the un just because of china blocking 😢
Dont be mistaken. Colonization always benefits the colonizer primarily
Don't mistake it. Whenever a country succeeds, PRC people say it's because of the colonizers. Don't mistake it. The two East Asian countries with the lowest average wealth are North Korea and China.
@@KashiARTWtf are you yapping about?
@@보키더록 What are you yapping about?
The Manchus as the colonizer did not care much about Taiwan until late 1800s...That's almost 200 years later after the Manchus conquered Taiwan. It's not until Qing and France had a war over Vietnam in 1884, and the French attacked the Pescadores and Formosa islands that Qing finally found out the importance of Taiwan's location. However, Qing lost Taiwan 10 years later to Japan through the first Sino-Japanese War over Korea in 1894.
It's interesting to know that it's also the war in Korea and Vietnam that changed Taiwan's fate after WWII.
After Korean War(USA and China/USSR fought over Korea) started, USA decided to defend Taiwan.
After Vietnam War started, USA decided to make a lot of USA bases on the island of Formosa. Taiwan used to be like Okinawa in the past.
哈哈，殖民是先剝削，等到沒什麼可以剝削了才會建設，奇葩的言論
謝謝分析台灣近代發展
新疆西藏自古就非東亞兩河流域民族國家的一員。所為亞洲領土大國時期都非中國漢族建立的（ 清朝/元朝）。如今中共對新疆西藏人民土地佔領統治，就是強權武力異族的赤裸搶掠侵略事實。
還好吧
，美國都把印地安人滅了
殺乾淨就會像美國一樣了 變成先進國家
Welcome to Taiwan!
Taiwan got rich 35 years ago. In case you people don't know about, in 1995 Taiwan hold $800 billions (US dollars) foreign currency reserves, the number one in the world. Right now down to a little more than $600 billions, the number five in the world. With just a population of 22 millions, Taiwan is in any mean a healthy county.
我們國家只是堅強的一步一步不放棄的往前走，即使沒能加入聯合國，即使國土小到很多人並不知道我們在地球的哪裡，但我們讓自己慢慢發光並保持善良，信仰讓我們內心強大，相信國家人民都被祝福著，也同樣的希望自己小小的力量都能幫助更多的國家跟人們，相信善的循環能一點一點改變全世界，希望世界和平❤
TAIWAN does not have yet a national flag. 😂😂 That "red flag" is the China flag, the Republic of China is originally from mainland China.
It’s like the Korean gov in late 1990s that promoted pop culture. But Taiwan focused on tech, not music earlier.
台灣gdp名目上漲，但是薪資上漲卻很緩慢，很多工種都只能靠著最低工資調升來加薪了，錢都富人賺走了，貧富差距越來越大，
薪水不漲，小孩不生，而且房價物價卻還在飆漲，
如果真愛台灣，就把人民在乎的問題講出來，然後帶領2300萬人一起解決，
而不是只會歌功頌德和內鬥。
台積電創造很多GDP，但台積電的股東大部分是外資，這些gdp中的財富很多並不屬於台灣。台灣的傳產利潤很低，還有台灣的房價高漲也造成名義GDP過高。
但是我覺得台灣現在的狀況其實還不錯，能繼續保持就很好了。❤🇹🇼
@@wushinfu5750
台積電外資約佔74%，稅後盈餘的74%應該不能計算在GDP 裡面，
全部的外資都應該這麼算，但我不知道馬蔡有沒有偷算進來，
因為自馬英九開始，台商在外的獲利就計算在GDP裡面，所以外商在台獲利就不能算台灣GDP,
但是實際上台商在外GDP幾乎不對台灣整體經濟有多大助益，而且幾乎只會加大炒房炒股票和貧富差距，
所以台灣經濟名目上好看，少數人收益，其他人實際上受益的差距很大。
表面繁榮而已，實際上就是那樣，沒有這麼好
@@wushinfu5750 還有，二手房交易，房價上漲也沒算進GDP的。
新蓋好的房子才算進去
@@Pikepike-gx8pm 感謝分享。台灣台商在外的營利也計入，難怪GDP會這麼高。這可能比台積電的收入更多。
@@wushinfu5750
再交流一下，
新建成屋才算GDP,
二手房不管怎麼漲都不算GDP,
100間新成屋今年賣了40間，剩下60間打算明年賣。
今年照樣算進這100間，停車位也是這樣算。
所以建商蓋的多GDP,數字就好看，
要數字好看就得多建新房子，
土地供給就要夠，價格要上漲買的人就多蓋房子的也多。
新上任的要表現，快要卸任的要美麗的下臺數據，他們當然不在意價格多高了
The reason Taiwan is so prosperous is due to the hard-working labor force and the high standard of education that produces many elites. Taiwanese people's quick learning ability and vocational education are very successful. Additionally, the relatively low wages contribute to this success. Japan once analyzed that Taiwan's culture tends to be more submissive and obedient, which indirectly makes workers in Taiwan more diligent and treat their work as a top priority. Taiwanese people are accustomed to getting things done rather than expressing themselves, which is quite the opposite of the work culture in some countries like India. However, this also contributes to Taiwan's silent success, with the CEOs of Nvidia and AMD both being Taiwanese, and TSMC being a true pride of Taiwan.
