S Rachmaninov: Moment musicaux in E minor, Op. 16 no. 4 - Ivo Pogorelich (Dubrovnik, 2016)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 12 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 175

  • @TaniaCarolineChen
    @TaniaCarolineChen Год назад +58

    Rachmaninoff played his compositions as if he were improvising and composing them in performance, this is how his work should be played. Ivo is definitely performing in the true spirt of Rachmaninoff, that expressive fluidity and powerful intensity. No two performances should ever be the same.

    • @Doozy_Titter
      @Doozy_Titter Год назад +1

      Yes and in fact Rachmaninoff is Ivo's favourite pianist, as he said in an interview.

    • @angelobonacci461
      @angelobonacci461 19 дней назад

      X me nonostante sia bravissimo non ha lo spirito x fare benissimo rach, ricordiamoci che x fare benissimo rach occorre fare benissimo Chopin Ancor più di Liszt soprattutto x l'espressione 🎉🎉

  • @kpokpojiji
    @kpokpojiji Год назад +35

    Pogorelich. The ultimate risk taker, always reaching for more❤

  • @buckachiddy
    @buckachiddy Год назад +47

    Ivo has and will always be polarising, but I quite like this. There's hundreds of the same-old run of the mill interpretations out there, I've listened to them all and remember none of them (Lugansky excepted). He knows how to stand out.

    • @DianAmini
      @DianAmini Год назад +10

      Bro Lugansky is an actual god when it comes to Rachmaninov. Op. 33 no 4, op 39 no 5, and op 16 no 4 will always be known as luganksy’s pieces in my mind

    • @spicy7302
      @spicy7302 Год назад +5

      He knows how to stand out and make a fool of himself, I agree.

    • @CristianRodriguez-it7il
      @CristianRodriguez-it7il Год назад +9

      @@spicy7302 I got it dude, u don't like it.

    • @spicy7302
      @spicy7302 Год назад +2

      @@CristianRodriguez-it7il Wow, amazing. Good for you. Congratulations. Do you want a medal or something...?

    • @CristianRodriguez-it7il
      @CristianRodriguez-it7il Год назад +13

      @@spicy7302 cringe

  • @LinaNaM
    @LinaNaM Год назад +58

    Those hands ❤

    • @ciararespect4296
      @ciararespect4296 Год назад

      Yes but lugansky plays it far better imo

    • @MarcAmengual
      @MarcAmengual Год назад +9

      @@ciararespect4296 I prefer Lugansky too but I like Pogorelich's style. He is original, you can like it or not, but he delivers an original performance like an original artist should. At least thats my ho.

    • @yoyogie69
      @yoyogie69 Год назад +3

      Hmm.. You kinda liked his fingering technique

    • @herobrine1847
      @herobrine1847 Год назад +1

      I agree, who cares if his playing got worse as he aged… I need his hands…

    • @herobrine1847
      @herobrine1847 9 месяцев назад

      Hands

  • @pablos5463
    @pablos5463 7 месяцев назад +1

    Porgorelich tiene un aire y un fraseo muy distinto al resto de pianistas que toca Rachmaninoff. El sonido que logra, la sutileza con que toca en algunas notas y pasajes no las he escuchado en otras interpretacines, es simplemente fantástico!!

  • @micaelabonetti949
    @micaelabonetti949 Год назад +10

    Goosebumps ❤

  • @marinab5262
    @marinab5262 9 месяцев назад +2

    It is what is THE ART ABOUT , each his performance full of his own spirit and emotions, and excellence

  • @alegal752
    @alegal752 Год назад +5

    Grande Maestro il suo suono è sempre cosi avvolgente magico ed ipnotico . Meraviglioso .Grazie

