That's just modern concert hall "etiquette", it was quite common in the day the clap or dance along with an opera or operetta. It still happens but on rare occassions such as the Vienna New Years concert, or a Rieu concert -- love or loathe the guy, he brings music the way it was intended to enjoy -- by engaging the public.
This is crazy. In 2011 Lucie was just a little kid, a promising musician from the Netherlands, Brett and Eddy were some random violinists in uni in far Australia. Who would have thought that 10 years later she will be roasting Twoset Violin, RUclipsrs with over 2 million subscribers while being an amazing recorder player signed by Decca Classics. That's just a reminder that we have honestly no idea where our lives can end up and who can we meet on the way.
Amazing, especially at her age! Maybe elementary school students who are just learning the soprano recorder (the type of recorder she is playing) should get to see videos like this, so that they don't develop the idea that recorders are just squeaky instruments that never sound good.
+Electric Dave Some people just have natural abilities that are far beyond most people. When I was 12 years of age I was very competent at mathematics and was fascinated by calculus. When I was 15 at school I was doing mathematical programming and trying to discover by myself optimization solutions that I didn't even know were real world mathematical problems and I thought I had stumbled into some new area that I invented. I hope that young girl uses her natural abilities and that may extend to beyond just music.
@@expression3639 Interestingly, far, FAR less so than everyone likes to think. Even professional musicians use plastic recorders. The material is far more "predictable" for the instrument makers than any natural grown material - and the rigidity and density of the material is what makes the sound. In reality, it is all about the skills of the musician (except for really, really cheap play "instruments").
Exactly. Such flutes are supposed to be basic instrument for beginners. But as we saw here, if the artist is skilled and hard working, you get music of highest degree. Big bravo also to her collegues, good musicians although of the age of a typical music school for beginners... You dont need to be a beginner for years. If you pay attention and work on, you can be good already as young. Although not everybody will be a master like girlie here. Also nice to see that many young public listening....
Da fehlen mir fast die Worte. Nicht nur die Musik ist wunderschön sondern die ganze Atmosphäre. Ich glaubte den Himmel sich zu diesen Kindern neigen zu sehen. ❤💐
The Recorder is the "sports car" of the woodwinds. It is the ultimate responder to the slightest touch and breath, even the beginner plastic Tudors and Yamaha tenor pieces. Lucie has shown amazing fluidity and intuitiveness with her instruments over the years. Would that our American young musicians draw inspiration from her.
It is very rare that a young musician in America would get some inspiration from something like this. Usually, they will watch this video and say "Hey that's cool!" and that would be the end of that. Lucie's dedication and discipline are the driving factors of her success (and help from her parents, of course), and these are rare qualities of American students, these days. Very recently, I showed a similar video and the one of Frans Bruggen playing the Bach concerto BWV 1053 (originally for keyboard, which, BTW Lucie also recorded), and they made the aforementioned reaction, and nothing more. No desire. Even the students that I taught flute to, had no interest in the instrument. Much less, the recorder, which I also play. It's a bit sad to think about, but it's a reality we have to contend with. 🙂
Nederlands are really a paradise for classical music! Victorsarmaniego is right! It's beautiful to see the interest that dutch children show towards the classical repertoire! This girl is a really AWESOME musician and the orchestra (very good) is entirely composed by young people. In my country (Italy) is almost impossible to find a similar situation! Here, the average public is interested in american pop music, and that's a pity, because we have been the motherland of a lot of great musicians!
A very talented young musician, isn't she, and I love that cute suppressed grin round 1.30. she's enjoying herself, and so did we! On visit to Brugge, we watched three young girls playing violin, cello and viola in the square, and they had a big crowd round them, all very appreciative, heaps better than rap! I'll watch for Lucie when she's on a world tour down in New Zealand!
It could be annoying but in this case when you play a rhythmically colourfull piece a stable clap is very usefull for children, that's why the conductor also does it, so it is intended and not ramdom as in many other cases in any kind of concerts.
