COURTROOM INSIDER | Defense witnesses take the stand
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 22 сен 2024
- #eastidahonews #daybell #truecrime
Tonight on 'Courtroom Insider,' more defense witnesses are called to the stand. We break down what happened!
Let us know if you have questions and where you are watching from.
► Follow Nate Eaton on Facebook: / nateeatonreporter
► Follow Nate Eaton on Instagram: / n.eaton
► Follow Nate Eaton on X: / natenewsnow
► Support East Idaho News: www.eastidahon...
► Subscribe to East Idaho News: www.youtube.co...
► Get East Idaho News merch: www.eastidahon...
► Download our free app: marketplace-red...
► Like us on Facebook: / eastidahonews
► Follow us on X: / eastidnews
► Follow us on Instagram: / eastidahonews
► Subscribe to our free newsletter: www.eastidahon...
Joseph Murray made himself look ridiculous. I have noticed everyone in the family seems quite....slow. I honestly wonder whether they need some sort of intervention because they appear to be perilously stupid. His anger at the police for wanting to investigate a house where two dead children were found. Joseph Murray is DENSE.
😂
😂😂😂 I didn't want to say it out loud but you read my thoughts lol
Well, he’s married to Emma…so there’s THAT.
And I thought I was the only one who thought that. Chad is an idiot so the apples, etc. etc. Slow minded yes. They were not able to pull off what Prior wanted them to do. A complete waste of time. No matter what they said or the pathologist, the prosecution laid it all out. Chad is toast.
It makes you wonder if there is some inbreeding going on
Thanks, JP for announcing in open court that Tammy was murdered. I hope that the jury caught his Freudian slip.
Where did that happen? Can you timestamp it please? Thank you.
@samsmom400 if you go to hidden true crime, Lauren talked about it on her lunch live, more info there
It was when he was redirecting after cross of the medical examiner.
It's right here in Thus video
39:55
Prior drove me nuts urging Emma and Garth to become emotional. "If you need to pause, drink some water or use a tissue....." Seriously? AND they were totally unemotional about their mother's death? Interesting! 😳
I thought the SAME thing…
I wrote that in the comments on yesterday's video. Luckily the "kids" are too stupid to get the cue to cry from those comments from JP.
Zero empathy!!
I wouldn't be surprised if he really was trying to be sympathetic (I believe prosecution has done that too for some of their witnesses). However, the fact that they didn't have emotions about it after he said that probably made it more apparent to the jury haha
To be fair, Garth did say he was gonna take a sip of water. Then he kept on going 😂 They have no self awareness ‼️
Thank you, Joe Murray! You handed the win to the prosecution! Joe Murray’s testimony was so cringeworthy. Joe, was MAD at the lead detective because the detective kept driving past Chads house. Detective Hermilliso, knew those innocent children were probably dead and buried in Chads backyard. He was RIGHT! Detective Hermillsio, is a HERO. Joe Murray, is a deranged, twisted nutcase.
But, he just didn't see ANY reason why Hermosillo would need to drive by! SMH Joe was so callous about those kids. May he and Emma have the lives they deserve!!
LDS TEACHES MEMBERS TO SETTLE TROUBLES WITHIN THE CHURC, or at least use their lawyers, etc. they never want govt. involved in their secrets, of which their are many. I looked up a little research, today, in addition to what I already had learned.
@@keep.it.moving77AGREED.
@@PeppersMomAnd based on the way Chad's kids have acted, I'm not sure they weren't in on it at this point.
yesterday's witnesses proved just that. they absolutely knew about the kids. i wanna know why the police never asked them when all this first started. @@FindMeOnABeach
The Daybell kids should b fired from teaching! Dangerous t have them around anybody's kids!!!!!🥵
I believe they should most definitely be fired if they are found to have committed perjury.
And removed from society
Oil 20:52 @@1stDoNoHarm63 no way they should be around any children not even there own,
Agree!
💯 Their beliefs are crazy. I mean Emma said a dark entity was trying to enter in to her body physically but her dad casted it out and she instantly felt better. I would NOT allow my child to be taught anything from that whack job. She needs a psych evaluation. Her and Garth both.
This whole family is dangerous….delusional and combative! If I were an officer, that was investigating this case, I would also keep a close eye on this family!
My thoughts too. No one knows how dangerous these kids could be. I mean no one would have suspected Chad to be so evil.
Yes, if Emma is still working with children, it's likely she'll get fired now that she's disclosed that someone or something inhabited her body on one or more occasions.
👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
They seriously need to check the water table around there! But yeah, those people are brainwashed and need reprogramming like nazis after ww2. They are in complete denial and la la land
@@oliphantfiction5144
I certainly hope so.
Lindsey Blake played Mr Prior like a fiddle during the doctor’s testimony. Forcing Mr. Prior’s objection and her swift rebuttal regarding the materials viewed by the defense expert was a masterclass in STRATEGY. She made sure all attention was riveted on her as she pointed out the lack of materials given to the doctor. Bravo!
I agree. But I think when she asked for a redirect and the judge said no because nothing new was addressed he was mistaken because the “new thing” was that the dr said that outside reports are never taken into account when determining manner of death. But anyone who has watched a murder trial (including this one where it was mentioned earlier in the trial). That outside reports are ABSOLUTELY used to establish murder as manner of death
@@karennotAkaren1 😊
Just got to this, and YES she set that up brilliantly by rattling off the list to deliberately draw an objection so she could show how this witness wasn’t properly prepared. Brilliant move
@@Malama_Ki 😊
Was very enjoyable to watch!