Cách thức Đài Loan trở nên con rồng châu á củng giống như Hàn Quốc , là sự kết hợp của nhiều yếu tố :
1. Được Mỹ , Nhật, Phương Tây hỗ trợ về tiền bạc và công nghệ và cả các đơn hàng để trở nên mạnh về kinh tế , Để làm thành trì chống lại khối XHCN lúc bấy giờ . Mỹ rất cần điều này.
2. Là yếu tố, tố chất con người , các nước như Hàn Quốc, Đài Loan mang gen Đông Á ,họ rất mạnh mẽ , thông minh, khôn ngoan trong thương mại và siêng năng , chăm chỉ , tiết kiệm và ý chí làm giàu cao. Khác với một số nước như thái lan, Philippines mặc dù là đồng minh Mỹ như con người rất kém cỏi.
3. Có những nhà quản lý, lãnh đạo giàu ý chí và khát vọng lớn.
4. Phát triển trong giai đoạn ít phải bị cạnh tranh như bây giờ, hiện tại.
Because Taiwan is a country , that's why
Taiwanese respect gods and believe in God. Taiwanese people still remain kind and caring. Taiwanese cherish their traditions and preserve their culture. Taiwanese people are gentle and kind.Taiwanese can be friends of the world. Taiwanese people can work with the democratic and free world to safeguard world peace.Taiwan needs a chance to stand with the world.
目前台灣的GDP又再加速起飛中，但影片卻沒談到這點，反而講了很多歷史。只能說沒談到目前的關鍵，有隔靴搔癢之感。
加速起飛? 你是說房價嗎? 台灣現在依靠的台積電和其他主要出口大宗的資通訊產業，都是三、四十年前發展竹科留下來的優勢，現在台積電被各國要求去他們境內在地生產，將會慢慢掏空台灣晶圓產業。
至少國際關係和能見度大幅提高。
@@我行我攝放心的，美国日本至少不会大量的挖角偷技术，共产党给每个人都在脑子里安装了，「必要时每个人都要为党奉现」的指令，待了台积电南京或上海在外流的人可太多了，对台积电是很大是有恶意存在的，该庆幸还好是28奈米制程。
@@我行我攝 結論：難怪你買不起房
喔不對你要買的地方絕對是要你認為「現在」很方便的地方對吧？
像我待在竹科20年有了吧，我工作了約8年！我就在大家嗤之以鼻的所謂竹北鳥不生蛋的地方買了房子當初買超級便宜
，上mobile01和PTT看房產版像你們這種睿智的人都在笑我們什麼點燈率沒幾支貓鳥不生蛋沒什麼生活圈很可憐的樣子
但是你看現在呢？
你如果看得懂算是你的造化，如果你還是看不懂那你也就這樣了我是真心為你好才多說幾句。
罐子老師的書法教室
Taiwan, thank you
Proud to be a Taiwanese. Thank you for your detailed commentary for Taiwan.
The further away from China, the more rich you are.
Up to 40% Taiwan's GDP is gathering from PRC now. Without trading between China will destroy Taiwan's economy.
@@我行我攝
賴神總統從政28年以來在很多場合公開說過台灣是一個主權獨立的國家, 他是務實的台獨工作者. 2024/5/20以來賴神總統多次公開以事實說出台支2國互不隸屬, 以失土和祖國論打臉共匪滿嘴謊言謬論. 即使如此, 西朝鮮支那共慘區共頭習禁評還是不敢公開回嘴將他列入台獨"懲處"名單, 反而找幾個小咖作作樣子. 因此, 賴神總統 > 習禁評 > 1億共匪 > 14億共奴!
