These people accepted Pakistan as their country , Not Bangladesh , they actively participated against the Independence Fight of Bangladesh, They Assisted Pakistani Forces in 1971 , They refused to Accept Bangladeshi Citizenship until 10-15 years ago , instead wanted to go to Pakistan. BD is kind enough to offer them shelter , even Bangladeshi Citizenship.
What do you mean by these people? Were they there when muktijuddho happened to take active participation against it? Probably they were not even born or were children. Past should not be carried forward to such an extent that it feels that the oppressed oppress more than the earstwhile oppressors.
Kabi kabi sochtaa hai kia jo mil gya inhe new new desh bana ka chaya wo Nepal ho chya srilanka chaya pakistan chaya Bangladesh chaya burma A to z sare desh lagbhag bankrupt ho chuke hai....mayanmar ma apna ma lar rha hai.... Bangladesh ka halat dekh hi rha ho aur aaj hi uska foreign minister na India sa help mangi hai economy bachana ja lia.... Srilanka to yrr covid ka karanchla gya Pakistan ka baat hi nirala hai... Nepal to chlo India kabi kuch nai hone dega usko Bs ek Bhutan acha kaam kar rha lkin aaj bhi Indian army bhutan ki border pa pehra de rai to bhai akhir kia hasil kar liya , toot ke Hindustan naam ma hi feel aa jata hai hamlog zero sa aaj kitta upar paunchna wala hai 3rd largest economy by 2030 now at 5th....Chlo karma is bitch aaj mehsus ho rha hoga....India ka value
They betrayed with their homeland (India) in 1947. They betrayed with Bengalis in 1971. Worked for Pakistani Army. They supported and helped Pakistani Army in 1971. Then after Independence of Bangladesh, Pakistan betrayed with them. Left them here. This is called karma. And an important thing you missed that this camp is called Geneva camp under the Geneva Convention (for war presoners). All the Bengali Razakar who helped Pakistani Army to kill or torture Bengalis in 1971, had to face trial for war crime. These people under Geneva Convention didn’t have to.
Homeland us one which is prophisized by last prophet a Muslim state with digital weapons. I think u didn't study about Islam focus more on these things...
1400 years ago Muslims of that time can also live under bannu quresh but Allah wants from Muslims to establish Islam as a state religion.. If you are not struggling to do this ND wanna. Live under hindus rules then change you name as well ND Marry a hindus.. Allah don't need anyone one..
@@shubradeepde7417 its your dream, these Biharis are still loyal to pakistan after everything and you think Sindhis and baluchis would be disloyal to pakistan? And pakistan did accept bangla as national language in 1965 but east pakistan kept demanding more autonomy until the war happened.
@@songoku3716 yes I think because we saw fight between sindhi vs pathan , shia vs sunni and sindhi muhajir , pathan vs muhajir ethnicity problem are there and same like balochistan need freedom .
@@shubradeepde7417 there will be some fight here and there between different groups, same as in india with Punjabis, Tamils etc but the fact of the matter is Pakistan is still one of the most patriotic countries on the planet with 95% willing to die for their country in their recent survey.
@@songoku3716 there is no fight tamil , Punjabi in India .. There is no problem like ethnicity , shia sunni in India . but little bit problem between Hindu vs Muslim but they live together .they study together , they go to school together, they go to job together . i study in kolkata . there are so many Muslims student and teacher in my college . they live together , they eat together
The Biharis in Bangladesh have been sufferings for the sins which their predecessors did during Liberation War in 1971. How do you comment in favour of them without knowing history?
Unfortunately the muslim biharies supported Pakistan during 71 war, not Bangladesh or bangalis, this is why they were suffering today. Bangalis wanted independence from brutal Pakistani rule and their hatred of bengali language, yet the Biharies wanted to be with Pakistan because of Urdu language
in 1971, this community acted as Razakar & Al Badar, Joined hand with Pakistani army & mercilessly killed Bengalis irrespective of Hindu Muslims. Result is now visible.
Motiur Rahman Nizami and Mir Quasem Ali, both leaders of the Jamaat e Islami, were hanged to death in Dhaka jail in 2016 for war crimes during 1971. Were they Biharis? Do you harrass THEIR family members like you harrass Biharis? Why don't you throw their family members into camps? Why are you punishing the descendants of Biharis who were involved in 1971 violence? How can someone born AFTER 1971 be held responsible for what happened then?
Great work Bishnu! I am a Bangladeshi and know some about the "Bihari"s, but this is the first time I am learning about them from their own authentic source. Really good......
You cannot take on side without knowing the brutal history. These Bihari( Pakistani) tortured Bangladeshi people till 1971. Still Bangladeshi government has given them citizenship of this country. Think about those Bengali people how has stuck in Pakistan if you compare then Behari must be in better position. Behari people still believe they're not Bangladeshi.
@@pajiitslayer6042 but they left Bihar (India) because of ur great Godfather Jinnah and went to east Pakistan that is Bangladesh at present. Some of them still today wants to go to Pakistan but fate had other plans. And stop abusing me brother. What is Ganges breed ?? We all are humans . At least show some humanity for these people. They already have suffered too much. Don't try to find religion in everything like Jinnah did.
@@bobghosh8313 ganges breed means people who are native to banks of ganges simply has nothing to do with religion. West pakistan is not for people native to ganges plains its only for people native to indus river plains. so simply that is the reason they are not allowed in pakistan. either they should go back to bihar or beg bangalis to accept them as they are genetically most similar to bengalis and are muslim like bangladeshis
They are descendents of rajakar bahini who helped the pakistani army by all means to oppose the independence of 🇧🇩Bangladesh. The tortured and killed many bengali. Dharmandh muslim behari in the name of religion devide the country. They may gladly go to Pakistan (their dream land) to live a Royal life. Why they are still living in Bangladesh? They are pakistani not bangladeshi. Joy Bangla.
Bihar and bangal was part of bengal sultanate before palassy and baxer ....they are same austroasatic race people !!!! This this British classification is true!!! Bihar jharkhand bengal odisha and Assamese bangla are same people
@Sunil Chahal they supported pakistan at their young age....because of them thousands of bengali people had to leave bangladesh and lived their live in the streets of kolkata
@@jihadi-against-oppression Beta Baap ko Bhul gaye shivaji raje Teri Sari betiyan de dega tab bhi Convert nahi honge hamare log ~Shambhaji maharaj Ab to bas Bhagwa e Prithvi ka Wait karo
Hi Vishnu, from your name felt that you are a Bengali by birth but may have stayed outside Bengal for long. The Hindi you speak is far cleaner than most Bengalis. Realised that you are not much clued in on history. You repeatedly kept on saying partition took place in 1971. There wasn't any partition in 1971. Undivided India got divided into India and Pakistan in 1947 (when both these countries achieved independence). This is what is known as partition. Pakistan had two portions one called West Pakistan (the present day Pakistan) and the other was called East Pakistan (the present day Bangladesh). In 1971 East Pakistan broke away from Pakistan and became an independent country called Bangladesh. This is the most basic information you should have known before visiting Bangladesh. While most Hindus from the newly formed Pakistan (from both East and West) moved into India, a large section of the Muslim population from western & northern India crossed over to western side of Pakistan while those from UP, Bihar, Bengal and Assam crossed over to eastern side of Pakistan. As in India where we have a large mix of languages, both sides of Pakistan also has a mix (the number of languages are not as many as in India) of languages. However today Urdu is the national language of Pakistan though Punjabi is also a very dominant language. Sindhi, Gujarati and Balochi are also spoken by large numbers. On the other hand Bangladesh was born on the lines of Bangla language and thus it has an overwhelming majority. This is where the non-Bengali Muslims find themselves stranded. Something their forefathers had not imagined. Though you kept on hearing Hindi/ Urdu in some form or the other as you walked across the by lanes of Bihari Camp, a slightly more sensitive ear would have told you that these people now have a strong Bangla influence in their language. Most pronunciation sounded clearly Bangla. Yes, you are right these people are not at fault. But the euphoria of partition caused untold havoc across the entire subcontinent leading to terrible bloodshed. The people who propagated the two nation theory on religious lines and called for Pakistan were all well read and very well off people. Neither they nor their immediate family suffered. They sat on the negotiation table and pushed for Pakistan, while influencing the larger masses at the lower end of the pyramid of a particular religion to join the call. The condition of these masses who were way down the ladder and crossed over to Pakistan are still in pitiable condition in fairly large numbers. Thus quite often we do hear an Indian Muslim thanking their forefathers for having decided to stay back in India and not crossed over.
If you knew the whole story you would think twice about siding with them, they're Pakistani prisoners of war, that's why live in Geneva camp, their fathers were Indian citizens ,they're Pakistani citizens, their children and grandchildren are Bangladeshi citizen; it's an absolute mess, The UN protected them otherwise they would've been put on trial and hanged long ago
But in recent years an average Bengali speaking Bangladeshi is moving closer to Urdu speaking Pakistani. Basically Bangladeshi love Pakistanis because of their common hate for Hindu Indians but also Bangladeshis hate Pakistan because of 1971 genocide. You guys should decide if Muslim brotherhood holds more value or 1971 Pakistanis hate towards Bengalis.
@changu mangu lol who is learning Urdu again?😂 you meant Arabic? Bruv in our religion it is compulsory to learn Arabic as the scripts of Al Quran is written in Arabic. And we always speak in Bangla, Bangla is our mother tongue. Bangladesh is the only country where peoples sacrificed their lives for a language. We love our language so much that we gave our country's name after it (Bangla-Desh). Don't speak rubbish, get to know what the truth is at first
@@rudetosociety I think u have a problem in understanding English...he said u guys are getting closer to Urdu speaking Pakistani.who responsible for ur genocide.when did he said u guys are learning Urdu 😂😂??
yes closer because of muslim brotherhood not only for pakistan but also for all muslim in this world.. For 1971, pakistani new jenaration are not responsible for this..
Yes , to a substantial extent true! Now , it's a fact that all were 'Pakistani citizens, including the Bengalis...part of East Pakistan ( earlier until 1961, East Bengal Province)! Well, many among them, expectedly, supported the state forces of Pakistan! Can u blame them entirely? The Dominions of India and Pakistan were created by British colonialists in 1947 ...not by the largely uneducated masses...the leaders Jinnah, Suhrawardy...and to an extent Nehru were responsible! Many of these joined those 'Razakar' forces, BUT not all were militants or responsible...many innocents were killed by the Bengali militia and mukti bahini also...for no fault of theirs! See, history is cruel and the British left a colony is such a way that they could have their influence over this region fr a long time! The state of ''Pakistan' was created immediately after WWII primarily as a 'bulwark' state by the Allied powers ( primarily GB and USA) to stop the then most powerful Soviet Union's expansionist aims of coming to South Asia to get a foothold on the Indian Ocean...this is to give a quick big pic of those decades in the last century!
But They should left india your grandparents are cheater they cheated hindus first they demanded separate Islamic country and voted for pakistan but after taking pakistan they didn't go there while they should must go and now you people say that you want to live with hindus not with muslims I don't know why u ppl want to live with hindus why don't you go to pakistan or Bangladesh Just go there and fall in identity crisis
Brother, 1.5 crore Biharis live in Bangladesh. They speak Bengali so they don't have any problem. There are many Biharis in my village too. There are many Bihari cities in North Bengal. But Bihari of the Geneva camp is different. They literally support Pakistan in the 1971 Bengali genocide. They still don't want to speak Bengali. Directly supports Pakistan. They celebrate when Pakistan wins a cricket match. They even celebrate Eid according to Pakistani time. How will the Bangladeshis support them? If they don't want Bangladesh. Bangladesh government also showed kindness and gave them citizenship. But Bengalis in Pakistan are still treated as fourth class people.
@@ssn8817 liberals and others think of India as an intolerant society,.... Still the rohingyas want to enter India and interestingly, muslim leadership expects the govt. of India to accept them (in large numbers..). And the Ummah is doing just lip service.... Bangladeshis are fed up of their 5lakh rohingya refugees...
These people helped pakistan army genociding bengalis. In pakistan they are called muhajirs, they fought against hindus while partition in 1947, in bangladesh, India as well as pakistan they are hated
@@cosmos2210 They are hated by India for leaving India, they are hated by Bangladesh for creating para military against Bengalis in 71 genocide and they are hated by Pakistanis which is why Pakistan call them Muhajirs.
Don't try to over simplify problems. It's not only language. It's all what they did with Hindu and Bengali Muslims when Pakistan was controlling that land.
Mr. Vishnu, It is ok to not know history properly. But after recording the video and before publishing, you should have researched about your content. The bihari people migrated to EAST PAKISTAN in 1947. When Pakistan army started massacring Bengalis in 1971, these biharis took side with Pakistan and formed para military force. Along with Pakistani army, These biharis massacred numerous bengalis. Fortunately, (unfortunately for biharis) Bangladesh got liberated. But these biharis got into a huge problem. The side they supported denied to take them to Pakistan. And Bangladesh cannot keep these traitor and war criminals in our holy motherland. So Bangladesh kept them in "Geneva camp" in hope that their country (pak) would retrieve them, which Pakistan never did. They are called stranded Pakistani. They killed our Bengali people in unimaginable ways. Still our govt is kind enough that, They were given Bangladeshi citizenship in 2008. Which is totally ironic because they still consider themselves Pakistani and they support Pakistan in Bangladesh vs Pakistan cricket match, even they wave Pakistan flag too!!! The Bengali population that got stuck or willfully chose Pakistan after liberation war are still waiting for citizenship which Pakistan denying to give even when these bengalis loved and chose pyara pakistan! They are treated as second class citizen in pak. These Pakistani biharis living in Bangladesh should be thankful to the god for what they achieved.
Have you ever kept yourself into their shoes, actual story is their ancestors fight and migrated for pakistan and many were killed including children and womens and many were seprated from their families but after getting Pakistan, bangladeshi people wanted their separate homeland (keep the reason aside) so in that scenario bihari supported pakistan for which they lost many lifes earlier and from their sights bangalis were wrong as they wanted to seprate their beloved country, if you were in their place what would you choose?
@@zeeshanahmed5943 I would put myself in the shoes of those Hindu Bengalis and marwadis who were fleeing to india for refuge in 1971. Biharis along with Pakistani army killed 448 of them in a planned massacre at syedpur rail station just a few kilometres from India. (Golahat massacre) I have zero sympathy for the biharis that took part in Bengali genocide alongside Pakistan army. They were not helpless they were active collaborators.