Joe Murray mentioned he saw Hermosito on Facebook, so who is stalking who ?😂
Saw him on Facebook? How did Joe see him on Facebook? Maybe he was just “driving by” different sites to observe what was being said about Chad. What a piece of work you are Joe. Your comment about law enforcement did not help Chad at all and revealed you for the nasty little boy you are.
I was wondering what that was about.
Me too! I thought the same thing! Lol
Lol 🤣😆
W t h was THAT about? 🤷🏻♀️
Nate deserves an award for his reporting, not to mention East Idaho News! I'm from North Dakota and your reporting far surpasses anything we have here! Thank you all for your hard work! Including Erica and Peggy!
Because we get the truth! The msm mafia has no clue what truth is!!!
Agreed! I wish we had reporters here in 🇨🇦 with half Nate’s dedication & candor.
@@achanneledname😂I think you should retire from the keyboard tonight & get back to whatever you’ve been smoking!!
Minnesota here and I totally agree!
He has, EIN has. They just had an awards thing a couple weeks ago and I think overall EIN received 12 awards. I wish I could remember which night he talked about it and showed pictures. They've definitely been recognized for their hard work. I love how real and relatable Nate is!
So joseph Murray is so hostile about police, but called them when his mother in law is shot at?🤔
He’s a typical a$$hole who will use police services when he needs to. He doesn’t give a hoot about police. He’s probably selfish, and his anger is definitely misdirected at police. Emma is also selfish. In her cop car dash-cam with Chad, she implied she’d play the sympathy card with neighbors by asking, “Can you help me? My mom died.” Even on the 48 hours show she tried to get sympathy by saying that her mom was dead and her father is in jail. She’s focused on how everything impacts her.
Pretty sure he was fine with police BEFORE they started going after Chad 🙄 I hope he never dials 911 again!
Exactly! Plus, the police/fire/EMS cannot get there fast enough!
The whole Daybell family is a bunch of dangerous narcissistic freaks.
@@MycatdiditExactly, he called before the family became the source of an investigation.
He was obviously not hostile until the police arrested his daddy in law ... plus I think Emma wears the pants in that relationship so no doubt has some influence on his views
I was there yesterday for the testimony of Emma and Garth. My heart absolutely breaks for Tammy after listening to both of them and having time to absorb their testimony. I understand they have lost their mother and are afraid to lose their father. It does not excuse their utter betrayal of their mothers memory. Emma was combative with the the prosecution and came across as angry. Garth came across as someone who was scared and nervous. Their monotone style of speaking reminded me of people who had been brainwashed and manipulated. It will be interesting to see if just one of the five children of Tammy’s, break away from the group and start reading and listening to the facts. I absolutely feel horrible for the children but it does not excuse describing their mother in a false light. I understand the place Tammy was in life. Her kids were grown, she was starting to figure out who she was. She had many years left ahead to find out the things she enjoyed. She was an incredibly hard worker. Supporting the household, running a business and most likely making the meals and doing housework. While Chad, spent his time writing silly stupid stories to send to a woman who also took advantage of her spouse. Chad and Lori absolutely deserve each other. Tammy and Charles just wanted to be supportive spouses and Chad and Lori wanted to destroy all the good around them for their own selfish desires. Emma and Garth are delusional about their father and I hope someday they see what a disservice they did to their mothers memory. I was not impressed with Joe, Emma’s husband. God forbid, he should need help from law enforcement someday. Civil servants such as law enforcement put their lives on the line everyday for us. The investigative work done on this case has been extensive and self sacrificing.
Were you able to see the jury's expressions? I would love to know if they thought their testimony was believable! Thank you!😊
Well said!
Well stated, every word.
@@annettew5740 Mate and his wife have stated the jurors are intricate to stay as emotionless as possible throughout the trial. Hope this helps. 😊
I sat in three different seats but didn’t have a good view of the jury as far as expressions. I noticed they were all paying attention and some taking notes. I think it’s a good jury and love how the court is so protective of this process. Judge Boyce runs a smooth ship and very impressed with all of the staff. I did notice Emma got emotional at the beginning of the dash cam footage that was shown but neither children showed any emotion talking about the day their mother died or thereafter. It is honestly unbelievable how robotic they were speaking about such a traumatic time in their lives. No emotion over children being found in the backyard either. It was bizarre, as a mother myself to three adult children.
Joseph Murray is so disrespectful saying that about law enforcement just because he's angry that his FIL got busted for his horrible behavior!!! What a crybaby coward
Unless he needs to report an incident that effects him..or he needs help. Then he will be the first to dial 911
The poor sad man was trying to appease the man he has been trained to kowtow to.... sitting right in front of him..never mind the 'reality of the situation'....
Ok, in everyone else’s world….
Lindsay Blake was absolutely sailing in the sunshine as she asked question after question about reports that Dr. Raven had not reviewed, but ultimately winning the objection *after* Boyce had at first sustained it and just seamlessly continuing down the same line of questioning was just… *[chefs kiss]* Puts the wind in my sails.