2010年西朝鮮支那共慘區共匪簽了ECFA減免關稅就間接承認2國論, 因為國與國之間才有關稅的問題. 這2年共匪3次作作樣子取消12, 134, 34共180項, 只是全部關稅減免項大約40%, 但共匪又不敢全面終止ECFA. 另外, 每年共匪放任將近千億美元的貿易赤字, 但又不敢全面終止失衡貿易. 結論: 共匪為了鞏固政權, 製造外敵, 卻暗地讓利資助台獨, 因此反獨是假的! 反正, 共奴孬種不敢公開評共匪獨裁專制倒行逆施貪污橫行, 共奴是共匪的奴隸, 韭菜, 奴礦. 可憐啊!
這2年西朝鮮支那共慘區嘴砲軍3次裝腔作勢宣布"環台"軍演, 卻草草收兵丟人現眼, 暗助台灣股市增加加權指數:
賴總統再次公開發表兩國論
2024/10/14 22,975.29, +73.65 (0.32%)
賴神總統公開發表兩國論
2024/5/23 21,607.43, +55.60 (0.26)
美國眾議院議長裴洛西訪台
2022/8/3 14,777.02, +29.79 (0.20%)
2022-24年德國安聯 (Allianz) 集團全球57國財富報告: 2021-2023年人均淨金融資產 (歐元) 台灣138,220, 141,600, 148,750; 支那共慘區15,400, 15,960, 16,470. 支那共慘區只有台灣的~1/9. 可憐啊!
2023年人均和中位數可支配所得 (台幣萬元): 台灣44.91, 37.98; 支那共慘區14.54, 12.25 (33036, 27816元奴隸幣, 平均匯率4.4024). 共慘區只有台灣的~1/3. 可憐啊!
IMF經濟預測數據2024年名目和購買力平價人均GDP (美元): 台灣34,432, 76,858; 支那共慘區13,136, 25,015. 共慘區只有台灣的~1/3. 可憐啊!
根據IMF, 2023年物價和勞務費用, 支那共慘區比台灣高18%. 根據WPR, 銷售貨物稅, 最高個人所得税, 公司營業稅: 共慘區13, 45, 25%, 台灣5, 40, 20%. 共慘區分別比台灣高8, 5, 5%. 可憐啊!
2024, 2025年台灣全國各地最低月薪27470, 28590元. 支那共慘區上海11994元 (2690元奴隸幣), 北京10790元 (2420元奴隸幣), 深圳10522元 (2360元奴隸幣), 吉林6866-8382元 (1540-1880元奴隸幣), 黑龍江6465-8293元 (1450-1860元奴隸幣), 遼寧6331-8516元 (1420-1920元奴隸幣). 可憐啊!
台灣主計總處公布2022, 2023年全國受僱平均人數分別817, 818萬人平均年薪69.3, 69.5萬元, 其中本國籍全時員工平均年薪72.9, 74.3萬元. 支那共慘區统計局卻用以下的方法自欺欺人. 不列全區就業奴數和平均年薪. 排除最低的鄉村年薪, 只列城鎮公營和私營平均年薪50.4, 28.9萬元 (114029, 65237元奴隸幣, 2022年平均匯率4.4239), 53.1, 30.1萬元 (120698, 68340奴隸幣, 2023年平均匯率4.4024). 可憐啊!
@@我行我攝实际上马英九时期开放的两岸，直接淘空了台湾本土的经济与技术外流，股市总值最差的也在这马英九任内，所谓的养肥了敌人造了飞弹，当今蛇与农夫。
👍👍🇹🇼台灣之光🇹🇼👍👍
💪💪🇹🇼台灣加油🇹🇼💪💪
Well…my parents used only took 2 days off in a month (running their own small business), raised 3 kids and put the rest money into real estate. Working super hard+invest in the right thing+most important-no any bad addictions (booze/cigarettes/drug). And that’s HOW THEY GET RICH😢
We are very friendly and accept diversity , willing to help and share , also wish world peace .
not perfect either. Typhoons and earthquakes can also happen here.
development environment is very difficult and restricted, and the journey has not been easy.
