CREDIT INCOMING!!! Had no idea that was from you, searched “liminal indoor grass” and the first pic that came up was yours. I’ll link your channel and video on that video :) Apologies for the confusion bro
Yes, but now Broogli has responded to this video and claimed that he had no idea that this RUclips channel generated those images and now he's going to give him credit (which is great, plus subscriptions to Liminal Spaces A.I.). By the way, a curiosity: I DIDN'T KNOW NEITHER BROOGLI OR THIS CHANNEL BEFORE, NOW I KNOW BOTH BUT I ONLY LIKE THIS ONE AND I KNEW BROOGLI ONLY THROUGH THIS VIDEO. XD
I don't know why, but this really gives me strange vibes, of like watching an old TV broadcast at 1 AM or something like it, it's off in a strangely pleasing way, the voice, the music, the images, I watch these to chill and relax
You've got the right attitude towards this. It would be pretty stupid to demand credit for an AI-generated image; though, as you said, crediting the person who generated the image is still certainly a nice thing to do. You've cemented yourself in my mind as one of RUclips's better AI content creators.
Daaang, Broogli did a dirty? He's generally got good content which is unfortunate as heck. I hope it gets worked out. Here's a suggestion: minigolf themed liminal spaces!
It’s all good I aint too mad. Would be cool if he gave me credit though! After all he did use like 10-20 of my pics. If someone uses like 1-2 of my pics, i wouldn’t have said anything.
Wooo! finally one of my suggestions in a vid! thanks a bunch. Not quite as deep fried as I was thinking, but still. Gonna come right up with another, try (in stable diffusion with the webUI) using negative numbers. For example, "(people):-10" In my experience, it can go crazy with some simple concepts.
1:55 this actually makes it better imo, it's just the right balance between following the script perfectly and complete jibberish mish-mash. It's combining the 2 environments in unexpected, unique ways, that gives off a feeling of strangeness, kind of like the uncanny valley of spaces, where it might actually strengthen the *L I M I N A L F E E L S.*
Love your channel and how it grows from a few views to thousands, I was there from the beginning. Would be nice to try some liminal anime places with real liminal places and see what happens
Been subbed for about a month now and oh my goodness I can't BELIEVE I found this channel. Your videos are awesome! I binge watched so many vids and I looks forward to your new ones. I've even lurked in some livestreams and love them. I've always been so fascinated by liminal spaces so you doing this is sooooo cool
Could we get some 90s and early 2000s style liminal spaces? Huge fan of further aero and the Y2K aesthetic. I feel like they would fit in with the grass rooms and poolrooms.
It's kinda sad that such a huge youtuber had to get images from you, although i know the credit is actually to the AI, you are the one who controls the AI and gives prompts, and especially shows these to youtube, so you deserve credit too, btw i loved how my suggestion turned out at 1:08 =D, also i have a suggestion: I wonder what the level "the end" would look like merged with level 3999, and level 21. Keep up the great work!!
Yeah credit to me for prompting the exact description of my grassrooms concept, then credit to the AI, then credit to the coders who made the AI, then credit to the artists and photographers it was trained on, then credit to the people who invented the art supplies and the people who inspired the artists in the first place, then credit to the people who taught those people basic education and art so that they’d be able to invent something or make their own art. The list goes on forever. I don’t actually care if I get credit and I have nothing against broogli, just thought it would make for a nice thumbnail🤣
@@liminalai Yea i know i kinda exagerated it, tho I really appreciate how you forgive him instead of creating useless controversies like most creators do, as another comment stated, he could've thought that since the images are made by AI, u don't require the credit.
Very possible! But the grassrooms that he specifically used is something i thought of, no other grassrooms images look similar to it. So even though I used AI to make them, those were from my brain and exactly how I imagined them😁
Amazing video, sorry to hear you didn't receive credit from Broogli. Here's my suggestion: The 'Outrun' style mixed with a space of your choosing. I believe natural spaces would make a weird mixture.
I have a suggestion :D Combining liminal spaces with beautiful sceneries in anime. You could take them straight out of any *actual* anime by screenshotting if you want. (I'd say mushoku tensei is amazing for this purpose as its filled to the brim with beautifully drawn sceneries.) Or you can just use anime-style paintings/drawings. I promise I'm no weeb xD
there should be a museum or something where its a bunch of backrooms recreated in real life and you can just walk around in it, I feel like there's a good chance that could be successful
probably just get the largest empty office building one could find, replace all the windows with walls, replace the lights with warmer ones, and then make the interior really confusing to navigate. essentially just a modern day winchester mystery house.