@@GoichoMakad they are not indian. They came to east Pakistan in 1947 as the partition forced Muslims to migrate to Pakistan and hindus to india. They are Pakistani, they wanted to remain Pakistani so that they participated in Bengali genocide in 1971. But they failed. But Pakistani government are not taking them to Pakistan. So they are called stranded Pakistani in Bangladesh. It's a shame that their country (Pakistan) does not want to take them.
At 1999 world cup they support Pakistan against Bangladesh in Cricket 🏏. They brought flag of Pakistan and i'm the eye witness. Now imagine the rest of all.
Muslims will always support for Muslims and it's obvious. Who is actually real Muslim he/she will never support injustice even that injustice comes from another person who belongs to the same religion.
The luckiest one are those who chose to stay in India , they got citizenship and are considered Indian, no one feels discrimination no matter what their roots are. India is such diverse country that everyone has it's own place.
You are living in a fool's paradise. The incidents I mentioned never happened in Bangladesh. Too bad for the misguided 2-Nation Theory. When Sarat Ch. Bose, Husein Suhrawardy, Kiran wanted undivided Bengal, Nehru, Patel sided with Hindu Mahashaba to divide Bengal and force partition. Gandhi, Maulana Azad however were against partition. Can't write the whole history here.
There forefathers fought against us and joined with pak military. Now they stuck with their deeds. But Islam says, descendants aren't responsible for the misdeed of their forefathers. Bangladesh govt should give them nationality because they living here like citizens of Bengal. They are also human🥺
They are not bihari, and on what basis you can call them bihari? Because their ancestors was from bihar? They even not know about our culture, no one cares a about them. It's on you that whatever you want to call them but not tell them Bihari.
I am Bihari hindu . You are saying once you know the history u will not side with those bihari. What Pakistani did with Bangladeshi before 1971 . All knows . Now Bangladeshi has lot of love for Pakistani. I saw the response of Bangladeshi in you ube . Then why cant bihari muslim be forgiven . You also fought with india in 1947 and separated but we don’t hate Bangladeshi. We think Bangladeshi as friendly nation . Did you watch Kolkata people response ‘when they were asked what you think about Bangladeshi’ . It was ❤. We respect and like you as neighbors. Don’t do this to Bihari Muslim . Give them respect that they deserve.
I know many Bihari people and 9 out of 10 people I know support Pakistan when Bangladesh plays against them in any sports. There are many Bangladeshis stuck in Pakistan also, Biharis living in Bangladesh are living thousands times better life than Bangladeshis who got stuck in Pakistan. In fact most people in Bangladesh count Biharis as their own.
@aseem hn bhai... Jaante hai.. ye logo ne 1971 PAK army ko support kia ... Or Pakistani army ne bahut julm kia tha Bengali par including r@p*s.. 😡 jo ki bahut galat hua Par ... Abb mostly new generation hai... And now , i don't think they should be excluded from the mainstream ... !
@@Khalid-fy6ib Gopalganj,Mirganj,Barharia,Siswan Ye Sab Jagha Ek Ke Baad ek apne log rehte hai Bahut miss karta hu.Kuch din pehle Aya ghumke.Nani Ghar,Mausi ka Ghar,❤️
Unfortunately the muslim biharies supported Pakistan during 71 war, not Bangladesh or bangalis, this is why they were suffering today. Bangalis wanted independence from brutal Pakistani rule and their hatred of bengali language, yet the Biharies wanted to be with Pakistan because of Urdu language
I have always been curious about it, in mere 23 years(till 1971) Pakistan witnessed 4 Bengali Prime Ministers, 4 Bengali Presidents, 2 Bengali Chief Justice of the Supreme Court and 5 Bengali Speakers of the National Parliament, from what angle exactly was this 'brutal rule'?
@@ytv31 Fool everyone knows how Pakistanis were looting East Pakistan. Bengal became the poorest region because pakistani rule where famine was happening. Today after 50 years of independance. Bangladesh has 4 times strongest economy then Pakistan
@@ytv31 Making someone prime minister doesn't mean Sh_it, we all know Bengali language and culture was being eliminated, they were being forced to accept Punjabi and Urdu culture, and add to that Famine was being created in East Pakistan, so average Bengalis would suffer and accept Pakistani rule. This is everywhere on the internet and even Ex PM Imran Khan just talked about this in his speech last week, go listen fool. And the amount rapes and killings that happened just before the 1971 war is very well documented
@@Deira854 putting to use a liberal dose of cuss words won't get you any scores here mate, my essential point being that Bengalis had absolutely dominated Pakistani polity in every sphere the entire time Bangladesh was it's part. With a record of 15 high level appointments in two decades, no other ethnic group on GOD's good earth will cry a river about systemic elimination and desolation.
If possible, please have a look at the lives of Bengalis stuck in Karachi. That should help you understand that these people are in a comparatively better state than stranded Bengalis in Pakistan. Partition of India was the biggest blunder in history of the world.
@@shazainbaloch2538 Pakistan ne kya cheena? Pakistan ne 3m people ko mara,women ko rap kiya..1952,1971 duno saal yaad rakna jo Pakistan ne Bangladesh ke saat kiya uski liye Pakistan abhi bhi maafi Nehi manga.... Aur app bol raha ho Pakistan ne kya cheena...
@@shazainbaloch2538For your kind information, these people get free electricity, free ration, which is NOT offered to average Bengali citizens. They were offered BD citizenship by Sheikh Mujib in 1972. They refused and hoped that Pakistan would repatriate them. Pak didn't repatriate them. BD again made them citizen in 2008. It's not that BD govt don't allow them to stay outside camp. They simply don't want to pay rent and get a better accommodation. They don't want to give up the free facilities they get in those camps. What do you expect BD govt to do? Give them free apartments? Funny thing is, Sheikh Hasina actually announced that she will build apartments for them. Yet these traitors will vote against Hasina, criticize Bengalis day and night. Look at their hatred against us. They brutally murdered and raped us in 1971. Those Pakistanis who are shedding crocodile tears for Biharis over here, you can try to do something for Bengalis stuck in Pakistan for a change. You can start by offering them citizenship. Both Bengalis and Biharis are Muslims. If you are sympathetic about plights of Biharis, be sympathetic about Bengalis near your home too.
Their ancestors did not shed blood for Bangladesh, instead joined hands with the enemy. They REFUSED to be called Bangladeshi until not very long, but only after it became clear that Pakistan wouldn't take them (yes, they wanted pakistani citizenship).
@Ammar Alam nahi. People of Pakistan and Bangladesh are highly radicalised with religious hate. They can't live in coexistence. Innkay sath koi bhi dusray religion k log nahi rah sakte because they are brainwash population because of their religious Insecurities and they know how they became muslim. So basically muslim of india pakistan Bangladesh try to be muslim+ 10% to hide religious Insecurity. So if they come back to religion of their forefathers then we can live together and their insecurity will end. Or they will self implod
@Ammar Alam thats because you are a good human being but not all muslims think like that majority thinks the non-muslims are kaffirs an they should be converted or killed because Islam teaches hate
jisy ap support keh rahy ho wo aisy hi jesy ap kisi hindu ko krty hain jo duniya k kisi b kony ma hi q na ho. ap na rakhien un hinduon sy hmdardi phir un ko kehna ko pakistan sy hmdardi krna bangla logun ka jurm ha
They still support pakistan?? How do you know?? Pakistan did use them and their fear over inter-racial riots. Then just left pretending to be clueless. They were interested to settle in pakistan as they didn't have citizenship for a long period, which they have now. Same is the case with bengalis stranded in pakistan.
@@cosmos2210 hum to hindu ummat nahi bolte. Na he "tera mera rishta kya la ilaha" Na he hum hindu republic hai. Tum converts k andar ka muslim+10% zyada chalta haina. Jab kashmiri k liya maray jaa rahay hoo to ye to Pakistan he hai jo Bangladesh mai phas gai hai
@@RajSingh-yd8ue tmhain hm ny tuo mana nai kiya ki hindu naary lagao ya hindu ko na umat bolo .this is your own choice .hm ek ha Alhamdulliah hmara la ila ka rishta ha hm kahien gy .ap ki takleef ki waja smjh nai aayi . ab ap ye sochty ho ki jesa ap kr rahy hain sb hi wesy q nai kr rahy tuo aisa kbi nai ho sakta ki sb apk hisab sy chalien so logic sy kam lyien zara.
One of my cousin is bihari. I didn't knew about this bihari meaning before watching this video.i used to think it's her title. But she have everything what i have as a Bangladeshi Citizen.
They supported and took part in the massacre of Bengalis in 1971.They are suffering for their dirty work in the past.They themselves are responsible for their present.
I think it was Indian Army who wear Pakistan Army uniform and did massacre, did rapes and looted many things and still some of politicians still now do blow job to Indian government. India never help Bangladesh without any profit. Bangladesh did help to India by giving transit to Indians, But India is still thinking to give transit to Bangladesh for Nepal and Bhutan. This unique friendship is only known as one friend is only taking advantages from another friend, that’s really very bad.
You know these Banaladeshi people got so filled in Assam. The government is not taking action against them, the whole of the North East is filled with Bangladeshi. 😢
I feel very sad and disgust€d that my ancestors did not ask for full partition. Used to lick pissfuls feat until i read their books. I don't want my motherland India to get another partition but mark my words, it is coming soon. 😓
Jo Muslim Bhai log india me rah ke insecure or azaadi nai rakhte aisa sochate hai o log iss vlog ko jaroor dekhna chahiye our unko proud hona chahiye ki o India me rahte hai 😊
I feel very sad and disgust€d that my ancestors did not ask for full partition. Used to lick pissfuls feet until i read their books. I don't want my motherland India to get another partition but mark my words, it is coming soon. 😓
Apne sai kaha Kash mere ajdad bhi Uttar Pradesh chor k Pakistan na jaty 💔 ye batwara karwa kar Urdu Hindi bolne wale sab logo ko barbad kardia or me khud indian Muslims ko kehti hu k achi bat hy k ap india me he rahy kahi or nahi hay or ap Hindu muslim log mil k raho india me please laro mat 🙏
I know a good number of Bihari people living in Bangladesh, they are living very normal life here. They built their life and made wealth and living happily with their family among us.
@@AfridiBD but your country will be safe and prosperous for next 100 years after that. BD can be prosperous only when bangla people won't let it's Bangali culture away. As indian I know bangali people are very good at education. But these people will put big amount of pressure on you guys. Your govt should tell arabs and turks to take these people. National intrest should be first.
@@AfridiBD always welcome bro, don't expect any good thing from pakistan, they didn't gave equal rights to muhajirs. You can see what happened to Karachi, they are not giving anything to baloch people too. They are still stuck in medieval times. They even destroyed beautiful modern Afghanistan. These days pakistani reaction channels trying to get soft corner in Bangla people. But in reality are jealous of you progress and economy. I hope one day Bangladesh nepal India Myanmar Thailand will be connected by roads and will form South Asian union with economic prosperity and technology development. We in rajasthan hear about malmal of dhaka a lot from our elders, I hope it will be back in market, your country proved everyone wrong who doubted you guys. You guys are leader in textile, ship repairing, jute production etc. You guys need just need to make population policy and infrastructure. You guys have great potential but please don't let pakistanies to influence your youth and distrub your harmony. Wish for prosperous BD. It will benifit both India and BD. Tread is very important and also education.
@@AfridiBD brother we hindus don't hate muslims, for example we have daudi Bohras here, nicest people, always contribute to country, naver create controversy and practice Islam and never make fun of other religions or target other religions. Same with 90% Shias, big section of educated muslims also don't anything bad about Islam. But Ashraf of our Muslim community still thinks like they are descendents of Mughals and arabs and their heart always beat for pakistan. All those years they made fun of hindus and sikhs, but now our community is getting frustrated and start doing tit for tat, because of foolish ashraf of muslim community, hindus are getting radicalised and it's not good for our country. These rich muslim leader don't care about getting people radicalised because their own family members study abroad and live life king size. I'm concerned about my community won't listen anyone if these polictal parties and leaders don't take it seriously.
I am bihari boy my born kolkata I love my kolkata I love Hindu Bengali Punjabi bhai log bahut accha hota hai Bengali Hindu bhai bahut accha insan hota hai koi dharam affect nahi larta peglhle insan samajtha hai 👏👏👏👏👏👏
Apke coments to bhut ache hote h, but when election come , maximum people vote for party who want division, like last election AIMIM wins 5 seats in Bhihar, same 1946 election, if muslim leage not win the election, partition will not happened, since muslim leage win election for making promise of Pakistan, & the common people of indian subcontinent suports it,
Abey chutiye yeh dharam ki baat nahi hai yeh langueage ki baat hai. I am a hindu bengali from kolkata and i would never accept hindi as a national langueage of INDIA.
I am bengali Muslim and I never knew about their existence. I have mixed feelings about this people. I feel like if this people gets another chance just like 1971 they will repeat their past mistake once again.
Now they have pent up anger inside. Way more than 1971 as that was a different case. So yes, u r right, give them a chance and they will surpass their 1971 achievements!
They will definitely do it. These Bihari and UP Muslims do think they are superior to Bengali Muslims. I am Bengali Hindu I have seen this in West Bengal though they don’t feel the same for Bengali Hindus I don’t know why. They also don’t mix with the Bengali Muslims as much as they do with Bengali Hindus. Probably because they are racist and thinks Bengali Muslims to be dark and inferior to them. One of my cousins friends rejected a Bengali Muslim for marriage only because he was Bengali and ended up marrying a Gujarati Muslim who was not even 1/10th rich like the Bengali Muslim she rejected.
@@ManabDasiammanab see now it's not about the religion. It doesn't matter if you are Hindu or Muslim or maybe Christian, Buddhist... It really doesn't matter. People hates what they want to hate. We Bengali ppl are looked down all over the world. They take us as a small fly. I hope there are more understanding Hindu's like you in Bengali community.
Inlog ko Bihari mat bolo. Bihari deshbhakt hote hen. Ye pahle Bharat se deshdroh kie, aur Pakistan banaae. Phir baad me Bangladesh se deshdroh kar ke Pakistan kaa saath dia. THESE PEOPLE ARE NOT BIHARIS THESE PEOPLE ARE TRAITORS.