Thank you Lucy that is such beautiful Plumbing, you indeed have a precious gift from Almighty God, thank you so much for sharing it with us all. Bill - UK
Isn't she great... not only her level of playing for her age but the obvious enjoyment she has during her performance... and now aged 13, she's just won the Dutch NTR Podium (6 May 2013) as Best Young Dutch Musician and will represent the Netherlands during the Eurovision Young Musicians in Keulen, Germany May 2014... GO BLOKFLUIT - GO RECORDER (*_*)
I saw her in an interview with Team Recorder. Apparently her parents, who were also musicians, made her practice a minimum of ten minutes a day before she could go off and do something else. It wasn’t the duration of the practice as much as making sure it was consistent. It probably helps that she’s a recorder prodigy.
Megeszem,de cuki!!!Kis zseni.Végigbőgtem.Annyira cuki ahogy beleéli magát. Meg ha jól láttam néhányszor majdnem elnevette magát.A karmester is milyen jófej...gyerekkoromban én is jártam zenekarba.
@@zeyroxbs I'm afraid I was joking . I never really thought it meant she was like a conker. Actually, it means "Such fun", not "too funny". Fun and funny are not at all the same thing, a mistake which foreigners often make . Thanks for trying to help, though .I appreciate that.
Zij heeft de zin van Brahms' stukje volledig begrepen. Het stukje heet "dans"! Zij gaat vreugde vewekkenmet haar manier van spelen. En het publiek mag rustig met z'n handen klappen. Doel van Brahms bereikt 🌷! Bewondering en Dank uit je buurland Duitsland, Lucie, Thomas
Bei so einem "Nachtigaeltje" muss man den Holländern hohen musikalischen Respekt zollen. Über die inzwischen erwachsene Lucie Horsch kann man ergötzlich staunen. Die Holländer haben auch brilliante Bach- Aufführungen und einen bewundernswerten Herreweghe. (Also nicht nur Heintje, wie die oft etwas überheblichen östlichen Nachbarn meinen!)
@@basedtrucker This doesn't make any sense at all. What's weak about wanting sheet music for the recorder? Somebody who wants sheet music knows how to read music, and if he a ukulele player knows how to read music he/she doesn't need anyone adapting TAB for guitar for him/her.
Normal adult's orchestra : no claps pls
Kids' orchestra : clap mother***ker clap clap clapclap clap clap clapclap.
That's just modern concert hall "etiquette", it was quite common in the day the clap or dance along with an opera or operetta. It still happens but on rare occassions such as the Vienna New Years concert, or a Rieu concert -- love or loathe the guy, he brings music the way it was intended to enjoy -- by engaging the public.
Underrated comment lol
@@forkless it's just my preference for music. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ i don't want a heck load of claps when i listen to music you know.
HAHAHAHAHAHA
lmaooo the conductor was showing them the rhythm of the clapssss hahaha
This is crazy. In 2011 Lucie was just a little kid, a promising musician from the Netherlands, Brett and Eddy were some random violinists in uni in far Australia. Who would have thought that 10 years later she will be roasting Twoset Violin, RUclipsrs with over 2 million subscribers while being an amazing recorder player signed by Decca Classics. That's just a reminder that we have honestly no idea where our lives can end up and who can we meet on the way.
333333444
What a special girl she is!
can you imagine what she is doing now?
YES !!
reacting To TwoSetViolin Video: Violin VS Recorder
and i Like it! LOL
Arie A Ginting Twosetters are everywhere. :) She did a good reacting video.
You literally commented that on another vid of her
@@drawbootiful8665 ops! you caught me LOL
Arie A Ginting yeah i did lmao
ruclips.net/video/pcaJyzvlrik/видео.html
Amazing, especially at her age! Maybe elementary school students who are just learning the soprano recorder (the type of recorder she is playing) should get to see videos like this, so that they don't develop the idea that recorders are just squeaky instruments that never sound good.