I think many of the “refugees” from China were some of the richest/smartest
1946 TIME: (6 Months after KMT China took over under US tutelage)
"the Chinese Army that took over the island, under U.S. tutelage, last fall. But the resumption of trade with tropically lush, industrially rich Formosa was a sweet-&-sour business.
Formosans complained that the Chinese occupation army was looting stocks, letting crops, refineries, railroads and power plants go to rack & ruin."
"Japan Got the Atom. Chen Yi rounded up scores of “collaborators” while his pooh-bahs made themselves snug. Last week “Down with the Governor!” posters appeared all over the island. In two towns, hungry natives burned sugar godowns. Formosans greeted the few visiting Americans with: “You were kind to the Japanese, you dropped the atom on them. You dropped the Chinese on us!”
Thoughtful Chinese on the mainland began to agree with the Formosans. Said Ta Rung Pao, China’s counterpart of the New York Times: “Fundamentally speaking, China was not qualified to take over . . . she lacks the men . . . technique . . . commodities . . . capital. She governs, but is inefficient. She takes, but she does not give. This is the government’s shame.”
Most foreign observers in Formosa agreed that if a referendum were taken today Formosans would vote for U.S. rule. Second choice-Japan."
1949 TIME: After the "refugees" arrived
"In Washington, Formosa assumed an increasing prominence in discussions of future U.S. strategy in Asia. With the help of U.S. sea and air power it could be held against Communist attack. It flanked the line of a possible Communist advance across the South China Sea.
But Formosa had its drawbacks as an anti-Communist redoubt governed by Chinese Nationalists. Mostly these boiled down to the simple fact that 6½ million Formosans did not like the Chinese. Last week TIME Correspondent Wilson Fielder cabled this picture of the island in its new, unwanted role:
Good Old Days. Cool breezes drifted gently across the golden grain of rice paddies that step up the lush green tropical mountains ringing Formosa’s capital. Farther south, water, buffaloes dragged plows for peak-capped farmers turning soil for one of their three yearly rice crops. Nearby lay fields thick with sugar cane and vegetables. At night, electric lights -rare in rural Asia-twinkled from the modest huts of tiny villages. By day many villagers not needed in the fields worked in the small industrial plants that dot the island. Compared to mainland Chinese, the Formosans were well off. Nevertheless they were grumbling. In guarded whispers they spoke of the “good old days” of Japanese rule. The years since V-J day had taken with them much of the sting of iron-fisted totalitarianism. The islanders now remembered how Japan had given , order to their lives, while China had brought them to the brink of chaos."
"Thousands of Chinese soldiers, with the defeat of Shanghai just behind them, camped in the cavernous railroad station or roamed the streets. Civilians and soldiers (1,500,000 in number) were refugees from the communism now flooding south across China. They were also a troublesome burden to a people who wanted their island home for themselves."
"Pigs Just Eat. This resentment is grounded partly in the psychology of a colonial people whose standards of living, general educational level and technical proficiency were raised well above the standards of their mainland Chinese brethren. The Japanese, for example, trained 30,000 Formosan doctors, more than the number in all the rest of China. But when the mainland Chinese took over the island, they did not even treat the Formosans as equals, but as “liberated” inferiors. The result is that even thoughtful Formosans now say: “We think of the Japanese as dogs and the Chinese as pigs. A dog eats, but he protects. A pig just eats.”
Many Formosans want complete independence for their island-to be gained by revolution or any other means. Others talk of “autonomy under a good Chinese government,” neither Nationalist nor Communist. A third group favors a U.S. mandate."
No thanx
Refugees and a large number of kidnapped illiterate soldiers.
Before WW2, China was a third-world poor country and Japan was a developed country and that's why Taiwan was chosen by Chinese Nationalist.
they were rich, corrupt criminals who looted Chinese treasury
@@qubit0002
Most were soldiers with no productivities.
Taiwanese had to share their food and money to feed those people.
@@qubit0002 There were Chinese then. The initial CCP country was named soviet China; it is not China.