@@ArturoRuizAnalogHorror yeah but i want something that has ALL the different types of liminal spaces, not just the backrooms, maybe there's a pool room section, maybe there's a part with a fake sky, y'know all that. and it connects together like that one big ol' liminal gmod map
The cargo ship spaces were very nice, that was a great idea, I especially liked the beach one. I'd love to see what you could do with some art by Zdzisław Beksiński
Thanks for using my idea but any way since the gorilla tag suggestion was so good this is day 1 of asking him to get the city map in the game gorilla tag and make into a liminal space.
What if you combined level 370 "The pool rooms" with some photos of the (acutal) poolrooms? Also that video was super cool to watch, I watched through all of it :D
Combine any nostalgic liminal space and mix it with a cyberpunk aesthetic, I'd like to see chucky cheese with that aesthetic. Can you please make a cozy liminal cabin through the seasons
1:40, well theres a liminal pool room in amsterdam, a house in portugal, and some museum installation that isnt actually a pool. anyways, have you ever used raw images in your videos? like midjourney images made only with text prompting. (also i find it funny how you joked about burning the grassrooms to prevent further stealing, but literally the first image shown simply gets a light "char")
The stealing part was dumb. It's bad he didn't give credit. Anyways I have a suggestion, I think you should do a fusion with backrooms level 0, backrooms level 94 and poolrooms.
Combine liminal spaces with images from the game mirrors edge. I always thought that game had a very clean liminal vibe. Even if i didn't know the word liminal yet. Don't use mirrors edge catalyst.
suggestions:blend the destroyed grassrooms and the destroyed liminal hotel from ruclips.net/video/dqY-Ki7Ny4s/видео.html blend a room from five nights at freddy's 1 and popular liminal spaces (for fnaf's 9 year anniversary)
i know that AI can't handle cartoon very well but i have a suggestion. can you get the UA high school building from My Hero Academia and combine it with multiple liminal spaces?
I mean no hate in this question, but is that your actual voice, or do you use some sort of fine tuned text to speech? Just curious, either way, the voice you use is perfect for these videos.
@@liminalai Maybe you could just look up pictures that don't specifically depict the library of Babel, but just infinite libraries and combine that with liminal spaces? Or maybe just show the images the AI struggled with anyway, just to see how it copes.
broogli is kind of annoying imo, I don’t think the backrooms should have generic creepy/survival horror aspects like super mega ultra almond water and poorly written SCARY!!!!!!!!! entities
The fact that I used to watch his videos makes me feel wierd after this. I’m glad I was able to point this out to you. Idk if he did it on purpose or not but if he did I’m not sure how I would feel about it Edit: the text above was edited due to my strong wording of it. I said I felt disgusted but in reality the heat of the moment had me fuming. I overreacted and said what I didn’t want to. I’m sorry if I got off on the wrong foot with you Broogli
Honestly bro I’m sure he didn’t do it on purpose. I don’t think he’s a bad guy at all. Who knows, maybe he will see it and get a laugh. If you like his videos keep watching him!
hi! asking for rainy poolrooms again,,,,,,,,, i saw that you hearted my last comment so i hope you put the whole discord server thing in consideration (so sorry if i sound annoying or anything i really just want to help)
CREDIT INCOMING!!! Had no idea that was from you, searched “liminal indoor grass” and the first pic that came up was yours. I’ll link your channel and video on that video :)
Apologies for the confusion bro
Pinned. I knew you were a cool guy, just thought it would make funny video topic😂
Thanks for commenting bro.
👁
His credit came, rightfully deserved
Whoa it’s it really you! Broogli!
Let's go Broogli! Nice that you showed up and are now giving credit.
The best way to destroy a liminal space is to add people into it.
Try To Mix Frutiger Aero With Disney World Or Disney Park Or Hyperpop Genre
I Would Want This Request In The Next Video
The audacity. This is the perfect way to get back at him lol
All in good fun!
Yes Ik, he’s a good person
Yes, but now Broogli has responded to this video and claimed that he had no idea that this RUclips channel generated those images and now he's going to give him credit (which is great, plus subscriptions to Liminal Spaces A.I.). By the way, a curiosity: I DIDN'T KNOW NEITHER BROOGLI OR THIS CHANNEL BEFORE, NOW I KNOW BOTH BUT I ONLY LIKE THIS ONE AND I KNEW BROOGLI ONLY THROUGH THIS VIDEO. XD
You have to make liminal spaces of cursed images!