@@muhammadmohaiminulislam7189 deshdroh means breaking your country. Bihar still has 16% muslim population, and its same as before independence. Why only a handful of them left for Porkistan? Why not rest? Wasn't there any threat to them? Even if suppose there was threat, there places in Bihar where Muslims were in majority (many pockets in Patna, Katihar, Gaya, Nalanda, Madhubani), even today Kishangunj has 75% muslim population, they could have gone there, but they chose to go to Pakistan. They were unfaithful to Bihar and India. They are unfaithful to Bangladesh too. The faithful muslims are even today in Bihar.
@@rcb1786 People did return to some extent, when hindu extremists cooled down, which you can see in this video too. People always look for a safer place and don't really like to get killed for a cow. Also, you too are traitors for breaking out of britain. We bangladeshis (not the biharis) are also traitors for breaking out of pakistan etc. According to your logic of course.
@@muhammadmohaiminulislam7189 btw I would conclude with one final statement, MA Jinnah is responsible for the disturbance that the subcontinent has witnessed since 1940s. His whole concept of a separate Muslim nation was flawed. The muslims and Hindus of Bengal have more common things than Hindus or Muslims of Bengal and Punjab. He fell into the words of extremists and took a wrong stand. (Which he himself later accepted, and told that he wants to return to India). Because of this partisan both Muslims and Sikhs/Hindus were killed in large numbers. Bengalis had to suffer for 30 years. And these (Biharis of BD) people are still suffering.
@@rcb1786 Maybe Jinnah was responsible to some extent. But riots weren't new, started during british period. Your view of justice is based solely on hindu supremacy, where anything that benefits that ideology is good and all others are bad. People want security but with freedom. Even a gang of robber doesn't harm anyone who abide by. That's not what people want. Jinnah was successful because muslims didn't feel safe for some reasons. After incidents like cow lynching , people being burnt for not chanting "jay shree ram" muslims will incline more towards Jinnahs decision and regret being an indian. Definitely you'd like muslims to just leave their ancestral land only for hindus OR denounce islam accepting all the demands made by hindus. But that's not going happen. Everyone wants safety, everyone has to live.
You have heard that it is a camp (Jeneva Camp) that they wanted to leave for Pakistan. According to the Geneva Convention, they were listed to leave Bangladesh after Liberation War. But the Pakistani Govt. did not take them and since then they were living here. They supported Pakistani armies and did not want to stay in Bangladesh. Still, they were living in this camp though Bangladesh Govt gave them other places to stay, but they do not want to go there. Now a day many of them got Bangladeshi nationality, but they do not believe or are loyal to Bangladeshi nationality.
Brother, 1.5 crore Biharis live in Bangladesh. They speak Bengali so they don't have any problem. There are many Biharis in my village too. There are many Bihari cities in North Bengal. But Bihari of the Geneva camp is different. They literally support Pakistan in the 1971 Bengali genocide. They still don't want to speak Bengali. Directly supports Pakistan. They celebrate when Pakistan wins a cricket match. They even celebrate Eid according to Pakistani time. How will the Bangladeshis support them? If they don't want Bangladesh. Bangladesh government also showed kindness and gave them citizenship. But Bengalis in Pakistan are still treated as fourth class people.
Bro, how can you force your language on them absolute non sense, bihari will and should support Urdu not bengali, understand they support Pakistan and didn't wanted to break way from there bcz they were afraid they will losse their language once east Pakistan seperate and this is what you are saying.. Sad but I am punjabi will not force a non punjabi to speak it
@@divyanshbatra8859 are bhi, tumhe history pata nehi hai,or kuch v bol rahe ho! En Loko ki hal serf language ka liya nehi hai,,,, accha se history janlo, e lok rajakar hai, kitna arto ko baltkar Kiya! kitna Bengali people ko khun Kiya tumhe pata hai,,,,?avi vi e lok Bangladesh ko dil se Manta hi nehi! Bangladesh Jane ki vi jarurat nahi west bengal me aj jaw enka history pata chala jayaga dost
@@divyanshbatra8859 ye log bengali ko jabardasti urdu sikha rahe the rajakar gang banakr rape karte the bengali aurat ka uska khamiaja hai ye. Yadi tumhare baap dada pap karenge to bhugtoge tum hi yahi duniya ka wasool hai. Tum punjabi mota dimag ke log ho. Bihari muslim india mein bhi Pakistan ki jeet pr patakhe fodte hain.
@@divyanshbatra8859 they supported pakistan at their young age....because of them thousands of bengali people murdered and some had to leave bangladesh and lived their live in the streets of kolkata.... They are living good life brother
@@divyanshbatra8859 No 1.5 crore bihari people live only a very few 5-8 lakh people live in Bangladesh. This man is foolish. In Bangladesh 15 crore bengali muslims live along with alomst 3crore bengali hindus & these biharis only amount to almost close to 8lakhs only.
They are suffering because of there karma in 1971. That time they had supported Pakistani army and joined with them to kill bangali people. Also they had killed many more intellectual Bangladeshi people. Still they are supporting Pakistan. Still they try to raise Pakistani flag in special day..
In Puran Dhaka, there are the old ethnic people who call themselves Kuttis (there's a legend that they used to cut dhaan (dhaan kutna) so they came to be called kuttis). Kuttis speak in Hindustani amongst themselves. They're a legacy community of the old Nawabs and Mughal Subedars, who brought their own administrative people to Medieval Dhaka. If you walk in the streets of Old Dhaka you'll hear many people conversing in Hindustani. So aside from Biharis, they are the only other Hindustani speakers in Bangladesh, I believe. There are other Urdu speaking communities in Chittagong and Sylhet too, but I don't know much about them.
Being a Bihari Muslim and Watching this from Danapur... And remembering Maulana Abul Kalam Azad "Tum Hijrat Ke Muqaddas Naam Pe Farar Ki Zindagi Guzaroge. " They shouldn't have migrated. India would embrace them too.
Bhai aaj Gandhi jee ka yaad agaya....what a visionary person our father of the nation was.....Hindu Mushlim sikh Christian sab milke iss desh ko balanced kar ke rakha he.....Proud to be Indian...
Bengalis are moving to the same fate, maximum bengali's are woke and act as pseudo liberals, there will be time when bengal will have Shariah-law due to their extra wokeness and i hope I am wrong but it's looking like that.
It's a great lesson for all. Under any circumstances, you should not leave your original mother land. In India Muslims enjoy the same rights like other citizens. There is no discrimination on religious ground. That is the beauty of Indian democracy. And Your identity shouldn't be based on religion, it should be based on your birth place. The so called exponents of Pakistan actually cheated the common people .
Im an urdu speaking person and my family roots are indian and i live in dhaka. What i wanna clear here is that the people you are watching in this video are some unsuccessful and lazy people who still after 52 years are stuck at the same place, and its not true that we are treated badly here. Totally false, after 1971, my father had the opportunity to leave the country but instead he lived here and worked hard and become successful and today we as a financial condition are in a good place and we are living our lives the way people are supposed to live, I've seen no discrimination happening to myself anywhere and i have lots of Bangali friends too. My point is that people of Bangladesh (bangali) are very straightforward, the people in the video are those who themselves haven't accepted this country as a bangladesh, instead of working hard they complain, they blame the government, they have thousands of excuses. Believe me the government are not the reason why they are in this situation but they are the one who choosed to live this kind of life.
Thanks for speaking out the truth. We are a family of freedom fighters. But my aunt got married to a Bihari. He is very successful in his career. I can't remember, we have ever behaved disrespectfully to him bcz of his race. I feel so shocked to see these people of geneva camps malign Bangladesh in every video. I don't think we deserve this betrayal. Are we supposed to offer them free apartments?
Proud to be indian muslim................ Love 💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖 my india . proud to be our indian constitution. Love you Gandhi ji neheru ji proudly say they give aur our right in constitution................. Jai Hind hai Bharat.Love you ❤️😘😘😘😘❤️❤️😘❤️❤️🇮🇳💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪 indian muslim jai hind jai bharat.
Bahut bahut sukriya mere dada aur baki khandan walon ka jo by birth aur by choice v hindustani rahe. Bahut khuskismat hai hmlog jo bharat jaisa pak sarjmin pe rah rahe m proud Indian muslim. Jai hind jay bharat
I feel very sad and disgust€d that my ancestors did not ask for full partition. Used to lick pissfuls feat until i read their books. I don't want my motherland India to get another partition but mark my words, it is coming soon. 😓
Pure hindu hate ...... Koi soch bhi nahi sakta yaha par hindu bhi reh rahe honge.... India me the to hindu se dikkat ..... pakistan me the to west pakistan se dikkat ...aaj bengladesh me hai to waha bhi dikkat.... But manana padega dedication poori hai abhi bhi hindu ko kuch bole Bina baat poori nahi karenge
*Elderly Bearded Guy expressed very heartwarmingly* 😔 *Politics & Politicians are reason for all this chaos, even Bangladeshis are in India, who are not treated well* 🥺
When is India and Pakistan to realise that it is the ethnicity that matters more than anything else? Nehru and company racked havoc on mother nature which is considered as a cause of celebration.
Pakistan and India then would be more different. Only 3% of Indians dhare ethnicity with Pakistanis, which include punjabis, Sindhis and Kashmiri’s. Other than that nobody in India does.
If you keep so much hatred in your heart, Such an outcome was bound to happen. First hatred towards India then hatred towards Bangladesh is responsible for their present situation. Until they are able to leave this hatred from their minds, they will not improve.
They Were Patriot Pakistanis, they were Aware of *Agartila Conspiracy* That's Why they Didn't Support Mukti Bahini, but after the Independence Of Bangladesh they brutally Tortured by Mukti Bahinis & Awami League. But Still Living in Bangladesh.
Don't you dare say anything about our anthem. What the fuck is Pakistan!!! A country whose name was coined out not even hundred years back!! Bangladesh has given citizenship to all those stranded Pakistan lovers.. What the fuck have you done to the stranded Bangalees in karachi?? Or do you even know about them?? Your anthem's language even a fucking mixture of different other language and you try to undermine ours'!! What a crapbag!!
@@shazainbaloch2538 those men worked with Pakistan and America to revolt and create a genocide in Bangla land but at last 90,000 of them surrendered and Pakistani had to get their arse off Bangla 🤣🤣 This is not hiduvta history. This is REAL history, I know Pakistanis are delusional but just accept your ancestors miserably failed 🤣🤣
@@shazainbaloch2538 shazain u r everywhere on tube. I wish a Bangladeshi gifts u his seed forcibly. Will wait for ur reply THEN . Danda hi chalega tere case me , Bangla Bangladeshi ka. Sab samajh jayegi. Jhoothi r kamzarf beghaiarat orat ha tu. Ho jaye teri drilling , agartala likhna seekh badzaat orat. Aur seekh kar bhool ja conspiracy wonspiracy.
These Biharis showed their loyalty towards Pakistan and even fought against the muktibahini during 1971. The Pakistanis abandoned them after the liberation of Bangladesh. This they will never say.
Bangladeshi Biharis all originated from Bihar, now a state of India. When they were Pakistanis, we Bengalis were too. Now it's Bangladesh, we all are Bangladeshis. None of the Biharis are from West Pakistan or current-day Pakistan.
Lakin may ya vhi manta ho ki en logo ko pakistan na vhi nahi apnaya hala ki en logo ka purvaj 1947 may india sa migrate hoka pakistan gaya fir vhi sala unlogo nahi apna mana en logo ko
May apna dada, nana sabi pariwar ka sukur gugar hu ki jo faisala un log na india yaniki apna desh may hi rahana faisala sahi kiya tha warna hum logo ka hal vhi en logo jsisa hota
Our regional history is confusing... When I was a kid I was in Malda anyone speaking hindi was called HINDUSTANI there.... and hindi speaking muslims were known as Bihari Musalmaan ( which is not a fact bcz any non bengali will speak hindi) at that time no Google so locals in East unable to imagine beyond Bihar as mostly influx in kolkata from Bihar only.
@@w27_offical bhai... Phle urdu chore, Bengali festival celebrate kre.... Sb log accept krenge..... Pr vo krenge nhi shayad... Unko lgta hai ki vo superior hai like pakistani
@@SHIVAMYadav-pw5uz In logo ko to pakistan na vhi nahi apnaya aaj tak kuki ya log manta hai ki sab india sa migrate hoka aya hai,,,soho agar hum India Muslim migrate karka jata to wo log yaniki pakistani bangaleshi hum kabi nahi apnata kuki simple reason of migration from india
I feel very sad and disgust€d that my ancestors did not ask for full partition. Used to lick pissfuls feet until i read their books. I don't want my motherland India to get another partition but mark my words, it is coming soon. 😓
Please represent the full picture, along with appropriate background. Those who left India during Partition are not Indians, please don't use the term Indians in Bangladesh. The crux of the problem is, they are not Bengalis, and they were the ones who were hand in glove in trying to destroy Bengali Identity along with the Pakistanis. The case of Bihari Muslims in Bangladesh cannot be even compared with the situation of Muhajirs in Pakistan. In erstwhile East Pakistan, a very large section of Bihari Muslims were enthusiastic participants of socio-economic ostracization and ethnic cleansing of Bengalis. They had been hand-in-glove with the brutal Pakistani regime which wanted to destroy Bengali culture, literature and identity. In fact a very large section of them were the 'Razakars' or willing perpetrators of crimes against humanity initiated, sustained and executed by the Pakistani Regime. They wanted to usurp the land, property and wealth of not only Hindus but ethnic Bengali Muslims during the freedom struggle of Bangladesh (Muktijuddho). But when the tables turned and Pakistanis fled Bangladesh with tails between legs, the Bihari Muslims in Bangladesh faced the heat and were systematically and effectively sidelined. Essentially, their karma hit back on them.
Bhai ye 1947 me Pakistan ka support karke Lakho Hindu ko mara... kolkata ke sath sath kai jagah par Hindu ko kat dala....or chale gye pakistan....fir jab 1971 Muslim ka Aapas (Urdu muslim - Bengali Muslim) me war huaa....Tab suffer Hinduo ko karna padta tha....me 3 saal se kolkata me rahta hu...mere Owner Ke koi relative Bangladesh se the .... unhone mujhe btaya .....ye Pakistani ( urdu-bengali) Aapse me Lad rhe the ....Tab war ke time Bangladesh me ...koi Urdu wale ko Hindu milta to wo usko maar dete.....same koi Bengali Muslim ko Hindu milta to wo bhi usko maar dete the.....ye sale peacefull community wale Aapas me Lad rhe the ......us time 1971 me ...Lakho Bangladeshi Hinduo ko apna ghar chod ke..... Tripura Assam or WB me aana pada tha....ye koi innocent nahi hai.....