I think it proved confirmation bias. Coroner doesn't examine rumors. They examine the body. Affairs and rumors are for the detectives.
Coroners actually do look at the circumstances around a death, sometimes it’s the only was to determine manner of death.
When a healthy woman dies - undetermined should lead to ask more questions - that expert used bias by only looking at what the defense gave her - I wonder if she asked for more. Imo
So confused why the witness didn’t review outside factors.
Other factors that a coroner may consider when determining the cause of death without an autopsy include:
Whether the death was set up to look like an accident or suicide
Whether the death was suspicious
Whether the death was a suicide
If a decedent has no known medical history or medical records, the cause and manner of death may be undetermined.
@@Carpooldj Dr Raven was provided with whatever she used in her determination.
…by John Prior.
Ray Hurmasio thank god for him he never gave up on the kids he put his whole heart into this he was brokenhearted to find the children the way he did ill never forget how emotional he was on the stand my heart goes out to this man he along with alot of other people will never forget what they saw
Some of the detectives in the Chris watts case had to retire early because of PTSD after finding the children 😭
@Mycatdidit I remember hearing that. After finding the 2 little innocents in the oil tanks they couldn't continue their profession. They must have seen a lot in their careers but clearly that was just too much!
Hermosillo
@@Mycatdiditthat's terrible. Can't even imagine what they saw. The stuff of nightmares
JJ Vallow would be 12 years old this Saturday, 5/25. Tylee Ryan would be 22 years old this year. 😢😢
This Daybell clan is insane.
Oh my goodness. 😢
John is doing his very best with what he has I must say. But my goodness these Witnesses have been better for the prosecution and show what liars and manipulators these people are
There have been so many times I've been wondering what he was even trying to accomplish with whichever witness he has up at the time. Haven't heard a single thing yet that helps the defense. (At least not that sounded believable.)
The kids are textbook cult victims...like Warren Jeff's kids or the Duggers
I agree with you. What an insurmountable amount of evidence, witnesses & bs for one attorney to wade through. Sure he can be extremely ridiculous & gets on my last nerve at times but he’s doing the job well- and by well I don’t mean he’s mounting a credible defense in any sense of the word. I simply mean when this is over & Chad is dealt his fate I don’t see any way he could claim ineffective counsel. I believe Prior has overturned every possible rock that reasonable doubt could be hiding under & it’s not there. Prior isn’t expecting an acquittal here, a win for his client would be life without the possibility of parole.
So we can thank him for a solid effort and for eliminating several grounds for appeal in the future. Without criminal defence attorneys there could be no prosecutions.
Perhaps they should have practiced more. But it seems like JP doesn't think practice makes perfect
@@msaijay1153 they already practiced for 4 years. Don’t think prior can squeeze another drop of juice from them lol. This is all they can do. I’m sure they practiced days & nights. They didn’t answer the questions, they recited the answers 😂.
Joseph Murray showed his true character, and it was ugly. How dare he question the rights of Detectives to drive past the house of horrors. 2 missing children were found behind the house, one of them butchered, beheaded, and her burned organs thrown into a bucket. The Detectives and others had to see that and didn't know which kids might have been involved. Joseph is not a poster boy for the LDS church. He's a heartless nobody.
They all are.
Is he slow? Not trying to be mean but the guy seems challenged.🇨🇦
Okay it was a cop raccoon driving a truck wearing a Fitbit with a paint gun. This is the most ridiculous defense I have ever heard.🇨🇦
Would rather choose any profession and yet he has none.
All these people make the LDS religion look bad. Rightfully so it seems. Nothing but a cult!
I’ve had anemia since I was a child. I’m 54. Anemia is not fatal
I’m 69 and also have anemia. No big deal.
Same here!
Many women have it occasionally, sometimes due to their monthly, or if they don't regularly get enough iron. If there's no underlying serious issue causing it like cancer, its not a huge deal at all, and very common.
every woman had anemia one time or the other, especially during pregnancies, we loose blood during our period, I had sever anemia I needed blood transfusions', I am not 72 did not die. No more period no more anemia.
Me too and I'm 54
I think the Joe fellow sounded foolish having a problem with the investigating officer doing his job and being stubborn about it during questioning.
Meanwhile he did a fundraiser for that Operation Underground Railroad scam. I wonder how Joseph decides which children are worth protecting and which ones it's okay if they turn up dead in the backyard.
Only shows he knew things
Accusatory. Law enforcement didn't kill and bury those children in the home of Chad Dabells. 3 people who died by Homicide are connected to that Home. Plus connection Charles valor's MURDER.
Chad refused to wear the Fitbit because it would track his movements, he was a serial cheater and had used burner phones before
That “Chad’s truck” argument is plain fooey! If the shooter intended to shoot Chad, he would have turned around and run upon seeing the driver was Tammy. Instead he slinked around and attempted to shoot her three times!?!?
Very good point. Hopefully someone on the jury sees it that way too.
Excellent point. Hopefully the jury has a majority of people like you who has common sense and intelligence.
No sh##! This is a bleak attempt over and over again.
Exactly they were face to face at 9ne point
I have to chuckle at the defense logic - it wasn't a gun, it was paintball gun. There was a deranged teenager in the neighborhood. And btw, the victim was Chad because it was his truck, not Tammy's, despite everyone calling it her truck. And then 10 days later, she died of natural causes, and Emma didn't want an autopsy. It really has nothing to do with Chad, who btw was having a physical affair with Lori. Nothing to see here. Case closed.
