I think it's fair to say(tho VERY UNLIKELY to happen) Connor McDavid should should be boosted to 99 overall at some point down the road of EA NHL games😂
You underrate Quinn Hughes defensive ability. The kid is extremely underrated on his own zone. Not a shutdown guy but still pretty good two way defenseman
His defensive numbers are by far the best on his team (not saying much lol) and his plus minus is second on the team and I do see the problem with the +/- stat
The notion that hughes isn’t good defensively hasn’t been fair for a couple of years. He is the only competent defenceman in their own zone on the team and he does it playing with ahl d partners
He didn’t say he isn’t good defensively, he said he’s not as good defensively as he is offensively and since he is 2nd in points as a d man tactix is right he is better offensively.
@@WaddickLawnCare He doesn't say that specifically but it's kind of implied. A 90 overall is very fair for a PPG defenseman who isn't a liability defensively
finally Stutzle got an overall boost could still be 89 imo since Hughes is a 90 and Stutzle is right behind him in points and similar age plus Stutzle plays PK for Ottawa
@Timmy Timmy not anymore Bunting is now Stutzle has never been fined for embellishment like a lot of players have been and what's this have to do with his skill
“88 based on how Kanes played in the last few years” 2019- 110 2020- 84 in 70 2021- 66 in 56 2022- 92 in 78 This year - 55 in 70, missed games due to injury, played games through injury, playing on an AHL roster that is bottom of the league up until the deadline. He has 10 in 16 with rangers but he clearly needed a good few games to settle in with a new team. Kaner has played the best hockey of his career through his 30s. Don’t mean any hate to you but a lot of people seem to underrate Kane as of late.
I think Novak rating is completely fair we put Rookies low 80s before they've even played in the NHL and he has 41pts in 46GP and has been good all season
Quinn Hughes’ defence has tremendously improved this year. Look at his underlying numbers before you make that false judgment that he’s not good defensively.
He didn’t say he wasn’t good defensively, he said he’s not as good defensively as he is offensively and since he is 2nd in points as a d man tactix is right he is better offensively.
Personally in my roster I have Tim Stütlze as a high elite 90 - 91 overall people don’t give him the respect he deserves already is a top 20 player being a new 21 year old he has some of the best edges and handed in the world not to mention will most likely be a 40 goal scorer this year his shot is unreal
Tell me you don't watch Canucks hockey without telling me you don't watch canucks hockey. Quinn has been very solid defensively. While I agree with your point his passing should be boosted. But his defense stats are prety good imo
I wonder if Kasper will get a boost despite only playing one NHL game. Also I don't get that Fabbri dropped from 84 to an 83, while Kubalik got to stay at 84
I'm gonna disagree Mackinnon has been injured for a good chunk of the year and is still putting up a career season Although Pasta being Med Franchise is better High
why does everyone still say quinn hughes ain’t good defensively? yes last year he wasn’t great, but he’s improved so much this year, silly to keep saying it unless you really watch him
I think Stutzle could be an 89, if not a 90. Also how the hell do you NOT give Connor McDavid high franchise potential? He’s literally the benchmark/definition of a franchise hockey player Also, how has Matthews been defensively this season? Is he pulling a Steve Yzerman and becoming a two-way god, or is he just not producing? Feel like 94 might be too high for him if he’s not ON TOP of his defensive game
Matthews based on most metrics has actually been not that good defensively this year (32% defensive WAR) also hasnt played PK. Mcdavid has actually been better defensively this year.
TacTix it’s no error on Marner, he is a Franchise Player it just took a while since Matthews was the face of the franchise but it’s clear to see that Marner is also the face of the franchise of the Leafs
He didn’t say it was weak, he said he’s not as good defensively as he is offensively and since he is 2nd in points as a d man tactix is right he is better offensively.
Also personally I can see Josh Norris being a 50 goal scorer in the near future he already had a 35 goal season in 66GP on one of the worst teams in the NHL once he is healthy I can see him and so many players on the Sens Beijing so much higher rated in my personal opinion
Yzerman signed Matt Carle when he had one decent season with Philly at like a 5-6 year contract at 5.5 million. So he had some bad signings in Tampa as well.
Can anyone help me with this? It doesn’t let me download the roster and says It couldn’t be saved because I have the maximum number of roster saves when I have no custom rosters only official
Every time you do these videos you underestimate pasta, like the man has put the bruins on his back, leading every category for the team and is only a few goals behind mcdavid, yes he doesn’t deserve high franchise but he deserves the overall. Matthews has not been up to standard maybe he should drop in overall like cmon.