Unfortunately you missed probably the most important factor of Taiwan’s success - it’s people, education and workforce culture. What you called “refugees” from Chinese civil war in 1949 are two million of the top scientists, engineers, educators, finance, economic, business, arts and literature professionals and civic leaders and essentially the top percentiles of every cross sections of the Chinese population. We are talking about adding the “cream of the crops” of 500 million population to an island of 6 million. This infusion of intellects, skills, culture and genetic pool formed the foundation of a special people destined for achievements. The arrival of this population and the immediate subsequent implementation and later expansion of mandatory education for the whole population to increase literacy, workforce development, and cultural learning including civic responsibilities, eventually created a workforce that’s capable of carrying out many of the successes in the video. I think omitting people development in Taiwan’s story is not only an insult to its people but also misleadingly implying similar governmental steps in another part of the world can achieve the same results.
是有點道理，但是日治時期的台灣人，素質已遠遠超越中國人，所以高素質中國人，很快就融入高素質的台灣環境，日本人對台灣現代化，功不可沒
i have a question Sir! Taiwan Region is Economic Tiger Who Really Feedings Them i said really Economic Links and Relationship 2:28
蔣介石對台灣經濟沒那麼影響高深.在我們印象中是蔣經國的政策影響台灣最巨....成為亞洲四小龍是蔣經國的帶領下.而不是蔣中正獨裁者造成
你的歷史考察還是有些錯誤
蔣中正是穩固根基 搞土改跟拉美援 不能說沒用啦 但確實蔣經國比較會"經國" 很多那時的政策影響持續到現在
如今滿街低薪族，貧富差距跟世界一樣越來越大，莫忘世上苦人多。
我不是種族主義者 但就事論事 東亞的中國 台灣 日本 韓國 新加坡 都是同一或類似的種族 文化雷同 跟西歐相似 有時你不得不承認 種族和文化決定了一切
朝鮮呢?
同一種族也有不同政治、思想、文化，同樣是華人國家，每個都不一樣。
所以朝鮮呢？ 越南呢？ 直接拿成功的例子粗暴的歸因於種族因素，這種論點非常low。
@@kscho1368 你要比較當然要控制外在的條件一樣 就像實驗的對比 朝鮮不是在自由經濟和制度上 實驗的參數不同 要比 比方菲律賓 日本 韓國 資本主義制度和人口 土地相近的參數下 再比如肯亞 馬來西亞 甚至來馬來西亞的華族和馬來族
種族不能決定一切，不該用種族這兩個字來進行道德綁架，這對分散在全世界的東亞人種很不公平。
台灣人很知足，不論日子過得如何台灣人從不怨天尤人，社會福利也是政府最重視的政策，我台灣我驕傲
哈哈，继续讲，很好，笑死
@@jackychen5578炒股炒的如何啦
喔！笑死了沒，我剛拿爆米花坐等看你耍猴戲，賣力點，加油@@jackychen5578
@@jackychen5578 笑死 死了嗎
DPP's propaganda machine
We are not rich.
Just try to survive in this cruel world.
Tiger economy? That is in the past. We are facing bigger and deeper problem to our future society. I can tell you as one of 23 million people in this island, we do not have next generation. With extremely high housing price and lowest fertility rate in the world, we are not going to have enough human resource to maintain our military power and logistics. This problem has been in this island for long time, but no parties try to solve it.
Chinese bot, Taiwan's economic growth in the first quarter was 6.51%, an 11-year high, much higher than China.
TSMC’s 2nm chips have not yet been launched; orders are already full until 2027.
Taiwan is the biggest beneficiary of AI.
@@genuinennessbefitting4734 Sorry, I am resident living in Taiwan. I just tell what I see in Taiwan. Our fertility rate is extremely low and housing price is way too high. These are fact. Only 1/4 of my colleague have one baby, others do not even have marriage. Ask DDP and KMT, facing this problem, how do you fight this war with less and less young generation?
@@taipeicitydevelopment6660 do your young people want to fight war?
@@genuinennessbefitting4734His statement is true. Despite having significant economic growth, we indeed have housing problems and fertility rate just as high of S.Korea.
@@evernam993m8 At least I don’t. Nobody wants war.
