actuly I think it sota is. if you pull every item out of the container you could count them one by one on a presure plate with like a hopper minecart. also afterwords you could put the items back
If giant containers were made they could have special "terminals" on the sides which output their comparator signal strength to defer the problem onto them (yay).
@@CraftyMasterman how not , you can place blocks inside container trough them goes redstone using repeaters , then you can turn in digital values using coder and then digital to analog , obiosly it wont have same space like chests or other but it should work
It's pretty cool how much the inside actually looks like the inside of an IC. Seriously, go look up the dye shot of an early 6502 or Intel 8080 or something. Awesome build!
I learned a lot. I love how simple the subtraction circuit is. I would think the design would have been better if it didn't have that one output redstone dust stuck inside the structure, but other than that, this is awesome.
So that's how a comparator looks inside! This man's just discovered that the comparator has microtechnology! Now create a repeater without using comparators or repeaters to explain how the repeater works without making a paradox that a repeater needs a repeater inside to function or that the repeater needs a comparator which has repeaters which have comparators...
comparators are like the transistors of MC. (The similarity is striking tho. You use it to do more advanced circuitry, you need them for logic gates... etc.)
@@nicolefischer1504 Because all of the comparator functions work on redstone signal strength you can can use one comparator instead of building a 4 bit subtractor or magnitude comparator (without A = B) so in those cases comparators can cut down on a lot of gates. Comparators can also be really useful for making compact logic gates
In a coding/mathematical sense, here’s the formula for the functions of a redstone comparator: - Compare output = rear × [left ≤ rear AND right ≤ rear] - Subtraction mode: output = max(rear − max(left, right), 0)
the new SethBling of the years of 2020-2030 (if u don't know SethBling was a minecrafter in 2011 through 2014 who had a a whole series about making giant minecraft blocks exactly like this that also work) i hope this guy keeps on making these, "SethBling" was a really cool minecraft creater/redstoner/coder the things he did at the time were insane for the capability's of redstone back then its really cool seeing someone taking a kinda inspiration of him
i just want to say i didn't know he referenced SethBling because i was barely 30 seconds into the vid but as soon i unpaused the vid he started talking about SethBling so yea
Imagine using your alt account to comment on your own comment section displayed on your own video saying crazy on your own comment section displayed on own video.
3:13 I remember making a similar circuit, but it used XOR gates to detect where the boundary between the powered and unpowered redstone was. (The point at which the signal strength ends would be the only point where there would be a powered and unpowered signal directly next to each other). I had no idea what the circuit was called nor how to build a better one.
@@stampyfan9988 did you ment that I was jealous? If so, I could give 0 damns about being "first" If you asked me this back in 2012 then yes I would be jealous.
I love how I can see comparators in the different components at the 3 minute mark when you keep saying "without using a single comparator" lol, but other than that, I enjoyed the video, nice going bud ( the first part does not mean offense btw )
weirdly enough it's easier to understand what a comparator does after learning electronics. Op amps actually are mirrors of this. For the first function, obviously there is no analog. Second function: Op amps can be constructed into "voltage buffers/ followers". These essentially keep the signal strength. Third function: Op amps can be used as comparators, and the + - pins can be used to do this. Op amps "want" a null difference between both terminals, and if there is not, the maximum / minium voltage will be outputted. Therefore, appling the first voltage to the + and the second to the - is equivalent. Fourth function: Merge inverting mode and non-inverting mode to make a subtractor In summary, comparators are like op amps.
GIANT REPEATER EXISTS! ruclips.net/video/OQwLs8IZRd0/видео.html
🅱️erry🅱️eregrine
Perry the 5x5 and 6x6 guy™
Does it detect items in chests?
a repeater wouldn't nearly as hard as this, especially if you use pistons
Next up: “making redstone dust without using redstone dust”
bruh before watching this video I had no idea what a comparator did and after watching it I still don't know what it does
Does anyone?
i have failed this is so sad
i guess im the only one who understood immediately after he explained.
@@michaelb8528 I know
almost
@@NANKAIDATTE you weakling. I knew long before.
If only there was a smaller version of this. It would be so useful!