Yeesss sir Electric Dave
+Electric Dave
Some people just have natural abilities that are far beyond most people. When I was 12 years of age I was very competent at mathematics and was fascinated by calculus. When I was 15 at school I was doing mathematical programming and trying to discover by myself optimization solutions that I didn't even know were real world mathematical problems and I thought I had stumbled into some new area that I invented.
I hope that young girl uses her natural abilities and that may extend to beyond just music.
I'm pretty sure that the fact she's playing a wood recorder instead of a plastic recorder has a huge impact on the quality of the sound.
@@expression3639 Interestingly, far, FAR less so than everyone likes to think. Even professional musicians use plastic recorders. The material is far more "predictable" for the instrument makers than any natural grown material - and the rigidity and density of the material is what makes the sound. In reality, it is all about the skills of the musician (except for really, really cheap play "instruments").
Exactly. Such flutes are supposed to be basic instrument for beginners. But as we saw here, if the artist is skilled and hard working, you get music of highest degree. Big bravo also to her collegues, good musicians although of the age of a typical music school for beginners... You dont need to be a beginner for years. If you pay attention and work on, you can be good already as young. Although not everybody will be a master like girlie here. Also nice to see that many young public listening....
Roasting TwoSet at such a young age..
Get Twoset to watch this
@@HowardTse She’s out of tune and squeaky in this, she might get roasted lol
@@justabaritone845 come on, as someone her age she is very good, they would never do that
MARIA ATHINA KONSTANTINIDOU Yeah that’s true. She’s very good for her age
And she’s like a pro now!
it's so interesting to see the strings accompanying one recorder on a violin piece.
It's actually an orchestral piece, but the 1st violins always have the melody
@@victoriap7808 It's actually a 4-hand piano piece. A few of the 21 dances were orchestrated by Brahms himself, but this isn't one of them.
Da fehlen mir fast die Worte. Nicht nur die Musik ist wunderschön sondern die ganze Atmosphäre. Ich glaubte den Himmel sich zu diesen Kindern neigen zu sehen.
❤💐
Hallo wie geht
She looks so amused every time they pull a major tempo change on the audience 😂😂😂
She was hamming it up for someone who was laughing at her antics. Sharp girl. Did you see her smile while she was trying to play?
ruclips.net/video/9KB2zNhE-5U/видео.html
@@randlyons7278 "Please don't make me laugh, I'm trying to play the recorder over here" ;)
Yeah, and the girl on the right at 1:43 is enjoying it to.
Kids like to play fast
I love her smiles during her performance. And to know how far she's come since then is amazing!
The Recorder is the "sports car" of the woodwinds. It is the ultimate responder to the slightest touch and breath, even the beginner plastic Tudors and Yamaha tenor pieces. Lucie has shown amazing fluidity and intuitiveness with her instruments over the years. Would that our American young musicians draw inspiration from her.
It is very rare that a young musician in America would get some inspiration from something like this. Usually, they will watch this video and say "Hey that's cool!" and that would be the end of that. Lucie's dedication and discipline are the driving factors of her success (and help from her parents, of course), and these are rare qualities of American students, these days. Very recently, I showed a similar video and the one of Frans Bruggen playing the Bach concerto BWV 1053 (originally for keyboard, which, BTW Lucie also recorded), and they made the aforementioned reaction, and nothing more. No desire. Even the students that I taught flute to, had no interest in the instrument. Much less, the recorder, which I also play. It's a bit sad to think about, but it's a reality we have to contend with. 🙂
And 11 years later she is as vivacious and fun-loving in her music as she was here- always great to watch and listen to.
always great on the flute...Lucie is always a great honor and a real pleasure to listen to her performances 🤓👍🏾👏👏👏👏
I love how the kids are looking at her and the recorder like "We gotta step up our game at music class".
Nederlands are really a paradise for classical music!