@@Ankitsingh11857 this is bonafide nonsense. It is true that in 1947, due to extreme polarization Hindu Muslim riots happened in Bengal. But whoever says, during 1971 Bengali Muslims killed Bengali Hindus, is an utter rascal. Infact, such was the momentum, that Mujibur Rahman (bangabandu) had planned a politico-social path for secular Bangladesh. But, he and his entire family was killed (except for Sheikh Hasina) and Bangladesh descended into the path of hardliners. In fact, it was one more blunder of Nehru's, to not have been able to support the nascent Bangladesh and protect its progressive goals.
@Śrīhaṭṭa Vaiśvānara please be mindful of language. Yes there were few bengalis in razakar group, but it was Pakistani and Bihari Muslims that primarily led the onslaught. Please don't try to be an armchair specialist without knowing ground realities and facts. Moreover your unrefined, semi civilized way of communicating tells a lot about your thought process....
@@Ankitsingh11857 lund kuch kar paya in bihari mullo ne kolkata mein danga start karkey kuch bihari aur oriya labour hinduo ko mara tha phir bangali hinduo ke upper caste ne inko kolkata me kat daley 15000-18000 ke taidat mein isliye baki 5 lakh darkey purvi bangal bhagey jan bachaney ke liye kyuki wo purvi pakistan banney wala tha.
even though theres some bad history, its natural for you to feel some sort of pity and empathy for these people..after all we are the same people from the same land..so no matter what a guilt resides.. u see a similarity..a lost similarity..hand full of bangladeshis feel the same way i assume when they meet bangals in west bengal.
Bangladesh kisliye gye the.... Aur jb tum Bangladesh k nhi hue 1971 m pakistan k support kiye the..... Bihari muslim isse jada acche se h... Main bihar se hu, mere bhut muslim friends h....
@@abdulgaffarchowdhury5255 Politics Kaun kar raha hai? Wahan k log Agar inko accept kar le to phir government kyun nahi accept karegi?. Sach yehi ki wahan k local log inhe abtak accept nahi kiye hain..Jaisa ki Pakistan me abhi bhi bahut sare Muslims jo ki partition k time pe wahan gaye the unko Pakistani ne accept nahi kiya..Aaj bhi wahan waise Muslim Muhajir keh k gaaliyan dete hain.
@@siddharthverma2849 Bro, These Muslim Biharis killed many bengali hindus in 1971 for supporting Pakistani Mulk. They even formed paramilitary for this. Now They are hated by every Bangladeshi for their past deed which is normal.
@@starboxrock9133 Fine..Here too severe communal riots took place at the time of partition and even after that..But we have moved forward..Now we don't keep that hatred feelings..Those people who had supported the Pakistan during the time of Bangladesh formation must have died by now..Why the people of Bangladesh and their government are punishing their grandchildren.. What mistakes they have done.They were born in independent Bangladesh ...They are natural born Bangladeshi citizens...They must get all the rights available in their country.
British included Odisha in Bengal for their administrative purpose or else Odisha was separated prior to that hence saying Bihar n Odisha culturally n historically part of Bengal is totally wrong n lack of knowledge about history.
@@bhoomika7572its their fault because they caused many attrocities against bengalis You have to thank the Bengalis for not commiting the same to the biharis
In 1971, after facing years of discrimination from West Pakistan, the region of East Pakistan declared independence as Bangladesh. The declaration led to the Bangladesh Liberation War, during which many Biharis either supported or joined the Pakistani army's efforts to maintain Pakistan's territorial unity, including committing significant atrocities against Bengali nationalists. However, after Bangladesh achieved independence, many Bangladeshis viewed Biharis as traitors, and the Pakistani government agreed to only allow a small percentage of Biharis to resettle in Pakistan. The rest of the Bihari community was forced to live in slum-like "camps" in Bangladesh, where they have remained since 1971.
I am from Bangladesh (Chittagong). The report touched my heart! It is really moving. Not a single life should be neglected/ deprived due to political reasons. All those people are the fabric of our community, they are part of Bangladesh. They government should fully recognise them as our valued citizens so that they could shine & thrive to their full potential. It is heartbreaking to see their living condition. They choose to live here , they love Bangladesh. We can’t live with the long gone and resolved past!
For your kind information, these people get free electricity, free ration, which is NOT offered to average Bengali citizens. They were offered BD citizenship by Sheikh Mujib in 1972. They refused and hoped that Pakistan would repatriate them. Pak didn't repatriate them. BD again made them citizen in 2008. It's not that BD govt don't allow them to stay outside camp. They simply don't want to pay rent and get a better accommodation. They don't want to give up the free facilities they get in those camps. What do you expect BD govt to do? Give them free apartments? Funny thing is, Sheikh Hasina actually announced that she will build apartments for them. Yet these traitors will vote against Hasina, criticize Bengalis day and night. Look at their hatred against us. They brutally murdered and raped us in 1971. Bengalis stuck in Pakistan are not offered citizenship. Both Bengalis and Biharis are Muslims. If you are sympathetic about plights of Biharis, be sympathetic about Bengalis too.
These people accepted Pakistan as their country , Not Bangladesh , they actively participated against the Independence Fight of Bangladesh, They Assisted Pakistani Forces in 1971 , They refused to Accept Bangladeshi Citizenship until 10-15 years ago , instead wanted to go to Pakistan. BD is kind enough to offer them shelter , even Bangladeshi Citizenship.
What do you mean by these people?
Were they there when muktijuddho happened to take active participation against it?
Probably they were not even born or were children.
Past should not be carried forward to such an extent that it feels that the oppressed oppress more than the earstwhile oppressors.
Kabi kabi sochtaa hai kia jo mil gya inhe new new desh bana ka chaya wo Nepal ho chya srilanka chaya pakistan chaya Bangladesh chaya burma
A to z sare desh lagbhag bankrupt ho chuke hai....mayanmar ma apna ma lar rha hai....
Bangladesh ka halat dekh hi rha ho aur aaj hi uska foreign minister na India sa help mangi hai economy bachana ja lia....
Srilanka to yrr covid ka karanchla gya
Pakistan ka baat hi nirala hai...
Nepal to chlo India kabi kuch nai hone dega usko
Bs ek Bhutan acha kaam kar rha lkin aaj bhi Indian army bhutan ki border pa pehra de rai to bhai akhir kia hasil kar liya , toot ke
Hindustan naam ma hi feel aa jata hai hamlog zero sa aaj kitta upar paunchna wala hai 3rd largest economy by 2030 now at 5th....Chlo karma is bitch aaj mehsus ho rha hoga....India ka value
@@debanshub916 if they leave islam, then they should be accepted.. Else get ready for riots.
@@debanshub916 Yeah but they want to go to Pakistan. They should be allowed do enjoy the status of Mohajirs in Pakistan.
Agree with you
They betrayed with their homeland (India) in 1947. They betrayed with Bengalis in 1971. Worked for Pakistani Army. They supported and helped Pakistani Army in 1971. Then after Independence of Bangladesh, Pakistan betrayed with them. Left them here. This is called karma.
And an important thing you missed that this camp is called Geneva camp under the Geneva Convention (for war presoners). All the Bengali Razakar who helped Pakistani Army to kill or torture Bengalis in 1971, had to face trial for war crime. These people under Geneva Convention didn’t have to.
Homeland us one which is prophisized by last prophet a Muslim state with digital weapons. I think u didn't study about Islam focus more on these things...
1400 years ago Muslims of that time can also live under bannu quresh but Allah wants from Muslims to establish Islam as a state religion.. If you are not struggling to do this ND wanna. Live under hindus rules then change you name as well ND Marry a hindus.. Allah don't need anyone one..
@@nehaasharijit6523 अल्लाह कुछ नही केवल पोपट की कल्पना मात्र है जब पोपट को अपनी इक्छा पूर्ति करनी होती तभी उस पर आयते उतर आती थी
Gadari ki saza milni he chaeya. What pakistan did in 1971 is inhuman
Ekdom thik bolechen bhai. Even paxtan call them muhajir now they are hated everywhere.
Bengalis are the people who rejected 'urdu' unlike punjabi, sindhi. Salute to all our bengali brothers who are proud of their language and culture .
sindhi , balochi also reject pakistan
@@shubradeepde7417 its your dream, these Biharis are still loyal to pakistan after everything and you think Sindhis and baluchis would be disloyal to pakistan? And pakistan did accept bangla as national language in 1965 but east pakistan kept demanding more autonomy until the war happened.
@@songoku3716 yes I think because we saw fight between sindhi vs pathan , shia vs sunni and sindhi muhajir , pathan vs muhajir ethnicity problem are there and same like balochistan need freedom .
@@shubradeepde7417 there will be some fight here and there between different groups, same as in india with Punjabis, Tamils etc but the fact of the matter is Pakistan is still one of the most patriotic countries on the planet with 95% willing to die for their country in their recent survey.
@@songoku3716 there is no fight tamil , Punjabi in India .. There is no problem like ethnicity , shia sunni in India . but little bit problem between Hindu vs Muslim but they live together .they study together , they go to school together, they go to job together . i study in kolkata . there are so many Muslims student and teacher in my college . they live together , they eat together
The Biharis in Bangladesh have been sufferings for the sins which their predecessors did during Liberation War in 1971. How do you comment in favour of them without knowing history?
Unfortunately the muslim biharies supported Pakistan during 71 war, not Bangladesh or bangalis, this is why they were suffering today. Bangalis wanted independence from brutal Pakistani rule and their hatred of bengali language, yet the Biharies wanted to be with Pakistan because of Urdu language
Not Bihari. But the Muslims who lived in Bihar long ago.
Cry about it lol
@@Deira854 they still follow islam first then nation.
Biharis are now taking over west bengal look at howrah chadni chowk new market barabazaar area no bengalis all biharis.
in 1971, this community acted as Razakar & Al Badar, Joined hand with Pakistani army & mercilessly killed Bengalis irrespective of Hindu Muslims. Result is now visible.
Motiur Rahman Nizami and Mir Quasem Ali, both leaders of the Jamaat e Islami, were hanged to death in Dhaka jail in 2016 for war crimes during 1971.
Were they Biharis? Do you harrass THEIR family members like you harrass Biharis? Why don't you throw their family members into camps?
Why are you punishing the descendants of Biharis who were involved in 1971 violence? How can someone born AFTER 1971 be held responsible for what happened then?
Great work Bishnu! I am a Bangladeshi and know some about the "Bihari"s, but this is the first time I am learning about them from their own authentic source. Really good......
You cannot take on side without knowing the brutal history. These Bihari( Pakistani) tortured Bangladeshi people till 1971. Still Bangladeshi government has given them citizenship of this country. Think about those Bengali people how has stuck in Pakistan if you compare then Behari must be in better position. Behari people still believe they're not Bangladeshi.
Why did these people didn't move to Pakistan after 1971?
@@bobghosh8313 They wanted to. Pakistan didn't accept them.
@@pajiitslayer6042 but they left Bihar (India) because of ur great Godfather Jinnah and went to east Pakistan that is Bangladesh at present. Some of them still today wants to go to Pakistan but fate had other plans.
And stop abusing me brother. What is Ganges breed ?? We all are humans . At least show some humanity for these people. They already have suffered too much. Don't try to find religion in everything like Jinnah did.
@@bobghosh8313 ganges breed means people who are native to banks of ganges simply has nothing to do with religion. West pakistan is not for people native to ganges plains its only for people native to indus river plains. so simply that is the reason they are not allowed in pakistan. either they should go back to bihar or beg bangalis to accept them as they are genetically most similar to bengalis and are muslim like bangladeshis
@@pajiitslayer6042 These Biharis joined Pakistan and were loyal to Pakistan and this is the answer they get from a third generation Pakistani?
They are descendents of rajakar bahini who helped the pakistani army by all means to oppose the independence of 🇧🇩Bangladesh. The tortured and killed many bengali. Dharmandh muslim behari in the name of religion devide the country. They may gladly go to Pakistan (their dream land) to live a Royal life. Why they are still living in Bangladesh? They are pakistani not bangladeshi. Joy Bangla.
Bihar and bangal was part of bengal sultanate before palassy and baxer ....they are same austroasatic race people !!!! This this British classification is true!!! Bihar jharkhand bengal odisha and Assamese bangla are same people
@@rehanansari009 bro stop spamming
@Sunil Chahal these peaceful communities never fails to spread peace all around 🤣😂
@@NareshCK001 রাজাকার ত্রিবিদ রায় চাকমা এর বংশধর??
@Sunil Chahal they supported pakistan at their young age....because of them thousands of bengali people had to leave bangladesh and lived their live in the streets of kolkata
Thanks God my ancestors migrated from East Bengal ! I'm a Hindu Bengali and proud.
@@mrkps1986 false....
Atleast have 3 kids & put effort in making india a hindu isreal Or No Use of Being Proud
@@sanatanidaliturfkafireazam5726 Orr peda karo....tum sub ko Islam kabool karwange Gazwa E Hind k baad 💪🏻☪️
@@jihadi-against-oppression Beta Baap ko Bhul gaye shivaji raje
Teri Sari betiyan de dega tab bhi Convert nahi honge hamare log
~Shambhaji maharaj
Ab to bas Bhagwa e Prithvi ka Wait karo
@@sanatanidaliturfkafireazam5726 bhag Yaha se Lindu 😂
Hi Vishnu, from your name felt that you are a Bengali by birth but may have stayed outside Bengal for long. The Hindi you speak is far cleaner than most Bengalis. Realised that you are not much clued in on history. You repeatedly kept on saying partition took place in 1971. There wasn't any partition in 1971. Undivided India got divided into India and Pakistan in 1947 (when both these countries achieved independence). This is what is known as partition. Pakistan had two portions one called West Pakistan (the present day Pakistan) and the other was called East Pakistan (the present day Bangladesh). In 1971 East Pakistan broke away from Pakistan and became an independent country called Bangladesh. This is the most basic information you should have known before visiting Bangladesh.