WaiteNg for the r/whoosh
But it allready the comparator
@@something2b445 r/whoosh
Lol
Ikr?!???111ii????!!!!!
oh so THAT’s what’s inside a comparator. good job crafty :)
258 likes and no reply?
imma fix that
+1 comment
:+1:,
Okay, maybe counting items from containers isn't possible because it requires comparator, but hear me out: *giant container*
I love seeing that pfp every now and then
actuly I think it sota is. if you pull every item out of the container you could count them one by one on a presure plate with like a hopper minecart. also afterwords you could put the items back
If giant containers were made they could have special "terminals" on the sides which output their comparator signal strength to defer the problem onto them (yay).
If you get 10 000 views and make a giant repeater, will you do an even bigger comparator out of giant repeaters?
No he needs to make a giant redstone dust first
@@thebe5twon-minecraftbikera979 but he already does that
giant repeater is easy though
@@vibaj16 catch： you have to be able to toggle the mode by clicking a button
@@9636dev still
Mojang: since comparators are proven redundant, we are going to remove it from the next update.
It Inhibits natural Creativity
@@eastereg7838do you mean the comparator helps creativity or removing it helps creativity or what?
latter probs@@SuperDestroyerFox
@@SuperDestroyerFoxthey were giving a reason like what mojang might say to justify it.
But cwafty mastemon, your comparator didn't read inputs from a container : |
not possible lol
@@CraftyMasterman if we give it a 1t pulse, will it activate ?
@@Door_Maker the only way to read containers is using comparators, but since this is comparatorless that's not gonna happen
@@CraftyMasterman how not , you can place blocks inside container trough them goes redstone using repeaters , then you can turn in digital values using coder and then digital to analog , obiosly it wont have same space like chests or other but it should work
@@CraftyMasterman it is if you count the items by pulling them out through a hopper, but you have to assume what the container is
1:40 LMAO
Also this is actually pretty darn impressive, nice.
It's pretty cool how much the inside actually looks like the inside of an IC. Seriously, go look up the dye shot of an early 6502 or Intel 8080 or something.
Awesome build!
Honestly yeah it’s kinda scary how closely it resembles that sort of thing. But most redstone looks that way to be honest lol
I learned a lot. I love how simple the subtraction circuit is.
I would think the design would have been better if it didn't have that one output redstone dust stuck inside the structure, but other than that, this is awesome.
3:14 but there is a comparator on the left...
I think it was only for testing
"but craftymasterman" is my favorite craftymasterman quote
So that's how a comparator looks inside! This man's just discovered that the comparator has microtechnology!
Now create a repeater without using comparators or repeaters to explain how the repeater works without making a paradox that a repeater needs a repeater inside to function or that the repeater needs a comparator which has repeaters which have comparators...
The repeated should be easy, you just need 2 Redstone torches
@@devonstaggs9470 you're forgetting the "lock" function, that almost nobody uses, but it is there!
@@helistorm98 but only repeaters can use the lock function and he said "repeaters without comparators or repeaters"
@@weirdtreats4855 and only comparators have the subtract function, but that doesn't make it impossible to recreate
@@helistorm98 Can't you use a piston moving a block cutting the line between the 2 torches for that?
Im so glad I found your channel through the poll you did awhile back.
But... a Giant repeater is literally just about the simplest thing to make
Just torch into torch, and to lock it you just make a super simple "memory"
make it without any redstone
That’s actually nostalgic, I remember when repeaters didn’t exist and I used that torch strategy to make a tnt cannon.
Don't forget adjustable delay
The recipe works as a repeater itself
You forgot about the locking repeater function which makes it way harder
I want this to be the canon inside of a normal comparator.
Imagine saying things in the live chat instead of the comments 😳
After seeing this (0:36), I instantly subscribed without hesitating. I pressed the like button and I smacked that damn bell to Earth 2.
Noice funi words XD
comparators are like the transistors of MC. (The similarity is striking tho. You use it to do more advanced circuitry, you need them for logic gates... etc.)
you don't. people have been building logic gates in minecraft for ages, since long before comparators were added
@@nicolefischer1504 Because all of the comparator functions work on redstone signal strength you can can use one comparator instead of building a 4 bit subtractor or magnitude comparator (without A = B) so in those cases comparators can cut down on a lot of gates. Comparators can also be really useful for making compact logic gates
No, it is almost identical to real world comparators.