Victorsarmaniego is right! It's beautiful to see the interest that dutch children show towards the classical repertoire! This girl is a really AWESOME musician and the orchestra (very good) is entirely composed by young people. In my country (Italy) is almost impossible to find a similar situation! Here, the average public is interested in american pop music, and that's a pity, because we have been the motherland of a lot of great musicians!
1:28 conductor teaching the audience how to clap
When time signature s change
and yet he is off as hell
i am from 2021 the futer
I have no words to thank Life enough for all of this.
She was so on time altho she wasn’t really looking at the conductor. Impressive
She was conducting the conductor...
Exactly. I thought he was a bit of an idiot and patronising to the audience,
A very talented young musician, isn't she, and I love that cute suppressed grin round 1.30. she's enjoying herself, and so did we! On visit to Brugge, we watched three young girls playing violin, cello and viola in the square, and they had a big crowd round them, all very appreciative, heaps better than rap! I'll watch for Lucie when she's on a world tour down in New Zealand!
Best part about the recorder.... doesn’t need a reed
Worst part is playing outside when there is wind!
What's a reed?
Best part of recorder on youtube? I can turn it off.
@@corriedebeer799 you can turn a normal off too. Just by stopping playing it.
I play bassoon, and all our reeds cost so much because they are handmade. Like $20 per reed...
Teljesen új hangzást adott Brahms művének ez a gyönyörű előadás. Gratulálok Lucie!
This beautiful performance gave Brahms a whole new sound. Congratulations Lucie!
Don't you hate it when people clap ?
Especially when they clap on 1, 2, 3 and 4.
Zij heeft alleen maar begrepen waarom Brahms deze muziek heeft gemaakt ... Om vreugde te verwekken. Her stukje heet "dans"!!
It could be annoying but in this case when you play a rhythmically colourfull piece a stable clap is very usefull for children, that's why the conductor also does it, so it is intended and not ramdom as in many other cases in any kind of concerts.
yup i do
Yeah if they would just clap on the offbeat (2,4) I would be fine. But switching of from 1,3 to 2,4 is just confusing.
¡Qué hermoso es ver a tantos niños a los que les gusta la música clásica!
Verdad!? Aunque es muy normal en Europa...
Wspaniała, brawurowa gra, pierwszy raz słyszę o tej wykonawczyni dzisiaj juz doroslej osobie. 🌹jak się zorientowałam.
now Lucie Horsch is reviewing twoset.
BTW thanks for playing mah song. (if u correct me, it's Brahms not Bruhms. well Bruh is a meme)
Prachtig gespeeld, pretty girl. Cheers van oude hilversumer sinds 1958 in huonville tasmania australia.🇳🇱.
I wonder what Twoset violin has to say about this, hmm...
I think this little chickadee inspired me more than anyone else to learn this instrument.
Mijn complimenten! Niet alleen voor deze jonge DAME, maar ook voor haar ouders, dat zij haar een GOEDE MUZIKALE opvoeding hebben gegeven!
Chapeau!
How old, and how good? Utterly spectacular. Thank you.
Petite Lucie est merveilleuse de grâce et de vivacité et mérite de faire une belle carrière musicale !
Genialne wykonanie !!👋🎼🎵🎶❤️
I think this peace of recorder music is so beautiful
Köszönöm szépen!Csodálatos volt!
Que talento incrível,saudações do Brasil
No clap and enjoy ! Love the little one playing..
She is the only student who takes recorder lessons seriously.
Such musicality as well as technucal skill. Awesome.
I've had a few rare Elementary students over the years, who could play this. I had the orchestral, "Music Minus One," backing track.
Great! This girl (must be a young woman by now) knows how to perform in front of people and plays extraordinarily well.
She shows promise . . . and now. Yup: a phenomenon.
She is a born legend
And she grew with such a mastery of the instrument!
0:58 I like her smile. Also in 1:20
Una belleza!!! Un ángel!!
MY GOODNESS, she's amazing
BRAVO LUCY.