While most Hindus from the newly formed Pakistan (from both East and West) moved into India, a large section of the Muslim population from western & northern India crossed over to western side of Pakistan while those from UP, Bihar, Bengal and Assam crossed over to eastern side of Pakistan. As in India where we have a large mix of languages, both sides of Pakistan also has a mix (the number of languages are not as many as in India) of languages. However today Urdu is the national language of Pakistan though Punjabi is also a very dominant language. Sindhi, Gujarati and Balochi are also spoken by large numbers. On the other hand Bangladesh was born on the lines of Bangla language and thus it has an overwhelming majority. This is where the non-Bengali Muslims find themselves stranded. Something their forefathers had not imagined.
Though you kept on hearing Hindi/ Urdu in some form or the other as you walked across the by lanes of Bihari Camp, a slightly more sensitive ear would have told you that these people now have a strong Bangla influence in their language. Most pronunciation sounded clearly Bangla.
Yes, you are right these people are not at fault. But the euphoria of partition caused untold havoc across the entire subcontinent leading to terrible bloodshed. The people who propagated the two nation theory on religious lines and called for Pakistan were all well read and very well off people. Neither they nor their immediate family suffered. They sat on the negotiation table and pushed for Pakistan, while influencing the larger masses at the lower end of the pyramid of a particular religion to join the call. The condition of these masses who were way down the ladder and crossed over to Pakistan are still in pitiable condition in fairly large numbers. Thus quite often we do hear an Indian Muslim thanking their forefathers for having decided to stay back in India and not crossed over.
Thank you for your explanation sir I am from Bihar and I was almost unknown of this side of the story.
Off course its their fault older age people supported pakistan in 1971 war...its their fault that they are neglected
Agreed.
What Vishnu did not show was that ALL these people can speak FLUENT Bengali.
Pakistan stabbed these people in the back.
Very well written thanks love 🇮🇳
Thanks man for the history
If you knew the whole story you would think twice about siding with them, they're Pakistani prisoners of war, that's why live in Geneva camp, their fathers were Indian citizens ,they're Pakistani citizens, their children and grandchildren are Bangladeshi citizen; it's an absolute mess, The UN protected them otherwise they would've been put on trial and hanged long ago
But in recent years an average Bengali speaking Bangladeshi is moving closer to Urdu speaking Pakistani.
Basically Bangladeshi love Pakistanis because of their common hate for Hindu Indians but also Bangladeshis hate Pakistan because of 1971 genocide.
You guys should decide if Muslim brotherhood holds more value or 1971 Pakistanis hate towards Bengalis.
@changu mangu lol who is learning Urdu again?😂 you meant Arabic? Bruv in our religion it is compulsory to learn Arabic as the scripts of Al Quran is written in Arabic. And we always speak in Bangla, Bangla is our mother tongue. Bangladesh is the only country where peoples sacrificed their lives for a language. We love our language so much that we gave our country's name after it (Bangla-Desh). Don't speak rubbish, get to know what the truth is at first
@@rudetosociety I think u have a problem in understanding English...he said u guys are getting closer to Urdu speaking Pakistani.who responsible for ur genocide.when did he said u guys are learning Urdu 😂😂??
@@shanu3588 getting closer to Urdu speaking Pakistani----- any prove?
yes closer because of muslim brotherhood not only for pakistan but also for all muslim in this world.. For 1971, pakistani new jenaration are not responsible for this..
Inke halat dekh kar lagta hai....humarae purbaz sahi kia...
As a bengali...Im happy in India.
Bangli gaddar ha chor ha
In 1971 war those Bihari Muslims support pakistan. We Bengalis from West BENGAL know that story 😡😡😡😡🤬🤬🤬🤬
Not only that, they had joined with Pakistani army to destroy Bangladeshi people. They had killed many more Bangladeshi people that time.
Right bro now government give him nationality
but eta ami jantam na.. ekhane discussion e janlam.
Their fault for supporting Pakistan
Yes , to a substantial extent true! Now , it's a fact that all were 'Pakistani citizens, including the Bengalis...part of East Pakistan ( earlier until 1961, East Bengal Province)! Well, many among them, expectedly, supported the state forces of Pakistan! Can u blame them entirely? The Dominions of India and Pakistan were created by British colonialists in 1947 ...not by the largely uneducated masses...the leaders Jinnah, Suhrawardy...and to an extent Nehru were responsible! Many of these joined those 'Razakar' forces, BUT not all were militants or responsible...many innocents were killed by the Bengali militia and mukti bahini also...for no fault of theirs! See, history is cruel and the British left a colony is such a way that they could have their influence over this region fr a long time! The state of ''Pakistan' was created immediately after WWII primarily as a 'bulwark' state by the Allied powers ( primarily GB and USA) to stop the then most powerful Soviet Union's expansionist aims of coming to South Asia to get a foothold on the Indian Ocean...this is to give a quick big pic of those decades in the last century!
Proud Indian Muslim from Jharkhand here
But They should left india your grandparents are cheater they cheated hindus first they demanded separate Islamic country and voted for pakistan but after taking pakistan they didn't go there while they should must go and now you people say that you want to live with hindus not with muslims I don't know why u ppl want to live with hindus why don't you go to pakistan or Bangladesh Just go there and fall in identity crisis
Nhi nhi India mein to buldozer chal rahe hain na muslim ke ghar par.😂
@@changumangu4660 😂
@@changumangu4660
He is shameless. Loves beating from his hindu masters
Brother, 1.5 crore Biharis live in Bangladesh. They speak Bengali so they don't have any problem. There are many Biharis in my village too. There are many Bihari cities in North Bengal. But Bihari of the Geneva camp is different. They literally support Pakistan in the 1971 Bengali genocide. They still don't want to speak Bengali. Directly supports Pakistan. They celebrate when Pakistan wins a cricket match. They even celebrate Eid according to Pakistani time. How will the Bangladeshis support them? If they don't want Bangladesh. Bangladesh government also showed kindness and gave them citizenship. But Bengalis in Pakistan are still treated as fourth class people.
They are not Indian either. They are Pakistani. They supported Pakistan during partition of India & in 1971 they supported Pakistan army
They mercilessly slaughtered bengalis, especially the Hindus... Mostly Albadr and Razakars were these biharis...they sided with the pakistani army...
I don't know why Delhi govt still supporting Rohingya refugees 😠😠🤨
@@ssn8817 liberals and others think of India as an intolerant society,.... Still the rohingyas want to enter India and interestingly, muslim leadership expects the govt. of India to accept them (in large numbers..). And the Ummah is doing just lip service.... Bangladeshis are fed up of their 5lakh rohingya refugees...
@@ssn8817 Delhi govt (KejriUddin)
@@sudipmallick7083 sahi pakde hain aap 😁😁😂
R8
These people helped pakistan army genociding bengalis. In pakistan they are called muhajirs, they fought against hindus while partition in 1947, in bangladesh, India as well as pakistan they are hated
no they are never hated . political issues doesn't means hate
Yes theses people helped Pakistan Army to remove 5000000 hindu of Bangladesh
@@cosmos2210 they helped pakistan killing bengali Muslims too.
@@cosmos2210 They are hated by India for leaving India, they are hated by Bangladesh for creating para military against Bengalis in 71 genocide and they are hated by Pakistanis which is why Pakistan call them Muhajirs.
@@starboxrock9133 do you even know the meaning of word muhajir ..ja k dictionary dekho. kon kehta ha ki muhajir haterd ma kaha jany wala word .
Is video ko dekh kar hume ek sikh milta hai hume apne desh k liye hamesha wafadar rehna chahiye
Jai hind 🇮🇳🥰
Don't try to over simplify problems. It's not only language. It's all what they did with Hindu and Bengali Muslims when Pakistan was controlling that land.
You are right.people don't know history.so people simplified the view. Ye Bihari na ghar ka na ghat ka.gaddari ki saja vugo
R8
Mr. Vishnu,
It is ok to not know history properly.
But after recording the video and before publishing, you should have researched about your content.
The bihari people migrated to EAST PAKISTAN in 1947.
When Pakistan army started massacring Bengalis in 1971, these biharis took side with Pakistan and formed para military force.
Along with Pakistani army,
These biharis massacred numerous bengalis.
Fortunately, (unfortunately for biharis)
Bangladesh got liberated.
But these biharis got into a huge problem.
The side they supported denied to take them to Pakistan.
And Bangladesh cannot keep these traitor and war criminals in our holy motherland.
So Bangladesh kept them in "Geneva camp" in hope that their country (pak) would retrieve them, which Pakistan never did.
They are called stranded Pakistani.
They killed our Bengali people in unimaginable ways.
Still our govt is kind enough that,
They were given Bangladeshi citizenship in 2008. Which is totally ironic because they still consider themselves Pakistani and they support Pakistan in Bangladesh vs Pakistan cricket match, even they wave Pakistan flag too!!!
The Bengali population that got stuck or willfully chose Pakistan after liberation war are still waiting for citizenship which Pakistan denying to give even when these bengalis loved and chose pyara pakistan! They are treated as second class citizen in pak.
These Pakistani biharis living in Bangladesh should be thankful to the god for what they achieved.
Yes
Have you ever kept yourself into their shoes, actual story is their ancestors fight and migrated for pakistan and many were killed including children and womens and many were seprated from their families but after getting Pakistan, bangladeshi people wanted their separate homeland (keep the reason aside) so in that scenario bihari supported pakistan for which they lost many lifes earlier and from their sights bangalis were wrong as they wanted to seprate their beloved country, if you were in their place what would you choose?
@@zeeshanahmed5943 I would put myself in the shoes of those Hindu Bengalis and marwadis who were fleeing to india for refuge in 1971.
Biharis along with Pakistani army killed 448 of them in a planned massacre at syedpur rail station just a few kilometres from India. (Golahat massacre)
I have zero sympathy for the biharis that took part in Bengali genocide alongside Pakistan army. They were not helpless they were active collaborators.
@@GoichoMakad There are many Bangladeshis in all parts of India
@@GoichoMakad they are not indian.
They came to east Pakistan in 1947 as the partition forced Muslims to migrate to Pakistan and hindus to india.
They are Pakistani, they wanted to remain Pakistani so that they participated in Bengali genocide in 1971.
But they failed.
But Pakistani government are not taking them to Pakistan. So they are called stranded Pakistani in Bangladesh.
It's a shame that their country (Pakistan) does not want to take them.
They live in heaven. On rent for home, no water bill, no electricity bill. Everything free!!!
Then why they are complaining so much??
@@MB1234-s4lThey want to be treated as VIPs.
@@hakunamatata3935 hmm
Danapur is in the patna district of bihar..
Inlogon ko bhi kuch jyaada hi shaukh tha apne muslims bhaiyon k sath muslim desh me rehne ka..
Nahi bro 😊 ye log Kolkata ke hai original bihar danapur ke hai magar partion ke time pakistan calegay
At 1999 world cup they support Pakistan against Bangladesh in Cricket 🏏. They brought flag of Pakistan and i'm the eye witness. Now imagine the rest of all.
How old are u
Mar kar jutay Pakistan bhayjo aaysay gadaro ko
I saw the world cup when Kapil Dev lifted that .
Muslims will always support for Muslims and it's obvious. Who is actually real Muslim he/she will never support injustice even that injustice comes from another person who belongs to the same religion.
Why you hate Pakistan.
The luckiest one are those who chose to stay in India , they got citizenship and are considered Indian, no one feels discrimination no matter what their roots are. India is such diverse country that everyone has it's own place.
Soon it will face another partition thanks to secularism against one particular community which is not a religion but a cult
@Shorot Personal if not heaven, atleast much better than Pakistan and Bangladesh .
You are living in a fool's paradise. The incidents I mentioned never happened in Bangladesh. Too bad for the misguided 2-Nation Theory. When Sarat Ch. Bose, Husein Suhrawardy, Kiran wanted undivided Bengal, Nehru, Patel sided with Hindu Mahashaba to divide Bengal and force partition. Gandhi, Maulana Azad however were against partition. Can't write the whole history here.
😂😂
But they also got 1993 Bombay riots and 2002 Gujarat riots which killed humanity in this world
There forefathers fought against us and joined with pak military. Now they stuck with their deeds. But Islam says, descendants aren't responsible for the misdeed of their forefathers. Bangladesh govt should give them nationality because they living here like citizens of Bengal. They are also human🥺
@Hafijur Rahman But they didnt forget pakistan, they still waves pakistani flags in pak vs Bangladesh match
humanism says, forget past, we have to live peacefully.
Humanity says so
Exactly my words. New generation don't deserve this. Humanity comes first.
They got citizenship back in 2008
Once u know the history you will not side with those Biharis
Jai hind🇮🇳
@Gandu Bojpuri still better then what Pakistani Army did And does
They are not bihari, and on what basis you can call them bihari? Because their ancestors was from bihar? They even not know about our culture, no one cares a about them.
It's on you that whatever you want to call them but not tell them Bihari.
@@arandomguy8978 they are Pakistani (By culture and Mentality )
@@sanatanidaliturfkafireazam5726 yaa
I am Bihari hindu . You are saying once you know the history u will not side with those bihari.
What Pakistani did with Bangladeshi before 1971 . All knows . Now Bangladeshi has lot of love for Pakistani. I saw the response of Bangladeshi in you ube . Then why cant bihari muslim be forgiven . You also fought with india in 1947 and separated but we don’t hate Bangladeshi. We think Bangladeshi as friendly nation . Did you watch Kolkata people response ‘when they were asked what you think about Bangladeshi’ . It was ❤. We respect and like you as neighbors. Don’t do this to Bihari Muslim . Give them respect that they deserve.
I know many Bihari people and 9 out of 10 people I know support Pakistan when Bangladesh plays against them in any sports.
There are many Bangladeshis stuck in Pakistan also, Biharis living in Bangladesh are living thousands times better life than Bangladeshis who got stuck in Pakistan. In fact most people in Bangladesh count Biharis as their own.
I'm also Bihari from SIWAN 🇮🇳. I'm proud Indian Muslim 🇮🇳🤗🥰...
@aseem hn bhai... Jaante hai.. ye logo ne 1971 PAK army ko support kia ... Or Pakistani army ne bahut julm kia tha Bengali par including r@p*s.. 😡 jo ki bahut galat hua
Par ... Abb mostly new generation hai... And now , i don't think they should be excluded from the mainstream ... !
Siwan Apna Gaon ❤️hai Currently I'm living in Bengal
@@rabindraaman7218 great...!