If you watch the oilers nuge for the most part is the one leading the play sure he’s playing with mcdavid and drai obviously it’s gunna look like that he’s a power play merchant usually I agree with you but love the videos keep up the good work don’t sleep on nuge
@@honortheoutsider9392 More than 50% of his points are on the PP and for most of the season especially recentley he has been on one of Mcdavid or Drais line so my point still stands that he is not a play driver.
@Ali D he's a great 2 way player, who cares where he gets his points from. He scores and that's what a team needs. He feeds off the McDavid and Drai like he's supposed to haha
Pastrnak is for sure franchise high because of the fact he’s gonna lead this franchise for years. That’s only the case though if mcdavid is franchise high as well
I think pettersson is a 92 also, out playing marner AND on a much worse team (also Hughes is not as bad as people make him out to be defensively) boeser should be 82, OEL has been playing horrible probably 80 and as of right now demko is more like an 85 as he hasn’t played great as of late
I love ea’s logic with the jets. Guy will have a career year and they get dropped. Love it. In case anyone was wondering Connor was a 91 high elite in 22 after having almost a 50-50-100 season he was downgraded to med elite 89. PLD needs to be med elite and 87. JMo is better at 88 tho I will say and wheeler 84. Barron needs to go up, Manelinen up Demelo needs to be 82-83 too. Having a phenomenal season with us rn
You: “I feel like, I feel like, I feel like, I feel like, I feel like, I feel like, I feel like, I feel like, I feel like, I feel like, I feel like, I feel like, I feel like, I feel like, I feel like”
(AS A BIASED DEVILS FAN) i think Hughes should be a 91-92 guy has 91 points already Dougie Also should be 90+ having a big year, and lastley TImo Meier 10 points in 17 games with 7 goals id say he took 6 game to get adjusted but has looked rlly good for us, not worth a drop at all i rate him 89
Leon shouldn’t be, although I think he’s a top 5 player he’s behind makar, mcdavid (ofc) and arguably Mac. Leon at 96/7 and mcdavid at 99 ofc (100 isn’t achieveable I don’t think)
Rantanen 93 franchise?? Th is ea smoking😂😂😂 then drai should be a 98 high franchise and mcdavid 99. Man do they hire a blind man to give them input for ratings or what xd
@@deejay8460 so? Karlsson has 100 points this season on the 3rd worst team in the league. According to ur logic he deserves 99 high franchise... its hella inflated bc of mckinnon and makar. Just look at hyman and rnh. Rnh should be a 93 medium franchise aswell bc he has over 100 points xd
@@nogitsune4542 That logic is dumb, look at Rantanen and how he carried the team when Makar and Mackinnon were out of the lineup and come back to me. Also this is RNH first big season where Rantanen has done it consistently for 5-6 years. On top of that over half of RNH points have come on the powerplay. Your logic that Rantanen is only good because of Mackinnon is like saying Draisaitl is only good because of McDavid.
Hope you guys enjoyed the video! Thoughts on the new ratings??
I think it's fair to say(tho VERY UNLIKELY to happen) Connor McDavid should should be boosted to 99 overall at some point down the road of EA NHL games😂
@@DylanLivingston87 I 100% agree
bro kane put up 90+ pts last season on a horrible team and this year he is playing decent he deserves a 90
You underrate Quinn Hughes defensive ability. The kid is extremely underrated on his own zone. Not a shutdown guy but still pretty good two way defenseman
By the way, bellows got claimed on waivers to the flyers so that is why he is not shown
Hughes is fairly rated. Defence has greatly improved and he’s 2nd in points for a d man.
His defensive numbers are by far the best on his team (not saying much lol) and his plus minus is second on the team and I do see the problem with the +/- stat
The notion that hughes isn’t good defensively hasn’t been fair for a couple of years. He is the only competent defenceman in their own zone on the team and he does it playing with ahl d partners
He didn’t say he isn’t good defensively, he said he’s not as good defensively as he is offensively and since he is 2nd in points as a d man tactix is right he is better offensively.
