TBH I feel like if she ever streams again it would be a history breaking event, next to the other hiatus members. It reminds me when Mayu or Meiji showed up in a 3D event after their grad and everyone went wild. I have noticed though like, whenever people say "sorry for not streaming too much"(which tbh is a handful of KR and ID I guess) I sometimes see people say like "Oh don't worry at least you dont leave for a year or 3" lol.
Rare nijilivers to be seen are gilzaren, tsumugu and amemori... If you are a long time fan of niji and you didn't know these 3 I'll be very disappointed on you. 😅
Actually i feel bad for amemori because her 3d got cancel, if i am not worng she have tweet the cancel because family problem I hope she will stream again
Okay, so what I got from this is: 1. She is at least alive, because she responds to her genmates's messages and she even watched their streams. Even if that happens once in a blue moon. 2. That random tweet of hers was just her being random, no secondary message. 3. She immediatly freezes up upon the mentions of either appearing on stream or even doing some kind of collabs. 4. She didn't necessarily stop streaming like it was her plan all along. _Something_ happened either inside the company or privately. And this is the main missing part of the puzzle - what happened?
coming from the future, after selen fiasco. it was shown that management in niji are allowed to skinwalk talents acc pretending as the liver without telling fans its management speaking
I feel like it's possible she was being terminated or quit the company because of internal problem and the company basically thought it was too late anyway for official announcement since she just debuted that time, I can't see other way considering how long has it been.. Although there is still possibility to comeback I guess, considering Yuzuki Roa has updated her status a week ago after 4 years of hiatus..
this is such a cool idea!!!! i really love that it's a nijihistory type of thing that doesn't revolve around drama and mostly relies on clips from the livers themselves!!!
The legendary liver, for she ghosts us for years. However, I wish I could have catch her live before, that would be a "I was here" moment. All the best for Kataribe!
Setomiya's laugh and Haruka being painfully cute was a treat. I really love the way that the Livers and the community handle her bizarre non-existance. This here clip for Kataribe was pretty great. Considering that I also want her to come back. One day....
The way her genmates speak of/to her is so sweet! There'll always be a seat for you here aw Shout out to the livers who talk about members who are on hiatus or graduated :') Your video format is really incredible!
might be a bit too far but there's also a possibility that she, her VA, had actually passed away and since her vtuber identity is already a ghost the company thinks its awkward to make a public announcement of it who knows lol
Oh another topic that came to mind was the "Revival of Sasaki". Although I heard she herself doesn't like to think about it too much since its rather awkward to be in a unique situation and existence in the company.
Oh wow. You covered one of the biggest cases I've always wanted to see. I often check her comments as each year people wish her happy birthday in her vids. I would also like to know, would you cover some of the other topics like what happened with ROA and Meiro? I know said topic is heavily controversial for its time , but I only ask as the entire thing is perplexing but not a lot of English info exists and the event seems like a buried topic. I mean I totally understand if that's a No Go though. I am excited to see more of these as Nijisanji has a rich history of people with unique lives, some forgotten, and some looked back fondly on. Your work is truly god tier in a void of its kind and fills in a niche I love.
1. she become fulltime staff in nijisanji, so she has to forfeit become talent for some reasons 2. she got fired for a reason wont be disclosed to avoid drama. so she stays MIA 3. she really gone in real life (family objected her job as vtuber, she got a better job than being vtuber, death) leaving nijisanji to figure out how to say this to fans, but because she is just starting, might as well dont say anything
It's more likely she's on some kind of sick/disability leave from something serious. That's basically the only reason you could leave your job for 5 years and not be fired. Or she passively makes enough money to justify keeping active but the former sounds the most accurate.
Oh another big mystery I myself am trying to research in my spare time, is, what specifically happened to Nijisanji Shanghai and Taipei? How did they lose the license? Of course that's still a lot of reading of old tweets and weibo posts but its pretty enthralling. I would assume you would need to know chinese to get a good idea of the content though. Oh another thing maybe you might like, you know Niji Network right? Thats a cool slice of Nijisanji history I also was looking at. I do like that Tenkai still hangs out with Kana alot though. Also Voiz was something I was looking at but didn't find too much info. There's alot of old branch history but I assume that's much too large for one video. Anyway hope you do more, these are superb! I love learning more or honestly I love that you are promoting and highlighting forgotten history and putting it in a easy to read place. I think its the best thing one can do is to keep these memories and ideas still alive.