His children PROVED there’s something super strange in that family! If that’s the best witness prior had he was up a creek without a paddle.
Imho, the trial is over. The defense attorney said Tammy was murdered today in cross direct! Let’s move to sentencing!
😊
Can you timestamp it please? I missed it. Thank you.
39:54 just about here 🤔
@@samsmom400 39:50-40
I heard that too!
Emma was so unbelievable and did nothing to help her father. In fact some of the things she said only proved how little she actually knew about the situation. Totally brainwashed. Her husband came off as a nutty sovereign citizen! 😵💫😵💫
I think it proves she knew. Who gets told there’s dead kids in the yard and doesn’t question it? Her dad was in cuffs. She could have asked and said whatever she wanted right then. Or how about asking questions after she knows he’s going to be locked up until at least trial? And how could she move into that house?
She knew and was fine with everything. 😡
My dad was a sovereign citizen nut in the '90s and I can definitely see those traits in Joseph Murray.
Oh my god that’s it!! Yes he totally reminds me of those narcissistic SC’s!! 😂 also, did you notice how prior said that he directed the kids not to watch the trial in his subpoena (even though they are allowed to because they are victims)? I bet that’s because if they did they’d finally come to terms with the obvious reality that their dad did all of this stuff and then they wouldn’t wanna testify 😂
39:50 I GASPED out loud when he said MURDER 😱 That's quite a Freudian slip from the defense.
I’ve heard news networks and internet channels referring to your excellent work a lot lately , and more often than not they mention you simply as “Nate” or “East Idaho’s Nate”. Seems you’ve joined the club of one of the one-named celebrities. Makes me smile every time I hear someone refer to you that way. It’s a well-deserved compliment 😊
i love him and Vinnie. those are my fave news guys. ❤
Lindsay Blake was a Rockstar!!!!🤩
🌹👌❤️👍 Fun to watch! A+
Joseph’s disdain for law-enforcement was a bad look. He made sure to mention twice that the last career he would ever want is law-enforcement. What a POS. Like he could ever even qualify
He certainly intended it to be a rude comment! Pathetic-
Alls he done was make him seem even more not believeable,SMH
It was a huge mistake. At least one or more of the jurors has a close friend or family member in LE. Worst thing he could do for Chad, honestly.
Unless they start a Wet Noodle Division.
It's such a contrast between what this family has done and the law enforcement work. I hope jury is furious.
“I would rather be in any other profession than Law Enforcement” believe me, Joe, the citizens of Idaho are thankful.
My son in law is FBI and my grandson is a police officer. It made me so angry to hear him speak that way about any law enforcement!! I hope his family never ever needs help!! But I know the law enforcement community would still be there to help them even with Joe’s horrible attitude!!!
@@debraboyer1972 how ironic that at the mere **thought** of danger re: Tammy’s shooting incident, Joe called the police immediately. In my head, I imagine him sitting in his closet, teeth chattering, nails being bitten, as he awaits their arrival 🙄
I will be so glad when this is over, to NEVER hear Pryor's voice again!!!
Me too. I literally forward through when Pryor is at the podium.
Chad’s two kids and the son in law all sound monotone puppets. Wouldn’t be surprised if they were involved
I will be so glad to never hear “kitty-corner” ever again.
@@carlyn1617I don’t know why they don’t just say diagonal.
He sounds like a predator at the bar drinking soda water and scamming on drunk women. So full of sh@t I bet the jury comments on how deceitful he sounds.
That’s fair 😉
Did anyone else notice what Emma said on her first day (i think) when asked how her dad was behaving the morning her mom died...She said he was acting like anyone else who "just saw their wife die"? Chad's hasn't said he saw the death (at least not to police). But he has said his kids are good at keeping secrets.
I caught that! The way she described him at the funeral was all kinds of creepy too.
Great catch! I thought it was a very odd way to word it.
I agree with Dr Mathias on hidden true crime… I don’t think this necessarily means anything. It could just be her mis-speaking by trying to say that he was there to find her dead when she was alive hours before. Who knows tho.
Children were the worst witness ever !
But the silver lining is hopefully the jurors saw right through them, and it will all be worth it in the long run.
They were, and isn’t it just great? 😊
They were unemotional zombie like robots, and terrible liars.
In the history of witnesses!!
@@bladz1girl Oh, I thought she meant in this trial, so now I got to toss Jennifer Crumbley's hat in the ring. She was a horrible witness on behalf of herself, thank God!
Blake is incredible. So many mic drop moments that she delivers with complete calm.
“Not present at the murder” Pryor’s own statement.
Anyone else hear?
Yes!!!
Oopsie!
Yep!
The looks on the prosecutors faces were priceless! 😂
Rude comment, the “ I’d rather choose any other profession “ was rude and I believe he intended it to be rude!
It was intended to be and it hurt his credibility! He doesn’t like law enforcement for investigating missing kids that ended up in his FIL’s back yard? then why should we give weight to anything he says? I’m certain the jury noticed this too! Rejoice that he HURT chads case today 😂😊
daybell and company is a Nasty group.
Yeah just wait until the next call for help comes for that address..