@@WaddickLawnCare for sure he is better offensively but he is acting as if he is so bad 90 is too high for him, which isn’t true
@@WaddickLawnCare He doesn't say that specifically but it's kind of implied. A 90 overall is very fair for a PPG defenseman who isn't a liability defensively
@@ozonelayer8684 no he did not act that way lmao nice reach tho
@@WaddickLawnCare he literally said 90 is too high for him
finally Stutzle got an overall boost could still be 89 imo since Hughes is a 90 and Stutzle is right behind him in points and similar age plus Stutzle plays PK for Ottawa
Stutzle is the biggest diver in the league let’s be fr
@Timmy Timmy not anymore Bunting is now Stutzle has never been fined for embellishment like a lot of players have been and what's this have to do with his skill
Agreed. It's crazy how he's a top 25 player but in NHL 24 being an 88 won't even make it to the top 50 😢
@@keirpatrick3045 that’s because EA also counts their careers in their ratings
@@timmytimmy803rent free 💀
Yesss, petey got an overall boost! And hughes! But feel like kuzy should get an 87 overall
Nate Mac has 100 points in 65 games he definitely deserves 95 ovr finally
This roster update hands out elite potential like candy
Quinn hughes did take some steps forward defensively this year so I don’t mind his rating
Tim Stütlze should have full list of abilities he is going to be one of the leagues best players for the next 15 years
i give most of my players x factors on my roster, i feel that it defines what they are good at
“88 based on how Kanes played in the last few years”
2019- 110
2020- 84 in 70
2021- 66 in 56
2022- 92 in 78
This year - 55 in 70, missed games due to injury, played games through injury, playing on an AHL roster that is bottom of the league up until the deadline. He has 10 in 16 with rangers but he clearly needed a good few games to settle in with a new team. Kaner has played the best hockey of his career through his 30s. Don’t mean any hate to you but a lot of people seem to underrate Kane as of late.
Novak is legit. He’s taking his game and translating it perfectly to the NHL. He was easily their best forward since joining the team.
montour has 65 points. 87 absolutely deserved
I think Novak rating is completely fair we put Rookies low 80s before they've even played in the NHL and he has 41pts in 46GP and has been good all season
Hughes has been good defensively this year
Quinn Hughes’ defence has tremendously improved this year. Look at his underlying numbers before you make that false judgment that he’s not good defensively.
He didn’t say he wasn’t good defensively, he said he’s not as good defensively as he is offensively and since he is 2nd in points as a d man tactix is right he is better offensively.
Mantha should be downgraded to a 60 but passing to Malkin should be 99. I am also not being swayed by my bias as an angry caps fan lol
I think its safe to give Martin Fehervary top 4 potential at this point
Will you be doing another custom roster update? I love your roster
Since when did powerplay goals count less?
Personally in my roster I have Tim Stütlze as a high elite 90 - 91 overall people don’t give him the respect he deserves already is a top 20 player being a new 21 year old he has some of the best edges and handed in the world not to mention will most likely be a 40 goal scorer this year his shot is unreal
Lol you’re clearly a sens fan🤣🤣
Tell me you don't watch Canucks hockey without telling me you don't watch canucks hockey.
Quinn has been very solid defensively. While I agree with your point his passing should be boosted. But his defense stats are prety good imo
No Devin Levi in this update?
He’s in there 77 ovr med elite
@@kinglyric569 thank you!
I wonder if Kasper will get a boost despite only playing one NHL game. Also I don't get that Fabbri dropped from 84 to an 83, while Kubalik got to stay at 84
McKinnon is def number 2 he has been an absolute monster since coming back from injury, as of rn he drives offense more than Matthews or Draisaitl
Hey guys when ea release new roster update for may and update iihf for this season?
Luostarinen still underrated
Noah Gregor has been playing really well for the sharks and just got his first career hattrick last week
I'm gonna disagree Mackinnon has been injured for a good chunk of the year and is still putting up a career season
Although Pasta being Med Franchise is better High
11 games isn’t a good chunk of the year
@@WaddickLawnCare he still the second best in the world
Id put Makar as 2nd best. Mack should be a 94
@@sc66666 that has nothing to do with what I said
Personally I think the best players goes
1. McDavid
2. Draisaitl
3. MacKinnon
4. Kucherov
5. Pastrnak
Id go
1. Mcdavid
2. Makar
3. Mackinnon
4. Drai
5. Pasta/Marner
@@alid7192 lol take away marner put kucherov
@@alid7192 idk Makar hasn't had the season to where I can put him in the top 5
I can’t update it, I still don’t have the reverse retros and I have a series X
why does everyone still say quinn hughes ain’t good defensively? yes last year he wasn’t great, but he’s improved so much this year, silly to keep saying it unless you really watch him
I think Stutzle could be an 89, if not a 90. Also how the hell do you NOT give Connor McDavid high franchise potential? He’s literally the benchmark/definition of a franchise hockey player
Also, how has Matthews been defensively this season? Is he pulling a Steve Yzerman and becoming a two-way god, or is he just not producing? Feel like 94 might be too high for him if he’s not ON TOP of his defensive game
Ya I agree considering Jack Hughes is a 90 and Stutzle isn't far behind him on points and Stutzle plays PK
Matthews based on most metrics has actually been not that good defensively this year (32% defensive WAR) also hasnt played PK.