While they're not as heavy as your other suggestion, these are way too serious of a topic, I might do it one day but no promises. A story for Tenkai might be intreresting though
i just found this video, love it. Can you do noraneko someday ? i'd really like to know why does she stream at 360p and why theres so many russians in the comment section. Thanks for your hardwork on this type of content
I might but no promises, her streams and behavior are just too bizarre to the point that researching about her will just raise more question rather than answer
By the way, if you're still wondering why she got so many russian comments, it's because a russian vtuber 'clipper' (his videos are too good to be called clips imo) by the name cyborg crab made a video about her and it got popular, thus the russian comments on her streams and videos
@@corvusinterpreter yes yes yes, i do some research after seeing your videos, and it lead to cyborg crab's vid about her, and the reason why shes streaming with 360p is to celebrate until 360k subs... dude, shes so bizzare yet so intresting, bgm, thumbnail, her way of speak.. alright, i'll enjoy your content whom ever the liver is
Is it Nara Haramaung? I'm sorry I don't think I can, aside from Nari and Ray, I don't really follow non-JP livers and not to mention she's already graduated too so finding concrete information regarding the topic would be very hard
Judging by all the info in this video - not quite. It probably wasn't on purpose initially, although now it kinda is. And we're missing crucial information about it, which can only be obtained via a first-party source: either Kataribe herself or direct Niji management of that time. Only time will tell if the mystery will be solved.
@@Arashi257 as much as now people forget the rule that taboo in vtuber world (the not talking about past live publicly), I think people just like "gundou mirei" not the other one, people like Lulu not the other one or people like gibara not the other one. Their ccv show it all
@@Arashi257 all of them still streaming. their CCV dropped down by massive numbers, especially mirei and gibara (their CCV dropped to around 200 from thousands). lulu dropped but still better around 1,5k-2k and she's hybrid and often stream with her irl face (she's pretty if you wondering lmao), she's using the same artist for her model as "lulu". they're all indie. gibara personality now toned down a lot and not like gibara you used to know. also if you wondering too, chitose now is famous singer in a electronic jpop group. "nun bora" went to other agency and she's doing well. "noor" became nijiEN staff iirc (idk if she still there or not). a lot of niji exID went indie, some quit streaming, some became less known streamers. former niji exID staffs work under local agency (don't know if they're the founder or not) this is why when people say "i hope she/graduate from XXX agency" kinda upset me because not every vtuber has equal opportunity, many of them dropped down into abyss after graduated and only few of them still intact with the community. it just sad, people love the character, so when they changed people just simply leave and people who asked them to graduate won't bother to watch them
![[NijiCase] Vampire Sanya [Nijisanji Eng Sub]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/lrUSpA8OftA/mqdefault.jpg)
![[NijiCase] Vampire Sanya [Nijisanji Eng Sub]](/img/tr.png)
![The End(?) of Furen and Hoshikawa's Saga [Nijisanji Eng Sub]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/mbILMyQxqZQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![Livers you don't want as a boyfriend ranking[nijisanji eng sub]](/img/1.gif)
Never in my life did I think I’d see a English clip for her. Thank you
She's a legend, streamed for 2 weeks, refuse to elaborate, and just left xD
Imagine she got 100k subs, and the first stream she do after so many years is just straight up 3D. LMAO
In Debidebi Debiru‘s wedding stream, you can see a funeral photo of Kataribe in the background.
could also be a joke about her being a spirit, works both ways
TBH I feel like if she ever streams again it would be a history breaking event, next to the other hiatus members. It reminds me when Mayu or Meiji showed up in a 3D event after their grad and everyone went wild. I have noticed though like, whenever people say "sorry for not streaming too much"(which tbh is a handful of KR and ID I guess) I sometimes see people say like "Oh don't worry at least you dont leave for a year or 3" lol.
I didnt know mayu and meiji showed up on an event after their graduation, which event was that?
@@Zantya Meiji was a Rain Drops stream iirc, don't recall which off the top of my head. Mayu I don't remember.
@@Zantya Meji showed up in Masarus 3D live... i forgot which one though? But raindrops performed on water with a piano
Rare nijilivers to be seen are gilzaren, tsumugu and amemori... If you are a long time fan of niji and you didn't know these 3 I'll be very disappointed on you. 😅
At least gilzaren still showing in other people's channel, sayo disclosed her reason for hiatus (school) but kataribe just mystery
Actually i feel bad for amemori because her 3d got cancel, if i am not worng she have tweet the cancel because family problem
I hope she will stream again
Okay, so what I got from this is:
1. She is at least alive, because she responds to her genmates's messages and she even watched their streams. Even if that happens once in a blue moon.