The speaker is a British
內容說錯了，中國完全是由台灣商人大舉進駐，才變成如今的富足！
片中有口誤，台灣早期經濟跟日治時期根本沒有關係，是蔣中正退守台灣時，美國援助才慢慢發展起來！
日本侵略亞洲各國，佔據台灣時期，只有一條準則，農業在台灣、工業在日本，移植農業水稻種植技術，跟做水庫灌溉嘉南平原，種植稻米供給前線戰爭使用，根本就是戰爭攻略的計畫。
山上鋪鐵路都只是為了盜採金礦 、煤礦還有盜伐神木回到日本蓋神社跟建設日本；都是掠奪物資還有姦淫擄掠，別講的那麼好聽。 殺人如屠狗一般的喪盡天良！
影片中都沒提到，台灣早期是世界工廠，所以大大小小的塑膠製品、五金工具、螺絲、紡織、鞋業等等通通是台灣製！
後期大舉進入中國大陸，把當時還是務農為主的大陸整個大翻轉，從農業變成工業大國。造橋鋪路 造鎮 台灣商人樣樣都做到了。
亂講,中華民國黨國砍的神木才多咧,台灣早期現代化發展基礎建設都是靠日本,國民政府搬遷期根本沒心治理台灣,都是劫收日治時期的資產好嗎😂笑死,真不知道是哪個黨國腦在亂講
你扭曲的心讓你看不見真相. 戰前台灣的經濟發展高點在1937年, 經過太平洋戰爭的破壞與國民黨難民的拖累一直到30年後的1960年代未期才重新回到此水準, 30年!!! 日本治台也總共才50年, 一個人的人生有幾個30年? 二戰與戰後被中國重新殖民, 可說是台灣人經歷的世紀大劫難
日本人留下了鐵公路機場港口, 通訊電力設施, 造船廠煉油廠等等工業基礎, 最重要的是對人口素質的提升, 無論從人數, 壽命, 健康, 教育程度, 相比大清而言是飛躍性的進步. 你只要認真的看待各國的史料都能得出同樣的結論. 如果殖民"虐待"的成果還比"母國"的良政好, 那這"母國"究竟有多糟多垃圾?
歷史上經歷無數的戰爭與壓迫, 台灣最需要的就是自立, 不再受任何外來人的支配
@@yu-mingchang2256 你才亂說，缺點都藏著，只說有優點，況且優點還被你放大，實在是了扭曲歷史的亂源，姦淫擄掠都不談，盜取台灣資源也不說！
別說你是台灣人，真羞恥！
開發最多的根本不是日本，也談不上跟經濟發展有多大關係。
你根本舉例不出來日本有幫助什麼！
台灣目前最能直接幫助台灣人的政策及福利是國民健保；蔣經國先生創新指示下屬規劃世界第一個全民健康保險。
在全民健保未開辦前，台灣地區社會福利制度由「勞保」、「農保」、「公保」及「軍保」四大系統。
民國75年，蔣經國先生擔任總統時，決定整合四大保險體系，並指示行政院，最晚在民國89做為全民健保的實施目標。民國77年，蔣經國過世後行政院指示由當時的經建會(現改國發會)成立專責規劃小組，民國80年由當時的衛生署接手進行細部作業。民國81年，時任行政院長的郝柏村，指示全民健保應提前辦理，隔年連戰上台，更決定應於民國83年開辦。
台積電也是蔣經國先生指示下創立至今。
你才亂說，缺點都藏著，只說有優點，況且優點還被你放大，實在是了扭曲歷史的亂源，姦淫擄掠都不談，挖空台灣資源也不說！
別說你是台灣人，真羞恥！
開發最多的根本不是日本，也談不上跟經濟發展有多大關係。
你根本舉例不出來日本有幫助什麼！
台灣目前最能直接幫助台灣人的政策及福利是國民健保；蔣經國先生創新指示下屬規劃世界第一個全民健康保險。
在全民健保未開辦前，台灣地區社會福利制度由「勞保」、「農保」、「公保」及「軍保」四大系統。
民國75年，蔣經國先生擔任總統時，決定整合四大保險體系，並指示行政院，最晚在民國89做為全民健保的實施目標。民國77年，蔣經國過世後行政院指示由當時的經建會(現改國發會)成立專責規劃小組，民國80年由當時的衛生署接手進行細部作業。民國81年，時任行政院長的郝柏村，指示全民健保應提前辦理，隔年連戰上台，更決定應於民國83年開辦。
台積電也是蔣經國先生指示下創立至今。
你才亂說，缺點都藏著，只說有優點，況且優點還被你放大，實在是了扭曲歷史的亂源，姦淫擄掠都不談，挖空台灣資源也不說！
別說你是台灣人，真羞恥！
開發最多的根本不是日本，也談不上跟經濟發展有多大關係。
你根本舉例不出來日本有幫助什麼！
台灣目前最能直接幫助台灣人的政策及福利是國民健保；蔣經國先生創新指示下屬規劃世界第一個全民健康保險。
在全民健保未開辦前，台灣地區社會福利制度由「勞保」、「農保」、「公保」及「軍保」四大系統。
民國75年，蔣經國先生擔任總統時，決定整合四大保險體系，並指示行政院，最晚在民國89做為全民健保的實施目標。民國77年，蔣經國過世後行政院指示由當時的經建會(現改國發會)成立專責規劃小組，民國80年由當時的衛生署接手進行細部作業。民國81年，時任行政院長的郝柏村，指示全民健保應提前辦理，隔年連戰上台，更決定應於民國83年開辦。
台積電也是蔣經國先生指示下創立至今。
During World War II, Taiwan was a substantial military base for Japan, and the U.S. military carried out intensive bombings.