  • @Chopin4321
    @Chopin4321 Год назад +5

    "Chopin´s playing evoked all the sweet and sorrowful voices of the past. Chopin sang the tears of music...in a whole gamut of different forms and voices, from that of the warrior to those of children and angels..."
    Bohdan Zaleski, polish poet, personal diary 2 feb 1844.
    "Under the fingers of Chopins´s hand the piano became the voice of an archangel, an orchestra, an army, a raging ocean, a creation of the universe, the end of the world."
    Solange Clesinger.
    Ivo is the archetype of the modern artist, the isolated and courageous master, who finds his own way to new heights of expression, no matter the prejudices or the barriers of misunderstanding raised against him. He stands alone at the beginning of a new epoch like a prophet, mapping the routes that art would take.
    Pogorelich´s cathartic and mystical sound, is concerned with the ultimate mysteries that transcend this world. His grandiose, colossal and majestic art, symbolizes the struggle of the human soul to find release from the bonds of its material body. His exquisite and overwhelming music continues to echo throughout the entire performance and beyond, so the action is at once momentary, eternal and complete.
    Pogorelich´s interpretations are indescribably beautiful and irresistible. His sound is pure poetry and extremely emotional, yet entirely unsentimental. We are hypnotized by his new and radical naturalness, by his nobility, dignity, severity and sobriety; transporting us to states of wonder, ecstasy, meditation, redemption, love and compassion.
    Sound and Silence, Life and Death, Time and Space; collapse into the Eternal moment of Infinity.
    - THE KING OF CHESS -
    You are the protégé of Death
    contemplating nailed in your Grave
    the game of Life.
    You're the one with the eyes
    on the nails of a Cross.
    Your hands caress tenderly
    the blind backs of your soldiers.
    Your armed and soulless guardians
    they ask you kneeling
    that you nail a cross to their chests
    because they are afraid of not being crucified
    at the desired time.
    Loyal painters advance drawing you
    the secret roads of Death.
    Your steel tears destroy when they fall
    the bare toes of your feet.
    Over the Earth keyboard
    the rain unearths
    the thousand hands of war.
    ! Oh King of Chess
    living pain of your childhood!
    ! You die for not winning
    and you also die to win!
    Alvaro Serralta
    - EL REY DEL AJEDREZ -
    Tu eres el protegido de la Muerte
    que contemplas clavado en tu Tumba
    el Juego de la Vida.
    Eres el que lleva los ojos
    en los clavos de una Cruz.
    Tus manos acarician con ternura
    las espaldas ciegas de tus soldados.
    Tus guardianes armados y desalmados
    te piden de rodillas
    que claves una cruz en sus pechos
    porque tienen miedo de no ser crucificados
    en el momento deseado.
    Leales pintores avanzan dibujándote
    los secretos caminos de la Muerte.
    Tus lágrimas de acero destrozan al caer
    los desnudos dedos de tus pies.
    Sobre el teclado de Tierra
    la lluvia desentierra
    las mil manos de la Guerra.
    ! Oh Rey del Ajedrez
    dolor vivo de tu niñez !
    ! Tu mueres por no Vencer
    y también mueres por Vencer !
    Alvaro Serralta

  • @PaulTame-iu2py
    @PaulTame-iu2py Год назад +9

    Wow, I love this performance!

  • @ranjanjoshi5027
    @ranjanjoshi5027 Год назад +20

    What a totally brilliant interpretation and performance.

    • @elegachi
      @elegachi Год назад +3

      It's weird for sure but I don't really think in an outstanding way. Hard to tell with this sound quality tbh

    • @Wuozlinga
      @Wuozlinga Год назад +2

      @@elegachi i wouldn’t call it brilliant, it’s kinda eh. Takes away a lot of the drama and terror this piece invokes when played by someone like Lugansky

  • @pghagen
    @pghagen Год назад +17

    Very impressive rendition! Don't think he played from the score. That's almost impossible. He just played it from memory. He just had the score in front of him to prevent a memory lap.

    • @joeyblogsy
      @joeyblogsy Год назад +2

      Sounds like and looked like he was indeed playing from the score. Interesting interpretation though.

    • @chester6343
      @chester6343 Год назад +3

      @@joeyblogsy doubt very much he didn't know this inside out

    • @erikfreitas7093
      @erikfreitas7093 8 месяцев назад

      *lapse

    • @at0mcollision
      @at0mcollision 3 дня назад

      He uses sheet music because of his severe arthritis - he simply cannot perform pieces with the fingerings he used to use so he has to adjust the fingerings in every single passage on the fly now…

  • @berlinzerberus
    @berlinzerberus 9 месяцев назад +2

    VERY GOOD indeed!

  • @birgirkarl
    @birgirkarl Год назад +6

    How can he not be playing this from muscle memory... a level of virtuosity where a score seems out-of-place. If he is reading it real-time, it is truly remarkable.

    • @DianAmini
      @DianAmini Год назад +6

      No chance

    • @kpokpojiji
      @kpokpojiji Год назад +3

      Do not forget the letter where Chopin describes, in total awe, Liszt sight reading Chopin's op 10 etudes from the manuscript, at tempo.

    • @i.ehrenfest349
      @i.ehrenfest349 11 месяцев назад +1

      Of course he’s not just sight reading it

    • @fortissimoX
      @fortissimoX 6 месяцев назад

      Of course he's not reading it.
      Each piece he's playing nowadays live, he's probably performed it at least tens of times if not hundred, not to mention how many times he read it and played in detail while practicing. As any concert pianist as a matter of fact.
      Sheet music is there just in case he needs a reminder.