Suggestion from a german viewer: a late 80s big carpet shop mixed with a furniture store
Donkey Kong Country for SNES I noticed has lots of Liminal Spaces. Can you combine your favorite Liminal Space with Donkey Kong Country levels?
I hope mailbox gets it together soon he seems moody lately
"If I don't get a hold of the grassrooms... No one will!"
Well played😎
Broogli?. Aw man, i liked his content a lot. That’s sad. But at least you know he watches ur vids
I don't know why, but this really gives me strange vibes, of like watching an old TV broadcast at 1 AM or something like it, it's off in a strangely pleasing way, the voice, the music, the images, I watch these to chill and relax
You've got the right attitude towards this. It would be pretty stupid to demand credit for an AI-generated image; though, as you said, crediting the person who generated the image is still certainly a nice thing to do. You've cemented yourself in my mind as one of RUclips's better AI content creators.
Thanks!
Level 13 plus Level 0
Cud have a seriously scary design
Daaang, Broogli did a dirty? He's generally got good content which is unfortunate as heck. I hope it gets worked out.
Here's a suggestion: minigolf themed liminal spaces!
It’s all good I aint too mad. Would be cool if he gave me credit though! After all he did use like 10-20 of my pics. If someone uses like 1-2 of my pics, i wouldn’t have said anything.
@@liminalaiare you sure ur images are not on google or posted anywhere else
he might’ve just searched up grassroom pics and stumbled upon yours on any platform or something
I’m 100% sure because he used like 10-20 of my images all from one video.
m.ruclips.net/video/KVbHRDcwouA/видео.html this is the video he took most of the images from
The mailbox abouta start another arg 😂
Excellent video. And also a suggestion: Combine images of destroyed and rundown places with liminal spaces.
Happy 4k subs!
Thanks!
Grassrooms are definitely my favorite type of liminal space. Reminds me of the Windows XP homescreen “Bliss”.
Wooo! finally one of my suggestions in a vid! thanks a bunch. Not quite as deep fried as I was thinking, but still.
Gonna come right up with another, try (in stable diffusion with the webUI) using negative numbers. For example, "(people):-10"
In my experience, it can go crazy with some simple concepts.
1:55 this actually makes it better imo, it's just the right balance between following the script perfectly and complete jibberish mish-mash. It's combining the 2 environments in unexpected, unique ways, that gives off a feeling of strangeness, kind of like the uncanny valley of spaces, where it might actually strengthen the *L I M I N A L F E E L S.*
Small or not this is one of my favorite channels
🙏🏼
Love your channel and how it grows from a few views to thousands, I was there from the beginning. Would be nice to try some liminal anime places with real liminal places and see what happens
You def need more love in this channel! I absolutely love it!
The poolrooms combined with stained glass and a beach at sunrise/sunset
its so wild to see you talk about Broogli. i watch both of you and its unfortune he stole your images.
Been subbed for about a month now and oh my goodness I can't BELIEVE I found this channel. Your videos are awesome! I binge watched so many vids and I looks forward to your new ones. I've even lurked in some livestreams and love them. I've always been so fascinated by liminal spaces so you doing this is sooooo cool
Glad you like it!
Could we get some 90s and early 2000s style liminal spaces? Huge fan of further aero and the Y2K aesthetic. I feel like they would fit in with the grass rooms and poolrooms.
Could we get an indoor colorful playplace liminal spaces compilation? I have many bright and vivid memories of them 😊
Here’s another suggestion to add to the pile, can you combine level 94 with level 94, level 94 and level 94.
Funny enough its actually against the rules on midjourney to combine the same image with itself
@@liminalaiYou'd probably have to put them in a different direction for each image like upside down or reversed.
It's kinda sad that such a huge youtuber had to get images from you, although i know the credit is actually to the AI, you are the one who controls the AI and gives prompts, and especially shows these to youtube, so you deserve credit too, btw i loved how my suggestion turned out at 1:08 =D, also i have a suggestion: I wonder what the level "the end" would look like merged with level 3999, and level 21. Keep up the great work!!
