Yes, that one is indeed tricky on the baroque flute. But ... suppose this isn't the original (= earliest) version of the flute sonata? What if Bach originally wrote this sonata in the the key of D major (which also sounds much better on the baroque flute without all those awkward fork fingerings), and then at a later point transposed it two semi-tones up? Perhaps in order to present Quantz or Buffardin with a challenge. The absence of low D-sharp's in the flute part makes me rather suspicious. You actually won't find a note lower than E in any of the four movements. By comparison: The flute sonata in E minor, BWV 1034 contains lots of low D-sharps. Therefore I am getting increasingly convinced that this sonata is most likely a transposed version - something that J.S. Bach also did with the B minor Sonata for flute and harpsichord, BWV 1030.
You know, there was a friend of mine that told me she thought Bach's flute sonatas were boring. And I quote "Snore," as she put it. I did not fall asleep---I actually rather enjoyed it! Found the allegros riveting and the Siciliano very intriguing.
Good afternoon. They are my favourite sonatas! Bach is genius of flauto music. Special I like sonata in e or second sonata: BWV 1034. . Thank for your video. . 8.12.22. . ☀️
Do I hear a cello as well as a harpsi or clavichord in the continuo line? Intriguing sonata. Use of rests on the first beat of the bar in the continuo line give the piece a syncopated feel. Thank you gerubach. Beautiful transcription and animation as always.
That's because it's a traverso/baroque flute. They didn't have the science to perfect the scale in the 1730s, unlike modern instruments today. That's part of the appeal though.
![Chicken P - People's Favorite (Remix) [Feat. 42 Dugg] (Official Video)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/a6Bn8FEtxmY/mqdefault.jpg)
As a flute player I thank you for these sonatas! This one is particularly tricky on baroque flute.
especially those trills on the last mov.
Martin Eslava ruclips.net/video/mhDIeqK-VC8/видео.html
Yes, that one is indeed tricky on the baroque flute. But ... suppose this isn't the original (= earliest) version of the flute sonata? What if Bach originally wrote this sonata in the the key of D major (which also sounds much better on the baroque flute without all those awkward fork fingerings), and then at a later point transposed it two semi-tones up? Perhaps in order to present Quantz or Buffardin with a challenge.
The absence of low D-sharp's in the flute part makes me rather suspicious. You actually won't find a note lower than E in any of the four movements. By comparison: The flute sonata in E minor, BWV 1034 contains lots of low D-sharps. Therefore I am getting increasingly convinced that this sonata is most likely a transposed version - something that J.S. Bach also did with the B minor Sonata for flute and harpsichord, BWV 1030.
The pitch here has been raised significantly from that of the 1975 recording.
You know, there was a friend of mine that told me she thought Bach's flute sonatas were boring. And I quote "Snore," as she put it. I did not fall asleep---I actually rather enjoyed it! Found the allegros riveting and the Siciliano very intriguing.
ok
Your friend just doesn't understand baroque interpretation
This and the e minor, 1034, are my favourites. Thanks for posting 👍
No one has talked about this yet, so I'll just bring it up now: the siciliano is (or at least starts as) a canon at the 15th.
My favorite one of all. I really like the fact you can hear the cello clearly.
Good afternoon.
They are my favourite sonatas! Bach is genius of flauto music. Special I like sonata in e or second sonata: BWV 1034.
.
Thank for your video.
.
8.12.22.
.
☀️
Makes me feel contemplative. Give it your full attention!
Spectacular!
Genius !
Thanks for uploading!
Do I hear a cello as well as a harpsi or clavichord in the continuo line? Intriguing sonata. Use of rests on the first beat of the bar in the continuo line give the piece a syncopated feel. Thank you gerubach. Beautiful transcription and animation as always.
Mari Christian it is a cello, ive been following the piece and I am interested in trying this out
You hear a cello. The C major, e minor and this E major, all have continuouwith the harpsichord. We used to do flute with bassoon continuo!
Does this not sound like BWV 211 the “coffee cantata”?
Bravo
6:05
Will you do BWV 1020 and BWV 1039, or move on to somehting else? Great video!
Time stamp 8:46
00:19
This is so hard to play!
What would the metronome speed be for the first movement??
Adagio ma non tanto
I believe he plays at a rough speed of 35-38 bpm
我比賽的指定曲...
449.2mhz
It sounds so good!!! But it’s out of tune....
That's because it's a traverso/baroque flute. They didn't have the science to perfect the scale in the 1730s, unlike modern instruments today. That's part of the appeal though.
Flute Cello Harpsichord
Hallo