Friend: Damn, I need a comparator on my survival world but I can't get to the nether yet for quartz!
Me: Do I have a solution for you!
0:17 ya you are accualy close to get 100k subs
very
@@CraftyMasterman true
watching this in nov 21 it says 13.3k subs. what happened? did i miss something?
@@wint3rsmith42 he's making it up lol
that image of the flying spaghetti monster from pastafarianism is the exact same thing i thought of when i first saw it... 5:30
Now make a giant giant comparator made from Giant repeaters and stuff.
Oh no.
Alternative title: What's inside comparator
1 year and only 2 likes... I'm happy to be your third
@@NormanTheDummy_RUclips Yeah 😂
this is such an amazing video i'm hooked. Subbed and everything
I think this is a good example of the value of circuit integration.
In a coding/mathematical sense, here’s the formula for the functions of a redstone comparator:
- Compare
output = rear × [left ≤ rear AND right ≤ rear]
- Subtraction mode:
output = max(rear − max(left, right), 0)
Ok but now make it read items
jk this is crazy my guy
Cant wait to see you make massive redstone dust without redstone.
HEV YOU USED COMPARATOR IN THE 3:25 I SAW IT!!!!
very sure its just for testing redstone signal strength
00:14 at this moment my like button is lights up
0:15
Wait a minute, that's the same music Wirtual uses.
amazing how the same 10 youtubers can just have these links in their communities and their formats and their sponsors and everything like that.
the fact you did this for content is awesome u gained my subscribe.
3:48 I saw a comparater
Mombo jumbo: finaly a worthy oponent
Our battle will be legendary
4:00 DANKPODS INTENSIFIES
Great video! I loved it so much but i feel lied to... 3:20 there are comparators on the red circut. But overall, great build!
lol when i saw this video i immediately thought of the one i saw from sethbling 7 years ago
well now we only need to find out what comparetors even do
i mean 10k is close to 100k, right?
somehow your short explanation on how comparators work helped me more then mumbo jumbo's video that ive been trying to learn from for like 2 years
Nice
comment for algorithms bc ur editing is very epic and stuff
3:34 bruh that is terraria music
I like the description, lol. Really reflects what I think when I read the description of most mc videos.
3:22 beside the lecturn
there is a..
I’ve played minecraft for over 12 years and I still have no clue what a comparator does
0:01 one second
Nice
Why did you comment this
@@themasterbee funny
@@silasdobson-jm4pdit’s obnoxious not funny
@@rocbot9479 nice opinion
the new SethBling of the years of 2020-2030 (if u don't know SethBling was a minecrafter in 2011 through 2014 who had a a whole series about making giant minecraft blocks exactly like this that also work) i hope this guy keeps on making these, "SethBling" was a really cool minecraft creater/redstoner/coder the things he did at the time were insane for the capability's of redstone back then its really cool seeing someone taking a kinda inspiration of him
i just want to say i didn't know he referenced SethBling because i was barely 30 seconds into the vid but as soon i unpaused the vid he started talking about SethBling so yea
crazy
Imagine using your alt account to comment on your own comment section displayed on your own video saying crazy on your own comment section displayed on own video.
No u
@@gamerocity5398 yes me
@@DumbName i said about crafty's bunker
3:13 I remember making a similar circuit, but it used XOR gates to detect where the boundary between the powered and unpowered redstone was. (The point at which the signal strength ends would be the only point where there would be a powered and unpowered signal directly next to each other). I had no idea what the circuit was called nor how to build a better one.
"giant repeater but with no repeater"
Me: *Thinks about * "Isn't that just 2 redstone torches?(Or the 0 tick repeater)"
I just found your channel in my recommended, and this is awesome! You’ve gained a sub, keep up the good work!
Comment
Finally. Finally someone who knows how comparoters work
First please heart
Omg guys I'm first that means I'm cool lets go poggers champ 360 no scope
@@DumbName your probaly jellus that you arent first why hate
@@stampyfan9988 did you ment that I was jealous? If so, I could give 0 damns about being "first"
If you asked me this back in 2012 then yes I would be jealous.