@@cathyhankins2929 they should block his number lol 😂
I think Tammy was killed before Garth got home from volunteering at the haunted house
I agree 100%
I think Garth knows much more!!
I have said that Garth knows his Dad killed Tammy. His phone call to 911 made me think that he was puzzled that she was rigid already. But consider this…Chad got into bed with his dead wife and slept! Psychopath!
@@candicewitzkoske3155all those kids and spouses do.
Would have been better off resting without a defense 😅 the kids did not help Chad out! Neither did the paid coroner who wasn’t prepared to testify!
Paid expert witnesses make really good money from the defense. They will say whatever it takes to get that money. I am a nurse. I refuse to be an expert witness as a nurse. It's viewed by many honorable nurses to be a dishonorable profession. That expert witness seemed to have a lot of general statements and no real expertise.
@@TremontonNurseMJ in my opinion.. it must change... no expert to testify for defense or prosecution.. it should be other way... no bias... i don't know... like all that kind of trial got to have 3 expert in any field needed... no there would be no 1 on 1...
That paid coroner was a joke!!!! She has no experience and sounds like a dumb ass. I don’t know how she can sleep at night what an idiot
That cross by miss Blake of the “did you review…” was a total mic drop moment
She's the goat.
i hope she has the biggest party thrown for her after this is over and Chad gets the DP 🎉🎉🎉
I really would like to hear jail calls between Emma and Chad. It's obvious to me that Emma was coached what to say by someone and i think it was Chad.
Chad had time to coach before he was ever locked up! Lori was already in jail!
@@cristineconnell7803yup!!
At first I was so confused why the prosecution didn’t play those calls but now I get it because it piques your curiosity and then you can’t forget about it! Then imagination takes over. Sometimes it’s more powerful not to be elaborate on key points. Also, I thought she might ask the kids if they keep chads secrets but she didn’t. That also makes sense in hindsight- because they’d just say no and then that would be that. If she waits to use that on closing when the kids can’t respond to it, it’s SO much more powerful. Let’s see if I’m right…
I think we WILL hear them. They will bring in a rebuttal witness to impeach her at the end.
There is NO way under any circumstance would any of my children be taught by Emma or her husband.
Or Garth!
Is her husband a teacher too?
My thoughts exactly. My kids went to Madison Jr. High.
Emma teaches 4th graders!!!!
Mine either,I think k so.ething needs to be done,maybe a petition I know the schools website and it has all the emails of the teachers,maybe we should email the school,
Thanks for our daily NATELINE!
Gotta rename courtroom insider!
Police driving by suspects’ places and keeping people who are linked to disappeared children is the opposite of sketchy - it’s exactly what you would hope the police were doing to work out what the deal with this property & family was. The idiocy of complaining about that…
I think Joseph’s testimony was as weird as Emma’s. What do they have to be so snippy about? THE BODIES WERE FOUND IN CHAD’S BACK YARD!!!!!
They’re a match made in heaven…or hell.
I thought the same thing. At least show an ounce of sympathy for two kids who were tortured and murdered. And his constant answers of “yep” got on my last nerve. I think he’d just a lying smart ass.
Isn't it now their backyard? 😂😂 Creepy
Disgusting how they have NO issues with murdered children being buried in the yard !
Wow I was shocked by Murry thoughtless harping on why the police officer kept driving by after the children were found. How can he not understand how these officers who had been looking for live children then to find them in such horrible conditions and wondering how could their deaths occurred. DID THE CHILDREN SUFFER . The detectives will need therapy. The daughter is just ĥeartless she enjoys throwing her mom under the bus by the words she uses. To be surrounded by such horrible children who wouldn't be depressed. The words Emma used to describe her mother almost gleeful descriptions that her mother wasn't up to snuff.
She's an awful person.
Emma basically called her mother….fat, lazy and a liar! Her adulterous father can heal her from depression or anxiety, with his blessing and deserves a tear or two over watching the video of Chud being taken into custody but you can forget about a “need for a moment, a drink of water or a tissue “ ( coached with failure by Prior ) for her dead mother. Poor sweet Tammy. I can only imagine her racing mind while her priest hood holding husband assisted in her murder.
Sadly both Tammy and Chad raised those kids old school LDS style- to honor the father and completely dismiss the mother. The culture can be so toxic.
The court should take the horrific pictures of Tylee❤ and JJ❤ and shove them in the Daybell/Murray faces. They need to look at them....really look at them and see what a revolting monster their father is 😡😠🤬😤
And Tammy worked full time, cleaned and cooked while Chad sat around playing with Lori. Who wouldn't be tired when they have no help around the house or financially. And work full time. Emma grated my nerves. Shame on her.
Emma claimed she searched the window direction at her parents’ house because she was late to getting a smart phone .. but one month later, she had a smart phone or computer in her home to see her mom’s Facebook post.
and she doesn't even know where west, north, south and east are so what use is checking on the wind direction?
Full of shite
Guarantee you a girl of Emma's age had a smart phone since at least 2010. I haven't known a single person, even social-media-averse or extremely data paranoid people, since that time to only use a flip phone or non-smart burner. That is, except Lori and her murderous clan of co-conspirators. Pretty sure Baby Girl just implicated herself in some serious crimes, bc they can easily prove she's had an iPhone or Android and when. Hell, Tammy was older and knew how to cheat her fitbit in order to play Candy Crush, like, how dumb do they think the jury IS???? This was the dumbest possible move.