2. That random tweet of hers was just her being random, no secondary message.
3. She immediatly freezes up upon the mentions of either appearing on stream or even doing some kind of collabs.
4. She didn't necessarily stop streaming like it was her plan all along. _Something_ happened either inside the company or privately. And this is the main missing part of the puzzle - what happened?
coming from the future, after selen fiasco. it was shown that management in niji are allowed to skinwalk talents acc pretending as the liver without telling fans its management speaking
@lqfr8813 , yeah, I know.
For now, though, it adds no clearance to Kataribe's mystery.
I feel like it's possible she was being terminated or quit the company because of internal problem and the company basically thought it was too late anyway for official announcement since she just debuted that time, I can't see other way considering how long has it been..
Although there is still possibility to comeback I guess, considering Yuzuki Roa has updated her status a week ago after 4 years of hiatus..
@@irvancrocs1753 this is very possible too. they wont bother saying they terminate her because internal problem
02:55 someone threw salt at her. Case closed.
this is such a cool idea!!!! i really love that it's a nijihistory type of thing that doesn't revolve around drama and mostly relies on clips from the livers themselves!!!
The legendary liver, for she ghosts us for years.
However, I wish I could have catch her live before, that would be a "I was here" moment. All the best for Kataribe!
Setomiya's laugh and Haruka being painfully cute was a treat. I really love the way that the Livers and the community handle her bizarre non-existance.
This here clip for Kataribe was pretty great. Considering that I also want her to come back. One day....
The way her genmates speak of/to her is so sweet! There'll always be a seat for you here aw
Shout out to the livers who talk about members who are on hiatus or graduated :')
Your video format is really incredible!
Still waiting for her to stream again and the eventual Sayo 3D
Sayo 3d announced from 2 years ago yet we still dont have any news since then
might be a bit too far but there's also a possibility that she, her VA, had actually passed away and since her vtuber identity is already a ghost the company thinks its awkward to make a public announcement of it
who knows lol
Nice work, Corvus. You did a splendid job doing these stuff, it really is feels like im watching a real detective to do some real cases!!!!
Oh another topic that came to mind was the "Revival of Sasaki". Although I heard she herself doesn't like to think about it too much since its rather awkward to be in a unique situation and existence in the company.
How the hell did i not realize that Miyako and Haruka were gen mates after all thia time...
Yet i knew Miyako and Kataribe were ...
Kinda scary if really something bad happen in reality even company didn't know 😢
Oh wow. You covered one of the biggest cases I've always wanted to see. I often check her comments as each year people wish her happy birthday in her vids.
I would also like to know, would you cover some of the other topics like what happened with ROA and Meiro? I know said topic is heavily controversial for its time , but I only ask as the entire thing is perplexing but not a lot of English info exists and the event seems like a buried topic. I mean I totally understand if that's a No Go though.
I am excited to see more of these as Nijisanji has a rich history of people with unique lives, some forgotten, and some looked back fondly on.
Your work is truly god tier in a void of its kind and fills in a niche I love.
Sorry but I dont think I will, the topic is too heavy for me
@@corvusinterpreter 100% fair.
Really wish roa come back soon and all her legal battle cleared
Kataribe Tsumugu... What a legend. I hope she just does a stream randomly one day.
Is her channel still around?
@@ClericV yep
a lot of people frequents her dissapearance stream, some even make bets on wether her or hunter x hunter manga comes back first.
@@aratabhist thanks. Good to know
ive been wanting to see a video on her for so long
thanks for the clip!!
1. she become fulltime staff in nijisanji, so she has to forfeit become talent for some reasons
2. she got fired for a reason wont be disclosed to avoid drama. so she stays MIA
3. she really gone in real life (family objected her job as vtuber, she got a better job than being vtuber, death) leaving nijisanji to figure out how to say this to fans, but because she is just starting, might as well dont say anything
It's more likely she's on some kind of sick/disability leave from something serious. That's basically the only reason you could leave your job for 5 years and not be fired.
Or she passively makes enough money to justify keeping active but the former sounds the most accurate.
Bro dug really deep for this one... Thank you
Oh another big mystery I myself am trying to research in my spare time, is, what specifically happened to Nijisanji Shanghai and Taipei? How did they lose the license? Of course that's still a lot of reading of old tweets and weibo posts but its pretty enthralling. I would assume you would need to know chinese to get a good idea of the content though.
Oh another thing maybe you might like, you know Niji Network right? Thats a cool slice of Nijisanji history I also was looking at. I do like that Tenkai still hangs out with Kana alot though.
Also Voiz was something I was looking at but didn't find too much info. There's alot of old branch history but I assume that's much too large for one video. Anyway hope you do more, these are superb! I love learning more or honestly I love that you are promoting and highlighting forgotten history and putting it in a easy to read place. I think its the best thing one can do is to keep these memories and ideas still alive.