  • @danielr.1205
    @danielr.1205 Год назад +1

    I'm speechless 😮

  • @dorfmanjones
    @dorfmanjones Год назад +4

    It's the kind of playing and acoustic that works ONLY if you already know the music. The sound levels between the hands are not regulated well. And it's obviously overpedaled. If you're a first time listener you won't hear the piece properly and probably won't get it. Lazar Berman sort of introduced this music in the late 1950's and his is still the standard as far as I can see.

    • @mustysheep3977
      @mustysheep3977 Год назад +1

      yeah, its way over pedaled. im shocked because one of my favorite parts of pogorelich is his dry and articulate sound, which this is the complete opposite spectrum of.

    • @amedeofabris1268
      @amedeofabris1268 3 месяца назад +1

      I think it's the hall that has a lot of reverb, hearing the piano I doubt it's the pedal

  • @damienmichelpianiste2693
    @damienmichelpianiste2693 Год назад +1

    i love that ❤

  • @brandonmacey964
    @brandonmacey964 8 месяцев назад

    Marvelous

  • @tongbunsing
    @tongbunsing Год назад +1

    I love Pogorelich

  • @kaleidoscopio5
    @kaleidoscopio5 Год назад +1

    Very personal interpretation. Interesting view of the piece, even if I disagree 🤔

  • @trevjr
    @trevjr Год назад +7

    Brilliant! I have always loved his playing especially Scriabin. I love that he is using music a la Richter. There is no need to memorize music, as Gould thought the piano recital was like a circus act, just waiting for the performer to slip off the high wire. With music we can hear more performances of great music. Why don't orchestras memorize their parts? Is it really distracting to see them turn pages? I can't figure what Ivo is doing here, there are no markings on the score so I would assume at some point he worked out all the fingerings and is just using a clean score to jog the memory once in a while. I see nothing wrong with this at all especially if we can see more of him without the added burden of memorization.

  • @paulvandenham6002
    @paulvandenham6002 7 месяцев назад

    Moment musical!!

  • @orsoncorwin7361
    @orsoncorwin7361 3 месяца назад

    The Hands of Dr.Orlac ? I think he has really gone over the edge this time. Frightful playing !

  • @creativecolours2022
    @creativecolours2022 Год назад +2

    Fantastic interpretation. Also I don't know if anyone else noticed how big his hands are. They are so big that he looks like he needs a somewhat larger keyboard. Rachmaninoff had such large hands and that is the reason why his works are very difficult to be played by those with smaller hands.

  • @joseluisrodriguezpitarch71
    @joseluisrodriguezpitarch71 6 месяцев назад

    This is like an Orkhestra❤

  • @tommasomarino1575
    @tommasomarino1575 Год назад +2

    (D)Ivo is always incredible!

  • @classicaloracle
    @classicaloracle Год назад +2

    For reference - especially those of you who may not have heard this piece elsewhere. ruclips.net/video/WhLDse5R8dQ/видео.html

    • @ciararespect4296
      @ciararespect4296 Год назад

      I've watched that a hundred times over the years

    • @exegetor
      @exegetor Год назад

      this one is my favorite: ruclips.net/video/kQD8IpWShKM/видео.html
      I'm particularly impressed with her crescendo on the descending chromatics and passionate delivery of the melody. Would love to hear your comments on this.

    • @ciararespect4296
      @ciararespect4296 Год назад

      @@exegetor absolutely excellent. If I were to nitpick I prefer Lugansky interpretation over it but they're virtually the same and different piano tone/action. Hall acoustics etc

    • @eytonshalomsandiego
      @eytonshalomsandiego 7 месяцев назад

      I just listened to both and though there's something very clean about the Lugansky I don't know doesn't feel like it's played by human being and he's not the only great pianist I feel that way about sometimes this one whether there's too much damper pedal or not it's so human I definitely prefer this one and I've never heard this piece before this is a first time listening and I'm not really particularly familiar I mean I know who ivo p is but I've not heard much of him

  • @witsukyai1685
    @witsukyai1685 Год назад +38

    I guess this is what you can do when you at “that level”; where people praise you for whatever you even though it’s not even that good. Sadly for most of us pianists, we may have even better ideas than but must conform to the “standard” way of playing because, let’s face it, playing like this will get you kicked out of the competition or the conservatory.

    • @spicy7302
      @spicy7302 Год назад +7

      Yeah, if people seriously think this interpretation is any good then they're either not pianists and have no clue about classical music or they're deaf.