All Japanese colonial railways, road construction, and economy were entirely destroyed by American bombing. After World War II, Taiwan did not even have an inch of railway.
The construction during the Japanese colonial period has nothing to do with Taiwan's economic miracle. It was the ten major construction projects carried out in the 1960s, 15 years after World War II, that truly paved the way for Taiwan's economic miracle, leaving a lasting impression on the island's history.
"All Japanese colonial railways, road construction, and economy were entirely destroyed by American bombing. "
It's not true...
日本制定的基礎建設才有後來的發展，怎麼會沒有關係?
Taiwan is Japan, USA, China fused into one.
India will be superpower and take over Southeast Asia and East Asia to create akhand bharat.
Body odour will take over the world
India will become superpower
India will become space superpower
21st century is Indians century
Indian will dominate the world’s economy
India will surpass every country in terms of AI
India will rule the world
India is set to be superpower
India will have toilet by the end of 21st century
Cow God will descend to India.
Indians 크크크
哈哈哈
Lost war to china 1969😂can't took Bangladesh. Southeast Asia and East Asia look at India as backward country😂
The truth is Taiwanese people not really rich but friendly.實際上台灣人並不是最富裕的但台灣人很友善
請正名 中華民國🇹🇼 台灣！
台灣只是區域名 真正的國名叫「中華民國」
除非有任何的新發明取代晶片 不然台積電的未來是無可限量的 當然美國押注台灣不是沒原因的 這次美國大選川普的談話很直白的說明 美國想明搶台積電的最先進技術 而台灣只能想辦法把最核心最先進的技術保留在台灣並不斷的革新技術 取的不可取代的地位 台灣不想受制於美國 只能拉歐盟來抗衡 單靠美國是最愚蠢的.
2008~2016 Taiwan is very poor😢
?????
Agree
馬英九
Is Taiwan rich? Doubtful.
YES. VERY RICH
Taiwan per capital GDP is higher than Japan and South Korea
Apparently richer than you.😂
don't be like that guys, just tell him Taiwan is poor okay? So he won't come here and just stay in his rich country. Wouldn't it be much better 😅
Definitely not when it comes to traffic. Period.
I want to thank you for explaining it clearly. I feel quite ashamed, because as a 50-year-old Taiwanese, I don’t know much about Taiwan as you have said.
你很好了❤
有其中一個原因是退出聯合國，不要繳會費給那個毫無作為日漸赤化的國際組織，替台灣省下太多經費作建設跟教育。
Amazing, Its in the DNA of The HAN Chinese people 🙏
No...Taiwanese are not chinese.
Only Han, don't use the word Chinese
@@SalesManual Taiwanese is Chinese too ～
After all，the country is the Republic of China 🇹🇼
@@LLENN0420
no, I'm Taiwanese, We dont drop ROC , just because China get mad ....
@@waffenss1234567不用找藉口好嗎？我也是 臺灣人，並且拿著 中華民國國籍，因此是臺灣人也是中國人，既然會怕 中華人民共和國 生氣，那麼就代表臺獨的實際脆弱無比，就認了事實吧
this is a holistic summary. i like it
跟清德宗沒有半毛錢關係卻把他晾出來超好笑的😂😂😂
跟你有關係？
@@小田學妹
哈哈哈，只有他敢向習嗆聲！