While they're not as heavy as your other suggestion, these are way too serious of a topic, I might do it one day but no promises. A story for Tenkai might be intreresting though
@@corvusinterpreter Of course yeah, passion is best when working on long projects so pick the things you love after all!
Thank you for this format and video.
Holy shit a ktrb clip... thank you so much!!
Thanks you for the clip
amazing video! really enjoyed it and I never heard about this liver before. 87k subs now maybe something happens at 100k after all
Are you gonna do one for Sayo? Thanks for the clip!!!
Maybe, but no promises
Last update on Sayo was they’re busy with school
the nijisanji iceberg is kinda like:
gwelu
gilzaren/sayo
kataribe
and then eudrick
And then
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Wolfgang
語部が現在も許されてて郡道先生が許されないことの累積で消えたのが「にじさんじ」らしさだよね
i just found this video, love it. Can you do noraneko someday ? i'd really like to know why does she stream at 360p and why theres so many russians in the comment section. Thanks for your hardwork on this type of content
I might but no promises, her streams and behavior are just too bizarre to the point that researching about her will just raise more question rather than answer
By the way, if you're still wondering why she got so many russian comments, it's because a russian vtuber 'clipper' (his videos are too good to be called clips imo) by the name cyborg crab made a video about her and it got popular, thus the russian comments on her streams and videos
@@corvusinterpreter yes yes yes, i do some research after seeing your videos, and it lead to cyborg crab's vid about her, and the reason why shes streaming with 360p is to celebrate until 360k subs... dude, shes so bizzare yet so intresting, bgm, thumbnail, her way of speak.. alright, i'll enjoy your content whom ever the liver is
Will you do story of Eudrick? 😂
I might, but it's gonna be a pretty short story though
Thank you.
damnnn
hahah. look at this ghost so cute
Do Gilzaren III next!
Can you do one for Nara? She supposed to debute along with 1st wave of niji id, but instead she got debuted later on with LAN_nee3s
Is it Nara Haramaung? I'm sorry I don't think I can, aside from Nari and Ray, I don't really follow non-JP livers and not to mention she's already graduated too so finding concrete information regarding the topic would be very hard
Maybe she's see Niji management and then just "I'm already dead, I don't want to deal with this shit" and ascend to afterlife 😂😂
I can't tell but the main branch seems fine so far?
@@HorseWithNoBane with their own drama like Roa and the others? Yeah, maybe
10:54 wait did she make this form and send it in or did they make all the forms?
I'm not too sure, but shes definitely the one who filled it, if you check the real VOD, there are other forms for other livers too
Did she really did this on purpose?? To not stream over years??
Yes, but nobody really knows why
Judging by all the info in this video - not quite. It probably wasn't on purpose initially, although now it kinda is.
And we're missing crucial information about it, which can only be obtained via a first-party source: either Kataribe herself or direct Niji management of that time.
Only time will tell if the mystery will be solved.
oof, hearing Gundo sensei hurt by a lot
Well, she's technically still around, still a teacher, and I think way more "you know what", since she's indie now.
@@Arashi257 as much as now people forget the rule that taboo in vtuber world (the not talking about past live publicly), I think people just like "gundou mirei" not the other one, people like Lulu not the other one or people like gibara not the other one. Their ccv show it all
@@prohanta9360Are the latter two still streaming?
I never actually bothered to look up if they went to another agency or went indie.
@@Arashi257 all of them still streaming. their CCV dropped down by massive numbers, especially mirei and gibara (their CCV dropped to around 200 from thousands). lulu dropped but still better around 1,5k-2k and she's hybrid and often stream with her irl face (she's pretty if you wondering lmao), she's using the same artist for her model as "lulu". they're all indie. gibara personality now toned down a lot and not like gibara you used to know. also if you wondering too, chitose now is famous singer in a electronic jpop group. "nun bora" went to other agency and she's doing well. "noor" became nijiEN staff iirc (idk if she still there or not). a lot of niji exID went indie, some quit streaming, some became less known streamers. former niji exID staffs work under local agency (don't know if they're the founder or not)
this is why when people say "i hope she/graduate from XXX agency" kinda upset me because not every vtuber has equal opportunity, many of them dropped down into abyss after graduated and only few of them still intact with the community. it just sad, people love the character, so when they changed people just simply leave and people who asked them to graduate won't bother to watch them
@@Arashi257yes, dunno about streaming but they are still in entertainment media
damn ive never heard of her till now, and I always thought Sayo's existence was crazy