@@gr122 yes, that was a doozie.
Tammy was surrounded by evil. No wonder she was tired and had fainting spells. Plus, her husband was having an affair. That's a super high stress situation.
I don't doubt she was tired, though I doubt she had fainting spells. No one but the children testified to that, no one Tammy worked with, not one she went to church with, etc. I am sure if she actually had a fainting spell, Prior would be quick to put any witnesses on the stand.
Just living with that self-proclaimed prophet is enough to depress a cat!
The children are lying and Prior is grasping at straws.
According to the children Tammy was volunteering at the 5K run. I don’t recall if any of the state’s witnesses testified otherwise.
And those so called fainting spells were nothing more than normal what most people experiences when they get up too fast, when they are bend down and get up fast quickly. Witness said that she sometimes felt dizzy, felt like fainting when she was bend down and got up.
Hello, Its normal... nothing to do with her general health.
She didn't have fainting spells.She felt light headed when she would stand up after kneeling for a longer time.Almost everyone feels that, especially if u have lower iron in the blood which is not a thing that kills I like that.I have that for most of my life, otherwise perfectly healthy and iam far from dead
Emma says she didn’t have a smart phone so needed to use her parents computer to check for wind flow. Yet she also received the notification on Facebook re her mum being shot at. Another lie
She claimed to check wind direction in September..The FB/paintball post would have been October
In the same statement she says she’s not good with directions, as in she doesn’t know her home and which direction is north or south. But we’re supposed to believe she searched for the wind directions (during teaching hours). Lying is part of their family culture. What a pathetic family.
@@misskelly9821 September was when Tylee was murdered.
Let's hope Detective Hermosillo keeps driving by their house... those nutballs Emma and Joseph have kids 😢
If I were him, I'd drive by every day on my way home from work. Well, until Prior kicks them out.
Im appalled at how rude and disrespectful Chads family is to the police. I sure hope they don’t need the police in the near future. Also it’s bizarre that non if his children have asked him WHY ARE THOSE Children DEAD and on YOUR PROPERTY?
Cultists dont like police officers or laws. They think they are so above everyone else and that their authority figures and laws comes from the cult, not from the "wrong" believers.
For all the years and hours that LE has put into justice for the children and Tammy. It was thoroughly disgusting that Garth stated his dislike of them in such a public way. Speaks volumes about him.
That wasn’t Garth. That was Joseph- Emma’s husband. Garth actually seems like a good dude that is just doing his best. Just my opinion. But Emma/Joe are nuts.
Better keep an eye on Joe Murray. He sounds like a dangerous person 😳
I was thinking he will probably take over Alex’s “projects” and those who testified against chad or didn’t agree with him may need to watch their 6
Yes @judistocker1811,I agree…I think there are some people that believe the psychotic teachings of chad and will carry on with “teaching” others because he won’t be able to…FBI need to keep an eye on melanie gibb,her husband,zulema and lori’s niece melanie too!
They all are dangerous.
Hope law enforcement looks into them.
They definitely are apart of this wickedness.
We don’t want any public servants who have the same character (no integrity) and egregious attitude as Joe Murray 😮
Slip of the tongue!!! Priceless!!!!
I think Joseph Murray has got a good dose of the Koolaid. Hope in his life he doesn’t need a policeman, I respect them so much for what they do. I have needed them and appreciate them. I think that says a lot about his character.
I, on the other hand, hope he does need help from LE at some stage. I hope any witnesses he needs are as helpful to him as he has been to Tammy, Tylee and JJ. I also hope that his father-in-law treats him with the love and respect he has shown to others.
This should be interesting if he stays in area. Rexburg and a lot of east Idaho is small town and wide open spaces. All law will remember his nasty attitude, his disdain for the children and law who found them.
Chad's kids I'd say have helped the prosecution more then anyone,
Hope they read this!
Emma was lying so much.
Thank you for your hard work Nate! These evening wrapups are priceless!
Yes..good job !!!
Joseph Murray sounds like Fozzie Bear. I guess it's lucky he wouldn't want to be a cop, because it would be ineffective to have a muppet doing traffic stops.
Here's your ticket! Wocka wocka wocka! 🧸
😂
Lmao 😂❤😂
Chad always sounded like Kermit the frog and well Lori just because she's vain could be Ms Piggy.
@@angelatheartist8349 I keep looking at Chad and think what the heck could any woman see in him. He’s just really gross.
You win best comment hahaha
the children are sure hostile aren't they? as well as uncooperative
Seriously, I couldn’t stomach listening to their drab, unemotional dribble and just quit.
Remember the snake in the old Robin Hood cartoon with the spinning hypnotic eyes? That’s Chad to his children….
It’s a gift to the prosecution!!! Kids are already going to be biased but why so angry? Oh right- because the cops totally set Chad up 😂😂😂 they have NO credibility now!
Emma is a callous liar. Tammy deserved better than these unfeeling idiots
Holy cow he says MURDER??!?! 🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️
Thanks Peggy! Your input was fun to have tonight. Thanks for helping in this horrific case.
❤100% thank you Peggy! I appreciate you 🙏
I think Tylee knew too much. She was there when Alex killed Charles, she knew about Chad, and Laurie. Colby is left alone.