Mcdavid has actually been better defensively this year.
Matthews as of a week or so ago was leading all NHL forwards in blocked shots, so I’d say he’s playing pretty well
@@jakebernardin Yes because blocked shots = strong defensive play
TacTix it’s no error on Marner, he is a Franchise Player it just took a while since Matthews was the face of the franchise but it’s clear to see that Marner is also the face of the franchise of the Leafs
Hronek and Quinn Hughes could have been the Red Wings top pair for years. 😂😂
9:33, Don't be discrediting Nuge cause he's scoring on the PP. Show some respect man.
You haven’t watched Hughes if you think his defence is weak tbh
He didn’t say it was weak, he said he’s not as good defensively as he is offensively and since he is 2nd in points as a d man tactix is right he is better offensively.
I don’t get how RHP won the molson cup but is a 78.
Also personally I can see Josh Norris being a 50 goal scorer in the near future he already had a 35 goal season in 66GP on one of the worst teams in the NHL once he is healthy I can see him and so many players on the Sens Beijing so much higher rated in my personal opinion
Biased sens fan🤣
He was riding an unsustainable shooting%
No Devi Levi on the Sabres?
He’s there
Yzerman signed Matt Carle when he had one decent season with Philly at like a 5-6 year contract at 5.5 million. So he had some bad signings in Tampa as well.
Also the Chariot and Copp signings are bad
Idk Sammy Walker's Really good in the AHL, minnesota put him on the First Line in Kaprizovs spot and I'm pretty sure he didn't get a single point
I’m a huge sammy walker fan but like hight top 6 should be highest potential he should have
Can anyone help me with this? It doesn’t let me download the roster and says It couldn’t be saved because I have the maximum number of roster saves when I have no custom rosters only official
Delete your older rosters
Thank you
Every time you do these videos you underestimate pasta, like the man has put the bruins on his back, leading every category for the team and is only a few goals behind mcdavid, yes he doesn’t deserve high franchise but he deserves the overall. Matthews has not been up to standard maybe he should drop in overall like cmon.
*clears throat** I revamped the whole shibang … made it more realistic as possible related to injury prone players and other factors
So many EA errors in this roster, what is going on? 🤣
Kieffer Bellows is on the Flyers
Thats a crap take on Novak
4th in Goals
4th in Assists
5th in Points with 41 in 46.
He has 20-30 less games played than the rest of the preds roster
Where’s evander Kane?!?
Some of these ea ratings don't make sense
I think they should give Nelson the shnipe X factor after winning the accuracy
the high potentials they give is when players are close to 27 years old so they dont matter as much
If you watch the oilers nuge for the most part is the one leading the play sure he’s playing with mcdavid and drai obviously it’s gunna look like that he’s a power play merchant usually I agree with you but love the videos keep up the good work don’t sleep on nuge
I watch almost every Oilers game and Nuge does not drive the play, great on the PP and as a supporting player to Mcdavid and Drai.
@@alid7192 watching the wrong team I see
@@honortheoutsider9392 More than 50% of his points are on the PP and for most of the season especially recentley he has been on one of Mcdavid or Drais line so my point still stands that he is not a play driver.
@Ali D he's a great 2 way player, who cares where he gets his points from. He scores and that's what a team needs. He feeds off the McDavid and Drai like he's supposed to haha
@@alid7192why couldn't puljujarvi then 🤔
Pastrnak is for sure franchise high because of the fact he’s gonna lead this franchise for years. That’s only the case though if mcdavid is franchise high as well
Matthews should be an 80
Thomer and dahlin most underrated players. Both deserve medium franchise, 92+
quinn hughes is great defensively. clearly you need to watch some canucks games.
Hey could I use this roster for franchise mode on xbox one. someone plz lmk
It’s an update by EA so yes
@@WaddickLawnCare oh thought it was custom. Any good custom ones for xbox one then ?
@@danielfalbo3323 pretty sure tactix roster is on Xbox
I think pettersson is a 92 also, out playing marner AND on a much worse team (also Hughes is not as bad as people make him out to be defensively) boeser should be 82, OEL has been playing horrible probably 80 and as of right now demko is more like an 85 as he hasn’t played great as of late
Idk, georgiev was great on the rangers when he got starts. His rating seems fair, but potential is too high
I dont mind McKinnon at 95 but if all those dudes are 94/95 McDavid deserves a 99
Best nhl RUclipsr
Nvm I got it thank you for showing us how to do it in the beginning!