@@DumbName ok
I AM FIRST OMNGGMGF 😱😤
it is absolutely INSANE that THAT MASSIVE BUILD does less than one block
(I’m now so glad it was added)
Really entertaining! I’d love to see more videos like this!
my man explained to me what a comparator does in like 10 seconds when minute long videos don't teach me a thing-
pretty sure this is the definition of re-inventing the wheel.
This is just what happens when you craft a comparator
After watching so many videos and reading a lot about comparators, I still have no idea what they do but, this was still amazing!
THIS MAN WAS 5ALKING NONSENSE WHICH MADE SENSE TO ME!!!!! SUBSCRIBED
7+ years playing this game and yet i still have no idea how comparator works
This looks like a build mumbo jumbo would make and afterwards he’ll say “that was surprisingly easy”
I can hear jumbo saying: after doing some simple Redstone we got a working giant comparator
Feels like a mumbo video where he shows what's inside mobs, himself, grain, etc but only this should be named what's inside a comparator
If you see that the use of a comparator in the examples is to avoid having to put the line of repeaters to indicate different signal levels
thank god at least one person has a brain
I love how I can see comparators in the different components at the 3 minute mark when you keep saying "without using a single comparator" lol, but other than that, I enjoyed the video, nice going bud ( the first part does not mean offense btw )
but then at 5:50 there aren't any, why did you include that xD
4:35. nice flying spaghetti monster. That is a church!
Everyone: "mumbo jumbo is the best redstoner!"
Meanwhile this guy creating a working giant comparator:
Really makes you appreciate that we got a comparator block
This is a must have build if you have something that needs an comperator that can do everything if you want to scare your friends.
In the description: yes this is not a manhunt. But it would be cool if you did one inside the comparator.
"I made an giant redstone line."
Congratulations.
this make me appreciate the comparator even more
This video gave me a new found appreciation of comparators!
I like the use of the custom music discs in the background
- So, what redstone components you used in your redstone pc?
- Err.. I.. Its hard to explain
this man's editing and content is insane bruh
subbed to him on first video
This video answered every question I had about comparators that hours of tutorials couldn't
This video is so good it feels like a redstone version of a rekrap vid
After several years, we've finally had a in depth behind the scenes on how Mojang made the comparator!
Really good editing and content!
I subscribed within 20 seconds of the first video ive ever seen from this channel and im not taking it back. No regrets.
"We are so close to 100k subscribers..."
i can appreciate optimism, subscribed!
I cannot believe that he used many comparators to make just one useless comparator but due to this much effort I love your videos
What my friends see who can barely make a 2x2 Redstone door every time I use a cauldron to open a door
Without a single comparator? Impressive!
i remember watching the mega block series when they were new
sethblings such a Chad so ahead of his tims
I wish I was intelligent enough to look at redstone and say "yes, i understand what they're doing"
The first minute is a very good guide to the comparator
in only 59 seconds i have already learned more about a comparator than anybody could ever explain to me
since i exit from my mom, i never knew that the redstone comparator can do more than just making a blinking light
I like your funny words, Magic Man!
weirdly enough it's easier to understand what a comparator does after learning electronics.
Op amps actually are mirrors of this.
For the first function, obviously there is no analog.
Second function: Op amps can be constructed into "voltage buffers/ followers". These essentially keep the signal strength.
Third function: Op amps can be used as comparators, and the + - pins can be used to do this. Op amps "want" a null difference between both terminals, and if there is not, the maximum / minium voltage will be outputted. Therefore, appling the first voltage to the + and the second to the - is equivalent.
Fourth function: Merge inverting mode and non-inverting mode to make a subtractor
In summary, comparators are like op amps.
The “BUt CwAFtWYmWaSTeRMAn” Memes were amazing!
Absolutely wonderful work, thank you so much to both of you!
Sometimes the "cwaftymastman" just pops into my head and I have to rewatch the video
Next step is to make a computer able to run Minecraft in Minecraft, except all it's components (repeaters, comparators etc.) are all huge ones.