I am from Barharia... 😀😀
@@Khalid-fy6ib Gopalganj,Mirganj,Barharia,Siswan Ye Sab Jagha Ek Ke Baad ek apne log rehte hai Bahut miss karta hu.Kuch din pehle Aya ghumke.Nani Ghar,Mausi ka Ghar,❤️
@@rabindraaman7218 hn bhai Hamhu Delhi m raheni... Abhi 1 mahina rah k gainea wapas ...
Apna Bhojpuri 😀❤️
Unfortunately the muslim biharies supported Pakistan during 71 war, not Bangladesh or bangalis, this is why they were suffering today. Bangalis wanted independence from brutal Pakistani rule and their hatred of bengali language, yet the Biharies wanted to be with Pakistan because of Urdu language
I have always been curious about it, in mere 23 years(till 1971) Pakistan witnessed 4 Bengali Prime Ministers, 4 Bengali Presidents, 2 Bengali Chief Justice of the Supreme Court and 5 Bengali Speakers of the National Parliament, from what angle exactly was this 'brutal rule'?
@@ytv31 Fool everyone knows how Pakistanis were looting East Pakistan. Bengal became the poorest region because pakistani rule where famine was happening. Today after 50 years of independance. Bangladesh has 4 times strongest economy then Pakistan
@@Deira854 do tell me Sir if even one fact I stated above is a lie.
@@ytv31 Making someone prime minister doesn't mean Sh_it, we all know Bengali language and culture was being eliminated, they were being forced to accept Punjabi and Urdu culture, and add to that Famine was being created in East Pakistan, so average Bengalis would suffer and accept Pakistani rule. This is everywhere on the internet and even Ex PM Imran Khan just talked about this in his speech last week, go listen fool. And the amount rapes and killings that happened just before the 1971 war is very well documented
@@Deira854 putting to use a liberal dose of cuss words won't get you any scores here mate, my essential point being that Bengalis had absolutely dominated Pakistani polity in every sphere the entire time Bangladesh was it's part. With a record of 15 high level appointments in two decades, no other ethnic group on GOD's good earth will cry a river about systemic elimination and desolation.
If possible, please have a look at the lives of Bengalis stuck in Karachi. That should help you understand that these people are in a comparatively better state than stranded Bengalis in Pakistan.
Partition of India was the biggest blunder in history of the world.
@VIRAL SHORTS 🐖🐖💨💨🇵🇰🇵🇰
Mr Stupid they are far better than even Bengali of Bangladeshi. We don't have hasina goons....they are earning here freely
8:14
Vishnu - Aap kaise ho sir ?
Man - Aap kahan se ho ?
Vishnu - India se.
Man - India se ?? Sorry, Go away.
🥺🥺
That's why they are suffering... No one can save them
Joss😂😂
Chacha ji bol raha bengali's sab chin liya.. 1971 pe Pakistan bhi Bengalis ka bohot kuch chin liya tha
Pakistan ne Kya Chena??
Aur agr Cheena To uski Saza kya Inko mily gi???
Kya hum 71 ki wja se hinduoo ko qatal krde??
@@shazainbaloch2538 Pakistan ne kya cheena? Pakistan ne 3m people ko mara,women ko rap kiya..1952,1971 duno saal yaad rakna jo Pakistan ne Bangladesh ke saat kiya uski liye Pakistan abhi bhi maafi Nehi manga.... Aur app bol raha ho Pakistan ne kya cheena...
@@shazainbaloch2538For your kind information, these people get free electricity, free ration, which is NOT offered to average Bengali citizens. They were offered BD citizenship by Sheikh Mujib in 1972. They refused and hoped that Pakistan would repatriate them. Pak didn't repatriate them. BD again made them citizen in 2008. It's not that BD govt don't allow them to stay outside camp. They simply don't want to pay rent and get a better accommodation. They don't want to give up the free facilities they get in those camps. What do you expect BD govt to do? Give them free apartments? Funny thing is, Sheikh Hasina actually announced that she will build apartments for them. Yet these traitors will vote against Hasina, criticize Bengalis day and night. Look at their hatred against us. They brutally murdered and raped us in 1971. Those Pakistanis who are shedding crocodile tears for Biharis over here, you can try to do something for Bengalis stuck in Pakistan for a change. You can start by offering them citizenship. Both Bengalis and Biharis are Muslims. If you are sympathetic about plights of Biharis, be sympathetic about Bengalis near your home too.
@@memediaries9090400k women
Secondly, I would say Pakistan also didn't provide any support to Behari. They are equally responsible for this mess!!!
ये लोग निजामे मुस्तफा बनाने गये थे ... वहाँ बिहारी बने है सही है
😂😂😂😂😂😅
Thanks for this type of content 💖....
Love from Bangladesh 🇧🇩💖
Love from India too 💞♥️🇮🇳
#PaperManNatureLover
Why you can't accept these people?
Their ancestors did not shed blood for Bangladesh, instead joined hands with the enemy. They REFUSED to be called Bangladeshi until not very long, but only after it became clear that Pakistan wouldn't take them (yes, they wanted pakistani citizenship).
Partition had literally devastated millions of lives. Love nd brotherhood is the need of time.
Chup hoja unity ke pujaari, these sh!ts have chosen East Pakistan in the past and now they deserve this.
Bada shauk jaga thana Islamic republic ka.
@Ammar Alam nahi.
People of Pakistan and Bangladesh are highly radicalised with religious hate. They can't live in coexistence. Innkay sath koi bhi dusray religion k log nahi rah sakte because they are brainwash population because of their religious Insecurities and they know how they became muslim.
So basically muslim of india pakistan Bangladesh try to be muslim+ 10% to hide religious Insecurity.
So if they come back to religion of their forefathers then we can live together and their insecurity will end. Or they will self implod
@Ammar Alam thats because you are a good human being but not all muslims think like that majority thinks the non-muslims are kaffirs an they should be converted or killed because Islam teaches hate
Jee, sahi farmaya apne
Pakistan is expected to support them financially. Infact they choose Pak and still supports Pak
jisy ap support keh rahy ho wo aisy hi jesy ap kisi hindu ko krty hain jo duniya k kisi b kony ma hi q na ho. ap na rakhien un hinduon sy hmdardi phir un ko kehna ko pakistan sy hmdardi krna bangla logun ka jurm ha
They still support pakistan?? How do you know??
Pakistan did use them and their fear over inter-racial riots. Then just left pretending to be clueless.
They were interested to settle in pakistan as they didn't have citizenship for a long period, which they have now. Same is the case with bengalis stranded in pakistan.
@@cosmos2210 hum to hindu ummat nahi bolte. Na he "tera mera rishta kya la ilaha"
Na he hum hindu republic hai.
Tum converts k andar ka muslim+10% zyada chalta haina.
Jab kashmiri k liya maray jaa rahay hoo to ye to Pakistan he hai jo Bangladesh mai phas gai hai
@@RajSingh-yd8ue zhaat ka alliah koi ummah chummah nahi agar jeb me paisa nahi
@@RajSingh-yd8ue tmhain hm ny tuo mana nai kiya ki hindu naary lagao ya hindu ko na umat bolo .this is your own choice .hm ek ha Alhamdulliah hmara la ila ka rishta ha hm kahien gy .ap ki takleef ki waja smjh nai aayi . ab ap ye sochty ho ki jesa ap kr rahy hain sb hi wesy q nai kr rahy tuo aisa kbi nai ho sakta ki sb apk hisab sy chalien so logic sy kam lyien zara.
One of my cousin is bihari. I didn't knew about this bihari meaning before watching this video.i used to think it's her title. But she have everything what i have as a Bangladeshi Citizen.
They supported and took part in the massacre of Bengalis in 1971.They are suffering for their dirty work in the past.They themselves are responsible for their present.
I think it was Indian Army who wear Pakistan Army uniform and did massacre, did rapes and looted many things and still some of politicians still now do blow job to Indian government.
India never help Bangladesh without any profit.
Bangladesh did help to India by giving transit to Indians,
But India is still thinking to give transit to Bangladesh for Nepal and Bhutan.
This unique friendship is only known as one friend is only taking advantages from another friend, that’s really very bad.
These biharis and pak armies massacred many bengalis,especially hindus in 1971 war.😢😢
On the time of partition their family chose Muslim state over india, that time it was east Pakistan.
Proud to be a bihari Muslim
From Bihar ( India)
Jai bharat jai bihar 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Tu bhi wahi jayega bahut jald 😡
Chad❤
@@hp9246 Woh Jai Bharat Kar rha aur Tu mc keh rha wahi jayegaa beta sudhar jaao nhi toh Accha nhi hoga
You know these Banaladeshi people got so filled in Assam. The government is not taking action against them, the whole of the North East is filled with Bangladeshi. 😢
I feel very sad and disgust€d that my ancestors did not ask for full partition. Used to lick pissfuls feat until i read their books. I don't want my motherland India to get another partition but mark my words, it is coming soon. 😓
Jo Muslim Bhai log india me rah ke insecure or azaadi nai rakhte aisa sochate hai o log iss vlog ko jaroor dekhna chahiye our unko proud hona chahiye ki o India me rahte hai 😊
India mein bhi koi badiya tarika se nahe rehte wo.
Bhai sab muslims proud feel karte hai as a Indian muslim bas kuch chutiyo ko chorh ke or tum sabko un chutiyo ki wajah se sabko bura bolte ho
I feel very sad and disgust€d that my ancestors did not ask for full partition. Used to lick pissfuls feet until i read their books. I don't want my motherland India to get another partition but mark my words, it is coming soon. 😓
Apne sai kaha Kash mere ajdad bhi Uttar Pradesh chor k Pakistan na jaty 💔 ye batwara karwa kar Urdu Hindi bolne wale sab logo ko barbad kardia or me khud indian Muslims ko kehti hu k achi bat hy k ap india me he rahy kahi or nahi hay or ap Hindu muslim log mil k raho india me please laro mat 🙏
Usually They speak Urdu in their area and Dhakaiya local language in outside. Same kind of Biharis also live in Chittagong in our Area.
They are loyal to pakistan or Bangladesh now a days??
@@theearth3569 I know about younger guys. They are obviously loyal to Bangladesh. Because they born here.
I know a good number of Bihari people living in Bangladesh, they are living very normal life here. They built their life and made wealth and living happily with their family among us.
Why are you guys paying for these traitors and Rohingyas. You should take care of only Bangla people. Give these people to United nation.
@@AfridiBD but your country will be safe and prosperous for next 100 years after that. BD can be prosperous only when bangla people won't let it's Bangali culture away. As indian I know bangali people are very good at education. But these people will put big amount of pressure on you guys. Your govt should tell arabs and turks to take these people. National intrest should be first.
@@AfridiBD always welcome bro, don't expect any good thing from pakistan, they didn't gave equal rights to muhajirs. You can see what happened to Karachi, they are not giving anything to baloch people too. They are still stuck in medieval times. They even destroyed beautiful modern Afghanistan. These days pakistani reaction channels trying to get soft corner in Bangla people. But in reality are jealous of you progress and economy. I hope one day Bangladesh nepal India Myanmar Thailand will be connected by roads and will form South Asian union with economic prosperity and technology development. We in rajasthan hear about malmal of dhaka a lot from our elders, I hope it will be back in market, your country proved everyone wrong who doubted you guys. You guys are leader in textile, ship repairing, jute production etc. You guys need just need to make population policy and infrastructure. You guys have great potential but please don't let pakistanies to influence your youth and distrub your harmony. Wish for prosperous BD. It will benifit both India and BD. Tread is very important and also education.
@@AfridiBD brother we hindus don't hate muslims, for example we have daudi Bohras here, nicest people, always contribute to country, naver create controversy and practice Islam and never make fun of other religions or target other religions. Same with 90% Shias, big section of educated muslims also don't anything bad about Islam. But Ashraf of our Muslim community still thinks like they are descendents of Mughals and arabs and their heart always beat for pakistan. All those years they made fun of hindus and sikhs, but now our community is getting frustrated and start doing tit for tat, because of foolish ashraf of muslim community, hindus are getting radicalised and it's not good for our country. These rich muslim leader don't care about getting people radicalised because their own family members study abroad and live life king size. I'm concerned about my community won't listen anyone if these polictal parties and leaders don't take it seriously.
@@AfridiBD you r a kind Muslim. Why should you not be loved back and respected well by non Muslim Indians? Sure, we will, always. ❤. Love, bro
In Bangladesh vs Pakistan cricket match they support Pakistan.
I am bihari boy my born kolkata I love my kolkata I love Hindu Bengali Punjabi bhai log bahut accha hota hai Bengali Hindu bhai bahut accha insan hota hai koi dharam affect nahi larta peglhle insan samajtha hai 👏👏👏👏👏👏
Apke coments to bhut ache hote h, but when election come , maximum people vote for party who want division, like last election AIMIM wins 5 seats in Bhihar, same 1946 election, if muslim leage not win the election, partition will not happened, since muslim leage win election for making promise of Pakistan, & the common people of indian subcontinent suports it,
Abey chutiye yeh dharam ki baat nahi hai yeh langueage ki baat hai. I am a hindu bengali from kolkata and i would never accept hindi as a national langueage of INDIA.
I am bengali Muslim and I never knew about their existence. I have mixed feelings about this people. I feel like if this people gets another chance just like 1971 they will repeat their past mistake once again.
Now they have pent up anger inside. Way more than 1971 as that was a different case. So yes, u r right, give them a chance and they will surpass their 1971 achievements!
@@ranjittyagi9354 believe me I can see it
@@itsrs14 yeah. Their faces, words and the anger betrays their thoughts.
They will definitely do it. These Bihari and UP Muslims do think they are superior to Bengali Muslims. I am Bengali Hindu I have seen this in West Bengal though they don’t feel the same for Bengali Hindus I don’t know why. They also don’t mix with the Bengali Muslims as much as they do with Bengali Hindus. Probably because they are racist and thinks Bengali Muslims to be dark and inferior to them. One of my cousins friends rejected a Bengali Muslim for marriage only because he was Bengali and ended up marrying a Gujarati Muslim who was not even 1/10th rich like the Bengali Muslim she rejected.
@@ManabDasiammanab see now it's not about the religion. It doesn't matter if you are Hindu or Muslim or maybe Christian, Buddhist... It really doesn't matter. People hates what they want to hate. We Bengali ppl are looked down all over the world. They take us as a small fly. I hope there are more understanding Hindu's like you in Bengali community.