    • @victorngrt8800
      @victorngrt8800 Год назад +27

      @@spicy7302 Don't be offensive like that.
      Ivo Pogorelich is a guy who decided to take risks by delivering highly atypical interpretations. So yes, it is polarizing and many do not like. But it's no reasons to insult him. We need people to take risks.

    • @spicy7302
      @spicy7302 Год назад +5

      @@victorngrt8800 We need people to take risks and deliver quality in those risks, what he does is nothing short of low quality. If you even tried to listen to this interpretation, you'd not only notice that you can barely hear the melody (he covers it up with the difficult part) but he also just straight up doesn't sound the notes leading into those thirds at the start. They are pretty much inexistent. Also, the thirds are very badly voiced. You can barely tell they are thirds. There are also parts where he introduces random accents for no reason and it makes no sense. If Rachmaninoff wanted the notes leading into the thirds to be barely hearable, he wouldn't note an ACCENT on both the note and the third. If he didn't want thirds, he wouldn't write thirds. If he wanted the accents he introduced, he'd write them. But he didn't. This isn't revolutionising, this is taking something and ruining it and having people applaud you.
      Another terrible mistake he does is that he messes with the tempo. Yes, tempo fluctuations are okay in Rachmaninoff, but he SLOWS down before most culminations. That makes absolutely no sense.

    • @ApostolosK06
      @ApostolosK06 Год назад +1

      @@spicy7302 I agree with most of your points but i think that the greatest performances stem from trying things out and seeing if they will work out. I think you will agree with me on that, although what we are both thinking is probably that those weird interpretations should be made when one is studying the piece and not when performing it, where the audience should hear a balanced and tasteful culmination of the ideas that came up in the process.

    • @spicy7302
      @spicy7302 Год назад +4

      @@ApostolosK06 Yes, I 100% agree. There is no other way to find out if an idea works. You just try it out, listen and then decide if you keep it or throw it. But you need to keep only the good ideas, not just mix in random thoughts into a piece and call it a day, which is what Pogorelich seems to be doing here sadly.

  • @M3taDarko
    @M3taDarko 10 месяцев назад

    buaaah, menudo coloso

  • @MadridistaDeCono
    @MadridistaDeCono Год назад

    why are some guys here cooking ivo for this performance brev this excellent 😭 guess they needed intense and violent playing every time

    • @null8295
      @null8295 9 месяцев назад +1

      they are just beginners

  • @giancarlomazzocchi4443
    @giancarlomazzocchi4443 Год назад

    Semplicemente geniale

  • @MarkFarago
    @MarkFarago Год назад

    I have never seen hands of that size...

  • @angelabagaeva2754
    @angelabagaeva2754 Год назад +7

    После такого прочтения этого "Момента"-другие интерпритации меркнут как-то.
    Такое исполнение -открытая боль...
    Оттого трудно слушать.
    Нужны силы сопереживать.

    • @music-man-hg1hk
      @music-man-hg1hk Год назад +1

      Много лишнего и надуманого. Слушайте Овчинникова!

    • @angelabagaeva2754
      @angelabagaeva2754 Год назад

      @@music-man-hg1hk почему не Березовского?

  • @marksmith3947
    @marksmith3947 Год назад

    There was a time when Pogorelich excelled in a limited repertoire. Now he plays everything with equal facility 😱

  • @ronl7131
    @ronl7131 9 месяцев назад

    Ivo Pogorelich

  • @marcobonacina7407
    @marcobonacina7407 Год назад

    ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

  • @andream.464
    @andream.464 Год назад +1

    His 2001 version is even better!

  • @ronnyvanderwee417
    @ronnyvanderwee417 Год назад +1

    Look at his hands

  • @espinosaherrerarodrigo6120
    @espinosaherrerarodrigo6120 9 месяцев назад

    He can play as well as Rach 'couse he literally has his hands...

  • @RoboticsBay
    @RoboticsBay Год назад +1

    A shadow of his former self - sadly.

  • @petersnell3128
    @petersnell3128 Год назад +1

    The damper pedal seems to be telling my ears it's out of control here.

  • @Sasty
    @Sasty Год назад +1

    Casually sight reading the piece

  • @Dertsm6795
    @Dertsm6795 Год назад +1

    Ноты выкидывает... Пропился видимо уже настолько

  • @nicholasroediger1045
    @nicholasroediger1045 Год назад

    Fire the sound engineer

  • @bigbong620
    @bigbong620 Год назад +1

    A shadow of his former self. Very sad.

  • @thomgeo8073
    @thomgeo8073 Год назад +1

    ?