Yeah credit to me for prompting the exact description of my grassrooms concept, then credit to the AI, then credit to the coders who made the AI, then credit to the artists and photographers it was trained on, then credit to the people who invented the art supplies and the people who inspired the artists in the first place, then credit to the people who taught those people basic education and art so that they’d be able to invent something or make their own art. The list goes on forever. I don’t actually care if I get credit and I have nothing against broogli, just thought it would make for a nice thumbnail🤣
@@liminalai Yea i know i kinda exagerated it, tho I really appreciate how you forgive him instead of creating useless controversies like most creators do, as another comment stated, he could've thought that since the images are made by AI, u don't require the credit.
Very possible! But the grassrooms that he specifically used is something i thought of, no other grassrooms images look similar to it. So even though I used AI to make them, those were from my brain and exactly how I imagined them😁
I've been enjoying the videos. Can you make liminal spaces with hospitals?
Idea: Human Fall Flat levels combined with outside liminal spaces
i have an idea, extremely large level 0. Like, huge rooms. the size of a football field. Big open empty rooms. Those always made me feel weird
I noticed that that Broogli had similar photos but I did not knew they were the same... Oh yeah how about a sea with skyscrapers coming out of it?🐢🐢
Yo bro congrats on 4k!!! I’m sure with the credits you will get new subs!
Maybe! The video is old now though. But it’s the thought that counts.
WOW! When did Broogli use your images? also Pizza tower liminal spaces please.
You should consider mixing Istanbul's Basilica Cistern with the grassrooms.
I have a suggestion: I'm curious what it'll look like if you combine Frutiger Aero with a dungeon.
1:24 true man, it's so easy to slip into the darkness
I like the creepyness of the last part
Amazing video, sorry to hear you didn't receive credit from Broogli.
Here's my suggestion: The 'Outrun' style mixed with a space of your choosing. I believe natural spaces would make a weird mixture.
I have a suggestion :D
Combining liminal spaces with beautiful sceneries in anime. You could take them straight out of any *actual* anime by screenshotting if you want. (I'd say mushoku tensei is amazing for this purpose as its filled to the brim with beautifully drawn sceneries.)
Or you can just use anime-style paintings/drawings.
I promise I'm no weeb xD
there should be a museum or something where its a bunch of backrooms recreated in real life and you can just walk around in it, I feel like there's a good chance that could be successful
It would be awesome. Someone should definitely do that.
probably just get the largest empty office building one could find, replace all the windows with walls, replace the lights with warmer ones, and then make the interior really confusing to navigate. essentially just a modern day winchester mystery house.
@@ArturoRuizAnalogHorror yeah but i want something that has ALL the different types of liminal spaces, not just the backrooms, maybe there's a pool room section, maybe there's a part with a fake sky, y'know all that. and it connects together like that one big ol' liminal gmod map
@@mrbeince8k303 hmm, well fake skylights are definitely a thing, and maybe there could be a hidden basement section that leads to the poolrooms.
@@ArturoRuizAnalogHorror see this is a million dollar idea waiting to happen! !!!! we just need someone to execute it
Hey! Awesome video as always! Anyways here is my suggestion, combine popular liminal spaces with the indie horror game five nights at freddys, thanks!
The cargo ship spaces were very nice, that was a great idea, I especially liked the beach one. I'd love to see what you could do with some art by Zdzisław Beksiński
Great video again! I loved the cargo ship ones
Me too😁
Thanks for using my idea but any way since the gorilla tag suggestion was so good this is day 1 of asking him to get the city map in the game gorilla tag and make into a liminal space.
What if you combined level 370 "The pool rooms" with some photos of the (acutal) poolrooms?
Also that video was super cool to watch, I watched through all of it :D
Suggestion: Could you combine a playground with level 9 from the backrooms, and the liminal hotel?
Combine any nostalgic liminal space and mix it with a cyberpunk aesthetic, I'd like to see chucky cheese with that aesthetic. Can you please make a cozy liminal cabin through the seasons
I have a suggestion combine a party room, the color black, and Level 11.
How dare he!
🤣🤣 it’s all good
Try to mix The Place from Earthbound with various famous Liminal spaces!
Combine a liminal space with an image of the sky
do poolrooms combined with pictures of a rainforest (day 11) (only a suggestion)
3:45 these looks like they're out of indie games
1:40, well theres a liminal pool room in amsterdam, a house in portugal, and some museum installation that isnt actually a pool.
anyways, have you ever used raw images in your videos? like midjourney images made only with text prompting.