Thank you Lucy that is such beautiful Plumbing, you indeed have a precious gift from Almighty God, thank you so much for sharing it with us all. Bill - UK
This Musik from the Orchestra Klingt so good and so beautiful
Assistido. Andréia Maria de Oliveira. Grupo de Flauta Doce. Impressionante ela tocando. Parabéns!
simply stunning, hear those phrases
Assistido, Alcione B. Gomes Barbosa GFD. Simplesmente Maravilhoso!
ABSOLUTELY BEAUTIFUL!!!
Thank you so much for bringing with you!!! :-)
Isn't she great... not only her level of playing for her age but the obvious enjoyment she has during her performance... and now aged 13, she's just won the Dutch NTR Podium (6 May 2013) as Best Young Dutch Musician and will represent the Netherlands during the Eurovision Young Musicians in Keulen, Germany May 2014... GO BLOKFLUIT - GO RECORDER (*_*)
Her amusement of the audiences inability to understand the tempo changes. Pure musical genius
I don't know many pieces that do it so abruptly.
Charles Chaplin used it to great comedic effect in the barber scene of
"The Great Dictator (1940)."
Did she practice 40 hours a day????
I saw her in an interview with Team Recorder. Apparently her parents, who were also musicians, made her practice a minimum of ten minutes a day before she could go off and do something else. It wasn’t the duration of the practice as much as making sure it was consistent. It probably helps that she’s a recorder prodigy.
Megeszem,de cuki!!!Kis zseni.Végigbőgtem.Annyira cuki ahogy beleéli magát. Meg ha jól láttam néhányszor majdnem elnevette magát.A karmester is milyen jófej...gyerekkoromban én is jártam zenekarba.
Bravo por Lucia mis mejores saludos para usted bendiciones
Any Twosetters ?
Nádhera už po několikáté si poslouchám ❤️❤️❤️
9:11 PM California
These children are astonishing.! And on a recorder!!! Amazing.
Linda criança. Linda música.Deus abençoe seu talento.
Великолепное исполнение!👍👏
This brings joy to my heart.
Trop marrant de voir Lucie Horsch alors qu'elle était une enfant !
La vidéo montre qu'elle était déjà très à l'aise sur scène.
"Marrant ! " Does that mean she is "comme un marron" ? And she is too much like un marron. I see.
@@mirpopolos6209 marrant means funny, basically hes saying that its amusing seeing lucie as a child
@@zeyroxbs I'm afraid I was joking . I never really thought it meant she was like a conker. Actually, it means "Such fun", not "too funny". Fun and funny are not at all the same thing, a mistake which foreigners often make . Thanks for trying to help, though .I appreciate that.
A doll playing that pretty!!!
Que linda essa menina! Muito talentosa!
Zij heeft de zin van Brahms' stukje volledig begrepen. Het stukje heet "dans"! Zij gaat vreugde vewekkenmet haar manier van spelen. En het publiek mag rustig met z'n handen klappen. Doel van Brahms bereikt 🌷!
Bewondering en Dank uit je buurland Duitsland, Lucie,
Thomas
Génial !!! Comme quoi le talent ça ne tombe pas de nul part...
Fabulosa exitante expectacular toda una diva la viva esencia de la música
When there's no corona virus at that time. Look wt those people so happy.. under the sun.. isnt it happy? 😔
can someone tell me where do they join those groups
Bei so einem "Nachtigaeltje" muss man den Holländern hohen musikalischen Respekt zollen.
Über die inzwischen erwachsene Lucie Horsch kann man ergötzlich staunen.
Die Holländer haben auch brilliante Bach- Aufführungen und einen bewundernswerten Herreweghe.
(Also nicht nur Heintje, wie die oft etwas überheblichen östlichen Nachbarn meinen!)
Ze heeft er plezier in! Leuk om te zien. Wat 'n talent blijkt 't zijn!
Toca muito... Parabéns 👏👏 Assistido, Rosineide, GFD.