The disrespect on Hughes defensive game still amazes me, elite corsi, plays pk
Last roster update before NHL 22, huh were going back in time
I love ea’s logic with the jets. Guy will have a career year and they get dropped. Love it. In case anyone was wondering Connor was a 91 high elite in 22 after having almost a 50-50-100 season he was downgraded to med elite 89. PLD needs to be med elite and 87. JMo is better at 88 tho I will say and wheeler 84. Barron needs to go up, Manelinen up Demelo needs to be 82-83 too. Having a phenomenal season with us rn
You: “I feel like, I feel like, I feel like, I feel like, I feel like, I feel like, I feel like, I feel like, I feel like, I feel like, I feel like, I feel like, I feel like, I feel like, I feel like”
72 in 78 and an 87 isn’t fair?
Muzzin shouldn't be an 84 because his career is basically over
Montour has been a stud all year, even since ekblad is back montours been the number 1 d man. He quarterbacks pp1. Could honestly even be a 88
I was at the same habs game!
Your crazy for always shitting on Hughes rating, guy should be a Norris finalist this year!!
(AS A BIASED DEVILS FAN) i think Hughes should be a 91-92 guy has 91 points already Dougie Also should be 90+ having a big year, and lastley TImo Meier 10 points in 17 games with 7 goals id say he took 6 game to get adjusted but has looked rlly good for us, not worth a drop at all i rate him 89
90 or 91 is fair
Why don’t they make mcdavid 97 then drai and mackinnon 95 seems fair
Leon & Connor should be 100 overall lol
Leon shouldn’t be, although I think he’s a top 5 player he’s behind makar, mcdavid (ofc) and arguably Mac. Leon at 96/7 and mcdavid at 99 ofc (100 isn’t achieveable I don’t think)
I love how they have Devon Levi drafted by Buffalo😂😂
Yes mackinnon deserves a 95 above all the players you mentioned, hes definitely 2nd best in the world
85 for PLD is a little low
Oshie needs back at ya!
Kinda disrespectful to put Robertson only at elite medium should be elite high the way he’s playing bro has 100+ points
Toffoli still being disrespected. Should be higher than an 86.
lets go Pasta high franchise
Mikko Rantanen should be 94 for sure maybe even 95!!
No he shouldn't. 93 at max. He's not better than Makar, Matthews, Pastrnak or at same level as MacKinnon.
EA just giving franchise to everybody
Boldy should have been like 89 ovr
Recency bias, he'll be there in 2 years anyway
@Mathieu Harbour he sort of deserves it though cause he had 2 hat tricks in 5 games
@@Leafs888 2 hat tricks ain’t enough to boost overall that much lol
@@Leafs888 and sam gagner had an 8 points game...
@@Just_a_Man780 when
Sup Tactix
Awful ratings by EA
Montour is better than Ekblad
didnt understand one word from this guy.
Seems like you dont know english then
Rantanen 93 franchise?? Th is ea smoking😂😂😂 then drai should be a 98 high franchise and mcdavid 99. Man do they hire a blind man to give them input for ratings or what xd
Wtf are you talking about? Rantanen has 54 goals and over 100 points this season.
@@deejay8460 so? Karlsson has 100 points this season on the 3rd worst team in the league. According to ur logic he deserves 99 high franchise... its hella inflated bc of mckinnon and makar. Just look at hyman and rnh. Rnh should be a 93 medium franchise aswell bc he has over 100 points xd
@@nogitsune4542 That logic is dumb, look at Rantanen and how he carried the team when Makar and Mackinnon were out of the lineup and come back to me. Also this is RNH first big season where Rantanen has done it consistently for 5-6 years. On top of that over half of RNH points have come on the powerplay. Your logic that Rantanen is only good because of Mackinnon is like saying Draisaitl is only good because of McDavid.
Minnesota Wild Changes
Top 6
Kaprizov 93
Spurgeon 89
Brodin 88
Boldy 87
Eriksson Ek 87
Zuccarello 86
Downgrades
Klingberg 84
Dumba 82
Goalies
Fleury 87
Gustavsson 90
First!
miller should be higher 88 at least. when he gets going hes more dominant then petterson.
Minnesota Wild Changes
Top 6
Kaprizov 93
Spurgeon 89
Brodin 88
Boldy 87
Eriksson Ek 87
Zuccarello 86
Gaudreau 84
Downgrades
Klingberg 84
Dumba 82
Goalies
Fleury 87
Gustavsson 90