  • @maximecloutier-gravel8908
    @maximecloutier-gravel8908 Год назад

    Not a fan of the accented notes and they're everywhere :/

  • @derththeope3286
    @derththeope3286 9 месяцев назад +1

    Is he sight reading or just looking at the dynamics?

  • @itseduardoorozco
    @itseduardoorozco Год назад +22

    What a horrible interpretation. The older he gets, the less he respects the composer

    • @savakiri5870
      @savakiri5870 Год назад +7

      opinions can differ

    • @itseduardoorozco
      @itseduardoorozco Год назад +5

      @@savakiri5870 can and do

    • @spicy7302
      @spicy7302 Год назад +12

      ​@@savakiri5870 Opinions differ but I don't think any professional pianist would consider this interpretation as any good.

    • @marksmith3947
      @marksmith3947 Год назад

      I think his mental deterioration is the issue. I suspect he's actually crazy as a loon now

    • @Paroles_et_Musique
      @Paroles_et_Musique Год назад +3

      @@spicy7302 He was one of the greatest when young so he kept many things from, there is a lot of dramatic power then sudden accelerations, the sound is powerful, technically not that bad. Is he near any of his peers at same age? No. Usually great pianists get better with age, he only gets worse, similar to Gavrilov. Interesting fact, both quit public performances for many years, before coming back. Burnt too fast.

  • @OuaghlaniAlaa
    @OuaghlaniAlaa 7 месяцев назад +1

    Too much accents. Too much unnecessary movements. Too much wrong dynamics.

  • @alessandropelizzoli6613
    @alessandropelizzoli6613 Год назад

    Eh si, geniale perché è Pogorelich....se foste dei pianisti o meglio ancora dei validi insegnanti di pianoforte e aveste un allievo che suona così, e per quarant' anni si ostinasse a suonare in modo tutto scombiccherato, vedreste cosa gli direste...
    ( Attacchi indecisi e sporchi della melodia declamata, articolazione confusa e armonie distrutte dall'uso del pedale indiscriminato, andamento da ubriachi circa il tactus, etc.etc....)
    Il popolo dei Divi, come Pogorelich, quelli che si pavoneggiavano perché avevano un bel visino, con i guanti bianchi a suonare con Karajan giovanissimo, adesso assomigliante fisicamente a Putin, invece, capaci persino di dire cose poco gentili a chi ha creato loro una carriera con le polemiche, ringrazia il popolo degli ascoltatori, che quando ascoltano hanno le orecchie al vento...

  • @mikern2001
    @mikern2001 Год назад

    Demonic and driving.

    • @mikern2001
      @mikern2001 Год назад

      Even if sloppy. His hands look like he has severe arthritis. Too loud. But he certainly has the emotion.

  • @쏭이는사춘기
    @쏭이는사춘기 8 месяцев назад

    Recording quality sucks

  • @eberhardj4128
    @eberhardj4128 Год назад +1

    Das kann ein begabter Hochschulabsolvent besser, vor allem treffsicherer.

  • @stefanbernhard2710
    @stefanbernhard2710 Год назад +1

    Wow. This was actually quite good technically. I wish he'd stop with the sheet music though. Really detracts from the audience's experience imho

    • @glenngouldification
      @glenngouldification Год назад +14

      Music is the art of sound. No idea how having the score present distracts from the audiences experience. It gives the performer some security and guards against the dreaded memory lapse. If sheet music helps you need to think of the performer not the audience !

    • @marksmith3947
      @marksmith3947 Год назад +1

      He may have memory problems due to psychiatric drugs

    • @victorngrt8800
      @victorngrt8800 Год назад +4

      @@marksmith3947 What do you mean ?
      Sources ?
      Also I don't get the problem with sheet music. Music is about music. People listen to the produced music. Nobody care if there is a sheet, or idk what on the stage

    • @spicy7302
      @spicy7302 Год назад +2

      This was actually quite terrible unfortunately. This interpretation is absolutely illogical. Pogorelich could've done far better.

    • @eytonshalomsandiego
      @eytonshalomsandiego 7 месяцев назад

      Are you joking about the sheet music I could care less I mean I listen with my ears not my eyes I wouldn't even notice at a concert if he had sheet music I mean I'd notice but it wouldn't affect me

  • @ericjohn5484
    @ericjohn5484 Год назад

    too harsh...little subtlety Howowitz and Yuja put old Ivo to shame

    • @MarcAmengual
      @MarcAmengual Год назад +2

      Horowitz puts pretty everybody else except Rubinstein, Argerich and one or two more in shame. Yuja does not, just female Lang Lang.

    • @ericjohn5484
      @ericjohn5484 Год назад

      @@MarcAmengual Your comments are thoughtless, dismissive, bigoted and just plain fked up.