Lucie, wat ben je goed! Krijg weer helemaal zin om gelijk mijn alt te pakken en lekker te gaan spelen!! Toppie meis!!!
このとき彼女は小学生くらい？
私も通っていた音楽教室の影響もあり、中学生の頃には、木製のアルト・リコーダーを購入し、リコーダー双方の教則本を見ながらタンギングや装飾音を学び、ヘンデルの協奏曲などを拭いていたことがあった。
一時は専門家を目指そうかと思ったこともあったくらいだったが、日本の音大ではブロックフレーテ専攻は難しいのに加え、私の肺活量にも問題があって諦めた。
-
小学校を卒業するまで授業を聴いたためしがなかった私は、教科書は学校に置きっぱなしで、学校には好きな本と詩やエッセイを書き溜めたノート、それにリコーダーを入れたカバンを持って通っていたほどリコーダーは好きだった。
けれども、ピアノやソルフェージュは習っていたとはいえ、さすがに小学生でここまで音楽性が育つほどの音楽環境ではなかった。
-
長じて、ウィーンで足掛け１５年に渉る資料研究滞在の間に、一流の音楽も浴びるほど聴いた私は、今なら本物の音楽性もわかる。
リコーダーは、フルートなどとは異なり、吹き口が既にできているから、子供でも音は出しやすい。
タンギングや指の動きなどは練習すれば習得できるが、問題は音楽性。
日本でも、バッハ・コレギウム・ジャパンではないけれど、親子二代の音楽家なら、幼少期からこのくらいの音楽性は育つのだろうけれど。
-
日本の音大は少子化とクラシック音楽低迷で、私立を中心に閉鎖の危機を迎えていると聞いた。
一児のピアノブームが異常だったと言えばそれまでだが、その分、学校の音楽教育で豊かな音楽性を育みたいものだ。
小学生がリコーダーでここまで吹けると知れば、刺激を受ける子も多いのではないかと期待する。
日本の小学校に、こういう天才少女を招聘したいものだ。
I come back to watch it again in 2024.
thanks twosetviolin. Like really. Lucie Horsch is godsent
you my star....little angel
How old is she? Great performance
Gabča Vodičková Now is 17 :) She is teenager
An incredible player who has (finally) taken over the mantle of Brüggen.
@@WiktoriaSzalaty so you are telling me that this was an 11 year old playing the recorder like this!? Wow.... Never knew that that was possible...
@@wolfydawolf5680 When I was 11, I played mostly BAG songs 😂
Lovely event. Every little thing is a blessing
Ahw, how cute. Little lucie with her flute. DOUBLE LIKE!
What is the name of the piece ?
@anyone
What a fine young lady she has grown up to becoming
Is no one going to talk about how the conductor is indicating the tempo change to the audience so that they clap well ?
Superb quality ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
beauty girl ,passion music.
0:38 TwoSet meme review the asian lady clapping
Yeah you can tell she is watching her kid in the orchestra like a hawk and knows the peice by heart lol
does anyone have sheet music for the recorder please?
If you need sheet music for recorder translation you're as weak as a uk player asking s guitarist to transpose a guitar song
Music shops stock heaps!
@@basedtrucker This doesn't make any sense at all. What's weak about wanting sheet music for the recorder? Somebody who wants sheet music knows how to read music, and if he a ukulele player knows how to read music he/she doesn't need anyone adapting TAB for guitar for him/her.
Est-ce que quelqu'un connaît la date de ce concert ?
Bravo! Well done! :-)))))
excelente interpretación!! buena música
Hey girl, that is fantastic. you are doing great, go on:) good luck
I also try that. But I couldn't play like that😁
Wonderful! Thank you for sharing!
That was some really great music. Thanks and keep up the good work.
Wonderful performance !! 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏🎵🎼🎶
This kid is amazing!!
Her wonderful performance is the acme of pleasure
너무 잘해요