They didn,t talk about their heinous war crime of 1971.
Don't spare them. Their ancestors were culprit
@@iamindianindian8286 they are pro-Pakistani elements.... Their condition is still better than Bengalis stranded during Pakistan partition
Inlog ko Bihari mat bolo. Bihari deshbhakt hote hen.
Ye pahle Bharat se deshdroh kie, aur Pakistan banaae. Phir baad me Bangladesh se deshdroh kar ke Pakistan kaa saath dia.
THESE PEOPLE ARE NOT BIHARIS THESE PEOPLE ARE TRAITORS.
How did they commit "deshdroh" in india??
Does "deshdroh" mean fleeing for their lives??
@@muhammadmohaiminulislam7189 deshdroh means breaking your country. Bihar still has 16% muslim population, and its same as before independence. Why only a handful of them left for Porkistan? Why not rest? Wasn't there any threat to them? Even if suppose there was threat, there places in Bihar where Muslims were in majority (many pockets in Patna, Katihar, Gaya, Nalanda, Madhubani), even today Kishangunj has 75% muslim population, they could have gone there, but they chose to go to Pakistan.
They were unfaithful to Bihar and India. They are unfaithful to Bangladesh too.
The faithful muslims are even today in Bihar.
@@rcb1786 People did return to some extent, when hindu extremists cooled down, which you can see in this video too. People always look for a safer place and don't really like to get killed for a cow.
Also, you too are traitors for breaking out of britain. We bangladeshis (not the biharis) are also traitors for breaking out of pakistan etc. According to your logic of course.
@@muhammadmohaiminulislam7189 btw I would conclude with one final statement, MA Jinnah is responsible for the disturbance that the subcontinent has witnessed since 1940s. His whole concept of a separate Muslim nation was flawed. The muslims and Hindus of Bengal have more common things than Hindus or Muslims of Bengal and Punjab. He fell into the words of extremists and took a wrong stand. (Which he himself later accepted, and told that he wants to return to India).
Because of this partisan both Muslims and Sikhs/Hindus were killed in large numbers. Bengalis had to suffer for 30 years. And these (Biharis of BD) people are still suffering.
@@rcb1786 Maybe Jinnah was responsible to some extent. But riots weren't new, started during british period.
Your view of justice is based solely on hindu supremacy, where anything that benefits that ideology is good and all others are bad.
People want security but with freedom. Even a gang of robber doesn't harm anyone who abide by. That's not what people want. Jinnah was successful because muslims didn't feel safe for some reasons.
After incidents like cow lynching , people being burnt for not chanting "jay shree ram" muslims will incline more towards Jinnahs decision and regret being an indian.
Definitely you'd like muslims to just leave their ancestral land only for hindus OR denounce islam accepting all the demands made by hindus. But that's not going happen. Everyone wants safety, everyone has to live.
You have heard that it is a camp (Jeneva Camp) that they wanted to leave for Pakistan. According to the Geneva Convention, they were listed to leave Bangladesh after Liberation War. But the Pakistani Govt. did not take them and since then they were living here. They supported Pakistani armies and did not want to stay in Bangladesh. Still, they were living in this camp though Bangladesh Govt gave them other places to stay, but they do not want to go there. Now a day many of them got Bangladeshi nationality, but they do not believe or are loyal to Bangladeshi nationality.
How do you know they are not loyal! Did they said anything like that. Change your mindset toward other people.
Love from Maharashtra 🚩🇮🇳
Yeh log bengali ke upar 71 me Pakistani army se milkar jo julm kiya aap soch nahin sakte,karma pays.
Prime example of How a religion destroys everything
Brother, 1.5 crore Biharis live in Bangladesh. They speak Bengali so they don't have any problem. There are many Biharis in my village too. There are many Bihari cities in North Bengal. But Bihari of the Geneva camp is different. They literally support Pakistan in the 1971 Bengali genocide. They still don't want to speak Bengali. Directly supports Pakistan. They celebrate when Pakistan wins a cricket match. They even celebrate Eid according to Pakistani time. How will the Bangladeshis support them? If they don't want Bangladesh. Bangladesh government also showed kindness and gave them citizenship. But Bengalis in Pakistan are still treated as fourth class people.
Bro, how can you force your language on them absolute non sense, bihari will and should support Urdu not bengali, understand they support Pakistan and didn't wanted to break way from there bcz they were afraid they will losse their language once east Pakistan seperate and this is what you are saying.. Sad but I am punjabi will not force a non punjabi to speak it
@@divyanshbatra8859 are bhi, tumhe history pata nehi hai,or kuch v bol rahe ho! En Loko ki hal serf language ka liya nehi hai,,,, accha se history janlo, e lok rajakar hai, kitna arto ko baltkar Kiya! kitna Bengali people ko khun Kiya tumhe pata hai,,,,?avi vi e lok Bangladesh ko dil se Manta hi nehi! Bangladesh Jane ki vi jarurat nahi west bengal me aj jaw enka history pata chala jayaga dost
@@divyanshbatra8859 ye log bengali ko jabardasti urdu sikha rahe the rajakar gang banakr rape karte the bengali aurat ka uska khamiaja hai ye. Yadi tumhare baap dada pap karenge to bhugtoge tum hi yahi duniya ka wasool hai. Tum punjabi mota dimag ke log ho. Bihari muslim india mein bhi Pakistan ki jeet pr patakhe fodte hain.
@@divyanshbatra8859 they supported pakistan at their young age....because of them thousands of bengali people murdered and some had to leave bangladesh and lived their live in the streets of kolkata....
They are living good life brother
@@divyanshbatra8859 No 1.5 crore bihari people live only a very few 5-8 lakh people live in Bangladesh. This man is foolish. In Bangladesh 15 crore bengali muslims live along with alomst 3crore bengali hindus & these biharis only amount to almost close to 8lakhs only.
14:45 thank God my grandfather stayed in India after leaving Balia because of riots he migrated to Hooghly (near Kolkata)
bach gaye tum
Ussh time Bach Gaye agr uttarkashi meh hotte toh nhi bachte
Gujrat meh 2002 meh hotte tbh bhi nhi bachte
Nielle genocide k time Assam meh hotte tbh bhi nhi bachte
Mumbai massacre k time meh bhi rehte toh nhi bachte
Delhi 2020 meh rehte tbh bhi nhi bachte
Abhi tk tumhari mob lynching bhi nhi Hui
God ka shukriya Karo tumhe God neh kitne affato seh bachaya😂
Yeah sbh dekh kr dukh aur dar bhi lgta hai
Yeah partition k time k comparison meh kuch nhi hai aur abbh yeah dekho voh log ussh time issh seh kharab mahol dekh kr kaisa lgta hogga
People think that they were supporters of Pakistan. I really don’t know what is the reality.they helped Pakistani army in 1971.
Suffering with identity 😂😂
इन्हीं के बाप दादाओं ने धर्म के आधार पर देश का बंटवारा कराने का पाप किया था । अब भुगत रहे हैं ।
Right joy Bangladesh
They are suffering because of there karma in 1971. That time they had supported Pakistani army and joined with them to kill bangali people. Also they had killed many more intellectual Bangladeshi people. Still they are supporting Pakistan. Still they try to raise Pakistani flag in special day..
In Puran Dhaka, there are the old ethnic people who call themselves Kuttis (there's a legend that they used to cut dhaan (dhaan kutna) so they came to be called kuttis). Kuttis speak in Hindustani amongst themselves. They're a legacy community of the old Nawabs and Mughal Subedars, who brought their own administrative people to Medieval Dhaka. If you walk in the streets of Old Dhaka you'll hear many people conversing in Hindustani.
So aside from Biharis, they are the only other Hindustani speakers in Bangladesh, I believe. There are other Urdu speaking communities in Chittagong and Sylhet too, but I don't know much about them.
Tnx for sharing this.
Bhai these bihari fight along with Pakistan army raped poor bengali
Yes.
All your Nawabs, including the ones who lived in Dhaka's Ahsan Manzil, had URDU as their mother tongue!
@@kumar7586 Not urdu. Hingdoostane.
Urdu name was given by muslims....
@@kumar7586 not all nawabs only the dhaka one. Rest of all muslim nawabs & zamindars in Bangladesh were bengali muslims.
Being a Bihari Muslim and Watching this from Danapur... And remembering Maulana Abul Kalam Azad "Tum Hijrat Ke Muqaddas Naam Pe Farar Ki Zindagi Guzaroge. "
They shouldn't have migrated. India would embrace them too.
Sahi kaha bhaijaan
Bhai aaj Gandhi jee ka yaad agaya....what a visionary person our father of the nation was.....Hindu Mushlim sikh Christian sab milke iss desh ko balanced kar ke rakha he.....Proud to be Indian...
It's really sad that you are making video without knowing the main history and presenting Bengali in negative way.
Bengalis are moving to the same fate, maximum bengali's are woke and act as pseudo liberals, there will be time when bengal will have Shariah-law due to their extra wokeness and i hope I am wrong but it's looking like that.
Hasina is providing them into Bangladeshi schools. After the liberation war many of them where living in Mohammadpur
Pakistan me bhi jitne bihari hain. Unko Pakistan ne bhi Aaj tak accept nhi kia. Ajj bhi pakistani officials bihari ko Indian bolte hain.
It's a great lesson for all. Under any circumstances, you should not leave your original mother land. In India Muslims enjoy the same rights like other citizens. There is no discrimination on religious ground. That is the beauty of Indian democracy. And Your identity shouldn't be based on religion, it should be based on your birth place. The so called exponents of Pakistan actually cheated the common people .
Im an urdu speaking person and my family roots are indian and i live in dhaka. What i wanna clear here is that the people you are watching in this video are some unsuccessful and lazy people who still after 52 years are stuck at the same place, and its not true that we are treated badly here. Totally false, after 1971, my father had the opportunity to leave the country but instead he lived here and worked hard and become successful and today we as a financial condition are in a good place and we are living our lives the way people are supposed to live, I've seen no discrimination happening to myself anywhere and i have lots of Bangali friends too.
My point is that people of Bangladesh (bangali) are very straightforward, the people in the video are those who themselves haven't accepted this country as a bangladesh, instead of working hard they complain, they blame the government, they have thousands of excuses. Believe me the government are not the reason why they are in this situation but they are the one who choosed to live this kind of life.
Thanks for speaking out the truth. We are a family of freedom fighters. But my aunt got married to a Bihari. He is very successful in his career. I can't remember, we have ever behaved disrespectfully to him bcz of his race. I feel so shocked to see these people of geneva camps malign Bangladesh in every video. I don't think we deserve this betrayal. Are we supposed to offer them free apartments?
Proud to be indian muslim................
Love 💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖 my india . proud to be our indian constitution. Love you Gandhi ji neheru ji proudly say they give aur our right in constitution.................
Jai Hind hai Bharat.Love you ❤️😘😘😘😘❤️❤️😘❤️❤️🇮🇳💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪 indian muslim jai hind jai bharat.
Please research about this people they'll take equal part in atrocities against BD Hindu's during 70s era
Not only BD Hindus but also Bangali Muslims. They helped Pakistani army to kill bangali people. Still they believe in Pakistan.
খুব সুন্দর ভাবে বিষয়টি তুলে ধরেছে দাদা, যে বিষয়গুলো মিডিয়ার তুলে ধরার কথা সেই কাজটি তুমি করছো।
Love you brother ❤️
এটা কোন জায়গায়
so sad story... mujhy dekh kr bohat bora lga
I'm from Pakistan 🇵🇰
Best wishes for all Muslim brothers❤
Ja ke Karachi ka Bengali community ko dekho, Jo aapne desh ke saath gaddari karte hain unke saath bura haal hota hain
@@ayanmukherjee8255. Asy tu nahin hota un k sath bhai G ur gaddari kis bat ki wo tu bechary majbor log hain unho ne kon c gaddari ki hai?
@mianahsan7544 do u not know what they did to bengalis while living in our land? They're not helpless and poor.
Bihari, cp. Up Muslims were the main reason for partition..
In 1946 proventional elections Muslim league won in this states unilaterally
All muslim equally fought for Pakistan expect baloch muslim
In united punjab and bengal muslims were majority so they start masscare non muslim for putting pressure on congress for Pakistan
Bahut bahut sukriya mere dada aur baki khandan walon ka jo by birth aur by choice v hindustani rahe. Bahut khuskismat hai hmlog jo bharat jaisa pak sarjmin pe rah rahe m proud Indian muslim. Jai hind jay bharat
Hindu majority hai isliye acche se ho..... Vahi Bangladesh ki halat dekho.... Fir kehte ho Muslim safe nahi hai India hai
Thanks to your video, witnessing a world that I had no idea about, great job Vishnu
I feel very sad and disgust€d that my ancestors did not ask for full partition. Used to lick pissfuls feat until i read their books. I don't want my motherland India to get another partition but mark my words, it is coming soon. 😓
Aur jao islamic federation ke raste pee
😂😂Bht sehe hua tum logo ke sath..you guys deserve it
These biharis & pak armies massacred many bengali hindus in 1971 war.
Hindu ki ma ko chut sath me ram ka mukh me mal dal dunggaa
Sahi kha marne do salon ko 🤣🤣
Mai Bangali Bangladeshi hu inlogo motherchod Pakistan support karte he Bangladesh me rehke
India is the Great Country ❤️❤️❤️❤️... This people don't deserve Hindustan.... That's why they leave India....jai hind
Pure hindu hate ...... Koi soch bhi nahi sakta yaha par hindu bhi reh rahe honge....
India me the to hindu se dikkat ..... pakistan me the to west pakistan se dikkat ...aaj bengladesh me hai to waha bhi dikkat....
But manana padega dedication poori hai abhi bhi hindu ko kuch bole Bina baat poori nahi karenge
*Elderly Bearded Guy expressed very heartwarmingly* 😔 *Politics & Politicians are reason for all this chaos, even Bangladeshis are in India, who are not treated well* 🥺
Because they came under wire.
They are infiltrators
They should be thrown out from our land
stfu! they rped bengalis in 1971
I am Bangladeshi people I just Bangladesh living this is Indian not this is Pakistan this my brother
We gave them citizenship but they didn’t give citizenship to Bengalis who stuck in karachi
When is India and Pakistan to realise that it is the ethnicity that matters more than anything else? Nehru and company racked havoc on mother nature which is considered as a cause of celebration.