Agree. She probably got in a fight with Lori and threatened to tell someone. She had to go.
Someone suggested it was actually Tylee who hit Alex in the head with the bat because if Charles had hit him, a fit man who played baseball, the hit would have killed Alex.
@@1stDoNoHarm63that would certainly explain the extent of the damage done to her body. As if the murderer (Alex) had a personal vendetta against her
Tylee and Lori did not wear a sandal when running out of the house. Lori got one from Walgreens. This means they rushed out for a solid reason. Also 45 mins later only Alex call 911. Tylee saw the killing is my assumption.
Right? So sad for Colby. She took so much from him.
Funny how Joe is so against LE but he called them for help the night Tammy got shot at.
I can't believe Prior said "..present at the murder." How could he have made such a mistake like that? Wixom & Deputy Atty Gen. definitely noticed with wide eyes and a smile as they look at each other. Doesn't seem like Wood caught it at all and Blake didn't either, it seemed, until she looked at Wixom; all of their reactions (or lack of) are so funny to me. I also looked at CD and he didn't seem to catch it or maybe he just kept his poker face. Did Prior ever realize what he said?!
Karma always comes to get you. 😂
Emma's husband is a bit cocky.. The whole Daybell clan are cocky.
Psychopaths.
Fits well in this family….right
Funny how all the defense witnesses so far have very selective memories or recollections.
Nate if you could answer this question or anybody else?
How in the world could anybody let children continue to go to Emma's classroom I would pull my student out so fast, it is disturbing beyond belief that she is in the care of children
If its a mormon school, thetes your answer.
@@jeaniechampagne8831there is no such thing as a Mormon School for one and for two the church is absolutely appalled by these people and they've been excommunicated so that doesn't even make sense play the victims are members of the church and this isn't a church issue anyways this is the decision of individuals. Trying to blame a church is just ignorant and gives Chad and Lori and out as if going to church, a church that teaches literally nothing that they teach, is justification and reason why they murdered these people?
@@jeaniechampagne8831oh, stop it! She works at a public school. “There’s your answer” haha I’m so funny…
@@jeaniechampagne8831 she’s worked at a public school. In a community full of LDS people. And none of those LDS people like her. I happen to know, because I am from this area and many friends I know know them. The whole family are pariahs. Stop bashing the church. Believe me when I say, those of us who are members of the LDS church have more disdain for the Daybells than you guys can ever imagine.
@@jeaniechampagne8831 it's not a Mormon school. It's a regular school. 🙄
Nate really has passion for this case as well as covering news! It's such a treat to watch him. I truly appreciate all of you! Including Erica and kiddos!
Yes, shout out to Nate! I'm watching from Switzerland and this channel provides the best coverage of the trial and everything around it. Thank you for your hard work!
Peggy’s commentary was insightful, interesting and full. Thank you Peggy. Really good commentary.
The so called "Coroner" ( I call the Guns for Hire) said it would take over 400 pounds of weight to asphixiate a healthy person by sitting on them. 2 POUNTS: 1) Asphyxiation could have been accomplished with a pillow, 2) Arent Pryor and his family claiming that Tammy wasnt health?? Therefore a lower threshhold would apply.
I would say Chud's weight plus Alex's weight would be over 400 lbs. Plus, they could have used a plastic bag as well.
Don't forget point #3; Chad + Alex equal nearly 450 lbs! Thereby proving Chad needed to help... if you follow the State's theory. Therefore: Chad is GUILTY!
I agree to both replies
I didn’t understand her at all. Like- JUST sitting on someone? Because who is going to try to k!LL someone by JUST sitting on their chest? Obviously they’re also gunna try to block their airways. So this was super weird to me. But I loved it cause she painted a picture of Alex and Chad sitting on Tammy 😂 thanks for helping the prosecution lady!
Lauren at Hidden true crime says the jury looked tired when they finished early because Prior’s witness wasn’t ready. This is dragging out, he has no case. He should rest . He witnesses either lie or have nothing not say. The defense has done nothing but attack Tammy and law inforcement.
For the Emma calls, I think they’re saving it for rebuttal and they might have to lay the foundation’s first
Nate, I understand why everyone has so much respect for you. You brake it down so even I can understand.
All I can say about Joseph is going to get a lot of tickets.
Hahaha. Hope so!
😂
😂
lol lol
Bet he's a sovereign citizen
$65 an hour! And these cases have cost us millions already.
Does anyone find it odd that Tammy posted about the gun to Facebook and didn’t call Emma first. They lived so close together and Emma knew everything about Tammy. Like what time she went to bed and what medication she takes. Seems like she would have told Emma right away.
All of Emma's testimony doesn't make sense, another fairytale from Chad, allegedly.
They are collusive and should be charged with perjury.
Emma and her husband are most infuriating - disrespectful AF to Tammy & those beautiful babies buried in their yard!Disgusting. 😤
They are all nuts
I agree. !!!!
And teachers! 😮😢 Can you imagine this is what is teaching your children in schools?
Chad is just sitting there, emotionless ! Knowing exactly what and how it happened. Knowing all of this is because his actions and ideas and words... Even that whole world hates his kids now, but he still dragged them into this and made them lie... No shame, no remorse. Nothing!
Exactly !!! Such a mess !!!
He’s enjoying the show it’s all about him.