(also i find it funny how you joked about burning the grassrooms to prevent further stealing, but literally the first image shown simply gets a light "char")
I gotta visit that! For the raw image thing, I’ve only do that like once.
The stealing part was dumb. It's bad he didn't give credit. Anyways I have a suggestion, I think you should do a fusion with backrooms level 0, backrooms level 94 and poolrooms.
Haha it’s all in good fun, I’m not actually mad🤣
Combine McDonald's KFC level 188 and the backrooms
Mix some images from shots from Wes Anderson's movies with liminal spaces.
👁Most creative revange i ever seen.👍👁
🤣🤣
Could you merge Alfaoxtrot's Infinite suburban and the pool rooms
@Broogli
.
love u man
Combine liminal spaces with images from the game mirrors edge. I always thought that game had a very clean liminal vibe. Even if i didn't know the word liminal yet. Don't use mirrors edge catalyst.
4:00 No way Gtag!
suggestions:blend the destroyed grassrooms and the destroyed liminal hotel from ruclips.net/video/dqY-Ki7Ny4s/видео.html
blend a room from five nights at freddy's 1 and popular liminal spaces (for fnaf's 9 year anniversary)
i know that AI can't handle cartoon very well but i have a suggestion.
can you get the UA high school building from My Hero Academia and combine it with multiple liminal spaces?
Day 2 of asking for a nostalgic image mixed with a liminal space.
5th try if asking: Do a different angled splitscreens of backrooms level 9223372036854775807 and the danger zone of the poolrooms then denoise it
DENOISE THE LIKE BUTTON! (serious suggestion)
I mean no hate in this question, but is that your actual voice, or do you use some sort of fine tuned text to speech? Just curious, either way, the voice you use is perfect for these videos.
Thanks! It’s an AI voice text to speech Voice
Attempts 3 at asking for library of Babel liminal space. I'm never leaving >:)
I need to figure out a way to do this one, i’ve tried it a few times but the AI struggles majorly
@@liminalai Maybe you could just look up pictures that don't specifically depict the library of Babel, but just infinite libraries and combine that with liminal spaces? Or maybe just show the images the AI struggled with anyway, just to see how it copes.
do the copenhagen freemason building that shi is soooooo liminal
damn broogli be wildin
Maybe he will see this😂
@@liminalai fr lmao
I subscribed 😄
🎉
Do the liminal hotel + baldi's school house pls
Good content
Thanks!
broogli is kind of annoying imo, I don’t think the backrooms should have generic creepy/survival horror aspects like super mega ultra almond water and poorly written SCARY!!!!!!!!! entities
Me either , he’s annoying asf
@Broogli 🤣🤣
LOL HOLY SHT
Day 4 of asking you to denoise a Tetris screenshot
What program did you used to burn down the images at the begining?
Something like: Burned, charred, abandoned,
@@liminalai But I mean like what program did you used for that feature?
@GardenDemonHR sorry i thought u said prompt. I used stable diffusion.
@@liminalai thanks
The fact that I used to watch his videos makes me feel wierd after this. I’m glad I was able to point this out to you. Idk if he did it on purpose or not but if he did I’m not sure how I would feel about it
Edit: the text above was edited due to my strong wording of it. I said I felt disgusted but in reality the heat of the moment had me fuming. I overreacted and said what I didn’t want to. I’m sorry if I got off on the wrong foot with you Broogli
Honestly bro I’m sure he didn’t do it on purpose. I don’t think he’s a bad guy at all. Who knows, maybe he will see it and get a laugh. If you like his videos keep watching him!
Dang bro, a homie can’t forget to link something 😭😭
oh damn, I just thought you stole them because why not. didn't know it wasn't that way. I'm sorry for assuming@@Broogli
hi! asking for rainy poolrooms again,,,,,,,,,
i saw that you hearted my last comment so i hope you put the whole discord server thing in consideration (so sorry if i sound annoying or anything i really just want to help)
Is it okay if I re-create the grass rooms in Minecraft?
For sure!
Can I offer recreate your other AI levels?
Stupid, AutoCorrect
What I meant to say was can I re-create your other AI liminal spaces im Minecraft?
yeah if you want to!@@Hugo-ev2nv
ay
Can you plz make a Tunisian liminal space plz 🔴⚪🔴
Hello!
36th
😂😂😂
Other than broogli not giving you credit, gotta still love the grassrooms