Exactly. Ethnicity is a major factor, that India, Pakistan don't consider.
Pakistan and India then would be more different. Only 3% of Indians dhare ethnicity with Pakistanis, which include punjabis, Sindhis and Kashmiri’s. Other than that nobody in India does.
In 1947 partison UP.. Bihari.. muslim support Pakistan.
If you keep so much hatred in your heart, Such an outcome was bound to happen. First hatred towards India then hatred towards Bangladesh is responsible for their present situation. Until they are able to leave this hatred from their minds, they will not improve.
They Were Patriot Pakistanis, they were Aware of *Agartila Conspiracy*
That's Why they Didn't Support Mukti Bahini, but after the Independence Of Bangladesh they brutally Tortured by Mukti Bahinis & Awami League. But Still Living in Bangladesh.
@xoxo xoxo They Didn't Tortured any Civilian but i can Understand Your History Wrote by Hindutuva just like your Anthem
Don't you dare say anything about our anthem. What the fuck is Pakistan!!! A country whose name was coined out not even hundred years back!! Bangladesh has given citizenship to all those stranded Pakistan lovers.. What the fuck have you done to the stranded Bangalees in karachi?? Or do you even know about them??
Your anthem's language even a fucking mixture of different other language and you try to undermine ours'!! What a crapbag!!
@@shazainbaloch2538 those men worked with Pakistan and America to revolt and create a genocide in Bangla land but at last 90,000 of them surrendered and Pakistani had to get their arse off Bangla 🤣🤣 This is not hiduvta history. This is REAL history, I know Pakistanis are delusional but just accept your ancestors miserably failed 🤣🤣
@@shazainbaloch2538 shazain u r everywhere on tube. I wish a Bangladeshi gifts u his seed forcibly. Will wait for ur reply THEN . Danda hi chalega tere case me , Bangla Bangladeshi ka. Sab samajh jayegi. Jhoothi r kamzarf beghaiarat orat ha tu. Ho jaye teri drilling , agartala likhna seekh badzaat orat. Aur seekh kar bhool ja conspiracy wonspiracy.
These Biharis showed their loyalty towards Pakistan and even fought against the muktibahini during 1971. The Pakistanis abandoned them after the liberation of Bangladesh. This they will never say.
Say bihari Muslims. The bihari Hindus saved the asses of Bengali Hindus when they fought as Warlords of gopal patha. Most of his men were non Bengalis
what bangladehsi acheave after partition only riding rikshaws ?
Bangladeshi Biharis all originated from Bihar, now a state of India. When they were Pakistanis, we Bengalis were too. Now it's Bangladesh, we all are Bangladeshis. None of the Biharis are from West Pakistan or current-day Pakistan.
Bro,Go to korachi and take a video about bengali people.They also live their life as like bihari in bangladesh.
They are not bihari. They migrated in 1947 then many return to kishanganj Araria katihar.
Kanana ka chata ho jo wapas india aya wahi bihari hai aur jo fas gaya waha east Pakistan or Bangladesh may wo bihari nahi hai
Lakin may ya vhi manta ho ki en logo ko pakistan na vhi nahi apnaya hala ki en logo ka purvaj 1947 may india sa migrate hoka pakistan gaya fir vhi sala unlogo nahi apna mana en logo ko
May apna dada, nana sabi pariwar ka sukur gugar hu ki jo faisala un log na india yaniki apna desh may hi rahana faisala sahi kiya tha warna hum logo ka hal vhi en logo jsisa hota
Apna desh apna hota hai
80 percent of Bangladesh population can understand Hindi language ,,, because of Bollywood movies and indian channels
Our regional history is confusing... When I was a kid I was in Malda anyone speaking hindi was called HINDUSTANI there.... and hindi speaking muslims were known as Bihari Musalmaan ( which is not a fact bcz any non bengali will speak hindi) at that time no Google so locals in East unable to imagine beyond Bihar as mostly influx in kolkata from Bihar only.
Actually whole hindi land is called as Hindustani,,, not the whole India
For these people, Best solution would be to adopt Bengali culture and language with full faith...
Correct
Tumara bat sahi hai laki fir vhi en logo ko aaj tak nahi apnaya
@@w27_offical bhai... Phle urdu chore, Bengali festival celebrate kre.... Sb log accept krenge..... Pr vo krenge nhi shayad... Unko lgta hai ki vo superior hai like pakistani
@@SHIVAMYadav-pw5uz In logo ko to pakistan na vhi nahi apnaya aaj tak kuki ya log manta hai ki sab india sa migrate hoka aya hai,,,soho agar hum India Muslim migrate karka jata to wo log yaniki pakistani bangaleshi hum kabi nahi apnata kuki simple reason of migration from india
Jai Hind Jai Bharat mera bharat mahan. proud to be an Indian Muslim.
I feel very sad and disgust€d that my ancestors did not ask for full partition. Used to lick pissfuls feet until i read their books. I don't want my motherland India to get another partition but mark my words, it is coming soon. 😓
U are Pakistani haram khut
Please represent the full picture, along with appropriate background.
Those who left India during Partition are not Indians, please don't use the term Indians in Bangladesh.
The crux of the problem is, they are not Bengalis, and they were the ones who were hand in glove in trying to destroy Bengali Identity along with the Pakistanis.
The case of Bihari Muslims in Bangladesh cannot be even compared with the situation of Muhajirs in Pakistan. In erstwhile East Pakistan, a very large section of Bihari Muslims were enthusiastic participants of socio-economic ostracization and ethnic cleansing of Bengalis. They had been hand-in-glove with the brutal Pakistani regime which wanted to destroy Bengali culture, literature and identity. In fact a very large section of them were the 'Razakars' or willing perpetrators of crimes against humanity initiated, sustained and executed by the Pakistani Regime. They wanted to usurp the land, property and wealth of not only Hindus but ethnic Bengali Muslims during the freedom struggle of Bangladesh (Muktijuddho). But when the tables turned and Pakistanis fled Bangladesh with tails between legs, the Bihari Muslims in Bangladesh faced the heat and were systematically and effectively sidelined. Essentially, their karma hit back on them.
Bhai ye 1947 me Pakistan ka support karke Lakho Hindu ko mara... kolkata ke sath sath kai jagah par Hindu ko kat dala....or chale gye pakistan....fir jab 1971 Muslim ka Aapas (Urdu muslim - Bengali Muslim) me war huaa....Tab suffer Hinduo ko karna padta tha....me 3 saal se kolkata me rahta hu...mere Owner Ke koi relative Bangladesh se the .... unhone mujhe btaya .....ye Pakistani ( urdu-bengali) Aapse me Lad rhe the ....Tab war ke time Bangladesh me ...koi Urdu wale ko Hindu milta to wo usko maar dete.....same koi Bengali Muslim ko Hindu milta to wo bhi usko maar dete the.....ye sale peacefull community wale Aapas me Lad rhe the ......us time 1971 me ...Lakho Bangladeshi Hinduo ko apna ghar chod ke..... Tripura Assam or WB me aana pada tha....ye koi innocent nahi hai.....
@@Ankitsingh11857 this is bonafide nonsense. It is true that in 1947, due to extreme polarization Hindu Muslim riots happened in Bengal. But whoever says, during 1971 Bengali Muslims killed Bengali Hindus, is an utter rascal. Infact, such was the momentum, that Mujibur Rahman (bangabandu) had planned a politico-social path for secular Bangladesh. But, he and his entire family was killed (except for Sheikh Hasina) and Bangladesh descended into the path of hardliners. In fact, it was one more blunder of Nehru's, to not have been able to support the nascent Bangladesh and protect its progressive goals.
@Śrīhaṭṭa Vaiśvānara please be mindful of language. Yes there were few bengalis in razakar group, but it was Pakistani and Bihari Muslims that primarily led the onslaught. Please don't try to be an armchair specialist without knowing ground realities and facts. Moreover your unrefined, semi civilized way of communicating tells a lot about your thought process....
@@Ankitsingh11857 lund kuch kar paya in bihari mullo ne kolkata mein danga start karkey kuch bihari aur oriya labour hinduo ko mara tha phir bangali hinduo ke upper caste ne inko kolkata me kat daley 15000-18000 ke taidat mein isliye baki 5 lakh darkey purvi bangal bhagey jan bachaney ke liye kyuki wo purvi pakistan banney wala tha.
@@Ankitsingh11857Don't speak nonsense. Bengali Muslims killing Bengali Hindus during 1971 is complete BS.
I seen rich Bihari my neighbor in Bangladesh. If you always live in negativity you can’t do anything where ever you live!
even though theres some bad history, its natural for you to feel some sort of pity and empathy for these people..after all we are the same people from the same land..so no matter what a guilt resides.. u see a similarity..a lost similarity..hand full of bangladeshis feel the same way i assume when they meet bangals in west bengal.
Bangladesh kisliye gye the.... Aur jb tum Bangladesh k nhi hue 1971 m pakistan k support kiye the.....
Bihari muslim isse jada acche se h... Main bihar se hu, mere bhut muslim friends h....
Inlogon ko bhi kuch jyaada shaukh tha apne muslims bhaiyon k sath muslim desh me rehne ka..Ab pata chalta hoga ki unke muslims bhai kaise hain..
@@siddharthverma2849 lol isme political issue hain... Religion ka nehi
@@abdulgaffarchowdhury5255 Politics Kaun kar raha hai?
Wahan k log Agar inko accept kar le to phir government kyun nahi accept karegi?.
Sach yehi ki wahan k local log inhe abtak accept nahi kiye hain..Jaisa ki Pakistan me abhi bhi bahut sare Muslims jo ki partition k time pe wahan gaye the unko Pakistani ne accept nahi kiya..Aaj bhi wahan waise Muslim Muhajir keh k gaaliyan dete hain.
@@siddharthverma2849 Bro, These Muslim Biharis killed many bengali hindus in 1971 for supporting Pakistani Mulk. They even formed paramilitary for this. Now They are hated by every Bangladeshi for their past deed which is normal.
@@starboxrock9133 Fine..Here too severe communal riots took place at the time of partition and even after that..But we have moved forward..Now we don't keep that hatred feelings..Those people who had supported the Pakistan during the time of Bangladesh formation must have died by now..Why the people of Bangladesh and their government are punishing their grandchildren.. What mistakes they have done.They were born in independent Bangladesh ...They are natural born Bangladeshi citizens...They must get all the rights available in their country.
Exmuslim Atheist From Bangladesh 🇧🇩
Bihar was culturally and historically part of Bengal.Bihar was separated from Bengal during 1905 Bengal partition.I am from West bengal.
1911 bihar was separated from west bengal.
1936 odisha separated from Bihar.
2002 Jharkhand separated from bihar.
बिहार शुरू से बंगाल से अलग रहा है मुगल शासकों ने इसे बंगाल में शामिल किया था,
British included Odisha in Bengal for their administrative purpose or else Odisha was separated prior to that hence saying Bihar n Odisha culturally n historically part of Bengal is totally wrong n lack of knowledge about history.
Yes mayanmar, arunanchal Pradesh ,nepal,Tibet,hongkong,yuan province were all historically part of Bengal .
@@noone-zl2di मुग़ल, गुप्त, मौर्य आदि काल से बंगाल बिहार का हिस्सा रहा है सिर्फ मुगल काल में कुछ दिनों के लिए बिहार को बंगाल में मिला दिया गया था
spread love not hate :) LOVE PEACE UNITY ... regardless of race or religion & political views.. lets live in harmony
But they are not in harmony
@@bhoomika7572its their fault because they caused many attrocities against bengalis
You have to thank the Bengalis for not commiting the same to the biharis
In 1971, after facing years of discrimination from West Pakistan, the region of East Pakistan declared independence as Bangladesh. The declaration led to the Bangladesh Liberation War, during which many Biharis either supported or joined the Pakistani army's efforts to maintain Pakistan's territorial unity, including committing significant atrocities against Bengali nationalists. However, after Bangladesh achieved independence, many Bangladeshis viewed Biharis as traitors, and the Pakistani government agreed to only allow a small percentage of Biharis to resettle in Pakistan. The rest of the Bihari community was forced to live in slum-like "camps" in Bangladesh, where they have remained since 1971.
I am from Bangladesh (Chittagong). The report touched my heart! It is really moving. Not a single life should be neglected/ deprived due to political reasons. All those people are the fabric of our community, they are part of Bangladesh. They government should fully recognise them as our valued citizens so that they could shine & thrive to their full potential. It is heartbreaking to see their living condition. They choose to live here , they love Bangladesh. We can’t live with the long gone and resolved past!
You don't know, they hate Bangladesh.
Bhai ektu porashona kore kotha comment koiren. Hudai na jani sympthay dekhaile hobe na
Pore aaye, tarpor eder gaanr chatbi gudir pola
Don't feel so sorry for them they are devils
@saeidbinhossain8530seems like you are some begairat behaya Islamabad wali ghasti ki najayaz nasl hira Mandi Pakistani😂😂😂
এটা দেখে খুবই খারাপ লাগলো। তারা তো শান্তিতে থাকার জন্যই পূর্বপাকিস্তানে এসেছিল। তাদের ভাষা উর্দু হওয়ায় আমরা তাদের পাকিস্তানি ভাবতে পারিনা৷
Lol! They killed many hindus in 1971 war
@@starboxrock9133 hindus nd bengalis also killed many biharis. So dont tell only one sided story.
তো তারা পাকিস্তান কে সাপোর্ট করেছিলো কেন?
পাকিস্তানে চলে যেতে পারতো বাংলাদেশে আসার কি দরকার ছিলো?
For your kind information, these people get free electricity, free ration, which is NOT offered to average Bengali citizens. They were offered BD citizenship by Sheikh Mujib in 1972. They refused and hoped that Pakistan would repatriate them. Pak didn't repatriate them. BD again made them citizen in 2008. It's not that BD govt don't allow them to stay outside camp. They simply don't want to pay rent and get a better accommodation. They don't want to give up the free facilities they get in those camps. What do you expect BD govt to do? Give them free apartments? Funny thing is, Sheikh Hasina actually announced that she will build apartments for them. Yet these traitors will vote against Hasina, criticize Bengalis day and night. Look at their hatred against us. They brutally murdered and raped us in 1971. Bengalis stuck in Pakistan are not offered citizenship. Both Bengalis and Biharis are Muslims. If you are sympathetic about plights of Biharis, be sympathetic about Bengalis too.