Nate does deserve a shout out! What a tough job and he does it so seamlessly! We truly appreciate all your hard work and sacrifices you make for the job. And thank your wife! For the sacrifices she makes as well. ❤
When the trap is starting to slam shut Mr Murray has no clue. He walked right into it and made it worse!! 😮
From Phoenix AZ and have watched you since Dateline!! Thank you for continuing to cover this with journalistic integrity ❤
Please give Nate a👍🏽. Thank you Nate!
Nate, you are absolutely AWESOME! I have admired you since you confronted the pair in Hawaii. Wanted too drop a comment that you did such respectful listening during the interview. Too many hosts interrupt their guests and just try to over power them but you allowed your guest to speak and explain herself. You have so much integrity!! Thank you for all you do!
Thanks for your thorough, organized and professional reporting. It's so helpful to hear a summary of what happened.
I hope Deputy Cannon had a video recorder running in his vehicle. The gaul of him calling the deputy a liar. Disgusting.
Nate! You are so vibrant and charismatic. It’s incredible how you keep all the details and history organized, plus your insights into people. Thank you for keeping us updated and educating when we have questions. Your work ethic and passion are wonderful!
PS. Can’t hear the humming, go ahead and keep your room on icebox. :)
Hi from Minnesota! And hi to Erica!
Emma made a snarky comment when Chad was in the police car “I’m not Colby”. I find that very offensive. Emma and Joe live in Chad’s house, Chad gave Emma $9,000 in cash and $8000 in her bank account. Tylee gave Colby about $100 a month
Thought Emma didn't really know anything about Lori's children.
@@Mtrench101202Right?!!
Yeah but Tylee was a minor, giving allowance to a grown man. Slightly different.
@msenglish8382 tylees account sent the money but it was actually off his mum
@@msenglish8382 true
Thanks again, Nate!
I’m exhausted working the flight from WASHINGTON DC to AMMAN, JORDAN, but I’m catching up!
I can’t wait for this coverage❤
Why is it that chads family are not bothered that 2 dead children were found in their dads back yard ,i mean can you imagine that happening at your parents place ,id never be the same again ever and i wouldnt move in neither, the place sounds over flowing with dead animals as well creepy .
They are all creepy. The kids are brain washed via Chad.
A life time of brain washing by Slug!
that is my issue also how can they brush over the fact these innocent children were buried in their yard?
I noticed that Emma listed the raccoons, bunnies, and SKUNKS that Tammy supposedly buried in the pet cemetery. I don’t believe for one minute Tammy would bury a skunk.
I'm still trying to figure out why Emma was helping him get all the money distributed and never once asked, "Dad, WTH? There are *bodies* *buried* in the bleeping yard?"
Why didn’t they question Dr Raven about the pink foam?
I don't know why Pryor keeps focusing on whether or not Tammy was shot at with a paint ball gun or a real gun, why does that even matter, we all know it was Alex, so I think Pryor focusing on that is totally irrelevant, it doesn't change the fact that Chad had 2 dead kids in his backyard.
I’d also like to know if it was real or not. A real gun means attempted murder. Why hasn’t this been brought into evidence?Were there bullet holes in the truck or not?
@@Cookie-pl9bnit has been brought into evidence. LE testified about similarities between an AR-15 and a paintball gun, with a photo comparison.
The gun failed to go off, so no bullet holes. There was also testimony of finding an AR-15 in Alex’s condo, AND that specific gun had something wrong with it which could prevent it from going off. The witness said it would make a “whooshing” sound if this happened.
Pretty darn compelling evidence.
@@Cookie-pl9bngun jammed, no bullets were shot. But a week or so later there was a dead wife in that house.
If Chad was the true target why is he here and Tammy 6 feet under?
What I found was that people in the South, as far west as Texas and as far north as Pennsylvania and Nebraska, are much more likely to say “catty-corner,” whereas everyone else in the U.S. and Canada is more likely to say “kitty-corner.”
Interesting!
I remember when this case first began and I had to make my own chart to keep track of everyone involved. Poor jurors, good thing they have a pad and paper.
When I started following the case in Dec. 2019 there were many channels that I was following. One channel had a flowchart of all involved and how they are related. It’s a convoluted and confusing case with many twists.
🌹Tuning in again from Portland, Oregon🌦.
🐟 Almost every night, I spend the evening cleaning fish tanks while listening to Nate.
👍He's great company during a boring task!
It's so fun to meet and hear from more of the EIN Team! Thank you Peggy for keeping us all in line :)
We love Nate!!! I saw someone refer to Courtroom Insider as Nateline. 😂
At the beginning of Prior questioning Emma he said something like I told you not to watch this trial, didn't I? So Prior told the kids not to watch the trial so they didn't learn the truth.
That’s what I think too. If they watched the trial, they would see all the evidence against their dad.
I’m from St. Louis Missouri and we always called it catty corner. Now I live in Michigan and it’s kitty corner.
Looking forward to listening to recordings of Emma and her father’s phone calls in the state’s rebuttal case!
I noticed Lindsey Blake said the date that Emma spoke to her father and he instructed her what to say! I hope they use the recordings and show Chads true character!
I never thought the Daybell kids were complicit until they took the stand. They absolutely know way more than they’re saying. Does anyone in this family have any empathy for the victims? Absolutely appalling!